Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 / 10
2026:CGHC:1983
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ALFIZA
BAIG
Digitally
signed by
ALFIZA BAIG
Date:
2026.01.15
14:03:12
+0530
WPS No. 13184 of 2025
Binita Ekka W/o Utara Kumar Ekka Aged About 31 Years Posted As
Sweeper/attendant Cum Chowkidar At Veterinary Dispensary Urba Block
Tamnar, Distt. Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary Livestock Development
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Naya Raipur, Distt. Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Veterinary Services, Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
-
Deputy
Director
Veterinary
Services,
Raigarh,
Distt.
Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
... Respondents
For Petitioner
: Mr. Mateen Siddiqui, Advocate
For State
:
Mrs. Akanksha Verma Dabadhker, Panel lawyer
S.B.: Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
Order on Board
13/01/2026
1.
Petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking following reliefs:
2 / 10
“10.1 That the Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to quash
the order dated 08.05.2025 (Annexure P/1) issued by the
Deputy Director, Veterinary Services, Raigarh.
10.2 That, the Hon’ble Court kindly be pleased to direct the
respondent state to reinstate the services of the petitioner on
the post of Sweeper/Attendant-cum-Chowkidar.
10.3 To kindly grant any other writ/writs, order/orders,
relief/reliefs in favour of the petitioner, which the Hon’ble
Court deemed fit and just in the facts and circumstances of
the case, including awarding of the costs of the petitioner.”
2.
Learned counsel for petitioner submits that the case of petitioner is
purely covered by order passed by this Court in WPS No. 11772 of
2025 connected with other matters dated 05.01.2026 and, therefore,
this case can also be disposed of at admission stage.
3.
Learned counsel for State do not dispute the submission made by
learned counsel for petitioner.
4.
In view of the aforementioned facts of the case, the case is heard
finally with the consent of counsels of both the respective parties.
5.
Facts of the case are that an advertisement was issued on 29.02.2012
by Deputy Director, Veterinary Services i.e. respondent no. 3 for filing
up the post of Sweeper/Attendant-cum-Chowkidar. Advertisement
issued by respondent no. 3 came to be amended and amendment was
published on 09.05.2012 mentioning that appointment is to be made
based on the written examination. Petitioner participated in due
procedure of recruitment formulated by respondent no. 3 in the
advertisement and got selected. Select list published by respondents
department was put to challenge by one of the private candidate by
making complaint raising allegation of irregularities committed by
3 / 10
authorities in selection process. Collector, Raigarh considering the
complaint submitted by private candidate, issued letter to the Deputy
Director, Veterinary Services, upon which, respondent no. 3 enquired
into the matter and submitted report to the Collector. Petitioners, were
served with show cause notice based on the enquiry report submitted
by respondent no. 3. Petitioners submitted reply to the show cause
notice, however, without considering the reply to the show cause
notice, appointment of petitioners were cancelled and thereafter they
preferred writ petition bearing WPS No. 4441 of 2012, which was
disposed of vide order dated 28.04.2023 setting aside the order dated
27.09.2012 cancelling appointment of petitioners along with others and
directed the authorities to issue fresh show cause notice and to
examine
case
of
petitioners
therein
individually.
Respondents
authorities thereafter issued show cause notice on 06.09.2024.
Petitioners filed reply and thereafter second show cause notice was
issued on 04.10.2024, which was also replied. After submission of
reply by petitioners, respondents authorities have passed the order
Annexure P-1 dated 08.05.2025 holding the recruitment proceedings to
be void and cancelled the appointment of petitioners and other persons
appointed pursuant to the recruitment proceedings based on the
advertisement dated 29.02.2012, which is put to challenge in this writ
petition.
6.
Learned counsel for petitioner would submit that petitioner has put to
challenge the order dated 27.09.2012 cancelling appointment of
petitioners along with oters in WPS No. 4441 of 2012 and upon
considering the grounds raised in that writ petition, this Court passed
an interim order of stay and further directed that petitioner shall be
4 / 10
allowed to continue in service. Petitioner thereafter continued in his
service till passing of order Annexure P-1 dated 08.05.2025. She also
contended that as petitioner has completed about 13 years of service,
therefore, he has acquired the status of permanent employee. In the
aforementioned, facts of the case, if any, action is to be taken against
petitioner like removal from service, then respondent authority could
have invoked the provisions under Chhattisgarh Civil Services
(Classification and Control) Rules, 1966 by initiating the departmental
enquiry against him, which has not been done, therefore, the order
Annexure P-1 dated 08.05.2025 is per-se illegal and bad.
7.
Learned State counsel while opposing the submission of learned
counsel for petitioners would submit that after passing of an order in
the aforementioned writ petition dated 28.04.2023, respondents issued
two show cause notices to each of petitioners, to which the petitioners
have replied and after considering the reply submitted by petitioners
based on the enquiry report, authorities have arrived at a conclusion
that at the time of recruitment proceedings, reservation roster has not
been followed. Post for scheduled caste candidate women, ex-service
men and physically handicapped candidate has not been reserved. He
also pointed out that authorities also revealed that in the advertisement
only 32 posts were advertised, however 44 candidates were appointed
based on the said advertisement, therefore, the order Annexure P-10 is
passed following due process of law granting opportunity of hearing to
petitioners. There is no merit in these writ petitions. He submits that
specific plea is taken in reply that even after petitioners continued in
their work pursuant to the interim order, they were not confirmed in
their services, therefore, submission of learned counsel for petitioners
5 / 10
that order Annexure P-10 is bad in law as petitioners have been
removed from service without conducting any departmental enquiry, is
not correct.
8.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents enclosed along with writ petition.
9.
It is not in dispute that earlier petitioners' appointments were cancelled
vide order dated 27.09.2012, whereby appointment of all 44
appointees were cancelled. Said order of cancellation of appointments
was put to challenge in WPS No. 4441 of 2012. Writ petition was finally
disposed of on 28.04.2023, wherein the Coordinate Bench of this Court
has made following observation :"12. The petitioners in order to substantiate their stand have
filed copy of orders passed by the Session Court discharging
the Evaluators/examinors of the offence against them, who
evaulated the answer sheets of the petitioners, and have
taken a stand in their defence that no irregularities or
manipulations were done in the answer sheets and justified
their selection on the aforesaid post. True it is that some
irregularities/ manipulations were found by the Enquiry
Officer in the selection of the petitioners on the aforesaid
post and there appears lack of transparency and non
following of reservation policy, more particularly against the
32 advertised posts, 44 appointments were done and the
mode of selection was also changed subsequently by way of
amended advertisement, but despite the same, the whole
select list should not have been cancelled and instead, the
candidate, whose selection would have been found to be
invalid and illegal, only his/her selection should have been
cancelled individually and there might be some candidates
who would have been selected genuinely.
13. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 27.09.2012 is
liable to be and is hereby set aside. However, keeping in
mind the irregularities done in the selection process of the
petitioner and other selected candidates as well as the
conduct of the selection committee, the respondent
authorities are directed to issue fresh show cause notice to
the petitioner and conduct fresh inquiry into the matter and if
6 / 10
after the inquiry into the matter and if after the inquiry the
selection of any of the petitioner or any other selected
employee is found illegal and invalid, he or she be removed
from service.”
10.
Perusal of the aforementioned extracted portion of order passed in
WPS No.4441 of 2012 would show that this Court has made
categorical observation that whole select list should not have been
cancelled and instead the candidate whose selection would have been
found to be invalid and illegal, only his/her selection should have been
cancelled individually and there might be some candidates who would
have been selected genuinely.
11.
From the aforementioned quoted portion of order, it is crystal clear that
this Court while allowing writ petition has made clear observation that
there is no requirement of cancelling entire list of appointments but
appointment of each of appointees is to be considered individually to
arrive at a conclusion whether particular candidate has been appointed
by giving undue favour or not, even if there is irregularity whether
particular candidate has been benefited with the said irregularity or not.
There was further direction in the above order that fresh show cause
notice is to be issued to each of candidates/appointees.
12.
Though fresh show cause notice was issued granting opportunity to the
appointees along with petitioners to submit reply to the show cause
notice. However, from the order (Annexure P-10) it is not revealing that
authorities have done exercise to consider the appointment of
appointees individually whether their appointment can fall or can be
said to be benefited by any favour etc., but the respondents have only
considered that in recruitment process, the authorities have done some
irregularity in not reserving post for women, ex-service man and
7 / 10
physically handicapped candidates and further that appointment of 44
candidates has been made against 32 posts advertised.
13.
Along with reply, respondents have submitted enquiry report dated
04.03.2025 conducted by five member committee pursuant to the
directives of respondent No.3. In para-1 of the enquiry report, the team
conducting enquiry have observed that initially applications from
aspirants were called till 26.03.2012 and by way of amendment in
advertisement dated 16.05.2012 published it is mentioned that three
posts are reserved for women but amendment appears to be unpurposeful as the date for submitting the application has not been
extended. Report submitted by members conducting enquiry have not
considered that pursuant to the post advertised, both the categories i.e.
male and female can submit application for appointment and from list
of candidates whose appointments were cancelled it appears that
woman candidates have also submitted application and they were also
appointed. Appointments of woman on the reserved post can be made
from the applicants, who have already submitted their application,
therefore, the said grounds for cancelling the entire appointment made
in teeth of the order passed by this Court in WPS No.4441 of 2012 is
not correct and sustainable. Further this Court has granted opportunity
to respondents authorities to examine the genuineness of appointment
of candidates individually meaning thereby it is for the respondents
authorities to consider the appointment of each of candidates
independently whether appointees including petitioners were benefited
directly even if there is some irregularities found to been committed by
authorities and officials of respondents department. There is no specific
finding recorded by the authorities in this regard.
8 / 10
14.
Order passed in WPS No.4441 of 2012 dated 28.04.2023 is not put to
challenge by respondents-departments, therefore, the order dated
28.04.2023 has attend finality and respondents have to initiate further
proceedings strictly in accordance with observation and directions of
the order dated 28.04.2023 passed in WPS No.4441 of 2012.
15.
Perusal of the impugned order dated 08.05.2025 would show that
respondents authorities have considered that irregularities have been
committed in initiating the recruitment proceedings and appointing 44
persons as Clause - IV employee, in particularly that posts were not
reserved for women scheduled caste category candidates, ex-service
man and physically handicapped candidates and further that select list
is not published in newspaper calling claim and objections.
16.
So far as the reservation for women is concerned, in the advertisement
by way of amendment, three posts were reserved for one category.
Even in the post advertisement, it is not mentioned that only male
persons is to be appointed, therefore, it was open for both the
candidates i.e. male and female to submit an application and after
making an amendment in the advertisement, from the woman
candidates applied, three posts reserved for women candidates can be
filled up, therefore, the said finding recorded by the authorities on non
reserving post for women is erroneous, is not sustainable.
17.
So far as the submission of calling claim and objections publishing
select list in the newspaper is concerned, it is a case of fresh
recruitment of Clause-IV posts, therefore, under the rules, there is no
requirement of publishing the select list in newspaper calling claim and
9 / 10
objections, therefore, also the said finding/observation of the
authorities is not sustainable.
18.
Be that as it may, earlier also, appointment of petitioners along with
others were cancelled mentioning that irregularities have been
committed by the authorities in publishing the advertisement and
completing the recruitment process. This Court while considering the
petition filed by petitioners there in has made categorical observation
that "whole select list should not have been cancelled and instead, the
candidate, whose selection would have been found to be invalid and
illegal, only his/her selection should have been cancelled individually
and there might be some candidates who would have been selected
genuinely". It is not brought to the notice of this Court that any
application for review of order is filed or this order is put to challenge in
an appeal, therefore, the order passed in WPS No.4441 of 2012 dated
28.04.2023 have became final. The order impugned dated 08.05.2025
is in excess of direction issued by the High Court in order dated
28.04.2023 in WPS No.4441 of 2012, therefore, the impugned order
dated 08.05.2025 (Annexure P-10) is not sustainable. Accordingly it is
quashed. However, the respondents authorities will be at liberty to pass
fresh order in terms of directives and observations made by this Court
in WPS No. 4441 of 2012 vide order dated 28.04.2023.
19.
This Court earlier allowed batch of the writ petitions i.e. WPS No.
11772 of 2025 and other connected matters of employees appointed in
the year 2012.
20.
Petitioner is one of the employee who was appointed pursuant to the
recruitment proceedings initiated in the year 2012 and therefore, this
writ petition is allowed in terms of order passed by this Court in WPS
10 / 10
No. 11772 of 2025 connected with other matters dated 05.01.2026. the
impugned order dated 08.05.2025 Annexure P-1 be not sustainable
and it is hereby quashed.
21.
Respondent authorities will be at liberty to pass order in terms of
directives and observation made by this Court in WPS No. 4441 of
2012 decided on 28.04.2023.
22.
Accordingly, this writ petition stands allowed.
Certified copy as per rules.
sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Alfiza
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review