Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:818
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 146 of 2023
Date of Decision :10.09.2025
Dr. Bela Keshan
D/o Late Sitaram Keshan,
R/o GF16/1, Rabindrapally, Jordabagan, Jyangra,
Baguiati, Kolkatta, Desh Bandhu Nagar,
North 24 Paraganas, West Bengal Pin-700059
…. Petitioner(s)
1.
Versus
North Eastern Hill University represented by
The Registrar, NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
2.
The Vice Chancellor, The North Eastern Hill University
represented by the Registrar, NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
3.
The Registrar, The North Eastern Hill University represented by
The Registrar, NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022.
4.
The Union of India, Ministry of Personnel,
Public Grievances and Pensions in the Department of
Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare, Lok Nayak Bhavan,
Khan Market, New-Delhi-110003.
5.
The Union of India, Ministry of Education,
Department of Higher Education, Shastri Bhavan,
New Delhi-110001.
6.
The State of West Bengal, represented by
The Commissioner and Secretary, Higher Education
Department CS Branch, Bikash Bhavan, Salt Lake, Kolkata-700091
7.
City College, 102/1, Raja Rammohan Sarani,
Kolkata-700009
… Respondent(s)
____________________________________________________________
2025:MLHC:818
____________________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Tiwari, Sr. Adv. With
Mr. S.P. Sharma, Adv.
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Sen, SC NEHU with
Ms. E. Blah, Adv. (For R 1-3)
Mr. B. Deb, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. M. Lyngdoh, Adv.
Mr. D. Das, Adv. (For R 6)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Yes/No
1.
The brief facts are that the petitioner had joined City College,
Kolkata on 02.01.1998 as a Lecturer in Zoology, wherein her service was
governed by the West Bengal Non-Government Colleges Teachers (DCRB)
Scheme. She was later promoted as Senior Lecturer and then to Reader, and
while serving in City College, on an application through proper channel with
lien for the post of Reader in Zoology at NEHU, joined the said post on
19.04.2007. After joining NEHU, the petitioner requested that her past
2025:MLHC:818
service under the DCRB Scheme be counted towards the Old Pension
Scheme (OPS) under the DCRB Scheme, but the same was rejected by
NEHU, who insisted that the West Bengal Scheme was not governed by the
CCS (Pension) Rules, and her earlier service was in a Non-Government
College. Hence being aggrieved, she is before this Court by way of this writ
petition.
2.
Mr. P.K. Tiwari, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.P.
Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner
on having entered service in City College had opted for pension (including
family pension) cum gratuity, as per the option allowed by Government
order No. 1097-Edn. (CS) of 31.05.1978 on 26.02.1998, and as such was
covered under the Old Pension Scheme. This he submits, is due to the fact
that City College, Kolkata is affiliated to the University of Calcutta and is
governed by the West Bengal Non-Government College Teachers (Death
Cum Retirement Benefit Scheme), which is parimateria to the CCS Pension
Rules of 1972. This fact he contends, was informed to the respondent NEHU
by the Principal of City College vide letter dated 27.07.2007, and as the
NEHU respondents still harboured doubts as to whether the petitioner could
be considered under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, a communication was
2025:MLHC:818
made by them to the City College, who by letter dated 13.02.2008 responded
that the petitioner would be eligible under the West Bengal NonGovernment College Teachers (Death Cum Retirement Benefit Scheme).
3.
The learned Senior counsel has then advanced a multipronged
argument revolving around the fundamental issue of the respondent NEHU
refusing to count the petitioner’s past service and cover her under the Old
Pension Scheme (OPS), with the main submission being that the petitioner’s
previous employment was in substance and spirit, service under the State of
West Bengal. The learned Senior counsel has then outlined the legal
character of the petitioner’s previous employment by submitting that City
College, Kolkata though administratively run by the Brahmo Samaj
Education Society, was legally and functionally a Government Aided NonMinority Institution, inasmuch as, the Government of West Bengal had in
2017, dissolved the Governing Body and brought the same under the direct
purview of the State laws, which made the petitioner, a defacto State
Government employee. It was then submitted by the learned Senior counsel
that the petitioner’s case is clearly within the ambit of Government policy
designed for service mobility, and in this context has placed reliance on an
O.M. dated 11.06.2020, issued by the Department of Pension and Pensioners
2025:MLHC:818
Welfare, Government of India. By this OM he submits, a One-Time option
has been provided to employees who joined the Central Government or
Autonomous Body under the New Pension Scheme (NPS) between
01.01.2004 and 28.10.2009, who after submitting a technical resignation
from pensionable State or Central establishment could be covered under the
OPS, and have their past service counted. Learned Senior counsel has then
submitted that the petitioner having resigned from her pensionable post in
West Bengal in 2007, and joined NEHU in that year itself, fits this criteria
perfectly, moreso, as the objective of the O.M.’s was to facilitate seamless
mobility for the employees between Government Bodies without stripping
them of their earned pension benefits, a benefit he contends NEHU, was
obligated to extend.
4.
The learned Senior counsel has further submitted that the stand
taken by the NEHU is untenable, inasmuch as, in spite of receiving
confirmation that the West Bengal Scheme provided for pension, gratuity
and family pension, have claimed that the West Bengal Scheme was not
identical to the Central Civil Service (Pension) Rules, 1972, though the same
is parimateria. It has also been argued that the respondent NEHU, has
admitted the fact that a crucial UGC circular dated 21.09.2020, which
2025:MLHC:818
brought the 11.06.2020 O.M. to the notice of all Central Universities, which
provided that the 3 month’s option window would begin from the date of the
circular was never circulated, and as such the respondent NEHU, was
estopped from citing delay as a ground to deny the writ petitioner the benefit.
In rounding up his submissions, the learned Senior counsel has submitted
that pension is not a bounty but a right, and that beneficial Government
policies must be interpreted liberally in favour of the employee, and the
Court should recognize the substantive nature of her previous service by
directing the NEHU to count her past service, and place her under the Old
Pension Scheme. In support of his submissions, the learned Senior counsel
has placed reliance on the following decisions:-
5.
i)
Union of India & Anr. vs. Pradeep Kumari & Ors (1995) 2 SCC
ii)
Parmatma Saroup vs. State of U.P. & Ors. 1989 SCC OnLine All
870 : 1990 Lab IC 648
iii)
Madan Singh Shekhawat vs. Union of India (1999) 6 SCC 459
Mr. S. Sen, learned Standing counsel for the respondent NEHU
in reply has submitted that the petitioner on consideration of the matter by
the respondent NEHU was not entitled under the Office Memorandums and
2025:MLHC:818
other Notifications. In this connection, the learned counsel has submitted
that the Government of India had issued OM’s dated 26.07.2005 and
28.10.2009, allowing portability of past service only in well-defined
situations and a conjoint reading of the two OM’s would show that O.M.
dated 26.07.2005, applied only to cases where an employee moves from a
Central Government Department or Central Autonomous Body, governed
under the CCS Rules, to another such entity and O.M. dated 28.10.2009,
expanded the scope to include State Government employees covered under
a pension scheme similar to CCS Pension Rules, Central Government
Departments under similar Non-CCS Rules and Central/State Autonomous
Bodies under the Old Pension Scheme. The OM’s he submits being
categorical and unambiguous, nowhere contemplate Non-Government
Colleges, such as City College, Kolkata being included. City College,
Kolkata he submits is administered by its own Managing Committee though
aided by the Government and the Scheme for the teachers namely; the West
Bengal Non-Government College Teachers (Dead Cum Retirement Benefit
Scheme) makes this distinction very clear. Section 5(b) (i) of the Scheme he
submits, excludes Colleges, established, maintained and administered by the
State Government and City College being neither a State Government
Institution nor State Autonomous Body, the petitioner’s service cannot be
2025:MLHC:818
considered for portability of pensionary benefits under the CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972.
6.
The learned counsel has then submitted that the OM’s having
strictly
confined
the
mobility
of
personnel
amongst
Central/State/Autonomous Bodies, the scope of the Notifications/Schemes
therefore, even in exercise of the powers of judicial review cannot be
expanded. It is also contended that the power of judicial review is about
examining the legal grounding and the exact purport of a notification and
not about adding to, or changing the wordings thereof, as the conditions for
seeking benefit under the OM’s or Notifications, are to be strictly
interpreted. In the instant case he submits, the wordings of the Notifications
being clear, the plain language used therein, must be given effect to. In
support of his arguments, the learned counsel has placed reliance on the case
of Union of India & Anr. vs. Deoki Nandan Aggarwal reported in 1992
Supp. (1) SCC 323 and the case of Saraswati Sugar Mill vs. Commissioner
of Central Excise Delhi III reported in (2014) 15 SCC 625.
7.
With regard to the UGC circular dated 21.09.2020 directing for
implementation of OM dated 11.06.2020 pertaining to mobility, it is
submitted that though it is a fact that instructions of the UGC are binding
2025:MLHC:818
upon the University as per the provisions contained in the UGC Act,
however, no purpose would be served in considering the petitioner’s case
afresh in terms of the OM dated 11.06.2020, as the same was not applicable
to her due to her in-eligibility. He finally submits that in any case, the claim
of the writ petitioner is not maintainable, as the instant writ petition has been
filed well after she resigned from the University.
8.
On behalf of the respondent No. 6, i.e. the State of West Bengal,
it has been submitted by Mr. B. Deb, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
M. Lyngdoh, learned counsel, that the petitioner who was appointed as a
Lecturer at City College, Kolkata in 1998, and had opted to be put under the
Old Pension Scheme, was granted a lien of 2 years from City College with
effect from 19.04.2007 in order to join as a Reader at NEHU, but instead of
retaining her lien, had submitted a resignation on the very date she joined
NEHU i.e. 19.04.2007. It is submitted that the petitioner by resigning had
severed her earlier service permanently, which has created a break in her
service. In addition, he contends even with regard to the One-Time option to
employees offered under the OM dated 11.06.2020, the failure of the
petitioner to exercise her option within the mandated 3 months, had rendered
her in-eligible for consideration under the OPS. He therefore, submits that
2025:MLHC:818
the denial of OPS benefits by the respondent University was correct, and no
interference is called for by this Court.
9.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, it is seen that the
entire crux of the matter hinges upon the past service of the writ petitioner,
for the purposes of counting her service, to entitle her to be put under the
Old Pension Scheme. In this regard, it is necessary first to examine the nature
and status of City College, Kolkata, as to whether it can be considered to
come under the definition of Article 12, on account of the fact that there is
deep and pervasive control over the College by the State of West Bengal as
submitted by the petitioner. The City College as can be seen from the
materials is a ‘Non-Government College’ administered by its own
Management Committee, though aided by the Government, the Governing
Scheme for its Teachers i.e. West Bengal Non-Government College
Teachers (Death Cum Retirement Benefit Scheme) has laid down the criteria
to distinguish Colleges established, maintained and administered by the
State Government from others. In this context, it would be useful to refer to
clause 5 (b) (1) contained in the Scheme at Chapter-II, which reads as
follows:“5. In this scheme unless there is anything repugnant in the
subject or context-
2025:MLHC:818
(b) “College” means a college or an institution having all or
any of the streams viz. Arts, Science, Commerce and
Education, which is affiliated to a University in accordance
with the provisions of the Act constituting such University or
the Statutes/Ordinance made thereunder but does not include
College –
(i)
established, maintained and administered by the State
Government.”
A plain reading of the above quoted clause, shows that the
Scheme which covers Non-Government College Teachers, does not include
Colleges that are established, maintained and administered by the State
Government. No doubt the College receives aid from the Government and
is under the purview of state legislation, such as the West Bengal College
Service Commission Act, 1978, with her salary being met by the State
Government and her service pensionable, but however, by operation of
clause 5 (b) (1) of the Scheme, it is clear that City College is neither an
institution of the State Government, nor can it be considered a State
Autonomous Body. As such, the question of considering the petitioner a
defacto State Government employee does not arise.
2025:MLHC:818
10.
Coming to the Office Memorandums (OM’s) from which the
petitioner also bases her claim to entitlement, the same are briefly illustrated
hereinbelow:i)
OM dated 26.07.2005 – Subject:- Counting of past service
on submission of technical resignation on or after
01.01.2004 by employees governed by Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972.
ii)
OM dated 28.10.2009 – Subject:- Mobility of personnel
amongst Central/State & Autonomous Bodies while working
under Pensionable establishments
iii)
OM dated 11.06.2020 – Subject:- Mobility amongst
Central/State & Autonomous Bodies while working under
Pensionable establishments
iv)
Circular dated 21.09.2020 issued by UGC - Subject:Mobility amongst Central/State & Autonomous Bodies
while working under Pensionable establishments; ….. three
months period for calling options from the date of the
circular/instructions.
2025:MLHC:818
The above quoted OM’s on a conjoint reading, extend benefits
of counting past service for employees who were governed by the Old
Pension Scheme under the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972,
which are akin to the Old Pension Scheme opted to by the petitioner. By OM
dated 26.07.2005, the same, brought under its cover employees who entered
into Central Government service or in the service of an Autonomous Body
set up by the Central Government on or before 31.12.2003, who tendered
technical resignation to take up new appointment. The Office Memorandum
dated 28.10.2009, merely extended the coverage of mobility to personnel
serving in State Governments, or appointed on or before 31.12.2003. The
OM dated 11.06.2020, on representations being received by personnel who
joined under the New Pension Scheme in Central Government/Central
Autonomous Bodies after 01.01.2004 but before 28.10.2009 but were denied
the benefit of counting of past service in the Old Pension Scheme, then
addressed the issue by providing for the exercise of options within three
months of issue of the OM dated 11.06.2020. Lastly the circular dated
21.09.2020, issued by the UGC instructed Central Universities to comply
with the OM dated 11.06.2020, calling for options, with the rider that the
provisions of the said OM should not be relaxed or diluted at any cost. In the
2025:MLHC:818
same circular it was also provided that the three months period for calling
the options would count from the date of issuance of the said circular.
11.
On the discussions above, reference can be made to the
judgments cited by the counsel for the respondent NEHU, firstly to the case
of Union of India & Anr. vs. Deoki Nandan Aggarwal (supra) wherein at
Para-14, which is reproduced hereinbelow, it has been held that a Court
adopts a construction which would carry out the obvious intention of the
legislature but could not legislate itself.
“14. We are at a loss to understand the reasoning of the
learned Judges in reading down the provisions in paragraph
2 in force prior to November 1, 1986 as "more than five
years" and as "more than four years" in the same paragraph
for the period subsequent to November 1, 1986. It is not the
duty of the Court either to enlarge the scope of the legislation
or the intention of the legislature when the language of the
provision is plain and unambiguous. The Court cannot
rewrite, recast or reframe the legislation for the very good
reason that it has no power to legislate. The power to legislate
has not been conferred on the courts. The Court cannot add
words to a statute or read words into it which are not there.
Assuming there is a defect or an omission in the words used
by the legislature the Court could not go to its aid to correct
or make up the deficiency. Courts shall decide what the law is
and not what it should be. The Court of course adopts a
construction which will carry out the obvious intention of the
legislature but could not legislate itself. But to invoke judicial
activism to set at naught legislative judgment is subversive of
the
constitutional
harmony
and
comity
of
instrumentalities. Vide P.K. Unni v. Nirmala Industries4,
2025:MLHC:818
Mangilal v. Suganchand Rathi5, Sri Ram Ram Narain Medhi
v. The State of Bombay6, Hira Devi (Smt) v. District Board,
Shahjahanpur7, Nalinakhya Bysack v. Shyam Sunder
Haldar8., Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Gujarat Steel Tubes
Mazdaor Sabha9, G. Narayanaswami v. G. Pannerselvam10,
N.S. Vardachari v. G. Vasantha Pai11, Union of India v.
Sankal Chand Himatlal Sheth12, and CST v. Auriaya
Chamber of Commerce, Allahabad13. Modifying and altering
the scheme and applying it to others who are not otherwise
entitled to under the scheme, will not also come under the
principle of affirmative action adopted by courts some times
in order to avoid discrimination. If we may say so, what the
High Court has done in this case is a clear and naked
usurpation of legislative power.”
4(1990) 2 SCC 378, 383-84 : (1990) 1 SCR 482, 488
(1964) 5 SCR 239 : AIR 1965 SC 101
1959 Supp 1 SCR 489 : AIR 1959 SC 459
1952 SCR 1122, 1131 : AIR 1952 SC 362
1953 SCR 533, 545 : AIR 1953 SC 148
(1980) 2 SCC 593 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 197 : (1980) 2 SCR 146
(1972) 3 SCC 717 : (1973) 1 SCR 172, 182
(1972) 2 SCC 594 : (1973) 1 SCR 886
12(1977) 4 SCC 193 : 1977 SCC (L&S) 435 : (1978) 1 SCR 423
(1986) 3 SCC 50, 55 : 1986 SCC (Tax) 449 : (1986) 2 SCR 430, 438
Secondly, the judgment in the case of Saraswati Sugar Mill vs.
Commissioner of Central Excise Delhi III (supra) at Para-19 thereof, which
is reproduced below has also held that when the wording in the notification
is clear, then the plain language of the notification must be given effect to.
“19. An exemption notification has to be strictly construed.
The conditions for taking benefit under the notification are
also to be strictly interpreted. When the wordings of
notification is clear, then the plain language of the
notification must be given effect to. By way of an
interpretation or construction, the Court cannot add or
2025:MLHC:818
substitute any word while construing the notification either to
grant or deny exemption. The Courts are also not expected to
stretch the words of notification or add or subtract words in
order to grant or deny the benefit of exemption
notification. In Bombay Chemicals (P) Ltd. vs. CCE - (1995)
Supp (2) SCC 646, a three Judge Bench of this Court held
that an exemption notification should be construed strictly,
but once an article is found to satisfy the test by which it falls
in the notification, then it cannot be excluded from it by
construing such notification narrowly.”
12.
The decisions relied upon by the learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner, to support the contention that the consideration of the case of the
petitioner should not be mired by technicalities and that the grant of
pensionary benefits should be construed liberally are not useful, in view of
the clear cut provisions of the OM’s and the facts surrounding the instant
case and as such, are not discussed or elaborated upon. Similarly, the
decision relied upon by the learned Senior counsel for the respondent No. 6,
would have no application, inasmuch as, the option as per the OM itself was
not available to be exercised by the petitioner.
13.
In the backdrop of these facts and circumstances, firstly the fact
that City College, Kolkata is not a Government College and secondly, the
OM’s being not applicable to the case of the petitioner, as she was neither in
her past service in the employ of the Central Government/State Government
2025:MLHC:818
or an Autonomous Body under the Central or State Government, the claim
of the petitioner for consideration for coverage under the Old Pension
Scheme is thus unsustainable. Further, the non-communication of the
circular dated 21.09.2020 to the petitioner, is found to be of no consequence,
as the same contained only instructions that the OM dated 11.06.2020
pertaining to mobility, be implemented without relaxing or diluting the
norms. It is also noted that the petitioner had resigned before instituting the
present writ petition and though the order accepting her resignation is also
impugned, the same is irrelevant in the present discourse.
14.
Accordingly, for the reasons stated above, the instant writ
petition being devoid of merit is dismissed, however with no order as to
costs.
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
10.09.2025
“V. Lyndem- PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2025.09.10 13:52:55 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review