Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C.R.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
FRIDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2019 / 26TH ASWINA, 1941
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
PETITIONERS:
C.P.AJITHKUMAR
AGED 41 YEARS
PROPRIETOR, SUBURBAN TRAVELS,
MAMANGALAM, COCHIN-24,(PRESIDENT, TRAVEL, OPERATORS
ASSOCIATION OF KERALA).
KERALA MERCHANTS UNION
(FORMERLY ERNAKULAM MERCHANTS UNION),
MERCHANTS UNION BUILDING,
MERCHANTS UNION ROAD, COCHIN-11,
REPRESENTED BY ITS GENERAL SECRETARY.
BY ADV. SRI.TOM K.THOMAS
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, (ROADS),
GOVT.SECRETARIAT, TRIVANDRUM.
THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
FINANCE DEPARTMENT,
GOVT.SECRETARIAT, TRIVANDRUM.
THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (ROADS),
TRIVANDRUM.
CORPORATION OF COCHIN,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
BOAT JETTY, ERNAKULAM.
GREATER COCHIN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
KADAVANTHARA, ERNAKULAM, COCHIN-20,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
ADDL.R6.THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
(NATIONAL HIGHWAYS),
TRIVANDRUM-695033.
ADDL.R7.THE REGIONAL OFFICER,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY OF INDIA,
OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
(NATIONAL HIGHWAYS),
TRIVANDRUM-695033.
(ADDDL. R6 AND R7 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER
DATED 28.11.2088 INIA.15338/2008).
ADDL.R8.THE PROJECT DIRECTOR,
PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION UNIT COCHIN,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY OF INDIA,
MANGALYA VAIDHYA MADOM, VYTILA, ERNAKULAM.
ADDL.R9.THE PROJECT DIRECTOR,
PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION UNIT PALAKKAD,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY OF INDIA,
ARMUGHAM COLONY, CHANDRA NAGAR, PALAKKAD.
(ADDL.R8 AND R9 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
17.12.2008 IN .I.A.16206/2008.)
ADDL.R10.UNION OF INDIA,
REP. BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
MINISTRY OF SURFACE TRANSPORT,
CENTRAL SECRETARIAT, NEW DELHI.
(ADDL.R10 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER 30.03.2009
DATED IN I.A.4647/2009.)
ADDL.R11.CENTRE FOR CONSUMER EDUCATION,
MARKET ROAD, PALAI,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING TRUSTEE DEJO KAPPAN,
AGED 54, S/O.LATE K.C.JOSEPH,
RESIDING AT 17 A, PRESIDENCY HOMES,
KALOOR, ERNAKULAM.
(ADDL.R11 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER 12.10.2011
DATED IN IA.15616/2011.)
ADDL.R12. KERALA GOVERNMENT CONTRACTORS
ASSOCIATION,
HEAD OFFICE SREEKUMAR BUILDING,
IRON BRIDGES.P.O.,
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
ALAPPUZHA-688001,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT VARGHESE
KANNAMPALLY
ADDL.R13.P.R.ASHOKUMAR,
RAMAPRIYA, PARAYAKADU.P.O.,
CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT-688001.
(ADDL.R12 AND R13 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER
DATED 18.10.2011 IN I.A.15475/2011.)
ADDL.R14.THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
ERNAKULAM.
(ADDL.R14 IS SUO MOTU IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER
DATED 11.10.2019 IN WPC.)
R1 BY ADV. SRI.BENHUR JOSEPH MANAYANI
R1 BY ADV. SRI.S.KRISHNAMOORTHY CGC
R1, R8 BY GOVERNMENT PLEADER
R1 BY ADV. SRI.JOHNSON MANAYANI
R1 BY ADV. SRI.JOMY GEORGE
R1 BY ADV. SRI.JEEVAN MATHEW MANAYANI
R1 BY ADV. SRI.SEBASTIAN THOMAS
R1 BY ADV. SRI.C.M.SURESH BABUSCCOCHIN CORPORATI
R1 BY ADV. SRI.M.K.THANKAPPANSCGCDAGREATER COCH
R1 BY ADV. SRI.BABU KARUKAPADATHSCCOCHIN CORPORA
R1 BY ADV. SRI.THOMAS ANTONY
SRI. C.P. SUDHAKARAPRASAD- A.G,
SRI. K.V.MANOJ KUMAR -SR.G.P,
SRI. S.SUDHISH KUMAR -S.C
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
18.10.2019, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
JUDGMENT
This writ petition is one of the longest pending writ petitions
of this Court - not surprising, because this case calls into focus a
rather vexatious problem faced by our citizens day in and day
out; but which has eluded any resolution even as on date.
2.
The petitioners complain about the pathetic road
conditions in Kerala and in particular, the “Queen of the Arabian
Sea” - the City of Kochi.
3.
The petitioners rue that in the last more than ten years
this writ petition has been pending before this Court, the situation
of the roads has not merely bettered, but has, in fact, drastically
deteriorated. They, therefore, pray that stringent and effective
directions be now issued to all stakeholders and especially to the
Institutions in which the various roads are vested; with a
corollary plea that the Government be directed to insist on a
minimum five year performance guarantee from the Contractor/
Agency which is entrusted with the work of laying new roads and
repairing it.
4.
Much has already been spoken about the absolute
necessity of good and motorable roads for any modern nation – it
being unequivocally admitted by all respondents – and hence I do
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
not see any reason or purpose in inditing any further on this –
which merely would be to restate the very obvious – moving and
directly into the issues involved, thus avoiding waste of precious
time and paper.
5.
I, therefore, pointedly asked the learned Advocate
General
Sri.C.P.Sudhakara Prasad, instructed by Sri.K.V.Manoj
Kumar -learned Senior Government Pleader, appearing for the
official respondents, as to the action taken to maintain the roads
presently in disrepair and he submitted that over the years the
latest technology and methodology have been adopted in laying
new roads and for its maintenance, but concedes that, in spite of
this, many of them turn decrepit for various unavoidable reasons,
including the vagaries of nature and monsoons. He, however,
submits that all necessary steps have been taken by the
concerned Authorities to immediately cause the essential repairs,
so as to make the roads safe and motoroble; and that such work
will be completed not later than 31.12.2019, if not earlier
depending upon the rains. As regards the roads vested with the
various Local Self Government Institutions are concerned, he
submits that they have also been instructed to do so within the
outer limit of 31.01.2020, since more than 1,33,384 projects
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
have been now identified for immediate repair of roads. He then
adds that the Government have already recorded that all the
concerned Engineers and Staff under the Local Self Government
Departments and Public Works Departments will be taken to task
if the work is not completed within the fixed time frames.
6.
The learned Advocate General thereafter added that
all the new works
being now notified and contracted are with
Performance Guarantee requirements and that the officials in
charge of such projects are responsible to ensure that such
terms are implicitly and scrupulously imposed and complied with.
He says that there is also defect liability periods in addition to
the above which is imposed on the Contractors/Agencies in
charge of the work and that an effective Road Maintenance
Management System, as per the PWD Manual and specifications
of the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MORTH
Specifications), have also been put into operation. He says that
these specifications ensure computerised Road Management System
so
as
o enable the use of limited resources
available for
maintenance work and controlling resources to accomplish a predetermined
level
of
service
through
scheduling,
reporting and evaluating.
planning,
budgeting,
The learned Advocate
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
General, therefore, says that the reliefs sought for in this writ
petition have already been acceded to by the Government and
that no further orders may be issued.
7.
From the materials available, I also notice that a few
District Collectors have initiated action against the concerned
Engineers and Officials; and in obedience to the orders of this
Court dated 11.10.2019, the District Collector, Ernakulam has
produced a report, along with an affidavit, wherein he has
proposed action against the concerned Engineers and Staff of the
Corporation/PWD.
8.
Even when the learned Advocate General makes the
afore submissions, it is ineluctable that what is important is not
words but action.
9.
Unless
promises
and
undertakings
translate
into
tangible results, they are worthless.
10.
The perceptible skepticism of citizens to repeated
promises of officials cannot be brushed aside since, it is crystal
clear that, in spite of several orders issued by this Court in this
writ petition – including constitution of a Road Repair Monitoring
Committee – nothing has changed on the ground level.
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
11.
Hapless citizens still spill blood and life in the craters
and pot holes in roads – the incident of the unfortunate death of
Sri. R.Umesh Kumar of Kochi being only the last of such but not
the last ever, unless real and effective action is taken.
12. Precious time, money and energy are being lost every
day on our roads on account of tenuous queues of vehicles
caught in traffic solely because of bad roads – the consequent
avoidable loss of fuel, especially detrimental to our economy,
which is already reeling from the natural disasters of this and last
year.
13.
No amount of excuses or reasons of any kind can
justify even the loss of one life or injury solely because of bad
roads.
14.
Past experience has shown us that the main reason for
the abject condition of roads is that repairs and maintenance are
not done in time. A small pot-hole or crater that appears on an
otherwise good road is left unattended, thus leading it to become
bigger, then crater like, finally deracinating the entire road. Any
amount of causes may be cited for this, but the primary is often
the indifference and callousness exhibited by the officials in
charge of the roads.
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
15.
I am, therefore, certain that no further apathy and
insocience can be tolerated and that the concerned stakeholders
must be made accountable forthwith.
16.
Sometimes,
extraordinary
situations
requires
extraordinary remedies!
Consequentially,
(a)
The Government, Public Works Department and the
Local Self Government Institutions will repair and maintain all
roads immediately to make them motoroble, at least to the
minimum necessary standard immediately, but not later than
31.12.2019 as far as the PWD roads are concerned and
31.01.2020 as far as the various roads under the Local Self
Government Institutions are concerned.
(b)
The repair and maintenance work shall be carried on
and completed following due procedure but under the strict and
continuous supervision of the concerned and competent Engineer
and Staff of the respective Departments/Institutions.
(c)
The primary responsibility to ensure that the repair
work is done properly and that future repairs are noticed and
done without delay will be on the concerned Engineers/Staff of
the respective Departments/Local Self Government Institutions
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
and any lapse on their part in doing so would lead to necessary
consequences, both under the Service Regulations and the Penal
Law.
(d)
It will be available to any citizen and Residents
Associations to bring the disrepair of any road, as also the
formation of pot holes and craters, in future to the concerned
Department/Institutions so that immediate action can be taken to
repair it. The Secretaries of the concerned Local Self Government
Institutions with respect to the roads under them and the Heads
of the Departments concerned with the other roads will be
responsible personally to respond to any such information and
take necessary and urgent action.
(e)
If the Secretaries of the LSGIs or the Heads of
Departments concerned encounter any issues in acting as per
direction (d)
above, they will be at liberty to bring it to their
Controlling Authorities, who will also, thereafter, be equally
responsible.
(f)
In order for the citizens and Residents Associations, to
act as per the liberty given to them in direction (d) above, I direct
the Government to publish the list of roads which are not under
the
Local
Self
Government
Institutions
with
the
name,
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
designation, address, phone number, E-mail and Whats app
number of the designated officer in charge in the official website
of the Public Works Department. Needless to say, as regards the
roads under the Local Self Government Institutions, the citizen
can approach it's
secretary, in terms of the liberty granted
herein.
(g)
Since the learned Advocate General has already
informed me that the Road Management Maintenance System has
been put in place for the roads under the PWD, I deem it also
necessary that the Local Self Government Institutions constitute
a team for maintenance work for day to day basis, so that the pot
holes or defects in roads can be rectified immediately without
waiting to let it finally destroy it. The formation of such
teams/squads shall be ensured by the Secretary of the Local Self
Government Institutions are concerned and if any difficulties are
encountered by such Authority in doing so, he/she will be at
liberty to approach the Secretary for Local Self Government
Institutions appropriately, who will there upon assist in such
formation through all steps that are necessary.
Finally, as regards the plea of the petitioners on insistence
of a minimum Five Year performance guarantee from the
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
Contractor/Agency is concerned, this being a matter of policy to
be decided upon by the Government, I cannot issue an
affirmative direction, but can only commend it. I do so.
I, however, also record the submissions made by the
learned Advocate General that a decision has already been taken
to insist on a performance guarantee for all works and that such
decision is being implemented in the last couple of years.
This Court certainly hopes that the directions herein, which
may not be exhaustive in its nature, could operate as a minimum
standard for all Authorities to act and I leave liberty to the
petitioners to approach this Court for any further clarification with
respect to the afore directions or further directions to be issued;
in which event, the Registry is directed to list this matter for
consideration appropriately.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
nak
JUDGE
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
APPENDIX
PETITIONERS' EXHIBITS:
ANNEXURE A1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION FILED BY
THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE RESPONDENTS
3 TO 4 DATED 27.8.2011.
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT DATED 28.8.98 IN
O.P.NO.346/98 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF REPLY VIDE
NO.3165/D2/98/PWD DATED 12.1.99 ISSUED
BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF REPLY VIDE NO.M.O.E41385/98 DATED 12.1.99 ISSUED BY THE
4TH RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT DATED 8.1.08 IN
WPC.NO.31431/06 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF NOTICE SENT ON BEHALF OF
THE PETITIONERS ON 6.10.08 BEFORE THE
1ST RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF RELEVANT PORTION OF PWD
MANUAL CONTAINS PROVISIONS FOR
MAINTENANCE OF ROADS AND BRIDGES.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF COUNTER AFFIDAVIT FILED
ON BEHALF OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT IN
WPC.NO.31431/06 BEFORE THIS HON'BLE
COURT ON 13.9.07.
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF BROCHURE INTRODUCING
LATEST MECHANICAL DEVICES FOR REPAIR
AND MAINTENANCE OF ROADS.
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF LATEST NEWS REPORTS
PANNEXURE R8 BUBLISHED IN MALAYALA
MANORAMA DAILY, METRO MANORAMA
MATHRUBHUMI AND KERALA KAUMUDI
DAILIES.
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE COPY OF NEWS REPORTS PUBLISHED BY
LEADING DAILIES - MALAYALA MANORAMA
AND METRO MANORAMA DATED 22.5.09,
INDIAN EXPRESS DATED 27.5.09, MALAYALA
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
MANORAMA DATED 9.6.09 AND METRO
MANORAMA DATED 23.6.09.
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE COPY OF REPORT SHARING EXPERIENCE
OF SHRI MOHANLAL IN MATHRUBHUMI WEEKLY
DATED 4.10.09.
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE COPY OF ARTICLE WHICH APPEARED IN
INDIAN EXPRESS DAILY DATED 12.11.09 BY
JUSTICE V.R.KRISHAN IYER.
EXHIBIT P13
TRUE COPY OF EDITORIAL IN MALAYALA
MANORAMA DATED 17.11.09 POINT OUT THE
NECESSITY FOR IMPROVING THE BASIC
FACILITIES IN COCHIN.
EXHIBIT P14
TRUE COPY OF NEW REPORT ABOUT THE
SLACKNESS ON THE PART OF AUTHORITIES
IN IMPROVING KALOOR JUNCTION PUBLISHED
IN MATHRUBHUMI ON 17.11.09.
EXHIBIT P15
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT APPEARED IN
THE CITY EDITION OF THE NEW INDIA
EXPRESS (EXPRESSO) DATED 10.6.2010.
EXHIBIT P16
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT APPEARED IN
THE CITY EDITION OF THE NEW INDIA
EXPRESS (EXPRESSO) DATED 21.6.2010.
EXHIBIT P17
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT APPEARED IN
THE CITY EDITION OF THE MALAYALA
MANORAMA (METRO MANORAMA) DATED
22.6.2010.
EXHIBIT P18
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT APPEARED IN
THE CITY EDITION OF THE MALAYALA
MANORAMA DATED 27.6.2010.
EXHIBIT P19
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT APPEARED IN
THE CITY EDITION OF THE NEW INDIA
EXPRESS (SUNDAY EXPRESS) DATED
4.7.2010.
EXHIBIT P20
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT APPEARED IN
THE CITY EDITION OF THE MALAYALA
MANORAMA (METRO MANORAMA) DATED
13.7.2010.
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
EXHIBIT P21
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORTS CONTAINING
THE PRESENT SITUATION OF ROADS AFTER
2011 MONSOON.
EXHIBIT P22
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORTS WHICH
APPEARED IN METRO MANORAMA DAILY DATED
20.6.2013, 25.6.2013, 28.6.2013 AND
2.7.2013, THE PRESENT SITUATION OF
ROADS AFTER THE MONSOON. (COPY OF THE
NEWS REPORT IN MALAYALA MANORAMA DATED
14.8.2019 CONTAINING THE PRESENT
SITUATION OF ROADS AFTER 2019
MONSOON.IN IA.1/2019)
EXHIBIT P22 A
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT IN MALAYALA
MANORAMA DATED 25.8.2019 CONTAINING
THE PRESENT SITUATION OF ROADS
AFTER2019 MONSOON.
EXHIBIT P22 B
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT IN TIMES CITY
DATED 29.8.2019 CONTAINING THE PRESENT
SITUATION OF ROADS AFTER 2019 MONSOON.
EXHIBIT P23
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT WHICH APPEARED
IN MALAYAL MANORAMA DAILY DATED
11.7.2013.
EXHIBIT P24
COPY OF THE NEWS REPORT WHICH APPEARED
IN MALAYALA MANORAMA DAILY DATED
17.7.2013.
RESPONDENT'S/S EXHIBITS:
ANNEXURE R1A
TRUE COPY OF THE DETAILS REGARDING THE
REQUIREMENT OF FUND UNDER THE NON PLAN
WORKS FOR THE YEAR 2008-09.
EXHIBIT R1 A
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(MS)NO.69/13/PWD DATED
13.8.13.
EXHIBIT R1 B
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(MS)NO.73/13/PWD DATED
31.8.13.
EXHIBIT R3 A
A TRUE COPY OF A CHART SHOWING THE
ACTION PLAN PREPARED BY THE DEPARTMENT.
(A CHART SHOWING THE STATUS OF THE
ORDINARY REPAIRS ARRANGED AS ON
14.10.2011 (AFFIDAVIT BY R3))
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
EXHIBIT R3 B
A CHART SHOWING AROUND 92% OF THE TOTAL
MAINTENANCE AND PATCH WORKS AS ON
30.11.2011
EXHIBIT R4 A
THE DETAILS OF THE ROADS UNDER THE
CORPORATION OF WHICH REPAIRING WORK ARE
COMPLETED RECENTLY. (TRUE COPY OF THE
WORK REPORT OF THE CORPORATION OF KOCHI.
(AFFIDAVIT BY 4TH RESPONDENT.)
EXHIBIT R4 B
THE DETAILS OF THE ROADS OF WHICH WORKS
ARE UNDER PROGRESS. (LIST SHOWING
DETAILS AND PROGRESS OF THE ROAD WORKS.
(IN IA.20263/2011)
EXHIBIT R4 C
THE DETAILS OF THE ROADS OF WHICH WORKS
PROPOSED TO BE COMPLETED BEFORE
31.3.2009 UNDER THE PLAN FUND 2008-09.
EXHIBIT R5 A
TRUE COPY OF THE GO(RT)NO.2282/06/ESTD
DATED 23.9.06.
EXHIBIT R5 B
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 16.7.08 OF
THE DY.SP VIGILANCE & ANTI CORRUPTION
BUREAU, ERNAKULAM, DIRECTING THE GCDA TO
PRODUCE THE FILES.
EXHIBIT R5 C
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 11.8.08
SENT BY THE GCDA TO THE DY. SP VIGILANCE
& ANTICORRUPTION BUREAU, ERNAKULAM, FOR
PERMISSION TO COMMENCE THE ROAD REPAIR
WORKS.
EXHIBIT R5 D
REPLY DATED 25.8.08 BY SP VIGILANCE AS
TO THE PROCEEDINGS IN ABEYANCE.
EXHIBIT R5 E
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 25.9.08
SENT BY THE GCDA TO THE 1ST
RESPONDENT/GOVT. FOR PERMISSION TO
COMMENCE THE RECONSTRUCTION WORKS OF THE
ROAD.
EXHIBIT R5 F
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 3.10.08
SENT BY THE GCDA TO THE DY. SP VIGILANCE
TO RETURN THE FILES AND FOR SANCTION TO
COMMENCE THE RECONSTRUCTION WORKS OF THE
ROAD.
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
EXHIBIT R5 G
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY/NOC DATED 4.10.08
ISSUED BY THE DY. SP VIGILANCE.
EXHIBIT R5 H
TRUE COPY OF THE SANCTION NO.64311/IA
3/08/LSGD DATED 17.10.08 GIVEN BY THE
1ST RESPONDENT/GOVT. TO COMMENCE THE
ROAD REPAIR WORKS, AFTER RE-TENDER AND
TO REALIZE THE LOSS AS SPECIFIED.
EXHIBIT R6 A
A TABLE SHOWING THE WORKS ALREADY
CARRIED OUT AND THE WORKS TO B CARRIED
OUT. (PROGRESS REPORT ON ROAD REPAIR
WORKS IN NATIONAL HIGHWAYS.(AFFIDAVIT BY
6TH RESPONDENT.) (TRUE COPY OF THE
GOVERNMENT ORDER NO.96/92/PW AND DATED
21.11.92. (IN COUNTER AFFIDAVIT BY
ADD.R6 & R7))
EXHIBIT R6 B
TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.NO.88/99 PWD DATED
18.11.1999.
EXHIBIT R9 A
THE TRUE PHOTOCOPIES OF THE STATEMENTS
PREPARED BY THE PROJECT DIRECTOR, PIU
PALAKKAD, FOR THE PERIOD 2006-2007 TO
2008-2009 SHOWING THE DETAILS OF THE
ESTIMATE SANCTIONED AND FUNDS RELEASED
BY NHAI TO THE RESPECTIVE EXECUTIVE
ENGINEERS OF NH DIVISIONS OF PWD.
EXHIBIT R10 A
TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT SHOWING
ALLOCATION OF FUND BY THE CENTRAL
GOVERNMENT TO THE STATE GOVERNMENT.
EXHIBIT R10 B
TRUE COPY OF THE DETAILS OF WORKS
EXECUTED ON THE STRETCH FROM AROOR TO
TAMILNADU.
EXHIBIT R10 C
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 23.4.2009
ADDRESSED TO THE CHIEF ENGINEER NATIONAL
HIGHWAYS, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
EXHIBIT R10 D
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 23.4.2009
ADDRESSED TO THE PROJECT DIRECTOR, NH
AUTHORITY OF INDIA, TRIVANDRUM.
EXHIBIT R10 E
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 11.5.2009
ADDRESSED TO THE CHAIRMAN NHAT.
WP(C).No.32680 OF 2008(M)
EXHIBIT R8 A
TRUE COPY OF THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING
DATED 29.08.2019
ANNEXURE R8 B
TRUE COPY OF THE LIST OF ROADS
EXHIBIT R8 C
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER UNDER SECTION 133
CRPC ISSUED TO THE SECRETARY KOCHI
CORPORATION AND CHAIRMAN GCDA
EXHIBIT R8 D
TRUE COPY OF THE PRILIMINARY ORDERS
UNDER SECTIN 133 ISSUED BY THE SUB
COLLECTOR, FORT KOCHI
//TRUE COPY//
P.A TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review