Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF JANUARY 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100309 OF 2022 (C)
BETWEEN:
BHIMAPPA S/O. RAMAPPA DURGI,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: FARMER,
R/O. BALOBAL, TQ: GOKAK, DIST: BELAGAVI.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. V.M. BANAKAR AND SRI. K. ANANDKUMAR, ADVOCATES)
AND:
STATE OF KARNATAKA,
THROUGH PSI GHATAPRABHA P.S.,
REPRESENTED BY S.P.P.
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH, DHARWAD.
…RESPONDENT
BHARATHI
HM
BHARATHI H M
Location:
HIGHCOURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
(BY SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADDITIONAL SPP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374(2) OF
CR.P.C. SEEKING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS AND SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT DATED 29.03.2022 PASSED BY THE XII ADDL. DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE BELAGAVI SITTING AT GOKAK IN S.C.
NO.8002/2020 AND CONSEQUENTLY ACQUIT THE APPELLANT FROM
THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 302 IPC IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This is the appeal filed under Section 374 of Cr.P.C.
praying for setting aside the judgment of conviction dated
29.03.2022 and order of sentence dated 31.03.2022 passed in
S.C.No.8002/2020 on the file of the learned XII Additional
District and Sessions Judge, Belagavi sitting at Gokak, for the
offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and sentencing him for
life and for a fine of ₹1,000/-, in default of payment of fine to
undergo simple imprisonment for 10 days.
2.
The parties would be referred with their ranks as
they were before the Trial Court for sake of convenience and
clarity.
3.
The case of prosecution in nutshell is that, accused
and deceased are brothers. PW.4 is the wife of accused and they
are having children. The deceased was unmarried. Accused was
suspecting that deceased was having illicit relationship with his
wife. Further, he had no intention to share the property with his
younger brother and thus, he was having motives to commit the
offence. It is the case of prosecution that there were frequent
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
quarrels between accused and deceased. On 28.06.2020 at
05.30 p.m. in the quarrel that took place between accused and
deceased,
accused
assaulted
deceased
with
sickle
on
his
forehead and neck and thereby murdered him. It is the case of
prosecution
that
complainant’s
son
P.W.4-the
wife
that
husband
her
of
accused
and
informed
deceased
were
quarreling with each other, and in turn son of complainant
informed it to the complainant, who along with P.W.2 and P.W.3
went to the spot of incident and while going there, they met with
accused who was holding a sickle in his hand, which was stained
with blood and his baniyan was also stained with blood. Accused
told them that he killed his younger brother-Basavaraj and then
they went to the spot i.e., in front of the house of accused and
deceased, wherein they saw that deceased was lying on the floor
and blood was oozing out from his neck and he was already
dead.
4.
According to the case of prosecution, some public
have informed these facts to the concerned police station and
accordingly, P.W.13-P.S.I. of the police station came to the spot,
and at the time, P.W.1 lodged a written complaint at the spot at
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
10.30 p.m. and he received it and then went to police station
and registered the case in Crime No.142/2020 and thus the
criminal law was set into motion.
5.
filed
After conducting thorough investigation, the I.O. has
charge
sheet
against
accused
alleging
the
offence
punishable under Section 302 of IPC.
6.
On behalf of prosecution, total 16 witnesses were
examined apart from marking Exs.P.1 to 47(a) and M.Os.1 to
10(a).
7.
After completion of evidence of prosecution side,
statement of accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. was recorded by
putting questions incriminating against him. In that statement,
accused accepted his relationship with deceased P.W.1 to 3,
however, denied all other incriminating evidence put against him.
He has not given any statement of defence and not led any
defence evidence. After recording statement under Section 313
Cr.P.C and hearing arguments of both sides, both oral and
written, the learned Session Judge has convicted the accused
under Section 302 IPC on the grounds that accused and
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
deceased along with P.W.4 and P.W.5 were residing under the
same roof; even though, the deceased was murdered at about
05.30 p.m., accused absconded from the spot and traced only on
the next day at 08.00 a.m. From the evidence of doctor and
F.S.L. report, it is clear that the death was homicidal. The F.S.L.
report establishes that the clothes found on deceased as well as
on the accused, the weapon recovered at the instance of accused
were stained with ‘A’ group blood.
8.
Aggrieved by the said judgment of conviction and
order of sentence, the appellant/accused is before this Court.
9.
Heard arguments of both the sides.
10.
Learned counsel Sri V.M. Bankar would submit that
except the official witnesses, none has supported the case of
prosecution. The recovery of the weapon and clothes of accused
at his instance is not proved. The spot panchanama and inquest
panchanama are not proved in accordance with law because
none of those witnesses have supported the case of prosecution.
11.
Learned counsel for accused would further submit
that there are several contradictions in the evidence of P.W.1 to
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
P.W.3 and P.W.15. According to P.W.1, P.W.4 has made phone
call to P.W.15 and P.W.15 informed it to him and hence, P.W.1
along with P.W.2 and P.W.3 had been to the spot, but according
to P.W.4 and P.W.15, P.W.4 has not made any phone call to
anyone and P.W.15 has not received any phone call. The I.O.
also has not made any efforts to collect the phone numbers of
both P.W.4 and P.W.15 and Call Detail Records (CDRs.) of those
two phones. According to the case of prosecution, the motive is
the suspicion of accused about illicit relationship between
deceased and P.W.4, which is not at all established. As per the
case of prosecution, accused has given extra judicial confession
before PWs.1 to 3, but none of them have deposed on said point.
Hence, the second motive, i.e. sharing of property with deceased
is also not established by producing any cogent evidence.
However, the learned Sessions Judge has not verified any of
these aspects and convicted the accused and thus, finding of
learned Sessions Judge is erroneous and it requires interference.
12.
The learned Additional S.P.P. Sri M.B. Gundawada
would submit that the relationship between parties is not in
dispute. The deceased is none other than the younger brother of
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
the accused and he is unmarried. P.W.1 has specifically deposed
about receipt of phone call from P.W.4 to P.W.15, who in turn
informed it to P.W.1., P.W.1 to P.W.3 have deposed that they
had been to the spot after receipt of such information and
immediately after the incident, they have seen the deceased
lying on the floor with fatal injuries on his neck. P.W.3 had
deposed that on the way to spot, they have seen the accused.
Furthermore, the post-mortem report, the opinion of doctor
about the weapon used for commission of offence clearly
establishes the homicidal death of deceased. The F.S.L. report
corroborates the case of prosecution.
Because all the private
witnesses are closely related to the accused, they have not
supported the case of prosecution and merely because they
turned hostile, the case of prosecution cannot be discarded in
toto.
All the official witnesses have supported the case of
prosecution.
The investigation conducted by the I.O. in proper
manner categorically establishes the case of prosecution beyond
reasonable doubt. Except accused, none could have committed
these
offences
and
he
absconded
from
substantiates the case of prosecution.
the
spot,
which
Considering these
aspects, rightly the learned Sessions Judge has convicted the
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
accused and it needs no interference. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of the appeal.
13.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, perused
the records of the appeal and the Trial Court records, the points
that arise for consideration are as follows:
i)
Whether the prosecution is able to establish
beyond
reasonable
doubt
that
accused
has
committed the murder of his younger brotherBasavaraj Ramappa Durgi by using sickle (Kurapi)
on 28.06.2020 at 05.30 p.m. in front of his house
situated at, Balobal, Tq: Gokak and thereby
committed the offence punishable under Section
302 IPC?
ii)
Whether the judgment of conviction of accused
and order of sentence passed against accused by
learned Sessions Judge is justifiable and the
reasons assigned are in accordance with law?
iii)
Whether the judgment of Trial Court requires
interference?
14.
Finding on the above points No.1 & 2 is in NEGATIVE
and on point No.3 is in AFFIRMATIVE for the following:
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
REASONS
15.
The case of prosecution in nutshell is that, accused
and deceased are brothers. Accused and P.W.4 are husband and
wife and they are having children and deceased was unmarried.
Accused had a suspicion that deceased was having illicit
relationship with his wife and had no intention to share the
property with his younger brother and thus, he was having
motives to commit the offence. It is the case of prosecution that
there were frequent quarrels between accused and deceased. On
28.06.2020 at 05.30 p.m. in front of their house in the quarrel
that has taken place between accused and Basavaraj Ramappa
Durgi, accused with the intention to kill his brother, assaulted
with a sickle on the forehead and neck of his brother- Basavaraj
Ramappa Durgi and thereby murdered him.
16.
To substantiate the case of prosecution, prosecution
relies upon the evidence of P.W.1 to P.W.3 and official witnesses
PWs.12 to 14 & 16. P.W.1 is the complainant; P.W.2 & P.W.3
accompanied the complainant to the spot of incident; P.W.4 is
the wife of the accused; P.W.5 is the daughter of the accused;
PWs.6 & 10 are said to be the inquest panch witness; PWs.7 &
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
11 are said to be the panch witnesses to the spot mahazar and
drawing of rough sketch and seizure of M.O.1 to 4; P.W.8 & 9
are said to be panch witnesses for Exs.P.18 to 20-panchanamas
i.e., seizure of M.O. No.5 to 10; P.W.12 is the doctor, who
conducted Post-Mortem (P.M.) on deceased on 29.06.2020 from
07.45 to 9.10 a.m. P.W.13 is the P.S.I. of concerned police
station who received the complaint from P.W.1 and registered
the case and also apprehended the accused on the direction of
I.O.-P.W.16; P.W.14 is the Scientific Officer of F.S.L., Belagavi,
who examined MOs.1, 2, 5, 6, 8, 9 & 10; P.W.15 is the son of
P.W.1; P.W.16 is the I.O.
17.
There are no eyewitnesses to the incident. Hence,
the case is based on circumstantial evidence.
Therefore, the
prosecution has to prove the following:
i.
the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is
to be drawn should be fully established. The
circumstances concerned must or should and not may
be established;
ii.
the facts so established should be consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to
say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty;
iii.
the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature
and tendency;
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
iv.
they should exclude every possible hypothesis except
the one to be proved; and
v.
there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not
to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and must
show that in all human probability the act must have
been done by the accused.
18.
In
this case, as per the case of prosecution, the
chain links to connect accused to this case are as follows:
i)
Firstly,
P.W.4
informed
the
quarrel
between
accused and the deceased to P.W.15 through
phone. In turn, P.W.15 informed it to P.W.1 who
has taken P.W.2 & P.W.3 and had been to the
spot i.e., in front of the house of accused and
deceased; and they have seen the dead body of
deceased.
ii)
Secondly, on the way to the said spot, P.W.1 to
P.W.3 have met accused with the weapon and
accused
made
extrajudicial
confession
before
P.W.1 to P.W.3 that he himself has murdered his
brother.
iii) Thirdly, drawing up of spot panchanama and spot
sketch and seizure of MOs.1 to 4 from the spot of
incident.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
iv) Fourthly, post mortem (P.M.) report and the
doctor
certified
that
death
of
deceased
is
stained
clothes
of
homicidal.
v)
Fifthly,
seizure
of
blood
deceased.
vi) Sixthly, arrest of accused and afterwards seizure
of his blood stained cloth.
vii) Seventhly,
accused
has
taken
the
I.O.
and
panchas and produced the weapon used for
commission of offence which was also blood
stained.
viii) Eighthly, F.S.L. report stating that the articles
seized at the spot i.e. blood stained mud, clothes
of deceased, cloth of accused and the weapon
were stained with human blood of ‘A’ group.
If all the above chains are established, then the prosecution can
prove the complete chain of link. Furthermore, according to the
case of prosecution, accused was having two motives. One is he
was suspecting the fidelity of his wife and deceased i.e. their
illicit relationship and second one is to avoid giving share to the
deceased who was unmarried. This motive plays an important
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
role in case of murder that too based on circumstantial
evidence.
19.
Now, we have to analyse whether prosecution is able
to establish all or any of these links.
20.
All private witnesses including complainant turned
hostile and were cross-examined by learned PP. However, merely
because they turned hostile, their evidence cannot be discarded
in toto; but is to be analysed with great care and caution. When
the alleged offence is heinous in nataure; the degree of proof
should also be high.
21.
From the evidence of P.W.1, we can only gather that
his son-P.W.15 received a phone call from P.W.4 that accused
and deceased were quarreling and immediately, P.W.15 informed
it to P.W.1 and thus P.W.1 while going to the house of accused
and deceased had taken P.W.2 and P.W.3 along with him and
when they reached the spot, Basavaraj was lying dead in front of
his house and people had gathered. Thus, it is clear that P.W.1
has not seen the incident. The evidence of P.W.1 on the point
that his son received a phone call from P.W.4 is not supported by
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
the evidence of P.W.4 and P.W.15. P.W.4 has deposed that she
has not made any phone call to anyone and P.W.15 has deposed
that he has not received any phone call from anyone and has not
given any information to P.W.1.
22.
From the evidence of P.W.2, we can only gather that
he had been to the spot along with P.W.1 & P.W.3 and they saw
Basavaraj lying dead on the floor and blood was oozing from his
neck and there was an injury on his neck.
23.
From the evidence of P.W.3, we could gather the
above fact and also that he accompanied P.Ws.1 & 2 to the spot
and saw the dead body of Basavaraj and blood had oozed and
further on their way to the spot, P.W.3 saw the accused and
according to him, accused did not tell anything.
24.
P.W.4, who is the wife and P.W.5, who is the
daughter of accused are closely related to accused and thus
naturally have not supported the case of the prosecution. Thus,
the prosecution cannot depend on their evidence to establish its
case.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
25.
PWs.6 & 10 are the inquest panch witnesses. They,
except admitting their presence at the spot by identifying
themselves in the photographs, have not supported the case of
prosecution. Nothing was elicited in their cross-examination to
believe that they have seen the injuries on the dead body.
26.
P.W.7 & P.W.11 are said to be the panch witnesses
to Ex.P-16-spot mahazar and of rough sketch at Ex.P-17.
According to the case of the prosecution, M.Os.1 to 4 were
recovered from the spot in their presence. However, they have
not supported the case of the prosecution regarding seizure of
M.Os.1 to 4 from said spot.
27.
P.W.8 & P.W.9 are said to be the witnesses for
recovery of clothes of the deceased, baniyan of accused in the
police station and at their instance, IO has recovered M.O.10weapon (sickle) from the lands of one Appayya Patil, which is
adjacent to the lands of the accused. However, they have not
supported the case of prosecution on these facts in their
examination-in-chief.
Hence, they were treated as hostile.
In
the cross-examination by learned PP, P.W.8 has admitted the
entire case of prosecution but again in the cross-examination by
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
the learned counsel for the accused, he has deposed that he
does not know anything about these two panchanamas.
But,
nothing was elicited in the cross-examination of P.W.9 by the
learned PP to believe that in his presence M.O.9 & 10 were
seized. Thus the evidence of P.W.8 & P.W.9 is not sufficient to
show that in their presence, accused has produced his banian;
took them to the land of one Appayya Patil and produced
M.O.10-weapon.
28.
The evidence of the Investigating Officer cannot be
discarded in toto only because it is not corroborated by
independent witnesses. However, his evidence needs to be
looked into with great care and caution to accept his evidence
without corroboration.
29.
In the instant case, evidence of P.W.13-PSI reveals
that he apprehended the accused on the next day of the incident,
as per the oral direction of P.W.16, at Naka No.1 of Gokak at
08.00 a.m. and produced before P.W.16 at 08.30 a.m.
30.
According to the case of prosecution, P.W.16 arrested
the accused and recorded his voluntary statement as per
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
Ex.P.37, wherein the admissible portion under Section 27 of the
Evidence Act “PÉÆ¯É ªÀiÁqÀ®Ä G¥ÀAiÉÆÃV¹zÀ PÀĦð ªÀÄÄaÑnÖgÄÀ vÉÛãÉ, £À£ßÀ
¸ÀAUÀqÀ §AzÀgÉ vÉÆÃj¹ ºÁdgÀ ¥Àr¸ÀÄvÉãɔ and based on it, he has
called the panchas i.e. P.W.8 & P.W.9 to the police station and
along with them had been to the lands of one Ayyappa Patil in
the police jeep as per the directions of accused and in that spot,
the accused produced the weapon-MO.10-sickle in presence of
panchas. However, as discussed above, those panchas have not
supported the case of prosecution. Further, the alleged weapon
seized from an open space in the neighbouring lands of accused
and deceased. Thus, said place is accessible to public.
31.
Under those circumstances, seizure of the weapon at
the instance of accused is doubtful.
32.
According to the evidence of P.W.3, he had seen the
accused while going to the spot but PWs.1 & 2 have not sated so.
Further, P.W.3 has not deposed that he had seen the accused
with the weapon.
Under these circumstances, the evidence of
P.W.3 is of least importance to prove the case of prosecution.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
33.
The evidence of P.W.14 establishes that Article
Nos.1, 5, 6, 8 to 10 were stained with “A” group human blood.
However, the prosecution has not produced any material to show
that the blood group of deceased or accused was “A” group to
connect those articles to this case. Furthermore, seizure of those
articles is under suspicion because none of the seizure witnesses
of these articles have supported the case of prosecution. Under
these circumstances, the evidence of Investigating Officer needs
corroboration which is lacking in the present case.
34.
P.W.15
Furthermore, as per the averments in the complaint,
has
received
the
phone
call
from
P.W.4.
But,
Investigation Officer has not made any efforts to collect the
phone numbers of P.W.4 and P.W.15 and to obtain CDRs of those
phone numbers to establish the said fact.
35.
According to the evidence of the Investigating
officer, he has seized M.O.10 in the presence of panchas and his
staff accompanied him to the said spot.
However, none of his
staff were examined to substantiate this fact.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
36.
Furthermore, as per the case of prosecution, the
weapon was recovered from the landed property of one Ayyappa
Patil.
Said witness is not examined by the prosecution. It is
recovered from the open space. Hence, it cannot be said beyond
reasonable doubt that the accused had hid the weapon in that
place.
There is every possibility that some other person could
conceal the weapon in the said place. Furthermore, seizure of it
is also not proved as discussed above.
37.
Without proving the seizure of weapon at the
instance of accused and without proving the seizure of blood
stained cloth of accused at his instance, mere producing the FSL
report saying that they were stained with human blood of ‘A’
group is of no use in proving the guilt of accused.
38.
Furthermore, according to the complaint, CW.14 is its
scribe. But according to P.W.1 it was written by the police. Under
those
circumstances, examination
important.
prosecution.
But
he
was
not
of
the
examined
scribe
on
was very
behalf
of
the
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
39.
The case of prosecution is that, P.W.4 had last seen
accused and deceased quarelling with each other. However, as
discussed above, P.W.4 has not deposed so. As discussed above,
it is P.W.4 who gave this information to P.W.1 through P.W.15.
But, both P.W.4 & 15 have not deposed so.
Thus, there is no
chain link to connect accused to the case.
40.
According to the case of prosecution, accused was
suspecting the fidelity of his wife and suspecting that she had
illicit relationship with the deceased, who is none other than his
brother. But, none of the prosecution witnesses deposed on this
point. Hence, motive for the accused to murder his own brother
is not established.
41.
As discussed above, only, when prosecution proves
all the links and completes the chain of circumstances against
accused, then, the case of prosecution is to be considered as
proved.
42.
contend
At this stage, the learned Additional SPP would
that
immediately
after
the
incident, the
accused
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
absconded from the spot and he was traced only on the following
day and his conduct itself substantiates the case of prosecution.
43.
The abscondence of accused from the spot is quite
natural, as FIR was lodged against him. The Hon’ble Apex Court
in the case of Paramjeet Singh alias Pamma v. State of
Uttarakhand reported in
(2010) 10 Supreme Court Cases
439 with regard to ‘abscondence of accused’ has held as follows:
“Abscondence of accused
31. In Matru v. State of U.P., this court repelled the
submissions made by the State that as after
commission of the offence the accused had been
absconding, therefore, the inference can be drawn that
he was a guilty person, observing as under:
“19. The appellant's conduct in absconding was also
relied upon. Now, mere abscondence by itself does not
necessarily lead to a firm conclusion of guilty mind. Even
an innocent man may feel panicky and try to evade arrest
when wrongly suspected of a grave crime such is the
instinct of self-preservation. The act of absconding is no
doubt relevant piece of evidence to be considered along
with other evidence but its value would always depend on
the circumstances of each case. Normally the courts are
disinclined to attach much importance to the act of
absconding, treating it as a very small item in the
evidence for sustaining conviction. It can scarcely be held
as a determining link in completing the chain of
circumstantial evidence which must admit of no other
reasonable hypothesis than that of the guilt of the
accused. In the present case the appellant was with Ram
Chandra till the FIR was lodged. If thereafter he felt that
he was being wrongly suspected and he tried to keep out
of the way we do not think this circumstance can be
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
considered to be necessarily evidence of a guilty mind
attempting to evade justice. It is not inconsistent with his
innocence.”
32. A similar view has been reiterated by this Court
in Rahman v. State of U.P. [(1972) 4 SCC (N) 6 : AIR
1972 SC 110] , State of M.P. v. Paltan Mallah [(2005) 3
SCC 169 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 674] and Bipin Kumar
Mondal v. State of W.B. [(2010) 12 SCC 91 : JT (2010) 7
SC 379]
33. Abscondence by a person against whom FIR has been
lodged, having an apprehension of being apprehended by
the police, cannot be said to be unnatural. Thus, mere
abscondence by the appellant after commission of the
crime and remaining untraceable for a period of six days
itself cannot establish his guilt. Absconding by itself is not
conclusive proof of either guilt or of a guilty conscience.”
44.
Respectfully relying on the above principles, we are
of the opinion that merely because accused was not there at the
spot from the night of the day of incident till next day morning, it
cannot be said that he with guilty mind absconded from the spot
of incident.
45.
The evidence of doctor coupled with PM Report only
establishes that death of deceased was homicidal and not
accidental or suicidal. However, to connect the accused to this,
it needs corroboration from the evidence of witnesses, which is
not available in the instant case.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
46.
The evidence of official witnesses only establishes the
procedure of investigation.
Their evidence is not sufficient to
connect the accused to the offence of murder of his own brother.
There shall be strong motive for the accused to kill his brother,
which is not at all established in this case.
47.
The above discussion reveals that except proving
that the death of Basavaraj Ramappa Durgi is homicidal, the
prosecution has failed to establish the motive of accused, seizure
of articles from relevant spots under different panchanamas and
extrajudicial confession of accused with P.W.1 to 3. In the case
of present nature, the evidence of official witnesses requires
corroboration, which is lacking.
48.
Thus, the prosecution has failed to prove the charge
leveled against the accused beyond reasonable doubt that on
28.06.2020 at 5:30 p.m., the accused assaulted his younger
brother with a sickle on his neck and forehead and caused
bleeding injuries and because of it, Basavaraj died at the spot.
However, the learned Sessions Judge has not appreciated the
evidence in a proper manner in accordance with law and the
reasons
assigned
by
him
are
not
justifiable.
Hence,
the
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:692-DB
CRL.A No. 100309 of 2022
HC-KAR
impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence is liable
to be interfered with.
49.
Accordingly points 1 to 3 are answered and we
proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The appeal filed under Section 374(2) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure is allowed by setting aside the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence passed in S.C. No.8002/2020
dated 29.03.2022 on the file of the learned XII Additional District
and Sessions Judge, Belagavi, sitting at Gokak.
The accused is acquitted of the offence punishable under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. The bail bond executed by
the accused shall be in force for a period of six months as
required under Section 437-A of Cr.P.C.
Sd/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SSP: PARA 1 TO 1
KMV: Para 19 to end
CT-MCK
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review