The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In view of the above, the notice issued by the respondent no. 6 to the respondent no. 8 dated 19th September, 2025, directing to upload the details of the employees of the cooperative banks including the petitioners on the portal emms.wb.gov.in is set aside and quashed.
19. WPA No. 27006 of 2025 is allowed. No order as to costs. Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the Judgment placed on the official website of the Court. Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities. (Krishna Rao, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
WPA No. 27006 of 2025
Bikash Rath & Ors.
Versus
Election Commission of India & Ors.
Mr. Sauradeep Dutta
Mr. Madan Mohan Ray
Mr. Himadree Ghosh
.....For the petitioners.
Mr. Soumya Majumdar, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Anamika Pandey
Mr. Ghanshyam Pandey
.....For the respondent nos. 1 to 3.
Mr. Ankit Sureka
Mr. Biplab Dan
.....For the respondent no. 5.
Mr. Harish Chandra Talwar
.....For the respondent no. 7.
Hearing Concluded On : 04.12.2025
Judgment on
: 07.01.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioners have challenged the communication dated 19th
September, 2025, issued by the District Magistrate, District Election
Officer, District- Medinipur East to the Head of the Office (Manager),
Balageria Central Cooperative Bank Limited, Contai Branch, to update
of office information and Employee Data for General Election to the
West
Bengal
Legislative
Assembly
(WBLA)
on
the
portal
emms.wb.gov.in for preparation of election personnel database.
2.
The petitioners are the employees of the Balageria Central Cooperative
Bank Ltd. serving in different categories.
3.
The petitioners have raised the issue that the petitioners being the
employees of the registered Cooperative Bank, is an autonomous
Cooperative Entity governed by its own Bye-laws and an elected
management do not fall within any category of authorities, whose
employees/staffs
may
be
requisitioned
for
election
duty
and
consequently, they cannot be summoned or deployed for election
related work, and their names cannot be uploaded or included on any
Government portal or website for the said purposes.
4.
Mr. Sauradeep Dutta, Learned Advocate representing the petitioners
submits that the management of the bank is vested in a duly elected
Board of Directors, constituted in accordance with its registered Bye-
laws. The final authority of the Bank lies in the General Body of its
members assembled in a General Meeting. He submits that Section 17
of the West Bengal Cooperative Societies Act, 2006, confers upon the
Bank the status of a body corporate under its registered name, having
perpetual succession and a common seal. By virtue of its statutory
incorporation, the Bank is empowered to acquire, hold, and dispose of
property to enter into contracts in its own name, to institute and defend
suits and other legal proceedings and to carry out all acts necessary for
attaining its objective.
5.
Mr. Dutta further submits that the Bank carries on its banking
business under the close regulatory supervision of the Reserve Bank of
India and the National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development
(NABARD) and is subject to the provisions of the Cooperative Act and
the Rules framed thereunder, as well as the legal requirements
contained in the Banking Regulation Act, 1949. He submits that the
Bank is a Cooperative Credit Structure Entity as defined under Section
134B of the Act and Section 134C(2) expressly grants such entities full
autonomy in all financial and internal matters, personal policy, staffing,
recruitment, posting and compensation of employees. He submits that
the salaries and other allowances of the petitioners paid out of the
funds of the bank as per terms and conditions of the employment.
6.
Mr. Dutta submits that the Bank is a registered cooperative body
governs by its own Bye-Laws, managed by an elected Board, and is not
owned by the State. He submits that the salaries and service benefits
are exclusively paid from the funds of the Cooperative Bank itself and
not from the funds of the State or Central Government.
7.
In support of his submissions, he has relied upon the judgment in the
case of Election Commission of India Vs. State Bank of India Staff
Association reported in (1995) Supp (2) SCC 13 and submits that
Article 324(6) of the Constitution of India means that “such staff” whose
services may be requisitioned by the Commission must be persons
employed by the Central Government or the State Government, and not
from statutory Corporation such as SBI. He further submits that the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the SBI is not a local authority within
the meaning of Section 159 of the Act, thus the Cooperative Bank is
also not coming under the purview of Local Authority.
8.
Mr. Dutta further relied upon the judgment in the case of Malda
District Central Co-operative Bank Employees Association and
Others Vs. Election Commission of India in WPA No. 10325 of
2024 passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court and submits that
the banks are not controlled and financed by the Government in a way
that makes them equivalent to public authorities for the purpose of
Election Commission requisition.
9.
Mr. Soumya Mazumdar, Learned Senior Advocate representing the
respondent nos. 1 to 3 submits that similar question came up for
hearing before the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court,
wherein the Hon’ble Division Bench held that it cannot be said that the
District Cooperative Bank is an institution, establishment or concern
which is controlled or financed wholly or substantially by funds
provided directly or indirectly, by the Central Government or a State
Government. He submits that being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the
said order, the Chief Electoral Officer has challenged the said order
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Petition(s) for Special Leave to
Appeal No(s). 563 of 2015 and by an order dated 10th April, 2017,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has stayed the operation of the said order
and the matter is pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10. Mr. Mazumdar submits that the judgment relied by the petitioner in the
case of Malda District Central Cooperative Bank Employees
Association (supra) has not considered the order passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 28th April, 2017 wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the similar matter had stayed the operation of the
order passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court
in the case of Bhavnagar District Cooperative Bank Ltd. & Anr.
(supra).
11. The preamble of the Representation of People Act, is an Act to provide
for the allocation of seats in, and the delimitation of constituencies for
the purpose of elections to the House of People and Legislatures of
States, the qualifications of voters at such elections, preparation of
electoral rolls, the filling of seats in the Council of States to be filled by
representatives and the matters connected therewith.
12. Sections 159(2) of the Act mentioned several authorities for the
purposes of sub-section (1). Sub-section (1) provides that such
authorities shall, when so requested by the Regional Commissioner
appointed under Article 324(4) or the Chief Electoral Officer of the
State, make available to any returning officer such staff as may be
necessary for the performance of any duties in connection with an
election. The mentioning of Article 324(4) in Section 159 makes it clear
that Article 324, at least with regard to the limited component of the
officer who can be appointed under the said Article has to be read in
conjunction with Section 159 of the Representation of the People Act. It
cannot be said that Article 324 overrides Section 159 of the
Representation of the People Act. The power exercisable under Article
324 by the Election Commission of India are circumscribed by Section
159 of the Representation of the People Act, which is specific statue for
the purpose of conduct of elections, in so far as the persons who can be
appointed for the purpose of election by the Election Commission of
India is concerned.
13. Section 159(2)(iv) stipulates that staff from any other institution,
concern or undertaking which is established by or under a Central,
Provincial or State Act or which is controlled, or funded by the Central
or State Government can be appointed for the purpose of an election.
Article 324(6) of the Constitution of India provides that the President of
India or the Governor of a State, shall, when so requested by the
Election
Commission
of
India,
make
available
to
the
Election
Commission of India or to a Regional Commissioner, such staffs as may
be necessary for the discharge of functions conferred on the Election
Commission of India by Clause 1. Clause 1 of the Article 324 provides
that the superintendence, directions and control of the preparation of
the electoral rolls for, and the conduct of, an election to the Parliament
and to the Legislature of every States and of elections to the offices of
Presidents and Vice-President held under the Constitution shall be
vested in a Commission referred to in the Constitution as Election
Commission.
14. In the case of Election Commission of India vs. State Bank of India
Staff Association, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that:
“19. We have already extracted clause (6) of
Article 324 which empowers the Election
Commission to request the President, or the
Governor of the State concerned to make available
such staff as may be necessary for it to carry out
its duty under clause (1). Such a provision was
necessary for the obvious reason that since the
Election Commission has to hold elections at
intervals it is not required to maintain a huge staff
at considerable expense to the exchequer and
therefore the power to seek on request such staff
as is necessary came to be engrafted in the
Constitution itself.
20. We assume that the powers of the
Election Commission under Article 324 are plenary.
Therefore, the Election Commission may issue any
direction in the matter of conduct of elections. But
the question is, in the garb of conduct of elections,
can the Election Commission usurp the power not
vested in it? This will depend on the understanding
of clause (6) of Article 324. For the conduct of
elections when the Election Commission makes a
request to the President or the Governor to make
available the staff they are obliged to provide the
services. What is the meaning of “such staff”?
According to Mr Dushyant Dave we should refer to
Article 310 which talks of a member of Civil Service
(in contradistinction to Defence Service of the Union
or the State), holding office during the pleasure
(durante bene placito) of President or the Governor.
Obviously “such staff” can only mean that staff
which is under the control of the President or the
Governor concerned and not any staff over which
they do not exercise control. It could mean only that
staff on which the President or the Governor, as the
case may be, would be in a position to exercise
disciplinary powers should they refuse the
President's or Governor's directive. Although the
Constitution-makers did not say the Union or the
State Governments but only the President or the
Governor, it is obvious they would have to act
consistently with Articles 74(1) and 163(1),
respectively. Therefore, on a request by the Election
Commission the services of those government
servants who are appointed to public services and
posts under the Central or State Governments will
have to be made available for the purpose of
election. When the Constitution came into force the
services of these officers were readily available. Of
course, there were also local authorities and the
services of the employees of the local authorities
were also available. That is why Section 159 of the
1951 Act provides that on request from the
Regional Commissioner or the Chief Electoral
Officer of the State, the local authority of the State
shall make available to any Returning Officer such
staff as may be necessary to carry out the duties in
connection with an election.
21. It is important to note that their services
came to be made available as Returning Officers
and Assistant Returning Officers under Sections 21
and 22 of the 1951 Act introduced by Amendment
Act 47 of 1966. Barring the services of these
officers does the Election Commission have power
to requisition the services of any other person? The
argument of the appellant is based on several
sections of the 1950 and 1951 Acts. We have
referred to the relevant provisions of the two Acts
hereinbefore.
22. Merely because the provisions of the two
Acts require that they must be officers of
Government or local authority, unlike in the case of
officers falling under Section 26 of 1951 Act, it does
not, in our opinion, follow that the services of the
officers of the State Bank of India could be
requisitioned. Section 26 of the 1951 Act is not a
source of power at all. It does not, in any manner,
enable the Election Commission to draft in the
services of officers other than officers of
Government and local authority. To draw
inspiration from these sections to support an
argument that the services of any person could be
drafted for the purpose of election is untenable.
May be, to conduct the elections many polling
stations are set up. Consequently, the services of
many persons may be required. May be, the
Election Commission may draw the minimum staff
from the banks to ensure that the banking business
is not disrupted but the question here is of power
and not discretion. If there is power it may be
exercised with circumspection and minimum staff
may be requisitioned but if there is no power the
question of the mode of its exercise will not arise at
all. It is a question of existence of power and not
the manner of its exercise.”
15. The Balageria Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. is a registered cooperative
body governed by its By-Laws and managed by an elected Board and is
not owned or controlled by the State. The functions of the bank are an
autonomous private organization within the cooperative sectors. The
salaries and service benefits of the employees of the bank are paid
exclusively from the funds of cooperative bank itself and not from any
fund of the State or Central Government.
16. Mr. Mazumdar relied upon the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Chief Electoral Officer, Gujarat State (supra)
dated 28th April, 2017 wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has stayed
the operation of the order passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench of the
Gujarat High Court in the case of Bhavnagar District Cooperative
Bank Ltd. & Anr. (supra) dated 10th April, 2014 wherein the Hon’ble
Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court held that the District
Cooperative Bank cannot be said that the District Cooperative Bank is
an institution, establishment of concern which controls of finance
wholly or substantially by funds provided, directly or indirectly, by the
Central Government or the State Government. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in its order dated 28th April, 2017, has simply passed an order of
stay of the operation of the order dated 10th April, 2014 without
considering the judgment passed in the case of Election Commission
of India (supra) wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the
Election Commission may issue any direction in the matter of conduct
of elections. For conduct of elections when the Election Commission
makes a request to the President or the Governor to make available the
staffs, they are obliged to provide the services. Such staffs can only
mean that staffs which is under the control of the President or the
concerned Governor and not any staff over which they do not exercise
control. It could mean only that staff on which the President or the
Governor, as the case may be, would be in a position to exercise
disciplinary power should they refuse the Presidents or Governor’s
directive.
17. In the present case, admittedly, the petitioners are the employees of
Balageria Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. which is an autonomous body
in the cooperative sector which does not fall within any of the categories
enumerated in Article 324(6) of the Constitution of India, Section 26 or
Section 159 of the Representation of the People Act.
18. In view of the above, the notice issued by the respondent no. 6 to the
respondent no. 8 dated 19th September, 2025, directing to upload the
details of the employees of the cooperative banks including the
petitioners on the portal emms.wb.gov.in is set aside and quashed.
19. WPA No. 27006 of 2025 is allowed. No order as to costs.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review