Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14328/2025
Bhanwar Singh Son Of Shri Bhagwan Singh, Aged About 60
Years, Resident Of Vpo-Hasanpura, Tehsil Shrimadhopur, District
Sikar (Raj).
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through Additional Chief Secretary,
Panchayati Raj Department, Govt. Secretariat, Govt. Of
Rajasthan, Jaipur (Raj).
2.
The Director Swachh Bharat Mission (Rural), Panchayati
Raj Department, Directorate, Jaipur.
3.
The District Collector Cum Chairman Of District, Swachh
Bharat Mission (Rural), Sikar.
4.
The Chief Executive Officer Cum Member Secretary,
District Swachh Bharat Mission, Zila Parishad Sikar.
5.
The Development Officer, Panchayat Samiti Patan, District
Sikar.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. G. S. Gauttam, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Prateek Saxena, Adv.,
Mr. Pranay Sharma, Adv.,
Mr. Anirudh Sharma, Adv.,
Ms. Anjali Ranga, Adv. &
Mr. Tarun Dhankar, Adv. for
Mr. Kapil Prakash Mathur, AAG
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND SHARMA
Judgment
05/03/2026
1.
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner with
following prayer:“It is therefore, most humbly prayed that your
Lordship may graciously be pleased to accept and
allow this writ petition and call for and examine
(2 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
[CW-14328/2025]
entire record of the case and by an appropriate
writ, order and direction
i) That the respondent may kindly be declare illegal
and discriminatory action of the respondents by
which respondents are going to retire the petitioner
on 30.09.2025 on attaining the age of 60 years
while the retired persons allowed to work till
attaining the age of 65 years by re-engaging on
contract basis;
ii) Further the Hon’ble Court may kindly be directed
to the respondents to allow the petitioner on the
post of Block Coordinator at Panchayat Samiti
Patan, District Sikar till attaining the age of 65
years;
iii) Any other order which this Hon’ble Court
deemed just and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case may also be passed in
favour of the petitioner.”
2.
Grievance of the petitioner is that although, while
appointing the petitioner to the post of Block Coordinator under
the Swachh Bharat Mission (Rural) in Panchayati Raj Department
in accordance with the Rajasthan Contractual Hiring to Civil Post
Rules, 2022 (for short ‘the Rules of 2022’), there was a clear
stipulation in the appointment order dated 28.06.2023 that the
petitioner shall be allowed to continue till 31.03.2028, yet
petitioner’s
services
have
been
terminated
immediately
on
completion of age of 60 years ignoring the circular dated
28.03.2023, which lays down that only such employees shall be
considered for re-appointment, who have not completed the age
of 65 years. Learned counsel submits that thus, the intention of
respondent-Government was clear that they would allow all the
contractual employees to continue, post retirement upto the age
of 65 years. Learned counsel for the petitioner also relies upon the
order dated 03.11.2025 passed by the Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.16199/2025 (Geeta Devi Salvi
(3 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
[CW-14328/2025]
Vs. The State of Rajasthan & Ors.) and submits that the Coordinate Bench while passing the order dated 03.11.2025 has
taken into consideration provisions of Rule 11 of the Rules of 2022
as well as the earlier circulars providing for continuation of
contractual employee upto the age of 65 years.
3.
Per
contra,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents submits that Rule 11 (1) of Rules of 2022 is quite
clear and provides the condition that the contractual appointment
shall not be extended beyond the date on which the contractual
appointee attains the age of 60 years. Learned counsel for the
respondents further submits that it is settled proposition of law
that if the Rule is explicitly clear then any circular providing
contrary to such Rule should be ignored, as the Rule would prevail
over any administrative instructions/circular. Learned counsel for
the respondents places reliance upon order dated 04.12.2025
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in D.B. Special Appeal
(Writ) No.1328/2025 (Bhanwar Singh Vs. State of Rajasthan
& Ors.), whereby while dismissing the D.B. Special Appeal, the
Division Bench has also given an observation that Rule would
prevail over any order or circular issued by the State Government
and as per Rule 11 of the Rules of 2022, tenure of contractual
appointment cannot be extended beyond the date on which the
contractual appointee attains the age of 60 years.
4.
Learned counsel for the respondents also refers order
dated 29.08.2025 passed by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in the case of Shyamu Vs. State of Rajasthan & Ors. (S.B. Civil
Writ Petition No.12428/2025), where the Co-ordinate Bench has
also held that the Rule would prevail and the contractual employee
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
(4 of 9)
[CW-14328/2025]
has got no right to continue after 60 years. Learned counsel for
the respondents also clarifies that the appointment order is
required to be read in entirety and indicates the condition that the
employee shall continue till 31.03.2028/till date of retirement,
whichever is earlier and since in the case of the petitioner, his date
of retirement was much earlier than 31.03.2028, therefore,
respondents have committed no mistake in discontinuing the
services of the petitioner immediately on attaining the age of
superannuation.
Accordingly, the order dated 29.09.2025 has
been passed for relieving the petitioner on attaining the age of
superannuation w.e.f. 30.09.2025. The order dated 29.09.2025
has also been placed on record by learned counsel for the
respondents.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
6.
It is an admitted case of the petitioner that his
contractual engagement is regulated by the Rajasthan Contractual
Hiring to Civil Post Rules, 2022. Rule 11 of the aforesaid Rules
deals with period of contractual appointment and reads as under:11. Period of contractual appointment.- (1) On
the posts created under these rules, first
contractual appointment shall be made for a period
not exceeding five years or up to the expiry of the
period of scheme/project whichever is earlier,
however, if the period of scheme/project is further
extended, the State Government may take decision
for renewal of contractual appointment by
extending the period of contractual appointment for
3 years at a time depending on the necessity of the
contractual
employees
and
after
assessing
suitability of person appointed on contract, The
contractual appointment shall not be extended
beyond the date on which contractual appointee
attains the age of 60 years.
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
(5 of 9)
[CW-14328/2025]
(2) Work assessment of the person hired on
contract shall be recorded so that his work may be
assessed in case he is to be considered for
appointment on contract for the next year.
(3) Contract appointment shall stand terminated
automatically on expiry of the period of the
contract and there shall be no need to issue
separate order for terminating the service.
7.
Bare reading of aforesaid Rule 11 would make it clear
that in no uncertain terms it has been mandated that the
contractual appointment shall not be extended beyond the date on
which contractual appointee attains the age of 60 years. Learned
counsel for the petitioner has relied upon circular issued by the
State Government. It is settled proposition of law that any
circular/administrative instructions cannot supplant the Rules,
however, can supplement the Rules only under the contingency,
where there is no specific rule governing the field. In the instant
case, where there is specific rule which has been framed in
unambiguous terms providing for not continuing contractual
appointment beyond the date on which contractual appointee
attains the age of 60 years, any circular or administrative
instructions to the contrary cannot prevail. Similar view has been
taken by Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Shyamu (supra),
relevant para of the aforesaid order in the case of Shyamu
(supra) is being reproduced as under:“Indisputably, the petitioner has been appointed
under the Rules of 2022, the relevant provision of
Rule 11A whereof, reads as under:
11.
Period
of
contractual
appointment.-(1) On the posts created
under these
rules, first contractual
appointment shall be made fora period not
exceeding five years or up to the expiry of
the period of scheme/project whichever is
earlier,
however,
if
the
period
of
(6 of 9)
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
[CW-14328/2025]
scheme/project is further extended, the
State Government may take decision for
renewal of contractual appointment by
extending the period of contractual
appointment for 3 years at a time
depending on the necessity of the
contractual employees and after assessing
suitability of person appointed on contract.
The contractual appointment shall not
be extended beyond the date on which
contractual appointee attains the age
of60 years.”
Thus, from the aforesaid provision, it is clear
that in no case, the contractual appointment shall
be extended beyond the date on which the
contractual employee attains the age of 60 years.
Indisputably, the petitioner shall attain the age of
60 years, i.e., age of superannuation, on
10.09.2025. In view thereof, this Court finds no
illegality in the decision taken by the respondents
in retiring the petitioner on the date he attains the
age of 60 years. Contention of the learned counsel
for the petitioner based on the terms of the
appointment order dated 15.05.2023 does not
merit acceptance inasmuch as the period of the
contractual employment mentioned therein, i.e.,
25.05.2028 appears to be an inadvertent error on
account of the provisions contained under Rule
11(1) which provide that the first contractual
appointment shall be made for a period not
exceeding five years or up to the expiry of the
period of scheme/project whichever is earlier,
oblivious of the fact that he would attain the age of
superannuation much prior to the expiry of the
period of five years from the date of appointment.
The holistic and harmonious reading and
interpretation of the provisions of Rule 11 gives
rise to an unquestionable position that in no case,
the contractual appointment of an appointee under
the Rules of 2022 can be extended beyond the age
of 60 years. Even otherwise, the principle of
‘promissory estoppel’ does not operate against
statute.”
8.
The Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Bhanwar Singh (supra) was considering the intra-court appeal
preferred
by
the
petitioner
against
ad-interim
order
dated
25.09.2025 passed by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
(7 of 9)
[CW-14328/2025]
present writ petition and while dismissing the appeal following
observations have been made by the Division Bench:“7.This appeal filed on behalf of the appellant
deserves to be dismissed for the reasons:(i)Admittedly, the appellant was given fresh
appointment under the Rules of 2022 vide order
dated 28.06.2023. According to Rule11 of the Rules
of 2022, the contractual appointment shall not be
extended beyond the date on which contractual
appointee attains the age of 60 years.
(ii)The contractual Rules of 2022 have been framed
by the State Government under the proviso to
Article 309 of the Constitution of India.
8.In our considered view, the Rules of 2022 will
prevail over any other order or circular issued by
the State Government.”
9.
It would be relevant to refer that in the case of Hyder
Consulting (UK) Ltd. Vs. Governor, State of Orissa: (2015)
2 SCC 189, the Hon’ble Supreme Court while meticulously
explaining the principle of ‘per incuriam’ has held as under:“46. Before I consider the correctness of the
aforementioned decisions, it would be necessary to
elaborate upon the concept of “per incuriam”. The
Latin expression “per incuriam” literally means
“through inadvertence”. A decision can be said to be
given per incuriam when the court of record has
acted in ignorance of any previous decision of its
own, or a subordinate court has acted in ignorance
of a decision of the court of record. As regards the
judgments of this Court rendered per incuriam, it
cannot be said that this Court has “declared the
law” on a given subject-matter, if the relevant law
was not duly considered by this Court in its decision.
In this regard, I refer to State of U.P. v. Synthetics
and Chemicals Ltd. [(1991) 4 SCC 139], wherein
R.M. Sahai, J. in his concurring opinion stated as
follows : (SCC p. 162, para 40)
“40. ‘Incuria’ literally means ‘carelessness’.
In practice per incuriam appears to mean
per
ignoratium.
English
courts
have
developed this principle in relaxation of the
rule of stare decisis. The ‘quotable in law’ is
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
(8 of 9)
[CW-14328/2025]
avoided and ignored if it is rendered, ‘in
ignoratium of a statute or other binding
authority’.”
10.
In Geeta Devi Salvi (supra), it appears that the Co-
ordinate Bench of this Court was not apprised of the earlier order
dated 29.08.2025 passed by another Co-ordinate Bench in the
case of Shyamu (supra) and therefore, the Co-ordinate Bench
while deciding the case of Geeta Devi Salvi (supra) had no
occasion to consider the aforesaid order in the case of Shyamu
(supra). Thus, it can be observed that since the order dated
03.11.2025 has been passed by the Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in the case of Geeta Devi Salvi (supra) in bona fide
ignorance of earlier order passed by a Single Judge in the case of
Shyamu (supra), therefore, the order in the case of Geeta Devi
Salvi (supra) is per incuriam and shall not prevail over the order
in the case of Shyamu (supra). Moreso, when Division Bench of
this Court while deciding the appeal filed by the petitioner himself
has given clear cut finding that rule shall prevail over any
circular/administrative instructions and since the rule provides for
continuance of contractual employee only upto the age of 60
years, therefore, no mistake whatsoever has been committed by
the respondent-Government in relieving the petitioner on attaining
the age of superannuation i.e. the age of 60 years. Even the
appointment order of the petitioner was conditional in nature and
specifically provides that the appointment shall continue till
31.03.2028/till the age of retirement, whichever is earlier and
since in the instant case date of retirement of the petitioner was
earlier in nature, at this stage, the petitioner cannot raise any plea
contrary to his own appointment order.
[2026:RJ-JP:9446]
11.
(9 of 9)
[CW-14328/2025]
In view of above, there is no substance in the writ
petition filed by the petitioner and same is hereby dismissed.
12.
Pending application(s), if any, stand(s) dismissed.
(ANAND SHARMA),J
Jatin /24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review