Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 19th SEPTEMBER, 2017
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CHIEF JUSTICE
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Petitioners
:
1.
Shri Bishnu Rai,
General Secretary of Ravangla Astha Organisation,
A Non-Government Organisation,
Registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860,
Having Office at Ravangla, Sikkim.
2.
Ravangla Astha Organisation,
A Non-Government Organisation,
Registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860,
Having Office at Ravangla, Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Union of India
through the Secretary,
Ministry of Law and Justice,
Having Office at 4th Floor,
„A‟ Wing, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi – 110 001.
2.
The Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India
through the Secretary,
Having Office at 1, Shastri Bhawan,
Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road,
New Delhi – 110 001.
3.
The Sikkim University,
Established and Incorporated under
the Sikkim Universities Act, 2006,
6th Mile, Samdur,
P.O. Tadong,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
4.
Prof. Mahendra P. Lama,
S/o Shri R. P. Lama,
House No.1327,
Poorvbanchal, NSC Delhi,
Pin – 110 067.
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Shri Bishnu Rai & Another
vs.
Union of India & Others
5.
Mr. Jyotiprakash Tamang,
DEAN of Micro-Biology,
The Sikkim University,
Established and incorporated under
the Sikkim Universities Act, 2006,
6th Mile, Samdur,
P.O. Tadong,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
6.
State of Sikkim
through the Chief Secretary
Government of Sikkim,
Having Office at Community Centre,
Jeewan Theeng Marg,
Sikkim – 737 101.
Petition under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Suman Sengupta, Ms. Prarthana Ghataney and Ms. Ranjeeta
Kumari, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel for Respondents
No.1 and 2.
Mr. Umesh Gurung, Advocate for Respondents No.3 and 5.
Mr. Nikhil Pillai and Ms. Rachhitta Rai, Advocates for the
Respondent No.4.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with Mr. S. K.
Chettri and Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocates for
Respondent No.6.
Mr. Hemant Shukla, Special Public Prosecutor, CBI/ACR/Kolkata.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Pointing
out
gross
irregularities
including
financial
irregularities and illegalities committed by the Respondents No.3, 4
and 5, the Petitioners had earlier filed a Writ Petition, being WP(PIL)
No.18 of 2000, seeking a direction to the State or the concerned
Ministry, to carry out thorough investigation as to the allegations
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Shri Bishnu Rai & Another
vs.
Union of India & Others
raised. Disposing of the Petition on 23-06-2014, the Division Bench
of this High Court ordered as follows;
2.
In
”(i)
The petitioners will file a representation with all the
allegations, which have been alleged in the present
writ petition against respondents No. 1 to 3, before
respondent No. 4, i.e. Ministry of Human Resource
Department, Government of India, New Delhi, with all
necessary facts and documents in support of their
allegations, within a period of six weeks from today.
(ii)
If such a representation is filed by the petitioners, the
respondent No. 4 is directed to consider/examine the
allegations alleged by the petitioners, to make an
enquiry in case there is any necessity and in case the
allegations are, prima facie, found to be proved then
to initiate appropriate actions/proceedings against the
University, the then Vice Chancellor, the then
Registrar (respondents No. 1 to 3) or any other
officer, who is found guilty, in accordance with law.
The needful will be done by respondent No. 4 within a
period of six months from the date of receipt of
representation.
(iii)
It will be open for the petitioners to approach this
Court again in case they feel aggrieved with the
action of respondent No. 4.
(iv)
In case the petitioners want a personal hearing, then
the respondent No. 4 will afford an opportunity of
personal hearing to them.
(v)
It is needless to mention that in case any action is
taken or proceedings are initiated, by respondent No.
4, against respondent No. 1 Sikkim University,
respondent No. 2 Prof. Mahendra P. Lama, former
Vice Chancellor, Sikkim University, respondent No. 3
Shri
Jyotiprakash
Tamang,
Registrar,
Sikkim
University or any other Officer, then an opportunity of
being heard or to defend themselves will be given to
them.
(vi)
Parties shall bear their own costs.”
compliance
thereto,
the
Petitioner
filed
a
representation dated 28-07-2014 before the Respondent No.2, who
on being satisfied prima facie about the allegations, constituted a
Fact Finding Committee (for short “FFC”) to enquire thereto.
A
prayer for extension of time to dispose of the representation dated
28-07-2014 was made by the Respondent No.2 before this Court
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Shri Bishnu Rai & Another
vs.
Union of India & Others
and allowed. Despite such extension, the Report of the Committee
was not made available to the Petitioner, giving rise to the instant
Writ Petition, seeking disclosure of the Report of the FFC to the
Petitioners, by furnishing it before this Court with a prayer to the
Court to direct any Law Enforcing Agency to take up legal
proceedings against the Respondents No.4, 5 and 6.
3.
The Respondents No.3 and 5 filed their respective
Counter-Affidavit disputing and denying the allegations levelled as
baseless. Respondent No.4 in his Affidavit also resisted
the
allegations levelled by the Petitioners as false and vexatious and
made with the malicious intention of damaging the Respondent‟s
reputation.
4.
The Respondent No.2 for their part filed the Report of
the FFC, which was placed before this Court in CM Appl. No.258 of
2015 and taken on record on 21-09-2015.
It was submitted that
the Report of FFC was under active consideration of the Government
for further course of action.
5.
On 09-07-2016 by filing I.A. No.03 of 2016, the
Respondent No.2, informed that, based on the Report of the FFC,
the Ministry had issued a Notice to the Respondent No.4 seeking
recovery of an amount of Rs.2,20,671/- (Rupees two lakhs, twenty
thousand, six hundred and seventy one), only, on account of
irregular payment of electricity bill made by the Respondent No.3,
purportedly for the second residence of the Respondent No.4.
An
Audit Team had also been constituted to complete the process of
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Shri Bishnu Rai & Another
vs.
Union of India & Others
auditing/examining the allegations of irregularity in submission of
Utilization Certificate for the year 2010-11 and irregularity in
appointment of a Caretaker for Siliguri Guest House.
6.
The Respondent No.2 by filing I.A. No.05 of 2016, on
03-10-2016, informed that after examining the aforesaid issues,
Report had been submitted by the Audit Team and was under
consideration of the University Grants Commission (UGC).
By the
same I.A., two letters, i.e., one dated 12-09-2016 addressed to
Respondent No.4 by the Deputy Secretary of the Respondent No.2
and another letter dated 13-04-2016 addressed to the Secretary,
UGC, by the Deputy Secretary of the Respondent No.2, were also
placed on record.
The first letter allowed the request of the
Respondent No.4 to pay the amount of Rs.2,20,671/- (Rupees two
lakhs, twenty thousand, six hundred and seventy one), only, in
twenty equal monthly instalments, while the second letter pertained
to constitution of a Team, for examining the aforesaid two
allegations. So far as the Fact Finding Report (FFR) was concerned,
it was canvassed by Respondent No.2 that some allegations were
found to be true, some unfounded and in respect of some
allegations the matter was to be enquired further.
7.
On 03-11-2016, as no response was forthcoming from
the Respondent No.2 with regard to proposed action against the
concerned Respondents, despite the observations in order dated 1410-2016, this Court ordered that an Independent Agency, namely,
the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), be directed to examine
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Shri Bishnu Rai & Another
vs.
Union of India & Others
the alleged irregularities in the functioning of the University and
appropriate action be taken, as advised, as per Law. Consequently,
Notice was issued to the Additional Director, CBI (In-Charge, N/E
States),
who
put
in
his
appearance
through
Additional
Superintendent of Police, Anti-Corruption Branch, CBI, Kolkata,
W.B., on 10-11-2016 and was directed to examine the matter and
submit a Preliminary Report, within a period of four weeks.
8.
In the interim, the Respondent No.3 filed I.A. No.06 of
2016 seeking modification of the Order passed by this Court on 0311-2016 and contended that the FFC had examined all allegations
levelled against the Respondents No.3, 4 and 5 and found the same
to be incorrect, hence, the CBI was not required to further
investigate into the matter.
This Court observed that no further
order is required in this Application at that stage.
9.
The CBI thereafter submitted a Preliminary Status
Report to the effect that it was examining a large number of
financial transactions pertaining to Sikkim University for the financial
years 2009-10 and 2010-11 and sought time for detailed enquiry
and report.
On 19-06-2017, the CBI filed a Report under sealed
cover, with copy made over to the Central Government Counsel
appearing for Respondents No.1 and 2.
10.
Now, the Respondent No.2 has filed an Affidavit on 07-
09-2017 submitting therein that on perusal of the Report of the CBI,
it is found that some prima facie evidence existed against the
Respondent No.4, towards which, the CBI proposed to register a
WP(PIL) No.04 of 2015
Shri Bishnu Rai & Another
vs.
Union of India & Others
Regular Case against the Respondent No.4 and some other
suspects. In view of the said circumstances, the Respondent No.2
submits that the Affidavit dated 26-10-2016, being I.A. No.11 of
2016, and an application for modification of Orders dated 03-112016 and 10-11-2016, being I.A. No.12 of 2016 may be treated as
withdrawn.
That, the Respondent has no objection to the CBI
proceeding on the basis of their findings.
In
11.
view
of
the
said
Affidavit
and
the
aforesaid
submissions, we are of the considered opinion that the CBI take
necessary
steps,
without
being
prejudiced
by
any
of
the
observations made by this Court. During the process, the CBI shall
afford fair and sufficient opportunity to the Respondent No.4 to
place his matter, before the Agency, with no reservations.
12.
Writ Petition stands disposed of accordingly.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
19-09-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
Sd/( Satish K. Agnihotri )
Chief Justice
19-09-2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review