Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/36
GAHC010180782025
2026:GAU-AS:8376
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4691/2025
BITUMIX INDIA LLP
A LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP FIRM INCORPORATED UNDER THE
PROVISIONS OF THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP ACT, 2008
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT C/O PAWAN KUMAR AGARWAL,
SIKARIA COMPOUND (COMPLEX), CHRISTIAN BASTI, G.S. ROAD,
GUWAHATI, KAMRUP (METRO), ASSAM, PIN- 781005
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS.
THROUGH MINISTRY OF FINANCE, DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL
SERVICES, 3RD FLOOR, JEEVANDEEP BUILDING, SANSAD MARG, NEW
DELHI- 110001
2:DIRECTOR GENERAL OF FOREIGN TRADE
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY
VANIJYA BHAWAN
A WING
16 AKBAR ROAD
NEW DELHI- 110011
THROUGH ITS BRANCH OFFICE
DGFT GUWAHATI OFFICE
RG BARUAH RD
OPP. OVERNITE EXPRESS
AIDC
NABIN NAGAR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM-781024
3:RESERVE BANK OF INDIA
A BANK ESTABLISHED AND INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS
Page No.# 2/36
OF RESERVE BANK OF INDIA ACT
1934 HAVING ITS OFFICE AT CENTRAL OFFICE BUILDING
SHAHID BHAGT SINGH ROAD
FORT
MUMBAI-400001. THROUGH ITS BRANCH OFFICE
RBI REGIONAL OFFICE GUWAHATI
STATION ROAD
MAWHATI
PAN BAZAAR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM- 781001
4:ICICI BANK LIMITED
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE
COMPANIES ACT
1956 AND CARRYING ON THE BUSINESS OF BANKING UNDER THE
BANKING REGULATION ACT
ALSO FUNCTIONING AS AN AUTHORISED DEALER CATEGORY-I BANK
UNDER THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE MANAGEMENT ACT
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT ICICI BANK TOWER
NEAR CHAKLI CIRCLE
OLD PADRA ROAD
VADODARA
GUJARAT-390007
THROUGH ITS BRANCH GUWAHATI- FANCY BAZAR
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT OHIO SHOPPING COMPLEX
M.G. ROAD
FANCY BAZAR
GUWAHATI
KAMRUP (METRO)
ASSAM- 78100
Advocate for the Petitioner : DR. ASHOK SARAF, B SARMA,MR P K BORA,MR. N N
DUTTA,MR S J SAIKIA,MR P BARUAH
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., N J DAIMARI(R-4),MR G BORDOLOI(R-4),MS. J
BURAGOHAIN(R-4),N J DAIMARI(R-4),MR G BORDOLOI(R-4),MR. K GOGOI(C.G.C),MR. P
HAZARIKA(R-3),MR. H S BORAH (R-3)
Page No.# 3/36
Linked Case : WP(C)/240/2026
BITUMIX INDIA LLP
A LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP FIRM INCORPORATED UNDER THE
PROVISIONS OF THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP ACT
2008 HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT C/O PAWAN KUMAR AGARWAL
SIKARIA COMPOUND (COMPLEX) CHRISTIAN BASTI
G.S. ROAD GUWAHATI
KAMRUP (M)
ASSAM -781005.
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS
THROUGH MINISTRY OF FINANCE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES
3RD FLOOR JEEVAN DEEP BUILDING
SANSAD MARG
NEW DELHI
DELHI 110001
2:DIRECTOR GENERAL OF FOREIGN TRADE
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY
VANIJYA BHAWAN
A WING
16 AKBAR ROAD
NEW DELHI 110011
THROUGH ITS BRANCH OFFICE
DGFT GUWAHATI OFFICE
RG BARUAH RD
OPP. OVERNITE EXPRESS
AIDC
NABIN NAGAR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
781024
3:RESERVE BANK OF INDIA
A BANK ESTABLISHED AND INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF
RESERVE BANK OF INDIA ACT
1934 HAVING ITS OFFICE AT CENTRAL OFFICE BUILDING
SHAHID BHAGAT SINGH ROAD
FORT
MUMBAI - 400 001 THROUGH ITS BRANCH OFFICE
Page No.# 4/36
RBI REGIONAL OFFICE GUWAHATI
STATION RD
MAWHATI
PAN BAZAAR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM- 781001
4:ICICI BANK LIMITED
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE
COMPANIES ACT
1956 AND CARRYING ON THE BUSINESS OF BANKING UNDER THE
BANKING REGULATION ACT
ALSO FUNCTIONING AS AN AUTHORISED DEALER CATEGORY-I BANK
UNDER THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE MANAGEMENT ACT
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT ICICI BANK TOWER
NEAR CHAKLI CIRCLE
OLD PADRA ROAD
VADODARA
GUJARAT- 390007
THROUGH ITS BRANCH GUWAHATI- FANCY BAZAR
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT OHIO SHOPPING COMPLEX
M.G. ROAD FANCY BAZAR
GUWAHATI
KAMRUP (M)
ASSAM- 781001
-----------Advocate for : DR. A SARAF
Advocate for : DY.S.G.I. appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS
–B E F O R E –
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Petitioner
: Dr. A. Saraf; Mr. P Boruah; Mr. N N Dutta;
Mr. S J Saikia; Mr. P K Bora; Mr. B Sarma;
Mr. A Kaushik
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K Gogoi, learned CGC for respondent
Page No.# 5/36
Nos.1 & 2;
Mr. P Hazarika, learned counsel for therespondent No. 3;
Mr. K N Choudhury; Mr. G Bordoloi; Mr. J B Gohain, learned
counsel for the respondent No. 4.
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 04.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 12.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part
of the judgment ?
:
No.
Whether the full judgment
has been pronounced ?
:
Yes.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Dr. A Saraf, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. A Kaushik, learned
counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. K Gogoi, learned CGC for the respondent
Nos. 1 & 2; Mr. P Hazarika, learned counsel for the respondent No. 3 as well as Mr. K
N Choudhury, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. G Bordoloi, learned counsel for
the respondent No. 4 in both these writ petitions.
2. Since common questions of fact and law arise for consideration in these two writ
petitions, they were heard analogously and are being disposed of by this common
judgment.
Page No.# 6/36
3. The challenge in both writ petitions is directed against the decision of Respondent
No.4, ICICI Bank Limited, an Authorised Dealer Category-I Bank under the Foreign
Exchange Management Act, 1999 (for short, “FEMA”), in declining to process certain
foreign exchange transactions arising out of merchant trade transactions undertaken
by the petitioner.
4. The petitioner contends that the refusal of the respondent bank is arbitrary,
unsupported by law and has resulted in substantial commercial prejudice.
5. Respondent No.4 opposes the writ petitions and contends that the impugned action
was taken strictly in accordance with the contractual framework governing the parties,
the declarations furnished by the petitioner and the regulatory obligations resting
upon an Authorised Dealer Bank under the FEMA-RBI regime.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND:
6. The petitioner is engaged in international trade and maintains banking relationships
with Respondent No.4.
7. It is not in dispute that the petitioner had availed various banking and credit
facilities from Respondent No.4 and that the relationship between the parties was
governed by facility documents executed between them.
8. The Working Capital Facility Agreement/Master Facility Agreement [hereinafter
referred to as facility agreement] dated 25.01.2023 entered into by the petitioner with
the respondent No. 4 for availing working capital credit facilities up to an overall limit
of Rs. 10 Crore is enclosed to both the writ petitions. The execution of such
agreement and its binding nature are not in dispute.
9. During the course of business, the petitioner approached Respondent No.4 for
processing foreign exchange transactions arising from merchant trade transactions
undertaken by them.
10. The transactions were required to be processed within the framework of FEMA,
Page No.# 7/36
the regulations framed thereunder, directions issued by the Reserve Bank of India and
the contractual documents including the facility agreement executed between the
parties.
11. As part of the processing requirements, Respondent No.4 called upon the
petitioner to furnish declarations and supporting documents relating to sanctions
compliance, origin of goods, countries involved in the transaction and other particulars
relevant for regulatory and compliance scrutiny.
12. The declarations sought by the respondent bank were furnished by the petitioner.
13. To be specific, in WP(C) No. 4691/2025, the petitioner declared the below
mentioned contract detail concluded by them with overseas seller.
S. No. Transaction details
Name
1.
Country of origin of goods ** (See Note Below)
United Arab Emirates
2.
Country of loading of goods***
United Arab Emirates
3.
Port of loading of goods
Jabel Ali
4.
Port and country of discharge of goods (if other Bangladesh
than India)
5.
Country of trans-shipment (if any)
6.
Name of the transport vessel /airline etc.
N/A
14. In addition to the aforesaid, declarations were also given by the petitioner to the
respondent No. 4 in respect of the subject import remittance towards merchant trade
transaction in question in terms of the conditions of the facility agreement and the
applicable rules. Three of such declarations are extracted hereunder for ready
reference:
“To
The Branch Manager
ICICI Bank Ltd.
Date: 10/01/2025
Page No.# 8/36
Ghy.
Declaration for Import remittance towards Merchant Trade Transaction
1/ We... BITUMIX INDIA LLP..... (ordering/importing party) hereby confirm that
the underlying transaction of AED 605795.66 for which funds are being remitted
does not involve:
a)
any
sanctioned/designated/restricted/blocked
person
or
entity
(Beneficiary/Shipping line/Vessel etc.);
b) any comprehensive sanctioned country/region (Iran, Sudan, Syria, Cuba,
Crimea Region of Ukraine and North Korea); and
c) goods which have been sourced or originated from a comprehensive sanctioned
country (Iran, Sudan, Syria, Cuba, Crimea Region of Ukraine and North Korea)
.
BITUMIX INDIA LLP
Designated Partner”
………………………………………………………………………………………….
“To
The Branch Manager
Date: 18/11/2024
ICICI Bank Ltd.
Ghy.
Declaration for Import remittance towards Merchant Trade Transaction
1/We BITUMIX INDIA LLP (ordering/importing party) hereby confirm that the
underlying transaction of AED 64959,00 AED for which funds are being remitted
does not involve:
a) any sanctioned/designated/restricted/blocked person or entity (Beneficiary/
Shipping line/ Vessel etc);
b) any comprehensive sanctioned country/region (Iran, Sudan, Syria, Cuba,
Crimea Region of Ukraine and North Korea); and
c) goods which have been sourced or originated from a comprehensive sanctioned
country (Iran, Sudan, Syria, Cuba, Crimea Region of Ukraine and North Korea)
BITUMIX INDIA LLP”
……………………………………………………………………………………………
“To
The Branch Manager
ICICI Bank Ltd.
Date: 06/01/2025
Page No.# 9/36
Ghy.
Declaration for Import remittance towards Merchant Trade Transaction
I/ We... BITUMIX INDIA LLP..... (ordering/importing party) hereby confirm that the
underlying transaction of AED 665829.071 for which funds are being remitted
does not involve:
a)
any
sanctioned/designated/restricted/blocked
(Beneficiary/Shipping line/Vessel etc.);
person
or
entity
b) any comprehensive sanctioned country/region (Iran, Sudan, Syria, Cuba,
Crimea Region of Ukraine and North Korea); and
c) goods which have been sourced or originated from a comprehensive sanctioned
country (Iran, Sudan, Syria, Cuba, Crimea Region of Ukraine and North Korea)
BITUMIX INDIA LLP
Designated Partner”
15. The record unequivocally demonstrates that the petitioner had represented, inter
alia, that the transactions in question did not involve any sanctioned jurisdiction,
including Iran, and that the goods forming the subject-matter of the transactions were
neither sourced from nor originated in any country, including Iran, to which applicable
sanctions regimes extended. Such representations constituted material declarations on
the basis of which the transactions were processed.
16. Thereafter, information came to the notice of Respondent No.4 which, according
to the bank, disclosed an Iranian nexus in relation to the transactions and raised
concerns regarding the accuracy of the declarations furnished by the petitioner.
17. The respondent bank thereafter sought clarifications from the petitioner through a
series of communications.
18. According to Respondent No.4, the explanations furnished by the petitioner did
not satisfactorily address the concerns which had arisen.
19. The respondent bank consequently undertook a compliance review of the
transactions.
20. Upon completion of such review, Respondent No.4 declined to process the
Page No.# 10/36
transactions.
21. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has instituted the present writ petitions under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
SUBMISSIONS:
22. Dr. A Saraf, learned senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the
impugned action is arbitrary and unsustainable in law.
23. It is contended that there exists no prohibition under FEMA, the regulations
framed thereunder or any direction issued by the Reserve Bank of India prohibiting
the transactions in question.
24. It is further contended that Respondent No.4 could not refuse to process the
transactions merely on the basis of sanctions concerns arising under foreign regulatory
regimes.
25. Learned senior counsel further submits that the petitioner had no knowledge of
any alleged Iranian nexus and that no material exists establishing any deliberate
misrepresentation on their part.
26. Per contra, Mr. K N Choudhury, learned senior counsel appearing for Respondent
No.4 submits that the issue is not whether the transaction ultimately violated any law
but whether the bank acted lawfully and reasonably while discharging its contractual
and regulatory obligations.
27. It is contended that the petitioner had expressly undertaken sanctions-related
obligations under the facility agreement and had furnished declarations concerning
sanctions compliance and origin of goods.
28. It is further submitted that once information surfaced giving rise to sanctions
concerns and casting doubt upon the declarations furnished by the petitioner, the
respondent bank was entitled, and indeed obliged, to undertake enhanced scrutiny
and determine whether the transactions could be processed consistently with the
Page No.# 11/36
governing contractual and regulatory framework.
29. Learned senior counsel appearing for Respondent No.4 further contends that the
impugned refusal was an action expressly contemplated by the facility agreement and
cannot therefore be characterized as arbitrary or unauthorized.
30. I have heard the learned counsels for the contending parties and perused the
materials available on record.
31. The following issues arise for determination:
(i) Whether the writ petitions are maintainable;
(ii) Whether the petitioner is liable to be non-suited on the ground of suppression
of material facts;
(iii) Whether Respondent No.4 possessed authority under the governing contractual
and regulatory framework to undertake sanctions-related scrutiny and refuse
processing of the transactions; and
(iv) Whether the impugned decision suffers from arbitrariness, irrationality, mala
fides or procedural impropriety warranting interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution;
MAINTAINABILITY OF THE WRIT PETITIONS:
32. Respondent No. 4 has raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the
present writ petitions on the ground that it is a private scheduled commercial bank
and is therefore not amenable to writ jurisdiction.
33. The objection necessitates examination of the nature of the controversy and the
character of the function being performed by respondent No. 4 in the facts of the
present case.
34. There can be no dispute that respondent No. 4 is not a State authority within the
meaning of Article 12 merely because it carries on banking business.
Page No.# 12/36
35. In Federal Bank Ltd. v. Sagar Thomas, reported in (2003) 10 SCC 733,
the Apex Court held that a private banking institution does not become amenable to
writ jurisdiction merely because its activities are subject to statutory regulation.
36. Likewise, in S. Sobha v. Muthoot Finance Ltd., reported in 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 177, the Apex Court reiterated that extensive regulatory supervision, by
itself, does not convert a private financial institution into a public authority.
37. However, those decisions do not lay down an inflexible proposition that a writ
petition can never be maintained against a private banking institution.
38. The true test is not the corporate identity of the respondent alone but the nature
of the function being performed and the character of the impugned action.
39. Respondent No. 4 has also contended that the disputes arise out of contractual
arrangements between private parties and involve matters essentially commercial in
nature.
40. The objection cannot be accepted in the broad form in which it is urged.
41. Respondent No.4 is an Authorised Dealer Category-I Bank functioning under the
statutory and regulatory framework established under FEMA and the directions issued
by the Reserve Bank of India.
42. The impugned action concerns the processing of foreign exchange transactions
undertaken by the respondent bank while discharging obligations arising under the
FEMA framework.
43. The challenge mounted by the petitioner is founded upon allegations of
arbitrariness and unreasonableness in the exercise of powers claimed by the
respondent bank while acting in its capacity as an Authorised Dealer Bank.
44. It is well settled that the existence of contractual relations between parties does
not by itself exclude judicial review where allegations of arbitrariness are raised in
relation to actions having a public law element.
Page No.# 13/36
45. In ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of
India Ltd., reported in (2004) 3 SCC 553, the Apex Court held that a writ petition
is not rendered non-maintainable merely because the dispute arises in a contractual
setting, particularly where allegations of arbitrariness and public law infirmity are
raised.
46. In Mahabir Auto Stores v. Indian Oil Corporation, reported in (1990) 3
SCC 752, the Apex Court recognized that arbitrariness remains amenable to judicial
scrutiny even where contractual relationships exist.
47. In Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi v. State of U.P., reported in (1991) 1
SCC 212, the Apex Court emphasized that contractual dealings do not create an area
immune from constitutional scrutiny where public law considerations are involved.
48. The present challenge therefore cannot be rejected at the threshold merely
because the relationship between the parties is also governed by contract.
49. Accordingly, the writ petitions are held to be maintainable.
SUPPRESSION OF MATERIAL FACTS:
50. Respondent No.4 has further contended that the petitioner has not approached
this Court with clean hands and are therefore not entitled to any discretionary relief.
51. According to the respondent bank, material particulars relating to the transactions
and the sanctions concerns which subsequently surfaced were not fully disclosed.
Extracted in this regard, relevant paragraph of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondent No. 4 on 22.01.2025 in WP(C) No. 4691/2025, reads as under: “U. The Respondent undertook the due diligence as regards the said
transactions, with the Internal Maritime Bureau (IMB) to comply with RBI
Circular. The IMB, a specialized body, is recognized under the RBI
Circular for undertaking authentication of shipping documents such as
bills of lading and air waybills. The IMB report in respect to the subject
Bills of Lading under both the transactions shockingly revealed that the
shipments of goods did not take place as per the stated references in the
Page No.# 14/36
Bills of Lading. The report provided a detailed timeline of the vessels used
for shipment of the goods from Bandar Abbas, Iran (not Jebel Ali, UAE as
was represented in the various documents) to Port Klang, Malaysia,
where the goods were further transshipped using another vessel before
final discharge at Chittagong, Bangladesh. The report further stated that
the vessels used for shipment of the goods - Artenos and Golsan, are both
named on the US OFAC SDN sanctions list. Both vessels are ultimately
owned by the Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines Company (IRISL)
who are also named on the OFAC SDN list. Additionally, the report also
stated that (i) the containers listed on the Bills of Lading are owned and
operated by HDS Lines, Iran, which are effectively a subsidiary of IRISL,
and are also named on the OFAC SDN list; (ii) Avrasya Container
Shipping Lines, the carrier named on the two Bills of lading is also closely
related to IRISL and HDS Lines. The report concluded that the Bills of
Lading were misrepresented by the submitting party and that actual
details were omitted. It further concluded that the port of loading and
vessel name were misrepresented and omitted, and the shipments did
not take place as described on the Bills of Lading; the containers were
exported from Iran, not the UAE, on a vessel currently subject to OFAC
sanctions.”
52. This Court is conscious of the settled principle that a litigant invoking the
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court must make a full and fair disclosure of material
facts.
53. At the same time, every omission or disputed factual assertion does not amount
to suppression warranting dismissal of proceedings at the threshold.
54. The alleged Iranian nexus and the consequences flowing therefrom constitute one
of the principal issues in the lis in hand.
55. The materials relied upon by Respondent No.4 have been placed before this Court
and have been subjected to detailed scrutiny during the course of hearing.
56. In the facts of the present case, this Court is not persuaded to non-suit the
petitioner solely on the ground of suppression.
57. The objection relating to clean hands is accordingly rejected as a preliminary
ground for dismissal.
Page No.# 15/36
58. The matter must therefore be examined on merits.
STATUTORY AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK:
59. The transactions in question fall within the domain of foreign exchange regulation
governed by FEMA and the directions issued by the Reserve Bank of India.
60. Under the statutory framework, Authorised Dealer Banks occupy a central position
in the regulation and processing of foreign exchange transactions.
61. Such banks are not mere conduits through which foreign exchange transactions
pass.
62. They are entrusted with important statutory and regulatory responsibilities and
are required to ensure compliance with the framework governing foreign exchange
transactions.
63. Section 10 of FEMA assumes significance in this regard, which reads as under:
“10. Authorised person.-(1) The Reserve Bank may, on an application made to it
in this behalf, authorise any person to be known as authorised person to deal in
foreign exchange or in foreign securities, as an authorised dealer, money
changer or off-shore banking unit or in any other manner as it deems fit.
(2) An authorisation under this section shall be in writing and shall be subject to
the conditions laid down therein.
(3) An authorisation granted under sub-section (1) may be revoked by the
Reserve Bank at any time if the Reserve Bank is satisfied that(a) it is in public interest so to do; or
(b) the authorised person has failed to comply with the condition subject
to which the authorisation was granted or has contravened any of the
provisions of the Act or any rule, regulation, notification, direction or order
made thereunder.
Provided that no such authorisation shall be revoked on any ground referred to
in clause (b) unless the authorised person has been given a reasonable
opportunity of making a representation in the matter.
(4) An authorised person shall, in all his dealings in foreign exchange or foreign
security, comply with such general or special directions or orders as the Reserve
Bank may, from time to time, think fit to give, and, except with the previous
permission of the Reserve Bank, an authorised person shall not engage in any
Page No.# 16/36
transaction involving any foreign exchange or foreign security which is not in
conformity with the terms of his authorisation under this section.
(5) An authorised person shall, before undertaking any transaction in foreign
exchange on behalf of any person, require that person to make such declaration
and to give such information as will reasonably satisfy him that the transaction
will not involve, and is not designed for the purpose of any contravention or
evasion of the provisions of this Act or of any rule, regulation. notification,
direction or order made thereunder, and where the said person refuses to
comply with any such requirement or makes only unsatisfactory compliance
therewith, the authorised person shall refuse in writing to undertake the
transaction and shall, if he has reason to believe that any such contravention or
evasion as aforesaid is contemplated by the person, report the matter to the
Reserve Bank.
(6) Any person, other than an authorised person, who has acquired or
purchased foreign exchange for any purpose mentioned in the declaration made
by him to authorised person under sub-section (5) does not use it for such
purpose or does not surrender it to authorised person within the specified
period or uses the foreign exchange so acquired or purchased for any other
purpose for which purchase or acquisition of foreign exchange is not permissible
under the provisions of the Act or the rules or regulations or direction or order
made thereunder shall be deemed to have committed contravention of the
provisions of the Act for the purpose of this section.”
The aforesaid provision thus recognizes the pivotal role of Authorised Persons
and Authorised Dealers within the foreign exchange regulatory framework.
64. Under Section 10(5), an Authorised Person is required, before undertaking any
transaction in foreign exchange, to obtain such declarations, information and
documents as may reasonably satisfy it that the transaction neither involves nor is
designed for the purpose of any contravention or evasion of the provisions of FEMA or
any Rule, Regulation, Notification, Direction or Order made thereunder.
65. Put differently, Section 10(5) casts upon an Authorised Dealer Bank a statutory
obligation to undertake appropriate scrutiny, verification, due diligence and compliance
review before processing a foreign exchange transaction.
66. An Authorised Dealer is therefore required to satisfy itself that the transaction
placed before it is bona fide and is not intended to contravene or circumvent the
Page No.# 17/36
provisions of FEMA or the rules, regulations, notifications, directions or orders issued
thereunder. Viewed in the light of these statutory obligations, respondent No. 4 was
fully justified in subjecting the transaction, to closer scrutiny, seeking further
particulars concerning the shipment and its provenance, evaluating potential sanctions
related implications, and undertaking such enhanced due diligence as the attendant
circumstances reasonably warranted.
67. This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that an Authorised Dealer acting
under Section 10(5) is neither expected nor permitted to function mechanically.
Rather, it is required to undertake an independent assessment of the transaction
placed before it and to satisfy itself that the transaction complies with the applicable
statutory and regulatory framework.
68.
The RBI framework governing Merchanting Trade Transactions similarly requires
Authorised Dealer Banks to satisfy themselves regarding the genuineness, bona fides
and regulatory compliance of the transactions undertaken through them. Marchanting
trade, broadly stated, refers to a transaction wherein an Indian intermediary procures
goods from one foreign jurisdiction and supplies them to another foreign jurisdiction
without the goods entering India. In the present cases, the petitioner, acting as a
merchant trader, received purchase orders from buyers in Bangladesh and placed
corresponding back-to-back orders from Leoti Trading LLC, UAE, for direct shipment of
the goods to the foreign buyers without the goods entering India. The petitioner
sought processing of the related foreign exchange transactions through Respondent
No.4, including remittances payable towards the overseas supplier against the
underlying trade documents. The respondent bank, being the Authorised Dealer Bank
through which the transaction was proposed to be routed, was required to
independently scrutinize the transaction and satisfy itself regarding the correctness of
the declarations furnished, the genuineness of the trade, the shipment particulars and
compliance with the applicable regulatory requirements before permitting release of
remittance.
Page No.# 18/36
69. The regulatory framework further mandates adherence to KYC requirements, AntiMoney Laundering obligations and risk-based due diligence measures.
70. The materials placed before the Court further indicate that regulated entities are
expected to take FATF-related concerns into account while undertaking scrutiny of
international transactions.
71. Consequently, where circumstances emerge giving rise to sanctions-related
concerns or raising doubts regarding the accuracy of information furnished by a
customer, an Authorised Dealer Bank cannot be expected to mechanically process the
transaction without undertaking an appropriate compliance assessment.
72. On the contrary, the statutory and regulatory framework obliges the bank to
examine the matter, seek clarifications where necessary and satisfy itself regarding the
permissibility of the transaction before proceeding further.
73. The authority to undertake scrutiny necessarily includes the authority to call for
explanations, verify information and assess the implications of material which comes
to the notice of the bank during the course of such scrutiny.
CONTRACTUAL FRAMEWORK GOVERNING THE PARTIES:
74. Having considered the statutory and regulatory framework governing the
transactions in question, this Court now turns to the contractual framework governing
the relationship between the parties. The rights and obligations of the parties are not
determined solely by the FEMA-RBI regime but are also regulated by the facility
agreement voluntarily executed between them. The parties are bound by the terms
thereof and the legality of the impugned action necessarily falls to be examined in the
backdrop of the contractual obligations undertaken by the petitioner and the rights
reserved in favour of Respondent No.4.
75. The facility agreement placed on record contains detailed provisions governing
sanctions compliance, representations and warranties furnished by the borrower,
Page No.# 19/36
obligations relating to the utilization of banking facilities and the consequences flowing
from any breach thereof. Of particular significance are the provisions dealing with
sanctions compliance and the rights of the respondent bank in relation to transactions
attracting sanctions-related concerns.
76. Clause 6.1 of the General Conditions forming part of Schedule II to the facility
agreement contains a series of continuing representations, declarations, warranties
and covenants furnished by the petitioner. Clause 6.1(i) specifically provides that all
information furnished by the borrower to the respondent bank shall be true and
accurate in all material respects, shall not be misleading and shall not omit any
material fact, the omission of which would render any statement misleading. The said
representations were agreed to remain operative not only on the date of execution of
the facility agreement but also throughout the subsistence of the facilities.
77. More importantly, Clauses 6.1(xiii) and 6.1(xiv) specifically deal with sanctions
compliance. Under Clause 6.1(xiii), the petitioner represented and undertook that
neither it nor any person benefiting from the facilities was a sanctioned person and
further agreed to ensure that the transactions undertaken through the facilities did not
violate any applicable sanctions or involve any sanctioned person or entity. The clause
expressly refers to sanctions promulgated by, inter alia, the Office of Foreign Assets
Control (OFAC), the United Nations, the European Union, India and other relevant
jurisdictions. The petitioner further agreed not to utilize the facilities for financing
transactions involving persons or entities subject to such sanctions and undertook to
indemnify the respondent bank against losses arising from any breach of the
sanctions-related representations and undertakings.
78. Clause 6.1(xiv) assumes particular significance. The said clause expressly
recognizes that sanctions may become applicable to the facilities and transactions
thereunder, including documentary credits, guarantees, disbursements, payments,
purpose and end use of facilities, origin or shipment of goods through particular
Page No.# 20/36
countries, ports, vessels, liners, persons or entities, including correspondent banks and
the facility office. The clause further provides that disbursement, issuance, payment
and processing under the facilities may become subject to sanctions considerations
and expressly reserves to the respondent bank an unconditional right to refuse
processing of any transaction which violates or may violate any sanctions. The
agreement also treats breach of the contractual obligations and representations as an
event of default and reserves wide powers in favor of the respondent bank, including
cancellation or suspension of facilities and enforcement of contractual remedies.
79. A plain reading of the aforesaid provisions leaves no manner of doubt that the
petitioner had expressly undertaken to ensure that the transactions undertaken
through the banking facilities did not violate any applicable sanctions and that no
sanctioned person or entity was involved in such transactions. Significantly, the
petitioner specifically agreed that the sanctions contemplated under the agreement
included, inter alia, those promulgated by the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC),
the United Nations, the European Union, India and other relevant jurisdictions.
80. The agreement further recognizes that sanctions-related concerns may arise in
relation to the facilities and transactions thereunder, including documentary credits,
guarantees, disbursements, payments, purpose and end-use of the facilities, origin of
goods, shipment through particular countries or ports, vessels, liners, correspondent
banks and participating entities.
81. Clause 6.1(xiii) casts a positive obligation upon the petitioner to ensure that the
transactions do not violate any applicable sanctions and that no sanctioned persons or
entities are involved in such transactions. The petitioner had agreed not to utilize the
facilities for financing any transaction involving a person or entity subject to sanctions.
82. More importantly, Clause 6.1(xiv) expressly contemplates that sanctions may
become applicable with respect to the facilities and/or transactions thereunder,
including by reason of the origin or shipment of goods through particular countries,
Page No.# 21/36
ports, vessels, liners, persons or entities. The said clause specifically provides that
disbursement, issuance, payment and/or processing under the facilities may become
subject to sanctions considerations and reserves to the respondent bank an
unconditional right to refuse processing of any transaction which violates or may
violate any sanctions.
83. The contractual allocation of risk is therefore explicit and unequivocal. The parties
consciously agreed that sanctions-related concerns arising from the countries involved
in the transaction, origin of goods, shipment routes, vessels, correspondent banking
arrangements or participating entities would constitute relevant considerations for the
respondent bank while determining whether a transaction could be processed.
84. Equally significant is Clause 6.1(i), whereby the petitioner represented and
warranted that all information furnished to the respondent bank was true and accurate
in all material respects, was not misleading and did not omit any material fact, the
omission of which would render any statement misleading.
85. The sanctions provisions do not appear in the agreement as incidental or ancillary
stipulations. They form an integral part of the compliance framework governing the
relationship between the parties and constitute binding contractual obligations
voluntarily undertaken by the petitioner while availing the banking facilities.
86. Once the parties consciously agreed that sanctions concerns relating to the
countries involved in the transaction, origin of goods, shipment routes, vessels,
correspondent banking arrangements and participating entities would be relevant
considerations, the respondent bank cannot be faulted for examining those very
considerations when information subsequently surfaced giving rise to such concerns.
87. This Court finds that the sanctions provisions contained in the facility agreement
are clear, unambiguous and capable of only one interpretation. They expressly confer
upon Respondent No.4 the contractual right to refuse processing of transactions which
violate or may violate sanctions obligations.
Page No.# 22/36
88. Consequently, once information came to the notice of the respondent bank giving
rise to sanctions-related concerns and casting doubt upon the declarations and
representations furnished by the petitioner, the respondent bank was not only entitled
but contractually justified in re-examining the transactions and, if not satisfied,
declining to process them.
89. The impugned refusal was therefore not an action dehors the contractual
framework governing the parties. On the contrary, it was an action expressly
contemplated and authorized by the facility agreement itself.
90. This Court is accordingly unable to accept the contention that the respondent
bank acted without authority or beyond the scope of the contractual arrangements
binding upon the parties.
91. The facility agreement, read as a whole, substantially supports the stand taken by
Respondent No.4 and furnishes a complete contractual foundation for the course of
action ultimately adopted by it.
92. Viewed thus, the refusal complained of by the petitioner was therefore not dehors
the contractual framework but was an action traceable to rights expressly reserved
under the agreement governing the parties.
DECLARATIONS FURNISHED BY THE PETITIONER:
93. The record further reveals that, in connection with the transaction in question, the
petitioner furnished the declarations and certifications sought by Respondent No.4.
94. These declarations formed an important component of the compliance framework
within which the respondent bank was required to evaluate and process the
transactions.
95. In particular, the petitioner expressly represented that the transactions did not
involve any sanctioned jurisdiction, including, inter alia, Iran, and the goods forming
the subject-matter of the transactions were neither sourced from nor originated in any
Page No.# 23/36
jurisdiction, including Iran, attracting the application of sanctions or sanctions related
restrictions.
96. The aforesaid declarations were not mere procedural formalities or routine
disclosures furnished in the ordinary course. Rather, they constituted material
representations upon which the respondent bank was entitled, and indeed required, to
rely while assessing the permissibility, regulatory compliance and processability of the
transactions.
97. Respondent No.4 has subsequently placed materials on record which, according to
it, disclosed an Iranian nexus in relation to the transactions. Admittedly, OFAC sanction
existed in respect of Iran at the relevant point of time.
98. Whether such nexus ultimately stood established in every factual detail is not a
matter which this Court considers necessary to conclusively determine in the present
proceedings.
99. Nevertheless, the material which subsequently came to the notice of the
respondent bank was sufficient to cast serious doubt upon the accuracy of the
declarations earlier furnished by the petitioner.
100. Once such doubt arose, the respondent bank could not be expected to proceed
with the transactions as though the declarations continued to remain unquestioned.
THE PLEA OF LACK OF KNOWLEDGE:
101. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner has contended that the
petitioner itself was unaware of any Iranian nexus and therefore cannot be blamed for
any discrepancy which may subsequently have emerged.
102. The submission does not persuade this Court.
103. The transactions in question were international trade transactions involving
substantial commercial value and multiple jurisdictions.
104. The declarations furnished to the respondent bank were not casual statements
Page No.# 24/36
but formed the foundation upon which the bank was expected to undertake its
regulatory and compliance assessment.
105. In transactions of the present nature, the obligation to furnish complete,
accurate and truthful particulars rests squarely upon the customer seeking processing
of the transaction through the authorized dealer bank.
106. Once information came to the notice of the respondent bank indicating an
Iranian nexus and thereby casting serious doubt upon the correctness of the
declarations furnished by the petitioner, the respondent bank was fully justified in
reassessing the transaction. Such reassessment cannot be faulted merely because the
petitioner subsequently attributed the discrepancy to lack of knowledge or
inadvertence.
107. A subsequent plea of ignorance cannot compel an Authorised Dealer Bank to
disregard material information that comes to its notice during the course of
compliance review. On the contrary, it was the responsibility of the petitioner, before
furnishing the declarations in question, to exercise due diligence and verify the origin
of the goods, the shipment particulars and the vessel involved in the transaction. In
modern international trade, such information is ordinarily available and capable of
verification. The obligation does not end with the mere submission of a declaration; it
continues throughout the transactions and binds the declarant to ensure that the
representations and declarations made to the bank remain true, accurate and not
misleading. Where subsequent facts emerge demonstrating a material departure from
the declarations furnished, the bank cannot be compelled to proceed as though such
information had never come to light.
108. This Court also finds it difficult to accept that in international trade transactions
of the present nature, involving shipment of goods across jurisdictions, the
provenance, routing and movement of goods would be matters wholly beyond the
knowledge of the parties undertaking the transaction.
Page No.# 25/36
109. Be that as it may, even assuming that the petitioner lacked prior knowledge of
the Iranian nexus alleged by the respondent bank, such circumstance would not dilute
the respondent bank’s entitlement and obligation to act upon information
subsequently received by it.
110. The respondent bank was therefore justified in treating the subsequent
information as a matter requiring enhanced scrutiny and reassessment of the
declarations furnished by the petitioner.
THE OFAC CONTENTION:
111. A substantial part of the arguments advanced on behalf of the petitioner
centered around the contention that sanctions administered by the Office of Foreign
Assets Control (OFAC) constitute measures of United States law and do not possess
force of law within India.
112. It was contended that Respondent No.4 could not refuse to process the
transactions merely because the transactions may attract adverse consequences under
a foreign sanctions regime.
113. There can be little dispute that the mere existence of a foreign sanctions regime
does not, by itself, render such sanctions enforceable as part of municipal law in India.
114. Article 51(c) of the Constitution enjoins the State to foster respect for
international law and treaty obligations. The said provision must be read in
conjunction with Article 253 of the Constitution. In National Legal Services
Authority v. Union of India, reported in (2014) 5 SCC 438, the Apex Court
comprehensively examined the relationship between international law and municipal
law in India. The Apex Court also referred to Kesavananda Bharati v. State of
Kerala, reported in (1973) 4 SCC 225, wherein it was observed that constitutional
provisions may, where appropriate, be construed in the light of India’s international
commitments and obligations. Similarly, in Apparel Export Promotion Council v.
A.K. Chopra, reported in (1999) 1 SCC 759, the Apex Court held that
Page No.# 26/36
international conventions and norms may be accorded due regard while construing
domestic law, particularly where no inconsistency exists between the two and where
domestic law admits of such interpretation.
115. In Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, reported in (1997) 6 SCC 241, the
Apex Court reiterated that international conventions and norms, so long as they are
not inconsistent with the fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution or
with domestic law, may be relied upon to inform and illuminate the interpretation of
municipal law, particularly in areas where domestic law is silent or where such
interpretation advances the object and spirit of constitutional guarantees.
116. Equally, in Jolly George Varghese v. Bank of Cochin, reported in (1980)
2 SCC 360, the Apex Court clarified that international covenants do not
automatically acquire the force of municipal law merely by virtue of their existence or
ratification.
117. The cumulative effect of the aforesaid decisions, particularly Jolly George
Varghese (supra) and National Legal Services Authority (supra), is that
Indian law recognizes a well-defined hierarchy governing the domestic operation of
international norms. At the apex of that hierarchy stands legislation enacted by
Parliament. International obligations attain enforceable municipal status only to the
extent recognised by the Constitution or incorporated through legislation. Resolutions
of the United Nations Security Council, when implemented through the statutory
mechanism contemplated under the United Nations (Security Council) Act, 1947, may
consequently acquire binding force within the domestic legal framework.
118. As explained in National Legal Services Authority (supra), international
obligations do not attain enforceable municipal status merely because they exist in the
sphere of international law. Their domestic operation is contingent upon the
constitutional and statutory framework applicable in India. Even treaties duly ratified
by India ordinarily operate as interpretative aids unless and until Parliament enacts
Page No.# 27/36
legislation giving them domestic effect. The Apex Court contrasted this position with
jurisdictions such as the United States, where treaties may, by constitutional design,
enjoy a different status within the domestic legal order.
119. Consequently, sanctions administered by the Office of Foreign Assets Control
(OFAC) remain measures of domestic law of the United States, binding in the first
instance upon persons and entities subject to that jurisdiction. Their recognition or
relevance within India must therefore be examined in the context of the applicable
contractual, regulatory and statutory framework and cannot be assumed to constitute
enforceable municipal law merely by virtue of their existence.
120. However, the controversy before this Court does not require determination of
that question in its widest amplitude.
121. The respondent bank is not seeking to justify its action solely on the footing that
OFAC sanctions constitute binding law applicable within India.
122. The foundation of the respondent bank’s case is considerably broader.
123. Respondent No.4 relies upon:
(i) the contractual obligations voluntarily undertaken by the petitioner under the
facility agreement;
(ii) the declarations furnished by the petitioner regarding sanctions compliance and
origin of goods;
(iii) the statutory and regulatory obligations resting upon an Authorised Dealer
Bank under FEMA and RBI directions; and
(iv) information subsequently received during the course of compliance review.
124. This Court has already found that the subject facility agreement expressly
contemplated sanctions-related concerns and conferred upon the respondent bank the
right to refuse processing of transactions which violate or may violate sanctions
obligations.
Page No.# 28/36
125. This Court has further found that the declarations furnished by the petitioner
subsequently became the subject matter of doubt upon information coming to the
notice of the respondent bank.
126. In such circumstances, the legality of the impugned action does not depend
exclusively upon the independent enforceability of OFAC sanctions within India.
127. The matter can be decided on the basis of the contractual and regulatory
framework governing the parties.
EFFECT OF THE SUBSEQUENTLY DISCOVERED IRANIAN NEXUS:
128. The respondent bank contends that during verification in respect of the original
shipping documents submitted by the petitioner with the IMB, it was revealed that all
goods in question were shipped from Iran. It is thus evident that information came to
the notice of Respondent No.4 indicating an Iranian nexus in relation to the
transactions.
129. The respondent bank contends that such information was inconsistent with the
declarations furnished by the petitioner and gave rise to serious sanctions-related
concerns.
130. It is important to note that the facility agreement themselves expressly
contemplated sanctions risks arising from the origin of goods, shipment routes,
vessels,
countries
involved
in
the
transaction
and
correspondent
banking
arrangements.
131. Consequently, once information indicating an Iranian nexus surfaced, the matter
fell squarely within the sanctions-review framework contemplated by the facility
agreement executed between the parties.
132. The respondent bank could not reasonably be expected to ignore such
information and proceed with the transactions regardless of the consequences which
might follow.
Page No.# 29/36
133. On the contrary, both the contractual framework and the regulatory framework
required the respondent bank to examine the implications of the information which
had come to its notice.
134. The respondent bank was therefore justified in treating the Iranian nexus as a
matter requiring enhanced scrutiny.
WHETHER THIS COURT SHOULD DETERMINE THE FACTUAL CORRECTNESS OF THE
SANCTIONS CONCERNS:
135. Considerable arguments were advanced regarding the actual origin of the goods,
the identity of the vessels involved, the routing of the shipments and the extent of the
alleged Iranian nexus.
136. The petitioner contended that the respondent bank had failed to conclusively
establish such facts.
137. In the opinion of this Court, the submission proceeds on a misconception
regarding the nature of the present proceedings.
138. The issue before this Court is not whether the respondent bank has established,
to the standard required in a civil trial, every factual assertion relied upon during the
compliance review.
139. The issue is whether the respondent bank acted lawfully in responding to
information which came to its notice and whether the decision-making process
adopted by it suffers from arbitrariness, mala fides or perversity.
140. Whether the goods were ultimately of Iranian origin, whether particular vessels
were involved, whether the petitioner possessed prior knowledge thereof and whether
every concern entertained by the respondent bank was factually correct in every
respect are questions which need not be conclusively determined in exercise of
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.
141. Such issues involve disputed questions of fact requiring detailed examination of
Page No.# 30/36
commercial records, shipping documentation, transactional records and evidentiary
materials.
142. A writ court is not ordinarily expected to undertake such an exercise.
143. More importantly, the legality of the impugned action does not depend upon this
Court recording a definitive finding on those issues.
144. The relevant question is whether material existed before Respondent No.4 which
reasonably triggered its contractual and regulatory obligations and whether the
respondent bank acted within the framework governing the parties.
145. It appears that upon undertaking verification with the International Maritime
Bureau (IMB), a specialized body, recognized under the RBI Circular for undertaking
authentication of shipping documents, such as bills of lading and airway bills, the
respondent bank came to know from such verification process that the entire
transaction have been undertaken and the goods were shipped from Iran and not
UAE, thereby violating the OFAC sanctions as Iran/Iranian origin goods and transport
thereof are clearly prohibited under the ambit of the OFAC sanctions.
146. This Court finds that such material did exist.
147. This Court further finds that the respondent bank was entitled, both
contractually and regulatorily, to act upon such material.
148. Once that conclusion is reached, the Court is not required to substitute its own
assessment for that of the respondent bank.
149. The matter must therefore be examined from the standpoint of the decisionmaking process adopted by Respondent No.4 and the limits of judicial review under
Article 226.
DECISION-MAKING PROCESS AND JUDICIAL REVIEW:
150.
It must be emphasized at this stage that this Court is not sitting in appeal over
the commercial wisdom of respondent No. 4.
Page No.# 31/36
151. Nor is the Court concerned with whether respondent No. 4 adopted the most
commercially prudent course available to it.
152. In Tata Cellular v. Union of India, reported in (1994) 6 SCC 651, the
Apex Court explained that judicial review is directed towards the legality of the
decision-making process and not towards appellate reassessment of the merits of the
decision itself.
153. Viewed thus, I have carefully examined the decision-making process adopted by
Respondent No.4.
154. The materials on record demonstrate that the respondent bank did not reject the
transactions at the threshold.
155. Information giving rise to sanctions-related concerns came to the notice of the
respondent bank during the course of its scrutiny.
156. The respondent bank thereafter sought clarifications from the petitioner [Refer:
Annexure-31 of WP(C) No. 4691/2025].
157. Communications were exchanged between the parties over a period of time.
158. Opportunities were afforded to the petitioner to explain the position and address
the concerns which had arisen.
159. The transactions were subjected to internal compliance review.
160. The respondent bank thereafter arrived at the impugned decision.
161. This Court finds that the considerations taken into account by the respondent
bank were not extraneous to the exercise undertaken by it.
162. The respondent bank was acting within a framework consisting of:
(i) obligations arising under FEMA and RBI directions;
(ii) duties resting upon an Authorised Dealer Bank under Section 10 of FEMA;
(iii) KYC, AML and due diligence obligations;
Page No.# 32/36
(iv) FATF-related compliance considerations recognized under the regulatory
framework;
(v) sanctions-related provisions contained in the facility agreement;
(vi) declarations furnished by the petitioner; and
(vii) information subsequently received during the course of compliance review.
163. No material has been placed before this Court to demonstrate mala fides,
arbitrariness, procedural unfairness, or the existence of any collateral or extraneous
purpose behind the impugned action.
164. I am thus of the unhesitant view, that the respondent bank cannot be faulted for
undertaking enhanced scrutiny when information came to its notice which, according
to it, raised concerns regarding the declarations earlier furnished by the petitioner.
Equally, the respondent bank also cannot be faulted for taking into account
considerations which the parties themselves had expressly recognized in their
contractual arrangements, including concerns relating to origin of goods, shipment
routes, vessels, countries involved in the transaction and sanctions-related risks.
165. In view of the foregoing, I am unable to accept the contention that the
respondent bank was bound to process the transactions notwithstanding the concerns
that had arisen in relation thereto.
166. This Court cannot be oblivious to contemporary developments in international
banking and finance which demonstrate that sanctions-related concerns may have
significant commercial and operational consequences for banks and financial
institutions participating
in, or dependent upon, international payment and
correspondent banking networks.
167. While foreign sanctions do not, by themselves, constitute enforceable municipal
law in India, it cannot be ignored that sanctions regimes administered by foreign
jurisdictions may, in practical terms, affect access to correspondent banking
Page No.# 33/36
relationships, international payment systems, trade finance arrangements and crossborder settlement mechanisms. Financial institutions engaged in international
transactions are therefore often required to assess and manage such risks as part of
their compliance and risk-management functions.
168. The commercial consequences of sanctions-related exposure may extend beyond
the sanctioned entity itself. Restrictions imposed within a major financial jurisdiction
may have downstream implications for counterparties, correspondent banks, clearing
arrangements and other participants in the international financial system. The
possibility of such consequences cannot be regarded as illusory or irrelevant from the
standpoint of a banking institution entrusted with regulatory compliance obligations.
169. It is in this backdrop that contractual provisions requiring declarations relating to
sanctioned jurisdictions, sanctions exposure and compliance obligations assume
significance. Such provisions are intended to enable a bank to assess and manage
risks associated with international transactions and to take informed decisions
regarding the processing of payments.
170. Consequently, where information subsequently emerges giving rise to concerns
regarding the accuracy of declarations furnished by a customer or indicating a
potential nexus with a sanctioned jurisdiction, the bank cannot be compelled to
disregard such information and proceed with the transaction as though no such
concern exists.
171. In the considered view of this Court, a banking institution engaged in
international financial transaction cannot be expected to ignore information bearing
upon sanctions-related risks, particularly where the customer has furnished specific
declarations concerning the absence of any nexus with sanctioned jurisdictions and
circumstances
subsequently
emerged
warranting
further
scrutiny
of
those
representations.
172. This Court is, therefore, unable to hold that the impugned action of the
Page No.# 34/36
respondent bank was arbitrary, irrational, unreasonable or otherwise susceptible to
interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of this Court.
CONCLUSIONS:
173. Upon total consideration of the matter, this Court records the following
conclusions:
(i) The writ petitions are maintainable;
(ii) The objection relating to suppression of material facts is rejected as a
preliminary ground for dismissal;
(iii) Respondent No.4, as an Authorised Dealer Category-I Bank, was required
under the FEMA-RBI framework to undertake due diligence and satisfy itself
regarding the permissibility and bona fides of the transactions placed before it;
(iv) The facility agreement executed between the parties expressly obligated the
petitioner to ensure sanctions compliance, contemplated sanctions risks arising
from countries involved in the transaction, origin of goods, shipment routes, vessels
and correspondent banking arrangements, and conferred upon Respondent No.4
the contractual right to refuse processing of transactions which violate or may
violate sanctions obligations;
(v) The petitioner furnished declarations concerning sanctions compliance and
origin of goods which formed part of the compliance framework governing the
transactions;
(vi) Information subsequently came to the notice of the respondent bank which
raised serious concerns regarding the accuracy of the declarations furnished by the
petitioner and warranted enhanced scrutiny under the contractual and regulatory
framework governing the parties;
(vii) The plea that the petitioner was unaware of the Iranian nexus does not dilute
the respondent bank’s entitlement and obligation to act upon information
Page No.# 35/36
subsequently received by it during the course of compliance review;
(viii) The respondent bank sought clarifications, afforded opportunities to the
petitioner and undertook a compliance review before arriving at the impugned
decision;
(ix) The refusal to process the transactions was an action taken in accordance with
the contractual framework governing the parties and cannot be characterised as
arbitrary or unauthorised;
(x) The Court finds no arbitrariness, mala fides, procedural impropriety or
perversity in the decision-making process adopted by Respondent No.4;
(xi) Whether the concerns entertained by the respondent bank were ultimately
correct on facts is not a matter requiring conclusive determination in the present
writ proceedings;
(xii) No ground for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution is made out.
174. This Court is satisfied that Respondent No.4 acted within the framework of its
contractual rights and regulatory obligations.
175. Hence, the impugned action cannot be characterized as arbitrary, irrational or
mala fide.
176. Accordingly, this Court is not inclined to interfere in exercise of its writ
jurisdiction.
OPERATIVE ORDER:
177. Resultantly, W.P.(C) No. 4691 of 2025 and W.P.(C) No. 240 of 2026 stands
dismissed.
178. Interim orders passed during the pendency of the writ petitions stand vacated.
179. It is clarified that this Court has not adjudicated upon any contractual, civil or
other remedies that may otherwise be available to the parties beyond the scope of the
Page No.# 36/36
present proceedings.
180. The dismissal of these writ petitions shall not preclude the petitioner from
pursuing such remedies as may be available to them in accordance with law before
the appropriate forum.
181. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
182. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Pranab
Kumar
Deka
Digitally signed
by Pranab
Kumar Deka
Date:
2026.06.12
14:53:59
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review