Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
****
C.R.P.Nos.4935, 4957, 5067, 5074, 5415, 5442, 5459, 5500 and 5869 of
2017 and C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4935/2017
Between:
Gheesubaigari Mahammed Sab
..... PETITIONER
AND
The Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition Officer, S.R.B.C., Nandyal
....RESPONDENT
DATE OF ORDER RESERVED
: 16.07.2026
DATE OF ORDER PRONOUNCED : 14.10.2026
DATE OF ORDER UPLOADED
: 14.10.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the common order?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copies of common order may be
marked to Law Reporters/Journals
Yes/No
3. Whether Your Lordship wishes to see the
fair copy of the common order?
Yes/No
_____________________________________
PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR CHINTALAPUDI,J
* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
C.R.P.Nos.4935, 4957, 5067, 5074, 5415, 5442, 5459, 5500 and 5869 of
2017 and C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4935/2017
%
14.10.2026
# Gheesubaigari Mahammed Sab
……petitioner
And:
$ The Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition Officer,
S.R.B.C., Nandyal
…. respondent
!Counsel for the petitioners
: Sri Anumula Karthik Reddy
^Counsel for the respondents
: Sri Lova Raju Uppalapati, Assistant
Government Pleader for Arbitrations
<Gist:
>Head Note:
? Cases referred:
1. AIR 1968 SC 432
2. 1990 Allahabad Law Journal 800
3. MANU/AP/0109/2005
4. 2002 (1) ALD 200
5. 1997 (5) ALT 561
6. 2021 Supreme (Online) (Tel) 2555
7. High Court of Madras, decided on 07.08.2009
8. C.M.A.No.1141 of 2018 & C.R.P.No.6787 of 2018, dated 06.03.2026
9. (2003) 3 SCC 472
10. (2021) 6 SCC 418
11. 2021 Supreme (Online) (Mad) 980
12. 2022 Supreme (AP) 140
Date of reserved for orders: 16.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 14.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 14.10.2026
APHC010151132017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3606]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)s
Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE 14th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
C.R.P.Nos.4935, 4957, 5067
5067,, 5074, 5415, 5442, 5459, 5500 and 5869 of
2017 and C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4935/2017
Between:
1. GHEESUBAIGARI
MAHAMMED
SAB,
KURNOOL
DIST,
S/O.
HUSSAIN SAB, AGE 75 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURIST, R/O.
MANCHALAKATTA
VILLAGE,
MIDTHUR
MANDAL,
KURNOOL
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPL
DY
COLLECTOR
LAO
KURNOOL
DIST,
LAND
ACQUISITION OFFICER, S.R.B.C NANDYAL, KURNOOL DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision petition and set aside the order in EP No. 11 of
2015 in L.A.O.P No.157 of 20
08 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 15-06-2017 and order the attachment of EP schedule
properties and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4957/2017
Between:
1. GHEESUBAIGARI AMEENA BI, W/O. GHOUSI BI, AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. KODUMURU VILLAGE, MIDUTHUR MANDAL, KURNOOL.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.C.NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision petition and set aside the in EP No.15 of 2015 in
L.A.O.P No.148 of 2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge, Nandikotkur
dt.14.06.2017 and order attachment of EP schedule properties and pass.
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5067/2017
Between:
1. KASIREDDYGARI PUNYAVATHI,, W/O. VENKATAKA PURSHOTHAM
REDDY,
AGED:
YEARS,
OCC:
AGRICULTURIST,
R/O.
KODUMURU VILLAGE MIDUTHUR MANDAL, KURNOOL.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.C NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the Civil Revision petition and set aside the order in EP No. 7
of 2015 in L.A.O.P No.179 of 2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 14-06-2017 and order attachment of EP schedule
properties and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5074/2017
Between:
1. SHAIK KHAJAMAIAH, S/O. KHASIM SAB AGRICULTURIST R/O.
MANCHALAKATTA
VILLAGE,
MIDTHUR
MANDAL,
KURNOOL
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE SPECIAL DEPUTY COLLECTOR, Land Acquisition Officer,
S.R.B.C. Nandyal, Kurnool District.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision Petition and set aside the order in EP No. 16 of
2015 in LAOP No. 212 of 2008 on the file of Learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 14-6-2017 and order the attachment of EP Schedule
property and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5415/2017
Between:
1. K.VENKATA LAKSHMI REDDY, S/O SUBBA REDDY AGED 49
YEARS, HINDU, AGRICULTURIST R/O MANCHALAKATTA VILLAGE,
MIDUTHUR MANDAL KURNOOL DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.C NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision petition and set aside the order in EP No. 59 of
2014 in L.A.O.P No.173 of 2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 20-07-2017 and order the attachment of petition schedule
properties and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5442/2017
Between:
1. TELUGU VENKATA SUBBAMMA,, W/O VENKATA RAMANA AGED 44
YEARS,
AGRICULTURIST
R/O
NANDYAL
TOWN,
KURNOOL
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.C NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision petition and set aside the order in EP No. 12 of
2015 in L.A.O.P No.128 of 2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 19-06-2017 and order the attachment of petition schedule
properties and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5459/2017
Between:
1. KATHA VENKATA SUBBA REDDY,, S/O VENKATA REDDY AGED 65
YEARS,
AGRICULTURIST
R/O
MANCHALAKATTA
VILLAGE,MIDUTHUR MANDAL KURNOOL DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.C NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision petition and set aside the order in EP No. 10 of
2015 in L.A.O.P No.158 of 2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 05-07-2017 and order the attachment of petition schedule
properties and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
The Court made the following:
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5500/2017
Between:
1. B.RAMAIAH,
SI
O
LATE
SESHAIAH
,
AGED
YEARS,
AGRICULTURIST R/O TALAMUDIPI VILLAGE, MIDUTHUR MANDAL
KURNOOL DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.C NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to allow the revision petition and set aside the order in EP No. 14 of
2015 in L.A.O.P No.129 of 2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Nandikotkur dated 19-07-2017 and order the attachment of petition schedule
properties and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5869/2017
Between:
1. BONTHALA SUBBA LAKSHMAIAH, OCC: AGRICULTURE, R/O.
TALAMUDIPI VILLAGE, MIDUTHUR MANDAL, KARNOOL DISTRICT
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition Officer, S.R.B.C
Nandyal
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to set aside the order in EP No. 13 of 2015 in L.A.O.P No. 131 of
2008 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge, Nandikotkur dt. 19-06-2017 and
order the attachment of petition schedule properties and pass.
IA NO: 2 OF 2017(CRPMP 32178 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 Code praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. GP FOR ARBITRATION (AP)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2696/2018
Between:
1. M.PAPAMMA, W/O M.CHINNANAGI REDDY AGED 52 YEARS,
HINDU, AGRICULTURIST
MANDAL
R/O TALAMUDIPI VILLAGE, MIDUTHUR
KURNOOL DISTRICT.
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT
KURNOOL TOWN
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
SPECIAL
DEPUTY
COLLECTOR,
LAND
ACQUISITION
OFFICER, S.R.B.O NANDYAL.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Sec. 115 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein,the High Court may be
pleased to set aside the order in EP No. 41 of 2014 in LAOP No.1 of 2011 on
the file of learned Senior Civil Judge, Nandikotkur dated 05-01-2018 and order
the attachment of petition schedule properties and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 Code praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANUMULA KARTHIK REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. Nil
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
C.R.P.Nos.4935, 4957, 5067, 5074, 5415, 5442, 5459, 5500 and 5869 of
2017 and C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018
COMMON ORDER:
The petitioners have filed these Civil Revision Petitions under Section
115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter, “the Code”), challenging
the orders of the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Nandikotkur (hereinafter, “the
learned Judge”), dismissing their Execution Petitions. In those petitions, the
petitioners, as decree-holders, sought attachment and sale of the scheduled
properties to realise the amounts awarded in the land-acquisition proceedings.
2.
These Civil Revision Petitions raise substantially the same issue:
whether the decree-holders may execute the compensation awards by
seeking attachment of properties belonging to the State.
3.
Sri Anumula Karthik Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioners, and Sri
Lova Raju Uppalapati, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Arbitrations,
represented petitioners and respondents respectively.
4.
These petitions are disposed of by this common order.
Factual Matrix:
5.
The State intended to acquire lands for widening the Srisailam Right
Branch Canal (SRBC). Accordingly, proceedings were initiated under the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter, “the Act”). The Land Acquisition Officer
(hereinafter, “the LAO”) was appointed to acquire the lands identified for the
SRBC. The lands fell within survey numbers in which the petitioners held land.
After hearing the petitioners as claimants, the LAO passed an award granting
compensation at Rs.65,000/- per acre under Award No.1/2007, dated
14.05.2007, in the cases arising from that award. C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018
concerns Award No.14/2007-2008, dated 20.10.2007, which also fixed
compensation at Rs.65,000/- per acre.
6.
The petitioners were dissatisfied with the LAO’s award. Although they
received the compensation, they did so under protest and sought a reference
to the Civil Court under Section 18 of the Act. Accordingly, the LAO referred
their claims to the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Nandikotkur, which
registered the references as Land Acquisition Original Petitions (L.A.O.Ps.).
7.
In the references, the petitioners were shown as claimants and the
LAO as the referring officer. No respondent was shown in the cause titles.
8.
After
hearing
the
references,
the
Civil
Court
enhanced
the
compensation from Rs.65,000/- to Rs.1,60,000/- per acre, together with 30%
solatium, 12% additional market value and interest at 9% per annum. The
record does not show that the LAO or the State paid the enhanced
compensation.
9.
The record does not show that any appeal was preferred against the
awards.
10.
Treating the awards as decrees, the petitioners filed Execution Petitions
under Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter, “the Code”),
seeking attachment and sale of movable and immovable properties for
recovery of the enhanced compensation.
11.
The learned Judge initially ordered attachment of movable and
immovable
properties
at
the
office
of
the
Tahsildar,
Nandikotkur.
Subsequently, the learned Judge dismissed the Execution Petitions on the
ground that the scheduled properties belonged to the Tahsildar’s office, which
was part of a department other than the land acquisition department. As the
LAO was shown as the judgment-debtor and the properties sought to be
attached did not belong to him, the learned Judge held that the properties of
another department could not be attached.
12.
The petitioners have challenged the dismissal orders in these Civil
Revision Petitions.
13.
The particulars of the respective Civil Revision Petitions, Execution
Petitions and Land Acquisition Original Petitions are as follows:
Sl.
No.
C.R.P.No. Petitioner/Claimant E.P.No. L.A.O.P.No.
4935/2017
4957/2017
5067/2017
Gheesubaigari
Mohammed Sab
Gheesubaigari
Ameena Bi
Kasireddygari
Punyavathi
Property
Details of Attachment / E.P.
Date of
Schedule Property
Order
5 computers, 10 tables, 10 iron
11/2015 157/2008
Movable
beeruvas at Tahsildar’s Office,
15.06.2017
Nandikotkur
15/2015 148/2008
Immovable
7/2015
Immovable
Tahsildar’s Office, Door No.7-105,
Nandikotkur.
14.06.2017
Door No.16-A, ground floor and
179/2008
open site, D.E.E., R.W.S. Office,
14.06.2017
Nandikotkur.
Door No.16-A, ground floor and
5074/2017 Shaik Khajamiah
16/2015 212/2008
Immovable
open site, D.E.E., R.W.S. Office,
14.06.2017
Nandikotkur.
5415/2017
5442/2017
K. Venkata Lakshmi
Reddy
Telugu Venkata
Subbamma
Katha Venkata
5459/2017
5500/2017 B. Ramaiah
Subba Reddy
Door No.16-A, ground floor and
59/2014 173/2008
Immovable
open site, D.E.E., R.W.S. Office,
20.07.2017
Nandikotkur.
6 computers, 10 tables, 10 iron
12/2015 128/2008
Movable
beeruvas, Mandal Education
19.06.2017
Office, Nandikotkur.
10/2015 158/2008
Immovable
14/2015 129/2008
Immovable
Tahsildar’s Office, Door No.7-105,
Nandikotkur.
05.07.2017
Door No.16-A, ground floor and
open site, D.E.E., R.W.S. Office,
19.07.2017
Nandikotkur.
Bonthala Subba
5869/2017
2696/2018 M. Papamma
Lakshmaiah
13/2015 131/2008
Immovable
41/2014 1/2011
Immovable
Tahsildar’s Office, Door No.7-105,
Nandikotkur.
Survey No.485, Ac.0.06 cents out
19.06.2017
05.01.2018
of Ac.8.46 cents, Nandikotkur.
14.
In all the above cases, the Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition
Officer, Srisailam Right Branch Canal (SRBC), Nandyal, is shown as the
respondent. The claimants sought references under Section 18 of the Act.
Case of the Petitioners:
15.
The respective revision petitioners moved execution proceedings before
the learned Judge for execution of the respective awards/decrees, stating that
the Civil Court had enhanced the compensation and awarded interest,
solatium and other statutory benefits.
16.
The petitioners contended that, although the respective awards had
been passed, the enhanced compensation remained unpaid. They therefore
sought to execute the awards/decrees.
17.
In some Execution Petitions, the petitioners sought attachment and sale
of movable properties (office furniture) under Order XXI Rules 43 and 77 of
the Code at the offices of the Tahsildar and the Mandal Education Officer,
Nandikotkur Town, Kurnool District.
18.
In the remaining Execution Petitions, the petitioners sought attachment
under Order XXI Rule 54 of the Code of the scheduled immovable properties,
including office buildings and land belonging to the Tahsildar’s office and other
Government offices at Nandikotkur Town, Kurnool District, and sought their
sale to realise the respective decretal amounts.
Proceedings before the Executing Court:
19.
The learned Judge took the respective Execution Petitions on file and
initially ordered attachment. Subsequently, the learned Judge questioned their
maintainability on the ground that the scheduled properties did not belong to
the LAO personally and were not in his possession, but belonged to the State
or other departments of the Government of Andhra Pradesh.
20.
The Execution Petitions sought attachment and sale of movable or
immovable properties for realisation of the awards. The two categories of
petitions are set out below:
Category
C.R.P.Nos.
Nature of property
Movable-
C.R.P.Nos.4935 and
Movable properties, including office
Relevant
provisions
Sec. 60
Category
C.R.P.Nos.
Nature of property
property cases
5442 of 2017
Immovableproperty cases
C.R.P.Nos.4957,
5067, 5074, 5415,
5459, 5500 and 5869
of 2017 and
C.R.P.No.2696 of
furniture, computers, tables and iron
beeruvas, situated in the Tahsildar's Office
and Mandal Education Office, Nandikotkur
Town, Kurnool District, respectively.
Immovable properties situated at
Nandikotkur Town, Kurnool District,
including the Tahsildar's Office building
bearing Door No.7-105, the building bearing
Door No.16-A with open site, and land in
Survey No.485, as described in the
respective E.P. schedules.
Relevant
provisions
Order XXI Rules 43
and 77 CPC
Sec. 60
Order XXI Rule 54
CPC and the
relevant provisions
relating to
sale/proclamation in
the respective E.Ps.
Movable Property Cases (C.R.P.Nos.4935 and 5442 of 2017):
21.
In the movable-property cases, the learned Judge opined as whether
attachment under Order XXI Rule 43 of the Code of movable properties
belonging to other departments of the Government of Andhra Pradesh, which
were not the judgment-debtor.
Immovable-property cases (C.R.P.Nos.4957, 5067, 5074, 5415, 5459, 5500
and 5869 of 2017 and C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018):
22.
In the immovable-property cases, the opined was whether attachment
under Order XXI Rule 54 of the Code of immovable properties belonging to
other departments of the Government of Andhra Pradesh.
23.
After hearing both sides, the learned Judge referred to to Abdul
Hussain Tayabali etc. v. State of Gujarat and another 1, but did not apply
that decision, observing that it concerned a Special Land Acquisition Officer
specially appointed to perform the functions of the Collector under the Act,
whereas the LAO in these cases was not the Collector.
24.
The learned Judge observed that the petitioners had shown the LAO as
the judgment-debtor in the Execution Petitions, whereas the State,
represented by the District Collector, had not been impleaded. Relying on
Section 79 of the Code, the learned Judge held that, when proceedings are
AIR 1968 SC 432
initiated against the Government, the State must be named as a party and
cannot be replaced by the LAO.
25.
The learned Judge further observed that the awards were not passed
against the State. As the LAO had been specially appointed under the Act to
perform the functions of the Collector, the petitioners ought to have impleaded
the State in the Execution Petitions. On that basis, the learned Judge held that
the attachment orders were not proper.
26.
The learned Judge also referred to Section 60 of the Code and held that
only movable or immovable property belonging to the judgment-debtor, or
property over which the judgment-debtor has a disposing power, is liable to
attachment and sale. According to the learned Judge, the LAO had no
saleable interest in the scheduled properties.
27.
In the movable-property cases, the learned Judge considered Order XXI
Rules 12 and 43 of the Code and concluded that those provisions did not
apply because the LAO did not possess the scheduled properties and the
properties belonged to another department.
28.
The learned Judge proceeded on the basis that the scheduled
immovable properties did not belong to the LAO and could not be attached
under Order XXI Rule 54 of the Code.
29.
The learned Judge dismissed the respective Execution Petitions. The
petitioners have filed these Civil Revision Petitions under Section 115 of the
Code, challenging the dismissal orders.
Grounds of Challenge:
30.
The petitioners rely on substantially the same grounds, which are as
follows:
i) The learned Judge erred in holding that the properties attached in the
Execution Petitions do not belong to the judgment-debtor and that the
judgment-debtor has no interest in the attached properties or that the said
properties are not in his possession.
ii) The learned Judge erroneously held that the petitioners ought to have
made the State a party in the Execution Petitions instead of the Land
Acquisition Officer to realise the amounts passed in the respective Awards.
iii) The learned Judge ought to have considered the contention of the
petitioners that the State Government is liable for realisation of the award
amounts.
iv) The learned Judge erred in holding that the Execution Petitions were not
filed against the State Government for proceeding against properties
belonging to the State Government.
v) The learned Judge ought to have considered the contention that the
District Collector is the Administrator of the District and that Government
properties in the District are under the administrative control of the State
through its officers.
vi) The learned Judge ought to have considered that the judgment-debtor
cannot be permitted to raise technical objections which result in delay in
payment of compensation to persons deprived of their property.
vii) The learned Judge erred in holding that the petition schedule properties
do not belong to the judgment-debtor and, therefore, the petitioners cannot
realise the respective awards.
31. With these revision grounds, the petitioners sought to set aside the
respective impugned orders, restore the Execution Petitions, and pass
appropriate orders.
Proceedings before this Court:
32.
This Court issued notice to the respondent-L.A.O. in the respective Civil
Revision Petitions, and learned Government Pleader for Arbitrations appeared
for L.A.O.
33.
According to the record, the respondent did not file written defence to
the Execution Petitions before the learned Executing Court. The learned
Judge independently questioned their maintainability, sought clarification and
heard both sides on that issue.
Submissions of learned counsel:
34.
Sri Anumula Karthik Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioners,
submitted that the learned Judge erred in holding that the properties could not
be attached merely because they were not the LAO’s personal properties. He
argued that the LAO represented the State, which was liable to satisfy the
compensation awards, and that the petitioners did not seek to proceed against
the personal properties of the LAO or any other officer.
35.
He further submitted that the State was responsible for paying the
compensation, but the amounts had remained unpaid for several years. The
petitioners sought attachment only of State property, not the personal property
of the LAO or the Tahsildar. He contended that the learned Judge misapplied
the law and erred in dismissing the Execution Petitions.
36.
Sri Lova Raju Uppalapati, learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Arbitrations, submitted that the impugned orders did not warrant interference
and disclosed no material irregularity. He argued that, as the properties
belonged to the State, the State had to be made a party. Relying on Article
300 of the Constitution of India, he submitted that proceedings against the
State must name the State as a party and that the LAO, who acted under the
State’s authority, had no personal liability.
37.
The learned Assistant Government Pleader further submitted that the
properties could not be attached unless the State was made a party and that
the Execution Petitions were therefore not maintainable.
38.
I have heard both learned counsel and perused the material on record
in all these Civil Revision Petitions.
Analysis:
39.
Learned counsel submitted that the respective awards had not been
challenged before the appropriate forum. This Court therefore proceeds on the
basis that the awards of the Reference Court remain operative. Neither party
has placed material to show that the State paid the enhanced compensation
after the impugned orders and before this Court took up these matters.
Discussion:
40.
The learned Judge appears to have dismissed the Execution Petitions
on the ground that the awards, though executable as decrees, could not be
executed against the LAO because the petitioners sought attachment of
properties belonging to the Tahsildar’s office, which was not a party, and
because the State had not been impleaded.
41.
The following points arise for consideration:
Point No. 1: Whether an award of the Reference Court is a decree
and, if so, whether it is executable?
Point No. 2: If the award is executable, against whom should
execution proceed?
Point No. 3: In execution proceedings, should the public officer
appointed under the Act or the State be treated as the proper party?
Point No. 4: If the proper party has not been impleaded, does that
affect the maintainability of the Execution Petitions?
Point No. 5: What relief?
The points are discussed below together:
42.
It is necessary to briefly refer to the procedure prescribed by the Act.
The State may acquire land for a public purpose and appoint or authorise an
officer to perform the statutory functions relating to the acquisition.
43.
The LAO’s determination of compensation culminates in an award. If a
claimant does not accept the award, the claimant may seek a reference on the
grounds specified in the Act, including measurement of the land, the amount
of compensation, the person entitled to receive it, or apportionment of
compensation.
44.
Section 18 of the Act reads as follows:
“18. Reference to Court.—
(1) Any person interested who has not accepted the award may, by
written application to the Collector, require that the Collector refer the
matter for the determination of the Court, whether his objection be to
the measurement of the land, the amount of the compensation, the
persons to whom it is payable, or the apportionment of the
compensation among the persons interested.
(2) The application shall state the grounds on which objection to the
award is taken:
Provided that every such application shall be made—
(a) if the person making it was present or represented before the
Collector at the time when he made his award, within six weeks from
the date of the Collector’s award;
(b) in other cases, within six weeks of the receipt of the notice from the
Collector under section 12, sub-section (2); or, within six months from
the date of the Collector’s award, whichever period shall first expire.”
45.
The above provision shows that persons claiming an interest in the
compensation payable for the acquired land, including persons interested in
an easement affecting the land, are persons interested for the purposes of the
Act.
46.
Section 18 permits a person interested who has not accepted the award
to seek a reference. The LAO is not a person interested in receiving
compensation and cannot seek a reference in that capacity. The claimants are
the persons who assert an interest in the acquired land or compensation.
47.
In the present cases, the Special Deputy Collector/Land Acquisition
Officer, SRBC, is shown as the referring officer in the respective references
under Section 18 of the Act, and the petitioners are shown as claimants. The
cause titles do not identify a respondent.
C.R.P.No.
L.A.O.P.No.
4935/2017
157/2008
4957/2017
148/2008
5067/2017
179/2008
5074/2017
212/2008
5415/2017
173/2008
5442/2017
128/2008
Referring Officer
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Claimant
Gheesubaigari Mohammed
Sab
Gheesubaigari Ameena Bi
Kasireddygari Punyavathi
Shaik Khajamiah
K. Venkata Lakshmi Reddy
Telugu Venkata Subbamma
C.R.P.No.
L.A.O.P.No.
5459/2017
158/2008
5500/2017
129/2008
5869/2017
131/2008
2696/2018
1/2011
48.
Referring Officer
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Special Deputy Collector/L.A.O.,
SRBC
Claimant
Katha Venkata Subba Reddy
B. Ramaiah
Bonthala Subba Lakshmaiah
M. Papamma
Once a matter is referred to the Civil Court, the Court exercises
jurisdiction over the reference and must pass an award in accordance with
law.
Sec. 26 of the Act reads as follows
“26. Form of awards.—
(1) Every award under this Part shall be in writing signed by the Judge,
and shall specify the amount awarded under clause first of sub-section
(1) of section 23, and also the amounts (if any) respectively awarded
under each of the other clauses of the same sub-section, together with
the grounds of awarding each of the said amounts.
(2) Every such award shall be deemed to be a decree and the
statement of the grounds of every such award a judgment within the
meaning of section 2, clause (2), and section 2, clause (9),
respectively, of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908).”
49.
Section 26(2) of the Act provides that the award of the Civil Court is
deemed to be a decree. Execution of that decree is governed by the Code.
50.
The principle that an award of the Collector is not a decree, whereas an
award of the Reference Court is treated as a decree under the Act, is
discussed in Smt. Shyam Lata Jouhari and others v. Collector, Allahabad
and others2.
51.
The relevant provisions of the Code are as follows:
Section 2(2) of the Code defines a “decree”. Section 2(2) of the Code
reads as follows:
1990 Allahabad Law Journal 800
“decree” means the formal expression of an adjudication which, so far
as regards the Court expressing it, conclusively determines the rights
of the parties about all or any of the matters in controversy in the suit
and may be either preliminary or final.”
52.
The person in whose favour a decree is passed is the decree-holder.
Section 2(3) of the Code defines “decree-holder” as follows:
“decree-holder” means any person in whose favour a decree has been
passed or an order capable of execution has been made.”
53.
The person against whom a decree is passed is the judgment-debtor.
Section 2(10) of the Code defines “judgment-debtor” as follows:
“judgment-debtor” means any person against whom a decree has been
passed or an order capable of execution has been made.”
54.
A judgment-debtor is a person against whom a decree has been passed
or an order capable of execution has been made.
55.
In the present batch, the cause titles of the respective awards show the
LAO as the referring officer and the petitioners as the claimants. This has
contributed to the present ambiguity.
56.
The cause titles do not identify a respondent. The LAO, as referring
officer, is neither a person interested in receiving compensation nor a
claimant. At most, the LAO acted as the officer representing the acquisition
proceedings. Merely naming the LAO as the referring officer does not, by
itself, establish that the award imposes liability on him personally or identifies
the State as the judgment-debtor.
57.
In principle, execution cannot proceed against the LAO in his personal
capacity merely because he performed statutory functions. The LAO is a State
officer appointed or authorised under the Act to discharge the functions
prescribed by law.
58.
Section 2(17)(g) of the Code reads as follows:
“public officer” means a person falling under any of the following
descriptions, namely:—
(g) every officer in the service or pay of the Government, or
remunerated by fees or commission for the performance of any public
duty.”
59.
The above provision shows that an officer in the service or pay of the
Government who discharges public duties is a public officer.
60.
Now, in this scenario, it is relevant to take aid of the provisions of the
Act.
61.
Sections 19 and 20 of the Act prescribe the procedure that the
Reference Court must follow after receiving a reference under Section 18.
62.
Section 19 reads as follows:
“19. Collectors statement to the Court
(1) In making the reference, the Collector shall state for the information
of the Court, in writing under his hand,
(a)(a) the situation and extent of the land, with particulars of any
trees, buildings or standing crops thereon;
(b)(b) the names of the persons whom he has reason to think
interested in such land;
(c)(c) the amount awarded for damages and paid or tendered
under sections 5 and 17, or either of them, and the amount of
compensation awarded under section 11; [*] [The word "and"
omitted by Act 68 of 1984, Section 14 (w.e.f. 24.9.1984).]
(cc) [ the amount paid or deposited under sub-section (3-A) of
section 17; and] [Inserted by Act 68 of 1984, Section 14 (w.e.f.
24.9.1984).]
(d)(d) if the objection be to the amount of the compensation, the
grounds on which the amount of compensation was determined.
(2)(2) To the said statement shall be attached a schedule giving the
parti- culars of the notices served upon, and of the statements in
writing made or delivered by the parties interested respectively.”
63.
Section 19 requires the Collector, when making a reference, to provide
the Court with particulars concerning the land, the parties and the
compensation, including the relevant statements and information.
64.
On receiving the reference, the Court has to proceed to serve the
notices required by law.
65.
Section 20 reads as follows:
“20. Service of notice
The Court shall thereupon cause a notice specifying the day on which
the Court will proceed to determine the objection, and directing their
appearance before the Court on that day, to be served on the following
persons, namely:
(a)
the applicant;
(b)
all persons interested in the objection, except such (if any) of
them as have consented without protest to receive payment of the
compensation awarded; and]
(c)
if the objection is in regard to the area of the land or to the
amount of the compensation, the Collector.”
66.
Section 20 requires the Court to issue notice to the applicant, to
persons interested in the objections concerning the amount of compensation
or the area of the land, and to the Collector where the objection concerns the
amount of compensation.
67.
The awards do not record whether the procedure under Sections 19
and 20 of the Act was followed. They show the LAO as the referring officer
and the petitioners as claimants. The absence of a recital in the awards does
not, by itself, establish that the required notices were not served; the relevant
records must be examined.
68.
The record, thus do not reflect as to the award proceedings included the
party responsible for opposing the claim for enhanced compensation. The
question thus to the effect that on execution the defect can be addressed in
accordance with law.
Executability of the Decree:
69.
The awards remain operative unless set aside by a competent forum.
The principle that an award of compensation should ordinarily be enforced
through execution proceedings is supported by the Full Bench decision in
Bhamidipati Annapoorna Bhavani v. Land Acquisition Officer3 (FiveJudge Bench).
70.
In Vemula Prabhakar and others v. Land Acquisition Officer and
Revenue Divisional Officer, Peddapalli, Karimnagar District and another 4,
it was held that execution proceedings cannot ordinarily be initiated under
Article 226 of the Constitution in place of the execution remedy.
71.
In B. Govinda Reddy v. Revenue Divisional Officer-cum-Land
Acquisition Officer5, it was held that a claimant should ordinarily first seek
execution of the compensation award and may approach the High Court
where the authorities fail to comply despite execution proceedings.
72.
The Full Bench in Bhamidipati Annapoorna Bhavani’s case overruled
Vemula Prabhakar’s case and upheld B. Govinda Reddy’s case as stating
the correct legal position. It held that, where compensation has been finally
determined, the claimant should ordinarily seek its realisation through
execution proceedings.
73.
The Full Bench held that the State Government or the authorities on
whose behalf the land was acquired may be directed to deposit the
compensation, in accordance with the applicable legal position.
74.
The first remedy for realisation of an award of compensation is
ordinarily
to
approach
the
Reference
Court
by
initiating
execution
case
(supra)
supports
proceedings.
75.
Bhamidipati
Annapoorna
Bhavani’s
enforcement of compensation awards against the State Government or the
authorities on whose behalf the land was acquired. In the present cases,
MANU/AP/0109/2005
2002 (1) ALD 200
1997 (5) ALT 561
however, the identity of the party bound by each award and the legal basis for
proceeding against the scheduled properties must be determined from the
record.
76.
In T. Tirupataiah & others v. State of Telangana & others6, the High
Court of Telangana relied on the Full Bench decision in Bhamidipati
Annapoorna Bhavani’s case. The case concerned land acquired by the State
and the recovery of compensation determined by the Reference Court.
77.
The claimants in T. Tirupataiah approached the High Court under Article
226 of the Constitution. Relying on Bhamidipati Annapoorna Bhavani’s
case, the High Court considered the State’s obligation to pay compensation in
the circumstances of that case.
78.
In Land Acquisition Officer v. E. Chitra Lekha7, the Court considered
the recovery of a land-acquisition award where movable property of the Land
Acquisition Officer had been attached. The decision must be applied with
regard to the facts and the scope of its holding.
79.
In the present cases, the LAO is shown as the referring officer in the
awards and as the respondent in execution. The fact that the LAO processed
the acquisition in an official capacity does not, by itself, resolve whether the
State is bound by each award or whether the particular properties scheduled
in the Execution Petitions are liable to attachment.
80.
The principles in Bhamidipati Annapoorna Bhavani’s case may be
relevant to identifying the authority responsible for satisfying the award. The
executing Court must, however, determine the proper judgment-debtor and
the legal basis for proceeding against the properties sought to be attached.
81.
Section 2(17)(g) of the Code defines a public officer. That definition
does not, by itself, establish that the officer is the State or that every property
held by a Government department is liable to attachment in execution of a
decree against that officer.
2021 Supreme(Online)(Tel) 2555
decided on 07.08.2009, the High Court of Madras
Movable Property Execution Petitions:
82.
In C.R.P.Nos.4935 and 5442 of 2017, the respective Execution
Petitions sought attachment and sale of movable properties under Order XXI
Rules 43 of the Code.
83.
In those cases, the learned Judge held that the scheduled movable
properties were not in the LAO’s possession and belonged to another
department of the Government of Andhra Pradesh.
84.
The learned Judge referred to Order XXI Rule 12 of the Code, which
reads as follows:
“12. Application for attachment of movable property not in
judgment-debtor’s possession.—
Where an application is made for the attachment of any movable
property belonging to a judgment-debtor but not in his possession, the
decree-holder shall annex to the application an inventory of the
property to be attached, containing a reasonably accurate description
of the same.”
85.
The learned Judge appears to have proceeded on the basis that the
movable properties were not in the LAO’s possession but were held by
another department, namely, the Tahsildar’s office. The applicability of the
relevant execution provisions depends not only on possession but also on
ownership, the identity of the judgment-debtor and the legal attachability of the
property.
86.
The enquiry could therefore be that the property belongs to the
judgment-debtor or is otherwise legally liable to attachment under the
applicable provisions, but not LAO possess the property.
Immovable Property Execution Petitions:
87.
In the other Civil Revision Petitions, the Execution Petitions sought
attachment of immovable properties. The relevant provision is Order XXI Rule
54 of the Code, which reads as follows:
“Order XXI Rule 54 CPC — Attachment of immovable property
Where the property is immovable, the attachment shall be made by
an order prohibiting the judgment-debtor from transferring or charging
the property in any way, and all persons from taking any benefit from
such transfer or charge.”
88.
The learned Judge proceeded substantially on the ground that the
properties sought to be attached did not belong personally to the LAO but
belonged to the State or another Government department.
89.
Although the modes of attachment differ between the two categories of
cases, the learned Judge’s common view was that the scheduled State
properties were not owned or possessed personally by the LAO.
90.
Order XXI Rule 52 of the Code is also relevant. It reads as follows:
“52. Attachment of property in custody of Court or public
officer.—
Where the property to be attached is in the custody of any Court
or public officer, the attachment shall be made by a notice to such
Court or officer, requesting that such property, and any interest or
dividend becoming payable thereon, may be held subject to the further
orders of the Court from which the notice is issued:
Provided that, where such property is in the custody of a Court,
any question of title or priority arising between the decree-holder and
any other person, not being the judgment-debtor, claiming to be
interested in such property by virtue of any assignment, attachment or
otherwise, shall be determined by such Court.”
91.
Order XXI Rule 52 prescribes a procedure for attachment of property in
the custody of a Court or public officer. Its application depends on the nature
of the property and the statutory conditions.
92.
The Court has to consider the applicable execution provisions to
determine the particular property can lawfully be attached in satisfaction of the
decree.
Attachment:
93.
An officer is a public officer does not make him personally liable for the
State’s obligations. The property is held by a public office does not, without
further examination, establish that it is liable to attachment.
94.
The LAO is authorized to perform statutory functions relating to land
acquisition. The obligation to pay compensation is to be determined from the
award and the applicable law. It cannot be attributed to the LAO personally
merely because he processed the acquisition.
95.
Naming the LAO or another Government officer in execution
proceedings does not, by itself, make that officer personally liable. The Court
must identify the party bound by the decree and determine whether the decree
can lawfully be executed against the State or the authority concerned.
96.
In Land Acquisition Officer v. E. Chitra Lekha’s case, the discussion
concerned attachment of movable property, can be applied, on examining the
nature of the property and the applicable execution provisions.
97.
Property held by a public office may belong to the State rather than to
the officer personally. Whether a particular scheduled property is liable to
attachment must be determined under the applicable provisions of the Code
and any relevant statutory restrictions.
98.
The Court is required to consider the relevant provisions of law and the
circumstances of each Execution Petition before dismissing it.
99.
The awards remain operative, and the petitioners seek payment of
compensation for the land acquired from them. Their entitlement to proceed
with execution should not be defeated on a merely technical ground.
Execution be in compliance with the requirements.
100. The issue of correcting the description of a party or adding the State is
considered the decision in Government of Andhra Pradesh v. M/s. SCL-CR
18G Joint Venture and others8. The Division Bench, while considering the
State as a party, observed in paragraph 20 as follows:
“20. The Division Bench, in General Manager, Central Organisation
for Railway Electrification, Allahabad and Others., vs. Y.
Parthasarathy and Another had also referred to the Judgments of the
Hon‘ble Supreme Court in Ranjit Mal v/s Northern Railway, and The
State of Punjab vs Okara Grain Buyers Syndicate Limited. A
reading of these two judgments raises certain significant issues. In
Ranjit Mal’s case, the General Manager rejected an appeal filed
against the removal of an employee of Northern Railway. This rejection
was challenged before the Hon'ble High Court of Rajasthan. The Writ
Petition was rejected on the ground that the Union of India was not
impleaded and the same was affirmed by the Division Bench.”
**********
101. The Division Bench referred to Article 300 of the Constitution and relied
on Chief Conservator of Forests, Government of Andhra Pradesh v.
Collector and others9, particularly paragraphs 13 and 16, which are
extracted below:
“13. The question that needs to be addressed is whether the Chief
Conservator of Forests, as the appellant-petitioner in the writ
petition/appeal, is a mere misdescription of the State of Andhra
Pradesh, or whether it is a case of non-joinder of the State of Andhra
Pradesh—a necessary party. In a lis dealing with the property of a
State, there can be no dispute that the State is the necessary party and
should be impleaded as provided in Article 300 of the Constitution and
Section 79 CPC viz. in the name of the State/Union of India, as the
case may be, lest the suit will be bad for non-joinder of the necessary
party. Every post in the hierarchy of the posts in the government setup, from the lowest to the highest, is not recognised as a juristic person
nor can the State be treated as represented when a suit/proceeding is
in the name of such offices/posts or the officers holding such posts;
therefore, in the absence of the State in the array of parties, the cause
will be defeated for non-joinder of a necessary party to the lis, in any
court or tribunal. We make it clear that this principle does not apply to a
C.M.A.No.1141 of 2018 and C.R.P.No.6787 of 2018, dated 06.03.2026
(2003) 3 SCC 472
case where an official of the Government acts as a statutory authority
and sues or pursues further proceedings in its name because in that
event, it will not be a suit or proceeding for or on behalf of a
State/Union of India but by the statutory authority as such.”
102. The Supreme Court observed in Chief Conservator of Forests,
Government of Andhra Pradesh v. Collector and others’s case that an
officer does not become the State merely by representing it. Where
proceedings are, in substance, by or against the State, the State must be
properly arrayed as a party, subject to the distinction drawn for statutory
authorities acting in their own capacity.
103.
Relying on that decision, the Division Bench in M/s. SCL-CR 18G Joint
Venture and others’s case observed in paragraph 26 as follows:
“26. This Article, in the light of the above judgments, would have
to be understood to mean that ―the Government of Andhra Pradesh‖
while being sued or suing, should be described as the ―State of
Andhra Pradesh‖. Put another way, the party to the litigation is actually
the Government of Andhra Pradesh but the said Government of State
is to be described as the State of Andhra Pradesh. Any technical
defect, of not naming the appropriate party, in a case where an
employee of the State is arrayed as a party instead of the State, can be
corrected at the primary level and for such matters can be remanded to
the primary level. Further, it is only a case of mis-description when the
party is described as the Government of Andhra Pradesh instead of
―the State of Andhra Pradesh‖. The same can be corrected within the
same proceeding. Where a Statutory authority is a party to the
proceedings, there would be no need, in view of the judgment of the
Hon‘ble Supreme Court, in Chief Conservator of Forests, Government
of Andhra Pradesh vs. Collector and Others11, to implead the State.”
104. The above extract indicates that a defect in the description of a party
may, in an appropriate case, be corrected by impleading the proper party.
Whether the defect is a mere misdescription or amounts to non-joinder of a
necessary party must be determined from the nature of the proceedings and
the relief sought.
105.
In the present cases, the LAO performed statutory functions in an
official capacity. He cannot be made personally liable merely because he is
named as the respondent. If the decree binds the State and the defect is
curable, the executing Court may consider the legally permissible course for
bringing the proper party on record.
106. In Rahul S. Shah v. Jinendra Kumar Gandhi10, the Supreme Court
addressed delays in execution and issued directions to make execution
effective. Paragraph 42.11 states as follows:
“42.11. Under Section 60 CPC the term “… in name of the judgmentdebtor or by another person in trust for him or on his behalf” should be
read liberally to incorporate any other person from whom he may have
the ability to derive share, profit or property.”
107. The direction concerning Section 60 of the Code requires the provision
to be applied in accordance with its terms. The Court must determine whether
the person or property in question falls within the provision.
108. The question as to party may be added at the execution stage in landacquisition proceedings is answered in Shanthi v. The Special Tahsildar11,
the Madras High Court observed in paragraph 5 as follows:
“5. The revision petitioner herein has filed LAOP No.41 of 1990 and
award was passed against the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition) on
the basis of award the revision petitioner had filed a petition in E.P.
No.135 of 2013 for attachment of movables of Tamil Nadu Housing
Board, Tirunelveli. The E.P. No.135 of 2013 was dismissed as the
Tamil Nadu Housing Board was not a party either in LAOP or in E.P.
Against the dismissal order, this revision petition has been filed. In this
revision, the District Collector, Tirunelveli District and the Tamil Nadu
Housing Board, Tirunelveli Housing Unit, Tirunelveli were suo motu
impleaded by this Court as Respondent Nos.2 & 3. The respondent
Nos.2 & 3 did not file any petition to agitate the suo motto order. Even
in appeal in A.S. No. 216 of 2000 the Tamil Nadu Housing Board was
added as R-2, no appeal was preferred against the impleading order.
Now, the Tamil Nadu Housing Board, Tirunelveli Housing Unit,
(2021) 6 SCC 418
2021 Supreme (Online) (Mad) 980
Tirunelveli was added. The order, dated 12.10.2015 passed in E.P.
No. 135 of 2013 in LAOP No.41 of 18990 for attachment of movables
of Tamil Nadu Housing Board is valid since the land acquisition is only
for Tamil Nadu Housing Board.”
109. In Kurra Murali Krishna Yadav v. Sri Lakshmi Rama Cooperative
Building Society Limited12, this Court observed in paragraphs 28 to 32 as
follows:
28. We are now faced with a dichotomy. The Hon„ble Supreme Court
had taken the view that in suits for specific performance, the correct
course of action is to join the subsequent purchasers also in the sale
deeds that need to be executed. In R.C. Chandiok vs. Chuni Lal
Sabharwal, (7 supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had specifically
directed this course of action even where the subsequent purchasers
were not parties to the suit. On the other hand, the provisions of Order
I, Rule 10, as interpreted by this court, do not lend themselves to
impleading subsequent purchasers. At this stage, one significant
aspect of these judgements has to be noticed. In all these judgements,
the court did not take the view that Order I, Rule 10, prohibits or bars
the impleading of third parties in an execution petition. The view taken
is that, the applications under Order I, Rule 10, are not maintainable in
execution proceedings as the language of this provision restricts the
application of this provision to live suits and pending matters. To put it
in another way, the ratio is that the provisions of Order I, Rule 10 are
not applicable to implead petitions in Execution Petitions. Therefore
there is no provision, in the Civil Procedure Code, governing the
procedure for impleading subsequent purchasers at the stage of
execution proceedings.
29. In such an event, the inherent powers of the court, under section
151 of C.P.C., can always be invoked. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court,
while considering the scope and ambit of section 151 of C.P.C. in Ram
Chand and Sons Sugar Mills (P) Ltd. v. Kanhayalal Bhargava:
(1966) 3 SCR 856: AIR 1966 SC 1899: (1967) 37 Comp Cas 42, in
paragraph 5, held as follows:
Having regard to the said decisions, the scope of the
inherent power of a court under Section 151 of the
Code may be defined thus: The inherent power of a
court is in addition to and complementary to the powers
expressly conferred under the Code. But that power will
2022 Supreme (AP) 140
not be exercised if its exercise is inconsistent with, or
comes into conflict with, any of the powers expressly or
by necessary implication conferred by the other
provisions of the Code. If there are express provisions
exhaustively covering a particular topic, they give rise to
a necessary implication that no power shall be
exercised in respect of the said topic otherwise than in
the manner prescribed by the said provisions. Whatever
limitations are imposed by construction on the
provisions of Section 151 of the Code, they do not
control the undoubted power of the Court conferred
under Section 151 of the Code to make a suitable order
to prevent the abuse of the process of the Court.
30. The presence of the purchasers in the sale deeds is essential to
the completion of the process and in the absence of any specific
provision for impleading the purchasers, the decree holder can always
rely upon the provisions of section 151 and seek invocation of the
inherent power of the court to do justice.
31. For the aforesaid reasons, the orders, impleading the purchasers,
would have to be upheld and C.R.P.Nos.1790, 1791, 2771, and 2900
of 2019 are dismissed. In view of the dismissal of these Revision
petitions, C.R.P.Nos.1282 of 2021 and 1293 of 2021 are closed.
32. The contentions raised by the purchasers relating to the merits of
their case and the defences raised by them, against the execution of
the decree, as may be permissible, are left open for adjudication.”
110. The above decisions read that Order I Rule 10 of the Code does not
ordinarily apply to impleadment applications in execution proceedings. In an
appropriate case, the Court may consider exercising its inherent powers under
Section 151 of the Code, subject to the limits of those powers and the rights of
the parties.
111.
In the present cases, the petitioners sought attachment of movable and
immovable properties at the offices of the Tahsildar and other Government
departments to realise the decretal amounts.
112.
The Court could have considered, that the proper party can be brought
on record, if the law permitted that course. The Court has to determine, that
the proposed party is bound by the award and the defect is one of
misdescription or non-joinder.
113.
The learned Judge relied on Order XXI Rule 13 of the Code and Rule
259 of the Andhra Pradesh Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders, 1980.
The learned Judge observed that the petitioners had not specified the
judgment-debtor’s saleable interest in the immovable properties or filed the
affidavit said to be required by those provisions, and treated that omission as
one ground for dismissing the Execution Petitions.
114. The learned Judge considered that the judgment-debtor had no
saleable interest in the immovable properties sought to be attached and sold.
115.
Order XXI Rule 13 of the Code reads as follows:
“13. Application for attachment of immovable property to contain
certain particulars.—
Where an application is made for the attachment of any immovable
property belonging to a judgment-debtor, it shall contain at the foot—
(a) a description of such property sufficient to identify the same and, in
case such property can be identified by boundaries or numbers in a
record of settlement or survey, a specification of such boundaries or
numbers; and
(b) a specification of the judgment-debtor’s share or interest in such
property to the best of the belief of the applicant, and so far as he has
been able to ascertain the same.”
116. It is applied, may be for the reasons the petitioners had not specified the
judgment-debtor’s share or interest in the properties. This was arisen as there
is no proper identification as to the JDR and whether the requirements of Rule
13 were satisfied.
117.
The LAO cannot be treated as personally owning State property or as
having a personal saleable interest in it. The Court has to determine the State
or another authority is bound by the award and the properties sought to be
attached are legally available in execution.
118. The present revision petitions are under Section 115 of the Code.
Section 115 of the Code reads as follows:
“115. Revision.—
(1) The High Court may call for the record of any case which has been
decided by any Court subordinate to such High Court and in which no
appeal lies thereto, and if such subordinate Court appears—
(a) to have exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law, or
(b) to have failed to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, or
(c) to have acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with
material irregularity, the High Court may make such order in the case
as it thinks fit.
[Provided that the High Court shall not, under this section, vary or
reverse any order made, or any order deciding an issue, in the course
of a suit or other proceeding, except where the order, if it had been
made in favour of the party applying for revision, would have finally
disposed of the suit or other proceedings.] [Substituted by the Code of
Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999, Section 12, for former proviso
(w.e.f. 1.7.2002).]”
119. Applying the above provisions, this Court view that the executing Court
required to consider the applicable provisions of Order XXI, including Rules
12, 43, 52 and 54, together with the relevant provisions of the Act. Court ought
to have determined the proper judgment-debtor, the status and ownership of
each scheduled property, and the legal requirements for attachment before
dismissing the Execution Petitions.
120.
If the proper party has not been impleaded, the executing Court may
consider whether the defect can be cured in accordance with law. It may also
consider the course recognised in Land Acquisition Officer v. E. Chitra
Lekha’s case, including whether a reasonable period for payment should be
allowed, if that decision applies to the facts. If payment is not made within the
time lawfully granted, further steps may be taken in accordance with law.
121. With the above reasons, the points are answered as follows:
Point No. 1: Under Section 26(2) of the Act, an award of the Reference
Court is deemed to be a decree and is executable in accordance with
the Code.
Point No. 2: The identity of the party against whom execution may
proceed is to be determined from the award, the reference proceedings
and the applicable law. Sections 19 and 20 of the Act prescribe the
procedure to be followed upon a reference, including notice to the
Collector where the objection concerns the amount of compensation.
The Court has to examine the record before deciding whether the State
or another authority is bound by the award.
Point No. 3: Property in the custody of a public officer may be attached
only if the applicable legal requirements are satisfied. The Court has to
identify the party legally responsible for satisfying the award and
determine whether the scheduled property is liable to attachment.
Point No. 4: If the proper party has not been impleaded, the Court may
consider, in the circumstances of the case, applicability of Section 151
of the Code permits the defect to be cured, and it is to be within the
limits of the Court’s inherent powers and do not effect liability on a
person who is not bound by the decree.
Point No. 5: Execution to be proceeded under Section 51 and Order
XXI of the Code. Where the property is not in the judgment-debtor’s
possession, the Court has to apply the relevant provisions governing
attachment and determine the legal liability to proceed against. The
absence of a proper party does not justify dismissal without considering
whether the same can be affected under due process of law.
Conclusion:
122. With the above discussion, I am of the considered view that, the
dismissal of the Execution Petitions is not proper, the court ought to have
considered to take steps to identify the proper parties, then has to proceed
further. As such, the impugned order is liable to be set aside, and execution
petitions to be restored.
123. It is made clear that, on restoration, the attachment do not revive as the
court has to pass proper orders, identifying the proper parties, giving time to
the parties so considered to comply decree. The trial court is at liberty to pass
appropriate orders as per due procedure of law for each case independently
without getting influenced with the findings of this court.
Result:
124.
In the result C.R.P.Nos.4935, 4957, 5067, 5074, 5415, 5442, 5459,
5500 and 5869 of 2017 and C.R.P.No.2696 of 2018 are allowed. The
respective impugned orders passed in the Execution Petitions referred to in
paragraph 13 above are set aside. The respective Execution Petitions are
restored to the file of the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Nandikotkur,
for fresh disposal in accordance with law after giving opportunity to both
parties.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, any miscellaneous petitions pending in these Civil
Revision Petitions shall stand closed.
___________________________________________
JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR CHINTALAPUDI
Dated: 14.10.2026
DSV
Whether the order is:
Speaking
Reportable
√
Reasoned
Non-Reportable
√
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review