The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 03.2017 filed by the Petitioner on the “no objection” from the W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017 Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr. Respondent No.1 is set aside and the Trial Court is directed to rehear the said application dated 24.03.2017 before pronouncing its judgment in the Title Suit. The Learned Trial Judge is free to decide the further course as per law after considering the application dated 24.03.2017 and deciding the lis thereof. It is also made clear that the observations made in this judgment on the aforesaid two unregistered documents have been made solely for the purpose of examining the lis before this Court and the Learned Trial Judge shall not be bound by the observations so made herein while examining the merits thereof.
18. The Writ Petition is allowed on the above terms. No order as to costs. Sd/(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------W. P. (C). No. 32 of 2017
1. Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma
2. Shri Trilochana Sharma and,
3. Shri Kharananda Sharma,
(All sons of Late Pashupati Sharma,
R/o Lower Padamchay,
East Pendam, P.O. Pachak,
P.S. Pakyong, East Sikkim)
…. Petitioners
versus
1. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma
S/o Late Pashupati Sharma,
R/o Lower Padamchay,
East Pendam, P.O. Pachak,
P.S. Pakyong, East Sikkim.
2. Land Revenue & Disaster
Management Department,
Through its Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…. Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
Appearance:
Mr. Sudesh Joshi and Mr. Sajan Sunwar, Advocates for the
Petitioners.
Mr. J.K.P. Jaiswal, Legal Aid Counsel and Miss Rajani
Rizal, Advocate for Respondent No.1.
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with Ms.
Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocate for StateRespondent No.2.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
(02.05.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
Heard
Mr.
Sudesh
Joshi,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Petitioners and Mr. J.K.P.Jaiswal, Learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.1. The Learned Counsel appearing for the State
(Respondent No.2) made no submission.
2.
On 29.12.2012 Respondent No. 1 filed a Civil Suit i.e. Title
Suit No. 22 of 2014 for declaration, partition, injunction and
other reliefs against the Petitioners and the Respondent No. 2
herein. The dispute is between siblings, all sons of Late
Pashupati Sharma, arrayed herein as the three Petitioners and
the Respondent No.1.
3.
The Petitioner No.1 filed his written statement and along
with it a list of documents to be relied upon. Amongst the twelve
documents sought to be relied upon were two unregistered
“Bandabast Kagaz” or settlement deeds dated 24.03.1992 and
01.03.2010 (unregistered documents). The originals of the said
two unregistered documents were filed on 28.02.2017.
4.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi would contend that an application dated
24.03.2017 under the provision of Notification No. 385/G dated
11.04.1928 of the Government of Sikkim praying for permission
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
of the Court to validate the afore-stated two unregistered
documents on payment of fifty times (i.e. ₹5000/- for each
document) was filed. The said application was disposed off by the
Learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok (Learned Trial
Judge) vide Order dated 05.04.2017.
5.
The Learned Trial Judge, disposed off the said application
for validation dated 24.03.2017 giving the following reason:
“However, since the petition filed by the defendant no.1 only
seeks permission to rely and exhibit two documents, and since
Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff raises no objection only for exhibition
of the same, the application is dismissed.”
6.
The Petitioners are aggrieved by the impugned Order dated
05.04.2017 dismissing the application dated 24.03.2017 on the
afore-stated ground. Mr. Sudesh Joshi would contend that when
Notification No. 385/G dated 11.04.1928 as amended vide
Notification No. 2947/G dated 22.11.1946 provided that an
unregistered document which ought in the opinion of the Court
to have been registered may however be validated and admitted
in Court to prove title or other matters contained in the
document on payment of a penalty up to fifty times the usual
registration fee it must be done in that way only. He would also
rely upon and invoke the settled principle that when a law
requires you to do a certain thing in a certain way it must be
done in that way and in no other.
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
7.
The relevant notifications sought to be relied upon by the
Petitioners are reproduced herein below:
“SIKKIM STATE
GENERAL DEPARTMENT
Notification No. 385/G
All Kazis, Thikadars and Managers of Estates.
“In continuation of the previous rules on the subject, His
Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim is pleased to order that the
Law of Registration applicable in the State shall be amended.
Notification No. 314 and 2283-36/G., dated the 23rd January,
1907 and 19th July, 1922, respectively shall be read and applied
as under:“any document such as mortgage and sale deeds,
and other important documents and deeds, etc. will not be
considered valid unless they are duly registered.
The contents of an unregistered document (which
ought in the opinion of the court to have been registered) may be
provided in court but a penalty upto fifty times the usual
registration fee shall be charged.
Exception:-
Handnotes
duly stamped
shall
be
exempt from registration penalty”.
BY ORDER OF HIS HIGNESS THE MAHARAJA OF SIKKIM
Gangtok
The 11th April, 1928
Sd/Gyaltsen Kazi
General Secretary to
H.H. the Maharaja of Sikkim.”
“SIKKIM STATE
GENERAL DEPARTMENT
Notification No. 2947/G
Amendment of para 2 of Notification No: 385/G dated the
11th April, 1928.
An unregistered document (which ought in the opinion of
the court to have been registered) may however be validated and
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
admitted in court to prove title or other matters contained in the
document on payment of a penalty upto fifty times the usual
registration fee.
Issued by order of H.H. the Maharaja of Sikkim.
Gangtok
The 22nd Nov., 46
Sd/T. Tsering
(Offs) General Secretary to
H.H. The Maharaja of Sikkim.
Copy of memo No. 2553/C & F dated the 18th Sept., 1949,
from the Dewan, Sikkim State to the Tahasildar, East
Sikkim.
A copy of Rule regarding registration of document (1930) is
sent herewith.
The seals of registration fees is one rupee fee every
Rs.100/- or fraction thereof on the value of property or
properties.”
8.
The above two notifications are what, along with many
others, is commonly referred to in Sikkim as the “old laws”
covered by Article 371F (k) of the Constitution of India.
9.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi would contend that unless the payment
of fifty time the applicable registration fees is paid the two
unregistered documents cannot become admissible evidence and
the “no objection” of the Learned Counsel for the Respondent
No.1 would be of no consequence in view of the aforesaid
notifications.
10. Mr. J.K.P. Jaiswal would however, vehemently submit that
the Writ Petition was filed belated and after the Respondent No.1
had filed his written synopsis of argument dated 20.06.2017 at
the final hearing of the said Title Suit to fill in the lacunae and
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
on this ground alone the present Writ Petition is liable to be
dismissed. He would further submit that the two unregistered
documents in any case do not fall within the purview of the said
two notifications.
11. The facts reveal that the two unregistered documents had
been filed and sought to be relied upon along with the written
statement filed by the Petitioners in the Title Suit. The original
copies of the said two unregistered documents were also filed by
the Petitioner No.1 on 24.03.2017. The application dated
24.03.2017 seeking validation of the said two unregistered
documents on payment of fifty times the registration fee under
the provisions of Notification No. 385/G dated 11.04.1928 was
filed. The impugned Order dated 05.04.2017 reflects that when
the said application dated 24.03.2017 seeking validation of the
said two unregistered documents was filed, the Plaintiff, the
Respondent No.1 herein, had as yet not been examined. It also
reflects that on the said date i.e. 07.04.2017 the Learned Trial
Judge
examined
the
Plaintiff
and
posted
the
matter
to
07.04.2017 for examination of the Plaintiff’s witness. It is not in
dispute that on 24.06.2017 when the present Writ Petition was
filed the trial of the Title Suit was already complete and the
matter was posted for judgment on 30.06.2017. The interim
order passed by this Court on 29.06.2017 on the application
filed by the Petitioner has deferred the pronouncement of the
judgment. In the back drop of the aforesaid facts this Court has
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
been called upon to determine firstly whether the application
dated 24.03.2017 seeking validation of the two unregistered
documents filed by the Petitioner No.1 could have been
dismissed barely on the ground that the Respondent No. 1 had
“no objection” only for exhibition of the said two unregistered
documents and secondly; whether the delay in approaching this
Court by the Petitioners against the impugned Order dated
05.04.2017 after the trial was complete and the matter was
posted for final judgment would prejudice the Respondent No.1?
12. A perusal of the unregistered “Bandabast Kagaz” i.e.
settlement document dated 21.03.1992 prima-facie reflects that
it is a document purportedly apportioning the landed property of
one Pashupati Sharma between his elder son Rabi Lall Sharma
and Bishnu Lall Sharma. Both of them apparently are parties to
the dispute before the Trial Court. The certified copy of the said
unregistered document prima-facie reflects that it has also been
exhibited. Similarly, a perusal of the unregistered “Bandabast
Kagaz” i.e. settlement deed dated 01.03.2010 prima-facie reflects
that it is a settlement arrived at on 01.03.2010 between
apparently the same Rabi Lall Sharma, Divya Rupa Sharma and
the same Bishu Lall Sharma. A perusal of this unregistered
“Bandabast Kagaz” or settlement deed further prima-facie
reveals that it has been agreed that the sons of Late Pashupati
Sharma had willingly partitioned the landed properties of Late
Pashupati Sharma on 21.03.1992 but had not been able to
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
mutate the same in their respective names. The said document
also prima-facie reflects that as per the decision of their mother
Rabi Lall Sharma, her elder son, in addition to his share was
given a further share from the share of Bishnu Lall Sharma. The
evidentiary value of the aforesaid two unregistered “Bandabast
Kagaz” or settlement deeds and the effect of the same on the
dispute in the Title Suit are to be necessarily decided by the
Learned Trial Judge.
13. The
application
filed
by
the
Petitioner
No.1
dated
24.03.2017 clearly invokes the provision of Notification No.
385/G dated 11.04.1928 and states that the Petitioner No.1
would like to rely and exhibit the said documents in the instant
case and for the said purpose is willing to pay fifty times the
stamp duty and the registration duty as required under the
notification. There is no anomaly on the intent and purport of
the said application dated 24.03.2017 as sought to be argued by
Mr. J.K.P. Jaiswal.
14. The Trial Court has however, dismissed the application
dated 24.03.2017 on the “no objection” from the Respondent No.
1 for exhibiting the same without examining the merits of the
application or applying its mind to the effect of Notification No.
385/G
dated
11.04.1928
as
amended
vide
Notification
No.2947/G dated 22.11.1946 to the said application dated
24.03.2017. Therefore, what in effect the impugned Order dated
05.04.2017 has done is the dismissal of the application dated
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
24.03.2017 seeking to pay the penalty for the Petitioners failure
to register the unregistered documents and validate them on the
“no objection” of the Respondent No.1 without a word on the
status of the two unregistered documents and further without a
finding on the effect of the Notification No.385/G dated
11.04.1928 as amended by Notification No.2947/G dated
22.11.1946 on the two unregistered documents.
15. The effect of failure to register an unregistered document
required to be registered may be harsh and it may be equally
harsh not to permit the validation of the unregistered document
if the Court comes to the conclusion that it ought in its opinion
to have been registered. Registration of a document involves the
parties to the document on the one hand and on the other the
Registering Authority. Payment of registration fee is the revenue
of the State.
In such circumstances a “no objection” of one
private party cannot permit another private party not to pay the
required amount of money for validation which is in effect is the
penalty for the failure of the said party to register the said
unregistered document on payment of the requisite fees. The
same party i.e. the Respondent No.1 vehemently contests the
present Writ Petition before this Court in spite of the “no
objection” given before the Trial Court which has been clearly
recorded in the impugned Order dated 05.04.2017. The Learned
Trial Judge has scribed no other reason for dismissal of the
application dated 23.04.2017. A judicial order must reflect the
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
mind of the Court and the mind of the Court must be drawn to
the lis before it. The lis in the application dated 24.03.2017
under
consideration
was
whether
the
two
unregistered
documents were documents which ought in its opinion required
to be registered and would be covered by Notification No.385/G
dated 11.04.1928 as amended by Notification No. 2947/G dated
22.11.1946 and whether the said unregistered documents ought
to have been allowed to be validated and admitted in Court to
prove title or other matters contained in the said unregistered
documents on payment of
penalty up to fifty times the usual
registration fee.
16. In view of the aforesaid this Court is of the view that the
application dated 24.03.2017 must necessarily be reconsidered
by the Learned Trial Judge. Mr. J.K.P. Jaiswal, for the
Respondent No.1 may be right that the Writ Petition has been
preferred belatedly when the trial was already complete and
judgment reserved. This however, cannot be a ground to
perpetuate an illegality. However, his argument that the present
Writ Petition has been filed only to fill in the lacunae in the Title
Suit may not be correct in view of the fact that the Petitioner had
filed the said two unregistered documents along with his written
statement and sought to rely upon them and further the
application was filed on 24.03.2017 when the Plaintiff was yet to
be examined much before the written synopsis of argument
dated 20.06.2017 was filed by the Respondent No.1. Filling in
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
the lacunae in a case cannot be equated with the fallout of an
oversight committed during trial as; to err is human. Prima facie
the said two unregistered documents seem to pertain to the
dispute before the Trial Court. The purpose of trial is always to
seek the truth. Probable evidence cannot be resisted on
technicalities or even delay in placing the evidence before the
Court. It must be remembered that it is the cardinal rule in the
law of evidence that the best available evidence should be
brought before the Court to prove a fact or the points in issue. In
the present case the Trial Court is yet to render its judgment.
The Respondent No. 1 may not be adversely effected if the
application dated 24.03.2017 is reconsidered before delivering
the judgment. Although the Learned Counsel appearing for the
respective parties have made extensive arguments on the two
unregistered documents and whether the said two unregistered
documents
would
fall
within
the
purview
of
Notification
No.385/G dated 11.04.1928 as amended by Notification No.
2947/G
dated
22.11.1946
this Court
would
desist
from
rendering its view on the arguments made and leave it open to
the parties to raise all such arguments before the Trial Court to
assist it effectively to enable the Learned Trial Judge to come to a
correct conclusion.
17. In view of the aforesaid the impugned Order dated
05.04.2017 to the extent it dismisses the application dated
24.03.2017 filed by the Petitioner on the “no objection” from the
W.P. (C) No. 32 of 2017
Shri Bishnu Lall Sharma & Ors. vs. Shri Rabi Lall Sharma & Anr.
Respondent No.1 is set aside and the Trial Court is directed to
rehear the said application dated 24.03.2017 before pronouncing
its judgment in the Title Suit. The Learned Trial Judge is free to
decide the further course as per law after considering the
application dated 24.03.2017 and deciding the lis thereof. It is
also made clear that the observations made in this judgment on
the aforesaid two unregistered documents have been made solely
for the purpose of examining the lis before this Court and the
Learned Trial Judge shall not be bound by the observations so
made herein while examining the merits thereof.
18. The Writ Petition is allowed on the above terms. No order as
to costs.
Sd/(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
02.05.2018
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
to/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review