Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supp.List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 15 of 2022
Date of Decision :28.01.2022
Benedic R. Marak
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & 19 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. K.Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. C.Garg, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A.Kumar, AG with
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG
Mr. A.Kharwanlang, GA.
:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This instant application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
has been filed assailing the notice dated 27-01-2022 issued by the Hon’ble
Governor of Meghalaya under Rule 36(5) of the Assam and Meghalaya
Autonomous Districts (Constitution of District Councils) Rules,1951 whereby
the District Council has been summoned to take up a no-confidence motion
against the Executive Committee of the Garo Hills Autonomous District
Council in Tura on 29-01-2022.
2.
Heard learned counsels for the parties.
3.
Mr. K.Paul, learned Sr. Advocate submits that the petitioner who is the
current Chief Executive Member of the Garo Hills Autonomous District
Council (GHADC) has been compelled to approach this Court seeking its
interference in view of the fact that the entire process which culminated in the
impugned notice, is fraught with procedural irregularities which necessarily
need to be corrected in order for any session of the District Council to be
summoned. He submits that by an application dated 25 th January, 2022, fifteen
members of the District Council (MDCs) had sought leave from the Chairman
to move a motion of no-confidence against the Chief Executive Member in
accordance with Rule 71 of the Assam and Meghalaya Autonomous Districts
(Constitution of District Councils) Rules,1951 (hereinafter referred to as the
Rules). He further submits that the said request was then transmitted by the
Chairman to the District Council Affairs Department and thereafter the
Governor in exercise of powers under Rule 36(5) of the Rules called for a
special meeting to be convened on 29th January, 2022.
4.
Mr. K.Paul, learned Sr. counsel submits that as per the scheme of the
Rules at Rule 71, the procedure for calling of a no-confidence motion is laid
out and he submits that a no-confidence motion can be set in motion after
presentation of a written notice of the motion before the commencement of the
sitting of the day, and if the Chairman is of the opinion that the motion is in
order shall proceed accordingly. Learned Sr. counsel then takes this Court to
Rule 36 of the Rules which provides for the summoning of the District Council
and submits that though Rule 36(5) vests vast discretionary power upon the
Governor to summon a meeting of the District Council at any time he deems
fit, this will not mean that the same can be done mechanically without any
subjective satisfaction being arrived at before the decision. He further submits
that the impugned order is categorical in its intent, by specifically indicating
therein, that the house is being specially convened to take up the no-confidence
motion. Mr. K.Paul, learned Sr. counsel submits that there is no inherent power
vested in the Governor, to direct for taking up of a no-confidence motion in the
manner as has been done and further, the bypassing of the provisos of Rule 36,
which provide a procedure for the convening of the house by the Chairman, on
the event of an emergency on short notice, and the necessity of receipt of a
requisition signed by not less than two thirds of the members of the District
Council is highly irregular. Learned Sr. counsel submits that the entire
procedure being highly irregular, the impugned notice is therefore, liable to be
set aside and quashed. Learned Sr. counsel has also relied upon the judgment
rendered in the case of S.R.Bommai vrs. Union of India (1994) 3 SCC 1 in
support of his submissions.
5.
Mr. A.Kumar, learned AG in reply to the submissions of the petitioner
has contended that the present case has been brought before this Court by the
petitioner to defeat a legitimate democratic process which has been initiated by
the members of the District Council themselves. He has drawn the attention of
this Court to the letter dated 25th January, 2022 which is the requisition for
summoning of the House by fifteen members of the Council and submits that a
bare perusal of the letter itself, reflects the necessity of summoning the house,
which is therefore the basis on which the subjective satisfaction has been
arrived at by the Governor. The learned AG also submits that, a plain reading
of Rule 36(5) shows that the Governor is vested with the power, that
notwithstanding anything contained in the Rules he can summon a meeting of
the District Council at any time he deems fit. The session that has been
summoned he submits, is all part and parcel of a fair and transparent process
that has been necessitated by the situation on the ground and a delay in the said
process might have adverse effects. He further submits that the no-confidence
motion which will be a floor test is in the best interest of a democratic institution
and possibly the most effective mechanism to settle the respective claims of the
parties. In support of his arguments, learned AG has relied upon the following
judgments:
(i)
Shiv Sena & Ors. vrs. Union of India & Ors. (2019) 10 SCC 809.
(ii)
Shivraj Singh Chouhan & Ors. vrs. Speaker, Madhya Pradesh
Legislative Assembly & Ors. (2020) SCC Online SC 363.
(iii)
Dharmesh Prabhudas Saglani & Ors. vrs. State of Goa, through
the Chief Secretary & Ors. (2021) SCC Online Bom 565: (2021)
4 Bom CR 176.
He finally submits that there being absolutely no merit in the case of the
petitioner and the same having been filed only to stall a democratic process, the
same deserves no consideration and should be dismissed.
6.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties, as the matter involves
urgency, without calling for affidavits or any further instructions from the
parties, by consent of the counsels, this matter is being finally disposed of today
itself. From the contentions of the petitioner, the main grievance centres around
the alleged non adherence to prescribed procedure as provided by the Rules and
the irregular exercise of power of the Governor under Rule 36(5) in summoning
the house to take up the no-confidence motion. Before embarking on deciding
the questions raised, the relevant provisions of the Rules are quoted
hereinbelow:
“71. Motion of No-Confidence in the Executive
Committee
(1) A motion expressing want of confidence in the
Executive committee or a motion disapproving the policy of
the Executive Committee in regard to any particular matter
may be made with the consent of the Chairman and subject
to the restriction that the member making the motion shall
present to the Secretary a written notice of the motion
before the commencement of the sitting of the day
(2) If the Chairman is of the opinion that the motion is
in order, he shall read the motion to the Council and shall
request those members who are in favour of leave being
granted, to rise in their places and, if not less than one
fourth of the members present rise accordingly, the
Chairman shall intimate that leave is granted and that the
motion will be taken on such day, not being more than two
days and not less than twenty four hours from the time at
which leave is asked for, as he may appoint: Provided that
if exigencies of business required, the Chairman shall have
power to relax the rule and take up the motion earlier than
twenty fourth hours.
(3) If less than one fourth of the members rise, the
Chairman shall inform the member that he has not the leave
of the Council.
36. Summoning of District Council:
(1) Subject to the provisions of sub rule (3), the
Chairman or such other person authorized by the governor
on this behalf shall summon the District Council to meet at
such time and place as he thinks fit. He shall inform the
Deputy Commissioner of the date, hour and place for such
meeting of the Council.
(2) The Chairman shall cause a notice appointing the
date, hour and place for such meeting signed by the
Secretary of the District Council to be served on each
member of the Council at least thirty days before the date
fixed for the meeting.
(3) The District Council shall be summoned to meet
three times in a year, and four months shall not elapse
between its last sitting in one session and the date appointed
for its first sitting in the next session:
Provided that in the event of an emergency the
Chairman of the Council, with previous approval of the
Governor may summon the District Council, oftener and at
shorter notice than what has been provided in sub rule (2);
Provided further that on receipt of a requisition
signed by not less than two thirds of the members of a
District Council, the Chairman shall summon a special
meeting of the Council.
(4) The Chairman or such other person who
summons the District Council under sub rules (1) or (3) may
also prorogue the Council.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in this rule,
nothing shall restrict the power of the Governor to summon
a meeting of the District Council at any time he deems fit.”
7.
A perusal of Rule 71 no doubt has prescribed the manner in which a
motion of no-confidence is to be initiated and it is also noted that the same
applies and is conducted when the house is in session. In the present case, the
situation as it pertains, is that the house is not in session and as such it cannot
be said that the Chairman has abused his powers in calling or requesting for an
emergency session. Rule 71 therefore, cannot be said to have been breached.
The contention of the petitioner therefore, that the Chairman could not have
acted on the notice of no-confidence dated 25-01-2022, since the house was not
in session and the requisition is by less than two thirds of the members of the
District Council is untenable. Coming to the other aspect, that is Rule 36, it is
noted that Rule 36(5) has vested the Governor with vast discretionary power in
summoning a meeting of the District Council. This provision has been resorted
to by way of impugned notice it appears, due to the written notice of the fifteen
MDCs and the request of the Chairman dated 25th January, 2022 (Annexure-2).
Though it has been strongly contended that the powers under 36 (5) of the Rules
cannot be resorted to for the purpose of summoning the house to vote on a noconfidence motion, this point though having a certain amount of relevance in
the interpretation of the Rules, however, in the context of the present case will
not be a deciding factor.
8.
It has to be kept in mind that the District Council as constituted under
the Sixth Schedule is a democratic legislative institution apart from other
functions, wherein members are elected, and to prove majority or strength in
the house in such institutions, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in a number of
decisions has consistently held that in the event of conflicting alliances or
claims, a floor test can be directed to avoid uncertainty and to ensure smooth
running of a democratic institution which would in turn ensure stability. In the
present case, a requisition has been made by fifteen members and the request
has been acceded to by the Governor in exercise of powers under Rule 36(5).
To interrupt this process may result in delaying the floor test which may further
result in other consequences and circumstances. This will therefore be against
the democratic principles enshrined in the Constitution. In this context, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shiv Sena & Ors vrs. Union of India &
Ors. (supra) as placed by learned AG, in para 17 and 20 which is quoted
hereinbelow has held as follows:
“17. Having heard the submissions of the learned counsel
on the issues of maintainability, extent of judicial review
and validity of the Governor’s satisfaction, we are of the
opinion that they can be adjudicated at an appropriate time.
There is no doubt that the contentions have to be answered,
as the petitioners have raised questions concerning
important constitutional issues touching upon the
democratic bulwark of our nation. However, at this interim
stage, we may note that it is imperative for this Court to be
cognizant of the need to take into consideration the
competing claims of the parties, uphold the democratic
values and foster constitutional morality.
20.
In a situation wherein, if the floor test is delayed,
there is a possibility of horse trading, it becomes incumbent
upon the Court to act to protect democratic values. An
immediate floor test, in such a case, might be the most
effective mechanism to do so. A similar view was expounded
by B. P. Jeevan Reddy, J., in the celebrated nine-Judge
Bench decision of this Court in S. R. Bommai v. Union of
India, wherein he held as follows (SCC pp. 277-78, para
395)
“395. The High Court, in our opinion, erred in
holding that the floor test is not obligatory. If only one keeps
in mind the democratic principle underlying the
Constitution and the fact that it is the Legislative Assembly
that represents the will of the people – and not the Governor
– the position would be clear beyond any doubt… There
could be no question of the Governor making an assessment
of his own. The loss of confidence of the House was an
objective fact, which could have been demonstrated, one
way or the other, on the floor of the House. In our opinion,
wherever a doubt arises whether the Council of Ministers
has lost the confidence of the House, the *only* way of
testing it is on the floor of the House except in an
extraordinary situation where because of all-pervasive
violence, the Governor comes to the conclusion – and
records the same in his report – that for the reasons
mentioned by him, a free vote is not possible in the House.”
9.
Similarly, in the case of Shivraj Singh Chouhan & Ors. (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in paras 69 and 70 has also held as follows:
“69. In analysing the observations made by the nine-judge
Bench in SR Bommai, it is pertinent to remember that the
Governor in that case did not call for a floor test. Rather,
the Governor of Karnataka sent a report to the President,
based on which a proclamation was issued under Article
356. The observations in SR Bommai can be relied on in
determining whether the Governor possessed the power to
call for a floor test. Discerning the subsequent of which the
exercise of such power is appropriate is a distinct issue. On
a perusal of the above observations in SR Bommai, it is
evident that:
(i)
Whether or not the Council of Ministers has
lost the confidence of the House must be
determined only on the floor of the house and
not by the Governor conducting an
independent verification;
(ii)
Where the Governor has reasons to believe
that the incumbent government does not
possess the support of the majority in the
legislative assembly, the correct course of
action would be for the Governor to call upon
the Chief Minister to face the assembly and to
establish the majority of the incumbent
government within the shortest possible time;
and
(iii)
An exception to the invariable rule of testing
whether the government has the assembly’s
confidence on the floor of the house is
envisaged only in extraordinary situations
where because of the existence of “all
pervasive violence”, a free vote is not possible
in the House.
70. As a matter of constitutional law, it would not be
correct to proceed on the basis that the constitutional
authority entrusted to the Governor to require the Council
of Ministers to prove their majority on the floor of the
House can only be exercised at the very inception after
general elections are held and not when the Governor has
objective reasons to believe that the incumbent government
does not command the confidence of the house. The
Governor is not denuded of the power to order a floor test
where on the basis of the material available to the Governor
it becomes evident that the issue as to whether the
government commands the confidence of the house requires
to be assessed on the basis of a floor test. Undoubtedly, the
purpose of entrusting such a function to the Governor is not
to destabilise an existing government. When the satisfaction
on the basis of which the Governor has ordered a floor test
is called into question, the decision of the Governor is not
immune from judicial review. The court would be justified
in scrutinizing whether the Governor prima facie had
relevant and germane material to order a floor test to be
conducted. It must be noted that the Governor does not
decide whether the incumbent government commands the
confidence of the house. The purpose of holding a floor test
in the legislative assembly is precisely to enable the elected
representatives to determine whether the Council of
Ministers commands the confidence of the House; that
verification is not conducted by the Governor. The decision
in SR Bommai in fact held that recourse to the power under
Article 356 was not warranted in a situation where the issue
of confidence could yet be tested on the floor of the house
by calling for a trust vote. Undoubtedly, in that case, it was
the Chief Minister who had suggested, following a meeting
of the Cabinet, that the House should be convened for the
purposes of testing the majority of the Council of Ministers.
The significance of the decision lies in the fact that the
decision of the Governor to submit a report under Article
356 was faulted on the ground that the floor test would have
been an appropriate course of action.”
10.
As such, this Court is satisfied that there are no reasons to interfere or
cause any delay in holding the no-confidence motion, inasmuch as, the entire
process notwithstanding any other consideration is part and parcel of a
democratic process which strengthens democratic values.
11.
For the foregoing reasons, the instant application is held to be without
any merit and is accordingly dismissed.
12.
No orders as to cost.
Judge
Meghalaya
28.01.2022
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review