Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010355462026
2026:CGHC:41214
NAFR
AVINASH
SHARMA
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by AVINASH
SHARMA
Date:
2026.09.30
16:32:31 +0530
WPC No. 4802 of 2026
1 - Budhnath Paigor S/o Late Shri Shivram Paigor, Aged About 53 Years
Member Janpad Panchayat Bilha, Area No. 12, R/o Village - Nagoi,
Thana - Sarkanda, Tahsil - Beltara, District - Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through, The Secretary, Panchayat And Rural
Development Department, Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Mahanadi
Bhawan,
Nava
Raipur
Atal
Nagar,
District
-
Raipur
(C.G.)
2 - State Election Commission, Through It's Secretary, Near D. K. S.
Bhawan, Old Mantralaya Road Motibag Raipur, District - Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Collector And District Election Officer Bilaspur, District - Bilaspur
(C.G.)
4 - Returning Officer (Panchayat) Sub Divisional Officer (Revenue),
Bilha,
Janpad
Panchayat
Bilha,
District
-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
5 - Assistant Returning Officer (Panchayat) /tahsildar, Bilha, Tahsil Bilha
District
-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
6 - Deepak Kumar Liberty, S/o Shri Om Narayan Liberty, Aged About 27
Years R/o Village Nagoi Dhabhipara, Tahsil Beltara District - Bilaspur
(C.G.)
7 - Alka Jwala Suryawanshi, R/o Mangla Bilaspur District - Bilaspur
(C.G.)
8 - Durga Kariyare, R/o Urtum Tahsil - Beltara District - Bilaspur (C.G.)
9 - Kapil Nath Suryawanshi, R/o Village - Nagoi, Tahsil - Beltara, District
-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
10 - Kunti Mehar, D/o Shri Neturam Mehar, R/o Village - Nagoi, Tahsil Beltara,
District
-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
11 - Lok Prakash Diwakar, R/o Village - Nagoi, Tahsil - Beltara, District Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from the Case Information System)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
:-
Mr. Sudeep Verma, Advocate
For State
:-
Mr. Priyank Rathi, G.A.
For Respondent No. 2 :-
Mr. Priyanshu Ojha, Advocate on behalf of
Mr. Rakesh Kumar Jha, Advocate
For Caveator :- Mr. Awadh Tripathi, Advocate
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order On Board
22.09.2026
1. Following reliefs have been prayed in this petition:“10.1 to call for the entire records pertaining to the
case of the petitioner for it's kind perusal;
10.2 to quash the impugned order dated 17.08.2026
passed by the Collector & District Election Officer,
Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.)/Election Tribunal
(respondent
no.3)
in
Case
No.
1/A-89/2024-
25/202505072100013;
10.3 to direct the Collector & District Election Officer,
Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.)/Election Tribunal
(respondent no.3) to conduct the proceedings of
Case No. 1/A-89/2024-25/202505072100013 strictly
in accordance with law;
10.4 That, any other relief, which this Hon'ble Court
thinks fit & proper as per the facts & circumstances
of the present case, in the interest of justice.”
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
order dated 17.08.2026 passed by the learned Election Tribunal is
unsustainable in law, having been passed without proper
consideration of the pleadings and the applicable provisions of the
Chhattisgarh Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices
and Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995, particularly
Rule 11 thereof. He submits that during the pendency of the
election petition, the Tribunal has permitted recounting of votes,
which amounts to granting a substantive relief at an interim stage,
without affording the petitioner a proper opportunity to lead
evidence and contest the allegations raised by respondent No.6. It
is further submitted that the impugned order proceeds on an
erroneous assumption that the petitioner had consented to the
course adopted by the Tribunal, whereas no such consent was
ever given. Upon coming to know of the order, the petitioner
immediately raised an objection on 27.08.2026. Learned counsel
submits that the petitioner has thereby been deprived of a fair
opportunity to defend the election petition and to adduce oral and
documentary evidence, in violation of the principles of natural
justice. Learned counsel further submits that an order directing
recounting of votes cannot be passed mechanically and that the
person challenging the election is required to establish the
necessary factual foundation by cogent material before such an
extraordinary course is adopted. The impugned order, according
to learned counsel, does not disclose adequate reasons or proper
application of mind and, therefore, deserves to be set aside.
3. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
opposes the petition and submits that the order passed by the
learned Election Tribunal is an interlocutory order passed in the
course of adjudication of the pending election petition and does
not finally determine the rights of the parties. It is submitted that
the Tribunal has acted within the scope of its jurisdiction and in
accordance with the applicable election law while dealing with the
issue of recounting. Learned counsel further submits that the
petitioner has an adequate opportunity to participate in the
proceedings before the Election Tribunal and to place his defence
and evidence in accordance with law. The grievance regarding the
alleged absence of consent and the manner in which the
proceedings have been conducted can appropriately be raised
before the Election Tribunal itself. It is, therefore, submitted that
no interference under Article 226/227 of the Constitution is
warranted at this stage and the petition deserves to be dismissed.
4. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
5. The issue in hand already stands covered by various earlier
pronouncements, therefore, in order to examine the case at hand
with the lens of earlier similar pronouncements, it is appropriate to
go through the order dated 31.08.2005 passed by this Court in the
matter of Parvatia vs. Padmini & Others {2005 SCC OnLine
Chh 204}. Relevant paragraphs 8 to 14, 16 & 17, reads as under:8. Madhya Pradesh High Court in the matter of
Chironjilal v. S.D.O. Vijaypur {1996 (I) MPWN 109}
after considering the judgment of the Apex Court in
the matter of Dr. Jagjit Singh v. Giani Kartar Singh
{(1967) 1 SCJ 762} held that merely on the basis of
consent recount cannot be ordered Consent would
not confer jurisdiction on the Specified Officer, case
for recount has to be made out.
9. Similarly, in another matter Gajanand v.
Ramchara {1997 (II) MPWN 3 }, the Court held that
“it is well settled that the justification for an order for
examination of ballot papers and recount of votes is
not to be derived form hind sight and by the result
of the recount of votes. Consent of parties cannot
give jurisdiction to inspect ballots and recount”.
10. In the matter of Ramdeen v. State of M.P {2002
(3) MPHT 180}, M.P. High Court has held that the
impugned order has been passed without recording
the evidence, which cannot be allowed to stand,
and directed the S.D.O. to record the evidence of
both the parties as may be adduced and thereafter
first to decide the question whether case has been
made out for order of recount on the averments
and the evidence adduced by the parties.
11. In the matter of P.K.K. Shamsudeen v. K.A.M.
Mappillai Mohindeen {AIR 1989 SC 640}, in para
15 of the judgment, the Apex Court has held that
“an order of recount of votes must stand or fail on
the nature of the avarments made and the
evidence adduced before the order of recount is
made and not from the results emanating from the
recount of votes”.
12. In the matter of Shri Scityanarain Dudhani v.
Uday Kumar Singh {AIR 1993 SC 367}, the Apex
Court has held that:
“It is settled proposition of law that the secrecy of
the ballot papers cannot be permitted to be tinkered
lightly. An order of recount cannot be granted as a
matter of course. The secrecy of the ballot papers
has to be maintained and only when the High Court
is satisfied on the basis of material facts pleaded in
the petition and supported by the contemporaneous
evidence that the recount can be ordered.”
13. In the matter of P.K.K. Shamsudeen (supra), in
para 10 the Apex Court has held that:
“Before examining the contentions of the parties we
may set out the position in law as regards the need
for the secrecy of the ballot being maintained and
as to when the well established rule can be
departed from. Since the principle of law has
already been enunciated by this Court in several
cases, we may refer to three of those decisions. In
Dr. Jagjit Singh v. Giani Kartar Singh, the appellant
had challenged the election of the first respondent
to the Punjab Legislative Assembly. In the recount
of votes ordered by the Tribunal it was found that
the appellant had secured 22,491 votes and the
first respondent had secured 22,412, votes. The
Tribunal allowed the election petition and declared
the appellant to have been duly elected. The High
Court set aside the order of the Tribunal and the
judgment of the High Court was confirmed by this
Court. In doing so this Court observed as follows
(at p.783 of AIR)
“Therefore, in a proper case, the Tribunal can order
the inspection of the ballot boxes and may proceed
to
by
examine
the
the
parties
in
objections
relation
to
the
raised
improper
acceptance or rejection of the voting papers. But in
exercising this power, the Tribunal has to bear in
mind certain important considerations. Section 83(I)
(a) of the Act requires that an election petition shall
contain a concise statement of the material facts on
which the petitioner relied; and in every case,
where a prayer is made by a petitioner for the
inspector of the ballot boxes, the Tribunal must
enquire whether the application made by the
petitioner
in
that
behalf
contains
a-concise
statement of the material facts on which he relied.
Vague or general allegations that valid votes were
improperly
rejected,
or
invalid
votes
were
improperly accepted, would not serve the purpose
which section 83(1)(a) has in mind. An application
made for the inspection of ballot boxes must give
material facts which would enable the Tribunal to
consider whether in the interests of justice, the
ballot boxes should be inspected or not. In dealing
with this question, the importance of the secrecy of
the ballot papers cannot be ignored, and it is
always to be borne in mind that the statutory Rules
framed under the Act are intended to provide
adequate safeguard for the examination of the
validity or invalidity of votes and for their proper
counting. It may be that in some cases, the ends of
justice would make it necessary for the Tribunal to
allow a party to inspect the ballot boxes and
consider
his
objections
about
the
improper
acceptance or improper rejection of votes tendered
by votes at any given election; but in considering
the requirements of justice, care must be taken to
see that election petitioners do not get a chance to
make a roving or fishing enquiry in the ballot boxes
so as to justify their claim that the returned
candidate's election is void.” (Emphasis supplied)
14. In the matter of Chandrika Prasad Yadav v.
State of Bihar {(2004) 6 SCC 331}, in para 20, the
Apex Court has held that:
“It is well settled that an order of re-counting of
votes can be passed when the following conditions
are fulfilled:
(i) a prima facie case;
(ii) pleading of material facts stating irregularities in
counting of votes;
(iii) a roving and fishing inquiry shall not be made
while directing re-counting of votes; and
(iv) an objection to the said effect has been taken
recourse to.”
16. Similarly, in the matter of Jibontara Ghatowar v.
Sarbananda Sonowal {(2003) 6 SCC 452}, the
Apex Court held that “Decision on, must be taken
be Returning Officer based on prjma facie opinion
formed in a reasonable manner in the facts and
circumstances - when a case for re-count made out
on the basis of averments made by election
petitioner coupled with breach of statutory duty cast
on Returning Officer under R. 63 of Conduct of
Elections Rules.”
17. Therefore, in view of the above, the settled
legal position is that before ordering for recount, the
learned Specified Officer was required to see as
per Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayats
(Election
Petitions,
Disqualification
for
Corrupt
Practices
Membership)
Rules,
and
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules, 1995’),
whether the election petition (a) contains a concise
statement of all material facts on which the
petitioner relies and (b) set forth with sufficient
particulars, the grounds on which the election is
called in question, and also to satisfy himself based
on the evidence of the parties after conducting the
trial that the petitioner has been able to make out a
case for recount on the basis of pleadings and
evidence.”
6. When the case is examined in view of the afore cited judgment, it
appears that the concerned Court has ordered for recounting of
votes without recording evidence of the parties. Once the matter is
seized by the Election Tribunal, unless and until, statement of
witness are recorded or prima facie it appears that case is made
out for interference in the matter for recounting and further there
are materials showing irregularities in respect of counting of votes,
roving and fishing inquiry shall not be made while directing
recounting of votes and since in the instant case, evidence was
yet to be recorded as such, prima facie impugned order passed
for recounting of votes is without any considerable material
showing the need of the same. Even if consent has been given by
the party, no order for recounting of votes can be ordered unless
prima facie case is made out and there are material available on
record to show that the order for recounting of votes is required to
be made.
7. Accordingly, in light of the aforcited principles by Hon’ble Supreme
court, impugned order dated 17.08.2026 passed by the Collector,
Bilaspur C.G. is quashed/set aside and the petitioner is directed to
cooperate with the election proceedings and to examine his
witnesses as expeditiously as possible. The petitioner shall furnish
the list of witnesses before the learned Election Tribunal and shall
thereafter lead the evidence of such witnesses within the time
prescribed by the Tribunal.
8. Upon the petitioner producing his witnesses, the learned Election
Tribunal shall record their evidence and shall afford respondent
No.6 an opportunity to cross-examine the said witnesses.
9. Thereafter, upon completion of the cross-examination and after
affording reasonable opportunity of hearing to all concerned
parties, the learned Election Tribunal shall, if considered
necessary in accordance with law, pass an appropriate order with
regard to recounting of votes.
10.The learned Election Tribunal is further directed to conclude and
dispose of the election petition, in accordance with law, as
expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of 45 days
from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
11.With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition stands disposed
of.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Avinash/Vishakha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review