Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t!3031
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 8045 OF 2022
Between:
1. Bokka Venkateswarlu, Sio. BokkaAdinarayana, Aged about 51 years, Occ. Clerk
in CMPF, Kothagudem, R/o. H.No. 9-7-177, Barlfit, Kothagudem, Peddapalli
District. (A-2)
2. Bokka Satyanarayana, S/o. BokkaAdinarayana, Aged about 43 years, Occ.
Contract Labour, At CMPF, Kothagudem, Kothagudem, Rio. H.No. 9-7-177,
Barlfit, Kothagudem, Peddapalli District. (A-3)
...Petitioner/Accused
AND
'1 The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State
of Telangana, Hyderabad.
2. Bokka Vrctoria Rani, Wo. Poornachander, Aged about 38 years, Occ. Employee,
R/o. Q.No D-340, Gandhinagar, Godavarikhani, Ramagundam.
...Respondents
Petition under Sectron 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased toto
quash all further proceedings in S.C.No. 104 of 2021 on the file of the V Additional
District Judge (SC/STs) Courts at Karimnagar, in the interest of justice.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2 022
Petition under section 482 of cr.P.c praying that in the circurr stances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of criminal petition, the High court mav re pleased to stay all
further proceedings including the appearance of the petitioners irr s.c No. 104 of 2021
on the file of the V Additional Diskict Judge (sc/ srs) courts
(arimnagar, pending
disposal of the criminal petition, in the interest of justice.
a
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under section 482 of cr.p.c praying that in the circurr itances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petition, the High court ma), re pleased to extend
the interim stay granted in crl.P.No 8045 of 2022 daled 7 -g-zoD_ pending before this
Hon'ble High Court, in the rnterest of Justice.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under section 482 of cr.P.c praying that in the circurr ;tances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of criminal petition, the High court ma1 re pleased to extend
the interim stay granted in LA.No 2 ol 2022 in crl.p.No 8045 of 2(;2 dated 2s-11-2022,
pending before this Hon'ble High Court, in the interest of Justice
I.A. NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under section 482 of cr p.c praying that in the circunr ,tances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of criminal petition, the High court may re pleased to extend
the interim staygranted in l.A.No.'1 of 2023 in crl.p. No 8045 of 2)zz dated 6-1-2023,
pending before this Hon'ble High Court, in the interest of Justice.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2023
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.p.C praying that in the circunl tances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal petition, the High Court may .e pleased to extend
I
the interim stay granted in lA.No. 2 of 2023 in in Crl.p.No. i )45 of 2022 dated
1810812023, pending before this Honourable Court in the interest o, ustice.
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Menl randum of Grounds
of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri N Moha r Krishna, Advocate
for the Petitioner and the Sri Jithender Rao Veeramalla, Additional I 'ubiic Prosecutor for
the State of Telangana on behalf of the Respondent No_1 anrl none appeared for
Respondent No.2.
The Court made the following: ORDER
,lrd
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENTVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION No.8O45 of 2o22
Dale: 07.O1.2026
Betureen
Bokka Vcnkateswarlu and another
Petitioners
AND
The S tate ol Telangana,
represented by its Public Prosecutor
High Court for the SLatc ol Telangana,
Hydcrabad.s and anot her
Rcspondents
ORDER
Ttris Crirrrinal Petition has been filed seeking to quash
the proceedings in S.C.No.lO4 of 2O2L on the hle of the
learned V Additior-ral District Judge, (SCs/STs) Court at
Karimnagar, wherein the petitioners were arrayed as
accused Nos.2 and 3, for the offences punishable under
Sections 49aA, 506 read with 34 of the Indian penal Code,
1860 (for short 'lPC'), Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition
Act, 1961 (for short'the D.P. Act') and Sections 3(1)(r)(s) and
3(2) (va) of the SCs/STs (POA) Act, 1989 (Arnendrnent Act
2015) (for short 'the ActJ.
2.
TLre case of prosecution in brief is tLrat respondent
No.2, who belongs to Madiga (SC) community, workcd as a
Compr-rter C)perator in the office of Pror r lent Fund at
Singareni Coal Mines, Godavarikhani, on ontract basis.
,
She got acquainted rvith accused No.1 at wor <, v,,ho belongs
to Seltibalijc (BC Il) corrrrtun ity. Later thc'.' ell in love and
got married on 24.|JL.2OO9 at Hyderabad, a; ainst the wish
of their family rnertbers, as they bclong trr lifferent caste.
Their rrrarriage was registercd alt Sub Regr : trar's ofhce at
Peddzrpalli ir-r the prcsence of both the farr lies. After one
year of tl-reir rlarriage, accuscd No- 1 sli rted insulting
respondenL No-2 snying that fascination is,r ,er on her and
he is getting ilritatcd and if he had rnarrir:rl sor-r-reone frorrr
his caste , he rvould travc got Rs.1O,OO,O l )/- as dowry.
Every day accuscd No.1 abused respond,: t No.2, kicked
her with legs and torturcd her rncntally ar r physica.lly for
additional do\l.r), of Rs.2,OO,OOO/ Out ol- t heir wedlock,
they were blessed with a daughter and sc n. Respondent
No.2 expected sorne change in the attituder t f accused No. 1
but he continr-red to harass her. Later, accttt; :d No. 1 lost his
job, as he lr,as involved in a crirninal case. He left to his
native viliage at Kothagundarn and star, :d working as
Security Guard in S & PC Departrnent
Accused No.1
harassed rcspondent No.2 to corne to Koth: gr-rdam. Due to
unbearable harassrrent, she left her job a- Godavarikhani
,,?
,1
and joined accused No.1 along with hbr c;hildren. Ttrerc she
lived along with the petitioners in the sarne house. It is
allcged that the petitioners supported accused No.l in
h aras
sing respondent No 2 . Accr.rsed No. I continued to
.
harass her by demanding Rs-2,OO,OOO /
and beat her and
later necked her out of the house and since then
respondent No.2 has bcen residing wittr her parents
Hcncc, shc lodgccl tLre cornplaint and based on tLre sarne,
Crirr-re No.283 of 20 l9 u.as registered for the oflences under
Sections 498 A,506 r/r,,, 34 of the IPC, Section 4 of the D.P
Act and Scctions 3(1)(r)(s) and 3(2)(va) of the Act and the
Investigating Ofhccr alter conducting investigation filed
charge sheet and the learned Sessions Judge, took
cogr-rizancc of thc sarne and numbered it as S. C. No. 1 04 of
2021.
I
I
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners through video
conference sr-rbmitted that pursuant to tfre order, dated
25.11.2022, he sent personal notice to respondent No.2 by
way of registered post with acknowledgrnent due and hled
proof of service uide USR No.7224 of 2023 on 04.O1.2O23
Along with the memo, learned counsel has filed postal track
f
T
E
E
E
I
I
I
i
consignrnent. Hence, this Court recorded the service of
notice on 27.12.2023. In spite of service, r( spondent No.2
has not chosen to cnter appearance. Hen,:: tlris Court is
not having any optron except to procced witlr lhis matter on
merlts
4. Heard Sri N.I\4ohan Krishna. learnr c counsel for
petitioners and Mr.M.Vivekananda Reddy, 1ca rned Assistant
Public Prosccutor appearing for respondcnt l'l r. 1 / State.
5. 1 Learned counsel lor thc petitioners su l) rLitted tirat the
petitioners have nol cornrnittcd the offences a-nd they were
falsely irnplicerted ir-r Lhe present case or-r1.,, rn the ground
that petitioner No.1 /accused No.2 is brc-.tL err of accused
No.1 and petitioncr No.2/accused No.3 is p I r:rnal uncle of
aecused No.1. He lurthcr subrnitted tha1. he petitioners
never lived w,ith accuscd No.1 and rcspolrc c:nt No.2. The
rnarriage of respondent No.2 and accus 3d No. 1 was
perforrned as long as in thc year 2OO9 and lhey are living
separately. The petitioners never harasscd rc spondent No.2
for dowry and they never abused her in the r rrre of caste.
r
5.2 He further subrnitted that the only zr legation rnade
against the petitioners is that tLrey were sup: trting accused
No. 1 and the entire allegations are levelecl tr lainst accused
No.1 only. Ezrer:. accor:ding to the cornplzrjr 1., the alleged
incident has occurred within the four corners of the house
of accused No.l, which does not fall within the ambit of
public view. Therelore, the ingredients of the oflences under
Sections 3(l)(r)(s) and 3(2) (va) of the Act are not attracted
against the petitioners.
Hence, continuation of the
proceedings against the petitioners is a clear abuse of the
process of law
5.3. In support of his contention, he relied upon the
following juclgrnents:
i) Dara Lakshrni Narayana and others v. State of
Telangana and anotherll and
ii) Karuppudayar v. State rep. by the Deputy
Superintendent of Police, Lalgudi Trichy and ottrers2;
6.
Per Contra, learned Assistant Public Prosecutor
subrnitted that there are specific allegations leveled against
the petitioners to attract the ingredients of ttre offences
under Sections 49aA, 506 read with 34 of the IPC, Section 4
of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 196 1 and Sections 3(1)(r)(s)
and 3(2) (va) of the Act. Whether the petitioners have
comrnitted the offences or not, has to be revealed after fi.rllt
1zozs1 a scc 735
,2025 SCC Online SC 215
l
{
u
l
(-)
fledged trial before thc trial Court. Basing otr the grounds
urged by the learned counsel for the prt'l i--ioners' the
petitioners €Lre not entitled lo scek for c lrashing the
pro ceedings
.
Having considered the rival stlbmission ; matde by the
respective parties and after perusal of the mre. ,rial avail able
on record, it reveals that respondent No.2 rrarriagc was
perlorrned with accused No.1 on 24.O1-2Oo') rt I Iyder .rbad
and rcspondent No.2 lodged thc complaint cl 06.o7 .2019.
Basing on the sarne, Crirne No.283 of 2|J19 '. 'as regisl ercd
an<l the Investigating Officer after recording rl -e staternents
of tkre witnesses f,rled a final report before :e learned V
Additional Drstrict and Scssions Colrrt
SCs/STs) at
Karimnagar, and the said Court has taken t r gnizance and
issr-red sLlrnrrlons to accused Nos. 1 to 3. Aftt:l lerustrl of the
cornplaint, staternents of the rvitnesses ancl lnal report, it
reveals ttrat there are no specific allegatioll; against the
petitioners ald the only allegation against tLrem is that
petitioner No.1, who is brother of accust cl No.1, and
petitioner No.2, who is paternal unclc of acct: ed No. 1, have
supported- aecused.. No.1.. -Even- aeoordilag-to 1 re- allegations
made in ttre cornplaint as r.t,ell as ttre firL Li leport, the
..?
J
""'
alleged incident of abusing ttrc de-facto Cornplainant in the
name of her caste has occurred in
de-facto complainant's
rnaternal horne. Respondent No.2 has also not specified
about the words uttered by the petitioners. Even according
to the final report, no eye witnesses were present at the time
of alleged incident. lt is not the case of respondenL No.2 that
there was any rnember of the public at the tirne of incident
in the said place except LWs. 2 and 3, who are parents of
LW1, LW4, who is brother of LW1, and LW5, who is
neighbour of LWs.2 and 3.
8.
Taking into consideration the allegations rnade in the
complaint and the charge sLreet, it reveals that the essential
ingredient of thc offences namely that the words were
uttered "in any place within public view" is not made or.rt.
9.
In Hitesh Verrna w. State of Uttarakhand and
another3, the Hon'ble Suprerne Court held that r.vhere the
alleged abusive words were uttered inside a private
premises with no public present, the rnandatory
requirernent of "public view" is not satished. Sirnilarty, in
Pradnya Pradeep l(enkare and arrother v. State of
,i
i!
I
I
lzozo; ro scc zro
-,)
Maharashtraa, the Bornbay High Court held t rat an offencc
under Scctior.r 3(1)(x) of tLre SC/ST (POA) .\: - is not rnade
out where thc FIR does not ailege that the pr rported insult
occr.rrred "withir-r public vier,v," and cl:r:-ii e:d th.rl this
ingredient requires both a placc accessible tcr he public ancl
the presence ol rnernbers of the public, r.r'l t could see orhear the alleged act.
10. In Sandhya Dwiwedi v. State of U.P. tnd anothers,
the Allahabad High Court observed that 1rr an ol-fence
under the SC/ST Act to be made olrt, th( allegcci insuLt
mr-rst be castc-specific, intentional, and r-:r.' je in a place
within pr. blic view.
1.. In Ramesh Chandra Vaishya v. State of u.l .e, thc Hor-r'ble
Supreme Court held that for an o.ffencr: rnder S cction
3(1)(x) ol the SC/ST Act to be rnade or.rt, th€ allcged insult
must be caste-specific, intentional, and me cte in a place
within pubiic view. Since the a.lleged abttst: <>ccurred in a
private setting without reference to caste or 1: rblic presence,
the essential ingredients of the offence were rl i s sing.
o
zoos{t) S('C onL_pdBombay 574
r 2025 SCC Onlinc AIt 1512
\2023], 17 SCC 615
12. In Karuppudayar supra, the Hon'ble Suprerne Court held
that for the offences Lrnder Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the
SCs/ STs (POA) Act, the F IR rrust disciose that the alleged
insult or abu.se occr-rrred "in any place within public view,,,
and where the allegations indicate that tLre incident took
place within the confines of an office witho ut public
presence, the continuation of proceedings would lall within
category ( 1) of State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal7.
13. In the present case, evcn if the allegations are laken at
face value, they do not disclose that the alleged czrste-based
abuses were rnade "in any place r.rzithin public view,,, as
rnandatorily required under Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of
the Act- The complaint indicates that the alicged abuses
arose out of a matrirnonial dispute and were purportedly
rnade wittrin tLre confines of the rnatrirnonial horne at
Kothagudern. There is no averment rnade in the cornplaint
that any public was present or that the alleged words were
u.ttered at a place accessible to the plrblic. Even otherwise,
the alleged caste-based abuse is attributed exch.rsively to
accused No.1. The petitioners were residing separately and
there is no specifrc allegation against thern that they uttered
any caste-related words or were otherwise involved in the
7 (1992) Supp (1) SCC 33s
(-y
alleged incident. The allegations are thu:; ;cnf-rned to a
private setting and iack the essential ingrt:<l e nt of "public
view," as expLained in Karuppudayat supr.t, Hitesh Verma
supra, Pradnya Pradeep Kenkare supra, Sandhye Dwivedi supra
and Ramesh Chandra Vaishya supra and the ir ' ocation of Lhe
provisions of the SCs/STs (POA) Act in the 1 resent case is
unsustainable.
14. In Dara Lakshmi Narayana supra, the Flo L'blc Supreme
Court quashed proceedings under Section 'i rtB-A IPCI ancl
Sections 3 and 4 of the D.P. Act, holding
J
at vague al<l
omnibus allegations against relatives resid i rg separately,
without specific attribution of overt acts arrr 1 attencled by
indications of a retaliatorv or mala fide
p ro secution.
constitute an abr. se of process, attracting
:rte gory (7) of
r
Bhajan Lal supra, and r.l,arrant interference at 1l t: tl-rrcshold.
15. In Ghanshyam Soni v. State (NCT of DeltLi re, thc Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that crimina-l proceedin;1, arising out of
rrratrirnonial disputes cannot be sustained rvt ere vague ald
omnibr.rs allegations are made against everal family
r
members, including sisters who were living eparately and
not part of the rnatrimonial hor.rsehold, w-it.ti, ,ut attributing
any specific role or overt act to them. The o rurt rerterated
8 2025 SCC Online SQi
I
that rnerely naming relatives, particularly those resicling
separately, is insuffrcient to constitute an offence under
i
Section 4984 IPC, and where no prirna facie case is madc
out, continuation of such proceedings v,,ould amount to an
abuse of process of law, warranting interference by the
Court in the interest of justice.
16. TLre principle laid down in,Ghanshyam Soni supra and
Dara lakshmi naryana supro is squarely attracted to the
present case, as the allegations of crr'elt]., dourry demand,
physical assault and caste-basecl abuse arc aLtributed
exclusiveiy to Accused No.l, namely. the husband of the
corrrplainant. Insofar as the petitioners are concerned, there
are only general assertions that Accused Nos.2 ar-rd 3
"supported" Accused No.1, without disclosing any specihc
act, incident, words used, or independent roie playcd by the
petitioner. Even dr..rring the period when the cornplainant
resided at KothagudelTr, no overt act is attributed to the
petitioners, and the allegations remain vague and ornnibus
in nature. The petitioners has thus been arrayed as an
accused solely by virtue of her relationship with Accused
No.1, ald tlre continuation of proceedings against thern, in
the absence of any prirna facie material, would arnount to
an abuse ofprocess of law.
t2
N
17. For the foregoing reasons as well as the rrinciplcs laid
down by the Hon'ble Apex Court as stated sr..7 r-a, this Court
is of considcrerl r,iew that contrnuation of thc ;roceedings in
S.C.No.1O4 of 2021, on the file of the V AcL([ tional DisLrict
and Sessions Judge (SCs/STs) Court at Karimn argar,
against thc pctitioners would arnounts to alr rse of proccss
of 1aw ancl it rs a fit case to invoke the jr-rris iiction of this
quasl-r the
proceedings against the petitioners.
I
In thc result. the Criminal Petition
8.
allowecl. 'lhc
r
proceedings ir-r S.C.No. 104 of 2O2 1, on t1-r: file of the V
I
Additional District and Sessions Judge, (S()r; STs) Courrt at
t
I
K:rrirnnagar, against the petitioners are here t 1'quashed- It
I
I
is rnade r:lezrr that any of the observation; rnade in this
I
order are only conhned for the purpose c I decidrn g this
CASC
I
Pending miscellaneous applications, if zt ry, shall stand
cIo sed
Sd/-C.DEEPIKA
ASI ISTANT REGISTRAR
\
//TRUE COPYI/
I
,i
SECTION OFFICER
To,
Ak
The V Additional District Judge (SC/ STs) Courts at Karinrr agar
The Station House Officer, Peddapalli Police Station, Pecr apalli.
One CC to SRl. N MOHAN KRISHNA Advocate [OPUC]
One CC to SRl. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (TG) Advocate ( )PUCI
E
Two CD Copies
i
HIGH COURT
DATED: 071O112026
' a-=: r:=
(.
o
(-)
ORDER
.{
CRLP.No.8045 of 2022
ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL PETITION
vvb
i rr rilr s t4 (
tfl LiE'.t I
(lr:"' t, H () ;i1.
'--:-.
--e.,,j.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review