Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010658902017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3548]
FRIDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1388/2017
Between:
1. BHUKYA NIRMALA, KRISHNA DIST AMP 3 OTHERS, W/O LATE
RAMESH BABU RAMESH NAI HINDU, AGE 26 YRS HOUSE WIFE, R
O D NO 1 246 TANDA BAZAR,
KEEL ESPURAM, JUPUDI
VILLAGE,LBRAHIMPATNAM MANDAL, KRISHNA DIST,. AP
2. BHUKYA GUNASEKHAR,, S/O LATE RAMESH BABU @RAMESH
NAIK HINDU, AGE 5 YRS , BEING MINOR. REP BY HIS NATURAL
MOTHER 1ST APPELLANT BHUKYA NIRMALA AS THE GUARDIAN,
HOUSE WIFE, R/O D NO: 1-246,TANDA BAZAR, KEELESPURAM,
H/O JUPUDI VILLAGE, IBRAHIMPATNAM MANDAL, KRISHNA DIST,.
AP
3. BHUKYA SREEKAR", S/O LATE RAMESH BABU @RAMESH NAIK
HINDU, AGE 4 YRS , BEING MINOR, REP BY HIS NATURAL
MOTHER 1ST APPELLANT BHUKYA NIRMALA AS THE GUARDIAN,
HOUSE WIFE, R/O D NO: I -246,TANDA BAZAR, KEELESPURAM,
H/O JUPUDI VILLAGE, IBRAHIMPATNAM MANDAL, KRISHNA DIST,.
AP
4. BHUKYA SETHAMMA, W/O LATE BALU , HINDU, AGED 52 YRS,
HOUSE WIFE, R/O D NO:1-246,TANDA BAZAR, KEELESPURAM, H/O
JUPUDI VILLAGE, IBRAHIMPATNAM MANDAL, KRISHNA DIST,. AP
(CLAIMANTS)
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
1. SIRI TECON HYDERABAD ANR, REP BY MR KOMMARAJU JAYA,
M/S SENTINI CENNICA PVT LTD,. PLOT NO 1229 ROAD NO 60
,JUBLI HILLS, HYDERABAD-500034
2. THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD, REP BY ITS DIVISIONAL
MANAGER, DIVISIONAL OFFICE, DIVISIONAL OFFICE-II, POST BOX
NO 774, BESIDES HIGH SCHOOL ROAD, PATAMATA, KRISHNA
DIST, VIJAYAWADA 520010 AP
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased toto set aside the Judgment and Decree passed in MVOP 627 of
2013, dt 25.1.2017 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Court
Cum XIV Additional District Judge, Vijayawada by allowing appeal and
decreeing M V 0 P 627 of 2013 as prayed for compensation of RS 17,00,000/with costs and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. T S RAYALU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. J DILEEP KUMAR
2. NARESH BYRAPANENI
The Court made the following:
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
JUDGMENT:
Heard,
Ms.Deepa, learned counsel representing Mr.T.S.Rayulu, learned
counsel for the appellants/claimants, and Sri Naresh Byrapaneni, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the 2nd respondent/Insurance Company.
1.
In pursuance to the orders of this Court, personal notice was
permitted to be served on 1st respondent and accordingly, notice was served
on the 1st respondent, who is the owner. Despite service of notice, none
present. Respondent No.1 remained ex parte all along.
2.
Dissatisfied and aggrieved by the Order and Decree passed in
M.V.O.P. No.627 of 2013, dated 25.01.2017 by the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum-XIV Additional District Judge, Vijayawada, the present appeal
has been filed by the claimants seeking enhancement of the compensation.
3.
The parties are arrayed as they are in the present appeal.
4.
The conspectus of facts leading to the filing of the case before the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Vijayawada (in short “Tribunal”), is as follows:
The claim petition before the Tribunal was filed under Section 166(1)(c)
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, read with Rule 455 of the A.P. Motor Vehicles
Rules, 1989, claiming compensation of Rs.17,00,000/- for the death of their
son, who died on 28.09.2013. The accident was occurred on 19.09.2013 at
about 09.00 p.m., while he was proceeding towards Ibrahimpatnam from
Chillakallu village, due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
crime vehicle i.e., lorry bearing No.AP28TB5072.
5.
The deceased was admitted in the hospital and in support of the
same, medical bills were filed and marked as Ex.A9. Ex.A1 is the copy of FIR,
Ex.A2 is the copy of alteration memo, Ex.A3 is the copy of inquest report,
Ex.A4 is the copy of post-mortem report, Ex.A5 is the copy of driving license
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
of one Andhraiah, Ex.A6 is the copy of registration certificate of the lorry,
Ex.A7 is the copy of insurance policy of the lorry, Ex.A8 is the copy of the
driving license of the deceased, Ex.A10 is the copy of charge sheet in Crime
No.227 of 2013 on the file of Kanchikacherla Police Station and Ex.A11 is the
copy of Motor Vehicle Inspector‟s report.
6.
Before the Tribunal, the claimants asserted that the deceased
used to get Rs.10,000/- per month and he was aged about 28 years by the
date of accident and he used to spend his entire earnings for the welfare of
the family and the mother, wife and maternal uncle spent Rs.1,50,000/- on the
deceased‟s treatment for 9 days and Rs.50,000/- towards miscellaneous
expenditure.
7.
The
1st
respondent
is
the
owner
of
the
lorry bearing
No.AP28TB5072 and the driver of the lorry having valid driving license, and
also the insurance policy was in force at the time of accident.
8.
The 1st respondent remained ex parte, while the 2nd respondent
filed counter denying the averments in the petition seeking compensation.
Refuting the contentions in the petition, it is stated that the claimants have to
prove that the conditions of the insurance policy were not violated, and they
were put to strict proof and also the accident did not occur due to rash and
negligent driving of the driver of the crime vehicle, and therefore, the
Insurance Company is not liable to pay any compensation.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants has drawn the
attention of the Court to the Award passed on 25.01.2017 vehemently
contending that the Tribunal erred in not considering the evidence in a proper
and perspective manner, and was misdirected in rejecting the case for
compensation only on the ground that the claimants could not prove that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving. Resultantly, the petition
for compensation was dismissed.
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
10.
Learned counsel has further drawn the attention of the Court to
the Award, wherein it is categorically stated that the FIR and the charge sheet
were filed, clearly stating that the accident was occurred due to the rash and
negligent driving and apart from the same, evidence was also marked on
behalf of the claimants to support that the accident was happened due to rash
and negligent driving. But the Tribunal erred in holding that RW1 did not
depose that the deceased died due to multiple injuries sustained in the
accident.
11.
Learned counsel has also drawn the attention of the Court to
paragraph 14 of the Award regarding the evidence of Ex.A11, which is the
Motor Vehicle Inspector‟s report, which reveals that the accident did not occur
due to any mechanical defect of the crime vehicle, and she argued that the
same has to be construed that the accident was occurred due to rash and
negligent driving. Mere not making any suggestion cannot be construed as
accepting that there is no rash and negligent driving.
12.
Learned counsel further argued that it is a fact that the deceased
lost his life in the accident, and on the other hand, there was no contra
evidence or any oral or documentary evidence by the Insurance Company to
show that the accident did not occur due to rash and negligent driving. But the
Tribunal has hastily drawn its contention and dismissed the claim against the
claimants.
13.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Insurance Company
while marking his arguments, has drawn the attention of the Court to the
exhibits filed and stated that the evidence placed by the claimants does not
reveal that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving and the
evidence adduced on behalf of the claimants also does not support the
arguments of the learned counsel for the claimants and requested the Court to
dismiss the appeal filed by the claimants.
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
14.
Owing to the arguments advanced on behalf of the claimants as
well as the respondents/Insurance Company, this Court is of the opinion that
the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant needs
attention and is also of the view that the Tribunal has not taken into
consideration the evidence placed in support of their claim particularly the
Ex.A11, which is the Motor Vehicle Inspector‟s report and also the charge
sheet filed in support. The arguments advanced by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the Insurance Company that when the claimants
approach the Tribunal under Section 166 of the Act, it is the burden of the
claimants to establish the negligence of the driver or the owner of the vehicle,
and in that absence, the claim of the claimants cannot be accepted and
asserted that the order passed by the Tribunal needs no interference.
15.
As outlined above, this Court finds that the evidence was not
properly appreciated and particularly in cases of Motor Vehicle Accidents,
which is beneficial piece of legislation, need to be considered in a liberal view
and strict adherence to the evidence or other laws need not to be adopted to.
dehors the evidence filed in support of the claimants clearly indicates that the
accident, in fact, occurred due to rash and negligent driving and this Court
holds that the claimants are entitled to compensation since the accident has
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the crime
vehicle, i.e., lorry bearing No.AP28TB5072.
16.
When the accident occurred was conclusive that due to rash and
negligent driving was proved, there would be no reason to disbelieve
Ex.A1 (FIR), Ex.A4 (post-mortem report), Ex.A10 (charge sheet) and Ex.A11
(Motor Vehicle Inspector‟s report). The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of
Sanju Bai Prajapati and Others vs. New India Assurance Company
Limited and Others1, held at paragraph No.6 as follows:
“6. As far as the accident, it is seen that there is no dispute since a Murg
report was made on intimation from the hospital which is produced as
(2025) 9 SCC 414
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
Annexure P-1 in which it was recorded that a person involved in a road
accident was admitted to the hospital who died at 12:30 am. The accident is
said to have occurred at 6 pm and the murg report was on the same day.
The mere fact that PW-2, the eyewitness did not approach the police cannot
be a reason to find the delay in FIR to be suspicious. The accident itself
having been proved and a Murg report filed, definitely investigation would be
carried out. We see from the FIR that based on the Murg report an
investigation was carried out in the course of which the eyewitness was
detected and Annexure P-2 FIR was registered. We do not find any reason
to disbelieve the FIR, especially since the insurance company did not make
any attempt to examine the investigating officer before the Tribunal.”
17.
Now coming to the quantum of compensation, the specific plea of
the claimants is that the deceased used to earn Rs.10,000/- per month and
used to spend towards the welfare of the family. This Court noticed that in the
entire pleadings, there is no supportive evidence to verify the claim of the
claimants that the deceased used to earn Rs.10,000/- per month and the
Court accepts the arguments advanced by the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the Insurance Company. The rulings of the Constitutional Courts
is that, in the case of coolie/contract labourers, the Court has fixed the earning
as Rs.7,000/- per month. But in view of the facts and circumstances of this
case, this Court takes Rs.5,000/- per month as income of the deceased, which
comes to Rs.5,000 x 12 = Rs.60,000/- per annum. 1/4th of the annual income
is deducted towards the personal expenses of the deceased, which finally
derived as Rs.45,000/- (Rs.60,000 x ¼). Applying the multiplier „17‟ as per the
judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Sarla Verma & Others
vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Another2, the compensation comes to
Rs.45,000 x 17 = Rs.7,65,000/-. An amount of Rs.70,000/- towards loss of
consortium, loss of estate and funeral expenses is fixed. The claimants placed
on record the medical bills amounting to Rs.1,35,150.24/-, which cannot be
denied, need to be also awarded to the claimants. Therefore, the total
compensation
comes
to Rs.7,65,000/-
+ 70,000/-
+
1,35,150.24
=
Rs.9,70,150.24/-.
18.
In fine, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is partly
allowed, setting aside the Order and Decree, dated 25.01.2017, in
2009 (3) ALD 83 (SC)
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1388 of 2017
M.V.O.P.No.627 of 2013, passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunalcum-XIV Additional District Judge, Vijayawada, granting compensation of
Rs.9,70,150.24/- to the claimants along with interest @ 6% per annum from
the date of filing of the petition till the date of realization. The respondents 1
and 2 are directed to deposit the aforesaid amount before the Tribunal, within
a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. On
such deposit, the claimants are entitled to withdraw the same in equal shares.
The shares of minor claimants shall be kept in Fixed Deposit in any
Nationalized Bank till they attain majority, and the interest accrued thereon
shall be paid to the 1st claimant. There shall be no order as to costs.
19.
As a sequitur, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
_______________________
TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA, J
Date: 02.01.2026
BMS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review