Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3168 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4360 OF 2025
Petition under Article 227 of the constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 11-08-2025 passed in l.A. No. 356 of 2025 in A.S. SR. No.2734 of 2025 on
the file of the court of the lll Additional District and Sessions Judge Cum Principal
Family Court, Medchal Malkajgiri, at Kukatpally.
Between:
Bodapunti Sudhaker, S/o B. Raghavulu, Aged about 52 years, Occ. Business,
R/o. H. No. 1-12-12619, Vinayaka Nagar, Nizamabad, Telangana
...Petitioner /1"t Respondent /1't Respondent
AND
1. Syed Saleemuddin, S/o Late Syed Azeemuddin, Aged about 76 Years, Occ.
Business, Residing at H. No.5-3-970, Fasih Jung Lane, Mouzamjahi Market,
Hyderabad. Presently residing at Phoenix, Arizona, USA. Rep by his General
Power of Attorney, Syed Kaleemuddin, S/o Late Syed Azeemuddin, Aged
aboutT2 Years, Occ. Advocate, Residing at H. No. 5-3-970, Fasih Jung Lane,
Mouzamjahi Market, Hyderabad.
...RespondenUPetitionerAppellant
2. Bodapunti Laxman, S/o Late Boudapunti Narayana, Aged about 64 Years,
Occ. Business, Residing at Flat No. 302, Yijaya Grandeur, Street No. 1,
Czech Colony, Sanath Nagar, Hyderabad.
3. M. Sri Hari, S/o Late Narasimha, Aged about 80 Years, Occ. Advocate,
Residing at Flat No. 302, Rose Apts, Abids,Hyderabad.
4. Nawab Fareed Nawaz Jung, S/o Nawab Sultanul tvlulk, Aged about 88 Years,
Occ. Business, 0/a G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D. Road,
Secunderabad.
5. Nawab Nazeer Nawaz Jung, S/o Nawab Sultanul Mulk, Aged about 80 Years,
Occ. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D. Road,
Secunderabad.
6. Nawab Mohammed Mifahuddin Khan, S/o Late Nawab M. Abdul Fatah Khan,
Aged about 55 Years, Occ. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock
Tower,S. D. Road, Secunderabad.
7. Mohammarj Sirajuddin Khan, S/o Late Nawab M. Abdul Fatah Khan, Aged
about 50 Years, Occ. Business,0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower,
S. D. Road, Secunderabad
8. Abedunnis;r Begum. D/o Late Nawab M. Abdul Fatah Khan, Aged about 60
Years, Oc<:. Housewife, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
9. Fazalunnisa Begum, D/o Late Nawab M. Abdul Fatah Khan, Aged about 50
Years, Oc<:. Housewife, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
10.Qasimunni,;a Begum, D/o Late Nawab M. Abdul Fatah Khan, Aged about 50
Years, Oc<:. Housewife, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
1 1.
Bashirunnir;a Begum, D/o Late Nawab Khair Nawaz Jung, Aged about 50
Years, Oc<:. Housewife, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
12.Nawab Eqtedaruddin Khan, S/o Late Nawab Khair Nawaz Jung, Aged about
55 Years, {Jcc. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Sectrnderabad.
13. Nawab Harniduddin Khan, S/o Late Nawab Khalr Nawaz Jung, Aged about 53
Years, Oct:. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
14.Nawab Raliuddin Khan, S/o Late Nawab Khair Nawaz Jung, . Aged about 50
Years, Ocr:. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
15.Nawab Masood Khan, S/o Late Nawab Khair Nawaz Jung, Aged about 50
Yeari, Occ. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
16.Nawab Mormood Jung, S/o Late Nawab Khair Nawaz Jung, Aged about 51
Years, Ocr;. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
17.Nawab Betrbood Ali Khan S/o Late Nawab Khair Nawaz Jung, Aged about 48
Years, Occ;. Business, 0/o G-33, Navakethan Colony, Clock Tower, S. D.
Road, Secunderabad.
18. B. Shankarlal, S/o Banarsilal, Aged. Major, Occ. Business, Residing at H. No.
5-9-70112, Chirag
All
Lane,
Abids,
Hyderabad.
Respondents/Respondents/Respondent No. 2 to 1B
(Respondents No. 2 to 18 are Formal Parties and notices are not
required for them)
...Respondents /RespondenURespondent No.2 to 18
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to grant stay
of all further proceedings pursuant to the order dated '1 1.08.2025 passed in lA No.
356 of 2025 in ASSR No. 2734 of 2O25 on the file of the Honble lll Additional Distrit
and sessions Judge cum Principal Family court Medchal Malkajgiri at Kukatpally,
pending disposal of the Civil Revision Petition.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2025
Petition under section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to extend the
interim suspension order passed in lA No. 1 ot 2025 in CRP No. 4360 of 2025 daled
05.12.2025 which was expired on 12.12.2025 until further orders pending disposal of
the Civil Revision Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : Sri K Devanath
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : Sri Rajagopallavan Tayi
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 to 18 : - - The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE I{[GH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT: HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
CIVIL REVIS TON PE TITION No.4360 O F 2025
D ATE: 13-02-2026
Betrveen:
Petitioner
Mr. Bodapu irti Sudhaker
Vs
Mr. Syed Saleemuddin & others
Respondents
This Court made the following:
RAL
DER:
Heard Mr. K. Devanath, leamed counsel for the petitioner and
Mr Raja Gopallar.an Tayi, learned counsel for respondent No.l
Respondent Nos.2 to 18 are not necessary partles
2. This revision is filed assailing the docket order dated
1 1.08.202j;
in I.A. No.356 of 2025 in ASSR No.2734 of 2025 passed
by learned lll Additional District and Sessions Judge-cum-Principal
Family couft, Medchal - Malkajgiri District at Kukatpally.
3. 1-he petitioner herein has filed a suit in o.S. No.671 of 2o2l
(Old O.S. No.347 ot2020) against respondent Nos.2 to 18, to declare
the registe,red sale deed bearing No.1341 of 1965, dated 02-06.1965,
t,
KLJ
CRP No.4360 of2025
as illegal and for consequential relief of perpetual
same was decreed on 05.10.2023. It was al
injunction' The
ex parte decree'
4. Challenging the said judgment and decree dated 05'10'2023,
..
respondent No.1 herein has preferred an appeal
vide ASSR No'2734
of 2025. He has also filed an Interlocutory Application vide
l'A'
No.356oflO}5seekingleavetopreferthesaidappeal.
5. Vide order dated 11.08.2025, learned appellate Court passed
the following order:
"Heard counsel for the petitioner' Perused the
record.Consideringtheaffidavitofthepetitioner
party of
stating that the petitioner is the aggrieved
the judgment passed in OS No'67112021' this
petition is allowed permitting the petitioner/third
party to prefer appeal subject to limitation."
.
-^
6. Challenging the said order, the ptaintiff in the said suit,
the
petitioner herein, filed the present revision'
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner herein would contend
the impugned order is not based on reasons
that
and it is an ex parte order
without giving opportunity to the petitioner herein'
8.Whereas,learnedcounselforrespondentNo.lwould
contend that the petitioner has filed the aforesaid
suit against
KLJ
CRP No.4360 of2025
respondenl Nos.2 to 18 herein who are no more and died before the
date of institution of the said suit itself. The petitioner herein has
mentioned the addresses of respondent Nos.4 to 17 as 'G-33,
Navanikethan Colony, Clock Tower, S.D. Road, Secunderabad'
Thus, he has obtained the said judgment and decree by
misrepresenting the trial Court and the said judgment and decree is
against the dead persons. Respondent No.1 herein has mentioned the
specific reasons in the affidavit filed in support of the petition in I.A.
No.356 ol 2A25, to grant leave for preferring the appeal challenging
the said judgment and decree. On consideration of the said aspects
only, leanred appellate Court allowed the said I.A. No.356 of 2025
and grante:d leave to respondent No.1 herein to prefer the said appeal.
. - In-lhe-l ight -t;f the-afbmi-dffilmbmi ssions it-is
*apt
to
note that in H. Anjanappa v. A. Prabhakarl, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in paragraph No.43 laid down the following principles
governing the grant of leave to prefer an appeal:
i.
Sections 96 and 100 of the CPC. respectively provide
-*--for preferring an appeal from-an-original-decree or
decree in appeal respectively;
'
. 2025 SCC ,Jnl-ine SC 183
KLJ
CRP No.4l60 of2025
11.
The said provisions db not enumerate the categories of
persons who can f,rle an aPPeal;
However, it a settled legal proposition that a stranger
lll
cannot be permitted to file an appeal in any proceedings
unless he satisfies the .oii.t that he fatls within the
category ofan aggrieved Person;
iv.
It is only where a judgment and decree prejudicially
affects a person who is not a party to the proceedings,
he can prefer an appeal with the leave of the
court;
'
A person aggrieved, to file an appeal, must be one
V
whose right is affected by reason of the judgrnent and
decree sought to be imPugned;
vl.
The expression'operson aggrieved" does not include a
person who suffers from a psychological or an
imaginary injury;
vll.
It would be improper to grant leave to appeal to every
person who may in some remote or indirect way be
-byrclee resTri u:dgniErit and v i i i.
I
Ordinarily leave to appeal should be granted to persons
,*,ho, though not parties to the proceedings, would be
bound by the decree or judgment in that proceeding and
who would be precluded -from-attacking jts -correctness
in other proceedings.
10. Respondent No.l has filed the aforesaid application in [-A.
No.356 of 2025 in ASSR No.2734 of 2025, seeking leave to prefer the
appeal contending as follows:
'7
-5
.
KLJ
CRP No.4160 of2025
"4.
I further submit that the Hon'ble IInd
Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, vide
its orders dated 23-01-1965 in I.A.No. 14 of 1965
directed the Respondent No. 3 herein by permitting
and authorizing to transfer alienate Prior sell the
properties forming part of Sultan-Ul-Mulk and on 09-
02-1965 Hon'ble IInd Additional Judge, City Civit
Court, Hyderabad, issued a sale l5 warrant
authorizing the Advocate-Commissioner, who was
appointed pursuant to an order in the Interlocutory
Application in the civil suit referred to herein above,
to convey to the partnership f,rrm, namely Friends &
Co. the shares of the plaintiff in suit O.S. No.l0 of
1962 along with the share of other shareholders
having accepting the amount deposited by the said
partnership firm with the court. It is submitted that in
furtherance to the order of the Hon'ble IInd
Additional Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad,
, tha. Court Receiver executed
sale deeds,
conveying their shares in the property, including the
property situate in survey No.80, 80/l and 80lz
admeasuring Acres 13-35 Guntas of Fateh Nagar
Village, with which I am concerned in the instant
suit. All the partners of the said parErership firm have
shares i,
l!_.__pto.p...g y.|i+ ryT pq.huqe! by ttre
partnership firm. I submit that the property situate in
survey No.80, 80/l and 80/2 admeasuring Acres 1335 Guntas of Fateh Nagar Village, Balanagar Mandal,
,7
KLJ
CRP No.4360 of2025
Ranga Reddy District devolved upon the firm. Thus,
the partners of firm are in peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the property, situate in survey No.80,
80/l and 80/2 admeasuring Acres 13-35 Guntas of
Fateh Nagar Village.
5. I submit that, the Respondent No. I herein have
filed the suit O.S.No.67l of 2021, against the
Respondent No. 2 to 18 herein before the Hon'ble
Senior Civil Judge, Medchal Malkajgiri District
Court at Kukatpally, for Declaration of Sale Deed
Doc. No. 1.341 of L965 as null and void and
lnjunction in respect of the Suit Schedule Property,
and the Hon'ble Senior Civil Judge, Medchal
Malkajgiri District Court at Kukatpally without
appreciating the Oral and Documentary evidence
available on record was pleased to allowed the suit,
vide Judgment and Decree dated 05-10-2023.
6. I submit that aggrieved by Judgment and Decree
o t 2021
the Hon'ble Senior Civil Judge, Medchal Malkajgiri
Hon'ble *Court-Jo *-peruse-and *"- consider
.
*the.-
Mernorandum of Grounds .filed in the above Appeal,
as
*part--and*parcel*bf--this*Affidavit for " better
appreciation of facts of the case."
.
KI.J
CRP No.4360 of2025
However, without considering the said aspects, more particularly, the
aforesaid principles laid down by the Apex Court, vtde impugned
order, learned appellate Court granted leave to respondent No.l to
prefer the said appeal. Therefore, the aforesaid order is nbt on
consideral.ion of the principles laid down by the Apex Court in H.
Anjanappa (Supra) and contentions of the appellant therein. It is a
cryptic orrler without reasons
l. Perusal of affidavit filed by respondent No.l in support of
I.A. No.3:i6 of 2025 would reveal that he has not stated that all the
defendantr; in the said suit are no more. However, in the counter filed
by him in the present revision he has stated the said fact.
12. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, the impugned order
daled 1l-08.2025
by learned Appellate_ Corrrt in LA. Nq,356 of
2025 inlA.SSRNo:2734G ZOZS is set aside. The mattef is remandetl
back to leamed appellate Court with a direction to decide I.A. No.356
of 2025 ir, ASSR No.2734 of 2025 afresh stricrl y in accordance with
law by considering the aforesaid principles summarized by-the Apex
ffi.i_ffi---
court in Ir. Anjanappa (Supra). Liberty is granted to respondent
No.l here:in to file better affidavit. The petitioner herein is also at
KI.J
CRP No.4350 of2025
liberty to file counter in I.A. No.356 of 2025. Learned appellate Court
shall consider the same and decide I.A. No.356 of 2025 afresh as
expeditiously as possible.
13. The present Civil Revision Petition is accordingly disposed
of. In the circumstances of the cases, there shall be no order as to
costs
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in
the revision shall stand closed.
SD/- T.SRINTVASA REDDY
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The lll Additional District and sessions Judge cum Principal Family court,
tVledchal Matkajgiri, at Kukatpally
2. One CC to SRI K DEVANATH, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to SRI RAJAGOPALLAVAN TAYI, Advocate IoPUC]
4. Two CD CoPies
W^" K/PSL
HIGH COTJRT
DATED: 1310212026
t oR
o
U
ORDER
CRP.No.4l360 of 2025
DISPOSING OF THE CRP
WITHOUT COSTS
b
ES
0 6 fitfl 20f6
t
*
DITcH
z
o
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review