Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.1 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
Digitally
SAIFAN signed by
KHAN SAIFAN
2026:CGHC:26187-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
KHAN
CRA No. 1925 of 2019
[Arising out of judgment dated 05.08.2029, passed in Sessions Trial
No.12/2019 (State vs. Bodya @ Bodiya Manjhi) passed by the Addl.
Sessions Judge, Gharghoda, District Raigarh (CG)]
Bodya Alias Bodiya Manjhi S/o Late Suknaath Manjhi Aged About
40 Years R/o Village Sonepur , Police Station Kapu, District Raigarh
Chhattisgarh., District : Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
(On Bail)
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station Kapu, District
Raigarh Chhattisgarh., District : Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
[Cause-title taken from Case Information System (CIS)]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Appellant :
Mr. Rajesh Jain and Ms. Kiran Jain, Advocates
For Respondent :
Mr. Rahul Tamaskar, Government Advocate
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Division Bench
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal, and
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal
Judgment on Board
(29.06.2026)
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J
(1)
Invoking criminal appellate jurisdiction of this Court, the sole
appellant herein has preferred this criminal appeal under Section
374(2) of Cr.P.C., calling in question the legality, validity and
Page No.2 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
correctness of the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 05.08.2029, passed in Sessions Trial No.12/2019
(State vs. Bodya @ Bodiya Manjhi) passed by the Addl. Sessions
Judge, Gharghoda, District Raigarh (CG), whereby he has been
convicted for offence under Section 302 of IPC and sentenced to
undergo imprisonment for life with fine of Rs.500/- and, in default of
payment of fine amount, sentenced to undergo additional rigorous
imprisonment for 02 months.
(2)
The case of the prosecution, in short, is that on 12.12.2018, at
about 15:00 Hours, at Village Sonepur, which comes within the
ambit of Police Station Kapu, District Raigarh (CG), the accusedappellant herein committed murder of his father, namely, Suknath
(hereinafter referred to as the “deceased”) by causing him club injury
by means of bamboo stick and, thereby, said to have committed the
aforesaid offence.
(3)
It is further case of the prosecution that when the matter was
reported to the police, merg intimation (Ex.P/01) and FIR (Ex.P/02)
were registered and wheels of investigation started running, in
which, summons under Section 175 of CrPC were sent vide Ex.P/04
and inquest proceedings were conducted vide Ex.P/05. Spot map was
also prepared and the dead-body of the deceased was sent for
postmortem examination, which was conducted by Dr. Sarju Prasad
Rathiya (PW-06) and, as per PM report (Ex.P/12), cause of death of
Page No.3 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
the deceased is coma due to head injury and intracranial bleeding
and nature of death is homicidal. The appellant-accused was
arrested and his memorandum statement was recorded vide
Ex.P/07. Pursuant to the memorandum statement of the appellant,
weapon of the offence i.e. bamboo stick was seized vide Ex.P/10.
Certain other articles were also seized from the spot vide Ex.P/08.
One t-shirt of the deceased was also seized vide Ex.P/14. However,
the seized articles were not sent for chemical examination for the
reasons best known to the prosecution. After statements of witnesses
were recorded and due investigation, the police filed charge-sheet
against the appellant in the competent criminal court having
jurisdiction and, thereafter, the case was committed to the Court of
Sessions for hearing and trial in accordance with law, in which the
appellant/accused abjured his guilt and entered into defence by
stating that he is innocent and has been falsely implicated.
(4)
The prosecution in order to prove its case examined as many as
07 witnesses and exhibited 14 documents, whereas the appellantaccused in support of his defence neither examined any witness nor
exhibited any document.
(5)
The learned trial Court after appreciating the oral and
documentary evidence available on record, proceeded to convict the
appellant for offence under Section 302 of IPC and sentenced him as
mentioned herein-above, against which this appeal has been
Page No.4 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
preferred by the appellant-accused questioning the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence.
(6)
Mr. Rajesh Jain, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submits that the learned trial Court is unjustified in convicting the
appellant for offence under Section 302 of IPC, as the prosecution
has failed to prove the offence beyond reasonable doubt. There is no
evidence available on record to connect the appellant in the present
crime. However, the learned trial Court has premised the conviction
of the appellant solely on the basis of statements of eye-witnesses,
namely, Ramsai (PW-01) and Kishun (PW-02), who have not at all
supported the case of the prosecution. They have not uttered a word
in their testimony that they have seen the incident of appellant
assaulting the deceased. Therefore, the evidence in shape of their
testimony is of no help to the prosecution. Further, though pursuant
to the memorandum statement of the appellant, one bamboo stick
has been recovered, but there is no FSL report or any other evidence
available on record to show that the said bamboo stick was used by
the appellant in the instant crime. Hence, the present appeal
deserves to be allowed and the appellant is liable to be acquitted of
the said charges on the basis of benefit of doubt.
(7)
Per-contra, learned State counsel supported the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence and submits that the
prosecution has proved the offence beyond reasonable doubt by
Page No.5 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
leading evidence of clinching nature. In view of the statements of
prosecution witnesses coupled with other material available on
record, the learned trial Court has rightly convicted the appellant for
offence under Sections Section 302 of IPC. Thus, the present appeal
deserves to be dismissed.
(8)
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their
rival submissions made herein-above and went through the records
with utmost circumspection.
(9)
The first and foremost question is as to whether the death of
the deceased was homicidal in nature, which the learned trial Court
has recorded in affirmative by taking into consideration the
postmortem report (Ex.P/12), wherein it has been opined that cause
of death of the deceased is coma due to head injury and intracranial
bleeding and nature of death is homicidal, which is duly proved by
the statement of Dr. Sarju Prasad Rathiya (PW-06). Accordingly,
taking into consideration the postmortem report (Ex.P/12) and the
statement of Dr. Sarju Prasad Rathiya (PW-06), who has conducted
the postmortem of the dead-body of the deceased, we are of the
considered opinion that the death of the deceased is homicidal in
nature, as the same is correct finding of fact based on evidence and
same is neither perverse nor contrary to the record. We hereby
affirm the said finding.
Page No.6 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
(10) Now, the next question for consideration would be whether the
appellant herein is the author of the crime or not ?
(11) In the case at hand, the conviction of the appellant is solely
premised on the statements of eye-witnesses, namely, Ramsai (PW01) and Kishun (PW-02). However, a careful perusal of the statement
of Ramsai (PW-01) would show that in his examination-in-chief at
Para-01 he has clearly stated that though he has seen the dead-body
of the deceased lying near the door, situated in front of the house of
the appellant, and the appellant was trying to administer water to
the deceased, but whether the appellant has assaulted the deceased
or the deceased died by own due to falling, he has no knowledge
about it. Further, in his cross-examination at Para-5 he clearly
stated that he has not seen the appellant assaulting the deceased,
indeed, he only heard the sound of quarrel. Even, he specifically
stated that he has not seen the appellant assaulting the deceased by
means of ‘danda’ and has also contradicted his statements recorded
under Section 161 of CrPC and as mentioned in the FIR (Ex.P/02).
As such, Ramsai (PW-01) cannot be considered to be an eye-witness
to the incident. Similarly, Kishun (PW-02) in his cross-examination
has clearly stated that he has not seen the incident of appellant
assaulting the deceased by means of bamboo stick, however, when he
reached to the spot he saw that the appellant was holding bamboo
stick, which belongs to the deceased. Further, he also admitted that
Page No.7 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
at the time of the incident he was not in the village where the
incident took place i.e. Sonpur, as he used to reside in another
Village, namely, Jobi and he visited village Sonpur, where incident
took place, after 1-2 days of the incident. As such, Kishun (PW-02)
also cannot be considered to be an eye-witness to the incident.
Accordingly, the learned trial Court committed grave legal error
while relying upon the testimonies of Ramsai (PW-01) and Kishun
(PW-02), being eye-witnesses to the incident, as from their
statements it is quite clear that they have not seen the incident of
appellant assaulting the deceased. Therefore, the finding recorded
by the learned trial Court to that extent is liable to be and is hereby
set aside. We hereby hold accordingly.
(12) Furthermore, though pursuant to the memorandum statement
of the appellant recorded vide Ex.P/07, one bamboo stick has been
recorded vide Ex.P/10, but there is no evidence available on record to
show that the appellant used the said bamboo stick in commission of
the instant crime at any point of time and, even, there is no FSL
report to show that any blood stains of human origin are present on
the said bamboo stick, for the reasons best known to the prosecution.
As such, the recovery of said bamboo stick from the appellant is also
of no help to the prosecution. We hereby hold accordingly.
(13) In view of foregoing analysis, we are unable to hold that the
prosecution has been able to prove their case beyond all reasonable
Page No.8 of 8
IN
CRA-1925-2019
doubt and, in absence of which, the learned trial Court is unjustified
in convicting the appellant for offences under Sections 302 of IPC
being the author of the crime in question in light of the evidence
culled out in the impugned judgment and same are liable to be set
aside.
(14) Accordingly, we hereby set aside the conviction so recorded and
the sentence so awarded by the trial Court to the appellant vide the
impugned judgment dated 05.08.2019. The appellant is acquitted of
the charge under Section 302 of the IPC on the basis of benefit of
doubt. The appellant is reported to be on bail, therefore, he need not
to surrender. However, his bail bond shall remain in force for a
further period of six months in view of the provision contained in
Section 437-A of the CrPC.
(15) This criminal appeal is allowed.
(16) Let a certified copy of this judgment alongwith the original
record be transmitted to the trial Court concerned for necessary
information and action, if any.
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
Judge
s@if
Sd/(Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review