Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
AS No. 331 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 24.06. 2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE T.V. THAMILSELVI
AS No. 331 of 2018
1. C.Gopal (died)
S/o. Late Chellapa Naicker, Res At,
No.94, Chinna Echankuzhi Village,
Pudu Napalayam Hamelt Of
Edayanchavadi Village, Ponneri Tk,
Thiruvallur Dist. and 10 Others
2.C.Venkatesan
S/o. Late Chellappa Naicker,
3.Unnamalai
W/o. Alte Munuswamy, Nop.92,2nd
Cross St, Sastri Nagar, Tondiarpet,
Ch-81
4.K.Ragini
W/o. Kesavan, No.51, Lakshmi Nagar,
Old Napalayam Village, Hamlet Of
Edayanchavadi Village, Ponnderi Tk
Thiruvallur Dt
5.Rajammal
W/o. Mani, Noi.2, Vinayagar Koil
St,kanniamman Pettai, Andarkuppam
Check Post, Manali New Town
Chennai -103
6.C.J.Selvi
W/o. Ganesan , No,.46, Vellan St,
Malliyankuppam, Arani Post, Ponneri
Tk Thiruvallur Dt
7.Muthu
S/o. Late Chellappa Naicker, No.94,
Chinna Echankuzhi Vill, Next To Pudu
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
Napalayam Vill, Hamlet Of ,ponneri Tk
Thiruvallur Dt
8.G.Manjula, W/o.Late C.Gopal
No.94, Chinna Echankuzhi Village,
Next To Pudu Napalayam Hamlet Of
Edayanchavadi Village, Ponneri Tk,
Thiruvallur Dist.
9.Gomathi,d/o.Late C.Gopal
No.94, Chinna Echankuzhi Village,
Next To Pudu Napalayam Hamlet Of
Edayanchavadi Village, Ponneri Tk,
Thiruvallur Dist.
10.Uma Mageshwari, D/o.Late
C.Gopal
No.94, Chinna Echankuzhi Village,
Next To Pudu Napalayam Hamlet Of
Edayanchavadi Village, Ponneri Tk,
Thiruvallur Dist.
11.G.Selvam, W/o.Late C.Gopal
No.94, Chinna Echankuzhi Village,
Next To Pudu Napalayam Hamlet Of
Edayanchavadi Village, Ponneri Tk,
Thiruvallur Dist. A1 Died, A8 To A11
Are Brought On Record As Lrs Of
Deceased 1st Appellant Viz., C.Gopal,
Vide Order Of Court Dated 14/02/2023
Made In Cmp.No.18295 Of 2021 In
As.No.331 Of 2018 (smsj)
Appellant(s)
Vs
1. K.Hari @haribabu
S/o. Venkatarathian Reddi, No.2, 2nd
Cross St, Anna Salai, Erukkancheri
Ch-118
Respondent(s)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
PRAYER: This First Appeal has been filed under Section 96 of CPC, praying to
set aside the judegement and decree dated 09/01/2018 passed in OS.No.27/2009
on the file of the IV Additional District Judge, Thiruvallure @ ponneri.
AS No. 331 of 2018
For Appellant(s):
Mr..D.Senthil Kumaar
For Respondent(s):
Mr..Krishnasamy R.
ORDER
Challenging the findings of the
IV Additional District Judge,
Thiruvallure @ ponneri passed in OS No. 27 of 2009, whereby
the learned Judge decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff by directing the
defendants to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff, the defendants
have preferred the present appeal.
2. The brief facts of the case are as follows:
The first defendant, claiming to be the absolute owner of the schedulementioned properties comprising Items Nos. 1 to 3, agreed to sell an extent
of 68 cents of land out of the total extent of 1.08 acres to the plaintiff at the
rate of Rs. 29,000/- per cent. The said offer was accepted by the plaintiff, who
paid the entire sale consideration of Rs. 19,72,000/- to the first defendant on
the date of the agreement, i.e., 03.03.2006. By way of abundant caution,
defendants 2 to 7, who are the children of the first defendant, also joined in the
execution of the said agreement for sale in favour of the plaintiff. In furtherance
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
thereof,
all the
defendants
voluntarily joined
together
and executed
a
registered Power of Attorney on the same date, namely 03.03.2006, vide
Document No. 875 of 2007, in favour of the plaintiff.
The
plaintiff
further contended that, while entering into the agreement for sale, none of
the defendants apprised him of the true state of affairs with regard to the first
defendant's title over Items Nos. 1 to 3 of the suit property. After the
execution of the agreement of sale, the plaintiff verified the revenue records
and found that the first defendant had no title in respect of Item No. 3 of the suit
property. As per the revenue records, an extent of 50 cents in old Survey No.
148/7, subdivided as Survey Nos. 148/7A and 148/7B measuring 25 cents each,
stood in the names of one Laxman and Pattammal, who were third parties to the
sale agreement. The plaintiff further came to know that, at the time of
execution of the earlier sale deed, the survey number had been mistakenly
mentioned as Survey No. 148/7 instead of Survey No. 148/3, which stood in
the name of the first defendant. The plaintiff also came to know that the first
defendant was the owner only in respect of Items Nos. 1 and 2 of the
suit properties.
3. The plaintiff subsequently came to know that the 1st defendant was
the owner only in respect of Item Nos. 1 and 2 of the suit properties, measuring
a total extent of 58 cents. Consequently, the plaintiff called upon all the
defendants to refund a sum of Rs.2,90,000/-, being the excess amount received
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
by them towards the purchase of an additional 10 cents of land to which the
1st defendant had no title. The plaintiff also demanded that the defendants
specifically perform their part of the contract in respect of Item Nos. 1 and 2
of the suit properties. However, the defendants evaded compliance on one
pretext or another. With a view to avoiding the refund of the excess amount
of Rs.2,90,000/- and
to
evade specific
performance
of the
agreement,
the defendants chose to revoke the power of attorney and caused a legal notice
to be issued to the plaintiff. The plaintiff sent a suitable reply and thereafter a
rejoinder.
In their
notice,
the defendants
deliberately suppressed
the
execution of the agreement of sale and falsely claimed that only a power of
attorney had been executed.
3.1.
Thereafter,
the
plaintiff personally
met
the 1st
defendant
and enquired about the matter. At that time, the 1st defendant agreed to perform
her part of the contract in respect of the 58 cents comprised in Item Nos. 1 and 2
of the suit properties and also agreed to refund the excess amount received.
Contrary to the said assurance, the defendants instituted O.S. No. 242 of
2006 before the District Munsif Court, Ponneri, against the plaintiff seeking the
reliefs of declaration and permanent injunction in respect of Item Nos. 1 to 3 of
the suit properties.
legal notice
The plaintiff was therefore constrained to issue a
dated 13.01.2007 calling
upon
the defendants
to
specifically perform the agreement in respect of Item Nos. 1 and 2 of the suit
properties and to refund the excess amount of Rs.2,90,000/- received by them.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
The defendants sent a reply notice calling upon the plaintiff to furnish a copy
of the agreement of sale. The exchange of notices clearly revealed that
the defendants were not willing to perform their contractual obligations or
alienate the suit properties in favour of the plaintiff.
3.2. Accordingly, the plaintiff has been constrained to institute the present
suit. The power of attorney executed in favour of the plaintiff is one
coupled with interest and is therefore irrevocable in law. Hence, the purported
revocation of the power of attorney by the defendants does not bind the plaintiff
or affect the rights already accrued in his favour.
3.3. Having regard to the title available with the 1st defendant,
the plaintiff has restricted his claim to Item Nos. 1 and 2 of the suit properties,
measuring 58
cents,
and
seeks
a decree
directing
the defendants
to
specifically perform the agreement by executing the sale deed and delivering
possession of the said properties. The plaintiff also seeks recovery of the
excess amount of Rs.2,90,000/- paid to the defendants.
3.4.
The
defendants
have entered
appearance
and filed
their
written statement, wherein they have denied the execution of the agreement of
sale
dated 03.03.2006 as
denied having
received
alleged
the sale
by the
plaintiff.
consideration
They have
further
of Rs.19,72,000/- or
any part thereof, and have contended that the plaintiff's allegations in this
regard are false.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
4. The defendants have further contended that the plaintiff's allegation
that they executed the power of attorney only after receiving the entire sale
consideration is false. According to the defendants, no agreement of sale was
ever executed, nor was any sale consideration received by them.
5. By way of an additional written statement, the defendants have
further contended that they are illiterate persons and that the plaintiff, taking
advantage of their illiteracy, fabricated the alleged agreement of sale with
the dishonest intention of grabbing the suit property. According to the
defendants, the alleged agreement of sale was never executed by them with
the intention of selling the suit property and is a fabricated document created by
the plaintiff solely to extract money from the defendants by fraudulent means.
Hence, they contend that the suit is liable to be dismissed. The defendants
further state that the plaintiff, who is engaged in the business of real estate,
approached the 1st defendant, the mother of the other defendants, through
a commission agent and persuaded her to execute a General Power of
Attorney in his favour. Believing the plaintiff and acting in good faith,
the defendants executed a registered General Power of Attorney in favour of
the plaintiff as Document No. 875 of 2006, dated 03.03.2006. They further
state that the original title deeds were handed over to the plaintiff solely for the
purpose of obtaining approval for forming a layout of house sites.
5.1. According to the defendants, after about three months, when they
contacted the plaintiff, he neither responded properly nor took any steps to
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
obtain layout approval. On noticing the plaintiff's conduct, they decided
to revoke the power of attorney and accordingly executed a Deed of
Revocation dated 23.06.2006. The revocation was communicated to the plaintiff
through a legal notice dated 29.07.2006, calling upon him to return the original
title deeds.
5.2. The defendants further contend that the plaintiff failed to return the
original documents and, instead, in collusion with certain local persons,
attempted to grab the suit property. Consequently, they instituted O.S. No. 242
of
2006 seeking
They further
the
allege
reliefs of
declaration
that,
the
in
and permanent
said suit,
the
injunction.
plaintiff filed
a
written statement suppressing the true facts and has now instituted the present
suit for specific performance, which, according to them, is not maintainable in
law.
5.3. The defendants also contend that the plaintiff, being a real estate
businessman, would necessarily have verified the title and ownership of
the property if he had genuinely intended to purchase it. They further
allege that, at the time of execution of the General Power of Attorney, the
plaintiff
obtained the
signatures
of the
defendants
on blank
papers
and subsequently converted the same into the alleged agreement of sale
(Document No. 1), falsely portraying it as an agreement executed by the
defendants for sale of the property.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
5.4. The defendants therefore contend that no agreement of sale was ever
entered into between the parties; that the alleged Document No. 1 is fabricated,
forged, and devoid of any legal sanctity; that the plaintiff is not entitled to
the equitable relief of specific performance; that he has no valid cause of action;
and
that he
is
not a
bona
fide purchaser.
On
these grounds,
they
pray for dismissal of the suit.
6. By way of reply, the plaintiff filed a rejoinder denying each and every
allegation, averment, and contention contained in the additional written
statement. The plaintiff reiterated the averments made in the plaint, denied that
the alleged agreement of sale was fabricated or forged, and asserted that the
agreement was validly executed by the defendants after receipt of the sale
consideration. The
plaintiff
further contended
that
the General
Power
of Attorney was executed for valuable consideration and was coupled with
interest, rendering it irrevocable. Accordingly, the plaintiff prayed that the
suit be decreed as prayed for.
7. In order to prove his case, the plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and
marked documents Ex.A1 to Ex.A15 on his side. On the side of the defendants,
the
3rd
defendant was
examined
as D.W.1,
and
documents Ex.B1
to Ex.B18 were marked.
8. The
learned
Trial Judge,
upon consideration
of
the oral
and
documentary evidence, held that, through Ex.B1, the defendants had revoked
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
the power of attorney, thereby admitting the execution of the power of attorney
and the relationship between the parties. Based on the said document, the
Trial Court concluded that the execution of the power of attorney was
not seriously disputed by the defendants. The Trial Court further observed
that the genuineness of Ex.A1, the suit agreement, was not specifically and
convincingly denied by the defendants and that there was no sufficient
material to create suspicion regarding the said document. The Trial Court also
found that, under Ex.A1, the plaintiff had agreed to purchase 68 cents of land
at the rate of Rs.29,000/- per cent. The Trial Court further noted that the plaintiff
had given up his claim in respect of the 3rd item of the suit property, since
the defendants had no valid right or title over the said property. It was observed
that, as per Ex.A5, the subject matter of the agreement of sale was only 68 cents
out of 88 cents, and that the inclusion of the 3rd item of the suit property in the
schedule was due to a mutual mistake between the parties.
8.1. Accordingly, the Trial Court held that the plaintiff was not entitled
to claim refund of Rs.2,19,000/- in respect of the 3rd item of the suit property.
However, the Trial Court held that the plaintiff was entitled to seek specific
performance in respect of Item Nos. 1 and 2 of the suit properties, measuring 58
cents, and consequently directed the defendants to execute the sale deed in
favour of the plaintiff in respect of the said properties. The relief of refund
of Rs.2,19,000/- was negatived.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
9. Aggrieved by the findings a of the Trial Court, the appellant/defendant
has preferred the present First Appeal.
10. The
learned
counsel appearing
for
the appellants/defendants
would contend that the Trial Court failed to appreciate the fact that the plaintiff
had not approached the Court with clean hands and, therefore, was not entitled
to the discretionary and equitable relief of specific performance. The learned
counsel further
submitted
that the
alleged
agreement
of
sale
marked as Ex.A1 was not a genuine document and was deliberately created by
the plaintiff with an intention to fraudulently claim rights over the suit property.
According to him, though the document was marked as Ex.A1, the contents
of the document would show that it is, in substance, a sale deed and not merely
an agreement of sale. He contended that an unregistered sale deed requires
compulsory registration
under
the provisions
of
the Registration
Act
and, being an unregistered document, it is inadmissible in evidence.
10.1. The learned counsel argued that, without considering the said legal
position, the Trial Court erroneously relied upon an inadmissible document
and granted the relief of specific performance in favour of the plaintiff.
Therefore, the findings rendered by the Trial Court are perverse and liable to be
set aside.
11. The
learned
counsel further
submitted
that Ex.A2, the
Power
of Attorney, was executed only for a limited purpose of developing the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
property and
obtaining
approval for
forming
a layout,
especially
considering that the plaintiff was engaged in real estate business. Since the
plaintiff failed to comply with the terms and conditions of the Power
of Attorney, the defendants cancelled the same.
11.1. According to the learned counsel, the Trial Court failed to appreciate
the circumstances leading to the cancellation of the Power of Attorney and
erroneously compared the same with Ex.A1, thereby arriving at a conclusion
that Ex.A1 was a genuine document. Such a finding, according to him,
is erroneous and liable to be set aside. The learned counsel further argued that, if
the plaintiff had genuinely paid a sum of Rs.19,72,000/- on the date of the
alleged execution of Ex.A1, he would have insisted upon execution of the
sale deed immediately. However, the plaintiff sought the relief of specific
performance
only after
cancellation
of the
Power
of Attorney,
which
clearly establishes that Ex.A1 was subsequently manipulated by the plaintiff
with an intention to grab the property. The said aspect was not properly
considered by the Trial Court, resulting in an erroneous decree.
12. The learned counsel further contended that, only after issuance of the
legal notice under Ex.A5, the defendants came to know about the alleged
agreement of sale. In their reply notice, the defendants specifically called upon
the plaintiff to furnish a copy of Ex.A1. However, the plaintiff failed to furnish
the same, which according to the learned counsel, clearly establishes that the
alleged unregistered document was fabricated and manipulated for the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
purpose of claiming rights over the suit property. The learned counsel submitted
that the Trial Court failed to appreciate these material circumstances and
erroneously granted the relief of specific performance. Hence, the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court are liable to be set aside.
13. The following points arise for consideration in this appeal:
i. Whether Ex.A1 is a true, valid, and enforceable agreement of sale on
the basis of which the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of specific performance?
ii. When
the
and admissibility
defendants have
of
Ex.A1,
whether
specifically
denied the
the plaintiff
has
execution
established the
genuineness and validity of the said document in accordance with law?
iii. Whether
the
mere fact
that
the execution
of Ex.A1 was
not
specifically denied by the defendants is sufficient to hold that the document
is true and genuine, and whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of specific
performance on that basis?
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
13. The
learned
counsel appearing
for
the respondent/plaintiff
would submit that, at the time of entering into the agreement of sale, the
defendants represented that they were the absolute owners of all the three items
of the suit properties and, based on such representation, the plaintiff entered
into the agreement of sale. Subsequently, upon verification of the title and
ownership, the plaintiff came to know that the 3rd item of the suit property did
not belong to the defendants or their family. Therefore, the plaintiff requested
the defendants to refund the excess amount received in respect of the said
item and also called upon them to perform their part of the contract in respect
of the remaining properties. However, the defendants failed to comply with their
contractual obligations. After issuing the necessary notice, the plaintiff
was constrained to institute the suit for specific performance. The Trial Court,
after properly appreciating the oral and documentary evidence, rightly decreed
the suit, and the said findings do not warrant any interference by this Court.
13.1. The learned counsel further contended that the Power of Attorney
was cancelled by the defendants without any valid reason, despite the fact
that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the
agreement. Therefore, the Trial Court rightly held that Ex.A1 is a genuine and
valid agreement of sale and directed the defendants to execute the sale deed
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
in favour of the plaintiff. The said finding is sustainable in law and requires no
interference.
14. The learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff further contended that
the defendants, by suppressing the terms and conditions of the agreement of
sale, instituted a separate suit in O.S. No.242 of 2006 in respect of Item Nos.
1 to 3 of the suit properties. After full-fledged trial, the Court therein held
that Item Nos. 1 and 2 of the suit properties alone belonged to the defendants,
which clearly established that the defendants had no right or title over the 3rd
item of the property. Therefore, the plaintiff restricted his claim only to Item
Nos. 1 and 2 of the suit properties by issuing a pre-suit notice and
sought specific performance only in respect of the properties owned by the
defendants. The learned counsel submitted that the Trial Court, after considering
the
entire evidence
and
circumstances,
rightly
accepted
the validity
of Ex.A1 and granted the relief of specific performance. Hence, the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court do not call for interference and the appeal is liable
to be dismissed.
14.1. Heard the learned counsel appearing on both sides.
15. For the sake of convenience the parties are denoted as per the suit.
According to the case of the plaintiff, the 1st defendant was the owner of
Item Nos. 1 to 3 of the suit properties and, along with the other defendants,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
agreed to sell the said properties at the rate of Rs.29,000/- per cent. Based on
the said representation, the plaintiff entered into an agreement of sale with
the defendants and paid a sum of Rs.19,72,000/- on 03.03.2006 under Ex.A1.
The further case of the plaintiff is that, subsequently, upon verification of the
title documents, he came to know that Item No.3 of the suit property did not
belong to the 1st defendant. Therefore, he issued notice to the defendants
and restricted his claim only in respect of Item Nos.1 and 2 of the
suit properties. Admittedly, in O.S. No.242 of 2006 filed by the present 1st
defendant before the District Munsif Court, Ponneri, seeking declaration
in respect of Item No.3 of the suit property, wherein the present plaintiff was
arrayed as the defendant, after trial, the Court held that Item Nos.1 and 2
alone belonged to the defendants. Based on the said finding, the plaintiff
restricted his claim to Item Nos.1 and 2 of the suit properties.
16. Considering the oral and documentary evidence, P.W.1 has deposed
that the defendants entered into an agreement of sale with him on 03.03.2006,
received a sale consideration of Rs.19,72,000/- at the rate of Rs.29,000/per cent, and executed the agreement marked as Ex.A1. However, as
rightly pointed
out
by
the
learned
counsel appearing
for
the defendants/appellants, the nomenclature of Ex.A1 describes the document
as a sale deed (Sutha Kiraya Pathiram). Admittedly, the said document is
an unregistered document. Further, on a perusal of the recitals contained
in Ex.A1, it appears that the entire sale consideration was paid by the plaintiff
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
on the date of execution itself and possession was also stated to have
been delivered to him on the same day. Contrary to the said recitals, the plaintiff
has instituted the present suit seeking a direction to the defendants to execute
the sale deed and deliver possession of the property. This circumstance creates
a doubt regarding the nature and genuineness of Ex.A1.
17. Further, the plaintiff has not assigned any valid reason as to why
the sale deed was not registered, especially when he claims to have paid the
entire sale consideration of Rs.19,72,000/- on 03.03.2006 itself. It is the specific
case of the plaintiff that the General Power of Attorney was executed in
his favour by the defendants on the same day and the defendants subsequently
revoked the same. On the other hand, the defendants contend that the Power
of Attorney
was
executed only
for
the purpose
of
forming a
layout
and converting the property into house sites within the stipulated period and
that the plaintiff, being a real estate businessman, failed to perform the
said obligation. According to the defendants, since the plaintiff demanded sale
of the property instead of developing the layout, they cancelled the Power of
Attorney. The execution and cancellation of the Power of Attorney are not
disputed by either party. The Power of Attorney was cancelled on 23.06.2006,
and the same was informed to the plaintiff through notice dated 13.07.2006.
However, only after a considerable delay, in January 2007, the plaintiff
issued notice calling upon the defendants to execute the sale deed and
thereafter instituted the suit for specific performance based on Ex.A1. Further, a
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
perusal of
Ex.A1 reveals
that
the entire
recitals
are typed,
whereas
the registration document number and date is subsequently inserted in
handwriting. This circumstance creates a serious doubt regarding the manner
in which Ex.A1 came into existence. As rightly pointed out by the learned
counsel for the appellants, Ex.A1 does not contain the particulars of the scribe.
Further, P.W.1, in his evidence, admitted that at the time of execution of the
document, the witnesses Anandan and Pushparaj were present. However, the
stamp papers used for Ex.A1 were purchased two months prior to the alleged
date of execution. P.W.1 has also admitted that the document was prepared
by him
and
that there
is
no mention
regarding
the scribe.
These
circumstances create a doubt regarding the genuineness of Ex.A1.
17.1. Further, P.W.2, one of the alleged witnesses, admitted that
the recitals contained in Ex.A1 are in the nature of a sale deed and also
admitted that
he
is a
admitted that the witnesses
close
friend of
mentioned
the
plaintiff.
He
further
in Ex.A1
and Ex.A2
are different
persons, though both documents are alleged to have been executed on the same
day,
namely 03.03.2006.
Considering the
above circumstances,
the
possibility that Ex.A1 was created subsequently by the plaintiff cannot be
ruled out. The Trial Court failed to properly appreciate these material aspects
while granting the relief of specific performance.
18. There is no explanation from the plaintiff as to why Ex.A1 was not
registered on the very same day if the entire sale consideration had already been
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
paid. Further, if the plaintiff had acquired rights under Ex.A1, there was
no necessity for execution of a Power of Attorney in his favour by the
defendants.
The
conduct
of the
plaintiff,
coupled with
the
surrounding circumstances, creates a doubt regarding his bona fides. The
plaintiff, being a person engaged in real estate business, was expected to verify
the title and nature of the property before entering into the transaction. The
relief of specific performance is a discretionary and equitable relief, and a
person seeking such relief must approach the Court with clean hands. In the
present case, the plaintiff has failed to establish his bona fides and has not
approached the Court with clean hands. Therefore, Ex.A1 cannot be relied upon
as a genuine and valid agreement of sale, and the findings of the Trial Court
granting specific performance are liable to be set aside. Thus point No. 1 & 2 is
answered.
19. Further,
as
rightly contended
by
the learned
counsel
for the
defendants/appellants, the Trial Court has failed to properly analyse the
documents relied
upon
by the
defendants
and has
not
considered the
surrounding circumstances relevant for deciding the entitlement of the plaintiff
to the
equitable
relief of
specific
performance.
On
the
face of
the
document, Ex.A1 is styled as a sale deed (Sutha Kiraya Pathiram) and is
admittedly unregistered. If the document is treated as a sale deed, registration
is compulsory under Section 17 of the Registration Act. Without registration,
such a document cannot be relied upon as a valid conveyance. Further, an
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
unregistered document cannot be relied upon for granting the main relief
claimed by the plaintiff. Since the entire claim for specific performance is based
upon Ex.A1,
and since
Ex.A1 is
found
to be
neither
genuine nor
legally enforceable, the relief granted by the Trial Court is unsustainable.
20. Further, the defendants specifically called upon the plaintiff to furnish
a copy of the alleged agreement of sale. However, the plaintiff failed to
provide the same. This conduct also creates a doubt regarding the existence
and genuineness of Ex.A1. Considering the conduct of the plaintiff and the
circumstances discussed above, this Court is of the view that the findings of the
Trial Court are liable to be set aside. Consequently, the suit filed by the plaintiff
is liable to be dismissed. Point No.3 is answered.
21. In the result, this First Appeal is allowed. The judgment and
decree passed by the Trial Court are set aside, and the suit filed by the
plaintiff is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently,
connected miscellaneous petitions, if any, are closed.
24.06.2026
pbl
Index:Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Internet:Yes
To
1. The IV Additional District Judge, Thiruvallur @ ponneri.
2. The Section Officer, V. R Section, High Court, Madras.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 331 of 2018
T.V.THAMILSELVI J.
pbl
AS No. 331 of 2018
24.06.2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review