Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:4005
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRMP No. 2862 of 2024
1 - Bharti Sahu And Anr. W/o Vijay Kumar Sahu Aged About 27 Years
R/o Village Joratarai, Shitala Para, P.S. Bhilai Bhatti, Tehsil Durg,
District Durg, C.G.
2 - Naitik Kumar Sahu S/o Vijay Kumar Sahu Aged About 6 Years (Minor
Natural Guardian Mother Bharti Sahu), R/o Village Joratarai, Shitala
Para, P.S. Bhilai Bhatti, Tehsil Durg, District Durg, C.G.
... Petitioners
versus
Vijay Kumar Sahu S/o Jagannath Sahu Aged About 30 Years R/o
Village Kataro P.S. Utai, Chowki Machandur Tehsil Durg, District Durg,
C.G.
... Respondent
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
Digitally
signed by
PREETI
PREETI KUMARI
KUMARI Date:
2026.01.24
11:09:56
+0530
For Petitioners
: Mr. Virendra Kashyap, Advocate
For Respondent
: Mr. Punit Ruparel, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
22.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Virendra Kashyap, learned counsel for the petitioners
and Mr. Punit Ruparel, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent.
2.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioners with the
following relief:-
“It is therefore prayed that, this Hon'ble Court may
kindly
be
pleased
to
allow
this
Criminal
Miscellaneous Petition against the order dated
27/09/2024 wherein the passed by the learned
Principal Judge of Family Court Durg (C.G.) in
Miscellaneous Criminal Case No.494/2019 in the
interest of justice.”
3.
Mr. Virendra Kashyap, learned counsel for the petitioners submits
that the impugned order dated 27.09.2024, passed by the learned
Family Court, Durg, allowing the application of the respondent for
conducting a DNA test of applicant No.2, is illegal, arbitrary, and
unsustainable in law. It is submitted that the marriage between
applicant No.1 and the respondent admittedly took place on
24.04.2018, and applicant No.2 was born on 27.12.2018 during
the subsistence of the said lawful wedlock. The respondent has
himself admitted both the marriage and the date of birth of
applicant No.2 in his reply filed under Section 125 CrPC. He
further submits that despite admitted cohabitation of the parties
after
marriage,
the
respondent
has
made
reckless
and
scandalous allegations against the character of applicant No.1,
only with a view to evade his statutory obligation of maintenance.
The allegations of alleged prior relationship are baseless, vague,
and unsubstantiated, and have been raised for the first time only
to defeat the object of Section 125 CrPC.
4.
It is submitted by Mr. Kashyap that the learned Family Court has
completely ignored the statutory presumption under Section 112
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which accords conclusive proof
of legitimacy to a child born during a valid marriage. The
respondent has neither pleaded nor proved non-access at the
time of conception, which is the only legally permissible mode to
rebut the presumption under Section 112. In the absence of such
pleadings or proof, the direction for DNA test is wholly
impermissible. He further submits that the proceedings under
Section 125 CrPC are summary in nature, intended to provide
immediate succour to destitute wife and child, and issues relating
to paternity are essentially civil in nature, which cannot be
permitted to derail maintenance proceedings. The respondent
was fully aware of the birth of applicant No.2 since 2018 and
never disputed paternity until the maintenance proceedings, which
clearly demonstrates mala fide intent.
5.
Mr. Kashyap contends that the learned Family Court has passed
the impugned order in a mechanical manner, without recording
any finding of eminent need or necessity for conducting DNA test,
and without weighing the serious consequences of such an order
on the dignity of applicant No.1 and the legitimacy of applicant
No.2, contrary to the settled law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Kantidevi vs. Poshiram (2001) 5 SCC 311
and Banarsi Dass vs. Tiku Dutta (2005) 4 SCC 449.
6.
Lastly, Mr. Kashyap submits that the impugned order suffers from
non-application of mind, is contrary to settled legal principles, and
deserves to be quashed and set aside, in order to protect the
statutory object of Section 125 CrPC and the legitimacy of the
minor child.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. Punit Ruparel, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent opposes the submissions advanced by learned
counsel for the petitioners and submits that the present petition
has been preferred challenging the order dated 27.09.2024,
passed by the learned Family Court, Durg, in the proceedings
under Section 125 of CrPC, whereby the application filed by the
respondent for conducting DNA test of petitioner No.2 has been
allowed. It is submitted that the petitioners had instituted the
proceedings under Section 125 CrPC seeking maintenance of
Rs.10,000/- per month, whereas the respondent has specifically
pleaded that he is not the biological father of petitioner No.2.
8.
Mr. Ruparel further submits that the learned Family Court, in
separate divorce proceedings, has recorded a categorical finding
that petitioner No.1 was pregnant for about 36 weeks at the time
of marriage with the respondent. On the basis of such finding, the
learned Family Court has granted a decree of divorce, thereby
dissolving the marriage between petitioner No.1 and the
respondent vide judgment and decree dated 09.10.2024. In view
of the said judicial determination, the respondent was fully justified
in seeking DNA examination to ascertain the paternity of petitioner
No.2. It is further submitted that although the maintenance
proceedings under Section 125 CrPC may continue irrespective of
the DNA test, the question of paternity is a foundational fact, and
conducting DNA test would conclusively determine whether the
respondent is the biological father of petitioner No.2. Learned
counsel submits that even if petitioner No.2 is ultimately held to be
legitimate or illegitimate, the legal consequences would follow, but
the DNA report is essential for determining the entitlement of
petitioner No.1. If the DNA report establishes that the respondent
is not the biological father, the respondent would be entitled to
demonstrate that petitioner No.1 was living in adultery, thereby
attracting the bar contained under Section 125(4) CrPC,
disentitling her from claiming maintenance.
9.
It is submitted by Mr. Ruparel that the impugned order has been
passed after due consideration of the facts and applicable legal
principles. Reliance is placed on the judgment passed by the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Preeti Miraniya v. Sanjay
Miraniya, (2021) 3 CGLJ 430, wherein a similar issue was raised
before this Court. In the said case, the wife had challenged the
order directing DNA test, and this Court, after considering the law
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dipanwita Roy v.
Ronobroto Roy, (2015) 1 SCC 365, dismissed the criminal
revision and upheld the order of the Family Court. The contention
that a wife cannot be compelled to undergo DNA testing was
specifically considered and negatived. As such, the order dated
27.09.2024 passed by the learned Family Court does not suffer
from any illegality or perversity and warrants no interference in the
present petition.
10.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perused the documents annexed with the present petition.
11.
From perusal of the impugned order, it transpires that the learned
Family Court, Durg, while considering the application (IA No. 1/24)
filed by the respondent for conducting DNA test in proceedings
under Section 125 CrPC, has allowed the said application vide
order dated 27.09.2024, primarily on the ground that the paternity
of petitioner No.2 is disputed. The learned Family Court relied
upon the respondent’s plea that petitioner No.1 had admitted a
prior physical relationship and pregnancy before marriage, as well
as a statement recorded during cross-examination indicating
willingness for DNA testing. The Court held that determination of
paternity was essential for adjudication of the maintenance claim
and, accordingly, directed DNA testing of petitioner No.2, his
mother (petitioner No.1), and the respondent at the Centre for
DNA
Fingerprinting
and
Diagnostics,
Hyderabad,
at
the
respondent’s cost.
12.
In Preeti Miraniya (supra), the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court,
has held as follows :“7. The scope of a Revisional Court is very
limited to the extent of determining the legality,
propriety and correctness of the order passed.
In the present case, the application filed by the
respondent was allowed unopposed by the
applicant side. Therefore, there is nothing to
make out that the impugned order is illegal,
improper or incorrect in any sense. The
concern of the applicants with respect to the
consequences of the D.N.A. test have come up
at a subsequent stage and it is because of that
the applicants now do not want to submit to
D.N.A. Test. In the case of Dipanwita Roy
(Supra)
the
Supreme
Court
has
made
observation in paragraph 18 as follows:“18. We would, however, while upholding the
order passed by the High Court, consider it
just and appropriate to record a caveat,
giving the appellant-wife liberty to comply
with or disregard the order passed by the
High Court, requiring the holding of the DNA
test. In case, she accepts the direction
issued by the High Court, the DNA test will
determine
conclusively
the
veracity
accusation
levelled
the
respondent-
by
of
husband against her. In case, she declines to
comply with the direction issued by the High
Court, the allegation would be determined by
the
concerned
Court,
by
drawing
a
presumption of the nature contemplated in
Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act,
especially, in terms of illustration (h) thereof.
Section 114 as also illustration (h), referred to
above, are being extracted hereunder:
“114. Court may presume existence of
certain facts – The Court may presume the
existence of any fact which it thinks likely to
have happened, regard being had to the
common course of natural events, human
conduct and public and private business, in
their relation to the facts of the particular
case.
Illustration (h) - That if a man refuses to
answer a question which he is not compelled
to answer by law, the answer, if given, would
be unfavourable to him.”
This course has been adopted to preserve
the right of individual privacy to the extent
possible. Of course, without sacrificing the
cause of justice. By adopting the above
course, the issue of infidelity alone would be
determined, without expressly disturbing the
presumption contemplated under Section 112
of the Indian Evidence Act. Even though, as
already stated above, undoubtedly the issue
of legitimacy would also be incidentally
involved.”
8. Therefore, it has been expressed by the
Supreme Court that even after the passing of
an order for conducting D.N.A. Test, one of the
parties which is the applicant in this case, has
option either to submit or to decline the same.
Therefore, in case, the applicants refuse to
submit
in
D.N.A.
Test,
they
cannot
be
compelled to do so, of course there shall be
consequences of such non submission.
9. Consent has been defined in the Section 13
of the Contract Act that “Two or more persons
are said to consent when they agree upon the
same thing in the same sense.” Any consent
given can be revoked at any later stage and it
is same case present her. Hence, on the basis
of the discussions made hereinabove, it is held
that there is no ground present under Section
397 of Cr.P.C. to entertain this revision for
setting aside the impugned order. Hence, the
petition is dismissed, however, according to the
observations made hereinbefore, the applicants
are at liberty to exercise any option and in case
of their refusal, there shall be no compulsion on
them in any manner.”
13.
It is not in dispute that the respondent has specifically disputed
the paternity of petitioner No.2 in the proceedings under Section
125 CrPC, and such dispute is not a vague or bald assertion but
is
founded
upon
pleadings,
evidence
led
during
cross-
examination, and a judicial finding already recorded in the
connected matrimonial proceedings. The learned Family Court,
while granting a decree of divorce vide judgment dated
09.10.2024, has recorded a categorical finding that petitioner No.1
was carrying an advanced pregnancy of about 36 weeks at the
time of marriage. Such finding, though rendered in separate
proceedings, undoubtedly has a bearing on the issue of paternity
raised in the maintenance proceedings.
14.
This Court is mindful of the statutory presumption enshrined under
Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act and the salutary object
sought to be achieved by proceedings under Section 125 CrPC
However, it is equally well settled that the presumption under
Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act, is not absolute in all
circumstances, and where compelling facts exist giving rise to a
serious and bona fide dispute regarding paternity, the Court is not
powerless to permit scientific examination for arriving at the truth,
particularly when such determination goes to the root of the
matter.
15.
The impugned order does not reflect any mechanical exercise of
jurisdiction. Rather, the learned Family Court has considered the
pleadings of the parties, the admissions attributed to petitioner
No.1 during evidence, and the necessity of determining paternity
for the just adjudication of the maintenance claim. The direction
for DNA testing has been issued after due application of mind and
by placing reliance on settled legal principles.
16.
This Court also finds merit in the submission that the direction to
undergo DNA testing does not amount to compelling the
petitioners to submit to the test. The law, as authoritatively laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dipanwita Roy (supra)
and followed by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Preeti
Miraniya (supra), clearly preserves the autonomy of the
concerned party either to comply with or decline such direction,
subject to the legal consequences flowing therefrom. Therefore,
the contention that the impugned order per se violates the dignity,
privacy, or statutory rights of petitioners, is devoid of substance.
17.
In the considered view of this Court, the impugned order neither
suffers from illegality, perversity, nor non-application of mind so as
to warrant interference in exercise of the limited supervisory
jurisdiction of this Court. The learned Family Court has acted well
within the bounds of its jurisdiction, and the order impugned
represents a judicious exercise of discretion aimed at discovering
the truth and securing the ends of justice.
18.
Accordingly, the Criminal Miscellaneous Petition being devoid of
merit is hereby dismissed. It is, however, clarified that the
petitioners shall be at liberty to exercise their option in accordance
with law in respect of the direction for DNA testing, and the
learned Family Court shall proceed further strictly in consonance
with settled legal principles, without being influenced by any
observations made herein, which are confined only to the
adjudication of the present petition.
19.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Preeti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review