Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 6TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
PETITIONER:
BIOHOMES PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED
AGED 13 YEARS
REPRESENTED BY THE MANAGING DIRECTOR ARUN M.G,
OPP. GOVT. VOCATIONAL HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL,
THATTAMALA, KOLLAM, PIN - 691020
BY ADVS.
RANJITH VARGHESE
RAHUL VARGHESE
SANTHA VARGHESE
GEO KENNEDY K.
RANJAN BABU JOSEPH
K.L.VARGHESE (SR.)
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY SENIOR DIVISIONAL ENGINEER(CO-ORD),
SOUTHERN RAILWAY, DIVISIONAL OFFICE, WORKS BRANCH,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM., PIN - 695014
THE GENERAL MANAGER
SOUTHERN RAILWAY, SOUTHERN RAILWAY HEADQUARTERS,
PARK TOWN, CHENNAI, PIN - 600003
K.K. ANTONY
KALARIKKAL, KADAKKARAPALLY P.O., CHERTHALA,
ALLEPPEY, PIN - 688529
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
BY ADVS.
SHRIHARI RAO K
S.SHANAVAS KHAN
S.INDU(K/002856/1999)
KALA G.NAMBIAR(K/515/2006)
OTHER PRESENT:
DSGI SRI T C KRISHNA
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON
27.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
“C.R”
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 27th day of March, 2025
The petitioner is an ‘A’ Class contractor company
with ample experience in different types of construction
work. The petitioner had submitted its bid in response to
Ext.P2 tender invited by the 1st respondent for the
construction of the Iravipuram – Raising and extension
of Platform Nos. 1 & 2 and allied works. As per Ext. P3
tender document, the closing date of the tender was
18.11.2024 and the advertised value of the contract is
Rs.1,99,81,135.46. Clause 10 of Ext.P2 stipulates the
financial eligibility criteria. Subsequently, by Advance
Correction Slip No.1, Clause 10.2 of Ext.P2 was
corrected. As per the amended financial eligibility
criteria, the average annual contractual turnover has to
be calculated on the average of the total contractual
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
payments received in the previous three financial years,
as per the audited balance sheet. In case the balance
sheet is not prepared/audited, the audited balance sheet
of the fourth previous year can be considered for
calculating the average annual contractual turnover.
Since the petitioner’s audited balance sheet for the
previous year was not approved in the Annual General
Body meeting (‘AGM’, in short), they were not in a
position to submit the said document. The petitioner’s
average annual turnover for the past three years,
considering the fourth previous year audited balance
sheet, is Rs.2,36,38,978/-. However, respondents 1 and 2
have failed to consider the petitioner's
4 th previous
year's audited balance sheet. Despite the petitioner
satisfying the financial eligibility, the respondents 1 and
2 are taking hasty steps to award the contract to the 3 rd
respondent.. The action of respondents 1 and 2 is
tainted with mala fides and arbitrariness. Hence, the
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
writ petition.
2.
The
respondents
and
2 have
filed
a
statement contending that, in response to the tender,
they received five bids, including that of the petitioner.
The
petitioner
has
Rs.2,35,15,437.04.
quoted
However,
the
lowest
upon
price
evaluating
of
the
petitioner’s financial eligibility, it was noticed that the
petitioner had submitted the audited balance sheets for
the financial years (‘FY’) 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23.
There was no mention of the audited balance sheet for
the FY 2023-24 in the Annexure VI - B form. Accordingly,
the Convenor of the Tender sent Annexure R1(a) letter
to
the
Chartered
Accountant
who
issued
Ext.P4
certificate, to ascertain whether the auditing of the
balance sheet for the FY 2023-24 was completed. By
Annexure R1 (b) reply, the Chartered Accountant
confirmed that the auditing of the petitioner’s accounts
for the above FY was completed on 02.11.2024. The
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
petitioner submitted the bid on 08.11.2024. Since the
petitioner’s balance sheet for the FY 2023-24 was not
submitted with the tender, the Tender Committee
resolved to only accept the petitioner’s average annual
contractual turnover for the FYs 2021-22 and 2022-23.
The turnover for the two FYs is Rs.168,69,460.90, which
is far below the required minimum average turnover
stipulated
in
Ext.P3
advertised
value.
Hence,
the
petitioner has failed to satisfy the financial eligibility
criteria. The writ petition is devoid of any merits and
may be dismissed.
3. The petitioner has filed a reply affidavit
stating that, as per Clause 10.2 of Ext.P2, in case the
balance sheet of the previous year is yet to be
prepared/audited, the audited balance sheet of the
fourth previous year can be considered to calculate the
average
annual
contractual
turnover.
The
audited
balance sheet of the petitioner was adopted in the AGM
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
of the shareholders only on 21.12.2024, but the tender
was
submitted
on
18.11.2024.
In
the
above
circumstances, the audited balance sheet of the FY
2023-24 was not submitted. Nonetheless, if the fourth
previous
year’s
balance
sheet
is
considered,
the
petitioner will be duly qualified. Ext.P4 certificate was
produced in Annexure VI-B form along with the tender
documents. Hence, the writ petition may be allowed.
4. Heard: Sri. K.L. Varghese, the learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner, Sri. K. Shrihari Rao, the
learned Central Government Counsel for respondents 1
and 2, and Sri.Shanavas Khan, the learned counsel for
the third respondent.
5. The dispute in the writ petition fundamentally
concerns the interpretation of Clause 'A' of Advance
Correction Slip Number 1 of Ext.P2. It is apposite to
refer to the said clause, which reads as follows:
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
“10.2 Financial Eligibility Criteria.
The tenderer must have minimum average annual
contractual turnover of V/N or ‘V’ whichever is less where
V= Advertised value of the tender in crores of Rupees.
N= Number of years prescribed for completion of work
for which bids have been invited.
The average annual contractual turnover shall be
calculated as an average of “total contractual payments in
the previous three financial years, as per the audited
balance sheet. However, in case balance sheet of the
previous year is yet to be prepared/audited, the audited
balance sheet of the fourth previous year shall be
considered for calculating average annual contractual
turnover.
The tenderers shall submit requisite information as per
Annexure-VIB, along with copies of Audited Balance
Sheets
duly
certified
by
the
Chartered
Accountant/Certificate from Chartered Accountant duly
supported by Audited Balance Sheet”
(emphasis supplied)
6. The above clause provides that the average
annual contractual turnover is normally calculated on
the total contractual payments received in the previous
three financial years. Nevertheless, a specific exception
is carved out for the non-submission of the last financial
year’s
balance
sheet,
if
the
same
is
not
prepared/audited. In such an eventuality, the audited
balance sheet of the fourth previous year can be
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
considered.
7. The petitioner’s case is that, although their
Chartered Accountant had prepared the balance sheet
for the FY 2023-24 on 02.11.2024, the said audited
balance sheet was considered and adopted in the AGM
only on 21.12.2024. The tender was submitted on
18.11.2024. It was in the above context that the
petitioner submitted Ext.P4 certificate in Annexure VI B
form with the audited annual balance sheets for the FYs
2020-2021, 2021-2022 and 2022-23 to prove that the
petitioner had an average annual contract turnover of
Rs.2,36,38,978/- in the three years, thereby satisfying
the financial eligibility criteria.
8. The learned Counsel for respondents 1 and 2
vehemently argued that, as there is an explicit condition
in Ext.P2 that only the prepared/audited balance sheet
of the previous year needs to be produced, the
petitioner could have very well submitted the prepared
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
balance sheet for FY 2023-24, although it was not
adopted by the AGM.
9. I find the above argument to be naïve and
untenable because, under the Companies Act 2013, it is
imperative that the shareholders of the company have to
consider and adopt the audited balance sheet for it to be
valid in the eyes of the law. Therefore, the nonsubmission of the audited balance sheet for the FY 202324 by the petitioner, which was not considered and
adopted by the AGM, does not constitute a fatal
shortcoming warranting the non-acceptance of the
petitioner’s
fourth
previous
year’s
balance
sheet,
particularly in view of the unequivocal condition in
Ext.P2 Advance Correction Slip No.1.
10. Conversely,
for example, had the petitioner
submitted the unapproved audited balance sheet of FY
2023-24 before it was adopted, and the AGM later
pointed out certain corrections/modifications in the
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
balance sheet; the petitioner could potentially face
allegations for furnishing false information. It is in the
said background that the author of Ext.P2 tender has
provided a leeway in the tender conditions, i.e., to
submit the audited balance sheet of the fourth previous
year in the case the just previous year’s auditing is not
complete.
11. In Banshidhar Construction Private Limited v.
Bharat Coking Coal Limited and others [(2024) 10 SCC
273], the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that, even
though courts do not sit in appeal in the matter of award
of contracts. It may merely review how the decision was
taken.
Yet,
the
government/instrumentalities
decision
must
be
of
the
free
from
arbitrariness and must not be affected by bias or
actuated by mala fides.
12. Similarly, in Michigan Rubber (India) Limited v.
State of Karnataka and others [(2012) 8 SCC 216], the
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that the basic
requirement of Article 14 of the Constitution of India is
fairness in action by the State. Non-arbitrariness is the
essence and substance of the heartbeat of fair play.
These actions are amenable to judicial review, only if the
State is not acting whimsically for any ulterior purpose.
Before interfering in a tender or contractual matter, the
court should pose to itself whether the decision is
arbitrary or irrational.
13. On a comprehensive consideration of the facts,
materials on record and the rival submissions made
across the Bar, this Court is resolutely of the view that
the decision of respondents 1 and 2 to exclude the
petitioner’s audited balance sheet of the fourth previous
year is irrational and arbitrary. The respondents 1 and 2
ought to have accepted Ext.P4 certificate in Annexure VI
B form, which proves that the petitioner has an average
annual contractual turnover of Rs.2,36,38,978/- for the
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
last three years.
In light of the aforesaid circumstances, I allow
the writ petition by declaring that the petitioner satisfies
the
financial
eligibility
criteria,
and
directing
respondents 1 and 2 to accept the petitioner’s tender
and process it in accordance with the law.
SD/C.S.DIAS, JUDGE
jm/
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 9270/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF CERTIFICATE OF REGISTRATION
ISSUED BY THE KERALA WATER AUTHORITY
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PORTIONS OF
THE TENDER DOCUMENTS REQUIRED FOR THE
PURPOSE OF THE INSTANT CASE INCLUDING
CORRECTION SLIP NO. 1 UNDER SUBHEAD A
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE TENDER DOCUMENT
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF ANNUAL CONTRACTUAL TURNOVER
DATA CERTIFICATE
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE EXPERIENCE CERTIFICATE
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DT. 20.01.2025
SIGNED BY THE CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE
OFFICER OF IIITMK
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DT. 14.01.2025
ISSUED BY M/S N.S. PANICKER & CO
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DT. 24.02.2025
ISSUED BY THE PETITIONER TO THE 1ST
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF LEGAL OPINION DT.
22.02.2025 FROM THE COMPANY SECRETARY
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DT. 05.03.2025
ENCLOSING THE COMMUNICATION ISSUED BY
THE RESPONDENT DT. 17.01.2025 AND
RESPONSE BY THE PETITIONER DT.
17.01.2025
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF BALANCE SHEET AS AT 31ST
MARCH 2024 FORWARDED BY THE PETITIONER’S
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT FOR THE YEAR ENDING
31ST MARCH 2024, PROFIT AND LOSS
2025:KER:26632
WP(C) NO. 9270 OF 2025
STATEMENT AS ON 31ST MARCH 2024 SENT
ALONG WITH OTHER DETAILS
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE R1(A)
TUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 08.01.2025
OF THE CONVENER OF THE TENDER COMMITTEE
ADDRESSED TO THE CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT OF
THE PETITIONER
ANNEXURE R1(B)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 14.1.2025
WITH SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS
ANNEXURE R1(C)
TRUE COPY OF CLAUSE 10.2 OF THE GENERAL
CONDITIONS OF CONTRACT 2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
ADDL. EXHIBIT P12
TRUE COPY OF THE UPLOADED UDIN DOCUMENT
ADDL. EXHIBIT P13
TRUE COPY OF THE TABULATION STATEMENT OF
FINANCIAL BIDS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review