Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC040004892026
2026:GAU-AP:618
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/153/2026
Bijoy Pertin
Son of Shri Dana Pertin, resident of Pasighat, PO and PS Pasighat, Est Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh, currently posted at DFCSO, Pasihgat, East Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 3 Ors
through the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Food and Civil Supplies
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Director
Age: 0
Occupation :
Food and Civil Supplies
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4:Dana Yirang
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Maklung Yirang
permanent resident of Ruksin
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
current address C/o SDFCSO
Anini
Page No.# 2/13
Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh 79210
Advocate for the Petitioner : F.I. Choudhury; Muk Pertin, Senior Advocate, Dakjum Riba,Mukbang
Pertin,Takom Pabin,Tshering Yangzom Bhutia, Mukbom Pertin,Rimo Riba,Karyom Dabi
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP); D. Panging, Sr. Adv.; Abanso Gamre,B Padung,Vijay
Jamoh: Tagum Jamoh SC (Food and Civil Supplies Department)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
22.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
:
No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Mr. F. I. Choudhury, learned Counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms.
K. Wangmo, learned Government Advocate for the respondent No. 1; Mr. T.
Jamoh, learned Standing Counsel, Food and Civil Supplies Department for the
respondent Nos. 2 & 3 and Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by
Mr. V. Jamoh, learned counsel for the respondent No. 4.
2.
This writ petition has been filed challenging the order dated 19.03.2026,
issued vide E-File No. DFCS-11011/33/2022 by the Secretary, Department of
Food and Civil Supplies, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, whereby the
Page No.# 3/13
petitioner, who is serving as District Food and Civil Supplies Officer (DFCSO),
Pasighat, East Siang District, has been transferred to Roing and in his place, the
respondent No. 4, namely, Shri Dana Yirang, who is a Sub-Divisional Food and
Civil Supplies Officer (SDFCSO) and functioning as In-charge DFCSO, has been
posted at Pasighat, on the ground that the same has been issued only to
accommodate the respondent No. 4.
3.
The case of the petitioner, in brief, is that the petitioner is a regular District
Food and Civil Supplies Officer belonging to Group-'A' cadre and is presently
serving as DFCSO, Pasighat. According to the petitioner, he has been
discharging his duties with utmost sincerity and diligence in the interest of
public service. It is his case that the respondent No. 4 belongs to Group-'B'
cadre and holds the substantive post of SDFCSO and, therefore, a regular
Group-'A' Officer cannot be replaced by a Group-'B' Officer to hold charge of the
higher post.
4.
Mr. F. I. Choudhury, learned Counsel for the petitioner, submits that though
a SDFCSO may be allowed to hold charge of the post of DFCSO to meet
administrative exigencies, a regular Group-'A' Officer, particularly the seniormost officer in the cadre, cannot be displaced by a Group-'B' Officer holding
charge of the higher post. He submits that the petitioner is the senior-most
DFCSO in the cadre after the retirement of one Shri S. Chakraborty and,
therefore, the impugned transfer order replacing the petitioner by the
respondent No. 4, who is substantively an SDFCSO, is arbitrary and contrary to
the service hierarchy.
5.
Mr. Choudhury, learned Counsel, submits that the impugned transfer order
has been issued only to accommodate the respondent No. 4 and not in public
interest. He submits that the respondent No. 4 had sought transfer from Anini to
Page No.# 4/13
Pasighat on medical grounds and had also obtained recommendations from the
Hon'ble Member of Parliament and Members of Legislative Assembly through
U.O. Notes. According to the learned Counsel, the transfer was effected solely to
facilitate the posting of the respondent No. 4 at Pasighat on personal grounds
and not on account of any administrative exigency or in furtherance of public
interest.
6.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner further submits that the petitioner, upon
obtaining documents under the Right to Information Act, 2005, has come across
the Standing Order dated 07.07.2023 issued by the Secretary, Food and Civil
Supplies Department, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, wherein it has been
specifically provided that an SDFCSO posted as In-charge DFCSO shall not claim
further posting against a post held by a regular District Food and Civil Supplies
Officer. He submits that despite the aforesaid Standing Order, the respondent
No. 4, who is an SDFCSO and functioning as In-charge DFCSO, has been posted
against the post occupied by the petitioner and, therefore, the impugned order
is contrary to the departmental Standing Order.
7.
Mr. Choudhury, learned Counsel, further submits that the file notings
obtained under the Right to Information Act reveal that the authorities
themselves had observed that since Pasighat is a sanctioned post of DFCSO and
a regular DFCSO is already posted there, it would not be appropriate to replace
him by a junior officer in the rank of SDFCSO and had suggested that the
respondent No. 4 may be posted as SDFCSO under the petitioner or be
accommodated elsewhere. He submits that despite such noting, the respondent
authorities have issued the impugned order showing it to be in the interest of
public service, whereas the record itself reveals that the transfer was sought on
medical grounds and on the basis of recommendations made by political
Page No.# 5/13
functionaries.
8.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Choudhury, learned Counsel, has placed
reliance upon the judgment of this Court in Shri Niapung Konia vs. State of
Arunachal Pradesh & Others [WP(C) No. 257(AP)/2016], wherein this
Court held that in a case of inter se transfer, the transfer has to be effected
amongst members belonging to the same cadre and that an officer holding only
additional or functional charge of a higher post cannot replace an officer holding
the substantive post. It was held that an Assistant Engineer, who was merely
allowed to hold the charge of Executive Engineer on a stop-gap basis in his own
scale of pay, could not be transferred to the post of Executive Engineer so as to
replace a regular Executive Engineer and accordingly the transfer order was set
aside as being vitiated by a fundamental error.
9.
Learned Counsel has further relied upon the decision of this Court in Hibu
Tama vs. State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors., reported in (2021) 1 GLR
449, wherein this Court, following the ratio laid down in Niapung Konia
(supra), held that there cannot be an inter se transfer between officers who are
not similarly placed in the Department. In the said case, the petitioner, who was
functioning as Superintending Engineer and enjoying the pay, status and
position attached to the post, was sought to be replaced by an Executive
Engineer who had merely been permitted to look after the charge of
Superintending Engineer on a temporary basis in his own scale of pay. This
Court held that the two officers were not similarly situated and that such an
inter se transfer was impermissible in law.
10. Reliance has also been placed on the judgment of this Court in Er. Kipa
Rinia vs.
State of
Arunachal Pradesh & 4 Ors. [WP(C) No.
202(AP)/2018], wherein the Court held that although transfer is an incident
Page No.# 6/13
of service, the power of transfer has to be exercised bona fide, reasonably and
in public interest. It was further held that a transfer made not in administrative
exigency but with the object of accommodating another person for undisclosed
reasons amounts to mala fide and colourable exercise of power. In the said
case, the Court found that the transfer order had been issued on extraneous
considerations and merely to accommodate another officer and, accordingly,
quashed the same.
11. Mr. Choudhury, learned Counsel, submits that it is now well settled that
there cannot be an inter se transfer between officers who are not similarly
placed in the Department and that a regular officer holding a higher substantive
post cannot be displaced by a junior officer belonging to a lower cadre who is
merely holding charge of the higher post. Therefore, according to the learned
Counsel, the impugned order dated 19.03.2026 is arbitrary, contrary to the
settled principles laid down by this Court and is liable to be set aside and
quashed.
12. On the other hand, Mr. T. Jamoh, learned Standing Counsel, Food and Civil
Supplies Department appearing for the respondent Nos. 2 & 3, submits that
transfer and posting of Government servants is an incident of service and the
petitioner has no vested right to continue at Pasighat. He submits that the
petitioner has been serving at Pasighat since June, 2014 and has completed
more than 12 years at the same place and, therefore, his transfer was long
overdue.
13. Mr. Jamoh, learned Standing Counsel, submits that the records reveal that
the respondent No. 4 had submitted a representation dated 20.11.2024 seeking
transfer from Anini on account of his diabetic illness, the 100% cerebral palsy
suffered by his son and the advanced age and medical condition of his mother.
Page No.# 7/13
He submits that the said representation was processed by the Department and
various levels of officers examined the issue. It is submitted that though certain
recommendations were received from the Hon'ble Members of Legislative
Assembly and the Hon'ble Member of Parliament, the same by themselves did
not form the basis of the transfer and the final decision was taken by the
Government after taking into consideration all relevant aspects.
14. It is further submitted that various alternatives were examined at different
levels in the Department and opinions were expressed in the file notings,
however, such notings are merely part of the decision-making process and do
not confer any enforceable right upon the petitioner. Ultimately, considering that
the respondent No. 4 had been serving as In-charge DFCSO, Anini since
September, 2021 and that the petitioner had been serving as DFCSO, Pasighat
since June, 2014, the competent authority found their transfer and posting to be
overdue and accordingly approved the transfer order.
15. Learned Standing Counsel further submits that there are several SDFCSOs
functioning as In-charge DFCSOs in the State and that the impugned order does
not adversely affect the rank, status or emoluments of the petitioner, who
continues to hold the substantive post of DFCSO at Roing.
16. According to the learned Standing Counsel, no mala fide or violation of any
statutory provision has been established and, therefore, no interference with the
impugned order is warranted.
17. Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, for the respondent No. 4, submits
that the respondent No. 4 was promoted to the post of SDFCSO on 27.09.2011
and in terms of the applicable Recruitment Rules, the post of SDFCSO is the
feeder cadre for promotion to the post of DFCSO. He submits that the
Page No.# 8/13
respondent No. 4 had completed the requisite qualifying service for promotion
to the post of DFCSO long ago, however, despite existence of substantive
vacancies, no regular Departmental Promotion Committee has been held and,
therefore, the respondent No. 4 has been serving as In-charge DFCSO since
16.08.2021.
18. Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, submits that out of the 31 sanctioned
posts of DFCSO in the State, as many as 19 posts are being manned by officers
functioning as In-charge DFCSO and, therefore, the contention of the petitioner
that the respondent No. 4, being substantively an SDFCSO, could not have been
posted as In-charge DFCSO at Pasighat is misconceived. He submits that had
regular promotions been undertaken in accordance with the Government
guidelines, the respondent No. 4 would have been promoted to the rank of
DFCSO.
19. Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, submits that though two U.O. Notes
were issued by the Hon'ble Member of Parliament and Members of Legislative
Assembly recommending the transfer of the respondent No. 4, the transfer was
not effected on the basis of the said recommendations but on account of the
medical condition and family problems of the respondent No. 4 as disclosed in
his representation dated 20.11.2024. He submits that merely because certain
U.O. Notes were issued by public representatives, the same by itself would not
vitiate the transfer order and no inference of mala fide can be drawn therefrom.
20. Learned Senior Counsel for the respondent No. 4 further submits that the
petitioner has been serving at Pasighat for the last 12 years and his transfer was
long overdue. He submits that it has been consistently held by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court as well as by this Court that no Government servant has a
vested right to remain posted at a particular place and prolonged stay at one
Page No.# 9/13
station may give rise to vested interests. He further submits that the petitioner
has already been relieved from Pasighat on 12.05.2026 and has joined at Roing
on 19.05.2026, whereas the respondent No. 4 has been relieved from Anini on
23.04.2026 and joined at Pasighat on 28.04.2026 and both the officers are
presently serving at their respective places of posting.
21.
Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, also submits that though the
petitioner has alleged that the transfer order was issued at the instance of
political functionaries, neither the Hon'ble Member of Parliament nor the
Members of Legislative Assembly, whose recommendations are sought to be
relied upon by the petitioner, have been impleaded as party respondents in the
present proceedings. He submits that in the absence of the concerned persons
against whom allegations are made being impleaded as parties, the plea of
mala fide is not maintainable and on this ground alone the writ petition is liable
to be dismissed.
22.
Accordingly, Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the
petitioner has failed to establish any mala fide or violation of any statutory
provision and, therefore, the impugned transfer order dated 19.03.2026
warrants no interference by this Court.
23. I have considered the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the
parties and also perused the materials available on record.
24. Admittedly, the petitioner is a regular District Food and Civil Supplies Officer
belonging to Group-'A' cadre and is presently posted as DFCSO, Roing pursuant
to the impugned transfer order dated 19.03.2026. It is also not in dispute that
the respondent No. 4 is substantively a SDFCSO belonging to Group-'B' cadre
and has been functioning as In-charge DFCSO since September, 2021.
Page No.# 10/13
25. The principal contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner is that a
regular Group-'A' officer cannot be replaced by a Group-'B' officer holding
charge of the higher post and that the impugned order dated 19.03.2026 has
been issued only to accommodate the respondent No. 4. It is also contended
that the transfer is actuated by extraneous considerations and political
recommendations and is contrary to the Standing Order dated 07.07.2023
issued by the Department.
26.
From perusal of the records, it appears that respondent No. 4 had
submitted a representation seeking transfer from Anini to Pasighat on account
of his diabetic condition, the 100% cerebral palsy suffered by his son and the
ailments of his aged mother. The records further reveal that by Note No. 43
dated 10.02.2026, the matter was re-processed and the representation of
respondent No. 4 along with the U.O. Notes and supporting medical documents
were
placed
before
the
authority
for
consideration.
It
appears
that
recommendations from certain Hon'ble Members of Legislative Assembly and
the Hon'ble Member of Parliament were also placed before the Department.
However, the records reveal that the matter was examined at different levels
and various alternatives were considered before the proposal was finally
approved by the competent authority.
27. It is true that at one stage, it was observed that since Pasighat is a
sanctioned post of DFCSO and a regular DFCSO was already posted there,
replacing him by a junior officer in the rank of SDFCSO may not be appropriate
and alternative postings were suggested. However, such note sheets merely
form part of the decision-making process and do not constitute the final decision
of the Government. It is well settled that opinions expressed in the note sheets
are merely part of the decision-making process and do not by themselves
Page No.# 11/13
constitute a decision of the Government. The petitioner, therefore, cannot claim
any enforceable right on the basis of the observations.
28. The records further show that the competent authority took note of the
fact that respondent No. 4 had been functioning as In-charge DFCSO since
September, 2021 and that the petitioner had been continuously serving at
Pasighat since June, 2014. Taking into account the long stay of the petitioner at
one station and the medical and family circumstances of respondent No. 4, the
transfer and posting order was approved. It is also not in dispute that
respondent No. 4 was relieved from Anini on 23.04.2026 and joined at Pasighat
on 28.04.2026, whereas the petitioner was relieved from Pasighat on
12.05.2026 and joined as DFCSO, Roing on 19.05.2026.
29. The petitioner has placed reliance upon the decisions of this Court in
Niapung Konia (supra), Hibu Tama (supra) and Er. Kipa Rinia (supra),
wherein this Court interfered with the impugned transfer orders having found,
on the facts of those cases, that inter se transfers between officers who were
not similarly placed in the service hierarchy were impermissible and, in the case
of Er. Kipa Rinia (supra), that the transfer order had been issued merely to
accommodate the private respondent and not in public interest. There can be no
quarrel with the principles laid down in the aforesaid decisions. However, the
principle that there cannot ordinarily be an inter se transfer between officers
who are not similarly situated is not absolute and its applicability would depend
upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
30. In Er. Taban Tabing vs. State of Arunachal Pradesh & 2 Ors., WA No.
21(AP)/2025, decided on 19.06.2025, the Division Bench of this Court held
that although ordinarily it may not be permissible to make inter se transfers
between officers who are not similarly placed in the Department, there would
Page No.# 12/13
not be a complete bar to transfer and posting of officers serving on in-charge,
officiating or functional basis, provided that no prejudice is caused to the rank,
status, service conditions or career prospects of the transferred officer and the
transfer is necessitated by administrative exigencies. The Division Bench further
reiterated the settled principle that the scope of judicial review in matters of
transfer to an equivalent post without any adverse consequence is extremely
limited and interference is warranted only on the grounds of mala fides or
violation of any statutory provision.
31. In the present case, the petitioner continues to hold the substantive post of
DFCSO and is presently serving as DFCSO, Roing. Nothing has been brought on
record to show that his rank, status, pay, emoluments or promotional prospects
have been adversely affected. Therefore, merely because respondent No. 4,
whose substantive post is that of SDFCSO, has been posted as In-charge DFCSO
at Pasighat, the same by itself cannot render the impugned order illegal.The
Standing Order dated 07.07.2023 relied upon by the petitioner is only an
executive instruction and, in the facts of the present case, cannot be construed
as creating an absolute prohibition against such transfer and posting. More so,
the petitioner had been serving at Pasighat since June, 2014 and his transfer
cannot be said to be premature or arbitrary.
32. So far as the allegation that the transfer was made on the basis of political
recommendations is concerned, merely because U.O. Notes issued by public
representatives formed part of the records, the same by itself cannot lead to an
inference that the transfer was actuated by mala fides or extraneous
considerations. A profitable reference may be made to the case of Mohd.
Masood Ahmad vs. State of U.P., reported in (2007) 8 SCC 150, wherein the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, after referring to several earlier decisions has,
Page No.# 13/13
reiterated that interference with transfer orders should be made only in very
rare cases. It held that even if a transfer has been made on the
recommendation of an MLA, the same by itself would not vitiate the transfer
order and there can be no hard and fast rule that every transfer made on the
recommendation of an MP or MLA would be illegal. It was observed that it
would depend on the facts and circumstances of each case.
33. In the present case, apart from the recommendations relied upon by the
petitioner, no material has been placed before this Court to establish malice in
fact or malice in law. On the contrary, the records show that the request made
by respondent No. 4 was independently processed and examined by the
Department before the competent authority took a final decision.
34. In view of the settled position of law and in the absence of any proven
mala fide or violation of any statutory provision, this Court finds no reason to
interfere with the impugned order dated 19.03.2026.
35.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed being devoid of merit. No
order as to costs.
JUDGE
Victoria
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review