Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.No.45 of 2025
Bina Dhar Choudhury aged about 59 years,
Wife of Pradyut Dhar Choudhury, resident of
Usha Bajzar, Chhinaihani Airport,
Agartala, West Tripura.
---- Applicant(s)
On behalf of accused person
Shri Pradyut Dhar Choudhury,
S/o: Lt. Adhir Dhar Choudhury,
Resident of Ushabazar, P.S. Airport,
Agartala, Tripura West.
---- Accused Person(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary,
To the Department of Home,
New Secretariat Complex,
P.S.: N.C.C., District: West Tripura.
----Respondent(s)
____________________________________________________________
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Adv.
Ms. Ayantika Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Special P.P.
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Special P.P.
_____________________________________________________________
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
07/07/2025
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya,
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Soumyadeep Saha appearing on behalf of
the accused in Custody. Also heard Learned Special P.P, Mr. Bibhal Nandi
Mujumdar along with Learned Special P.P., Mr. Sankar Lodh and Learned
P.P., Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of the State-respondent.
This bail application under Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is filed for
releasing the accused person in custody on bail in connection with Airport PS
Case No. 2024 ARP 037 under Sections 320/120B of IPC read with Section
27 of Arms Act corresponding to S.T. (T-1) 31 of 2025.
(2)
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
accused in custody has drawn the attention of this court that in this case,
the main allegation of the prosecution was that the accused in custody made
telephonic conversation with the principal accused namely, Raju Barman
within the period with effect from 01.03.2024 to 30.04.2024 and excepting
this allegation, no materials could be collected by the I.O. during
investigation of this case. Referring the contents of the F.I.R., Learned
Senior Counsel has drawn the attention of this court that in the F.I.R. dated
01.05.2024, laid by S.I. Srikanta Guha to O/C Airport PS, there was no
allegation against the accused in custody that he participated in the
commission of crime and furthermore, the accused person has been lodging
in jail for more than 337 days and is suffering from different ailments. So,
Learned Senior Counsel urged for releasing him on bail in any condition.
It is further submitted that initially the present accused was
granted interim bail by Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala by
order dated 11.11.2024 in connection with Bail Application No. 233 of 2024
but as he was suffering from illness, so, he could not surrender before the
court within time so, he was taken into custody again. The present accused
also approached this court and this court vide order dated 10.03.2025 in
connection with BA No. 9 of 2025 was pleased to reject his bail application.
It was further submitted that two more other accused persons namely, Uma
Sarkar and Susmita Sarkar have been granted bail by Learned Sessions
Judge. So, considering the nature of allegation against the accused in
custody, Learned Senior Counsel has drawn the attention of this court that
parity may also be applied in this case and referring the annexed documents
in support of treatment of the accused person, Learned Senior Counsel
urged this Court to consider the bail application of the accused person in any
condition. Learned Senior Counsel relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in Ajit Singh vs. State of Chhattisgarh reported
(3)
in (2018) 14 SSC 286 wherein in para No. 4, Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“4. After investigation, final report under Section 173 CrPC has
been filed against the appellant and four other persons on 1910-2016. The case against the appellant is almost similar to
that of other co-accused who have been enlarged [Lal Bahadur
Verma v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2017 SCC OnLine Chh 1521] ,
[Dulal Chatterji v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2017 SCC OnLine Chh
1520] on bail. The accused has been in custody for the past sixand-half months. No criminal antecedents have been reported
against the appellant. We are of the view that it is just and
proper to enlarge the appellant on bail subject to the following
conditions:
1. The appellant shall not stay in the State of
Chhattisgarh during the pendency of the case. He shall
stay in Patna during the said period. However, he is
permitted to come to the State of Chhattisgarh for
attending the aforesaid case. He shall personally appear
before the trial court on all the dates of hearing except
under unavoidable circumstances.
2. Soon after release, he shall appear before the Senior
Superintendent of Police, Patna, and notify his address
at Patna to the SSP, Patna. The SSP, Patna, shall
intimate him the jurisdictional police station for his
attendance once in a week on every Sunday between
9.00 a.m. to 5.00 p.m.
3. The appellant shall not tamper with the evidence
during the trial in any manner. He shall not pressurise
or intimidate the prosecution witnesses. The appellant
shall execute a personal bond of rupees one lakh with
two sureties for the like sum to the satisfaction of the
trial court.”
Relying upon the same, Learned Senior Counsel urged for
releasing the accused on bail.
On the other hand, Learned Special P.P., Mr. Majumdar, assisted
by Learned Special P.P., Mr. Lodh and Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta strongly
opposed the bail application and submitted that earlier when the accused
was granted interim bail, he did not surrender before the Learned Court
within time and thereafter, he approached to a co-ordinate bench of this
court for granting pre-arrest bail and this court by order dated 11.02.2025 in
AB No. 10 of 2025 rejected his bail application. Furthermore, Learned
Special P.P., Mr. Majumder submitted that regarding the principle of parity,
this court at the time of disposal of BA No. 9 of 2025 by order dated
10.03.2025, elaborately discussed all the grounds and rejected the bail
application. As such, in absence of any new grounds at this stage, there is
(4)
no scope to entertain the present bail application. Learned Special P.P., Mr.
Lodh appearing on behalf of the State-respondent in support of his
contention relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Kalyan Chandra Sarkar vs. Rajesh Ranjan alias Pappu Yadav & Anr.,
reported in (2005) 2 SCC 42 wherein in para Nos. 19 and 20 Hon’ble the
Apex Court observed as under:
“19. The principles of res judicata and such analogous
principles although are not applicable in a criminal proceeding,
still the courts are bound by the doctrine of judicial discipline
having regard to the hierarchical system prevailing in our
country. The findings of a higher court or a coordinate Bench
must receive serious consideration at the hands of the court
entertaining a bail application at a later stage when the same
had been rejected earlier. In such an event, the courts must
give due weight to the grounds which weighed with the former
or higher court in rejecting the bail application. Ordinarily, the
issues which had been canvassed earlier would not be
permitted to be reagitated on the same grounds, as the same
would lead to a speculation and uncertainty in the
administration of justice and may lead to forum hunting.
20. The decisions given by a superior forum, undoubtedly, are
binding on the subordinate fora on the same issue even in bail
matters unless of course, there is a material change in the fact
situation calling for a different view being taken. Therefore,
even though there is room for filing a subsequent bail
application in cases where earlier applications have been
rejected, the same can be done if there is a change in the fact
situation or in law which requires the earlier view being
interfered with or where the earlier finding has become
obsolete. This is the limited area in which an accused who has
been denied bail earlier, can move a subsequent application.
Therefore, we are not in agreement with the argument of
learned counsel for the accused that in view of the guarantee
conferred on a person under Article 21 of the Constitution, it is
open to the aggrieved person to make successive bail
applications even on a ground already rejected by the courts
earlier, including the Apex Court of the country.”
Learned Special P.P., Mr. Lodh also relied upon another citation,
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in LT. Col. Prasad Shrikant Purohit
vs. State of Maharashtra, reported in (2018) 11 SCC 458 wherein in
para No. 30, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under;
“30. Before concluding, we must note that though an accused
has a right to make successive applications for grant of bail, the
court entertaining such subsequent bail applications has a duty
to consider the reasons and grounds on which the earlier bail
applications were rejected. In such cases, the court also has a
duty to record the fresh grounds which persuade it to take a
view different from the one taken in the earlier applications.”
Referring the same, Learned Special P.P., Mr. Lodh has drawn
the attention of this court that as the accused in custody has failed to
(5)
project any new grounds in support of his bail application, so, the same is
not maintainable. Furthermore, regarding involvement of the accused with
the alleged crime, Learned Special P.P. submitted that the present accused
was the President of Bharat Ratna Sangha till formation of new committee in
2024, when he was removed from his post. After formation of new club
committee, though, he was relieved from the post of President, he was
closely monitoring each and every development of the club and as his
relinquishment from the post of President was a social stigma to him. So,
out of his mental agony a strained relation cropped up in between the old
and the new committee and ultimately this alleged occurrence took place.
The present accused was monitoring the entire plan and made constant
telephonic calls with one of the principal accused namely, Raju Barman. So,
considering the nature of the allegation, if at this stage he is released on
bail, then there is every chance of tempering the witnesses of the
prosecution. It was further submitted that due to non-cooperation of the
accused persons in custody, the Learned Trial Court is also not in a position
to proceed with the case. However, there was no lacuna from the side of the
prosecution to drag the case.
Learned Special P.P. also relied upon another citation of the High
Court of Gujarat in Adeel Salim Nurani vs. State of Gujarat[Criminal
Misc. Application No.7240 of 2021 decided on 24.11.2021] wherein in
para No. 18, the High Court of Gujarat observed as under:
“18. The telephone call details of the present applicant accused
with the prime accused was revealed and in all, the present
applicant accused has made at least 242 telephone calls to
various numbers of the prime accused and it proves the active
connection of the present applicant accused with the prime
accused.”
Relying upon the same, Learned Special P.P. submitted that
considering the nature of the allegation, at this stage, there is no scope to
release the accused on bail and urged for rejection of the bail application.
(6)
In this case, prosecution was set into motion on the basis of an
F.I.R. laid by one S.I. Srikanta Guha of Airport PS to O/C Airport PS alleging
inter alia that on 30.04.2024 at about 2025 hours one telephonic
information was received that a person was shot at Salbagan Bazaar,
Hatipara under Airport PS. Accordingly, the PS officers along with staff
rushed to the spot and found one dead body lying by the side of the road
with bullet wounds and immediately with the help of local public, the body
was shifted to ILS Hospital wherein the attending doctor declared him dead
and the body was identified as of one Durga Prasanna Deb. From the local
enquiry, it was learnt that at about 2010 hours, one miscreant shot upon
Durga Prasanna Deb while he was sitting in a vehicle bearing registration
No. TR 06-A 0745 and the same was parked at Hatipara in front of one
medicine shop of Sri Bikash Das of Salbagan BSF Para and on receipt of
bullet injury, he fell down on the road from the vehicle and the miscreants
fled away. Later on, some kin relatives of the deceased arrived at the
hospital when it came to their knowledge that one Raju Barman, Rakesh
Barman, Debabrata Barman, Biman Das and Pradyut Dhar Choudhury and
some others made criminal conspiracy and were involved in the commission
of offence. Accordingly, on the basis of that F.I.R., the case was registered
and after completion of investigation, the I.O. has laid charge sheet against
the present accused along with others. By this time, the case has been
committed to the Court of Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala
and the same is now pending for disposal before the Court of Learned Addl.
Sessions Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala. It appears that the case
is at the stage of production of the accused/ supplying copy.
It is the admitted position that earlier the present accused was
granted interim bail but as he could not surrender so, he was again taken
into custody and in between he approached for pre-arrest bail that was
rejected. He also approached this Court for granting him bail which was also
rejected on the ground of parity.
(7)
So, after hearing both the sides and considering the relevant
prosecution papers and the materials on record, it appears to this court that
the accused at this stage could not raise any new grounds to consider his
bail
application
and
the
citations
referred
by
Learned
Special
P.P.
representing the prosecution appears to be very much relevant for decision
of this case.
So, considering the nature and gravity of the offense, the bail
application filed at this stage stands rejected. The accused is to remain in
J.C. as before.
Since the accused persons along with others are lodging in
custody, so, it is directed that the Learned Trial Court shall take all
endeavour to dispose of the case giving top priority.
Send down the record of the Learned Trial Court along with a
copy of this order. Also return back the CD to IO through Learned P.P along
with a copy of this order.
JUDGE
Snigdha
Digitally signed
by AMRITA DEB
AMRITA DEB Date: 2025.07.07
18:06:52 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review