Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 12th November, 2018
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Petitioner
:
Bijay Gurung
versus
Respondents
:
The State of Sikkim and Others
Application under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Ms. Panila Theengh, Mr. Karma Sonam Lhendup
and Ms. Tashi Doma Sherpa, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General, Mr. Karma Thinlay,
Senior Government Advocate with Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia,
Government Advocate, Mr. S. K. Chettri and Mrs. Pollin Rai,
Assistant Government Advocates for State-Respondents No.1, 2 and
3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The impugned Office Order bearing No.10/SPE/RDR/
2004(Vol-II)558/SPIC, dated 09-07-2016 (Annexure P5), of the
Respondent No.3, Superintendent of Police, East District, Gangtok,
Sikkim, imposed the penalty of compulsory retirement on the
Petitioner pursuant to a departmental enquiry under the Sikkim
Police Force (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1989 (hereinafter “1989
Rules”). Claiming irregularities and non-compliance of statutory
provisions in the departmental enquiry which culminated in the
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
impugned Office Order supra, the Petitioner exhorts that his
fundamental rights have been abrogated and seeks reprieve.
2.
In the year 1996, the Petitioner was recruited in the first
batch of the Indian Reserve Battalion (hereinafter “IRB”) and posted
in Delhi from 1996 to 2011, where, according to him, he served with
honesty, integrity and to the best of his ability. In the year 2015,
the IRB was merged with the Sikkim Police and the Petitioner
transferred to the said Force.
Beset with family problems at the
relevant time, his performance declined following which he was
ordered to undergo Reformatory Course at the Sikkim Armed Police,
Pangthang, East Sikkim (hereinafter “SAP”) from 19-02-2016 to 2003-2016.
In compliance thereof, he joined the Course on 19-02-
2016, where on 20-02-2016 on an alleged search of his bag,
controlled substances comprising of eight bottles of “Khoos Khoos”
cough syrup, eight strips of Spasmo Proxyvon containing sixty-four
capsules and one strip of Nitrosun 10, containing ten tablets were
recovered.
That, the allegation being false was consequently not
reported to the concerned Police Station despite the mandate of the
Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006. Office Order bearing No.010/POL/SPE/
RDR/2004(Vol-II)/161, dated 20-02-2016 (Annexure P1), impugned
herein, came to be issued by the Respondent No.3 placing the
Petitioner under suspension in contemplation of departmental
proceedings. The Office Order was allegedly issued on a Complaint
received from the Training Officer, SAP, informing the Respondent
No.3 of recovery of the aforestated controlled substances. This was
followed by Memorandum bearing No.10/POL/SPE/RDR/2004/193,
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
dated 27-02-2016 (Annexure P2), also impugned, issued by the
Respondent No.3 proposing to hold an enquiry against the Petitioner
and directing him to submit within ten days of the receipt of the
Memorandum, a written statement of his defence and whether he
desired to be heard in person, duly appending the statement of
articles of charge. That the list of documents on the basis of which
the articles of charge were to be proved were not made over to the
Petitioner.
Although Sl. No.2 of the list pertains to a Property
Seizure Memo but as no criminal case was registered against the
Petitioner the requirement of such a document is questionable. Vide
Order of the disciplinary authority, Respondent No.3, bearing No.
10/POL/SPE/RDR/2004(Vol-II)/213, dated 09-03-2016, (Annexure
P3), one Prasad Dewan, Dy. SP, SDPO, Pakyong was appointed as
the Inquiry Officer (hereinafter “I.O.”) and PI Bikash Tiwari, SHO,
Pakyong P.S., as the Presenting Officer (hereinafter “P.O.”) to
present the matter on behalf of the disciplinary authority.
Both
Officers being subordinate to and working under the Respondent
No.3 are alleged to be amenable to his directions.
Upon his
appointment the I.O. issued a letter dated 09-03-2016 (Annexure
P4) to the Petitioner directing him to file his written statement of
defence, without furnishing the relevant documents, within a period
of ten days from the receipt of the said letter revealing thereby his
ignorance of the Memorandum dated 27-02-2016 (Annexure P2)
supra, thereby indicating the ulterior motive of the authorities. That,
the records made over to the Petitioner reveal that the Respondent
No.3 and the I.O. were evidently at the same place on 09-03-2016
to have issued Annexure P3 (supra) and Annexure P4 (supra). It is
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
alleged that the Petitioner who was directed to be stationed in the
Office of the Respondent No.3 vide Office Order dated 20-02-2016
(Annexure P1) was coerced and intimidated not to assail the abovementioned Office Orders and Memorandum with assurances of
leniency in the enquiry.
That, the Petitioner till then was neither
served with the Office Order dated 20-02-2016 nor a copy of the
Memorandum but his signature obtained on blank paper on the
pretext that it would be used to mark his attendance.
In such
hostile circumstances, the Petitioner was compelled to file his
written statement without fully comprehending the charges levelled
against
him
sans
documents
or
statement
of
witnesses.
Nevertheless, the Petitioner has denied the charges framed against
him in his written defence as false and fabricated. Pursuant thereto,
the
enquiry
was
conducted
without
following
the
procedure
prescribed in Rule 7 of the 1989 Rules and without extending an
opportunity to the Petitioner of making any verbal representation or
the
benefit
witnesses.
of
examining
documents
or
cross-examining
the
Admittedly he appeared before the I.O. on four
occasions but alleges the absence of the P.O. except on one date.
Further, that none of the listed witnesses were seen by him at the
enquiry, nor was he allowed to take the help of his superiors or legal
assistance. On subsequent realisation by the Respondents that the
departmental enquiry against the Petitioner would not sustain, the
Respondents coerced him to admit and plead guilty to the charges
levelled against him, following which, the impugned Order bearing
No.10/POL/RDR/2004(Vol-II)558/SPIC,
dated
09-07-2016
(Annexure P5), was issued by the Respondent No.3. In the month
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
of August 2016, the Petitioner with false assurances and in the
absence of records of the enquiry was persuaded to apologise but
his apology was treated as an Appeal under Rule 11 of the 1989
Rules by the Respondent No.2 before whom he was neither
summoned nor proceedings initiated.
Office Order dated 22-08-
2016 (Annexure P7) instead was served on him confirming the
penalty imposed.
The Petitioner on legal advice approached the
Respondent No.3 seeking the departmental enquiry records on
several occasions, but none were forthcoming. Hence, the prayers
in the Petition as follows;
(a)
to
issue
a
Impugned
writ/order
Office
or
Order
direction
to
quash/set
aside
No.010/POL/SPE/RDR/2004(Vol-
II)/161 dated 20.02.2016, Memorandum No.10/POL/SPE/
RDR/2004/193
dated
27.02.2016
and
Office
Order
10/SPE/RDR/2004(Vol-II)558/SPIC dated 09.07.2016 issued
by Respondent No.3 and Office Order No.169/PHQ/L&O/2016
dated 22.08.2016 issued by Respondent No.2;
(b)
to issue appropriate Writ/Order or direction to quash all
subsequent
amendments
to
the
Sikkim
Police
Force
(Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1989 brought about after 1989;
(c)
to pass any other direction/s, relief/s, order/s that may be
deemed fit and proper in the circumstances of this case;
(d)
to allow the costs of the Writ Petition in favour of the
Petitioner.
3.
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 filed a joint Counter-Affidavit
disputing and denying the allegations made in the Writ Petition or
violation of fundamental rights of the Petitioner. That, on the
recommendation of the concerned SDPO on 15-02-2016, the
Petitioner along with eight others was sent to SAP, Pangthang, for a
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
Reformatory Course from the Sadar P.S., Gangtok, where they were
posted, on failure to perform their duties diligently. During the
morning physical training on 20-02-2016 the Petitioner‟s inability to
walk/run was noticed following which at around 0730 hours after the
morning session a surprise check of the belongings of the Petitioner
was conducted by two ASIs and one Head Constable (H/C) stationed
at SAP.
The search led to recovery of the controlled substances
detailed supra from a pair of black boots belonging to the Petitioner
kept under his bed. The seized items were duly handed over to the
Respondent No.3 along with a Property Seizure Memo prepared by
the Training Officer, SAP. Consequently, the Petitioner was placed
under suspension vide impugned Office Order dated 20-02-2016 and
disciplinary proceedings initiated against him for gross misconduct
and negligence in terms of Rule 7 of the 1989 Rules and the Sikkim
Police Force (Disciplinary & Appeal) Amendment Rules, 1995
(hereinafter “Amendment Rules 1995”).
Pursuant thereto, the
Memorandum dated 27-02-2016 (Annexure P2) was issued by the
Respondent
No.3
to
the
Petitioner
while
the
I.O.
issued
correspondence dated 09-03-2016 (Annexure P4). Although on 1703-2016 when the Petitioner filed his written statement to the
articles of charge (Annexure R6) he accepted the charges framed
against him contrarily when the I.O. recorded his statement he
denied ownership of the articles.
On 30-03-2016, the I.O. also
recorded the statements of six witnesses in the presence of the P.O.
PI Bikash Tiwari. On 28-06-2016, the I.O. recorded the statements
of the Training Officer and thereafter afforded an opportunity to the
Petitioner to cross-examine the Officer, which he declined.
On
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
completion of departmental enquiry on 30-06-2016, the I.O.
submitted report to the Respondent No.3, who after taking into
consideration the report, imposed the penalty of compulsory
retirement on 09-07-2016 with effect from 20-02-2016, the date of
suspension of the Petitioner. On 01-08-2016, the Petitioner filed an
Appeal before the appellate authority requesting grant of pardon
who on 22-08-2016 after hearing the Petitioner upheld the Orders of
the disciplinary authority. As per the Respondents the Writ Petition
is liable to be dismissed as it is neither maintainable in law or facts
and suffers from delay and laches as penalty imposed was
confirmed on 22-08-2016 but the Writ Petition has been filed only
on 21-11-2016.
4.
In Rejoinder, the Petitioner while denying recovery of
the controlled substances from his possession would also reiterate
the facts put forth in the averments made in his Petition which for
brevity are not reiterated herein.
It was also averred that the
State-Respondents in its Counter-Affidavit did not deliberately file
certain records, viz.; the letter dated 01-04-2017 which was the
letter of the Petitioner through his Counsel being Annexure P9.
(Pausing here for a minute, Learned Counsel was unable to establish
that the alleged Annexure P9 was filed by the Petitioner before this
Court or that it existed in the records of the instant matter, despite
walking this Court through the documents filed.) That, the StateRespondents however made available letter dated 20-04-2017,
Office Orders dated 07-02-2017 and 14-02-2017. Both these Office
Orders pertain to the second delinquent LNK/960197 Karma Bhutia
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
(hereinafter
“second
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
delinquent”)
against
whom
proceedings with the Petitioner was undertaken.
common
It was also
reiterated that in view of the submissions made in the Writ Petition
and the Rejoinder Affidavit the prayers of the Petitioner be allowed.
5.
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Learned Counsel advancing his
arguments for the Petitioner drew the attention of this Court to Rule
7 of the 1989 Rules and contended that the provisions elucidated
therein have been grossly violated by the Respondents No.2 and 3
inasmuch
as
although
at
Sl.
No.1
of
Annexure
III
of
the
Memorandum (Annexure P2) issued by the Respondent No.3 details
a report submitted by the Training Officer of SAP, this alleged report
was not made available to the Petitioner nor does it find place in the
records of the case which reveals that the matter was an endeavour
to frame the Petitioner without any basis. The Rules mandate supply
of documents to the Petitioner not only to prove the charges against
him but to enable his defence, however no such documents were
made available to him. The controlled substances were seized not
from the person of the Petitioner but admittedly recovered from the
pair of boots kept under the bed of the Petitioner without verification
as to whether the boots actually belonged to the Petitioner. That,
seizure of any Article could be resorted to only in the event of
criminal proceedings against the Petitioner but records reveal that
no criminal case was ever registered against the Petitioner as the
allegations were false. The appointments of I.O. and the P.O. are
against the tenets of equity and fair play as both Officers work
directly under the Respondent No.3 and would therefore be
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
acquiescent to his directions in regard to the action to be taken
against the Petitioner.
That, anomalies arise also in the orders of
appointment of the I.O. since Annexure P3 would indicate that the
I.O. was appointed on 09-03-2016 but the I.O. has signed on
Annexure R4 after receiving the departmental enquiry File in respect
of the Petitioner on 03-03-2016 itself, which concludes that the File
was received by the I.O. on 03-03-2016, prior to his appointment,
on 09-03-2016.
Further, Annexure R9 would indicate that the
statement of the Training Officer was allegedly recorded on 28-062016, but his statement is bereft of any report given against the
Petitioner contrary to what has been stated in the impugned Office
Order dated 20-02-2016.
Training
Officer
is
Besides, the entire statement of the
computer
generated
but
the
sentences
―Opportunity has been given to both the delinquent for cross
examination of the witness but they declined to do so‖ is
handwritten indicating its insertion as an afterthought without
actually affording the Petitioner such opportunity.
disciplinary
proceedings
were
initiated
not
only
That, the
against
the
Petitioner but also against second delinquent where although the
memorandum of charge was prepared individually, the statement of
the Training Officer pertains to both the delinquents which is
therefore irregular and deserves to be set aside. That the statement
of H/C Bhagat Thapa was recorded by the I.O. on 28-06-2016 where
both the Petitioner and the other delinquent have signed whereas
there ought to be different statements for each of the alleged
delinquents and their signatures obtained separately to indicate that
both had understood the statement and sufficient opportunity had
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
not been offered to them to cross-examine the witnesses. Despite
both the Petitioner and the second delinquent being tried together
during the departmental enquiry, the case of the second delinquent
was taken into consideration by the Director General of Police (DGP)
and his order of compulsory retirement revised to voluntary
retirement, by stating that prescribed procedure for awarding
punishment was not followed.
The case of the Petitioner however
was not taken into consideration thereby establishing a bias against
him.
In view of the joint enquiry of both delinquents the
consideration given to the second delinquent is also applicable to the
Petitioner. That the letter dated “8-16”, Annexure P6 (clarified to be
of 01-08-2018), was a request for pardon and relaxation but was
instead treated as an Appeal contrary to Rule 11 of the 1989 Rules
and decided and disposed of by the IGP.
vitiated,
the
reliefs
prayed
for
be
That, the enquiry being
granted.
To
fortify
his
submissions, reliance was placed on decision of this Court in Tashi
Chopel Bhutia vs. The State of Sikkim and Others .
6.
Resisting the arguments Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Learned
Additional Advocate General would canvass the contention that no
grounds exist for setting aside the Office Order dated 09-07-2016
(Annexure P5) which is compliant to all provisions laid down in the
1989 Rules.
That, the enquiry report has infact not been
challenged, in such circumstances, the report is valid and hence, the
penalty and the orders issued on the appeal of the Petitioner also
follow suit.
That, the appeal filed by the Petitioner dated 01-08-
MANU/SI/0038/2016
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
2016 before the IGP was duly considered by the concerned authority
and the orders of the disciplinary authority upheld.
He would
further contend that the records clearly reveal that the Petitioner
has admitted to the offences charged with. That, Rule 7(4) of the
1989 Rules provides that the disciplinary authority shall deliver or
cause to be delivered to the police officer a copy of the articles of
charge, the statement of the imputations of misconduct and
misbehaviour and a list of documents and witnesses by which each
article of charge is proposed to be sustained.
The provision also
requires the police officer to submit within such time as may be
specified, a written statement of his defence and to state whether
he desires to be heard in person.
no.71/SDPO/
Pakyong
dated
Annexure R5, Memo bearing
09-03-2016
made
over
to
the
Petitioner by the I.O. indicates compliance of the said Rules. That,
the written statement of the Petitioner submitted to the I.O. reveals
in unequivocal terms that the controlled substances were recovered
by the Police personnel from a bag and admittedly were for the
Petitioner‟s use.
Being contrite, he sought excuse for the act and
assured its non-repetition thereby clearly confessing his guilt.
Learned Additional Advocate General would rely on the decision of
Manoj H. Mishra
vs. Union of India2 to contend that where the
Petitioner had once admitted his guilt in his written statement he
cannot resile from his statement at a later stage and that the
penalty imposed on the Petitioner is proportionate to the gravity of
the offence.
That, in the event this Court reaches a finding that
there has been non-compliance of the mandatory requirements and
(2013) 6 SCC 313
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
the principles of natural justice violated, then the Court while setting
aside the order of punishment can remit the matter to the
disciplinary authority to enable it to take a fresh decision from the
stage that it stood vitiated. Reliance was placed on the decisions of
Chairman, Life Insurance Corporation of India
Masilamani
and Others
vs. A.
and Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad and Others vs. B.
Karunakar and Others .
It was urged that the Court cannot go into
the decision made by the concerned authorities but would only
consider
the
irregularities
in
the
decision-making
process.
Conceding to the fact that Rule 7(16) of the 1989 Rules was not
complied with, Learned Additional Advocate General would hold that
the said provision requires that when the case for the disciplinary
authority is closed, the police officer shall be required to state his
defence, orally or in writing, as he may prefer.
If the defence is
made orally, it shall be recorded and the police officer shall be
required to sign the record. In either case, a copy of the statement
of defence shall be given to the P.O., if any, appointed. No copy of
such statement was made over to the P.O.
However, the other
provisions of Rule 7 of 1989 Rules have been complied to the letter.
Further, he would contend that although the delinquent asserts that
cross-examination was not conducted, the documents on record
would prove otherwise.
That should the Petitioner allege prejudice
on account of irregularity in following procedure the burden to
establish prejudice would be upon him. Strength on this count was
garnered from the ratio in State of U.P. vs. Harendra Arora and
(2013) 6 SCC 530
(1993) 4 SCC 727
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
Another .
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
He would further argue that infraction of every statutory
provision does not make the procedure invalid buttressing his
arguments with the decision in Union of India and Others vs. P.
Gunasekaran .
7.
Careful and anxious consideration has been given to the
submissions made at the Bar, the documents which Learned
Counsel have walked this Court through during the hearing have
also been carefully perused and considered as also the Judgments
relied on.
8.
The question for consideration is whether there were
procedural defects in the departmental enquiry, if so, whether it
was in breach of principles of natural justice or violation of any rules
to the prejudice of the Petitioner?
9.
Before embarking on a discussion of the merits of the
matter, we may refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in State
of Andhra Pradesh and Others
vs. Chitra Venkata Rao7.
While
discussing the scope of Article 226 of the Constitution in dealing
with departmental enquiries, the Supreme Court would hold as
follows;
―21. The scope of Article 226 in dealing with
departmental inquiries has come up before this Court.
Two propositions were laid down by this Court in State
of A.P. v. S. Sree Rama Rao [AIR 1963 SC 1723 : (1964) 3
SCR 25 : (1964) 2 LLJ 150]. First, there is no warrant for
the view that in considering whether a public officer is
guilty of misconduct charged against him, the rule
followed in criminal trials that an offence is not
established unless proved by evidence beyond
(2001) 6 SCC 392
(2015) 2 SCC 610
(1975) 2 SCC 557
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
reasonable doubt to the satisfaction of the Court must
be applied. If that rule be not applied by a domestic
tribunal of inquiry the High Court in a petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution is not competent to
declare the order of the authorities holding a
departmental enquiry invalid. The High Court is not a
court of appeal under Article 226 over the decision of
the authorities holding a departmental enquiry against
a public servant. The Court is concerned to determine
whether the enquiry is held by an authority competent
in that behalf and according to the procedure
prescribed in that behalf, and whether the rules of
natural justice are not violated. Second, where there is
some evidence which the authority entrusted with the
duty to hold the enquiry has accepted and which
evidence may reasonably support the conclusion that
the delinquent officer is guilty of the charge, it is not
the function of the High Court to review the evidence
and to arrive at an independent finding on the
evidence. The High Court may interfere where the
departmental authorities have held the proceedings
against the delinquent in a manner inconsistent with
the rules of natural justice or in violation of the
statutory rules prescribing the mode of enquiry or
where the authorities have disabled themselves from
reaching a fair decision by some considerations
extraneous to the evidence and the merits of the case
or by allowing themselves to be influenced by
irrelevant considerations or where the conclusion on
the very face of it is so wholly arbitrary and capricious
that no reasonable person could ever have arrived at
that conclusion. The departmental authorities are, if
the enquiry is otherwise properly held, the sole judges
of facts and if there is some legal evidence on which
their findings can be based, the adequacy or reliability
of that evidence is not a matter which can be
permitted to be canvassed before the High Court in a
proceeding for a writ under Article 226.
22.
Again, this Court in Railway Board,
representing the Union of India, New Delhi v. Niranjan
Singh [(1969) 1 SCC 502 : (1969) 3 SCR 548] said that the
High Court does not interfere with the conclusion of
the disciplinary authority unless the finding is not
supported by any evidence or it can be said that no
reasonable person could have reached such a
finding. ………………………………………..‖
[emphasis supplied]
10.
The Judgment with clarity elucidates the stance that can
be adopted by the High Court in matters under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India in relation to departmental enquiries. It is also
now settled by a plethora of other Judgments that in matters of
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
disciplinary proceedings the High Court exercises a limited power as
the grounds for judicial review are limited and would be reluctant to
intervene unless the findings are wholly perverse, illegal, untenable
or in prejudice of the statutory provisions or principles of natural
justice.
11.
It would now be appropriate to examine whether the
procedure prescribed was followed in the instant matter for which
consideration may be taken of the following provisions.
12.
Rule 7 of the 1989 Rules is the provision that deals with
procedure for imposing penalties specified in Clauses (xi) to (xv) of
Rule 3.
By an amendment vide Notification bearing No.183/GEN/
DOP on 12-08-2009 the above clauses are under the marginal
heading of “Major penalties”.
The said provisions are extracted
below;
―3. Penalties.— Without prejudice to the provision
of any law, or any special orders for the time being in
force, the following penalties may, for good and
sufficient reasons, be imposed on any police officer,
namely:....................................................................
Major penalties
(xi)
Reduction to a lower stage in the time
scale of pay for a specified period, with
further directions as to whether or not the
police officer will earn increments of pay
during the period of such reduction and
whether on the expiry of such period, the
reduction will or will not have the effect of
postponing the future increments of his
pay;
(xii)
Reduction to a lower time-scale of pay,
grade, post or Service which shall
ordinarily be a to promotion of the police
officer to the time scale of pay, grade,
post or Service from which he was
reduced, with or without further directions
regarding conditions of restoration to the
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
grade or post or Service from which the
police officer was reduced and his
seniority and pay on such restoration to
that grade, post or Service;
(xiii) Compulsory retirement;
(xiv) Removal from service which shall not be a
disqualification for future employment
under the Government;
(xv)
Dismissal from service which shall
ordinarily be a disqualification for future
employment under the Government.
......………………………………………..‖
13.
[emphasis supplied]
In the instant matter, the penalty imposed on the
Petitioner is in terms of Rule 3(xiii), i.e., compulsory retirement.
Rule 7(1) provides that no order imposing any of the penalties
specified in Clauses (xi) to (xv) of Rule 3, which also includes
compulsory retirement at Clause (xiii), shall be made except after
an enquiry is held, in the manner as provided in the Rule.
The
disciplinary authority for the purposes of the instant matter is the
Senior Superintendent of Police, Respondent No.3, he is also the
appointing authority, while the appellate authority is the Deputy
Inspector General of Police/ Inspector General of Police in terms of
Notification No.81/GEN/DOP dated 23-11-1998.
The argument of
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner that Respondent No.3 is not the
appointing authority is not tenable as the Notification No.62/
GEN/DOP dated 29-13-1995 clarifies the position and confirms that
he is indeed the appointing authority. Rule 7(2) lays down that if
the disciplinary authority is of the opinion that there are grounds for
inquiring into the truth of any imputation of misconduct or
misbehaviour against a police officer, the disciplinary authority can
either inquire into the imputation himself or appoint an authority for
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
the matter.
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
In the instant case, the disciplinary authority vide its
Order bearing No.10/POL/SPE/RDR/2004(Vol-II)/213, dated 09-032016, has appointed Deputy Superintendent of Police (Dy.SP)
Prasad Dewan, the SDPO as the I.O.
14.
Rule 7(3) pertains to proposal to hold an inquiry against
a police officer, in such a situation the disciplinary authority shall
draw up or cause to be drawn up (i) the substance of the
imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour into definite and distinct
articles of charge; (ii) a statement of the imputations of misconduct
or misbehaviour in support of each article of charge, which shall
contain (a) a statement of all relevant facts including any admission
or confession made by the police officer; and
(b) a list of
documents by which and a list of witnesses by whom, the articles of
charge are proposed to be sustained.
In this context, we may
examine whether this provision has been complied with in the
instant
matter.
The
disciplinary
authority
has
prepared
Memorandum bearing No. 10/POL/SPE/RDR/2004/193, dated 2702-2016. The Memorandum includes at Annexure I the Statement
of articles of charge framed against the Petitioner, Annexure II the
Statement of imputation of misconduct or misbehaviour in support
of the articles of charge framed against the Petitioner, Annexure III
is the list of documents as required under Rule 7(3)(b) and
Annexure IV is the list of witnesses also furnished as per Rule
7(3)(b) of the 1989 Rules.
No admission or confession of the
delinquent finds mention in the Memorandum in terms of Rule
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
7(3)(a), evidently as none existed at that point in time.
Hence,
there is compliance of Rule 7(3) of the 1989 Rules.
15.
Rule 7(4) of 1989 Rules reads as follows;
―(4) The disciplinary authority shall deliver or
cause to be delivered to the police officer a copy of the
articles of charge, the statement of the imputations of
misconduct or misbehaviour and a list of documents
and witnesses by which each article of charge is
proposed to be sustained and shall require the police
officer to submit, within such time as may be specified,
a written statement of his defence and to state
whether he desires to be heard in person.‖
16.
An examination of Annexure R3 relied on by the
Respondents which is the Memorandum dated 27-02-2016 issued by
the disciplinary authority, reveal at Sl. Nos.1, 2 and 6 as follows;
―……………………………………………………………………………
MEMORANDUM
1.
The undersigned proposes to hold an
inquiry against Nk.960208 Bijay Gurung of
Sadar P.S., East District under Rule 7 of
the Sikkim Police Force (Discipline &
Appeal) Rules, 1989. The substance of
the
imputations
of
misconduct
or
misbehaviour in respect of which the
inquiry is proposed to be held is set out in
the enclosed statement of articles of
charge (Annexure – I). A statement of
the
imputation
of
misconduct
or
misbehaviour in support of each article of
charge is enclosed (Annexure-II). A list
of documents by which, and a list of
witnesses by whom, the articles of charge
are proposed to be sustained are also
enclosed (Annexure III and IV).
2.
Nk.960208 Bijay Gurung is directed to
submit within 10 days of the receipt of
this memorandum, a written statement of
his defense (sic) and also to state whether
he desires to be heard in person.
……………………………………………………………………….
6.
Receipt of this Memorandum may be
acknowledged by Nk.960208 Bijay Gurung
of Sadar P.S., East District.
…………………………………………….‖
[emphasis supplied]
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
Copy of the document Annexure R3 bears the signature of the
Petitioner, thereby acknowledging and indicating receipt of all the
documents as listed in the Memorandum, hence establishing
compliance of the aforestated Rules. It is clear from the above that
steps envisaged by Rule 7(3) and Rule 7(4) have met with
compliance.
17.
Rule 7(5)(a), (b) and (c) is extracted hereinbelow;
―(5) (a)
On receipt of the written statement
of defence the disciplinary authority may itself inquire
into such of the articles of charge as are not admitted,
or, if it considers it necessary so to do, appoint under
sub-rule 2 an inquiry authority for the purpose, and
where all the articles of charge have been admitted by
the police officer in his written statement of defence,
the disciplinary authority shall record its findings on
each charge after taking such evidence as it may
think fit and shall act in the manner laid down in
under sub-rule 25.
(b) If no written statement of defence is
submitted by the police officer, the disciplinary
authority may itself inquire into the articles of charge
or may, if it considers it necessary so to do, appoint
sub-rule 2 an inquiring authority for the purpose.
(c) Where the disciplinary authority itself
inquires into any article of charge or appoints an
inquiring authority for holding an inquiry into such
charge, it may, by an order, appoint a police officer or
a legal practitioner, to be known as the Presenting
Officer to present on its behalf the case in support of
the article of charge.‖
[emphasis supplied]
18.
What Rule 5(a) envisages is that pursuant to the
documents listed at Rule 7(3) being made over to the delinquent, he
shall file his written statement before the disciplinary authority,
who, on receipt of the written statement has the option of inquiring
into the articles of charge himself when the charges have „not‟ been
admitted by the delinquent. In other words, where the delinquent
has not pleaded guilty to any of the charges the disciplinary
authority can inquire into these charges.
The provision also
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
empowers the disciplinary authority to appoint inquiring authority if
he so requires, for this purpose. The second leg of this Rule provides
that when all the articles of charge have been “admitted” by the
delinquent in his written statement, the disciplinary authority „shall‟
record his findings on each charge, take evidence, followed with
action in the manner provided in Rule 7(25) which reads as follows;
―(25) If the disciplinary authority having regard
to its findings on all or any of the articles of charge is
of the opinion that any of the penalties specified in
clause (xi) to clause (xv) of rule 3 should be imposed
on the police officer, it shall not be necessary to give
the police officer any opportunity of making
representation to the penalty proposed to be
imposed:‖
[emphasis supplied]
It is relevant to state here that the proviso to the Rule has
been deleted vide amendment notified on 29-03-1995, Notification
bearing No.62/GEN/DOP.
19.
Rule 7(5)(b) supra, gives the disciplinary authority the
option of inquiring into the matter himself if no written statement is
submitted by the delinquent officer.
The disciplinary authority is
also clothed with the option of appointing an inquiring authority
under Rule 7(2) if he considers it necessary. Rule 7(5)(c) requires
appointment of a police officer or legal practitioner as a Presenting
Officer to present the case on behalf of the disciplinary authority,
irrespective of the fact that the inquiry may be conducted by the
disciplinary authority himself or by the inquiring authority. Rule 7(6)
provides that if the disciplinary authority does not take up the
inquiry, he shall forward to the inquiring authority the documents
listed
therein.
convenience.
The
provision
is
extracted
hereinbelow
for
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
―(6) The disciplinary authority shall, where it is
not the inquiring authority, forward to the inquiring
authority -
20.
(i)
a copy of the articles of charge and
the statement of the imputations of
misconduct or behaviour;
(ii)
a copy of the written statement of
defence, if any, submitted by. the
police officer;
(iii)
a copy of the statement of witnesses,
if any, referred to in sub-rule 3;
(iv)
evidence proving the delivery of
documents referred to in sub-rule 3 to
the police officer; and
(v)
a copy of the order appointing the
Presenting Officer.‖
A bare reading of the aforestated provisions would
obtain that the role and duties cast upon the disciplinary authority
extend from Rule 7(2) to Rule 7(6).
It may be elucidated herein
that when disciplinary proceedings are to be held against a police
officer it becomes incumbent upon the disciplinary authority to draw
up the details as laid down in Rule 7(3)(i), (ii)(a) and (b).
Thereafter, the disciplinary authority is also to ensure delivery of the
documents to the delinquent specifying a time frame within which
the delinquent is to file his statement of defence as emanates from
Rule 7(4).
The written statement is to be received by the
disciplinary authority himself and none else as envisaged under Rule
7(5)(a), following which the said authority is to take steps, viz.;
where the articles of charge are not admitted then he is to enquire
into such of the articles which are not admitted or appoint an inquiry
authority under Rule 7(2) for the said purpose. However, where the
articles of charge have been admitted by the delinquent the
disciplinary authority is clothed with powers to record his findings on
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
each charge after recording evidence as he thinks fit and then take
steps as per Rule 7(25) which provides for steps to be taken for
imposing penalty instead of inquiring into the matter or causing
inquiry. The disciplinary authority has therefore to take steps in
terms of rule 7(25) which he overlooked.
21.
In the instant matter, the disciplinary authority before
receipt of written statement of the Petitioner proceeded to appoint
the I.O. on 09-03-2016, thereby putting the cart before the horse,
whereas the written statement was submitted by the Petitioner only
on 17-03-2016. To obfuscate the above is the letter dated 09-032016 issued by the I.O. requiring the delinquent to submit his reply
over and above the time given in the Memorandum issued by the
disciplinary authority.
It may be noted that the role of the I.O.
kicks into place only on completion of the provisions of Rule 7(2) to
Rule 7(6).
Before completion of the steps envisaged under the
aforestated Rules the inquiring authority has no role to play.
22.
This would concomitantly take us to the argument of
Learned Additional Advocate General which was to the effect that
the enquiry stood vitiated from the stage of Rule 7(16), while
disagreeing with this contention, in my considered opinion, there
was no necessity of reaching the aforestated stage, nevertheless for
the sake of argument, we may look into Rule 7(16) of 1989 Rules
which provides as follows;
―(16) When the case for the disciplinary
authority is closed, the police officer shall be required
to state his defence, orally or in writing as he may
prefer. If the defence is made orally, it shall be
recorded and the police officer shall be required to sign
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
the record. In either case, a copy of the statement of
defence shall be given to the Presenting Officer, if any,
appointed.‖
23.
Learned Additional Advocate General contends that
copies of the statement of defence was not made over to the P.O.
Even on a cursory look at Rule 7 and its Sub-Rules, it is noticed that
the disciplinary authority was to have proceeded in terms of Rule
7(25) in view of the admission of guilt of the Petitioner as revealed
by Annexure R6 written statement of the Petitioner and as laid down
in Rule 7(5)(a) which he failed to do. Therefore the argument of the
Learned Additional Advocate General pertaining to Rule 7(16) is
indeed not tenable.
Once the written statement of the Petitioner
was received admitting to the charges, the Rules provides necessary
steps as emanates from Rule 7(5)(a). It is from this stage that the
enquiry stood vitiated, since on admission of guilt firstly it was not
necessary to have put the delinquent officer through the process of
enquiry as the disciplinary authority was clothed with sufficient
powers to record evidence and follow it up with imposition of
penalty.
24.
The discussions which have ensued hereinabove reveal
that the Petitioner was aware of the imputations and charges
against him having acknowledged receipt of the Memorandum and
its Annexures and he has filed his response admitting his guilt
contrary to the argument of his Learned Counsel that he had denied
the charges framed against him. No prejudice was evidently caused
to the Petitioner at that stage since as established, he was in receipt
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
of all relevant documents with sufficient opportunity afforded to
rebut the allegations.
25.
The instant case is distinguishable from the ratio in Tashi
Chopel Bhutia (supra) relied on for Learned Counsel for the Petitioner
inasmuch as in the case supra there was absolute non-compliance of
the statutory procedure which had prejudiced the Petitioner and he
was denied an opportunity of proving his innocence ambiguous
notice having been issued to the Petitioner therein and insufficient
time to resist the charges. He was afforded no opportunity of crossexamining the witnesses or to examine himself or his witnesses and
above all the relevant documents had not been made over to the
Petitioner to enable him to put up a defence. The circumstances in
the instant matter clearly differ as would be evident from the
discussions supra.
26.
In the light of the facts and circumstances discussed
hereinabove and in consideration of the ratio extracted supra, the
following impugned Orders are hereby set aside;
(i)
Order No.10/POL/SPE/RDR/2004(Vol-II)/213, dated 0903-2016;
(ii)
Office Order No.10/SPE/RDR/2004(Vol-II)558/SPIC dated
09-07-2016 issued by Respondent No.3; and
(ii)
Office Order No.169/PHQ/L&O/2016 dated 22-08-2016
issued by Respondent No.2.
27.
In Chairman, Life Insurance Corporation of India (supra) it
was enunciated that it is settled legal proposition that once the
Court sets aside an order of punishment, on the ground that the
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
enquiry was not properly conducted, it must remit the case
concerned to the disciplinary authority for it to conduct the enquiry
from the point that it stood vitiated and conclude the same.
At
Paragraph 21, it was held as follows;
―21. After hearing the counsel for the parties,
we are of the view that the impugned judgment and
order dated 10-1-2011, in LIC v. A. Masilamani [LIC v.
A. Masilamani, Writ Appeal No. 7 of 2011, decided on 10-1-2011
(Mad)], as well as the order of the learned Single Judge
dated 17-2-2010, passed in A. Masilamani v. LIC [A.
Masilamaniv. LIC, Writ Petition No. 11152 of 2002, decided on 172-2010 (Mad)], cannot be sustained in the eye of the law
and are therefore hereby set aside. The present appeal
is allowed. The matter is remitted to the disciplinary
authority to enable it to take a fresh decision, taking
into consideration the gravity of the charges involved,
as with respect to whether it may still be required to
hold a de novo enquiry from the stage that it stood
vitiated i.e. after issuance of the charge-sheet.
…………………………………….………‖
28.
Consequently
the
disciplinary
proceedings
shall
commence from the stage it stood vitiated as discussed and clarified
above.
29.
The disciplinary authority while taking a decision in the
matter may take into consideration that the concerned authorities in
the first instance failed to lodge a complaint against the Petitioner
under the provisions of the Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006, when he
was allegedly found to be in possession of controlled substances.
Secondly, the disciplinary authority may also take into consideration
that the Director General of Police in his Office Order bearing
No.13/PHQ/2017, dated 07-02-2017 (Annexure P11) has while
considering the representation filed by the second delinquent
LNK/960197
Karma
Bhutia
for
conversion
of
his
compulsory
retirement to voluntary retirement following the departmental
WP(C) No.57 of 2016
Bijay Gurung
vs. The State of Sikkim and Others
enquiry, recorded that, on going through the departmental enquiry
proceedings it was found that the proper procedure for awarding
punishment under Clauses (xi) to (xv) of Rule 3 of the 1989 Rules
was not followed.
Accordingly, he had revised the order of
compulsory retirement of the delinquent and allowed him voluntary
retirement as requested by the second delinquent.
30.
Under the facts and circumstances, the Writ Petition
stands disposed of with the above directions.
31.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
12-11-2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review