Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 227 of 2023
Date of Decision: 20.05.2024
Dr. Bela Keshan
D/o Late Sitaram Keshan,
Resident of GF 16/1,
Rabindrapally, Jordabagan, Jyangra,
Baguiati, Kolkata, Desh Bandhu Nagar,
North 24, Paraganas, West Bengal,
PIN- 700059
:::Petitioner
-Vs1.The North-Eastern Hill University,
represented by the Registrar, NEHU
Campus, Shillong-793022
2.The Vice Chancellor, North-Eastern
Hill University represented by the
Registrar, NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
3.The Registrar, North-Eastern Hill University,
represented by the Registrar, NEHU Campus,
Shillong-793022
4.The Head of Department of Zoology,
North-Eastern Hill University,
NEHU Campus, Shillong-793022
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.P. Sharma, Adv.
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Sen, Adv.
Ms. S. Shallam, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner who is a
Professor in the department of Zoology, NEHU Shillong, on the noncondonation of her leave for the period from 28.05.2020 to 14.06.2020,
and from 11.07.2020 to 12.12.2020, had preferred representations dated
29.10.2021 and 03.02.2022, attributing the ground for non-attendance
of duties due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and on the rejection of the
same, has been constrained to approach this Court.
2.
It has been submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner
that the petitioner had initially sought leave for 3(three) days from
23.03.2020 till 25.03.2020, with permission to leave station, but
however, she could not join her duty after the expiry of her leave
period, as by then the COVID-19 pandemic had set in, and lockdown
had been declared. The petitioner he submits, due to the extension of
lockdown, informed the Head of Department by email on several dates
i.e. 14.04.2020, 04.05.2020 and 17.05.2020, about her inability to
return to Shillong, and as the phased reopening continued till
30.09.2020, coupled with the fact that educational institutions, had not
been opened, worked from home, as per advice. He further submits that
the petitioner had informed the University on 01.10.2020, that she
would continue to work from home because of the pandemic, and that
in this regard, various guidelines had also been issued by the
Government of Meghalaya/Ministry of Home Affairs advising and
permitting faculty members to work from home, and to take online
classes.
3.
Her continued absence it is contended was not irregular,
inasmuch as, the HOD Zoology assigned her duties while she was in
Kolkata, and the petitioner accordingly worked from home, by taking
online classes and finished all her assigned teaching research and
examination duties with a regular report being sent to the department in
the prescribed format. It is submitted that on receipt of the first
impugned letter dated 05.10.2020, directing her to report for duty by
12.10.2020, the petitioner replied vide emails dated 09.10.2020,
11.10.2020, 11.11.2020 and 26.11.2020, requesting the respondents to
allow her to continue to work from home. Thereafter he submits, the
petitioner resumed charge on 11.12.2020, but the respondents by a
Resolution had decided that as despite the letter dated 05.10.2020, s the
petitioner had failed to join on or before 12.10.2020, her leave
application would be examined as per existing rules and the salary be
withheld from the month of December 2020, till finalization of her
entitlement/deduction of allowances during her leave/absence from the
headquarter. The petitioner he submits, as desired by the respondents
which was communicated by letter dated 30.06.2021, requiring her to
apply for proper leave for the period of absence of 171 days, then
accordingly applied for the same vide leave application dated
05.07.2021.
4.
The learned counsel submits that the respondents then on
12.07.2021, passed an order regularizing the leave of the petitioner in
various categories, to which the petitioner being aggrieved preferred an
appeal on 29.10.2021, for condonation of forced leave for the period
from 28.05.2020 to 14.06.2020, which came to be rejected by the
impugned order dated 15.12.2021. It is urged that, the absence of the
petitioner from station being through no fault of hers, but due to the
pandemic, the respondents had acted arbitrarily, inasmuch as, she had
performed her duties and completed works as assigned to her by the
University, and the treatment meted out to her is exploitative and
discriminatory, apart from the misuse of services rendered by her. It is
lastly submitted that, the petitioner has been penalized without due
process being followed, and as such, the respondents are liable to be
directed to condone her leave and grant her relief as prayed for.
5.
In reply Mr. S. Sen, the learned counsel for the respondents
submits that the petitioner was due to join back on 26.03.2020, but due
to the COVID-19 pandemic, the University vide notification dated
23.03.2020, had permitted the teaching and non-teaching staff to work
and conduct their online classes from home, but thereafter, vide
notification dated 04.05.2020, work from home was discontinued from
05.05.2020. But to avoid crowd and for maintaining social distancing,
as per the guidelines of the Government, he submits online classes were
allowed to be continued. The writ petitioner however he submits,
without seeking leave, and or extension or permission to remain out of
station, sought permission by email to conduct online classes, which
was brought to the notice of the Registrar of the University by the HOD
of Zoology on 16.09.2020, who informed about the petitioner’s
continued absence, though her physical presence was required for
examination related and other administrative responsibilities, and a
request was made by the said letter, for the Registrar to do the needful
in this regard. As such, he submits a letter dated 05.10.2020, was sent
informing the writ petitioner that the authority was viewing her case
seriously, for not being present or reporting to the department, and the
petitioner was directed to report to the department latest by 12.10.2020.
Thereafter he submits, the Executive Council of the University on
15.10.2020, passed a Resolution that necessary concession may be
given only to the period of complete lockdown to faculty members, and
that anyone was out of station, was to apply for proper leave, failing
which necessary action would be taken.
6.
The writ petitioner he submits, then by letter dated
07.12.2020, intimated that she would join and submit her charge report
on 11.12.2020, and on 16.12.2020, concerning her case of prolonged
absence, the same was taken up by the Executive Council, and it was
resolved therein to the effect that, for the period the writ petitioner
remained absent from station without any station leave, the same would
be regularized as per leave rules. It is further submitted that, this
Resolution was to apply as well to all other faculty members/staff, in
the matter of prolonged absence of a similar nature. The learned
counsel submits that there is no arbitrariness in the action of the
respondent University, as the writ petitioner was granted all concession
for the period of complete lockdown, and her absence w.e.f. 28.05.2020
to 10.12.2020, was regularized by granting available sanctioned leave.
This he submits, was in line with the decision taken on 15.10.2020, that
faculty members on an unauthorized leave, after the complete
lockdown were to apply for leave to regularize their unauthorized
absence. He lastly added that, the respondent University did not take
any disciplinary action, as is warranted in cases of unauthorized
absence, taking into account the inconvenience caused by COVID
restrictions. He submits that there being no illegality, and the petitioner
having committed serious lapses in remaining absent, no injustice has
been caused.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties. From the submissions of
the learned counsels, it is seen that the only point to be examined by
this Court, is whether the action of the respondent University in not
condoning the leave of the petitioner, and non-consideration of her
various representations is arbitrary, discriminatory and whether the
same has infringed upon her rights, in any manner as alleged. Without
recapping or narrating the facts any further, inasmuch as, the same has
been adequately dealt with by the respective counsels, this Court will
confine itself only to the relevant materials to determine, as to whether
the impugned action is to be interfered with in judicial review.
8.
It is correct that the relevant period, when the petitioner was
not present in station was during the highs and lows of the COVID
pandemic, on which the main ground seeking condonation of her leave
has been based upon. However, what cannot be overlooked is that, the
petitioner apart from emails for grant of permission to work from
home, no permission was sought to remain out of station. It is also seen
that, notifications and notices have been issued by the respondent
University from time to time, with regard to the functioning of the
University and its employees. Her absence as submitted earlier was
brought to the notice of the Registrar vide letter dated 16.09.2020,
which prompted the respondents to issue a letter dated 05.10.2020,
which is reproduced herein below.
North-Eastern Hill University
Nehu Campus, Shillong 793 022 (Meghalaya)
Dated 5th October, 2020.
No.F.17-353/Estt.II/2018-6711
To
Prof. Bela Keshan,
Deptt. of Zoology,
NEHU, Shillong
Sub: Absence and negligence of duty.
Madam,
I am directed to inform you that the Authority has viewed your case
very seriously for not being present/reported in the Department. In this
connection, it is hereby directed that you should report to the Department
immediately latest by 12th October, 2020 and submit your Charge Report
through proper channel accordingly.
Your prolonged absence from the Department till the date of
resumption of duties will be settled strictly as per provision of the rules
only after your joining the Department.
This issues with the approval of the Vice-Chancellor.
Yours faithfully,
Joint Registrar(Estt.II).
Copy to:
1. The Sr. P.S to the Vice-Chancellor, NEHU, Shillong for V.C’s kind
information.
2. The P.S to the Pro-Vice-Chancellor, NEHU, Shillong for P.V.C’s
kind information.
3. The Head, Department of Zoology, NEHU, Shillong
4. The P.A. to the Registrar, NEHU, Shillong for Registrar’s kind
information.
5. Personal file.
9.
The Executive Council meeting dated 15.10.2020, in its
Resolution had also recorded as follows.
“(i) Prolonged absence from duty/Headquarter by Faculty
Members, Officers and Staff:
No. EC:175:2020:6:7(i): The Council was apprised that so
many Faculty members/staff/others are in the habit of
leaving the station without sanction of proper leave and
remain absent from duty for a long time, which affects the
normal functioning of the Department/academic activities.
From the outstation/home town, the Faculty members/staff
informed that they are on ‘work from home’ in view of the
Covid-19 Pandemic. The Council deliberated on the matter.
The Council RESOLVED that no staff/Faculty
Member(s) should leave the station without sanction of
proper leave and that action as per Rule will be taken for
such unauthorized leave/absence from duty.
The Council further RESOLVED that necessary
concession may be given only for the period of complete
lockdown that is, from the date lockdown was announced by
the Government of India till the period of Railways/
Airlines/travel
facilities
being
operational/functional.
Thereafter, anyone who was out of station has to apply for
proper leave, failing which necessary action need to be
taken.
The Council also RESOLVED to list out the name of
Faculty members/Officers/staff from the records, by the
concerned Section, who are in out of station now and take
necessary action as per Rule(s). The Council also
RESOLVED that a Circular in this regard will be issued to
all the Department from the Administration.
The Council also RESOLVED that “work from home”
is to remain in station and not out of station, and has to be
examined case to case basis.
The Council also RESOLVED that Casual Leave for a
period of more than 5 days at a stretch, should not be
allowed.”
10.
It is noted that even after the abovementioned
letter was
issued, the writ petitioner did not resume her duties on 12.10.2020, nor
did she take heed of the Executive Council’s resolution adopted on
15.10.2020, and it was only on 11.12.2020, that she resumed charge.
This prolonged absence, taking into account the COVID restrictions
and the representations and letters of the petitioner to the respondents,
was then deliberated by the Executive Council in its meeting dated
16.12.2020, and the Resolution arrived at which is very relevant is
reproduced herein below.
“(ii)
Prolong
absence
of
Prof.
Bela
Keshan,
Department of Zoology, NEHU, Shillong:
No.EC:177:2020:6:3:(ii): The Council was apprised that Prof.
Bela Keshan, Department of Zoology, NEHU was out of station on
Casual Leave from 23rd to 25th March, 2020 after taking station
leave permission from March, 2020 to 25th March, 2020 to visit her
Home town, Kolkata. However, the Head, Department of Zoology,
NEHU vide letter dated 16.9.2020 informed that Prof. Bela Keshan
is out of station on a casual leave (23-25 March, 2020) and station
leave from 20th to 25th March, 2020 till 16th September, 2020 and in
between Prof. Keshan has sent some email letters for grant of
permission to work from home in view of Covid-19 pandemic
lockdown or other reasons, and that the email letters have been
forwarded to the Registrar/AR (Estt-II) for necessary action. Now,
the Department has started examination related work, besides
other administrative responsibilities to faculty members and
therefore, Prof. B. Keshan’s presence is required in the
Department and needful to be done at the earliest. The matter of
absence and negligence of duty was communicated to Prof. Bela
Keshan
from
the
Estt.II
Section
vide
letter
No.F.17-
353/Estt.II/2018-6711 dated 5th October, 2020 informing her that
the
Authority
has
viewed
very
seriously
for
not
being
present/reported in the Department and that she should report to
the Department immediately latest by 12th October, 2020 and
submit her charge report through proper channel. She was further
informed that her prolonged absence from the Department till the
date of resumption of duties will be settled strictly as per provision
of the rules only after her joining the Department. In response to
that letter, Prof. Bela Keshan has furnished her reply vide letter
dated 9th October, 2020 that due to extraordinary situation of
spread of Covid-19 pandemic she was compelled to stay back in
Kolkata and carrying out her duties online from Kolkata and that
she finished entire assigned syllabus for the M.Sc. and Ph.D.
Course work classes (Even Semester 2020) online and have also
conducted Internal Assessment Test and set the question papers for
the Internal Test/End Semester Examination, while working from
home at Kolkata. Now, due to serious sickness of her aged mother,
she is requesting to allow her to stay in Kolkata and extend her
physical reporting in the Department till such time the Doctor
advice that her mother is medically fit. Due to Covid-19 pandemic,
she is requesting to allow her to take her teaching/learning
activities online from her home at Kolkata or allow her to take
leave as permissible under NEHU Rules. The Council was further
apprised that Prof. Bela Keshan has reported to her duty on
11.12.2020 and submitted the Charge Report to the Estt.II Section.
The Council deliberated on the matter.
The Council RESOLVED that Establishment II Section will
examine her leave application as per existing Rules and
withholding her salary from the month of December, 2020
onwards
till
finalization
of
her
entitlement/deduction
of
allowance(s) during her leave/absence from the Head Quarter.
The Council further RESOLVED that Establishment I and
Establishment II Section will take action in the same line in respect
of other Faculty member(s)/staff on the matter of prolong absence
of similar nature.”
11.
What emerges from the facts as laid out above, in the
considered view of this Court, is that the action of the respondents in
arriving at a decision to require the petitioner to apply for proper leave
for the period of absence from headquarters for 171 days, is neither
arbitrary or unreasonable. From the materials as seen and discussed
above, the petitioner notwithstanding the pandemic, was duty bound to
at least seek permission for her absence from station and or to apply for
leave. The decisions therefore, as seen from the Executive Council
resolutions and other correspondence have been arrived at after due
consideration and the same also being uniform in its application and
implementation to all similarly situated faculty members, no case of
discrimination has also been made out.
12.
Accordingly, for the reasons stated above, the writ petitioner is
not entitled to the reliefs as claimed, and the writ petition is dismissed.
13.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
20.05.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review