Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. M. C. No. 07 of 2017
1.
Birendra Prasad,
Aged about 37 years,
Son of Shivji Prasad,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
2.
Bramadeo Prasad,
Aged about 26 years,
Son of Shivji Prasad,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
3.
Shivji Prasad,
Aged about 60 years,
Son of Jabab Ram Saha,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
4.
Smt. Sanju Devi,
Aged about 34 years,
Wife of Birendra Prasad,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
…
Petitioners.
State of Sikkim
Represented by and through
the Public Prosecutor,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…
Respondent.
versus
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
Petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Ms. K. D. Bhutia
and Mr. Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Public Prosecutor with Ms. Pollin
Rai, Assistant Public Prosecutors for the State.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
(29.05.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The petitioners, who are close relatives, have come
up with this petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (for short, the Code), seeking quashing of the
criminal proceedings bearing G.R. Case No.129 of 2014 (State
of Sikkim vs. Birendra Prasad and others) along with the First
Information Report (FIR) dated 20.11.2013 and charge-sheet,
thererfor, pending on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
East Sikkim at Gangtok.
2.
Fourth petitioner is the legally wedded wife of the
first petitioner, second petitioner is the brother of the first
petitioner and the third petitioner is the father-in-law of the
fourth petitioner, i.e. father of the first petitioner. The criminal
proceedings culminated on the basis of a FIR lodged by the
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
fourth
petitioner on 19.11.2013 (sic. 20.11.2013) at around
11:35
hours,
complaining
that
on
07.02.2013,
the
first
petitioner had eloped with another woman and, thereafter, she
was constantly tortured by her in-laws, namely, the second and
third petitioners. It was further alleged that on 03.10.2013, the
second petitioner had stabbed the fourth petitioner with a knife
and absconded thereafter.
3.
A case was registered vide FIR No.74/2013 on
20.11.2013 under Sections 498A/324/34 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (for short, IPC) against the first, second and third
petitioners.
After investigation, a charge-sheet for having
committed offences against the first petitioner under Sections
494/498A of the IPC, against the second petitioner under
Sections 498A/324 IPC and against the third petitioner under
Section
498A
IPC,
was
filed
and
charges
were
framed
accordingly.
4.
During pendency of the trial, the fourth petitioner
(complainant) made a submission before the trial Court,
expressing her intention to settle the matter with the accused
persons. Further, in the meantime, the first petitioner, who had
eloped earlier with other woman, started living with the fourth
petitioner and also begot a child within the wedlock on
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
12.12.2015. All the petitioners, who are close relations, entered
into a compromise as recorded under „Deed of Compromise‟
dated 01.08.2016 annexed in the petition as Annexure-P4,
undertaking that the accused/petitioners will not do any
mischief, wrong, assault, hurt or commit any act of harm to the
fourth petitioner.
It was also agreed that a share of the
properties held by the third petitioner and his wife would be
given to the fourth petitioner. The accused/petitioners have
further undertaken to take proper care of the children and also
to provide proper education to them. Thus, the instant petition
is filed to quash the criminal proceedings, FIR and charge-sheet
therefor.
5.
Referring to the observations made by the Supreme
Court in Gian Singh vs. State of Punjab & Anr.1, Mr. A.
Moulik, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners,
would contend that to maintain peace, harmony and also to
uphold
the
family
fabrics,
the
proceedings may be quashed.
FIR
leading
to
criminal
The quashing of FIR and
criminal proceedings would be in the interest of settlement of
minor children and also the family to maintain peace and
tranquility.
6.
Joining learned Senior Counsel, Mr. J. B. Pradhan,
---------------------------------------1
(2012) 10 SCC 303
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
learned Public Prosecutor submits that since the husband and
wife have started living together and they have decided to live
peacefully, the criminal proceedings may be quashed in the
interest of family and society.
7.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties, examined the
submissions put forth by learned Senior Counsel for the parties
carefully, perused the pleadings and documents appended
thereto.
8.
On perusal of all the documents, it is manifest that
the petitioners are very close relations, namely, husband, wife,
brother-in-law, father-in-law.
The complaint was lodged after
the husband, first petitioner, ran away with other woman and
assault was made by the second and third petitioners on the
fourth petitioner.
9.
With
the
passage
of
time,
the
parties
settled
amicably, husband started living with wife and also a child was
born within the wedlock. Indisputably, there are three children,
who need proper care and education. Parties, particularly first,
second and the third petitioners, who are present in Court,
unequivocally stated that they will not do any mischief or wrong
in future, which may disturb the peace and harmony in the
family. The fourth petitioner will not be hurt by anyone.
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
10.
In the Deed of Compromise, it is clearly stated that
in the event the fourth petitioner is hurt by any party, she may
be free to take recourse to police help by lodging a complaint.
In the Court, the wife came forward and pleaded for relief in
favour of amicable settlement, which is taken on record.
The
accused/petitioners have filed one more Bond in the course of
the arguments signed by all of them to the following effect: “
BOND FOR GOOD BEHAVIOUR
WHEREAS We,
1.
Birendra Prasad,
Aged about 37 years,
Son of Shivji Prasad,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
2.
Bramadeo Prasad,
Aged about 26 years,
Son of Shivji Prasad,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
3.
Shivji Prasad,
Aged about 60 years,
Son of Jabab Ram Saha,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
the petitioner nos. 1 to 3 herein have been called upon to
enter into a bond to maintain good behavior with
petitioner no.4 i.e.
Smt. Sanju Devi,
Aged about 34 years,
Wife of Birendra Prasad,
Resident of Lall Bazar,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
and not to do any act that may cause harm or injury of
any nature to the petitioner no.4 in any manner
whatsoever in future.
We hereby bind ourselves to
maintain peace within the family and to comply with the
terms contained in the Deed of Compromise dated
1/8/2016 (Annexure-P4) in Crl.M.C. No.07/2017
(Birendra Prasad & others Vs. State of Sikkim).
We sign this Bond on this the 26th day of May, 2017 at
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
Petitioner nos. 1 to 3:
sd/1. Birendra Prasad,
sd/2. Bramadeo Prasad,
sd/3. Shivji Prasad.
“
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
11.
Considering all aspects of the matter, it is imperative
that the settlement arrived at between the parties be accepted
and criminal proceedings bearing G.R. Case No.129 of 2014
(State of Sikkim vs. Birendra Prasad and others) along with the
First Information Report (FIR) dated 20.11.2013 and chargesheet, pending on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, deserve consideration for quashing.
12.
A larger Bench of Supreme Court in Gian Singh vs.
State of Punjab & Anr.1, examining the correctness of the
decisions of the Supreme Court in B. S. Joshi & Ors. vs. State
of Haryana & Anr.2, Nikhil Merchant vs. Central Bureau of
Investigation & Anr.3
and Manoj Sharma vs. State &
Ors. 4 in reference made in Gian Singh vs. State of Punjab &
Anr. 5 settled the proposition of law as under:
“57.
Quashing of offence or criminal proceedings on
the ground of settlement between an offender and
victim is not the same thing as compounding of
offence. They are different and not interchangeable.
Strictly speaking, the power of compounding of offences
given to a court under Section 320 is materially
different from the quashing of criminal proceedings by
the High Court in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction. In
compounding of offences, power of a criminal court is
circumscribed by the provisions contained in Section
320 and the court is guided solely and squarely thereby
while, on the other hand, the formation of opinion by the
High Court for quashing a criminal offence or criminal
proceeding or criminal complaint is guided by the
---------------------------------------2
(2003) 4 SCC 675
(2008) 9 SCC 677
(2008) 16 SCC 1
(2010) 15 SCC 118
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
material on record as to whether the end of justice
would justify such exercise of power although the
ultimate consequence may be acquittal or dismissal of
indictment.
58.
Where the High Court quashes a criminal
proceeding having regard to the fact that the dispute
between the offender and the victim has been settled
although the offences are not compoundable, it does
so as in its opinion, continuation of criminal proceedings
will be an exercise in futility and justice in the case
demands that the dispute between the parties is put to
an end and peace is restored; securing the ends of
justice being the ultimate guiding factor. ………………”
13.
Subsequently, in Ashok Sadarangani & Anr. vs.
Union of India & Ors.6, referring to earlier decision rendered
by the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court observed as under:
“24.
Having carefully considered the facts and
circumstances of the case, as also the law relating to
the continuance of criminal cases where the complainant
and the accused had settled their differences and had
arrived at an amicable arrangement, we see no reason
to differ with the views that had been taken in Nikhil
Merchant case or Manoj Sharma case or the several
decisions that have come thereafter. It is, however, no
coincidence that the golden thread which runs through
all the decisions cited, indicates that continuance of a
criminal proceeding after a compromise has been
arrived at between the complainant and the accused,
would amount to abuse of the process of court and an
exercise in futility, since the trial could be prolonged and
ultimate, may conclude in a decision which may be of
any consequence to any of the other parties.”
14.
Applying the well-settled proposition of law, as
analyzed hereinabove to the facts of the case wherein the close
relationship of the complainant and accused/petitioners is
established, I am of
the
---------------------------------6
(2012) 11 SCC 321
considered opinion that this is a fit
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2017
Birendra Prasad & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
case wherein the discretion may be exercised to quash the
proceedings pending in the trial court.
15.
Resultantly, considering the totality of the fact in the
larger interest of peace, harmony and interest of minor children
of the first and fourth petitioners, criminal proceedings bearing
G.R. Case No.129 of 2014 (State of Sikkim vs. Birendra Prasad
and others) along with the First Information Report (FIR) dated
20.11.2013 and charge-sheet, therefor, pending on the file of
the Chief Judicial Magistrate, East Sikkim at Gangtok, are
hereby quashed.
16.
The petition is ordered accordingly.
Chief Justice
29.05.2017
Approved for Reporting
Internet
pm
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review