Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 07.04.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 01.07.2026
Date of uploading
: 01.07.2026
APHC010907772017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3566]
WEDNESDAY, THE 1st DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 1636/2017
Between:
1. BODAPATI BHAVITHAV, S/O. SUBBA RAO, KOTHAPETA, CHIRALA
PRAKASAM DSITRICT.
...APELLANT
AND
1. STATE OF A P, Rep., by its P.P., High court at Hyderabad
...RESPODENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that the High
Court may be pleased to
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(CRLAMP 3207 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 128 days in filing the above Crl.A.
IA NO: 2 OF 2017(CRLAMP 3208 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 30 days in representing the above case
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant interim bail to the accused in SC.No. 321 of 2014 on the file of the VII
Additional Sessions Judge, Ongole vide CT.No. 5280 and to pass such further
orders as this Honourable Court may deem fit and proper in the interest of
justice.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. I V N RAJU
2. Counsel for the Respondent/s:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI
SPECIAL DIVISION BENCH
PRESENT
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.1636 of 2017
JUDGMENT: (Per Sri Justice A. Hari Haranadha Sarma)
Introductory:1.
[i]
The sole accused in Sessions Case No. 321 of 2014 on the file
of Special Judge for trial of offences under S.Cs and STs (POA) Act,1989
cases-cum- VII Additional District Judge, Ongole filed the present appeal,
challenging the conviction and judgment dated 19.04.2017, whereby he was
found guilty and convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC
and sentenced to suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of
Rs.1,000/-, for the said offence; in default of payment of fine directed to
suffer simple imprisonment for a period of (3) months. He was also found
guilty of the offence under Section 380 IPC and sentenced to suffer Rigorous
imprisonment for a period of (2) years with a fine of Rs.500/- and in default of
payment of fine sentenced to suffer simple imprisonment for a period of one
month, while directing both the principal sentences to run concurrently.
Case of the prosecution:2.
[i]
Accused/appellant herein murdered his maternal grandmother
and taken away gold ring, gold ear studs and gold chain, apart from cash of
Rs.2,000/- to meet his vices including the debts.
[ii]
One LW.1/Bodapati Dhanalakshmi and LW.3/Bodapati Subbarao
are the parents of the accused, while LW.2/ Alaparthi Subbaramaiah and one
Alaparti Anasuryamma [herein after deceased] are the maternal grandparents
of the accused and parents of LW.1/Bodapati Dhanalakshmi and LW.2/
Alaparthi Subbaramaiah.
The deceased were residing in the neighbourhood
of LW.1/ Bodapati Dhanalakshmi and LW.3/Bodapati Subbarao.
Accused
was in the habit of sleeping in the house of maternal grandparents viz., house
of the deceased. But three (3) days prior to 07.01.2010, discontinued the
same.
[iii]
On 08.01.2010 at about 05.30a.m., LW.2/Alaparthi Subbaramaiah
came hurriedly to the house of LW.1/Bodapati Dhanalakshmi and informed
that the deceased was in unconscious state. Then, LW.1/Bodapati
Dhanalakshmi along with her husband went to the house of the deceased and
found that neck of the deceased was tied with a saree and gold chain, gold
ear studs of the deceased were found missing. They expected that thieves
might have committed the offence killing the deceased for gold and cash.
Then, LW.1/Bodapati Dhanalakshmi reported the matter vide Ex.P16, to
PW.10- the Station House Officer of Chirala II town Police Station. On the
strength of the same, PW.10 registered the same as a case in Crime No.08 of
2010 vide Ex.P17 - FIR dated 08.01.2010.
[iv]
Investigation was taken up, scene of offence was observed in the
presence of PW.5 and PW.6. Further, broken pieces of bangles were seized
from the scene of offence under the cover of observation report attested by
PW.9 and LW.15/Thota Sreenivasa Rao.
[v]
LW.19/G.Ramakoteswara Rao - the Inspector of Police, has sent
the dead body for autopsy. PW7 - Dr. R. Ajay Kumar conducted autopsy over
the dead body of the deceased and opined that the death was occurred due to
asphyxia due to throttling.
[vi]
During the course of investigation, the accused was arrested on
15.01.2010, and one gold chain and Rs.500/- note were seized from the
possession of the accused. Pursuant to his confession, gold ring and gold ear
studs were recovered apart from cash of Rs.1100/-, which was given by the
accused to PW.6 towards house rent from the stolen property. The gold ring,
chain and ear studs were recovered under mahazarnama attested by PW.8
and LW.15/Thota Sreenivasa Rao. Recovered property was identified in the
presence
of
mediators
PW.8,
LW15/Thota
Sreenivasa
Rao
by
Lw.1/B.Dhanalakshmi, who is daughter of the deceased, stating that the
recovered objects belong to her mother. Thus the investigation revealed that
the accused perpetrated the murder of the deceased, after committing theft of
gold chain, gold ring, ear studs and cash, having gained access to the house,
when the deceased woke up and tried to raise alarm, gagged her mouth,
pressed her neck forcibly and tied her neck with her women‟s wearing, due to
which the deceased died.
[vii]
Thus the accused is guilty of the offences committing murder for
gain.
3.
Learned Additional Junior Civil Judge, Chirala, committed the matter
vide PRC No.13 of 2010 to the Court of Sessions and the same is numbered
vide S.C.No.321 of 2014 and the learned Special Judge for Trial of Offences
under S.Cs & STs (POA) Act, 1989 cases –cum-VII Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Ongole [herein after referred as „the Sessions Judge‟] tried the
accused for the charges under Section 302 IPC for causing death of the
deceased and under Section 380 IPC, for committing theft of gold chain, gold
ring, ear studs, cash of Rs.2000/-, on denial of the plea of said offences.
4.
During the course of Trial, the prosecution has examined PW.1 to
PW.11; PW.1 to PW.3 are said to be the neighbours. PW.4 is the Inspector of
Police, who collected chance finger prints at the scene of offence and
compared with that of the accused finger prints. PW.5 is resident of Chirala,
to speak about the habits and conduct of the accused and, PW.6 is resident of
Chirala, to speak about accused giving money.
PW.7 is the Doctor, who
conducted autopsy. PW.8, is V.R.O., to speak about the confession of the
accused and the same leading to recovery of M.Os.1 to 7 and preparation of
seizurenama. PW.9 is the witness for observation at the scene of offence and
recovery of broken bangle pieces and who attested scene observation report/
Ex.P15. PW.10 is the Sub-Inspector of Police, Chirala II Town Police Station,
who received the report/Ex.P16 and the registered F.I.R./Ex.P17. PW.11 is
the investigation officer, who conducted the investigation. PW1, PW2, PW3,
PW5, PW6 did not support the prosecution case. They were declared as
hostile. During their cross-examination, the statements given by PW.1 to PW.3
were marked under Ex.P1 to P3 respectively and the statements of PW.5,
PW.6 were got marked under Ex.P7 and Ex.P8 respectively; the witnesses
denied that they did not state as mentioned in the Exhibits P1 to P3, and
Ex.P7 and Ex.P8.
5.
Further, the prosecution relied on Exs.P1 to Ex.P20 and M.Os.1 to 7
marked on its behalf. M.O.1 is two rows gold chain; M.O.2 is Rs.500/- note;
M.O.3 is Lakshmidevi idol gold ring; M.O.4 is one pair of gold ear studs;
M.Os.5 to 6 are the currency notes.
6.
When the accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he denied
the incriminating evidence appearing against him.
Findings of the learned Sessions Judge:7.
Learned Sessions Judge, relying on the inquest report, post mortem
certificate and the evidence of inquest panchaytdars as well as the Doctor,
who conducted post mortem examination, believed the death of the deceased
as homicidal; considering the evidence of PW.8 before whom the Test
Identification Parade was conducted with regard to the gold jewelry marked
under M.Os.1,3 and 4, identified by LW.1/Bodapati Dhanalakshmi, daughter of
the deceased that they belongs to her mother, and the recovery of the articles
pursuant to the confession of the accused, on the strength of the evidence of
independent mediators-PW.8 and LW.15/Thota Sreenivasa Rao, found that
the prosecution is able to connect all the links in the chain of circumstances,
and that the accused has committed murder of the deceased and committed
theft of gold, jewelry and cash recovered under M.Os.1 to 7, thus found guilty
of the offences under which he was tried. Accordingly, convicted the accused
and imposed sentence as referred above.
8.
Heard Sri I.V.N. Raju, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant/accused and Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor appearing on behalf of the respondent-State.
Arguments in the appeal :
For the accused:9.
(i)
The case is based on circumstantial evidence and the informant -
LW.1/Bodapati Dhanalakshmi, is not examined.
(ii)
Material
witnesses
i.e.,
LW.1/Bodapati
Dhana
Lakshmi,
LW.2/Alaparthi Subbaramaiah and LW.3/Bodapati Subbarao, who are the
parents and grandfather of the accused, who allegedly stated about the
involvement of the accused, are not examined.
(iii)
The other witnesses, relied on by the prosecution, did not support
the prosecution case.
(iv)
The alleged recovery of the material objects from a public place is
highly doubtful and lacks evidentiary value. The circumstances relied upon by
the prosecution constitute a weak link in the chain of evidence and are
insufficient to sustain the conviction. In the absence of cogent and reliable
evidence, the accused is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
(v)
There is no legally admissible and reliable evidence connecting
the accused with the alleged commission of the offence. The conviction
recorded by the Trial Court is based on conjectures and surmises, and the
prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable
doubt, and several material discrepancies and doubts arise from the
prosecution case. Therefore, the accused is entitled to the benefit of doubt,
and, consequently, to an acquittal.
For the prosecution-State:10.
(i) It is not the quantity of the evidence but the quality of the evidence
that matters.
(ii)
The prosecution has successfully established all the vital links in
the chain of circumstantial evidence, pointing exclusively to the guilt of the
accused and are inconsistent with any hypothesis of innocence. There is no
plausible explanation or possibility other than that the accused caused the
death of the deceased for gain, with the intention of meeting his vices and
discharging his debts. The evidence, when considered cumulatively, leads to
the irresistible conclusion that the accused alone is responsible for the
commission of the offence.
(iii)
The gold jewelry belonging to the deceased is recovered at the
instance of the accused and the same is sufficient in the context of the death
of the deceased being homicidal and that the accused alone is responsible for
the death, particularly in the absence of satisfactory explanation as to how the
accused get access to the gold jewelry of the deceased.
11.
Perused the record. Thoughtful consideration and anxious consideration
is given to the arguments advanced by both the parties.
12.
The points that arise for determination in this appeal are 1) Whether prosecution is able to bring home the guilt of the
appellant/accused for the offences punishable under Sections 302,
380 IPC, beyond all reasonable doubt? and Whether the conviction
and sentence imposed under the impugned judgment dated
19.04.2017 in S.C.No.321 of 2014 passed by learned Special Judge
for Trial of Offences under S.Cs & STs (POA) Act, 1989 cases –cumVII Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ongole is sustainable in
law or on facts? Or require any interference? If so, in what grounds
and to which extent?
2)
What is the result of the appeal?
Point No.1:Setting Criminal law into motion:13.
The First Objection of the learned counsel for the appellant/accused is
that the LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, who is shown as informant in Ex.P17-F.I.R.,
and is stated to have lodged the report marked as Ex.P16, is not examined. It
is relevant to note that, LW.1/B.Dhana lakshmi died before the trial. Hence,
she could not be examined and the factum of giving report and setting the
criminal law into motion is spoken by PW.10, who registered the F.I.R..
Hence, the same is proper. Therefore, to the extent of setting the criminal law
into motion, at the instance of LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, and sufficiency of
evidence of PW.1, need not be doubted.
The proof of contents of Ex.P16 is
different from speaking about the setting criminal law into motion at the
instance of LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi. To the extent of LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi,
submitting Ex.P16/report, and registration of F.I.R./Ex.P17 on the strength of
Ex.P16, can be accepted with the evidence of PW.10, and non-examination of
LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, cannot be considered as fatal to that extent. For this
preposition, reliance can be placed on the observations of the Hon‟ble Apex
Court in Lalitha Vs. Vishwanath and Others1.
Relevant observations
contained in paragraphs 32 to 34 reads as follows:“
32. If the informant dies, the First Information Report can be,
unquestionably, used as a substantive evidence. A prerequisite condition
2025 SCC OnLine SC 370
must be fulfilled before the F.I.R. is taken as a substantive piece of evidence
i.e. the death of the informant must have nexus with the F.I.R. filed or
somehow having some link with any evidence regarding the F.I.R. This is
what has been explained by this Court in the case of Damodar Prasad v.
State of U.P. [(1975) 3 SCC 851 : AIR 1975 SC 757].
33. There are plethora of decisions taking the view that an F.I.R. can be
a dying declaration if the informant dies of his injuries after lodging the
same. [See Munna Raja v. State of M.P. ((1976) 3 SCC 104 : AIR 1976 SC
2199)].
34. Another important thing is that for an F.I.R. lodged by a deceased
person to be treated as substantial, its contents must be proved. It has to be
corroborated and proved for there to be any value of the same in the case.
The F.I.R. can be used by the defence to impeach the credit of the person
who lodged the F.I.R. under Section 154(3) of the Evidence Act. In case the
death of the informant has no nexus with the complaint lodged i.e. he died a
natural death and did not succumb to the injuries inflicted on him in relation
to a matter, the contents of the F.I.R. would not be admissible in evidence.
In such circumstances, the contents cannot be proved through the
Investigating Officer. The Investigating Officer, in the course of his
deposition, should not be permitted to depose the exact contents of the
F.I.R. so as to make them admissible in evidence. All that is permissible in
law is that the Investigating Officer can, in his deposition, identify the
signature of the first informant and that of his own on the First Information
Report and he can depose about the factum of the F.I.R. being registered
by him on a particular date on a particular police station.”
14.
In view of the above discussion, the first objection of the learned
counsel for the appellant /accused is answered concluding that to the extent of
setting the criminal law into motion by LW.1/ B.Dhana Lakshmi, the evidence
of PW.10 can be believed.
Circumstantial evidence:15.
The prosecution has relied on the circumstantial evidence to establish
the guilt of the appellant/accused. The appreciation of circumstantial evidence
is governed by the five golden principles enunciated by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra2, are as
follows:
“(1)
The circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn
should be fully established.
(2)
The facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis
of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be
explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty.
(3)
The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency.
(4)
They should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be
followed, AND
(5)
There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of
the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must
have been done by the accused.”
16.
Therefore, in the present case, the evidence adduced by the
prosecution require examination in the light of the aforesaid principles to
determine whether the chain of circumstances relied on by the prosecution are
proved and whether they could establish the guilt of the appellant/accused,
they are :(i)
Homicidal death of the deceased.
(1981) 4 SCC 116
(ii)
Recovery of M.Os.3 and 4 belonging to the deceased, from the
accused, pursuant to his confession.
(iii)
The presence of the fingerprints of the accused at the scene of
offence and matching with the chance fingerprints collected by
the Investigating Officer and access of the accused to the
deceased.
(iv)
Motive.
(i)
Homicidal death of the deceased:-
17.
a)
„70‟ years.
As per Postmortem Certificate/Ex.P9, the age of the deceased is
As per the inquest report/Ex.P10 and opinion of the
Panchayatdars, saree was tied around the neck and pulled due to the reason
of tying around the neck, pulling or for any other reason by the thieves, the
deceased might have died and her gold jewellery was taken away by the
culprits.
b)
As per the Postmortem Certificate, the deceased is died due to
Asphyxia due to Throttling and the medical expert opined that the hyoid bone
is having ante-mortem outward fracture of right and left greater horn of the
hyoid bone.
c)
With the medical evidence covered by Ex.P9, corroborated with
the evidence of PW.8 and the contents in Ex.P10/inquest report, the nature of
the death of the deceased can be accepted as homicidal death.
(ii)
Recovery of M.Os.3 and 4 belonging to the deceased, from the
accused, pursuant to his confession:18.
Evidence of PW.8, the then V.R.O., Kothapeta, is very clear that basing
on the confession of the accused, (2) rows of gold chain was recovered from
the possession of the accused; in furtherance of his confession statement
under Ex.P11, the accused has lead PW.8 and other Police party to a rice
mill, Kothapeta village and picked up one gold ring and ear studs from a pit on
removing the earth and there upon, the gold ring and the ear studs /M.Os.3
and 4, were recovered.
19.
Learned counsel for the accused would submit that during the cross-
examination, PW.8 stated that M.Os.3 and 4 were recovered from the
accused. However, this appears to be a stray statement made independently,
which shall be read along with Ex.P11 and his entire evidence would indicate
that the accused after leading to the spot where M.Os.3 and 4 were
concealed, and the said articles were recovered pursuant to the disclosure
made by him and it cannot be construed to mean that PW.8 intended to state
that M.Os.3 and 4 were physically handed over by the accused along with
M.O.1 and therefore, there is no contradiction.
20.
The alleged contradiction is sought to be projected is, at best, a minor
and inconsequential discrepancy.
Even assuming that it constitutes a
contradiction, the same is not of such a nature to affect the crux of the
prosecution case. A harmonious reading of the entire evidence would make it
clear that the answer elicited during the cross-examination was with reference
to handing over the M.Os.3 and 4, on recovery from the place where they
were kept, pursuant to the disclosure made by the accused. The statement
cannot be construed in isolation so as to suggest that the witness intended to
convey that M.Os.3 and 4 were physically handed over by the accused.
When the evidence is appreciated as a whole, no material contradiction
emerges so as to discredit the recovery proceedings, if the same is read in
continuation of the questions relating to the functioning of rice mill etc., elicited
during the cross-examination.
21.
In fact, in the cross-examination, PW.8 was more clear as to how the
accused has lead the police party to the mill and a particular place including a
compound wall of eastern side of the rice mill and recovery of the material
objects from the place where they were concealed. Inability to give answers
by PW.8 to certain particulars such as door numbers of the houses of certain
people, etc., is not sufficient to discard his evidence.
22.
Further, with regard to identification of the material objects-M.Os.1, 3
and 4, by LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, under the Mediatornama marked as
Ex.P14, it has not even disputed during the cross-examination conducted on
behalf of the accused.
The absence of any challenge to such identification
lends further credence to the prosecution case regarding the identity and
ownership of the said material objects.
23.
Ex.P14 would clearly proves the prosecution version that the two rows
of gold chain, gold ring with Lakshmidevi idol, two gold ear studs handed over
to PW.8 and in the presence of mediators, those items were mixed with the
other similar items and then, LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi was asked to identify the
ornaments and she has identified and stated that they belongs to her
mother/deceased. Ex.P14 is not disputed during the cross-examination as
observed above.
24.
The objection of defence is that, identification parade of material objects
by LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, is not proved as there is no evidence of
LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi.
This objection is answered stating that in the
presence of PW.8, LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, identified M.Os.1, 3 and 4 as that
of her mother and the same is sufficient. To the extent of identification of
material objects i.e., M.Os.1, 3 and 4, by LW.1/B.Dhana Lakshmi, PW.8 is an
eye witness. Therefore, his evidence can be relied on. There is no denial that
those material objects does not belongs to the deceased.
Hence, the
objection can be brushed aside.
25.
Further, this Court finds it proper to find the observations of the Hon‟ble
Apex Court made in Upendra Khare vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh3 on
25th May, 2026, relating to the issue whether the recovery can be proved
through the Investigation Officer, the observations made in para 18 and 19 are
as follows:3
2026 SCC OnLine SC 935
“18. Scene of the offence panchnama show that the syringes were
found near the toilet seats. Though an attempt is made by the learned counsel
for the appellant to submit before this Court that the recovery at the instance
of the present appellant is not proved because the panch witnesses to the
recovery panchnama turned hostile. We are unable to accept this submission
of the learned counsel for the simple reason that this Court had consistently
taken a view that merely on account of the panch witnesses turning hostile
cannot be a ground to discard this important piece of evidence, if the recovery
is proved through the investigating officer. On the backdrop of this fact, perusal
of the record shows that the recovery at the instance of the present appellant is
proved through the testimony of the investigating officer Arun Singh/PW 24. We
may refer to the judgment of this Court in Rameshbhai Mohanbhai Koli v. State
of Gujarat4, wherein this Court has reiterated the settled principle that recovery
is not vitiated merely because the panch witnesses have turned hostile. The
judgment read as follows:
“33. In Modan Singh v. State of Rajasthan [(1978) 4 SCC 435 :
1979 SCC (Cri) 56] it was observed (at SCC p. 438, para 9) that where
the evidence of the investigating officer who recovered the material
objects is convincing, the evidence as to recovery need not be rejected
on the ground that seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution
version. Similar view was expressed in Mohd. Aslam v. 4 (2011) 11
SCC 111 State of Maharashtra [(2001) 9 SCC 362 : 2002 SCC (Cri)
1024] .
34. In Anter Singh v. State of Rajasthan [(2004) 10 SCC 657 :
2005 SCC (Cri) 597] , it was further held that: (SCC p. 661, para 10)
“10. … even if panch witnesses turn hostile, which happens very often
in criminal cases, the evidence of the person who effected the recovery
would not stand vitiated.”
35. This Court has held in a large number of cases that merely
because the panch witnesses have turned hostile is no ground to reject
the evidence if the same is based on the testimony of the investigating
officer alone. In the instant case, it is not the case of defence that the
testimony of the investigating officer suffers from any infirmity or doubt.
(Vide Modan Singh case [(1978) 4 SCC 435 : 1979 SCC (Cri) 56] ,
Krishna Gopal case [(1988) 4 SCC 302 : 1988 SCC (Cri) 928] and Anter
Singh case [(2004) 10 SCC 657 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 597] .
36. In view of the above principles and in the light of the discussion
about the recovery as stated and concluded earlier, those materials
produced by the prosecution are relevant, acceptable and rightly
connected these circumstances with the appellants.”
19. This position was further reiterated by this Court in Mallikarjun v. State of
Karnataka [2019 (2) SCC 752], observing as under:
“23........On behalf of the accused, the learned Senior Counsel
contended that the evidence of PW 17 PSI as to the recovery of MO 1
dagger at the behest of Accused 1 is 5 (2019) 8 SCC 359 doubtful and
when PWs 8 and 9 have turned hostile, no weight could be attached to
the alleged recovery of MO 1 dagger. There is no merit in the
contention that merely because the panch witnesses turned hostile, the
recovery of the weapon would stand vitiated. It is fairly well settled that
the evidence of the investigating officer can be relied upon to prove the
recovery even when the panch witnesses turned hostile…..”
26.
In view of the above mentioned evidence and the preposition of law
clarified by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the above authority, the recovery of gold
chain and ear studs covered under M.Os.1, 3 and 4 of the deceased at the
instance of the accused is acceptable.
(iii)
Fingerprints of the accused - matching with the chance
fingerprints collected by the Investigating Officer:27.
The argument of the learned counsel for the appellant/accused is that
the accused is none other than the grandson of the deceased. Therefore,
there is nothing strange in his finger prints being matching of finger prints,
cannot be strong material.
28.
It is relevant to note that the cross-examination done on behalf of the
accused on PW.11, which is as follows:“It is true that Alaparthy Subbaramalah (LW2) was the husband of
deceased/
Alaparthy
Anasuyamma.
It
is
true
that
Alaparthy
Subbaramaiah (LW2) stated to me that the accused was residing with him
and his wife Alaparthy Anasuyamma at their house, as he himself and his
wife Anasuyamma attained old age. The witness adds that said Alaparthy
Subbaramaiah (LW2) further stated to him that the accused was not
visiting their house since last three (3) days prior to the murder of his wife
Alaparthy Anasuyamma.”
29.
This is elicited during the cross-examination of PW.11 but the same is
not denied by the accused and it was not deposed by PW.11 during the chiefexamination, whereas in the cross-examination the same is elicited.
30.
If a witness states something during cross-examination, which was not
stated during the chief examination, the accused cannot validly contend that
such evidence should be disregarded merely because it was not mentioned in
the chief examination.
Cross-examination always carries the risk of the
witness making statements that may be adverse to the accused. Therefore,
the argument that the statements made by the witness during crossexamination cannot be considered holds no substance.
31.
PW.4 -Inspector of Police, Finger Print Bureau, CID, Ongole stated that
he has visited the scene of offence, on requisition of Inspector of Police,
Chirala taken the chance prints at the scene of offence, which were available
on Television; marked the chance prints as 'A' and 'B' for his convenience. 'A'
was not fit for comparison as it was not having the sufficient number of clear
ridge characteristics. The 'B' marked chance print was fit for comparison.
PW.4 compared the chance print which is marked as 'B' along with the finger
prints of the accused those were sent under Ex.P4 and the chance print which
is marked as 'B' tallied with that of the finger prints of the accused, which were
sent in two sheets along with the requisition under Ex.P4. Ex.P5 is the
comparison chart and opinion. The middle finger of the accused tallied with
the chance print under Ex.P5. Ex.P6 is the report. Except the suggestion that
the Inspector did not seek to take chance prints on any other article, nothing
elicited from the cross-examination of PW.4. The undisputed presence of
fingerprints on the Television at the house of the deceased is also a strong
connecting link.
(iv)
MOTIVE:-
32.
The motive of the accused is for gain, as he committed the offence in
order to snatch away the gold jewellery of the deceased, who is none other
than his maternal grand-mother.
33.
The prosecution is relying on the access of the accused to the
deceased, being close relative and the recovery of gold jewellery from him
after a considerable time and he absconding after the incident and recovery of
gold jewellery of the deceased from the accused pursuant to his confession, if
recovery is proved, motive becomes acceptable.
34.
Recovery of gold jewellery of the deceased covered by M.Os.1, 3 and 4
from the accused, after her death, pursuant to the confession of the accused,
access of accused to the deceased and absence of explanation as to how and
why the gold articles of the deceased were with the accused, if viewed
together with the motive, namely the intention to take away the gold jewellery
of the deceased, these circumstances relied by the prosecution sufficiently
establishes the role of the accused and connects him with the commission of
the offences.
Therefore, the links in the chain of circumstances, viz.,
homicidal death of the deceased, missing of gold jewellery of the deceased
and the recovery of the same from the accused, identification of the same as
that of the deceased, are the strong circumstances having all connected links
in the chain of evidence not leaving any reasonable ground to believe the
innocence of the accused and that the same would show that in all human
probability the offence must have been committed by the appellant/accused
only.
35.
In view of the above discussion, this Court satisfied that the prosecution
is able to bring home the guilt of the accused for the offences punishable
under Sections 302, 380 IPC beyond all reasonable doubt, and the conviction
and sentence imposed under the impugned judgment dated 19.04.2017 do
not warrant any interference. Consequently, the appeal fails. Point No.1 is
answered accordingly, against the appellant.
Point No.2:36.
In the result, appeal is dismissed confirming the conviction and
sentence recorded by the learned Special Judge for trial of offences under
S.Cs and STs (POA) Act,1989 cases-cum-VII Additional District Judge,
Ongole, in Sessions Case No. 321 of 2014 under the impugned judgment
dated 19.04.2017.
Needless to state that the period already undergone by
the appellant/accused shall be given set off under Section 428 Cr.P.C.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the Criminal Appeal, shall
stand closed.
________________________
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
__________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Date:
Pnr
01 .07.2026
Whether the order is:
Speaking
Reportable
√
-
Non-speaking
-
Non-reportable
√
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.1636 of 2017
Date:
Pnr
01.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review