Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010273192025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/1235/2026
BISWAJIT SUTRADHAR
SON OF LATE BRAJABASHI SUTRADHAR RESIDENT OF THEO TANGANI
NAGAON ASSAM- 782124 OWNER OF M/S PUSPA PHARMA GST
REGISTRATION GSTIN - 18CWYPS8147Q1ZW MOBILE NO- 9706402981
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 2 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISIONER AND SECRETARY FINANCE
DEPARTMENT ASSAM GUWAHATI
2:THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX
ASSAM NAGAON
3:THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX
NAGAON UNIT NAGAO
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. AMIT GOYAL, MR. A CHOUDHURY
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, FINANCE AND TAXATION,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
ORDER
16.03.2026
Heard Shri Amit Goyal, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Shri
Page No.# 2/13
H. Baruah, the learned Standing Counsel for the Finance (Taxation) Department.
2.
Before dealing with the issue involved, the brief facts of the case may be
put in a nutshell.
3.
The petitioner was issued a summary of show cause dated 18.07.2025 in
Form GST DRC-01 for the tax period from April 2024 to March 2025 along with
an attachment as regards the determination of tax. It is the case of the
petitioner that there was no proper Show Cause Notice attached to the
Summary of the Show Cause Notice dated 18.07.2025 in the portal. Subsequent
thereto, an order was passed on August 19, 2025 in Form GST DRC07. It is
contended that the order under Section 74 A (1) read with Section 74 A (5)(i)
dated 19.08.2025 was not authenticated by any signature of the Proper Officer.
4.
Shri Goyal, the learning counsel for the petitioner submitted that it is the
requirement in terms of Rule 142 of the Central Goods and Services Tax
Rules, 2017 (for short, ‘the Rules of 2017’) that the notice under Section 74A
has to be issued and a summary thereof is to be additionally issued
electronically in Form GST DRC-01. He has submitted that under no
circumstances the attachment to the GST DRC-01 can be said to be a Show
Cause Notice inasmuch as in the said attachment, there is no mention that the
petitioner is required to show cause. Additionally, he submitted that the order
uploaded under Section 74 A does not contain the signature of the Proper
Officer and it is the mandate of Rule 26 of the Rules of 2017 that the Order had
to be authenticated with digital signature or through e-signature as specified
under the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 or verified by
Page No.# 3/13
any other mode of signature or verification as notified by the Board in that
behalf. In that regard, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
learned Division Bench of the Telangana High Court in the case of M/s Silver
Oak Villas LLP vs. the Assistant Commissioner ST {WP(C) No.6671/2024}
vide its judgment and order dated 14.03.2024 had dealt with Rule 26 of the
Rules of 2017 and categorically opined that since the impugned order therein
was an unsigned document, it lost its efficacy in the light of Rule 26 (3) of the
Rules of 2017 as well as the Telangana Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
and the Rules framed therein under. It was also observed therein that the
impugned order would not be sustainable and deserved to be set aside and
quashed. The learned counsel has relied upon the case of the Division Bench of
the Andhra Pradesh High Court in A.V. Bhanoji Row vs. Assistant
Commissioner (ST) & Others, reported in (2024) 123 GSTR 432. Reliance
has also been placed on the case of Nkas Services Private Limited vs.
State of Jharkhand & Others, reported in (2022) 99 GSTR 145, the
learned Division Bench of the Jharkhand High Court and another judgment of
the Karnataka High Court in the case of LC Infra Projects Pvt. Limited vs.
Union of India and Others, reported in (2020) 73 GSTR 248.
5.
He has submitted that even in a case where an adverse decision is
contemplated to be passed, there is a requirement for providing an opportunity
of hearing irrespective of whether the petitioners seek such an opportunity. By
referring to the Summary of the Show Cause Notice issued in GST DRC-01, he
has submitted that there is no mention whatsoever about the date of hearing
and the Column had been left blank. He submitted that use of the word ‘or’ in
Section 75(4) of the Central Act as well as State Act in between the words
Page No.# 4/13
‘when a request is received in writing from the person chargeable with tax or
penalty’ and ‘where any adverse decision is contemplated against such person’
clearly shows the legislative intent to the effect that irrespective of a request
made or not but when an adverse decision is contemplated an opportunity for
hearing is mandated. The learned counsel for the petitioner had referred to the
judgment of the learned Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court in the
case of Mahindra & Mahindra Limited vs. Union of India and Others ,
(WA No.172/2024) delivered on 10.04.2024 wherein the learned Division Bench
dealt with the scope and ambit of Section 75 (4) of the Central Act and
observed that when the statute contains a mandate of hearing which is a
synonym to natural justice, it cannot be given a go by or can be made porous.
The learned counsel for the petitioner therefore submitted that in the instant
cases as the impugned orders have been passed without giving a proper
opportunity of hearing as mandated under Section 75 (4) of both the Central
Act as well as the State Act, the impugned orders are liable to be interfered
with.
6.
Per contra, Shri Baruah, the learned Standing Counsel, Finance (Taxation)
Department of the Government of Assam submitted that the respondent
authorities have issued the Summary of the Show Cause Notice in Form DRC-01.
The learned counsel, however, fairly submitted that there is no separate Show
Cause Notice apart from the determination of tax enclosed to the Summary of
the Show Cause Notice. On the question of lack of signatures in the
attachments to the Order issued under Section 74 A dated 19.03.2025, the
learned counsel fairly submitted that the materials on record do not show that
there is/are any signature(s) in the attachment to the to the said order. He
however submitted that in the order it is mentioned as “Assistant Commissioner
Page No.# 5/13
of State Tax.” The learned counsel further submitted that when the order under
Section 74 A is uploaded, the same is duly authenticated in the portal with
digital signatures and without such authentication, the portal cannot be
operated.
7.
From the materials on record as well as the submissions advanced, the
following issues will arise for determination.
(i) Whether Show Cause Notices were issued prior to passing the
Impugned Order under Section 74 A of the State Act?
(ii) Whether summary of the Show Cause Notice in GST DCR-01 and
Summary of the Order in GST DCR-07 can be said to be the Show Cause
Notice and Order respectively?
(iii) Whether the impugned order under Section 74 A of the State Act is in
conformity with Section 75(4) of the State Act and is in consonance with
the principles of natural justice?
8. The records show that in GST DRC-01 issued to the petitioner, it is stated that
a Show Cause Notice is attached. The respondents claim that the said document
constitutes the SCN. The core issue is whether such attachment qualifies as a
valid SCN under the Central and State GST Acts and their respective Rules.
Notably, all the SCN summaries were issued under Section 74 A. Section 74 A
would show that the said provision is set into motion when it appears to the
Proper Officer that:(a) Any tax has not been paid; or
(b) Any tax short paid; or
Page No.# 6/13
(c) Any tax erroneously refunded; or
(d) Where input tax credit had been wrongly availed or utilized, for any
reason other than the reason of fraud or any willful misstatement or
suppression of facts to evade tax.
9.
Considering that it is only in the circumstances referred to above, the
Proper Officer is mandated to issue a SCN only under specific circumstances as
outlined in Section 74 A. Therefore, the SCN must clearly state the reasons and
circumstances justifying its issuance under this section. Only then can the
recipient effectively respond, particularly if they wish to challenge the
applicability of Section 74 A. Section 74 A requires the Proper Officer to
determine the tax, interest, and penalty after considering the representation.
Section 74 A (2) and 74 A (7) are interconnected, while Section 74 A (7) allows
passing the order within 12 months from the issuance of notice under Section
74 A (2), Section 74 A (2) mandates that the SCN must be issued within fortytwo months from the date for furnishing annual return for the connected
Finance year.
10. It may be noted that in Section 74 A, there is no mention of issuance of a
Summary of Show Cause Notice. The requirement of issuance of a Summary of
the Show Cause Notice is seen in Rule 142 of the Rules of 2017 which reads as
follows:“142. Notice and order for demand of amounts payable under the Act.- (1)
The proper officer shall serve, along with the (a) notice issued under
section 52 or section 73 or section 74 or section 76 or section 122 or
Page No.# 7/13
section 123 or section 124 or section 125 or section 127 or section 129 or
section 130, a summary thereof electronically in FORM GST DRC01, (b)
statement under sub-section (3) of section 73 or sub-section (3) of
section 74, a summary thereof electronically in FORM GST DRC-02,
specifying therein the details of the amount payable.”
11. From a perusal of the above quoted Rule, it would show that in addition to
the Show Cause Notice to be issued under Section 74 A (1), there is an
additional requirement of issuance of a Summary of the Show Cause Notice in
GST DRC-01 and the Summary of the Statement in GST DRC-02. The natural
corollary from the above analysis is that the issuance of the show cause notice
by the proper officer is a mandatory requirement in addition to the Summary of
Show Cause Notice in GST DRC-01 and Summary of the Statement in GST DRC02.
12.
The Division Bench of the Hon’ble Jharkhand High Court in Nkas
Services Pvt. Ltd. (supra) held that a summary in GST DRC-01 cannot replace
a proper SCN. Similarly, in LC Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd. (supra), the Hon’ble
Karnataka High Court emphasized that issuing a proper SCN is essential before
the recovery of interest or penalty under the Act.
13. In light of these decisions, the Court holds that merely providing a summary
in DRC-01 does not amount to valid initiation under Section 74 A. The summary
is only supplementary to a full SCN. Thus, the impugned orders, having been
passed without a proper SCN, are in violation of Section 74 A and Rule 142(1)
(a).
Page No.# 8/13
14. This brings this Court to the issue as to whether the determination of tax as
well as the order attached to the Summary to the Show Cause Notice in GST
DRC-01 and the Summary of the Order in GST DRC-07 can be said to be the
Show Case Notice and Order respectively.
15. Earlier, this Court has clarified that a summary of show cause notice cannot
substitute a SCN under Section 74 A (1). Therefore, the respondent’s claim that
the summary in GST DRC-01 constitutes a valid SCN is misconceived and
contrary to law. Moreover, the submission made on behalf of the petitioner finds
force that the order issued under Section 74 A summaries lacks legal value, as it
bears no authentication by the Proper Officer, violating Rule 26(3). In this
connection, reliance may be put on the judgments in M/s Silver Oak Villas
LLP (supra) and A.V. Bhanoji Row (supra) which emphasize the necessity of
proper authentication for such documents to be valid.
16. Rule 26 (3) of the Rules of 2017 reads as follows:
“26. (3) All notices, certificates and orders under the provisions of this
Chapter shall be issued electronically by the proper officer or any other
officer authorized to issue such notices or certificates or orders, through
digital signature certificate [or through E-signature as specified under the
provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000) or
verified by any other mode of signature or verification as notified by the
Board in this behalf.”
17.
Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules, 2017 lays down the manner of
Page No.# 9/13
authentication for notices, certificates, and orders, stating they must be
electronically issued by the Proper Officer or an authorized officer, using a digital
signature, e-signature as specified under the provisions of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 or any other Board-notified mode. However, it is important
to note that Rule 26 falls under Chapter III, which relates to Registration, not
Demand and Recovery, which is governed by Chapter XVIII. Therefore, the
direct applicability of Rule 26(3) to documents issued under Section 7 (falling
within Demand and Recovery) may be limited unless specifically extended or
adopted by the relevant provisions or judicial interpretation.
18. The question arises whether Rule 26(3), though located under Chapter III
(Registration), can apply to Chapter XVII (Demand and Recovery). In the case
of M/s Silver Oak Villas LLP, (supra) it was held that Rule 26(3) applies even
to Chapter XVIII, requiring authentication through digital or e-signature for all
notices and orders and this view was endorsed in the case of A.V. Bhanoji
Row (supra). It was laid down that signatures cannot be dispensed with, and
Sections 160 and 169 (which deal with procedural lapses) cannot cure an
unsigned notice or order. The said view is also supported in the case of Railsys
Engineers Pvt. Ltd. V. Additional Commissioner of Central Goods and
Services Tax (Appeals-II) reported in (2023) 112 GSTR 143, wherein it has
been stated that at least digital signatures must be affixed on SCN and Orders.
Section 74 A mandates that the Proper Officer must issue the SCN and the final
Order under Section 74 A (6). As per Section 2(91), a Proper Officer is the
Commissioner or someone entrusted by him. Therefore, unless these documents
are duly authenticated by the Proper Officer, they fail to meet the statutory
requirements and are rendered invalid and unenforceable. Section 74 A of the
Page No.# 10/13
Act requires that notices and order be issued by the Proper Officer but it does
not prescribe the mode of authentication outside Chapter III of the Rules. Since
no specific rule under Chapter XVIII (relating to Demand and Recovery) governs
authentication, a regulatory gap exists. Given the critical importance of
authentication by the Proper Officer, the Court held that, until proper rules or
notifications are issued by the Board to address this gap, Rule 26(3), which
requires digital or e-signature, must be applied by default. This ensures that any
notice, statement or order issued under the Act maintains its legal validity and
enforceability.
19. On the question of whether the impugned orders under Section 74 A
conform to Section 75(4) of the State Act and is according to the principles of
natural justice, the Court observed that the Summary of the Show Cause Notice
did not mention any date of hearing, leaving the relevant column blank. The
petitioner was merely asked to submit a reply, without being offered a cleared
opportunity for personal hearing.
20.
Section 75(4) of both the Central and State GST Acts mandates that an
opportunity of hearing must be granted when a written request is made by the
person chargeable with tax or penalty, or when any adverse decision is
contemplated against such person. This provision serves as a safeguard for
assessees, ensuring procedural fairness.
21.
The Division Bench of the Hon’ble Chhattisgarh High Court in the case of
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. (supra) reinforced this by holding that where a
statute mandates a hearing, it must be granted, and failure to do so renders the
Page No.# 11/13
provision ineffective and violative of natural justice. Accordingly, the Court held
that non-compliance with Section 75(4) in the present case violates both
statutory requirements and principles of natural justice, thereby vitiating the
impugned order.
22.
In this case, FORM GST DRC-01 attached to the writ petition includes
fields for the reply submission date, date and time of personal hearing, and
venue. However, in the Summary of the SCN, only the reply date was filled,
while the rest were marked as “NA”. The Proper Officer may have presumed that
a personal hearing was only necessary if the notice explicitly requested it in
their reply. However, the Court clarified the even when no reply is filed, the
second limb of the Section 75(4) still applies, i.e., if an adverse decision is
contemplated, a hearing must be granted.
23.
Failing to provide such a hearing renders the second part of Section 75(4)
meaningless, and thus, passing an adverse order without a hearing in such
circumstances violated both the statutory mandate and the principles of natural
justice.
24.
This Court, upon detailed analysis, hold that the Summary of the SCN
issued in FORM GST DRC-01 does not substitute the proper SCN required under
Section 74 A(1) of both the Central and State GST Acts. A formal and duly
authenticated SCN is mandatorily required to initiate proceedings under Section
74 A. The summary in the present case cannot be treated as a valid SCN.
Therefore, initiating proceedings solely based on such a summary is not in
conformity with law.
Page No.# 12/13
25.
It is further clarified that the SCN, the Statement, and the final Order
under Section 74 A must be issued and passed only by the Proper Officer, as
defined under Section 2(91) of the Act, these documents must be properly
authenticated in accordance with Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules, 2017. The
summaries issued in GST DRC-01, and DRC-07 are merely supplementary and
cannot override or replace the requirement of issuing proper and authenticated
primary documents.
26.
This Court also notes that the impugned order contravenes Section 75(4)
of the Act which mandates that the impugned order contravenes Section 75(4)
of the Act, which mandates that a reasonable opportunity of hearing must be
provided either when an adverse decision is contemplated or when a written
request is made by the assessee. In a situation, the Proper Officer cannot
proceed to pass an adverse order without granting an opportunity of hearing, as
doing so would render the safeguards under Section 75(4) ineffective and
violate principles of natural justice.
27.
Accordingly, the impugned order dated August 19, 2025 is interfered with
and set aside. However, as it appears that the respondents have proceeded
under the mistaken impression that attaching the determination of tax to the
summary constitutes a valid Show Cause Notice, the Court grants them liberty
to initiate de novo proceedings under Section 74 A, if considered appropriate. To
enable this, the Court directs that the period between the issuance of the
Summary of the Show Cause Notice and the date when a certified copy of this
judgment is served upon the Proper Officer be excluded from the computation
Page No.# 13/13
of the limitation period under Section 74 A (7) of the Act.
28. Writ petition accordingly stands allowed in the manner indicated above.
29. No order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review