Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MOHAMMED
AADIL KHAN
Date: 2026.09.30
13:47:26 +0530
CGHC010383182026
2026:CGHC:42462
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WP227 No. 1271 of 2026
1 - Brijendranath S/o Sitaram Kushwaha, Aged About 72 Years, Occupation
Agriculture, R/o Village Darain, Tahsil Jaisingh Nagar, Distt.- Shahdol (M.P.)
2 - Premvati W/o Late Rajendra Kushwaha, Aged About 40 Years, Occupation
Agriculture, R/o Village Darain, Tahsil Jaisingh Nagar, Distt.- Shahdol (M.P.)
3 - Sanjeev Kumar S/o Vijendranath Kushwaha, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Village
Darain, Tahsil Jaisingh Nagar, Distt.- Shahdol (M.P.)
4 - Jammibai W/o Late Ramdulare Kushwaha, D/o Shri Sitaram Kushwaha, Aged
About 75 Years, R/o Village Budwa Dhari No. 02, Tahsil Byouhari, Distt.- Shahdol
(M.P.)
5 - Ahillabai W/o Shivprasad Kushwaha, D/o Sitaram Kushwaha, Aged About 70
Years, R/o Village Khad, Tahsil Byouhari, Distt.- Shahdol (M.P.)
6 - Champabai W/o Bhagwat Kushwaha, D/o Sitaram Kushwaha, Aged About 68
Years, R/o Village Khad, Tahsil Byouhari, Distt.- Shahdol (M.P.)
... Petitioners
versus
1 - Birendra Kumar S/o Late Ramkrishn Kushwaha, Aged About 57 Years,
Occupation Agriculture, R/o Village Ghatai, Tahsil Bharatpur, Distt.- M.C.B. (C.G.)
2 - Vijay Mala W/o Ramlakhan Kushwaha, D/o Ramkrishn Kushwaha, Aged About
63 Years, R/o Village Sariya, Tahsil Ramnagar, Distt.- Satna (M.P.)
3 - Shyama W/o Ramkaran Kushwaha, Aged About 60 Years, R/o Village Sariya,
Tahsil Ramnagar, Distt.- Satna (M.P.)
4 - Ranjana W/o Ramswarup Kushwaha, D/o Ramkrishn Kushwaha, Aged About 48
Years, R/o Village Bhattu Jhiriyatola, Tahsil Jaisinghnagar, Distt.- Shadol (M.P.)
5 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Collector, Manendragarh, Distt.- M.C.B.
(C.G.)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Ramsajiwan, Advocate.
For State
:
Ms. Richa Sahu, Panel Lawyer.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J.
Order on Board
29-09-2026
1.
The present is a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
filed by the petitioners challenging the order dated 10-08-2026 passed by the
learned Civil Judge Junior Division Janakpur, District Koriya in Civil Suit
No.02/2026 whereby the application filed by the defendants No.1 to 6 under
Section 16 of the CPC has been rejected.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that the petitioners are
defendants No.1 to 6 before the learned trial Court where respondent No.1 is
prosecuting a suit for declaration of title and permanent injunction and also
for partition of the suit property situated at Village Darain, Kharika Tola and
Ghatai. He would further submit that the property situated at Village Darain is
situated at District Shahdol, M.P. and the property situated there is the self
acquired property of the defendants and it is not the ancestral property. The
plaintiff is claiming his share over the entire property situated in the aforesaid
three villages. The property of village Ghatai is situated at Tahsil Bharatpur,
District Manendragarh-Chirmiri-Bharatpur (C.G.) and also the property of
village Kharika Tola is also within the District of District ManendragarhChirmiri-Bharatpur (C.G.) which were their ancestral property, however, the
property situated at Village Darain, District Shahdol, Madhya Pradesh is the
self acquired property of the defendants No.1 to 6. The nature of the property
itself was apparent from the documents filed by the plaintiff along with his
plaint. Therefore, the learned trial Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the
suit as the property of Village Darain is out of the jurisdiction of the learned
trial Court situated at Chhattisgarh, yet the application filed by the petitioners
has been rejected. He would further submit that the trial Court has no
territorial jurisdiction to decide the dispute, therefore, the application filed by
the petitioners may be allowed and suit filed by the plaintiff may be
dismissed.
3.
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioners and perused the documents
annexed with the petition.
4.
From perusal of the plaint, filed by the plaintiff before the learned Civil Judge
Junior Division Janakpur, District Koriya, Chhattisgarh, it transpires that the
plaintiff is claiming declaration of title, partition and permanent injunction over
the suit property which are situated at Village Darain bearing Khasra No.228
area 6.34 acre and Khasra No.362 area 7.50 acres and in para No.8 he
made pleadings that it was acquired by Sitaram and Ramkrishn, both of them
were jointly cultivated the same and there was no partition between them. In
para 9 of the plaint it has also been pleaded that the defendant No.1 without
giving any information kept the property mutated in his name alone, however
the right and title of the plaintiff is also there over the suit property. In para 10
he pleaded that during their joint holdings, their fathers have acquired the
property of village Ghatai before the settlement bearing Khasra No.227, 341,
342, 349 and 350/2 total area 3.209 hectare and the sale deed was executed
on 30-01-1973 in the name of plaintiff and defendant No.1. It is further the
pleading of the plaintiff in the plaint that the other property of village Ghatai
bearing Khasra No.423, 645, 657, 658 area 0.267 hectare, 0.360 hectare,
0.828 hectare and 0.227 hectare respectively was also acquired in the name
of plaintiff and defendant No.1 through registered sale deed in the year 1974.
5.
The plaintiff has made detailed pleadings with respect to acquisition of the
suit properties which are situated in different places either in the State of
Madhya Pradesh or in the State of Chhattisgarh. Though the defendants
No.1 to 6 have raised objection that the property situated at Village Darain,
District Shahdol, M.P. was the self acquired property of defendants No. 1 to
6, however, the said issue is required to be examined by the trial Court after
recording of the evidence of the parties concerned with respect to the nature
of its acquisition and other surrounding circumstances. In the present case,
the defendants No.1 to 6 have raised issue with respect to the jurisdiction of
the learned trial Court that since the property situated at village Darain,
Shahdol, M.P. is out of the territorial jurisdiction of the learned trial Court
situated at District Koriya, C.G. the suit cannot be proceeded.
6.
Jurisdiction of the Civil Court is provided under Section 16 of the CPC and
Section 17 of the CPC provided the jurisdiction of suit for immovable property
situated within jurisdiction of different Courts. It is necessary here to note
both sections, i.e., Section 16 and 17 of the CPC which read as under:“16. Suits to be instituted where subject-matter situate.- Subject
to the pecuniary or other limitations prescribed by any law, suits—
(a) for the recovery of immovable property with or without rent or
profits,
(b) for the partition of immovable property,
(c) for foreclosure, sale or redemption in the case of a mortgage
of or charge upon immovable property,
(d) or the determination of any other right to or interest in
immovable property,
(e) for compensation for wrong to immovable property,
(f) for the recovery of movable property actually under distraint
or attachment,
shall be instituted in the Court within the local limits of whose
jurisdiction the property is situate:
Provided that a suit to obtain relief respecting, or compensation
for wrong to, immovable property held by or on behalf of the
defendant may, where the relief sought can be entirely obtained
through his personal obedience, be instituted either in the Court
within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the property is situate,
or in the Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the
defendant actually and voluntarily resides, or carries on
business, or personally works for gain.
Explanation.—In this section "property" means property situate
in India.
17. Suits for immovable property situate within jurisdiction of
different Courts.- Where a suit is to obtain relief respecting, or
compensation for wrong to, immovable property situate within the
jurisdiction of different Courts, the suit may be instituted in any Court
within the local limits of whose jurisdiction any portion of the property
is situate:
Provided that, in respect of the value of the subject-matter of the suit,
the entire claim is cognizable by such Court.”
7.
From the aforesaid two provisions, it is quite clear that if the property situated
within different places and different jurisdictional court, the plaintiff may file
the suit in any of the local jurisdiction of the civil Court in whose jurisdiction
any portion of the property is situated. As per the plaint itself the property
situated at Village Ghatai and
Kharika Tola are within the jurisdiction of
learned trial Court at Janakpur, therefore, the plaintiff has filed the suit there
at Janakpur. In para 25 of his plaint, the plaintiff has also explained the
jurisdictional aspect of the learned trial Court.
8.
In Shivnarayan (Dead) By Legal Representatives Vs Maniklal (Dead)
Through Legal Representatives and others, (2020) 11 SCC 629, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in paragraphs No.11, 12, 13, 14, 33 and 34
that:“11. We need to notice the scheme under the Code of Civil
Procedure as delineated by Section 16 and 17. Section 16 provides
that the suit shall be instituted in the court within the local limits of
whose jurisdiction the property is situated. Section 16(b) mentions
“for the partition of immovable property”.
12. Now, we look into Section 17, which deals with suits for
immovable property situated within jurisdiction of different courts. As
per Section 17, the suit may be instituted in any court within the
local limits of whose jurisdiction any portion of the property is
situated. What is the meaning of the words "any portion of the
property"? There may be a fact situation where immovable property
is a big chunk of land, which falls into territorial jurisdiction of two
courts in which fact situation in court in whose jurisdiction any
portion of property is situated can entertain the suit. Whether
Section 17 applies only when a composite property spread in
jurisdiction of two courts or Section 17 contemplate any wider
situation. One of the submissions of the learned counsel for the
appellant is that the word "property" as occurring in Section 17 shall
also include the plural as per Section 13 of the General Clauses
Act, 1897. Section 13 of the General Clauses Act provides:
“13. Gender and number.—In all Central Acts and
Regulations, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or
context—
(1) words importing the masculine gender shall be taken to
include females; and
(2) words in the singular shall include the plural, and vice
versa."
13. Applying Section 13 of the General Clauses Act, the Bombay
High Court explaining the word "property" used in Section 17 held
that it includes properties. We are also of the same view that the
word "property" used in Section 17 can be more than one property
or properties.
14. The word "property" under Section 17 of the Civil Procedure
Code may also be properties, hence, in a schedule of plaint, more
than one property can be included. Section 17 can be applied in
event there are several properties, one or more of which may be
located in different jurisdiction of courts. The words "portion of the
property" occurring in Section 17 have to be understood in the
context of more than one property also, meaning thereby one
property out of a lot of several properties can be treated as portion
of the property as occurring in Section 17. Thus, interpretation of
words "portion of the property" cannot only be understood in a
limited and restrictive sense of being portion of one property
situated in jurisdiction of two courts.
33. Sections 16 and 17 CPC are part of the one statutory scheme.
Section 16 contains general principle that suits are to be instituted
where subject-matter is situate whereas Section 17 engrafts an
exception to the general rule as occurring in Section 16.
34. From the foregoing discussions, we arrive at the following
conclusions with regard to ambit and scope of Section 17 CPC:
34.1. The word "property" occurring in Section 17 although has
been used in "singular" but by virtue of Section 13 of the General
Clauses Act it may also be read as "plural" i.e. "properties".
34.2. The expression "any portion of the property" can be read as
portion of one or more properties situated in jurisdiction of different
courts and can be also read as portion of several properties situated
in jurisdiction of different courts.
34.3. A suit in respect of immovable property or properties situate in
jurisdiction of different courts may be instituted in any court within
whose local limits of jurisdiction, any portion of the property or one
or more properties may be situated.
34.4. A suit in respect of more than one property situated in
jurisdiction of different courts can be instituted in a court within local
limits of jurisdiction where one or more properties are situated
provided suit is based on same cause of action with respect to the
properties situated in jurisdiction of different courts.”
9.
From perusal of the impugned order passed by the learned trial Court it
transpires that the learned trial Court has rightly appreciated the provisions of
Section 16 and 17 of the CPC and keeping in view the principle laid down by
the the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shivnarayan (supra) has rejected the
application filed by the petitioners.
10.
After having gone through the entire material produced along with the petition
as well as the provision of Section 16 and 17 of the CPC and also the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shivnarayan
(supra), I do not find any perversity or jurisdictional error in rejecting the
application filed by the petitioners. Accordingly, the present writ petition fails
and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Aadil
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review