Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
WA NO.128 OF 2024
1. Bibhu Debbarma,
D/o: Lt. Birulal Debbarma,
R/o: Vill- Rangachara, P.O.- Sikaribari, P.S.- Ambassa,
District-Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799288.(Age-35 years)
2. Uttam Debnath,
S/o: Digendra Debnath,
R/o: West Lalchari, P.O.-Balaram Bazar,
District- Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799204.
(Age-31 years)
……..The Appellant(s)
Verses
1. The State of Tripura,
(To be represented by) the Secretary,
Education(School) Department,
Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Secretary,
Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799001.
……….Respondent(s)
WA NO.27 OF 2025
1. Sanjoy Rudra Paul,
S/o: Moanoranjan Rudra Paul,
R/o Kashipur, mission road, Reshambagan,
East Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799008(Age-37 years).
2. Shilpi Das,
W/o: Indrajit Bhowmik,
R/o: Vill. & PO-Mariamnagar,
District-West Tripura, P.S. East Agartala,
Pin-799008.(Age-33 years).
3. Shatabdi Majumder,
D/o: Sukhendu Bikash Majumder,
R/o: Ranirbazar, Gopal Road, P.O.-Ranirbazar,
Dist-West Tripura, Pin-799035(Age-33 years).
4. Prasenjit Nath,
S/o: Mritynujoy Nath,
R/o: Vill & P.O.-Rajnagar Laxmipur,PS. Dharmanagar,
Dist-North Tripura Pin-799254(Age-33 years).
5. Simul Das,
S/o Kunja Mohan Das,
R/o: Vill & P.O-Rangamati, P.S. Birganj,
Dist- Gomati, Tripura, Pin 799101. (Age-33 years).
6. Sudipta Choudhury,
D/o: Gouranga Choudhury,
R/o: Vill & P.O. Pecharthal, Unakoti Tripura,
Pin-799263. (Age-33 years).
7. Sumen Kanti Nath,
S/O: Birendra Kumar Debnath,
R/o: Vill & P.O.- Kadamtala,
District-North Tripura, Pin-799261(Age-33 years).
…… Appellant(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
(To be represented by) the Secretary,
Education (School), Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Secretary,
Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799001.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate.
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Adv. General
Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. G.A.
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 13.08.2025.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
T. Amarnath Goud, J
1.
Both the writ appeals are heard and decided together
as common questions of law and facts were involved. The appellants herein
were appointed as Post Graduate Teachers and Graduate Teachers under the
State of Tripura after the New Pension Scheme ( in short ‘NPS’) was brought
into effect by Notification dated 13.07.2018 with retrospective operation
from 01.07.2018. At the time of their appointment, they submitted
undertakings in the prescribed format, acknowledging that they would be
governed by the NPS and not by the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
1972, as adopted by the State of Tripura.
2.
Prior to the present proceedings, the appellants herein
had earlier approached the learned Single Judge by filing WP(C) No.608 of
2022 and WP(C) No.609 of 2022, praying for coverage under the Old
Pension Scheme( in short ‘OPS’). Those writ petitions were disposed of by
order dated 25.04.2023 with a direction to the petitioners to submit individual
representations before the competent authority.
3.
Pursuant thereto, the appellants submitted their
representations, which were rejected by orders dated 07.08.2023 and
08.08.2023 respectively, passed by the Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura. The ground taken in the rejection was that the
petitioners had joined service after 30.06.2018, i.e. after the coming into
force of the NPS, and had accepted its terms and conditions by furnishing
undertakings at the time of joining. It was also observed that mere
participation in a selection process or issuance of an appointment order does
not create any vested right prior to actual joining.
4.
Being aggrieved by the rejection orders, the appellant-
petitioners once again approached the learned Single Judge by filing WP(C)
No. 570 of 2023 and WP(C) No. 571 of 2023, seeking a direction upon the
respondents to extend to them the benefit of the OPS. However, by Judgment
and Order dated 25th July, 2024, the learned Single Judge dismissed the writ
petitions. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant-petitioners have preferred the
present appeal.
5.
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Sr. counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellants
as well as Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned Advocate General, Mr. P. Gautam,
learned Sr. G.A., Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A., Mr. D.
Sharm, learned Addl. G.A., and Ms. P. Chakraborty, learned Advocate
appearing for the State-respondents.
6.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the appellants, submit that the central issue before the learned Single
Judge was whether the petitioners are to be governed by the OPS or the NPS.
It is submitted that the NPS came into force on 1st July, 2018. At the time of
joining, the appellants–petitioners were required to sign undertakings opting
for the NPS. However, such undertakings were not executed voluntarily but
under compulsion, inasmuch as, without signing the same, the appellants–
petitioners would not have been permitted to join their posts. Considering the
scarcity of employment opportunities and the effort undertaken by the
appellants in securing the posts, they were left with no real option and were
compelled to sign the undertakings under duress.
On the said argument, learned Sr. Counsel relied upon
Para-13, 37 and 43 of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 3rd
September, 2021 bearing No.Civil Appeal No(s).3922-3925 of 2017 titled as
Somesh Thapliyal and anr.etc Vs. Vice Chancellor, H.N.B. Garhwal
University and anr. The same is produced here-in-under:“13. The appellants raised dispute by filing a protest
petition but as already observed that they not being in the equal bargaining
position were in the need of employment, left with no option but to sign on
the dotted lines offered by the University at the time of employment.
37. From the narration of facts as being referred to
supra, it clearly manifests that the appellants were appointed after going
through the process of selection as contemplated under Part VI of the Act
1973 which indeed was an appointment on substantive basis and since the
appellants were not in an equal bargaining position and were in the need of
employment when the offer of appointment was made, left with no option but
to accept such arbitrary conditions incorporated in the letter of appointment
in treating it to be contractual for a limited period still recorded their protest
while joining but no heed was paid. When they were allowed to continue by
extending their services, they remained under the bonafide belief that as their
appointment is being substantive in character, they will be made
permanent/confirmed immediately after the permanent posts are sanctioned
in the Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences but to their dismay, after an
advertisement dated 29th August, 2011 came to be notified by the respondent
Central University, no option was left with them but to approach the High
Court by filing of a writ petition.
43. The bargaining power is vested with the employer
itself and the employee is left with no option but to accept the conditions
dictated by the authority. If that being the reason, it is open for the employee
to challenge the conditions if it is not being in conformity with the statutory
requirement under the law and he is not estopped from questioning at a stage
where he finds himself aggrieved.”
6.1.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants
further submit that the undertaking was not part of the Offer of Appointment
issued to the appellants–petitioners on 30.06.2018. It was only at the stage of
posting that the requirement of furnishing such undertaking was imposed.
The appellants–petitioners were categorically informed that unless the
undertaking was signed, they would not be permitted to join their posts.
Thus, after having already accepted their offers of appointment, the
appellants–petitioners were compelled to furnish the undertaking at the time
of posting. The undertaking itself was pre-drafted by the respondents,
provided in a dotted-line format, leaving the appellants–petitioners with no
choice but to sign it.
6.2.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that it is a settled
principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that where the
process of selection stands completed prior to the cut-off date of enforcement
of the NPS, the appointees would be governed by the OPS, even if their
formal joining takes place after the cut-off date. In the present case, the offers
of appointment were issued to the appellants–petitioners on 30.06.2018, i.e.,
prior to the enforcement of the NPS on 01.07.2018. The subsequent joining
after the cut-off date occurred solely due to administrative delay. Therefore,
applying the settled principle of law as well as various circulars issued by the
Central Government, the appellants–petitioners are entitled to be covered
under the OPS. The undertakings obtained from them cannot defeat such
entitlement as they were secured under duress and in circumstances where
the appellants–petitioners had no bargaining power. In support of this
contention, learned Senior Counsel placed reliance on the Judgment of the
Hon’ble Delhi High Court in WP(C) No.1358 of 2017, titled as Shyam
Kumar Choudhury & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., decided on
09.04.2019.
6.3.
Learned Senior Counsel also placed reliance upon
another Judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in WP(C) No.2810 of
2016, Inspector Rajendra Singh & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., wherein
relief was granted in circumstances identical to those of the present
appellants–petitioners. The challenge carried against the said Judgment by
the Union of India in the form of a Special Leave Petition before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court was dismissed by the Apex Court, thereby confirming the
view of the High Court. Stating thus, the learned Senior Counsel prayed that
the present appeals may be allowed.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned
Advocate General appearing for the respondents, submits that the
Notification dated 13.07.2018 issued by the Finance Department, Pension
Cell, has not been challenged by the appellant–petitioners. The said
Notification categorically provides that all employees joining service on or
after 01.07.2018 shall be governed by the NPS. In the absence of any
challenge to the said Notification, the subsequent actions of the respondents
flowing there-from cannot be called into question. It is contended that the
appellants–petitioners had the opportunity to challenge the Notification at the
appropriate stage, but they chose not to do so.
7.1.
The learned Advocate General further submits that the
appellants–petitioners consciously signed the undertakings at the time of
joining and remained silent for a considerable period thereafter. Only after
several years, they raise representations, seeking to retract from their earlier
acceptance. Once a candidate has signed a document forming part of the
service conditions with full knowledge, he or she cannot subsequently
backtract from it. Such matters cannot be reopened on the basis of belated
pleas.
7.2.
The learned Advocate General submits that reliance is
placed on Somesh Thapliyal & Anr. etc. vs. Vice Chancellor, H.N.B.
Garhwal University & Anr(supra)., by the learned Sr. counsel appearing for
the appellants wherein, in paragraph 43, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
it is open to an employee to challenge service conditions if the same are not
in conformity with statutory requirements. However, in the present case, the
appellants–petitioners have not challenged any statutory requirement.
Instead, they merely contend that the undertakings were signed under duress.
According to the learned Advocate General, such a contention cannot be
accepted within the principle laid down in Somesh Thapliyal (supra), as the
submissions of the appellants–petitioners are more in the nature of emotional
pleas rather than legally sustainable arguments.
7.3.
To strengthen his argument, learned Advocate
General referred to Para 45(iv) of the Judgment of the 3(three) Judges’
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 25th November, 2022 bearing
No.Civil Appeal Nos.6622-6623 of 2022 titled as State of U.P. and ors. Vs.
Virendra Kumar and ors. The same is produced here-in-under:“45(iv) Those officers and employees of the Board
who have accepted the benefit under the old scheme before 7 th
September 2012 after giving an undertaking in terms of the
Office Order dated 16th January 2004 shall nto be C.A.
Nos.6622-6623 of 2022 etc. entitled to the benefit of the new
pension scheme made applicable as per the notification dated
19th May 2009;”
8.
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
9.
This Court is of the considered view that the offer
letters issued in 2018 were merely offers of appointment and not final
appointments in themselves. The appellants subsequently accepted the said
appointments and furnished undertakings in terms of the NPS. The plea that
such undertakings were given under duress or coercion cannot be accepted.
There is no material on record to substantiate the allegation of coercion, and
it is not possible to assume that the appellants, who entered service with their
eyes wide open, were unaware of the service conditions or the statutory
scheme governing their employment.
10.
challenge
It is further relevant that the appellants did not
the
foundational
Notification
dated
13.07.2018,
which
categorically mandated that employees joining on or after 01.07.2018 would
be governed by the NPS. In the absence of any challenge to the notification
itself, the subsequent actions of the respondents flowing there-from cannot be
questioned. The appellants consciously signed the undertakings and remained
silent for nearly four years, only raising their grievance in June, 2022 by way
of representations, followed thereafter by writ petitions. Such belated and
afterthought challenges, long after accepting the terms of service, cannot be
permitted.
11.
The argument of the learned Senior Counsel for the
appellants that the undertakings were obtained under duress is more of an
emotional plea rather than a legally sustainable contention. As rightly argued
by the learned Advocate General, once the appellants voluntarily executed
undertakings forming part of the service conditions, and without challenging
either the Notification dated 13.07.2018 or the undertakings themselves, they
cannot now backtrack from their own actions. The reliance placed on
principles of “duress” or “lack of bargaining power” is misplaced in the facts
of the case.
12.
This Court also finds merit in the submission of the
learned Advocate General that, in Somesh Thapliyal & Anr. vs. Vice
Chancellor, H.N.B. Garhwal University & Anr.(supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court clarified that an employee may challenge service conditions
only if they are not in conformity with statutory requirements. In the present
case, however, no such statutory violation has been demonstrated; rather, the
appellant only relies upon an unsubstantiated plea of compulsion.
13.
This Court further notes that in an earlier round of
litigation, in the case of Sourav Datta Vs The State of Tripura and ors,
bearing No.WA No.156 of 2023 decided on 20.02.2024, similar claims had
been rejected, and the Special Leave Petition before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court was also dismissed. The issue thus stands concluded.
14.
In light of the binding precedent of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court Judgment in State of U.P. & Ors. vs. Virendra Kumar &
Ors.(supra) and upon careful consideration of the submissions advanced, this
Court finds no infirmity in the Judgment of the learned Single Judge.
15.
Accordingly, the writ appeals stand dismissed. As a sequel,
stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stands closed.
B. PALIT, J
Suhanjit
signed by
SABYASAC Digitally
SABYASACHI GHOSH
2025.08.21
HI GHOSH Date:
12:50:54 +05'30'
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review