Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed by
AJINKYA
PANSARE
Date:
2026.02.12
18:14:28
+0530
2026:CGHC:7473
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 251 of 2020
1 - Arun Kumar Das S/o Late Shri Haval Das Aged About 63 Years R/o
Village- Champakpara, Police Station And Tahsil- Sitapur, DistrictSarguja, Chhattisgarh., District : Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
2 - Smt. Kusumlata Das (Died) Through Legal Heirs As Per Hon'ble
Court
Order
Dated
26-04-2023.
2.1 - (A) Smt. Gita Kashyap D/o Shri Arun Kumar Das, W/o Shri Vijay
Kashyap Aged About 42 Years R/o Sadakpara Pratapgarh, Police
Station And Tahsil Sitapur, District : Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
2.2 - (B) Sarita Das D/o Shri Arun Kumar Das Aged About 39 Years R/o
Village Sitapur, Police Station And Tahsil Sitapur, District : Surguja
(Ambikapur),
Chhattisgarh
2.3 - (C) Hemant Kumar Das S/o Shri Arun Kumar Das Aged About 36
Years R/o Village Sitapur, Police Station And Tahsil Sitapur, District
Sarguja (C.G.) At Present Detained In Central Jail Ambikapur, District :
Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Vimlesh Kumar Dubey S/o Shri Jagdev Prasad Dubey Aged About
46 Years R/o Sargipal Railway Jagdalpur, Police Station- Bodghat,
District- Bastar, Chhattisgarh. (Driver And Owner Of Truck No. C.G.-04/
J.B.5197),
District
:
Bastar(Jagdalpur),
Chhattisgarh
2 - The Branch Manager The Oriental Insurance Company Limited,
Hotel Laxman Avenue, Medical College Road, Jagdalpur, DistrictBastar, Chhattisgarh. (Insurer Of Truck No. C.G.-04/ J.B.- 5197),
District
:
Bastar(Jagdalpur),
Chhattisgarh
3 - The Branch Manager The Oriental Insurance Company Limited,
Ambedakar Chowk Ambikapur, District- Sarguja, Chhattisgarh. (Insurer
Of Truck No. C.G.-04/ J.B.- 5197) (Non-Applicants), District : Surguja
(Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
WITH
MAC No. 172 of 2020
1 - Branch Manager The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Ambedkar
Chowk, Ambikapur, District Sarguja Chhattisgarh, District : Surguja
(Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
2 - Branch Manager The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd, Hotel
Laxman Avenue, Medical College Road Jagdalpur, District Bastar
Chhattisgarh
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1 - Arun Kumar Das S/o Late Haval Das Aged About 62 Years Resident
Of Village- Champakpara, Thana And Tehsil- Sitapur, District- Sarguja
Chhattisgarh, District : Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
2 - Smt. Kusum Lata Das W/o Arun Kumar Das Aged About 55 Years
Resident Of Village- Champakpara, Thana And Tehsil- Sitapur, DistrictSarguja Chhattisgarh, District : Surguja (Ambikapur), Chhattisgarh
3 - Vimlesh Kumar Dubey S/o Jagdev Prasad Dubey Aged About 45
Years Resident Of Village- Sargipal Railway Jagdalpur, Thana Bodghat,
District- Bastar Chhattisgarh (Vehicle Driver Co Owner), District :
Bastar(Jagdalpur), Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
For Claimants
: Ms. Ananya Chatterjee, Advocate on
behalf of Mr. Rishi Rahul Soni, Advocate
For Insurance Company
: Mr. Sudhir Agrawal, Advocate
Hon’ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Judgment On Board
10.2.2026
1) Claimants have filed MAC/251/2020 for enhancement of
compensation
whereas
Insurance
Company
has
filed
MAC/172/2020 challenging therein liability pertaining to the award
passed by learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Ambikapur,
District Sarguja in Case No. 35/2019 dated 23.9.2019 whereby
learned Tribunal passed an award to the tune of Rs. 93,07,440/along with interest @ 7% p.a. on account of death of Dr. Sunil
Kumar Das. It is further stipulated that if amount of compensation
is not paid within period of 30 days from the date of award, penal
interest of 9% per annum would apply on the award amount.
2) Facts of the present cases are that on 11.6.2018, Dr. Sunil Kumar
Das was going from Jagdalpur to Dhamtari in his car with his wife
and other relatives. When they reached Balenga High School, the
offending vehicle – Truck bearing registration No. CG-04-JB-5197
being driven in rash and negligent manner, dashed the car. In the
accident, Dr. Sunil Kumar Das sustained grievous injuries and
died on the way to hospital. Claimants, who are the parents of
deceased moved claim application and pleaded that deceased
was 35 years old Medical Officer (Ayurved) working at Govt.
Ayurved Dispensary, Narayanpur earning Rs. 50,000/- per month.
They claimed a total sum of Rs. 1,34,00,000/-. Insurance
Company filed reply and denied the contents of claim application.
Learned Tribunal framed issues ; parties led evidence and
thereafter, award impugned was passed.
3) Learned counsel appearing for the claimants submits that
although learned Tribunal has rightly assessed loss of income
and awarded fair compensation under conventional heads but
granted meager compensation towards loss of consortium
overlooking the number of dependents. She prays to modify the
award accordingly.
4) On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the Insurance
Company submits that deceased was a Medical Officer (Ayurved)
in government dispensary but he was not a salaried person,
instead he was working on contract basis and used to receive
fixed emolument to the tune of Rs. 49,000/- after deduction of
income tax which is evident from salary slip (Ex. P/16) but
learned Tribunal has awarded 50% of the established income
towards future prospect, instead of 40% as per the law laid down
by the Supreme Court in the matter of National Insurance Co.
Ltd. Versus Pranay Sethi1. He further submits that the deceased
and his wife died in the accident and parents of the deceased
have filed the claim petition, therefore learned Tribunal ought to
have deducted 1/2 dependency towards personal and living
expenses of deceased instead of 1/3. He contends that learned
Tribunal has wrongly applied multiplier of 16 whereas the
deceased was aged 35 years 2 months and 9 days on the date of
accident and appropriate multiplier should have been 15 as per
the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Sarla Verma Versus Delhi Transport Corporation2. He further
contends that learned Tribunal awarded penal interest @ 9% per
annum which is contrary to the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the matter of National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs.
1. (2017) 16 SCC 680
2. (2009) 6 SCC 121
Keshav Bahadur and Others3. He prays to modify the award
accordingly.
5) I have heard learned counsel appearing for the respective parties,
considered their rival submissions made herein above and
carefully perused the documents placed on record.
6) Admittedly, deceased was 35 years old and he was working as
Medical
Officer
(Ayurved)
at
Govt.
Ayurved
Dispensary,
Narayanpur. Arun Kumar Das (AW/1), father of deceased
admitted that deceased was a contractual employee and he was
getting fixed salary of Rs. 50,000/- per month. The pay-slip
(Ex.P/16) would show that income tax of Rs. 1,000/- was being
deducted from his salary, thus it can be safely construed that
deceased was a contractual employee receiving fixed monthly
emolument Rs. 49,000/-. It appears that learned Tribunal has
awarded 50% of established income towards future prospect
whereas the deceased not a permanent employee, therefore
claimants would be entitled to receive 40% of established income
towards future prospect as per law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the matter of Pranay Sethi (supra), instead of
50% as awarded by Tribunal.
7) Furthermore, deceased is survived by his parents but learned
Tribunal deducted 1/3 dependency towards personal and living
expenses of deceased whereas as per the law laid down by the
3. (2004) 2 SCC 370
Apex Court in the matter of Sarla Verma (supra), appropriate
deduction under this head would be 1/2 looking to the number of
dependents. It is argued by Mr. Agrawal that learned Tribunal
erroneously applied multiplier of 16 whereas the deceased was
aged 35 years 2 months and 9 days on the date of accident. It is
well-settled that the applicable multiplier for the 31–35 age
bracket is 16, whereas it is 15 for those aged 36–40. As the
deceased was under 36 years of age at the time of the accident,
learned
Tribunal
correctly
adopted
the
multiplier
of
16.
Consequently, this finding is consistent with precedent set by
Apex Court in the matter of Sarla Verma (supra) and warrants no
interference.
8) Evidently, learned Tribunal has awarded a meager sum of Rs.
40,000/- towards loss of consortium overlooking the fact that
parents
of
deceased
are
entitled
to
receive
separate
compensation towards loss of consortium as held by Hon’ble
Supreme in the matter of Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. V.
Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram & Ors.4 therefore in my opinion,
claimants are entitled to receive compensation to the tune of Rs.
40,000 along with an additional sum of 20% i.e. Rs. 48,000/- in
total.
9) A careful perusal of award would reveal that learned Tribunal has
imposed penal interest @ 9% per annum. In this regard, Hon'ble
4. (2008) 18 SCC 130
Supreme Court in the matter of National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs.
Keshav Bahadur and Others5 held as under :“13.Though Section 110-CC of the Act
(corresponding to Section 171 of the new
Act) confers a discretion on the Tribunal to
award interest, the same is meant to be
exercised in cases where the claimant can
claim the same as a matter of right. In the
above background, it is to be judged
whether a stipulation for higher rate of
interest in case of default can be imposed
by the Tribunal. Once the discretion has
been exercised by the Tribunal to award
simple interest on the amount of
compensation to be awarded at a particular
rate and from a particular date, there is no
scope for retrospective enhancement for
default in payment of compensation. No
express or implied power in this regard can
be culled out from Section 110-CC of the
Act or Section 171 of the new Act. Such a
direction in the award for retrospective
enhancement of interest for default in
payment of the compensation together with
interest payable thereon virtually amounts
to imposition of penalty which is not
statutorily envisaged and prescribed. It is,
therefore directed that the rate of interest as
awarded by the High Court shall alone be
applicable till payment, without the
stipulation for higher rate of interest being
enforced, in the manner directed by the
Tribunal.”
In view of the judgment rendered by the Apex Court in the
matter of Keshav Bahadur (supra), learned Tribunal was justified
in imposing interest @ 7% per annum on the award from the date
of filing of claim petition till its realization, but has committed
illegality in imposing penal interest @ 9% per annum on the
award, if compensation is not deposited within a period of one
5. (2004) 2 SCC 370
month before the Tribunal from the date of award. Therefore, the
order of the Tribunal regarding penal interest is liable to be and is
hereby set aside.
10) Thus, in light of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is recomputing the compensation as below:
Sr.
No.
1.
Heads
Compensation
awarded
Tribunal
Compensation
by awarded by this Court
Annual Income after Rs. 5,77,340/deduction of Income
Tax
Rs. 5,88,000/-
Annual Income after Rs. 8,66,010/adding
Future (@50%)
Prospect
Rs. 8,23,200/-
3.
Annual income after Rs. 5,77,340/Deduction
towards (@1/3)
personal expenses
Rs. 4,11,600/(@1/2)
4.
Annual Income after Rs. 92,37,440/applying Multiplier
(@16)
Rs. 65,85,600/-
5.
Loss of Estate
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
6.
Funeral expenses
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
7.
Loss of Consortium
Rs. 40,000/-
Rs. 88,000/-
TOTAL
Rs. 93,07,440/-
Rs. 67,03,600/-
2.
(@Rs. 49,000 pm)
(@40%)
(@16)
11) Accordingly, the amount of compensation of Rs. 93,07,440/awarded by the learned Tribunal is reduced to Rs. 67,03,600/-.
The Insurance Company is made liable to pay the reduced
compensation to the claimants within period of 60 days.
12) Accordingly, the appeals preferred by Insurance Company and
Claimants are allowed in part and the impugned award is
modified to the extent as indicated herein-above.
Sd/Rakesh Mohan Pandey
JUDGE
Ajinkya
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review