Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27290
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 32429 OF 2016
PETITIONER:
BENNY MARKOSE
AGED 55 YEARS
S/O V.M.MARKOSE, VANDANATHIL HOSUE,
KOLENCHERRY, ERNAKULAM.
BY ADV SRI.M.C.JOHN
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY, WATER RESOURCES DEPARTMENT,
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,PIN:695001.
THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
PROJECT CIRCLE PIRAVOM, KOLLICKAL,
PIN:686 664, ERNAKULAM.
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
IDAMALAYAR IRRIGATION PROJECT (11P),
DIVISION NO.1, ANGAMALI, ERNAKULAM-683572.
THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL,
KERALA, BRANCH-THRISSUR, PIN:680 001.
BY ADV GOVERNMENT PLEADER
OTHER PRESENT:
SMT.RASHMI.K.M,SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
24.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
P.M. MANOJ, J
-----------------------------W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
-------------------------------------------------Dated this the 24th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The writ petition is preferred challenging Ext.P15 demand of
fine raised on the basis of audit objection.
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that he has been awarded
with the work of Idamalayar Irrigation Project – LL.C improvements
to the inspection road and providing drainage facilities between
Ch.2700m to 3663m.
The probable amount of contract was
Rs.24,70,612/-. As per the selection notice the work had to be
completed within six months from the date of handing over the
site. The agreement was executed between the petitioner and the
2nd respondent.
3.
However, it is contended by the petitioner that the site
was handed over only on 31.05.2011, just one day before the
onset of monsoon.
30.11.2011.
The time for completion of the work was
The initial level proposed for filling was sanctioned
only on 28.10.2011 ie., almost one month prior to the date of
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
completion of the work as per the agreement.
The monsoon
started from 01.06.2011 and the work was delayed, and the
petitioner was constrained to ask for extension since only one
month
time
was
left
for
completion
from
the
date
of
acknowledgment of handing over the site. Therefore, the petitioner
has preferred Ext.P5 application for an extension, wherein the
petitioner has assigned specific reasons for the delay occurred
from his part. On considering the same, the Superintending
Engineer
who
signed
the
agreement,
after
evaluating
the
circumstances, granted an extension as per Ext.P7 for a further
period of four months from 30.11.2011 to 31.03.2012, without
imposing any penalty.
4.
Even thereafter, the petitioner could not complete the
work, the assigned reason is that the part bill was not paid to him.
Accordingly, he has preferred Ext.P8 representation for further
extension. Even that was also considered by the 2 nd respondent
and after evaluating the circumstances he was pleased to extend
the period up to 30.06.2012. Thereafter, a completion certificate
was issued as per the certificate dated 16.11.2012, following an
inspection conducted on 14.11.2012, by the 1st respondent to his
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
complete satisfaction. Therefore, Ext.P11 was issued whereby it is
intimated that certain audit objections were raised by the
Accountant General on the ground that an extension was granted
due to delay in the payment of a part bill.
In that respect the
petitioner has produced Ext.P12 Government Order, wherein it is
specifically stated that if the part bills remain unpaid for a period
ranging from 2 to 3 years and the contractors have a problem in
proceeding the work, then the exemption can be granted from
payment of fine to those contractors for whom time of completion
of work is extended on account of delays in payment of part bills.
5.
On receipt of the same, the petitioner has preferred his
explanation by filing Ext.P13 reply wherein he has categorically
stated the reasons for the delay and noted that he had been
granted with extension of time without fine by the 2 nd respondent.
This issue was communicated to the Accountant General as per
Ext.P14. Thereafter, by Ext.P15, another Superintending Engineer
has declined the same and directed the petitioner to pay an
amount of Rs.50,600/- towards fine for the delay in completing the
work.
Therefore,
the
petitioner
challenging Ext.P15 order.
preferred
this
writ
petition
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
6.
The 2nd respondent has preferred a counter affidavit,
wherein it is specifically contended that the petitioner himself has
executed an indemnity bond while releasing the security deposit
and he has indemnified that as per Ext.R2(a). In consideration of
the payment of sum of Rs.1,00,000/- to the petitioner, which is the
security deposit, he had agreed that he will at all times indemnify
and keep indemnified the Government from the fine for extending
the time of completion, if any, made or which may be made, and
all actions and proceedings taken against the Government by any
person whomsover in respect of the payment of the said amount to
the petitioner.
7.
The 4th respondent Accountant General also preferred a
counter affidavit, wherein it is stated that Superintending Engineer
vide order dated 25.02.2012 sanctioned extension of time of
completion up to 30.06.2012, without penalty on the ground that
eligible part bill was pending. Upon reviewing the details, it was
found
that
the
said
letter
had
been
sought
from
the
2nd respondent, and vide letter No.A3-636/2010 dated 26.08.2013,
the Executive Engineer, Idamalayar Irrigation Project Division, No.I,
Angamaly, submitted that the first part bill of the above work was
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
received in that office on 27.03.2012 only. Therefore, the extension
of time of completion without fine was not acceptable as the bill
was submitted only a few days before the due date of completion
and the same was communicated to Superintending Engineer. The
Department quoted G.O.(P) No.83/2000/PWD dated 18.12.2000,
that is Ext.P12. That benefit was given in cases where the part bill
was delayed for more than two to three years.
8.
In response to that the petitioner has preferred a reply
affidavit stating that the petitioner has earnestly completed the
work within the stipulated period.
The delay was occurred only
due to the reason stated in Exts.P7 and P9. It is further contended
that the bills are not prepared by the contractor but by the
Assistant Engineer with due certification. Any delay in submitting
the part bill, if at all, is not attributable to the petitioner. Merely
executing an indemnity bond for the limited purpose of releasing
the security deposit does not justify imposing the entire liability on
him.
9.
I have heard Sri.M.C. John, the learned counsel for the
petitioner and Smt.Rashmi K.M., the learned Senior Government
Pleader for the respondents.
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
10.
I have considered the arguments across the Bar. It is an
admitted fact that the petitioner had agreed to complete the work
of Idamalayar Irrigation Project – LL.C improvements to the
inspection
road
and
Ch.2700m to 3663m.
providing
drainage
facilities
between
The initial date of completion of the work
was six months from 31.05.2011 to 30.11.2011. However, the
initial level proposed for filling was sanctioned only on 28.10.2011.
Monsoon started from 01.06.2011 and the work was delayed. As a
result, the petitioner was constrained to request for an extension,
as there was only one month remaining for completion of the work.
Sanction was granted for filling the initial level.
Accordingly, he
submitted a proper application as per Ext.P5. Upon considering the
same, as per Ext.P7, the Superintending Engineer granted an
extension of four months, from 30.11.2011 to 31.03.2012.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted Ext.P8, citing the noncompletion of the work within the stipulated time due to a shortage
of funds caused by the non-payment of the part bill he had
submitted.
11.
Upon
reviewing
the
facts
of
the
case,
the
Superintending Engineer once again granted an extension without
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
imposing fine.
This was in compliance of Ext.P12 Government
Order which is referred as item No.5 in the reference of Ext.P9
order, and the petitioner had completed the work in the extended
period which was acknowledged by issuing Ext.P10 completion
certificate, wherein the 2nd respondent has recorded his complete
satisfaction.
Thereafter, the same Superintending Engineer
intimated the petitioner regarding the audit objection raised by the
4th respondent Accountant General. This was replied by the
petitioner as per Ext.P13. On considering the said reply, the
Superintending
Engineer
recommended
the
matter
to
the
Accountant General, however, that was rejected. On the basis of
such rejection, Ext.P15 demand was raised for an amount of
Rs.50,600/- towards fine for extending the period of work up to
30.06.2012.
12.
Upon considering the issue involved in this case, I
gathered that Exts.P7 and P9 orders were issued for extension of
time. The Superintending Engineer is the competent authority at
the first instance to examine the factual aspects of the contractual
agreement.
He made a conscious decision on two occasions, in
compliance with Ext.P12 Government Order whereby he explicitly
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
decided to exclude the fine while extending the period, and he has
also recorded his satisfaction with the completion of the work.
Nevertheless, merely based on an audit objection which was raised
on the grounds that Ext.P12 was issued on the premise that the
part payment bill had been pending for more than two years, fine
cannot be imposed. In that case, the delay occurred in completing
the work can be exempted from effecting payment of fine. But to
that aspect, the petitioner submitted his explanation, stating that
the part bill was allegedly submitted two or three days prior to
27.03.2012 ie., during the first extension period. He further
explained that the preparation of the part payment bill was the
responsibility of the Assistant Engineer and not the contractor.
13.
Therefore, the responsibility of delay in submitting the
part bill cannot be mulcted on the petitioner, being the contractor.
On considering this, I deem it appropriate to hold that the
petitioner cannot be mulcted with the liability of paying the fine
because the Superintending Engineer had taken a conscious
decision after considering all these aspects, including Ext.P12.
Having been satisfied that there was sufficient reason not to
impose the fine, the petitioner cannot be made liable to pay it only
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
because of the audit objection. Under such circumstances, Ext.P15
is set aside. However, if it is found that the amount is still due to
the Government, appropriate action may be taken against the
person who sanctioned the extension without imposing fine.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed.
sss
Sd/P.M.MANOJ
JUDGE
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 32429/2016
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1:
A TRUE COPY OF THE SELECTION NOTICES
DATED 7.4.2011 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P2:
A TRUE COPY OF THE AGREEMENT DATED
23.5.2011
EXHIBIT P3:
A TRUE COPY OF THE ACKNOWLEDGMENT FOR
HANDING OVER THE SITE DATED 31.5.2011.
EXHIBIT P4:
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
28.10.2011 FROM 2ND RESPONDENT TO 3RD
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P5:
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED
30.11.2011.
EXHIBIT P6:
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 1.12.2011
FROM THE 3RD RESPONDENT TO THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P7:
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 13.1.2012
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P8:
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED
31.3.2012.
EXHIBIT P9:
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 25.5.2012
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT EXTENDING
THE TIME OF COMPLETION UPTO 30.6.2012
WITHOUT PENALTY.
EXHIBIT P10:
A TURE COPY OF THE COMPLETION CERTIFICATE
DDATED 16.11.2012 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
W.P.(C) No.32429 of 2016
2025:KER:27290
EXHIBIT P11:
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
29.11.2014 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P12:
A TRUE COPY OF THE G.O(P) NO.83/2000/PWD
DATED 18.12.2000 ISSUED BY THE IST
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P13:
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 27.1.2015
ISSUED TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P14:
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 18.5.2015
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P15:
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.05-2506/16
DATED 5.9.2016 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review