Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:7929
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MCRC No. 912 of 2026
VAIBHAV
SINGH
VAIBHAV SINGH
Date: 2026.02.13
12:59:19 +0530
Bharat Singh S/o Shri Khuman Singh Aged About 41 Years Presently
R/o House No. A-232, Uni-Homes Bhatagaon, Raipur C.G. And
Permanent R/o Near Kisan Rice Mill, Neora, Distt. Raipur C.G.
... Applicant
versus
Union Of India Through Superintendent Of A.C.B./c.B.I., Raipur C.G.
... Non-Applicant
For Applicant
: Mr. Pragalbha Sharma, Advocate.
For Non-Applicant/UOI : Mr. Vaibhav A. Goverdhan, Advocate.
Hon'ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
12.02.2026
1. This is the Second bail application filed under Section 483 of the
Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 for grant of regular bail
to the applicant who has been arrested in connection with Crime
No. RC1242025A0002 registered at Police Station – A.C.B./C.B.I.
Raipur (C.G.), for the offence punishable under Sections 61(2) of
BNS and Section 7 and 7A of the Prevention of Corruption Act
1988.
2. The earlier bail application of the applicant being MCRC No. 2981
of 2025 was rejected by this Court vide order dated 20.05.2025,
on merits.
3. The case of the prosecution is that on 31.01.2025 an FIR was
registered on the basis of a complaint made by Lalchand Athwani,
proprietor of M/s The World of Beauty, situated at Station Road,
Durg, alleging that the present applicant, while posted as
Superintendent in Central Goods & Services Tax, Raipur,
conducted a raid at his shop on 28.01.2025 and 29.01.2025 and
thereafter, in criminal conspiracy with co-accused Vinay and one
Shri Mishra (absconding), demanded a bribe of ₹34,00,000 to
settle the GST liability of the complainant; upon his request for
negotiation,
the
bribe
amount
was
allegedly
reduced
to
₹10,00,000, but as the complainant was unwilling to pay, he
submitted a written complaint on 30.01.2025 to the Central
Bureau of Investigation, whereupon the CBI verified the
allegations and registered an FIR under Section 61(2) of the BNS
read with Sections 7 and 7A of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988; on 31.01.2025 a trap was laid after completing pre-trap
formalities and at about 06:00 PM the complainant received a call
from co-accused Vinay Rai asking him to reach outside Currency
Tower at VIP Chowk, Raipur, where the bribe money was handed
over to Vinay Rai and he was apprehended by the investigating
agency with the tainted money, and it is further alleged that the
present applicant was thereafter called by an Inspector to the
CGST office, where his mobile phone and one green file
containing 72 pages relating to the search conducted on
28.01.2025 at the premises of the said firm were seized along with
two bill books and two hard disks from the CGST office at Raipur,
and a copy of the FIR is annexed as Annexure A/2.
4. The applicant is innocent and has been falsely implicated by the
investigating agency despite having no role in the commission of
the alleged offence. The present second bail application is being
filed on account of a significant change in circumstances after
rejection of the earlier bail application and dismissal of the SLP by
the Supreme Court of India on 04.08.2025, inasmuch as the
investigating agency has filed a Supplementary Final Report
(charge sheet) on 06.09.2025 and similarly placed or higherranked co-accused persons have been granted bail by the trial
court; notably, the main officer and team leader of the raid, Shri
Subrato Pal, along with seven other co-accused, has already
been enlarged on bail, whereas the applicant was merely a
member of the team acting under his directions as per the search
authorization. The co-accused Subrato Pal, who was responsible
for determining the tax liability, has been granted bail and
therefore continued detention of the applicant amounts to violation
of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India, particularly when
the Supplementary Final Report dated 06.09.2025 does not
disclose any evidence against the applicant showing his
involvement
conversations
in
the
alleged
relating
to
the
offence.
demand
The
transcripts
verification
of
dated
30.01.2025 and the trap dated 31.01.2025 also do not indicate
that the applicant either demanded or accepted any bribe, and the
allegations against him are based solely on the statements of the
complainant and unverified third-party witnesses, which are
matters of trial. The earlier rejection of bail on the allegation that
the applicant removed a DVR hard disk was based only on the
statements of Lalchand Athwani and Mohit Athwani, which stand
contradicted in the supplementary charge sheet and therefore
cannot be relied upon. The allegation that the applicant conspired
with Mishra and Vinay Rai to demand ₹34,00,000/- and accepted
₹10,00,000/- as an instalment is untenable, as the determination
of tax liability was carried out by the team leader only after
issuance of a show-cause notice, following which the complainant
allegedly lodged a false complaint and arranged the trap. The
applicant was working under the Directorate General Analytics
and Risk Management (DGARM), an apex analytical body under
the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs, whereas the coaccused Subrato Pal belonged to the Preventive/Anti-Evasion
wing, and therefore implicating the applicant in the present crime
is unjustified. The applicant has been in judicial custody since
01.02.2025, the prosecution has cited about 65 witnesses, and
the trial is likely to take considerable time; he has cooperated with
the investigation throughout and never attempted to abscond.
Though sanction for prosecution has been obtained against the
applicant after filing of the charge sheet, sanctions against other
co-accused named in the supplementary charge sheet are still
awaited,
reflecting
inconsistency
in
the
prosecution.
The
presumption of innocence operates in favour of the applicant until
proven guilty, and even on the basis of the prosecution case,
there was no justification for his arrest; rather, he has been made
a scapegoat. The applicant’s aged mother, about 70 years old, is
suffering from serious ailments and is dependent on him, and his
prolonged incarceration has caused severe hardship to his family,
including his wife and two children. The rejection of bail of coaccused Mishra @ Anil Kumar Gupta does not apply to the
applicant due to differences in role, conduct and period of custody,
and similarly, though the applicant’s earlier bail and SLP were
rejected, he has now undergone more than one year of
incarceration while other co-accused, including Vinay Rai and
several GST officers, have been granted bail subsequently on the
principle of parity. The applicant is a permanent resident, there is
no likelihood of absconding, and he is ready to furnish adequate
surety and abide by all conditions imposed by this Hon’ble Court;
therefore, in view of the changed circumstances, long custody,
lack of evidence, and parity with co-accused, the applicant
deserves to be released on bail.
5.
Mr. Vaibhav A. Goverdhan, learned Standing Counsel appearing
for the respondent/Union of India, opposes the submissions
advanced on behalf of the applicant and contends that Crime No.
RC1242025A0002 was registered on 31.01.2025; he further
submits that, whereas the first bail application had already been
considered and dismissed on merits by the High Court, it is
pertinent to note that the applicant thereafter approached the
Supreme Court by filing Special Leave Petition (SLP) No. 10762
of 2025, which was also dismissed vide order dated 04.08.2025.
The record indicates that the applicant, Bharat Singh, actively
participated in the commission of the alleged offence and played a
significant and instrumental role in its execution, thereby
demonstrating his direct involvement and responsibility in the
matter. In this context, it is further relevant to refer to the bail
granted by the Apex Court to the co-accused, Vinay Rai, in SLP
No. 20004 of 2025 vide order dated 11.01.2026. The Supreme
Court, while granting bail to the co-accused, specifically observed
that the present applicant’s bail had already been rejected by the
High Court, and that the facts and circumstances concerning the
role and status of the co-accused differed significantly from those
of the present applicant, it is further submitted that the case was
registered on the basis of a written complaint dated 30.01.2025
submitted by Lal Chand Athwani, proprietor of M/s The World of
Beauty, alleging that on 28–29.01.2025 the applicant Bharat
Singh, Superintendent, CGST, Raipur, conducted a raid at his
shop and, in conspiracy with Vinay Rai and Mishra, demanded a
bribe of ₹34,00,000/-, which was later reduced to ₹10,00,000/-,
and when the complainant refused to pay, he approached the
Central Bureau of Investigation on 30.01.2025; upon verification
of the complaint in the presence of an independent witness, an
FIR under Section 61(2) of the BNS, 2023 read with Sections 7
and 7A of the Prevention of Corruption Act was registered on
31.01.2025 and a trap was laid the same day at VIP Chowk,
Raipur, where Vinay Rai was allegedly caught red-handed while
accepting ₹5,00,000/- as bribe, and during the trap one person
arrived on a scooter, snatched his mobile phone and fled; the
tainted money was recovered from Vinay Rai in the presence of
independent witnesses and the present applicant Bharat Singh
was thereafter arrested from his office and is presently in judicial
custody; it is further contended that after completion of
investigation, a charge-sheet has been filed in Special Case No.
04/25 against the accused persons while further investigation has
been kept open under Section 193(9) of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, and that sanction for prosecution against
the applicant, the then Superintendent, CGST, Raipur, was duly
granted by the competent authority on 11.04.2025 by the office of
the Principal Commissioner, Central Tax (CGST & Central
Excise), thereby justifying the action taken against the applicant.
6.
It has been argued by Mr. Goverdhan that on 28.01.2025, a
search was conducted by the CGST Raipur team of 08 members
consisting of Shri Subrato Pal, Supdt. Shri Bharat Singh, Shri
Yogesh Moria, Inspector Shri Suraj Rawat, Inspector Shri Arvind
Kumar Sisodiya, Inspector Shri Nandini Rajput, Inspector Ms. Kirti
Gajbhiye, TA, Shri Shivangi Singh, Hawaldar and led by Shri
Subrato Pal, Superintendent at the official premises i.e. M/s The
World of Beauty, of the complainant on the strength authorization
for search issued by Shri Prabhat Dandotiyaa, Additional
Commissioner vide No.GEXCOM/AE/INV/GST/353/2025-AE-0/0
Principal Commissioner dated 28.01.2025 in presence of
independent witness Shri Diggi Bhoi @ Durgesh Kumar Bhoi and
Shri Bhagwat Sahu. The CGST team seized the two bill books
vide order of seizure dated 28.01.2025 and drew the Panchnama
Mated 28.01.2025 for the search proceedings conducted by them.
hereafter, on 29.01.2025 when the complainant along with his
brother returned from Prayagraj to his aforesaid shop, accused
Bharat Singh, Superintendent who was one of the members of
search team told the complainant that he should meet his
seniorShri Mishra for settling of his tax matter. The complainant
along with his brother visited in the car of CGST to Starbucks
situated at Currency Tower, near VIP chowk, Raipur and met one
person who was introduced by Vinay Rai as Mishra Ji,
Commissioner of CGST, Raipur. During discussion, such person
namely Mishra Ji informed him about his tax liability towards GST
and further informed that the liability of tax would by settled in Rs,
11,00,000/-, he has to pay Rs.34,00,000/-. It has been further
argued that on 28.01.2025, the accused Bharat Singh had
removed the hard disk from the Digital Voice Recorder containing
recording of the CCTV installed of the official premises of 'The
World of Beauty' in presence of Mohit Athwani kept the same in
the bag carried by him. He handed over the aforesaid hard disk of
the CCTV footage installed at the search spot to Durgesh Kumar
Bhoi @ Diggi Bhoi while the search team of CGST left the
aforesaid search spot with instructions to keep the same in the
hall at preventive branch of CGST office. The said hard disk was
kept by him in the said hall on 29.01.2025. During the
examination, Mr. Pal has stated that he was not aware whether
any hard disk containing recordings of the CCTV installed in the
official premise of 'The World of Beauty' was removed and taken
by Bharat Singh. He had not instructed any of the search team
members of the CGST to take the said hard disk.
7.
It has been submitted by Mr. Goverdhan that one Vivek
Dewangan was deputed for the cleaning work in the office Central
Tax (CGST) from April 2024 to May 2024, he was deputed by M/s.
Special Management Service and his name was not in the pay-roll
of CGST Department Raipur. He was exclusively engaged by one
Saurav Singhal and accused Bharat Singh on private basis and
they used to provide him cash for the work done by him on
monthly basis. Shri Dewangan had worked related to Data Entry
with respect to DGARM cell in the computer assigned by the
Superintendents including accused Bharat Singh and Saurav
Singhal, who are the Superintendents. During post trap
proceedings, Vinay has informed that the person who ran away
with his phone is named as Vivek and he worked as private
worker in CGST office and sometimes drives office vehicles. It has
been further submitted that the CCTV footage dated 29.01.2025
of Starbucks was seized by the CBI and the accused Mishra was
identified by Ms. Pragya Mishra an ex-employee of ARPEE Group
as a person "Anil Kumar Gupta vide CCTV identification memo
dated 19.03.2025 in presence of independent witness Shri
Akhilesh Roshan Gajbhiye. Ms. Pragya Mishra also identified the
voice of accused Shri Mishra as a person Shri Anil Kumar Gupta
vide voice identification memo dated 19.03.2025 from the IO copy
of the conversations recorded by the CBI during verification and
trap proceedings in presence of aforesaid independent witness.
The accused Vinay Rai was identified by Shri Laxman Kumar
Biswal vide identification memo dated 11.03.2025 in presence of
independent witness Shri RoshanKumar Sahu as also from the
voice identification from the 10 copy of the conversations
recorded by the CBI during verification and trap proceedings. It is
further submitted that the accused Mishra was identified by Shri
Anurag Gupta as well as Shri Kamlesh Kumar Sahu as the voice
of person Shri Anil Kumar Gupta vide CCTV identification memo
dated 08.03.2025. Similarly, the complainant and his brother Shri
Naveen Kumar Athwani identified the accused Shri Mishra as well
as accused Shri Vinay from the IO copy of the CCTV footage
dated 29.01.2025.
8.
Mr.
Vaibhav
A.
Goverdhan,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent/Union of India, submits that the investigation has
revealed that a WhatsApp call was made on 30.01.2025 by the
complainant from Mobile No. 9827181835, belonging to his
brother Naveen Kumar Athwani, to Mobile No. 8305001283 of coaccused Mishra, and screenshots of the WhatsApp call log were
voluntarily produced by Naveen Kumar Athwani in the presence of
independent witnesses vide mobile operation and data retrieval
memo
dated
08.03.2025;
these
facts,
according
to
the
prosecution, disclose that the present applicant Bharat Singh,
then Superintendent (DGARM Cell), entered into a criminal
conspiracy with co-accused Vinay Rai and Mishra, identified as
Anil Kumar Gupta, and thereby committed offences punishable
under Section 61(2) of the BNS, 2023 read with Sections 7 and
7A of the Prevention of Corruption Act (as amended in 2018) and
Sections 319(2) and 204 of the BNS, 2023; it is lastly argued that
considering the gravity of the offence, the strength of the
prosecution
case,
and
the
potential
impact
on
ongoing
proceedings and further investigation, the present applicant is not
entitled to be released on bail and the instant bail application
deserves to be rejected as being devoid of merits.
9.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perused the case diary.
10.
Considering the matter in its entirety as well as taking into
consideration the facts and circumstances of the case, nature and
gravity of the offence and further considering the fact that Crime
No. RC1242025A0002 has been registered on 31.01.2024 on the
basis of the written complaint dated 30.01.2025 of Shri Lal Chand
Athwani, who owns M/s The World of Beauty and on 2829.01.2025, Shri Bharat Singh, Superintendent, CGST, Raipur.
raided the shop of Shri Lal Chand Athwani and, in conspiracy with
Shri Vinay and Shri Mishra, demanded Rs.34,00,000/- as bribe,
which was later reduced to Rs. 10,00,000/- and the complainant
unwilling to pay, had filed a complaint with CBI on 30.01.2025 as
well as on the basis of verification of the complaint dated
30.01.2025, an FIR under Section 61(2) of BNS, 2023 as well as
Sections 7, 7A of the P.C. Act was registered on 31.01.2025. It
transpires from the record that after investigation of the case,
charge-sheet has been filed vide Special Case No.04/25 against
the accused persons and the sanction order for prosecution
against accused Bharat Singh, the then Superintendent, CGST,
Raipur, was issued by the competent authority on 11.04.2025 to
remove the accused from office as well as a search was
conducted by the CGST Raipur team of 08 members and the
CGST team seized the two bill books vide order of seizure dated
28.01.2025 and drawn the Panchnama dated 28.01 2025 for the
search proceedings. It also transpires that the accused Bharat
Singh had removed the hard disk from the Digital Voice Recorder
and the CCTV footage dated 29.01.2025 of Starbucks was seized
by the CBI and the accused Mishra was identified by Ms. Pragya
Mishra an ex-employee of ARPEE Group as a person "Anil Kumar
Gupta vide CCTV identification memo dated 19.03.2025 as well
as by Shri Akhilesh Roshan Gajbhiye. The accused Vinay Rai was
identified by Shri Laxman Kumar Biswal vide identification memo
dated 11.03.2025 and accused Mishra was identified by Shri
Anurag Gupta as well as Shri Kamlesh Kumar Sahu. It has been
also reflected that applicant/accused Vinay Rai was caught redhanded while he was receiving bribe amount of Rs.5,00,000/from the complainant.
11.
Taking into account the overall facts and circumstances of the
case, and considering that this is the second bail application filed
by the applicant whereas the first bail application had already
been considered and dismissed on merits by the High Court, it is
pertinent to note that the applicant thereafter approached the
Supreme Court by filing Special Leave Petition (SLP) No. 10762
of 2025, which was also dismissed vide order dated 04.08.2025.
The record indicates that the applicant, Bharat Singh, actively
participated in the commission of the alleged offence and played a
significant and instrumental role in its execution, thereby
demonstrating his direct involvement and responsibility in the
matter. In this context, it is further relevant to refer to the bail
granted by the Apex Court to the co-accused, Vinay Rai, in SLP
No. 20004 of 2025 vide order dated 11.01.2026. The Supreme
Court, while granting bail to the co-accused, specifically observed
that the present applicant’s bail had already been rejected by the
High Court, and that the facts and circumstances concerning the
role and status of the co-accused differed significantly from those
of the present applicant. The distinction in the nature of
participation, involvement, and role in the offence was expressly
noted, thereby justifying a different approach in the consideration
of bail for the co-accused as opposed to the present applicant. In
view of the above considerations, the Court finds that no sufficient
or compelling grounds exist to justify the grant of bail to the
present applicant. Consequently, having regard to the applicant’s
active involvement in the offence, the prior dismissal of his earlier
bail applications, and the distinction in facts regarding the coaccused, the present second bail application is liable to be, and is
hereby, rejected.
12.
Accordingly, the second bail application of the applicant – Bharat
Singh, filed under Section 483 of the BNSS, involved in Crime
No. RC1242025A0002 registered at Police Station – A.C.B./C.B.I.
Raipur (C.G.), for the offence punishable under Sections 61(2) of
BNS and Section 7 and 7A of the Prevention of Corruption Act
1988, is rejected.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
vaibhav
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review