Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.32828 of 2023
….
Bikash Sethy
Petitioner
Mr. B. Senapati, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha and
Others
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. A. Tripathy, AGA
CORAM:
JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
ORDER
22.01.2026
Order No.
13. 1.
This
matter
is
taken
up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
challenging order dated 24.03.2023, so passed by the
Opp. Party No.1 under Annexure-5, confirmed vide
order dated 21.09.2023 under Annexure-7.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that
while continuing under the State Govt., a proceeding
was initiated against him under Rule-15 of OCS(CCA)
Rules, 1962 (in short “Rules”) vide Memorandum dated
04.01.2021 under Annexure-1. It is contended that in
// 2 //
the
said
proceeding,
petitioner
filed
his
written
statement of defence on 13.07.2021. After such filing of
the written statement of defence, Opp. Party No.1 vide
office order dated 04.09.2021 under Annexure-C/2,
appointed the A.D.M., Nabarangpur as the Enquiry
Officer in terms of the provisions contained under Rule15(4) of the aforesaid Rules.
4.1. It is contended that after such appointment of the
Enquiry Officer, petitioner vide order dated 18.11.2021
was issued with the notice by the Enquiry Officer fixing
the date of appearance to 07.12.2021. Thereafter, vide
another order passed on 04.02.2022, petitioner was
directed to appear before the Enquiry Officer on
14.02.2022 and on the said date, petitioner duly
appeared before the Enquiry Officer.
4.2. It is contended that without causing any enquiry
by giving due opportunity of hearing to the petitioner
and without proving the charges in accordance with
law, the enquiry was closed on 14.02.2022 with
submission of the report vide letter dated 01.06.2022.
It is contended that since the enquiry was not
conducted in accordance with law and the enquiry was
closed on 14.02.2022 i.e. on the date of appearance of
the petitioner, petitioner could not get a chance to
dispute the allegations made against him in the
proceeding in question.
// 3 //
4.3. However, basing on the Enquiry Report so
submitted by the Enquiry Officer, petitioner was issued
with the 1st show-cause vide notice dated 11.07.2022
under Annexure-D/2 and thereafter the 2nd showcause vide notice dated 13.01.2023 under AnnexureE/2,
proposing
therein
to
impose
the
following
punishments:
“(i) Censure.
(ii) Withholding of one annual increment with cumulative effect.
(iii) Period of unauthorised absence from duty on 22.05.2019 may
be treated as EOL.”
4.4. Petitioner though submitted reply to the 2nd showcause on 31.01.2023, but without proper appreciation
of
the
same,
petitioner
was
imposed
with
the
punishment so proposed in the 2nd show-cause vide the
impugned order dated 24.03.2023 under Annexure-5
by Opp. Party No.1. It is contended that petitioner
though
preferred
an
appeal
before
the
Hon’ble
Governor under Annexure-6, but the same was also
rejected vide order dated 21.09.2023 under Annexure7.
4.5. Learned counsel for the petitioner vehemently
contended that since the enquiry was never conducted
in accordance with law and the same was conducted
and concluded on a single day i.e. 14.02.2022, basing
on the report so submitted by the Enquiry Officer,
petitioner could not have been issued with the showPage 3 of 9
// 4 //
cause proposing the punishment which was ultimately
imposed
on
him
vide
order
under
Annexure-5,
confirmed vide order under Annexure-7.
4.6. It is accordingly contended that the impugned
order of punishment so passed against the petitioner,
is required to be interfered with. In support of his
submission, reliance was placed to a decision of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Satyendra Singh
Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Anr., Hon’ble Apex
Court in the said judgment in Para-17 has held as
follows:“17. Thus, even in an ex-parte inquiry, it is sine qua non to
record the evidence of the witnesses for proving the charges.
Having tested the facts of the case at hand on the
touchstone of the Rules of 1999, and the law as expounded
by this Court in the cases of Roop Singh Negi15 and Nirmala
J. Jhala16, we are of the firm view that the inquiry
proceedings conducted against the appellant pertaining to
charges punishable with major penalty, were totally vitiated
and non-est in the eyes of law since no oral evidence
whatsoever was recorded by the department in support of
the charges.”
5.
Learned Addl. Govt. Advocate on the other hand
while supporting the impugned order of punishment
made his submission basing on the stand taken in the
counter affidavit so filed by Opp. Party No.2. It is
contended that petitioner during his incumbency as
Executive
Officer,
Jagatsinghpur
Municipality,
he
availed 2 (two) advances, which was not permissible
and
while
continuing
as
Assistant
Collector
in
// 5 //
Collectorate, Nabarangpur, he remained absent from
Election duty on 22.05.2019.
5.1. It
is
contended
that
since
petitioner
never
attended the Election duty on 22.05.2019, the same
amounts to a major mis-conduct and even though
enquiry was completed on a single day, but taking into
account the conduct of the petitioner in not attending
the Election duty, no illegality or irregularity can be
found with the impugned order of punishment so
passed against him. Stand taken in Para-15 of the
Counter affidavit reads as follows:“15. That in reply to the averments made in Para-13
csv of the Writ Petition, it is humbly submitted that; the
petitioner during his incumbency as Assistant Collector,
Collectorate, Nabarangpur was assigned with Election
duty to record result trend in respect of 75-Nabarangpur
(ST) AC during SGE 2019.He was directed to remain
present at Model Degree College, Nabarangpur on
22.05.2019 for review of counting arrangement, mock
rehearsal in the counting hall taken up by the Counting
Observer. However, during the visit of the Counting
Observer at 9.30 A.M on 22.05.2019, the petitioner was
found absent. Again on 22.05.2019 at 4.30 PM during
the mock rehearsal, he was found absent. For such
negligence on the part of the D.O, the counting observer
requested Collector, Nabarangpur to call explanation
from the petitioner and to take appropriate action as per
service/Election Rules. The petitioner was called for an
explanation and the petitioner in his written explanation
dated 25.05.2019, has admitted that he was not
present till 5.30 P.M as his spectacle was broken, but
has not submitted any proof in support of his
explanation. Further, as regards acquittance register
obtained by the petitioner, it is found that, the petitioner
has not signed in the Signature column which raised a
question. From the above scenario It reveals that the
petitioner shown his utter carelessness and committed
irregularity by wav of remaining unauthorized absent
from the duties vested upon him.”
// 6 //
6.
To the submission made by the learned Addl.
Govt. Advocate, learned counsel for the petitioner
contended that petitioner was very much present on
his Election duty and he has put his signature in the
attendance register. But on the face of the application
being made by the petitioner, such attendance register
was never called for. It is accordingly contended that
without any proof that petitioner remained absent from
election duty, the order of punishment could not have
been imposed on him.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
considering the submissions made, this Court finds
that while in service, the proceeding in question was
initiated against the petitioner vide Memorandum dated
04.01.2021 under Annexure-1. As found from the
record, petitioner after receipt of the Memorandum,
filed his written statement of defence on 13.07.2021
under Annexure-B/2. There is no document available
in the record showing any application made by the
petitioner asking for any document to file his written
statement of defence and the same was filed suo-moto
basing on the charges framed against him.
7.1. It is however found that, after receipt of the
written statement of defence so filed by the petitioner
on 13.07.2021, the enquiry officer was appointed vide
office order dated 04.09.2021 under Annexure-C/2.
After
such
appointment
of
the
Enquiry
Officer,
// 7 //
petitioner was noticed to appear before the Enquiry
Officer on 14.02.2022 vide order dated 04.02.2022 as
found from Annexure-C/3.
7.2. It is found that on 14.02.2022, the Enquiry
Officer without causing any enquiry and without
proving the allegation against the petitioner basing on
the charges framed in the Memorandum by oral and
documentary evidence, closed the enquiry on the said
date and submitted the Enquiry Report on 01.06.2022
by holding the petitioner guilty of the charges. Basing
on such Enquiry Report submitted by the Enquiry
Officer on 01.06.2022, petitioner was issued with the
1st show-cause on 11.07.2022 under Annexure-D/2
and 2nd show-cause on 13.01.2023 under AnnexureE/2.
7.3. As found, petitioner though submitted a detailed
reply to the 1st and 2nd show cause, but without
considering the same, the proceeding was disposed of
with imposition of the punishment so proposed in the
2nd show-cause vide order dated 24.03.2023 under
Annexure-5. Petitioner though filed an appeal before
the Hon’ble Governor, but the same was also rejected
vide order dated 21.09.2023 under Annexure-7.
7.4. This Court after going through the records, finds
that after appointment of the Enquiry Officer vide order
dated
04.09.2021,
though
enquiry
was
fixed
to
// 8 //
14.02.2022 vide order dated 04.02.2022 for the 1st
time, but on the very same date, enquiry was
completed
and
the
report
was
submitted
on
01.06.2021. Since the enquiry has not been conducted
in accordance with law and allegations made in the
Memorandum were never proved with examination of
the prosecution witnesses and proof of the documents
so relied on by the prosecution, it is the view of this
Court that, the punishment imposed basing on such
enquiry report is vitiated.
7.5. In view of the aforesaid analysis, this Court is
inclined to quash the order of punishment passed
against the petitioner under Annexure-5 so confirmed
vide order under Annexure-7. While quashing both the
orders, this Court remits the matter to the stage of
Enquiry and directs Opp. Party No.1 to appoint a fresh
Enquiry
Officer
and
decide
the
proceeding
in
accordance with law in which this Court expresses no
opinion.
7.6. The decision relied on by the learned counsel for
the petitioner in case of Satyendra Singh so cited
(supra) as per the considered view of this Court is not
applicable to the facts of the present case as in the case
in hand, the proceeding is of the year 2020 and this
Court taking into account the fact that no enquiry was
conducted, while quashing the order of punishment is
// 9 //
remitting the matter for fresh disposal in accordance
with law.
8.
The Writ Petition accordingly stands disposed of.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Basudev
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASUDEV SWAIN
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 28-Jan-2026 17:57:47
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review