Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.35206 of 2025
Bighneswar Barik & Anr.
….
Petitioners
Mr. A. Das, Sr. Advocate
along with Mr. A.K. Pal, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha & Ors.
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. C.K. Pradhan, AGA
Order No.
05. 1.
CORAM:
JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
ORDER
28.01.2026
This
matter
is
taken
up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties.
Affidavit filed in Court be kept in record.
3.
The present Writ Petition has been filed by the
Petitioner inter alia with the following prayer:“It is, therefore, most humbly and respectfully rayed that
this Hon'ble Court may be graciously pleased issue Rule
NISSI calling upon the Opp. Parties to show ause as to
why :1. The order no. 8421 dtd 03.11.2025 issued by OP. No. 2
under annexure-16 shall not be quashed after declaring
the same as illegal;
2. The O.P. No.2 shall not be directed to conduct the
recruitment as per modalities fixed on 08.09.2025 which
has been prepared in compliance to Order dtd. 18.07.2025
passed in WPC(OAC) No.1322 of 2016 as well as Order
dtd. 04.09.2025 passed in CONTC No. 1626 of 2024
within a stipulated period;
// 2 //
If the Opp. Parties fail to show cause or show insufficient
cause, the Rule may be made absolute;
And further be pleased to pass any other order/orders as
would be deemed fit and proper;
And for this act of kindness, the petitioners as in duty
bound shall ever pray.”
4.
It is contended that advertisement issued for
recruitment to various post by Opposite Party No.2 on
22.10.2012 was the subject matter of dispute
in O.A.
No.1322(C) of 2016. The said Original Application after
being transferred to this Court was disposed of finally
vide order dtd.18.07.2023 under Annexure-11 with the
following direction so contained in Para-6:“6. Accordingly, while disposing the Writ Petition as well
as all the pending Interim Applications, this Court directs
Opposite Party No.2 to proceed with the recruitment in
terms of the advertisement issued under Annexure-2 by
making necessary modification and complete the
recruitment process within a period of 6 (six) from the date
of receipt of this order, if there is no other legal
impediment.”
4.1. Learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioners contended that on being communicated with
the order so passed by this Court under Annexure-11,
Opposite Party No.2 issued a notice on 28.07.2023 under
Annexure-12. In the said notice, it was clearly indicated
that the recruitment will be held in terms of the
advertisement issued on 22.10.2012 and the notice
issued under Annexure-12.
// 3 //
4.2. It is contended that after issuance of such a notice
under Annexure-12 on 28.07.2023 to proceed with the
recruitment
in
terms
of
the
advertisement
dtd.22.10.2012, when no action was taken, CONTC
No.1626 of 2024 was filed, seeking compliance of order
dtd.18.07.2023. In the said Contempt Petition, Opposite
Party No.2 on his Personal appearance basing on the
letter issued on 02.09.2025 by Opposite Party No.1, fairly
contended that recruitment will be conducted strictly in
terms of the advertisement issued on 22.10.2012 and the
exercise will be completed by the end of 2025.
4.3. It is contended that after disposal of the Contempt
Petition vide order dtd.04.09.2025, Opposite Party No.2
vide his letter dtd.08.09.2025, prescribed the modalities
to be followed for recruitment of 54 (Group-C) Industrial
Post as per advertisement dtd.22.10.2012, in terms of the
decision taken by the Appointment Committee in its
proceeding
dtd.31.03.2021,
Government-Opposite
Party
so
approved
No.1
in
by
its
the
letter
dtd.27.08.2021.
4.4. It is contended that, on the face of the modality
approved
by
the
Committee
in
its
proceeding
dtd.31.03.2021 with approval of the Government vide
letter dtd.27.08.2021, so issued on 08.09.2025, the
impugned letter was issued by Opposite Party No.2 under
// 4 //
Annexure-16
on
03.11.2025,
prescribing
different
modalities to conduct the recruitment in question.
4.5. Learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioners contended that since the modality prescribed
by the
Appointment Committee in its proceeding
dtd.31.03.2021
was
duly
notified
vide
letter
dtd.08.09.2025 under Annexure-15, with due approval of
the Govt.-Opposite Party No.1, there was no necessity to
prescribe different modality to conduct the recruitment
vide
the
impugned
letter
dtd.03.11.2025
under
Annexure-16.
4.6. It is accordingly contended that modality prescribed
in the impugned communication dtd.03.11.2025 under
Annexure-16 of Opposite Party No.2, is required to be
interfered with by this Court.
5.
Considering the stand taken in the Writ Petition,
this Court vide order dtd.12.12.2025 directed the learned
Addl. Government Advocate to obtain instruction in the
matter. While directing so, this Court passed an interim
order
by
staying
communication
the
operation
dtd.03.11.2025,
of
the
impugned
so
issued
under
Annexure-16.
6.
Basing on the order passed by this Court, learned
Addl. Government Advocate produced the instruction so
provided
by
Opposite
Party
No.2
vide
his
letter
// 5 //
dtd.29.12.2025. Placing reliance on the said instruction,
learned AGA contended that, subsequent to issuance of
the letter dtd.08.09.2025 under Annexure-15, in the
meeting held on 14.10.2025, a fresh set of modality was
approved by the Appointment Committee to complete the
recruitment in terms of the advertisement issued on
22.10.2012 under Annexure-1.
6.1. Basing on such modality approved by the Committee
in its proceeding dtd.14.10.2025, the communication
under Annexure-16 was issued by Opposite Party No.2 on
03.11.2025.
6.2. It is contended that since the modality of the test so
approved
by
the
Committee
in
its
proceeding
dtd.14.10.2025 has been acted upon with issuance of the
letter dtd.03.11.2025 under Annexure-16, no illegality or
irregularity can be found with such action of Opposite
Party Nos.1 and 2 and Opposite Party No.2 be permitted
to proceed with the recruitment in terms of Annexure-16
communication dtd.03.11.2025.
7.
To the submission of the learned State counsel,
learned
Sr.
Counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioner
contended that after disposal of the Writ Petition by this
Court vide order dtd.18.07.2023 under Annexure-11 and
further order passed in the Contempt on 04.09.2025
under
Annexure-14,
the
modality
adopted
by
the
Appointment Committee to conduct the recruitment in its
// 6 //
proceeding dtd.31.03.2021, was duly notified by Opposite
Party No.2 vide letter dtd.08.09.2025 under Annexure-15
and the said modality was also approved by the
Government
in
its
letter
dtd.27.08.2021 vide
Annexure-18.
7.1. It is accordingly contended that after issuance of the
notice
dtd.08.09.2025,
there
was
no
necessity
to
prescribe a different modality, basing on the proceeding of
the Committee dtd.14.10.2025.
7.2. It is also vehemently contended that modality
framed
by
the
Committee
in
its
proceeding
dtd.14.10.2025, is not legal and justified, as the said
decision has been taken by an incompetent Committee,
which is not in accordance with the provisions contained
under
Rule-9(A)
Industrial
of
the
Employees
Orissa
Government
Classification,
Press
Requirement,
Promotion, Condition of Service & Appeal Rules, 1978.
Rule-9(A) of the Rules reads as follows:“9(A) Appointment and Promotion Committee
The Director who is the appointing authority with respect
to all non-gazetted industrial posts will make appointment
to such posts by way of direct recruitment, internal
promotion and deputation from outside. He will be aided
and guided by a Committee of officers comprising the
following, namely:Director
Chairman
All Unit Officers
Members
Labour Welfare Officer
Members
// 7 //
Establishment Officer
Member-Secretary.”
7.3. It is contended that all such decision by the
Appointment Committee, is required to be taken by a
team of Members containing not less than 11 members.
However the proceeding dtd.14.10.2025 has only been
attended by four members, including the Principal
Secretary of the Department. It is however contended that
the decision taken by the Committee in its earlier meeting
dtd.31.03.2021
was
taken
by
a
duly
constituted
Committee in terms of Rule-9(A) of the Rules.
7.4. It is accordingly contended that since the decision
taken by the Committee in its proceeding dtd. 16.10.2025
is not in terms of the provisions contained under Rule9(A) of the Rules, the decision taken by such Committee
could not have been acted upon, with issuance of the
impugned
communication
dtd.03.11.2025
under
Annexure-16.
7.5. Making all the submissions, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the Petitioners contended that Opposite
Party No.2 be directed to complete the recruitment
process
in
terms
of
the
advertisement
issued
on
22.10.2012 under Annexure-1, notice dtd.28.07.2023
issued under Annexure-12 and the modality accepted by
the Committee in its proceeding dtd.31.03.2021 so
notified vide letter dtd.08.09.2025 under Annexure-15,
// 8 //
with qushing of the impugned letter dtd.03.11.2025, so
issued by Opposite Party No.2 under Annexure-16.
8.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
Parties and considering the submissions made, this Court
finds that the recruitment process initiated by Opposite
Party No.2 way back on 22.10.2012 under Annexure-1,
was the subject matter of challenge in WPC(OAC) No.1322
of 2016. The said writ petition was disposed of finally vide
the
order
dtd.18.07.2023
under
Annexure-11,
by
permitting the Opposite Party No.2 to proceed with the
recruitment in terms of the advertisement issued on
22.10.2012, with necessary modification and to complete
the process within a period of six months from the date
of receipt of the order.
8.1. After such disposal of the matter vide notice
dtd.28.07.2023 under Annexure-12, Opposite Party No.2
indicated that the recruitment is to be conducted in terms
of the advertisement issued on 22.10.2012. On the face of
the order passed by this Court, when the recruitment
process so issued vide advertisement dtd.22.10.2012 was
not completed, this Court passed the following order on
04.09.2025 in CONTC No.1624 of 2024:“1. This matter in talken up through Hybrid Arrangement
(Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2. Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3. Pursuant to order dated 26.08.2025, Mr. Diptesh
Patnaik, Opp. Party/Contemnor appeared in person and
// 9 //
produced copy of the letter issued by the Department vide
letter dated 02.09.2025. The same be kept in record.
4. Basing on the letter issued by the Department, Opp.
Party/Contemnor contended that he has now been
permitted by the department to proceed with the selection
process in terms of the advertisement issued on
22.10.2012 and will complete the entire exercise by the
end of this year.
5. Considering the instruction and the submission made by
the Opp. Party/Contemnor in Court, list this matter in the
1st week of January, 2026.
Personal appearance of the Opp. Party/Contemnor is
dispensed with.”
8.2. After disposal of the Contempt Petition, Opposite
Party No.2 vide letter dtd.08.09.2025 under Annexure-15
issued the modality to be followed for completing the
recruitment process so approved by the Committee in its
proceeding
dtd.31.03.2021,
and
approved
by
the
Government vide letter dtd.27.08.2021. After issuance of
the communication dtd.08.09.2025 under Annexure-15,
the impugned communication was issued on 03.11.2025,
basing on the decision taken by the Committee in its
proceeding dtd.14.10.2025 so produced by the learned
AGA.
8.3. This Court after going through the proceeding of the
meeting dtd.14.10.2025, finds that the said meeting has
been held contrary to the provisions contained under
Rule-9(A) of the 1978 Rules. Since the decision taken by
the Committee in its proceeding dtd.14.10.2025 is not in
accordance with Rule-9(A) of the Rules and contrary to
// 10 //
the earlier decision so issued on 08.09.2025, as per the
considered view of this Court, such decision taken by the
Committee could not have been acted upon, with
issuance of the impugned letter dtd.03.11.2025 under
Annexure-16.
8.4. In view of the aforesaid analysis, this Court while
quashing the impugned communication dtd.03.11.2025
so issued under Annexure-16 basing on the proceeding of
the meeting dtd.14.10.2025, directs Opposite Party No.2
to
proceed
with
the
recruitment
in
terms
of
the
advertisement issued on 22.10.2012 and the modality
accepted and published vide letter dtd.08.09.2025 under
Annexure-15. This Court directs Opposite Party No.2 to
complete the recruitment process without any further
delay, as the recruitment is of the year 2012 and more
than 13 years have passed in the meantime.
9.
With the aforesaid observations and directions the
Writ Petition stands disposed of.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Subrat
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBRAT KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 10-Feb-2026 15:43:29
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review