The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. 05.1999 with the vendor (Mahendra Kanhar) endorsing his signature and the date on the body of the deed. As there was no permission on that date, the deed was obviously not valid. But as on 18.09.1999, that is, the date of its registration, permission had been granted. It is to be noted that ordinarily, a document conveying title takes effect from the date of its execution but when it involves the member of the Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe the same cannot be held to be valid unless it is preceded by permission from the competent authority. So, till permission is obtained a document, even if executed, remains a paper transaction only without bearing any legal effect and becomes valid only from the date permission is granted. The doctrine of relating back in the present case cannot therefore, be applied and the sale must be held to have been validly made only on 18.09.1999 that is, after granting of the permission. The fact of grant of permission has also been inserted subsequently on the body of the sale deed and the subsequent signature of the presenter (Mahendra Kanhar) bears the date 18.09.1999. The doctrine of relating back can be applied only if the document was executed validly in the eye of law at the relevant time.
15. For the foregoing reasons therefore, the contentions raised on behalf of the petitioners are unacceptable for which, this Court is not persuaded to interfere with the impugned orders.
16. In the result, the Writ Petition is dismissed. ..……..…………………. (Sashikanta Mishra), Judge The High Court of Orissa, Cuttack 23rdJuly, 2026 Puspanjali Ghadai, Jr. Stenographer Designation: Junior Stenographer Reason: Authentication Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.7385 of 2020
(An application under Articles 226 and 227 of Constitution of
India)
Binodini Mallick & Another
.....
Petitioners
-VersusAdditional District Magistrate,
Kandhamal & Others
.....
Opp. Parties
W.P.(C) No.34890 of 2025
Binodini Mallick @ Kanhar
& Another
.....
Petitioners
-VersusState of Odisha & Others
.....
Opp. Parties
_______________________________________________________
For Petitioners
: Mr. G.N. Mishra, Sr. Advocate
Mrs. P.P. Mohanty, Advocate
For Opp. Parties
: Mr. S.N. Patnaik,
[Addl. Government Advocate]
Mr. A.K. Panda, Advocate
[Opp. Party No.3]
_______________________________________________________
CORAM:
JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA
JUDGMENT
23rd July, 2026
SASHIKANTA MISHRA, J.
Order dated 31.12.2005 passed by the Sub-Collector,
Kandhamal in R.M.C. No.8 of 2005 and order dated 11.06.2009
passed by the Additional District Magistrate (ADM), Kandhamal
in R.M.A. No.4 of 2007 are impugned in the present Writ
Petition.
BRIEF FACTS
2.
The case land situates in Mouza-Jiringipada in
Kandhamal district appertaining to Plot No.643 under Khata
No.140 measuring area H0.02OR. Originally, the property stood
recorded in the name of one Srikar Kanhar. After his death, his
son namely, Mahendra Kanhar inherited the property and
possessed the same. A sale deed was executed and registered by
said Mahendra Kanhar on 22.05.1999 in respect of the case
land, transferring the same in favour of the present Opposite
Party No.3 for consideration. According to the petitioners, who
are the daughter and widow of said Mahendra Kanhar, the sale
deed was executed by practising fraud and without delivery of
possession. Further, there was no legal necessity to sell the
land but Mahendra Kanhar being a drunkard, was influenced to
do so. That apart, though Mahendra Kanhar belongs to the
Scheduled Tribe (Kandha) and the Opposite Party No.3 belongs
to General Caste, no permission under Section 3(1) of the
Orissa Scheduled Areas Transfer of Immovable Property (By
Scheduled Tribes) Regulation of 1956 (for short, Regulation) was
obtained from the competent authority. A proceeding was
initiated by the Sub-Collector, Kandhamal under Section 3-B (3)
of the Regulation for enquiry into the genuineness of the
transaction. Without appreciating the matter in its proper
perspective, the Sub-Collector, by order dated 31.12.2025
closed the case. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioners preferred
appeal before the Additional District Magistrate, which also
came to be dismissed. According to the petitioners, the recorded
owner was made to sign the sale deed on 22.05.1999 by
practising fraud but the permission to sell the property was
granted only on 15.09.1999. As such, there was no prior
permission of the competent authority as required under the
Regulation for which the sale transaction is void. Subsequent
grant of permission cannot legalize the transfer. The above
aspects, according to the petitioners were not considered by
both the authorities below. The petitioners have therefore, filed
this Writ Petition seeking the following relief.
“It is therefore, prayed that this Hon’ble Court may
be graciously please to admit the writ petition, issue
notice to the Opposite Parties call for the LCR and after
hearing the parties set aside the impugned orders
dated 31.12.2005 and dated 11.06.2009 under
Annexure-6 and 7 and may pass such other
order/orders as deemed just and proper.
And for this act of kindness, the petitioner shall as
in duty bound ever pray.”
3.
The State has not filed any counter but learned
State counsel preferred to make oral arguments.
4.
Counter affidavit has been filed by the Opposite
Party No.3. It is stated that because of legal necessity Mahendra
Kanhar decided to sell the land in question and thus
approached the Opposite Party No.3. He applied for necessary
permission before the Sub-Collector, Kandhamal, which was
granted by order dated 16.09.1999. The sale deed was executed
and registered on 18.09.1999 that is, after grant of permission,
payment of consideration and delivery of possession. The
Opposite Party No.3 has peacefully possessed the land ever
since. She also filed a return before the Sub-Collector,
Kandhamal under Section 3(B) (1) of Amendment Regulation (1)
of 2002 leading to registration of R.M.C No.8 of 2005. The SubCollector, after verifying the documents and recording the
statement of Mahendra Kanhar, Opposite Party No.3 and other
witnesses, allowed the case. The petitioners preferred appeal
before the A.D.M but the same was also dismissed after
considering the materials on record. It is also stated that the
petitioners created disturbance in the peaceful possession of
Opposite Party No.3 in 2002 for which, she initiated a
proceeding under Section 144 of Cr.P.C. vide M.C. No.118 of
2002, wherein her possession was confirmed.
5.
The petitioners also filed a suit being T.S. No.2 of
2001 in the Court of learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Phulbani
challenging the validity of the sale deed but the same was
dismissed vide judgment dated 18.08.2004. Said judgment was
challenged in appeal being R.F.A. No.6/2009/ 26 of 2006 in the
Court of learned Adhoc Additional District Judge, Fast Track
Court-II, Kandhamal, which was also dismissed vide judgment
dated 26.02.2010. The petitioners had filed a Writ Petition being
W.P.(C) No.6769 of 2010 before this Court but the same was
dismissed vide order dated 06.11.2019 on the submission of no
instruction with liberty granted to file fresh Writ Petition, if any
further cause of action arises. According to the Opposite Party
No.3 no fresh cause of action has arisen for which, the present
Writ Petition is not maintainable.
6.
Heard Mr. G.N. Mishra, learned Senior counsel
with Mrs. P.P. Mohanty, learned counsel for the Petitioners; Mr.
S.N. Patnaik, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
State and Mr. A.K. Panda, learned counsel for the Opposite
Party No.3.
7.
Mr. Mishra would argue that both the authorities
below have failed to appreciate the vital fact that the sale deed
was executed on 22.05.1999, though it was subsequently
registered on 18.09.1999. Permission under the Regulation was
granted on 16.09.1999. So, as on 22.05.1999, there was no
permission of the competent authority for sale of the land for
which, the entire transaction is void as per the provisions of
Regulation. Mr. Mishra further submits that even otherwise, the
petitioners are admittedly the daughter and widow of the
recorded owner Mahendra Kanhar. Since the property in
question is their ancestral property, they have a valid share over
it, ignoring which the property could not have been sold.
8.
Mr.
Patnaik,
learned
Additional
Government
Advocate on the other hand, would submit that the competent
authority granted permission in favour of the recorded owner to
sell the property to Opposite Party No.3 on 16.09.1999 and the
property was actually sold with registration of the sale deed
being done on 18.09.1999. The Sub-Collector as well as the
A.D.M had taken note of this fact and accordingly held the sale
transaction to be valid. Findings of the civil Court in the civil
suit and appeal filed by the petitioners have also been taken
into account.
9.
Mr. Panda, learned counsel for Opposite Party
No.3, on the other hand would submit that the Writ Petition is
not maintainable being barred by res-judicata. He submits that
on the same cause of action, the petitioners had filed the earlier
Writ Petition, which was dismissed on the submission of ‘no
instruction’ by their counsel but liberty was granted to file fresh
Writ Petition, if any further cause of action arises. Mr. Panda
further submits that all the revenue authorities as well as the
competent civil Courts have ruled in favour of the Opposite
Party No.3 concurrently after considering the evidence and
materials placed before them. There is therefore, no justified
reason for this Court to interfere with the impugned orders.
10.
As regards the question of maintainability of the
present writ application, this Court finds that in the earlier Writ
Petition being W.P.(C) No.6769 of 2010, the relief claimed is
identical to the one claimed in the present Writ Petition.
Undisputedly, the Writ Petition was dismissed for want of
instruction. Liberty was granted to file fresh writ petition if
further cause of action arises. Thus, ex-facie, there is force in
the submission of Mr. Panda that the present Writ Petition filed
on identical cause of action cannot be entertained. But then,
the above referred order of this Court passed in the earlier Writ
Petition was on the submission of the learned counsel for the
petitioner that he had no instruction in the matter. The Writ
Petition was therefore, dismissed on such ground. Needless to
mention, there was no adjudication on merits but the matter
was dismissed on the technical ground of ‘no instruction’. This
Court is therefore, of the view that dismissal of the earlier Writ
Petition, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case
shall not operate as res-judicata.
11.
Coming to the merits of the case, this being a
certiorari
proceeding
this
Court
would
like
to
keep
in
perspective the law relating to the limitations on exercise of
such jurisdiction by this Court vis-à-vis orders passed by the
quasi-judicial authorities. It is well settled that the Court
issuing a writ of certiorari acts in exercise of supervisory and
not appellate jurisdiction, which implies that the Court will not
review findings of fact recorded by the inferior Court or Tribunal
even if appears to be erroneous. The judgment of the
constitution Bench of the Supreme Court passed in the case of
Hari Viswa Kamakha Vrs. Ahamad Ishaque1, may be
referred to wherein it was held that a writ of certiorari under
Article 226 of the Constitution can be issued only when there is
a failure of justice by error in jurisdiction or breach of principles
of natural justice. Reference may also be had in this regard to
AIR 1955 SC 233
the case of Santhalal Gupta Vrs. Modern Co-operative Group
Housing Society Limited.2
12.
Coming to the facts of the present case, it is seen
that the challenge by the petitioners are to the orders passed by
the Sub-Collector, Kandhamal exercising jurisdiction under
Section 3B-3 of the Amended Regulation (1) of 2002 and the
A.D.M., Kandhamal under Section 3(3) of Regulation 2 of 1956.
Perusal of the impugned order reveals that both the authorities
have based their findings on the basis of the evidence and
materials placed before them. Nothing has been placed before
this Court to show as to what error of jurisdiction the said
authorities committed in passing the impugned orders. It has
also not been shown as to how the concurrent factual findings
are erroneous being perverse or not in consonance with the
evidence on record. This Court therefore, finds no justified
reason to interfere with the factual findings rendered by the
authorities below.
13.
Nevertheless, a point of law having been raised, this
Court deems it proper to examine the same. It is argued that by
2010 13 SCC 336
applying the doctrine of relating back the date of execution of
the sale deed must be deemed to be 22.05.1999. Admittedly, on
that date there being no permission granted by the competent
authority under the Regulation, the sale deed registered on
18.09.1999 has to be treated as invalid.
14.
This Court is not impressed with the above
argument. This is for the reason that Section 3 of the
Regulation
is mandatory in the absence of which, the
transaction is rendered invalid. It is borne out from the
materials on record that the sale deed was scribed on
22.05.1999 with the vendor (Mahendra Kanhar) endorsing his
signature and the date on the body of the deed. As there was no
permission on that date, the deed was obviously not valid. But
as on 18.09.1999, that is, the date of its registration,
permission had been granted. It is to be noted that ordinarily, a
document conveying title takes effect from the
date of its
execution but when it involves the member of the Scheduled
Caste or Scheduled Tribe the same cannot be held to be valid
unless it is preceded by permission from the competent
authority. So, till permission is obtained a document, even if
executed, remains a paper transaction only without bearing any
legal effect and becomes valid only from the date permission is
granted. The doctrine of relating back in the present case
cannot therefore, be applied and the sale must be held to have
been validly made only on 18.09.1999 that is, after granting of
the permission. The fact of grant of permission has also been
inserted subsequently on the body of the sale deed and the
subsequent signature of the presenter (Mahendra Kanhar) bears
the date 18.09.1999. The doctrine of relating back can be
applied only if the document was executed validly in the eye of
law at the relevant time.
15.
For the foregoing reasons therefore, the contentions
raised on behalf of the petitioners are unacceptable for which,
this Court is not persuaded to interfere with the impugned
orders.
16.
In the result, the Writ Petition is dismissed.
..……..………………….
(Sashikanta Mishra),
Judge
The High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
23rdJuly, 2026 Puspanjali Ghadai, Jr. Stenographer
Digitally Signed
Signed by: PUSPANJALI GHADAI
Designation: Junior Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Date: 24-Jul-2026 11:22:39
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review