The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. 11.2024 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with B. A. No.233 of 2024. It is also on record that the accused failed to surrender before the Learned Court below within the stipulated period on the ground of his illness. It is also on record that he left the station without prior intimation/permission of the OC, Airport P.S. Thus, it appears that he violated the order of bail granted by the Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala. Although he was later on arrested by police and his bail applications were rejected. From the materials on record, it appears that although the accused is directly FIR named but during investigation the I.O. has procured some materials through which his involvement cannot be ruled out at this stage. The plea taken by Learned Counsel Ms. A. Chakraborty that the case of the accused is related to case of the another co-accused Pratima Sarkar for which the accused may be given the same benefit. But on perusal of the record it appears that the involvement of that accused is totally different from the present accused. So, considering the materials on record at this stage, I find no scope to release the accused on bail. Hence the bail application filed by the applicant stands rejected. Since the case is case at the stage of commitment so Learned CJM or the Jurisdictional Magistrate shall take all endeavour to commit…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.9 of 2025
Bina Dhar aged about 59 Years
Wife of Pradyut Dhar Chowdhury,
Resident of Usha Bazar,
Chhinaihani Airport, Agartala, West Tripura
…. Petitioner
ON BEHALF OF THE ACCUSED PERSONS
Shri Pradyut Dhar Chowdhury
S/O. Lt. Adhir Dhar Chowdhury,
Resident of Usha Bazar P.S. Airport,
Agartala, Tripura West.
…. Accused Person
Versus
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary
To the department of Home,
New Secretariat Complex,
P.S.-N.C.C. District- West Tripura.
…….Respondent
For Applicant(s)
:
Ms. Ayantika Chakraborty, Adv.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Spl. P.P.
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Spl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
10/03/2025
This application is filed under Section 439 of Cr.P.C. for
releasing the accused Sri Pradyut Dhar Chowdhury in connection with
Airport P.S. Case No.37 of 2024 under Section 302/120(B) of IPC
read with Section 27 of the Arms Act on bail.
Heard
Learned
Counsel
Ms.
Ayantika
Chakraborty
appearing on behalf of the accused-in-custody along with Learned
Counsel Mr. Soumyadeep Saha. Also heard Learned Special P.P. Mr.
Bibhal Nandi Majumder along with Learned Special P.P. Mr. Sankar
Lodh appointed by the State to represent the State-respondent.
Further heard Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of the
State-respondent.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel Ms. Ayantika
Chakraborty drawn the attention of the Court that this accused was
initially taken into custody on 01.05.2024 and after that on the
ground of sudden demise of his mother he was released on interim
bail by order dated 11.11.2024 passed by Learned Sessions Judge,
West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Bail Application No.233 of
2024 and by the said order a direction was given to surrender before
the Learned Court of CJM, West Tripura, Agartala on 30.11.2024 at
about 10.30 am. But the accused due to his sudden illness could not
surrender rather due to sudden chest problem he had to attend
AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala but as his condition become
deteriorated because he was suffering from chronic diabetic, heart
disease and problem of eyes, he had to leave for Kolkata and prior to
that he approached to the Learned Court below but could not obtain
any permission so he could not surrender in time and finally police
rearrested him again on 15.02.2025 from AGMC and GBP Hospital in
course of his treatment, since then he is lodging in custody.
It was further submitted that during that period he also
approached for anticipatory bail but that was not considered by
Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala by order dated
07.01.2025 in connection with Case No.B.A. No. 01 of 2025.
Learned Counsel Ms. A. Chakraborty further submitted
that in similar other matters, other two accused persons namely Uma
Sarkar and her mother were granted bail by the Learned Court. Uma
Sarkar was granted bail by Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura,
Agartala by order dated 07.09.2024 in connection with B.A. No.173
of 2024. Learned Counsel further submitted that the accused-incustody although FIR named but there was no allegation against
him. Just on the basis of phone calls he was taken into custody in
connection with this case and as he is suffering from prolong illness
and the case is not yet been committed as by this time the I.O. has
laid charge-sheet. So, she urged for releasing the accused on bail in
any condition and also relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Apex
Court reported in (2021) 2 SCC 427 [titled as Arnab Manoranjan
Goswami versus State of Maharashtra and others dated
27.11.2020] wherein in para Nos.69 and 70, the Hon’ble Apex
Court observed as under:“69. It would be apposite to extract the
observations made, albeit in a dissenting
opinion, by one of us (Dhananjaya Y.
Chandrachud, J.) in a decision of a three-Judge
Bench
in
Romila
Thapar
v.
Union
of
India:(2018) 10 SCC 753: (SCC p. 796, para 79)
"79. ...[T]he basic entitlement of every
citizen who is faced with allegations of
criminal
wrongdoing,
is
that
the
investigative process should be fair. This
is
an
integral component
of
the
guarantee against arbitrariness under
Article 14 and of the right to life and
personal liberty under Article 21. If this
Court were not to stand by the principles
which we have formulated, we may
witness a soulful requiem to liberty."
The decision was a dissent in the facts of the
case. The view of the leading majority
judgment is undoubtedly the view of the Court,
which binds us. However, the principle quoted
above is in line with the precedents of this
Court.
70. More than four decades ago, in a celebrated
judgment
in
State
of
Rajasthan
v.
Balchand:(1977) 4 SCC 308, Krishna Iyer, J.
pithily reminded us that the basic rule of our
criminal justice system is "bail, not jail". The
High Courts and courts in the district judiciary
of India must enforce this principle in practice,
and not forego that duty, leaving this Court to
intervene at all times. We must in particular
also emphasise the role of the district judiciary,
which provides the first point of interface to
the citizen. Our district judiciary is wrongly
referred to as the "subordinate judiciary". It
may be subordinate in hierarchy but it is not
subordinate in terms of its importance in the
lives of citizens or in terms of the duty to
render justice to them. High Courts get
burdened when courts of first instance decline
to grant anticipatory bail or bail in deserving
cases. This continues in the Supreme Court as
well, when High Courts do not grant bail or
anticipatory bail in cases falling within the
parameters of the law. The consequence for
those who suffer incarceration are serious.
Common citizens without the means or
resources to move the High Courts or this Court
languish as undertrials. Courts must be alive to
the situation as it prevails on the ground- in
the jails and police stations where human
dignity has no protector. As Judges, we would
do well to remind ourselves that it is through
the instrumentality of bail that our criminal
justice
system's
primordial
interest
in
preserving the presumption of innocence finds
its most eloquent expression. The remedy of
bail is the "solemn expression of the
humaneness of the justice system's Tasked as
we are with the primary responsibility of
preserving the liberty of all citizens, we cannot
countenance an approach that has the
consequence of applying this basic rule in an
inverted form. We have given expression to our
anguish in a case where a citizen has
approached this Court. We have done so in
order to reiterate principles which must govern
countless other faces whose voices should not
go unheard.”
Relying upon the same, she submitted that since the coaccused has been granted bail so parity may also be followed in this
case in deciding bail of this accused.
Per contra, Learned Special P.P. Mr. S. Lodh appearing on
behalf of the State-respondent referring the order dated 11.11.2024
delivered by Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in
connection with B.A. No.233 of 2024 drawn the attention of this
Court that by the said order Learned Sessions Judge at the time of
granting interim bail clearly observed that the accused shall not
leave the jurisdiction of his residence at Usha Bazar without prior
permission of the OC, Airport P.S. But there is no evidence on record
from the side of the accused that he approached to the OC, Airport
P.S. before proceeding towards Kolkata. Rather he approached to the
Court of Learned CJM that is why no effective order would be passed.
Learned Special P.P. further submitted that he has
misused the conditions of bail and referring the annexures submitted
by Learned Counsel for the accused-in-custody, Learned Special P.P.
Mr. Lodh submitted that from the medical papers annexed with the
bail application it appears that the accused himself refused to take
admission in AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala and also from other
connected papers, it is clear that the condition of accused was not so
critical and serious which compelled him to leave the station or since
the accused complaint of some diabetic and other heart diseases but
those problems were apparent prior to his taking into custody and
furthermore he went to Kolkata to consult eye at Sankara Nethralaya
and Narayana Hospital for treatment of heart. So, on the basis of
those medical papers, there is no scope to give him any scope the
privilege of granting bail and furthermore according to Learned
Special P.P. Mr. S. Lodh due to his non-appearance, the case could
not be committed in time as the IO in this case has submitted
charge-sheet.
Supporting the contention of Learned Special P.P. Mr. B.
N. Majumder also strongly argued opposing the bail application filed
by the accused-in-custody and submitted that the accused is FIR
named but during investigation the I.O. collected such materials
which shows his implication with the alleged offence and furthermore
considering the nature and gravity of the offence if at this stage the
accused is released on bail, the trial would be delayed and there is
likelihood of tampering evidence on record of the prosecution or
threatening the witnesses. Furthermore, Learned Special P.P. also
drawn the attention of the Court that this is a clear case of violation
of privilege of bail granted to the accused. So, at this stage there is
no scope to release him on bail.
Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta reiterates the submission
made by Learned Special P.P. Mr. S. Lodh and urged for dismissal of
the bail application.
I have heard both the sides and perused the bail
application and the connected documents annexed with the bail
application including the medical papers. It appears to this Court that
the case is at the stage of commitment. However, it is the admitted
position that this accused was granted interim bail by order dated
11.11.2024 delivered by Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura,
Agartala in connection with B. A. No.233 of 2024. It is also on record
that the accused failed to surrender before the Learned Court below
within the stipulated period on the ground of his illness. It is also on
record that he left the station without prior intimation/permission of
the OC, Airport P.S. Thus, it appears that he violated the order of
bail granted by the Learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala.
Although he was later on arrested by police and his bail applications
were rejected.
From the materials on record, it appears that although
the accused is directly FIR named but during investigation the I.O.
has procured some materials through which his involvement cannot
be ruled out at this stage. The plea taken by Learned Counsel Ms. A.
Chakraborty that the case of the accused is related to case of the
another co-accused Pratima Sarkar for which the accused may be
given the same benefit. But on perusal of the record it appears that
the involvement of that accused is totally different from the present
accused. So, considering the materials on record at this stage, I find
no scope to release the accused on bail. Hence the bail application
filed by the applicant stands rejected.
Since the case is case at the stage of commitment so
Learned CJM or the Jurisdictional Magistrate shall take all endeavour
to commit the case to the concerned Court of Learned Sessions
Judge, West Tripura, Agartala at an earliest keeping it in mind that
the accused is in custody. The accused is to remain in J/C as before.
Superintendent,
Kendriya
Sansodhanagar,
Bishalgarh
shall extend all cooperation to the accused, in case the accused
complains of any medical urgency.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this order.
Supply
a
copy
communicating
the
same
Sansodhanagar,
Bishalgarh.
of
to
this
order
the
Also,
a
to
Learned
P.P.
Superintendent,
Kendriya
copy
order
of
this
communicated to I.O. through Learned P.P. for information.
Case Diary be accordingly returned back.
The bail application is thus disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Amrita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.03.11
10:39:11 +05'30'
for
be
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review