Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
PETITIONER:
BINU K THOMAS
AGED 43 YEARS
S/O. K V THOMAS, KUZHIKKATTIL HOUSE, PADICAP P.O.,
IDUKKI, PIN - 685561
BY ADVS.
DEEPA R MENON
MATHEW A KUZHALANADAN
KURIAKOSE VARGHESE
V.SHYAMOHAN
NABEEL B.A.
NIKITHA MARTHA GIJU
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, KERALA, PIN - 695001
KERALA HYDEL TOURISM CENTRE
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR VYDYUTHI BHAVAN,
PATTOM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
ANEESH P R
AGED 45 YEARS
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
FATHER'S NAME NOT KNOWN TO THE PETITIONER
PUTHUVAL HOUSE, PADNHARATHARA HOUSE, WAYANAD,
PIN - 673575
C H ASHRAF
AGED 50 YEARS
FATHER'S NAME NOT KNOWN TO THE PETITIONER
CHITTETHUKUDY HOUSE, ADIMALI P.O, IDUKKI, PIN 685561
BY ADVS.
LATHA ANAND
GIGIMON ISSAC
Jijo Paul Kallookkaran
POOJA P.O.(K/001621/2021)
JOSHY P.O.(K/71/2006)
C.SNEHA(K/000359/2022)
TOBIAS TOGI MATHEW(K/867/2018)
S.VISHNU (ARIKKATTIL)(K/986/2012)
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
ADMISSION ON 28.03.2025, THE
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
COURT ON THE SAME DAY
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
Dated this the 28th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The petitioner is the Director of the Company
named Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd. The petitioner has
been carrying out water sports activities at Munnar and
Banasurasagar Dam with the 2nd respondent ― the Kerala
Hydel Tourism Centre, on a revenue share basis for the
last two years. Meanwhile, the 2 nd respondent has
published
Ext.P4
tender
notice,
calling
for
eligible
operators to conduct the water sports activities in the
above two locations. The petitioner and the respondents 3
and 4 have submitted their bids. The petitioner is
confident of being awarded with the contract. The tender
proceedings has not been finalised.
While so, the 2nd
respondent has issued a notice to the petitioner to stop
the operations and vacate from the two locations on or
before 28.02.2025.
By Ext.P7 order, this Court
has
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
directed the parties to maintain status-quo till the tender
is finalised. Later, the 2nd respondent issued Ext.P8 letter
stating that the respondents 3 and 4 have been selected
and the presentation round would be conducted on
06.01.2025. The respondents 3 and 4 are ineligible to
participate in the tender because they have produced
fabricated documents. The 3rd respondent runs a tea shop
in the Sun-Moon Valley Boat Centre on a contract basis
with the 2nd respondent. He is in no way connected with
the company named Youngwind LLP.
Similarly, the 2nd
respondent has accepted the documents submitted by the
4th respondent without any application of mind. Ext.P8
document shows that a concern named New Periyar
Water Sports has submitted the bid. However, the
documents submitted along with the application are those
of the petitioner's company. The 4th respondent is in no
way
connected
with
the
petitioner’s
company.
The
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
petitioner has been conducting the operations to date.
Therefore,
the
4th
respondent
is
also
ineligible
to
participate in the tender. The action of the 2nd respondent
in accepting the bids of the respondents 3 and 4 is
actuated with mala fides and arbitrariness. Hence, the 2nd
respondent may be directed not to include respondents 3
and 4 in the tender, and declare that the petitioner is the
successful bidder.
2. The 2nd respondent has filed a counter affidavit
stating that the petitioner has no locus standi to file the
writ petition because he has not participated in the
tender. The evaluation process has been clearly explained
in clause 7 of Ext.P5. Marks have been awarded based on
each category. The 2nd respondent has adopted a liberal
approach and evaluated the bids. The petitioner and the
respondents 3 and 4 have qualified to the next round. The
3rd respondent has produced an experience certificate
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
issued by M/s.Youngwind LLP to prove his technical
capability. In the previous tender floated in 2022, the
petitioner company had participated in the tender and
was awarded the current tender on the strength of an
experience certificate issued by Basil Kuriakose. The
impugned tender is floated with the
same conditions.
Therefore, the document submitted by the 3 rd respondent
is sufficient to prove his eligibility.
The New Periyar
Water Sports is a newly established firm, and the
4 th
respondent
has
is
its
partner.
The
4 th
respondent
submitted the bid on behalf of the firm. The 4 th
respondent
and the petitioner are the Directors of M/s
Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd., the current contractor. It
was
the
4th
respondent
who
was
making
all
communications for the company with the 2nd respondent
and looking after to all the activities of the company. In
the present bid, both the petitioner and the fourth
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
respondent have claimed experience based on the current
contract entered between the 2nd respondent and Periyar
Water Sports (P) Ltd. In the said circumstances, the 2nd
respondent had accepted the technical bids of all three
parties. Therefore, the writ petition may be dismissed.
3. The third respondent has filed a counter affidavit
contending that he has obtained a consent letter from
Youngwind LLP, who has agreed to collaborate with him
to carry on his sports activities. The said course is
sufficient to participate in the tender in view of clause 5.5
of Ext.P5. Therefore, the writ petition may be dismissed.
4. The 4th respondent has filed a counter affidavit
contending
that the
petitioner
has
suppressed
the
material facts in the writ petition. In fact, it is New
Periyar Water Sports that has participated in the tender
and not the 4th respondent, although he is a partner of
the firm. The 4th respondent and the petitioner are
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
Directors of Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd. It is without any
approval from the Board of Directors of the company that
the petitioner has filed the present writ petition. The writ
petition is liable to be dismissed on the sole ground. The
4th respondent's firm is eligible to participate in the
tender due to the 4th respondent's experience as a
director in Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd.
The above
course is permitted by Clause 5.5 of Ext.P5. Therefore,
the writ petition may be dismissed.
5. The petitioner has filed reply affidavits refuting
the contentions raised by the respondents 2 to 4.
6. Heard; the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the learned Government Pleader, the learned Senior
Counsel for the 2nd
respondent and the respective
learned counsel for the respondents 3 and 4.
7. Ext.P5 tender has been floated by the 2nd
respondent,
inviting
tenders
for
the
selection
of
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
operators/agencies to operate water sports activities in
the Kerala Hydel Tourism Centres for two years. The
petitioner, New Periyar Water Sports and the third
respondent have submitted their bids in response to
Ext.P4 e-tender notice.
8. It is necessary to refer to relevant conditions in
clause 5 of Ext.P5 tender, which reads as follows:
“5. INSTRUCTIONS TO BIDDERS
5.1 Sealed Tenders are invited under Two-cover system
from reputed Water sports operators/Individuals having
support of professional staff with proven track record of
operating Water sports and who/which fulfill the Technical
and Financial capabilities as mentioned in this tender
document.
5.2
Tender
can
be
downloaded
from
www.etenders.kerala.gov.in. before the Bid Due Date. The
bidders are requested to submit the Tender fee of Rs. 2000/+ GST shall be remitted online to the account number given
in the remittance from provided by the e-procurement
system for this particular tender only. Only NEFT/SBI
internet Banking/RTGS/ are allowed as mode of payment.
5.3 The Bidder shall carefully go through the
requirements and prepare the required documents to be
uploaded.
5.4 Bids should be submitted on or before the Bid Due
Date and should be in the prescribed BOQ forms/formats as
mentioned in this Tender. Bids not in the prescribed
forms/formats will be summarily rejected.
5.5 Bidders shall fulfill Financial Capability while Bidders
are allowed to associate with individual/Organization/Agency
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
for meeting the Technical Requirements. However the bidder
shall mention such arrangements in the bid with the
necessary consent letter from such associates with necessary
documents.
5.6 Bids must be accompanied with the following
documents: (duly signed and scanned)
(i) Documentary proof, where applicable, as evidence of
satisfaction of the Technical and
(ii) A copy of the Tender Downloaded by the Bidder with
each page manually signed by the Bidder or by an
authorized signatory (in case of authorized signatory a
certified true copy of the resolution authorizing the
signatory to sign the Tender shall have to be enclosed);
(iii) Copies of all tax registrations; and
(iv) In case of individuals, a certified true copy (attested by
a notary) of identity proof. Acceptable identity proofs are
Indian passports, Voter IDs and/or Ration Cards.
(v)Details of previous experience.
(vii)All other relevant documents as per clause 5.1.
***
***
***
***”
9. Clause 5.1, extracted above, permits water
sports
operators/individuals
having
the
support
of
professional staff with a proven track record of operating
water
sports
and
who
fulfil
the
technical
and
financial bids to be eligible to submit the bids. Similarly,
clause 5.5 permits the Bidders to associate with an
individual/Organization/Agency to meet the technical
requirements.
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
10. The New Periyar Water Sports had submitted its
bid since its partner ― the 4th respondent ― is also
the Director of Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd, has gained
sufficient
experience
through
the
current
contract.
Similarly, the 3rd respondent has produced Ext.R3(a)
consent letter from Youngwind LLP, who consented to
give all support to the 3rd respondent to take up the work.
Likewise, Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd has participated in
the bid on the basis on its current experience.
11. Therefore, as rightly contended by the 4 th
respondent, the petitioner does not have the locus standi
to challenge the tender in his individual capacity because
he has not individually participated in the tender. Even
otherwise, when the author of the tender has found
respondents 3 and 4 to be suitably qualified on the basis
of support letters and previous experience and 4 th
respondent's experience as the Director of Periyar Water
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
Sports (P) Ltd,
a rank outsider cannot question the 2 nd
respondent’s wisdom in the matter.
12. After evaluating the technical bids of three
bidders, the second respondent has found all of them to
be qualified as per clause 5 of Ext.P5. Accordingly, the
second respondent has proceeded to the next rounds, and
ultimately found, as per Ext.R2(J) score sheet, that New
Periyar Water Sports is the successful bidder. The firm is
not a party to the writ petition. Therefore, the writ
petition has to fail on the said ground.
13. In Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa and others
[(2007) 14 SCC 517, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed that evaluating tenders and awarding contracts
are essentially commercial functions. Principles of equity
and natural justice stay at a distance. If the decision
relating to the award of the contract is bona fide and is in
the public interest, courts will not, in exercising the
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
power of judicial review, interfere even if a procedural
aberration or error in assessment or prejudice to a
tenderer is made out.
14. In Afcons Infrastructure
Ltd v. Nagpur Metro
Rail Corporation Ltd. And Another [(2016) 16 SCC
818], the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that the
constitutional Courts must defer to the understanding
that the employer of a project having authored the tender
documents,
is
the
best
person
to
understand
and
appreciate the requirements and interpret the documents
unless
there
is
mala
fides
or
perversity
in
the
understanding or applying the terms of the tender
conditions. It is possible that the owner or employer of a
project
may
give
an
interpretation
to
the
tender
documents that is not acceptable to the constitutional
Courts, but that by itself is not a reason for interfering
with the interpretation given.
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
15. Likewise, in Silppi Constructions Contractors v.
Union of India
and another [(2020) 16 SCC 489], the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that the authority
which floats the contract or tender and has authored the
tender documents is the best judge as to how the
documents have to be interpreted. If two interpretations
are possible then author’s interpretation is to be accepted
16. In the case at hand, the author of the tender
states that in the 2022 tender, which had the same
conditions, the 2nd respondent awarded the tender to
Periyar Water Sports (P) Ltd on the strength of a support
letter from a third party. In the present tender, the 2nd
respondent has found that all three participants are
qualified, and consequentially has proceeded to the
subsequent rounds and found the financial bid offered by
the New Periyar Water Sports to be the most competitive
bid. Accordingly, the contract has been awarded to the
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
said firm. It is not for this Court to sit in appeal over the
said decision and take a divergent view. This Court does
not find any element of mala fides or arbitrariness in the
whole process.
On an overall evaluation of the pleadings and
materials on record, this Court is of the view that the writ
petition sans substance or merits and is only to be
dismissed. Consequentially, I do so.
SD/rmm/28/3/2025
C.S.DIAS, JUDGE
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 9023/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE LICENSE AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE PETITIONER AND 2ND
RESPONDENT FOR ENTIRE LAND AROUND
MALABAR CIRCUIT NUMBERED AS
17/KHTC/HQ/2022-2023 DATED 17.10.2022
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE LICENSE AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE PETITIONER AND 2ND
RESPONDENT FOR ENTIRE LAND AROUND
MUNNAR CIRCUIT NUMBERED AS
10/KHTC/HQ/2022-2023 DATED 29.08.2022
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
2ND RESPONDENT NUMBERED KHTC/HQ/DB
12024-25 DATED 21.11.2024
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE TENDER NOTICE ISSUED
BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT NUMBERED AS
18/KHTC/ HQ /2024-25 DATED 06.01.2025
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
E-TENDER SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER’S
COMPANY DATED 20.01.2025
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
2ND RESPONDENT NUMBERED KHTC/HQ/
DB1/2024-25 DATED 24.02.2025
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER IN WP(C)
NO. 7919 OF 2025 DATED 28.02.2025
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
2ND RESPONDENT NUMBERED AS
KHTC/HQ/DB1/2024-25/51 DATED 28.02.2025
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
TENDER APPLICATION AND DOCUMENTS
SUBMITTED BY 3RD RESPONDENT NUMBERED
AS E TENDER NO 18/KHTC/HQ/2024-25 DATED
06.01.2025
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE LIMITED LIABILITY
PARTNERSHIP INFORMATION OF YOUNGWIND
LLP ISSUED BY MINISTRY OF CORPORATE
AFFAIRS DATED 24.02.2025
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF ETENDER SUBMITTED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT DATED 28.01.2025
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT SUBMITTED
BY THE PETITIONER TO THE 2ND
RESPONDENT DATED 03.03.2025
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R 4 ( 1)
true copy of the Bid Submission Conformation
dated 28-01-2025,
Exhibit R 4 ( 2)
true copy of the registration certificate issued by
the Registrar of Firms, dated 27-01-2025
Exhibit R 4 (4)
true copy of the Company Information extracted
from the website for the Ministry of Corporate
Affairs, dated 04-03-2025
Exhibit R 4 (5)
True copy of the certificate No. BSHTC/DB01/2024-25 dated 24-01-2025
Exhibit R 4 (6)
True Copy of the certificate No.
KHTC/MNR/GNL/2024-25-25/837 dated 25-012025, issued by the Senior Manager of the Kerala
Hydel Tourism Centre, Munnar Circuit
Exhibit R 4 (7)
True copy of the certificate of experiences issued
by the officer on Special Duty, Kerala Hydel
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
Tourism Centre, Banasura Sagar Dam, Wayanad,
dated 29-01-2025
Exhibit R 4 (8)
true copy of the letter No 03/RTI/25/KMGM dated
10-02-2025, issued by the Public Information
Officer Kothamangalam Police Station to one
Sajeev MK is along with its typed copy
Exhibit R 4 ( 3)
True copy of Partnership deed
Exhibit R2(d)
True copy of the GST registration certificate
dated 24/08/2022
Exhibit R2(e)
True copy of the certificate of networth of Mr.
Basil Kuriakose, along with the bid submission
confirmation dated 12/07/2022
Exhibit R2(f)
True copy of the communication dated
23/07/2024 issued by the 4th respondent on
behalf of M/s Periyar Water Sports Pvt Ltd
Exhibit R2(g)
True copy of the Minutes of the Meeting dated
17/12/2022, showing the participation of the 4th
respondent
Exhibit R2(i)
True copy of the report dated 30.04.2024 by the
Vigilance Department of the KSEB
Exhibit R2(j)
True copy of the final scoresheet
Exhibit R2(a)
True copy of the relevant page of the agreement
dated 26/02/2020 between Assistant Executive
Engineer , PVIP Subdivision and Mr. Basil
Kuriakose
Exhibit R2(b)
True copy of the tender conditions pertaining to
E-tender 15/KHTC/HQ/2022-23 dated 29.06.2022
Exhibit R2(c)
True copy of the certificate of incorporation
pertaining to the petitioner s company
2025:KER:27060
WP(C) NO. 9023 OF 2025
Exhibit R2(h)
True copy of the complaint dated 12/02/2025 filed
by one Ms Sajitha Thankappan
Exhibit R3(a)
True copy of the consent letter dated 18/1/2025
issued by Youngwind LLP partnership firm in
favour of this respondent
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review