The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. 09.2019 supra, which includes the Institute wherefrom the petitioner has obtained the diploma, shall be registered by the Council only in case of students who had been admitted during the affiliation period. Admittedly, registration of the Institute in question was valid till the year 2016 and the petitioner had got registration in the Institute in the year 2015 and completed his diploma in the year 2017, therefore, manifestly suggesting that the petitioner was admitted in the Institute in question during the period when the affiliation of the Institute was in force and consequently the diploma obtained by the petitioner, which was registered by the Council after the issuance of Government Order dated 04.02.2020, was proper and valid and thereby the petitioner could not have been said to be ineligible for the post in question on the ground that the diploma certificate obtained by him is issued post 2016 when the Institute was no longer affiliated. 5) Furthermore, perusal of the material available on record also clearly shows that the petitioner indisputably has been possessed of the educational qualification prescribed for the post and has also secured more merit than the selected private respondents and, therefore, once the petitioner is found to be eligible and possessed of higher merit than the private respondents, denial of selection and consequent appointment to him agains…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT JAMMU
Reserved on:
30.12.2025
Pronounced on: 19.02.2026
Uploaded on:
20.02.2026
Whether operative part or
full
judgment
is
pronounced:
Full
WP(C) No.705/2021
BILAL ASHRAF WAZA
Through: -
....PETITIONER(S)/APPELLANT(S)
Mr. Mohd. Israr, Advocate.
Vs.
UT OF J&K & OTHERS
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG, with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate-for official
respondents.
None for private respondents.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner, in the instant petition filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution, has implored for the
following reliefs:
A.
WP(C) No.705/2021
CERTIORARI; So as to quash
Selection List impugned issued
by respondent No. 2 vide Order
No. 739/AHJ of 2021 dated
25.03.2021 to the extent it
pertains to selection of private
respondents to the post of X-Ray
Assistant
pursuant
to
Advertisement Notification No.
02 dated 07.12.2018 and also
quash subsequent appointment
order if any issued in their favour
pursuant to the said selection.
B.
2)
MANDAMUS; So as to command
and
direct
the
official
respondents to select and
appoint the petitioner to the
aforesaid post of X-Ray Assistant
pursuant
to
Advertisement
Notification No. 02 dated
07.12.2018 along with all the
consequential benefits.
The facts, under the shade and cover of which the
aforesaid reliefs have been prayed and as are stated in the
petition, are that respondent 2 invited applications for
engagement of X-Ray Assistants on academic arrangement
basis under SRO 384 of 2009 dated 14.12.2009 read with
SRO 409 of 2013, prescribing the eligibility qualification
therein as 10+2 or above with diploma in the line from a
recognized institute. 20 points were prescribed for basic
qualification and 80 points for technical qualification in the
said Advertisement Notice, and that the petitioner applied
for the aforesaid post and in the provisional merit list
prepared in December, 2019 by the official respondents,
was shown to be figuring at serial No.4 having secured 76.2
points and the private respondents herein having secured
72.1, 71.0 and 71.0 points respectively placed in the said
provisional merit list at serial Nos.14, 23 and 24
respectively. However, in the final selection list the
petitioner was not shown as selected whereas the private
WP(C) No.705/2021
respondents were shown to be selected, aggrieved whereof,
the petitioner has questioned the said selection on the
grounds that the same is illegal and arbitrary besides being
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution for the
petitioner having secured more merit/points than the
private respondents, has not been selected.
3)
Objections to the petition have been filed by the
respondents wherein the petition is being opposed and the
exclusion of the petitioner from the selection is justified on
the ground that the diploma obtained by the petitioner was
not found valid in view of Government Order No.828-HME
of 2019 dated 18.09.2019, while stating further that upon
receipt of applications from the aspiring candidates against
the post in question, a letter came to be addressed to the
Registrar, State Paramedical Council, Jammu ( for short
“the Council”) vide No.AHJ/2019/3970 dated 11.10.2019,
whereafter it came to be resolved that only those candidates
would be considered who had completed their diploma/
technical course from an institute which is recognized by
the
Council
in
terms
of
Government
Order
dated
18.09.2019 supra and till the year 2016, only three
institutes,
namely,
Paramedical
Technology,
Pahari
Chatterpuri, New Delhi, Sai Institute of Allied Sciences,
WP(C) No.705/2021
Channa Patana, Ramanagaram, Karnataka, and Institute
of Public Health and Hygiene Mahipalpur, New Delhi, were
recognized by the Council and, therefore, in terms of the
aforesaid decision, the final selection list came to be issued
on 25.03.2021 and the petitioner excluded therefrom being
ineligible in terms of Government Order dated 18.09.2019
read with Government Order No.122-JK(HME) of 2020
dated 04.02.2020, and also on the ground that registration
certificate was not enclosed with the application form by the
petitioner.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
4)
It is significant to mention here that during the course
of proceedings, a supplementary affidavit had been filed by
the petitioner stating therein that he, the petitioner,
obtained the diploma from the Institute of Public Health
and Hygiene, Mahipalpur, New Delhi, in Session 2015-17,
whereafter he approached the Council for registration
which came to be granted vide No.REJ/JMU/XR/0397,
which is shown to be valid from 15.10.2022 to 14.10.2027,
stating further therein the affidavit that once the Council
granted registration to the petitioner on the basis of
aforesaid diploma secured by him, it does not lie in the
mouth of the respondents to say that the said Institute is
WP(C) No.705/2021
not recognized for the purposes of appointment, having
stated further in the said affidavit that as per the
information provided by the Council under Right to
Information Act, 2005, the diploma courses conducted by
the said Institute are recognized by the Council as per the
No Objection Certificate issued by the Health and Medical
Education Department, J&K Government from time to time.
Besides Government Order No.129-JSMPC of 2016 dated
18.01.2016 has been placed on record by the petitioner
signifying the grant of sanction to the Institute for a period
of one year in terms of the provisional No Objection
Certificate by the Council and in the said order, X-Ray and
ECG Technology finds place at serial No.2. Government
Order No.122-JK(HME) of 2020 dated 04.02.2020 has also
been placed on record by the petitioner, by virtue of which,
Government Order No.828-HME of 2019 dated 18.09.2019
supra has been modified providing therein in the last para
of the said Government Order that the last para of the
Government Order dated 18.09.2019 shall and shall always
be deemed to have been recast as under:
“Now therefore the general public is hereby
informed that no individual NOC/Affiliation has
been granted by the Government of Jammu and
Kashmir to any institution situated outside Jammu
and Kashmir including the above mentioned three
institutions beyond 2016 and also that the J&K
Paramedical Council shall register, upon
WP(C) No.705/2021
completion of the course, the Diploma Certificates
of the students admitted only during the affiliation
periods by the above mentioned three institutions,
after verification of individual cases. However, the
J&K Paramedical/ Nursing Council shall register the
Diploma/ Degree certificates of the candidates who
have been training from the Institutions situated
outside Jammu and Kashmir which are duly
recognized by/affiliated with different Paramedical
Councils/Nursing Councils/Recognized Universities
/respective State Governments."
A plain reading of the Order dated 04.02.2020 supra
tends to show that the diploma certificate of a student
obtained from three institutes mentioned in Order dated
18.09.2019 supra, which includes the Institute wherefrom
the petitioner has obtained the diploma, shall be registered
by the Council only in case of students who had been
admitted
during
the
affiliation
period.
Admittedly,
registration of the Institute in question was valid till the
year 2016 and the petitioner had got registration in the
Institute in the year 2015 and completed his diploma in the
year 2017, therefore, manifestly suggesting that the
petitioner was admitted in the Institute in question during
the period when the affiliation of the Institute was in force
and consequently the diploma obtained by the petitioner,
which was registered by the Council after the issuance of
Government Order dated 04.02.2020, was proper and valid
and thereby the petitioner could not have been said to be
ineligible for the post in question on the ground that the
WP(C) No.705/2021
diploma certificate obtained by him is issued post 2016
when the Institute was no longer affiliated.
5)
Furthermore, perusal of the material available on
record also clearly shows that the petitioner indisputably
has been possessed of the educational qualification
prescribed for the post and has also secured more merit
than the selected private respondents and, therefore, once
the petitioner is found to be eligible and possessed of higher
merit than the private respondents, denial of selection and
consequent appointment to him against the post in
question cannot,
but said to be unfair, unreasonable,
arbitrary, inasmuch as violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution rendering the exclusion of the petitioner from
the selection in question, despite his higher merit legally
unsustainable.
6)
Viewed thus, for what has been observed, considered
and analyzed hereinabove, the instant petition deserves to
be allowed and is, accordingly, allowed in the following
terms:
(I)
The selection list dated 25.03.2021, to the extent it
relates to the selection of private respondents against
the Open Merit quota for the post of X-Ray Assistant, is
quashed in so far as it affects the claim of the petitioner.
WP(C) No.705/2021
(II)
The official respondents are directed to re-draw the
selection list based upon the merit position of the
candidates
including that
of the petitioner
in
accordance with the prescribed criteria and select and
offer appointment to the petitioner against the post of XRay Assistant with all consequential benefits.
(III)
The aforesaid exercise shall be undertaken and
completed by the official respondents within a period of
eight weeks from the date a copy of this judgment and
order is served upon them by the petitioner.
(Javed Iqbal Wani)
Judge
Srinagar
19.02.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the Judgment is speaking:
Whether the judgment is reportable:
WP(C) No.705/2021
Yes
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review