Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
WEDNESDAY, THE 21ST DAY OF FEBRUARY 2024 / 2ND PHALGUNA, 1945
WP(C) NO. 17124 OF 2021
PETITIONER/S:
BIJU B.N.,AGED 43 YEARS, S/O.G.NARAYANA PANICKER,
ACCOUNTANT, CIVIL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT, COCHIN PORT TRUST,
WILLINGTON ISLAND, COCHIN - 682 009, RESIDING AT THACHECTH,
BIJU BHAVAN, UDYOGAMANDAL P.O., ELOOR SOUTH, PIN- 683 501.
BY ADV M.R.HARIRAJ
RESPONDENT/S:
COCHIN PORT TRUST, REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN, COCHIN PORT
TRUST, COCHIN - 682 009.
SECRETARY, COCHIN PORT TRUST, ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE, COCHIN
- 682 009.
UNION OF INDIA,REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF
INDIA, MINISTRY OF SHIPPING, NEW DELHI - 110 001.
BY ADVS.M.GOPIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR
MANU S., ASG OF INDIA
K.JOHN MATHAI,JOSON MANAVALAN
KURYAN THOMAS,PAULOSE C. ABRAHAM
RAJA KANNAN
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV JAI MOHAN
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
21.02.2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WPC. 17124/2021
JUDGMENT
(Dated: 21st February, 2024)
The petitioner commenced his service as Bundary, Marine Department
under the 1st respondent Port in 2008. As per the recruitment regulations
applicable to the Lower Division Clerks (LDC) post, 20% of the vacancies in the
said cadre were earmarked for promotion among persons working in
categories lower than LDC based on a competitive examination. By Ext.P1
Minutes of the proceedings of Meeting No.4 of 1997-98 of the Board of
Trustees held on 28.11.1997, revised the recruitment rules, i.e., the
qualification for direct recruitment to the post of LDC was revised as
Graduation. A similar resolution was adopted with respect to the shed clerks.
The recruitment regulations approved by the Board of Trustees were not
approved by the Central Government or published in the Official Gazette as
required under Section 124 of the Major Port Trust Act.
2. The Central Government Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court,
Ernakulam, had occasion to deal with an issue in respect of Shed Clerks in ID
No.39/2008. In the award of the Tribunal, it was held that the Regulation
Amendment was not effective, and the qualification for appointment of Shed
WPC. 17124/2021
Clerks remained to be SSLC, and Ext.P2 is the copy of the award. However, the
said award was upheld by this Court through Ext.P3 judgment. The selection
to the post of LDC among the lower grade officials was conducted, and the
petitioner became the first rank holder and was accordingly appointed as LDC
by order dated 03.09.2011 (Ext.P5).
3. The petitioner completed a distance education course conducted by
Chhattisgarh University and cleared his B.A. Economics, Ext.P6 is the degree
certificate. The Chhattisgarh University was a private university, and the Apex
Court had occasion to consider the validity of the notification establishing
universities in Chhattisgarh. Sections 5 and 6 of the notification, by which the
universities were established in the State of Chhattisgarh, were held to be
ultra vires, and the gazette notification notifying the university was quashed.
4.
The Cochin Port Trust (Recruitment Seniority and Promotion)
Amendment Rules, 2015, were approved by the Central Government and
published in the Kerala Gazette dated 22.03.2016. While so, the petitioner
was directed to show cause, why action should not be initiated against him as
his degree from Chhattisgarh University is not a valid degree.
5. The petitioner submitted a detailed reply, pointing out that the Rule at
the time of appointment does not require any graduation, and his graduation
WPC. 17124/2021
is not acceptable and cannot affect his promotion granted to LDC based on a
competitive examination, but it was rejected by Ext.P12. The petitioner
challenges Exts.P12 and P15 before this Court. The petitioner has also
procured another degree from M.S.University, Tirunelveli, subsequently, as
per the degree certificate dated 11.01.2013. Thereafter, by Ext.P15 order,
the petitioner was reverted to the post of Bundary with immediate effect.
6. A counter affidavit and an additional counter are filed on behalf of the
1st and 2nd respondents. In the counter affidavit filed, it is submitted that a
circular dated 03.03.2011 was issued for the preparation of a select list of
candidates for the appointment to the post of LDC against the unfilled
vacancies of 20% quota for the year 2009 - 10. The method of recruitment
was through competitive examination and interview. The minimum
qualification stated in Ext.R1(a) is graduation in any subject from a recognized
university or its equivalent. However, an exception was given to persons who
were in service as of 26.03.1994 from the minimum graduation qualification.
This exemption does not apply to the petitioner as he joined the service of the
1st respondent on 19.06.2008.
7. The qualification in the recruitment rules was incorporated pursuant to
a direction issued by the Ministry of Shipping, Government of India, followed
WPC. 17124/2021
by a conciliation settlement dated 26.03.1994. Ext.R1(c) is the memorandum
of settlement by which the basic qualification for the recruitment of L.D.Clerks
will be graduation with KGTE (Lower) in Typewriting (English) or its equivalent.
The petitioner, on 16.03.2011, submitted an application for the above post
stating that he has passed B.A.(Economics) Examination and awaiting the
certificate. A copy of the provisional certificate dated 20.01.2005 issued by
the Chhattisgarh University declaring that the petitioner has passed the
Bachelor of Arts (Honours) Economics in the examination held in 2004 was
produced. Based on the performance in the written exam and personal
interview, the Service Selection Committee on 10.08.2011 recommended the
petitioner for appointment for the post of LDC. He was promoted to UDC on
09.09.2014 and to the post of accountant on 18.11.2017. While so, the 1st
respondent received a complaint regarding alleged irregularities like
promotions/appointments based on false qualifications, and upon
investigation, it was found that the degree certificate obtained by the
petitioner from Chhattisgarh University was invalid. Accordingly, he was
issued with Ext.P10 notice dated 6.07.2021. The 2nd respondent heard the
petitioner, and he requested time for the submission of an explanation.
WPC. 17124/2021
8. He submitted Ext.P11 reply, and the departmental promotion
committee on 31.07.2021 recommended a review of the petitioner's case as
he has deliberately concealed and suppressed the fact that the B.A. degree
from Chhattisgarh University was invalid. Thereafter he was directed to be
reverted from the post of accountant to the post of Bundary. The recruitment
regulations of LDC and Shed Clerks are not approved by the Central
Government or published in the Official Gazette as required under Section
124 of the Major Port Trusts Act, is incorrect and denied. Under Section 28
of the Major Port Trusts Act 1963, the Cochin Port Trust Employees
(Recruitment, Seniority and Promotion) and Regulations, 2010 was issued in
exercise of the powers under Section 28 with the approval of the Central
Government as required under Section 124 of the Act.
9. In Class II, III, and IV, the manner of appointment shall be laid down by
the board from time to time. Accordingly, the board, in exercise of the power
vested in it, had laid down the regulation fixing graduation as a minimum
qualification.
10. Regarding Ext.P2 award, it pertains to different posts, and the issue is
different. Therefore, prayed for dismissal of the writ petition. An additional
counter affidavit was also filed in which the marks obtained by the candidates
WPC. 17124/2021
and the copy of the certificate were also produced. A reply affidavit is filed to
the counter affidavit filed by the respondents, in which it is stated that the
provisional degree certificate of B.A. Economics passed from Chhattisgarh
University submitted along with the application was entered into the service
of records correctly based on the application the petitioner was permitted to
appear for the examination. After joining LDC in 2011, he was placed on
probation for a period of two years, and after the declaration of probation, he
was further promoted to UDC and then Accountant.
11. As far as the 2010 regulation is concerned, the schedule contains only
recruitment posts of Class-1. The recruitment Rules of Classes II, III, and IV to
the post that includes the recruitment rules of LDC were only notified on
22.3.2016 in the State Gazette. Therefore, as of that date, the minimum
qualification required is SSLC, and though he has produced a degree
certificate, even if it is ignored, the petitioner is fully qualified for appointment
of LDC under the 20% quota. Therefore, prayed for allowing the prayers in
the writ petition.
12. Heard Sri.M.R. Hariraj, counsel for the petitioner and Sri.Jayamohan,
counsel for the respondents.
WPC. 17124/2021
13. The question to be decided in the writ petition is whether Ext.P12 and
P15 need interference. Ext.P12 is the order dated 17.08.2021 by which the
petitioner, while working as an accountant in the Civil Engineering
Department, is reverted to the post of Bundary with immediate effect.
Ext.P15 is the proceedings of the Secretary of the Cochin Port Trust, by which
a detailed examination of the case of the petitioner was done, and it was
decided to revert the petitioner to the post of Bundary. The short question
that arises for consideration is, on the date of application of the petitioner for
promotion to the post of LDC, whether the minimum qualification required
for the post can be fixed as graduation or not.
14. Ext.P1 is issued based on a letter issued by the Ministry of Surface
Transport for restructuring the staff in a ministerial wing and regarding the
basic qualification for direct recruitment as graduation. The Board of Trustees
held on 28.11.1997 decided to include graduation as a minimum qualification
for Class IV Employees, eligible for promotion as LDC in 20% quota. The
petitioners applied to the said post pursuant to Ext.R1(a) circular dated
03.03.2011, in which graduation is shown as a minimum qualification. It is not
in dispute that the minimum qualification for the post of LDC as graduation
was amended as per the Cochin Port Trust (Recruitment, Seniority and
WPC. 17124/2021
Promotion) Amendment Rules, 2015, which was published in the Gazette on
22.03.2016. Short title and commencement sub-clause -2 specifically state
that which shall come into force on the date of publication of the State
Gazette, therefore; the amendment incorporating the university degree in
any subject from a recognised university for the post of LDC for promotion
from Category -IV of the employees can only act prospectively from
22.03.2016 onwards.
15. Section 124 of the Major Port Trust Authorities Act, 1963 reads as
follows:
124. Provisions with respect to regulations.- (1) No regulation made
by the Board under this Act other than a regulation made under subsection(2) of section 17, shall have effect until it has been approved
by the Central Government and until such approval has been
published in the Official Gazette.
16. The board is given the power to make regulations not inconsistent with
the Act to provide for the appointment, promotions, suspension, removal of
its employees, their leave, and other service conditions. So once the board
makes the regulation under Section 28, the same has to be approved by the
Central Government and published in the Official Gazette. Section 124 states
explicitly that no regulation made by the Board shall have effect until the
Central Government has approved it and until such approval has to be
WPC. 17124/2021
published. So, there are two conditions to be satisfied for approval of the
regulation.
i) The Central Government should approve it, and it
should be published in the Official Gazette. Admittedly, the
resolution
of
the
board
fixing
the
minimum
qualification/graduation for the post of LDC to 20%
graduation is only approved by the Central Government and
published in the Gazette as per Ext.P8 amendment on
22.03.2016. Therefore, as of the date of application, the
minimum qualification required for the promotion to the
post of LDC from among the lower categories can only be
SSLC. Even though the petitioner has applied with the
provisional certificate issued by the Chhattisgarh University
and subsequently the Apex Court has held that the degree
issued by the said University is non est, it does not affect the
promotion of the petitioner, as he has got the minimum
qualification as on the date of consideration of the
application to the post of LDC.
ii) The respondent has found that he is fully qualified as
promoted to the post of LDC and subsequently UDC and to
an accountant. It is also a fact that in 2013, he obtained
another degree certificate from another university in Tamil
Nadu in 2013. Ext.P10 show cause notice is issued to the
petitioner only in the year 2021, a period of approximately
WPC. 17124/2021
10 years after he has been given promotion. As held earlier,
as a minimum qualification required as of the date of an
application pursuant to Ext.R1(a) can only be SSLC and not
graduation as the Special Rules have not been given effect to
approve by the Central Government as well as the
publication in the Official Gazette. It was only in 2016 that
the same was published.
Therefore, I have no hesitation in holding that Ext.P12 and P15 are issued
in violation of the then-existing rules regarding promotion. Therefore, Ext.P12
and P15 stand quashed. The writ petition allowed as stated above.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI,
JUDGE
ss
WPC. 17124/2021
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 17124/2021
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS OF MEETING NO.4 OF 1997-98 OF
BOARD OF TRUSTEES HELD ON 28/11/1997 ALONG WITH
RELEVANT AGENDA NOTE.
Exhibit P2
AWARD DATED 31/5/2011 OF CENTRAL GOVERNMENT
INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL CUM LABOUR COURT, ERNAKULAM, IN
ID 39/2008.
Exhibit P3
JUDGMENT DATED 29/8/2011 IN WP(C) 23334/2011 OF THIS
HONOURABLE COURT.
Exhibit P4
COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE SERVICE SELECTION
COMMITTEE HELD ON 10/8/2011.
Exhibit P5
ORDER NO.A10/4393/LDC/C1.IV/2011/S DATED 03/09/2011.
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY THE
CHHATTISGARH UNIVERSITY IN DECEMBER, 2004.
Exhibit P7
LETTER NO.PR 12012/12/2013-PE-1 DATED 6/4/2014.
Exhibit P8
COCHIN PORT TRUST (RECRUITMENT, SENIORITY AND
PROMOTION) AMENDMENT RULES, 2015.
Exhibit P9
JUDGMENT DATED 15/1/2019 OF THIS HONOURABLE COURT IN
WP(C) 955/2014.
Exhibit
P10
COPY OF THE NOTICE NO.A10/58/VIG/BBEN/2021/S DATED
6/7/2021.
WPC. 17124/2021
Exhibit
P11
REPRESENTATION DATED 19/07/2021.
Exhibit
P12
ORDER NO.A10/58/VIG/BBN-REVERSION/2021-S DATED
17/08/2021.
Exhibit
P13
CERTIFICATE DATED 11/1/2013 FROM MS UNIVERSITY
TIRUNALVELI.
Exhibit
P14
LETTER DATED 6/3/2021 ISSUED TO THE FIRST RESPONDENT
FROM THE MS UNIVERSITY.
Exhibit
P17
True Copy of the order No. D7/Probation/2013-S dated
28.11.2013
Exhibit
P18
True copy of the Agenda Item No.C4 in Board of
Trustees meeting for the year 2012-2013 dated 28-032013
Exhibit
P19
Agenda Item number C-6 in Board of Trustees Meeting
for the year 2013-14 dated 29-5-2013
Exhibit
P20
Agenda item No. C6 in Board of Trustees meeting for
the year 2013-14 dated 29.01.2014
Exhibit
P21
True copy of the judgment dated 26/11/2018 in
W.P.(C) 32038/2018
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit
R1(h)
A TRUE COPY OF STATEMENT OF MARKS OBTAINED IN THE
WRITTEN EXAMINATION HELD ON 21.07.2011.
WPC. 17124/2021
Exhibit
R1(I)
A TRUE COPY OF FIRST PAGE OF SERVICE BOOK OF
PETITIONER.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review