Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 9309 OF 2025
PETITIONERS:
BEENA
AGED 49 YEARS
WIFE OF RAJAN, VADAKKEPURAKKAL HOUSE’, VAILATHUR,
NURSERIPPADI, PONMUNDAM, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676106
RAJAN
AGED 59 YEARS,
SON OF KARAPPAN, VADAKKEPURAKKAL HOUSE’,
VAILATHUR, NURSERIPPADI, PONMUNDAM, MALAPPURAM,
PIN - 676106
BY ADVS.
AKASH S.
GIRISH KUMAR M S
RICHU HANNA RANJITH
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HEALTH
AND FAMILY WELFARE, SASTHRI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI,
PIN – 110001.
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HEALTH
AND FAMILY WELFARE, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695001.
THE DISTRICT REPRODUCTIVE & CHILD HEALTH ("RCH")
OFFICER,
DISTRICT MEDICAL OFFICE, ERNAKULAM, PARK AVENUE,
MARINE DRIVE, ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682011.
SABINE HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE PVT. LTD,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR,
PEZHAKKAPPALLY PO, MUVATTUPUZHA, PIN - 686673
BY ADV VISHNU J
DSGI SRI.DINESH
GOVT.PLEADER SMT.VIDYA KURIAKOSE
THIS
ADMISSION
WRIT
ON
PETITION
08.04.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
(CIVIL)
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 08th day of April, 2025
The 1st petitioner is the wife of the 2nd
petitioner. The petitioners are aged 49 and 59 years,
respectively. They are issueless. The 1 st petitioner has
undergone in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) procedures at the
4th respondent hospital. Although the doctors have
advised the 1st petitioner to undergo another IVF
procedure, the hospital has declined the procedure for
the reason that the 2nd petitioner has surpassed the age
of 55 years as stipulated under Section 21 (g) (ii) of the
Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act,
2021 ('Act', for brevity) and the petitioners fall within
the purview of the term “commissioning couple”
defined under the Act. Since the 1 st petitioner is 49
years of age and she is a “woman” as defined under
Section 2 (1)(u) of the Act, and further, the 2 nd
petitioner has given his consent for the procedure; the
1st petitioner is entitled to undergo the procedure. The
refusal of the hospital to provide treatment to the
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
petitioners is an infringement of their right to life. The
age restrictions laid down under the Act apply only if
the man and woman participate in the Assisted
Reproductive Technology (‘ART’) procedure. In the
present case, only the 1st petitioner needs to undergo
the
procedure.
Hence,
the
respondents
may
be
directed to permit the 1st petitioner to avail of the ART
procedure using donor male gamete.
2. In W.P(C) No.31161/2024, a case of identical
nature, the 1st respondent has filed a counter affidavit
contending that, as the 2nd petitioner has exceeded the
age criteria prescribed under Section 21(g)(ii)of the
Act, the petitioners are ineligible to avail the ART
services. Merely because the 1st petitioner has not
surpassed the age prescribed under Section 21(g)(i) of
the Act, she is not entitled to proceed with the
procedure. In view of Section 2(1)(e) of the Act, which
explicitly
defines
a
commissioning
couple,
the
petitioners have to fulfil the conditions under Sections
2(1)(e) and 21(g) of the Act. The Act has been enacted
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
considering the status of a single woman (unmarried,
divorcee and widow) and a married woman. The
criteria for selecting the beneficiaries under the Act
was discussed by the Parliamentary Committee as per
Ext.R1(a) report. The age restrictions in the Act have
been laid down after considering the best interest of
the child to be born through the ART procedure. The
petitioners have filed the writ petition as a couple;
therefore,
they
fall
within
the
definition
of
a
commissioning couple. Section 21(g) requires a man
and a woman to complete the procedure. Any married
woman or married man constituting a commissioning
couple and wanting to undergo an ART procedure has
to simultaneously qualify the twin conditions under
Sections 21(g)(i) and 21 (g) (ii) of the Act. There is no
indication in the Act that only one among the men or
women constitutes a commissioning couple. The age
restrictions have
been
imposed
on
both
parties,
keeping in view the social responsibilities of the father.
As per Section 2(1)(e) of the Act, when a woman
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
approaches
an
ART
clinic
with
her
man
as
a
“commissioning couple”, they should be married and
infertile as provided under Section 2(1)(j). Moreover,
as per Rule 13(1)(f)(iii) of the Assisted Reproductive
Technology (Regulation) Rules, 2022, a married woman
is required to submit the consent of her husband in
Form 8. If a married woman is permitted to approach
the clinic as a woman, her husband will not come into
the picture, and she will escape the stipulation under
Rule 13(1)(f)(iii), which would defeat the condition
under the Act and the Rules. The Act does not envisage
a married woman approaching a clinic as a woman. In
the process of fulfilling the desire of a couple to
become parents, the rights and welfare of the unborn
child should not be neglected, which is of paramount
importance.
To
ensure
the
above
matters
are
addressed, the 1st respondent has issued Ext.R1(b)
instructions. The constitutional validity of Section 21(g)
is under challenge before the Honourable Supreme
Court of India in W.P(c) No.756/2022 and connected
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
cases. It is settled law that there is a presumption in
favour of the constitutionality of an enactment. The
petitioners have failed to plead or show that their
fundamental rights have been infringed. The imposition
of an upper age limit in the Act is only a reasonable
restriction and cannot be said to violate the rights of
individuals/couples. The writ petition is meritless and
may be dismissed.
3.
Heard; Sri. Akash Sathyanandan S., the
learned counsel for the petitioners, Sri.Dinesh, the
learned counsel for the 1st respondent and Smt.Vidya
Kuriakose, the learned Government Pleader.
4. The question that emerges for consideration
is whether the 1st petitioner can avail of the ART
services in the status as a “woman” despite being
married to the 2nd petitioner who has surpassed 55
years of age.
5.
The
Assisted
Reproductive
Technology
(Regulation) Bill 2020 was introduced in the Lok Sabha
on
14.09.2020
and
referred
to
the
Standing
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
Committee.
The
Lok
Sabha
passed
01.12.2021,
and
the
Rajya
Sabha
the
bill
on
passed
it
on
08.12.2021. The President gave assent to the Bill on
18.12.2021, and the Assisted Reproductive Technology
(Regulation) Act 2021 (42 of 2021) came into force on
25.01.2022.
6. To decide the question posed, it is essential
to analyse the relevant provisions in the Act, which are
reproduced below for reference and understanding of
the legislative intention.
(A) Section 2(1)(a) defines “Assisted Reproductive
Technology” as under:
“assisted reproductive technology” with its grammatical
variations and cognate expressions, means all techniques that
attempt to obtain a pregnancy by handling the sperm or the oocyte
outside the human body and transferring the gamete or the embryo
into the reproductive system of a woman”.
(B) Section 2(1)(e) defines a “commissioning
couple”, thus:
“commissioning couple” means an infertile married couple who
approach an assisted reproductive technology clinic or assisted
reproductive technology bank for obtaining the services authorised
of the said clinic or bank”.
(C) Section 2(1)(j) defines “infertility” as
follows:
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
“infertility” means the inability to conceive after one year of
unprotected coitus or other proven medical condition preventing a
couple from conception”.
(D) Section 2(1)(n) defines “patients” as
under:
“patients” means an individual or couple who comes to any
registered assisted reproductive technology clinic for management of
infertility”.
(E) Section 2(1)(u) defines woman as follows:
“woman means any woman above the age of twenty-one years
who approaches an assisted reproductive technology clinic or
assisted reproductive technology bank for obtaining the authorised
services of the clinic or bank”.
(F). Section 21 deals with the General duties of
assisted reproductive technology clinics and banks,
which reads as follows:
“The clinics and banks shall perform the following duties,
namely:—
“(a) the clinics and banks shall ensure that
commissioning
couple, woman and donors of gametes are eligible to
avail the assisted reproductive technology procedures
subject to such criteria as may be prescribed;
***
***
***
***
***
(g) the clinics shall apply the assisted reproductive
technology services, —
(i) to a woman above the age of twenty-one years
and below the age of fifty years;
(ii) to a man above the age of twenty-one years and
below the age of fifty-five years;
(h) the clinics shall issue to the commissioning couple or
woman a discharge certificate stating details of the
assisted reproductive technology procedure performed
on the commissioning couple or woman……. ……..”.
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
(emphasis
supplied)
(G) Section 22(1)(a) of the Act reads as follows:
“22. Written informed consent.
(1)
The clinic shall not perform any treatment or
procedure
without—
(a)
the written informed consent of all the parties
seeking assisted reproductive technology…………..”.
(H).
Rule
13(1)(f)(iii)
of
the
Assisted
Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Rules, 2022,
specifies that the consent for Intrauterine Insemination
with donor semen is to be obtained in Form No.8.
7. Taber’s Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary defines
Assisted Reproduction Technology as any of the
techniques to assist infertile women to conceive and
give birth. These include hormonal stimulation of
ovulation and operative techniques such as in vitro
fertilisation with embryonic transfer, zygote intrafallopian transfer for women whose infertility results
from tubal factors, and gamete intrafallopian transfer
for couples whose infertility stems from semen.
8. In MODIs textbook of Medical Jurisprudence
and Toxicology, 27th Edition, it stated that Assisted
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
Reproductive Techniques have not only enhanced the
possibility of pregnancy but have also made women
conceive in situations where this would not have been
possible decades ago. In in-vitro fertilisation, the eggs
are surgically removed from the woman, fertilised with
the available sperms in a dish, and the embryo is
replaced into the womb of the woman who completes
the carriage till delivery. In IVF, the semen samples of
the husband are screened two or three times. In this
process, the oocyte is picked up trans-vaginally.
9. What is in vitro fertilisation has been succinctly
explained by the Mayo Clinic in the following manner:
“In vitro fertilization, also called IVF, is a complex series of
procedures that can lead to a pregnancy. It's a treatment for
infertility, a condition in which you can't get pregnant after at
least a year of trying for most couples. IVF also can be used to
prevent passing on genetic problems to a child. During in vitro
fertilization, mature eggs are collected from ovaries and
fertilized by sperm in a lab. Then a procedure is done to place
one or more of the fertilized eggs, called embryos, in a uterus,
which is where babies develop. IVF can be done using a couple's
own eggs and sperm. Or it may involve eggs, sperm or embryos
from a known or unknown donor. In some cases, a gestational
carrier — someone who has an embryo implanted in the uterus
— might be used. IVF may be an option if a partner has fallopian
tube damage or blockage, ovulation disorders, endometriosis,
uterine fibroids, previous surgery to prevent pregnancy, issues
with sperm, unexplained infertility or genetic disorder”.
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
10.
The contention of the petitioners' is that,
given that only the 1st petitioner (the wife) has been
advised to undergo the IVF procedure using donor
male gamete, and she is under the age of 50, the age
restriction imposed under Section 21 (g) of the Act
does not apply to her, although the 2nd petitioner has
exceeded 55 years of age.
11. Conversely, the respondents contend that both
petitioners must satisfy the age criteria set forth in
Section
(g),
as
they
are
recognised
as
a
“commissioning couple.”
12.
The
terms
“commissioning
couple”
and
“woman” are defined under Sections 2(1)(e) and 2 (1)
(u). However, the term “man” is notably not defined in
the Act, even though age restrictions are distinctly laid
down for both “woman” and “man” in Section 21 (g).
Likewise, there is no specific age restriction for a
‘commissioning
couple”.
This
omission
poses
a
significant question of whether the legislature has
excluded a composite age criterion for “commissioning
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
couples”. The literature on the subject suggests that
ART procedures are generally applied to women and
men individually, even when both parties may undergo
the procedure jointly.
13. To gain further insight into the legislative
intent behind Section 21 (g), it would be meaningful to
refer to Ext.R1(a) produced in W.P(C) No.31161/2024,
Report
No.129
of
the
Parliamentary
Standing
Committee on Health and Family Welfare Suggestions
on Clause 21 (g) of the Bill, which ultimately shaped
into Section 21 (g). The relevant portion of the report
reads thus:
“SUGGESTIONS:
4.14.14 One stakeholder has informed that the complications of
IVF (Ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, OHSS) are higher in
younger woman. The earlier guideline had kept the cut off at 21
years. It has been suggested to keep the lower age limit for woman
more than 20 years to ensure safety their safety. The upper age limit
for women/man should be decided based on factor viz (i) risk to
maternal health due to pregnancy at advanced maternal age (ii) care
of child until 18 years and average life expectancy in India.
4.14.15 The upper limit for woman should not be beyond
45 years and for man, it should be not be beyond 50 years. The
combined age of the couple (woman and man) should not be
beyond 90 years (this requirement is same as for adoption in
India)
DEPARTMENT’S RESPONSE:
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
4.14.16 The criterion of age limit for a man and woman to avail
ART services has been drafted in consonance with the provisions of
the Surrogacy Bill 2019.
OBSERVATIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS:
4.14.17 The Committee observes that the DHR has agreed to
the stakeholders’ suggestions to remove the phrase “legal age or
marriage” from the definition of woman for approaching an ART
centre as lower age of marriage is acceptable in some religions. The
Committee observes that the ICMR Guidelines stipulates minimum of
20 years of age for woman availing ART services. The Committee has
already recommended removal of the term “legal age of marriage”
and prescribed that the specific age i.e. 21 years in definition of
“woman” as mentioned in the Bill under clause 2(x), therefore, the
Committee reiterates the minimum of 21 years for woman and man
for availing ART services. The upper age limit for woman and man
may be 50 and 55 years, respectively, as recommended by the Select
Committee on Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill 2020.
4.14.18 Subject to the above recommendation, the clause is
adopted”.
(emphasis supplied)
14. A careful reading of the above suggestions
reveals that the Parliamentary Standing Committee
had suggested the upper age limit for women and men
not to exceed 45 and 50 and the couple's combined age
(woman and man) not to surpass 90 years to draw a
parallel with the age restrictions in the Adoption
Regulation.
Nevertheless,
the
Parliament
has
consciously omitted incorporating any age criteria for a
“commissioning
couple”,
possibly
recognising
the
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
distinct nature of ART services and the procedures for
adopting a child.
15. In this context, it is relevant to refer to
Clauses 5 (4) and 5(5) of the Adoption Regulations
2022, which lays down the age criteria to adopt a child
and it reads as follows:
“5. Eligibility criteria for prospective adoptive parents.―
***
***
***
***
(4) The age of prospective adoptive parents, as on the date of
registration, shall be counted for deciding the eligibility of
prospective adoptive parents for children of different age groups as
under:-
Age of the
Child
Upto 2
years
Above 2 and
upto 4 years
Above 4 and
upto 8 years
Above 8 and
upto 18
years
Maximum
composite
age of
prospective
adoptive
parents (couple)
85 years
Maximum age of
single prospective
adoptive parent
90 years
45 years
100 years
50 years
110 years
55 years
40 years
Provided that the minimum age difference between the child
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
and either of the prospective adoptive parents shall not be less than
twenty five years.
(5) In case of a couple, the composite age of the prospective
adoptive parents shall be counted.
16. Conspicuously, the Act does not contain the
concept of combined age for commissioning couples
analogous to the composite age criteria applicable to
prospective adoptive parents. Instead, the Act adopts
an
individual-centric
approach,
whereby
the
age
eligibility criteria are separately laid down for women
and men rather than collectively for a couple. This
interpretation is further supported by Section 2 (1) (n)
of the Act, which defines “patients” as both individuals
and couples seeking infertility treatment at a clinic.
Additionally, Section 21 casts duties on the ART clinics
and banks to ensure adherence to the statutory
requirements. Notably, under Section 21 (g) the
mandate is for the clinics to apply ART services to a
woman only if she is above 21 and below 50 years of
age and to a man if he is above 21 and below 55 years
of age. The provision reinforces that the age restriction
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
is
gender-specific
rather
than
couple-specific,
reinforcing that eligibility depends on the individual’s
age rather than the couple’s combined age.
17. In the context of the case at hand, the 2 nd
petitioner has attained 59 years of age, rendering him
ineligible to avail of the ART procedure. However, the
couple still intends to pursue parenthood through the
1st petitioner, who desires to avail of the ART procedure
of intrauterine insemination using donor male gamete,
as she falls within the legally permissible age range.
18. A holistic understanding of the Act and the
associated ART procedures and services reveal that the
only legal requirement that the 2nd petitioner has to
comply with to enable the 1st petitioner to apply the
ART procedure is to give his consent in Form 8,
undertaking that he would acknowledge the child born
through the procedure as his legal heir.
19. In essence, the 1st petitioner’s eligibility to
apply for the ART procedure operates independently
despite the 2nd petitioner’s ineligibility, provided the 2nd
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
petitioner gives his consent for the procedure. Hence,
when a woman wants to undergo an IVF procedure,
only her age is considered relevant, irrespective of her
husband’s
age,
and
the
same
principle
applies
conversely to men. The above interpretation leads to
an inevitable conclusion that the legislature has
treated men and women as distinct legal entities under
the Act rather than imposing uniform couple-centric
legislation.
20. On the contrary, if the respondents' contention
is accepted that both spouses must satisfy the age
criteria,
it
would
create
an
unconstitutional
classification, treating married women and single
women as separate and distinct classes. Take, for
example, a hypothetical situation where a married
woman is ineligible for an ART procedure solely
because her husband has surpassed the age limit; the
woman would become eligible immediately on her legal
separation or becoming a widow. Such a classification
would be a fallacy and would put married women at an
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
unfair disadvantage when compared to single women
to access ART procedures. It can never be presumed
that the Parliament intended such an inequitable
classification within a benevolent statute like the Act.
It is a well-established legal principle that no one can
supplement conditions not explicitly provided in the
statute. Without any express provision in the Act
restricting commissioning couples on the basis of their
composite age, there is no legal bar in a woman who is
otherwise eligible under Section 21 (g) (i) from
applying the ART procedure even if her husband has
surpassed the age limit. The same rationale applies to
men, ensuring that single and married individuals
enjoy equitable access to reproductive assistance. The
above discussions conclude that there is no legal bar
for the 4th respondent to apply the ART procedure on
the 1st petitioner. The experience of childlessness is a
silent anguish known to only those who walk that path.
In light of the above discussions, I answer the
question in favour of the 1 st petitioner by allowing the
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
writ petition and directing the 4th respondent to
provide ART services to the 1 st petitioner as per the
provisions of the Act after obtaining the consent of the
2nd petitioner.
ma/08.04.2025
Sd/- C.S.DIAS, JUDGE
2025:KER:30505
WP(C) NO.9309 OF 2025
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 9309/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE AADHAAR CARD OF THE
1ST PETITIONER, BEARING NO.4920 8694
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE AADHAAR CARD OF THE
2ND PETITIONER, BEARING NO.5532 6030
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE TREATMENT SUMMARY OF
THE 1ST PETITIONER ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT HOSPITAL DATED 10.02.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review