Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I q448I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 1801 OF 2022
Petition under Article 227 ot lhe Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the order
dated 30-1 1-2021 passed in l.A.No.6B1 of 2019 in 1.A.No.615 ot 2015 in O.S.No.03
of 2007 on the file of the Court of the Senior Civil Judge at Huzurabad.
Between:
Bathini Mogili, S/o. Gattaiah, aged about 62 years, Occupation: Agriculture,
r/o. Gopalpur Village of Elkathurthy Mandal revenue of Warangal Urban
district.
...Petitioner/Plaintiff
AND
1. Utukiuri llaiah, S/o. Narsaiah, aged about 50 years, Occupation. Agriculture
and Toddy Tapper
2. Utukiuri Rajaveery, S/o. Chandraiah, (died his L.Rs. defendants No. '10 to 16
are brought on record)
3. Masipeddi Rajaiah, S/o. Lasmaiah, aged 70 years, Occupation. Agriculture
4. Masipeddy Narasaiah, S/o. Lasmaiah (Died his L.Rs. defendants No.5 to 9
are brought on record)
the defendants No. 'l to 4 are rlo. Gopalpur Village of Elkathurthy
5. Masipeddy Kamalamma, w/o. Narasaiah, aged about 70 years, r/o- Gopalpur
Village of Elkathurthy Mandal Revenue of Karimnagar district, presently
Warangal Urban district
6. Masipeddy Sampath Rao, s/o Narasaiah, aged about 48 years, Occupation.
Teacher, U.P.S. Pangidipally, P.O. Pangidipally of Kamalapur Mandal of
Karimnagar district, presently Warangal Urban District
7. Masipeddy Srinivas Rao, S/o- Narasaiah, aged about 45 years, Occupation.
Agriculture, r/o. Gopalapur village of Elkathurthy Mandal Revenue of
Karimnagar District, presently Warangal Urban district
8. Perala Radha, w/o. Sudhakar, d/o. Masipeddy Narasaiah, aged about 43
years, Occupation. Housewife, r/o. H.No. 2-10 Sai Medical Hall and General
Stores, Hanamkonda of Warangal District
9, Masadi Rama Devi, w/o. Sampath Rao, d/o. Masipeddy Narasaiah, aged
about 37 years, Occupation. Household, r/o. Bornapally Village of Huzurabad
Mandal of Karimnagar District
10.Utkuri Venkata Swamy, s/o. Late Rajaveeru, aged about 45 years'
Occupation. Agriculture
'1
1. Utkuri Venu Gopal, s/o. Late Rajaveeru, aged aborr 38 years, Occupation.
Agriculture,
Defendants Nos. 10 and 1 1 are r/o- Gopalapur \,rill3r; r of Elkathurthy Mandal
revenue of Karimnagar District, presently Warangal Ur ran District
'12. Ravula Thirupathamma, w/o. Ramachandram (died)
't
3. Bathini Shobha, w/o. Mohan, aged about 32 years, ( rccupation. Household,
r/o. Baopet village of Elkathuthymandal of Karim r rqar distnct, presently
Warangal Urban District
14. Pendyala Srilatha, w/o. Komirelly, aged about 28 yea':, r/o. Mulkanoor village
of Bheemadevarapally mandal of Karimnagar distri t, presently Warangal
Urban District
15.Modem Sujatha, w/o. Praveen, aged about 25 years, (,r;cupation. Household,
r/o- Seethampet village of Jammikunta mandal of Karir rragar District
16.Ravula Sumalatha, d/o. Ramchandram, aged about 2 I years, r/o. Jeelugula
village of Elkathurthy mandal of Karimnagar Distr ( ., presently Warangal
Urban District.
...Re s rondents/Defendants
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circr rstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court ma1, re pleased to stay all
further proceedings in O.S.No.3 of 2O07 [Old O.S.No.17!;t 1022 on the file of ll
Additional Senior Civil Judge cum ll Addl. Assistant Sessions . udge, Hanumakondal,
pending disposal of the above C.R.P.No.1801 ot 2022 in the r ierest of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri K. Ajay Kumar
Counsel for the Respondents: Sri K. Venumadhav
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COIIRT FOR THE STATE OF TELATTGANA AT HYDERABAI)
THE HOIT'BLE JUSTICE B,R. MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CML REVISION PETITION No.1EO1 oI 2o22
DATED TIIE 2oth DAY OF JAITUARY, 2026
Between:
Bathini Mogili, S/o, Gattaiah
... PetiLioner-plaintiff
And
Utikiuri Ilaiah, S/o, Narsaiah and 15 others
... Respondents-defendants
ORDER:
1.
This Memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is filed under
Article 227 of the Conslitution of India assailing the order dated
3o.ll.2O2l passed in I.A.No.681 of 2Ol9 in LA.No.615 of 2015 in
O.S.No.3 of 2007 by the learned Senior Civil Judge at Huzurabad.
2.L Petitioner is t.I.e petitioner-plaintiff and respondents are the
respondents-defendants in I.A.No.681 of 2Ol9 in I.A.No.615 of 2015
in O.S.No.3 of 2OO7.
2.2 Notice got issued to respondent Nos. 1, 13, 14 and 16 are
refused, served on respondent Nos. 10, 1l & 15.
3.1 Petitioner-plaintiff has filed an application in I.A'No.681 of
2019 under Order VII Rule 14 (3) of CPC seeking leave of the Court
to receive thlmnifred copies of depositions of the parties who gave
evidence in C.C.No.3409 of 2OO8 on the frle of I AJMFC, Huzurabad.
./
-/
BRMR,J
CRP.No.luO 1 of 2022
3.2 It is stated in the affidavit that the petitioner plaintiff has hled
suit for specific performance of agreement of sale lated O4.O1.2006
against the respondents-defendants uide O.S.No.i tf 2OO7 which is
coming up for trial. The important documents z r : depositions of,
l)PW. 1
Nasipelli Rajeshwer Rao, dated 1O.( 3.2016; 2lPW.2
Masipeddi Srinivas Rao, dated 10.03.2016; i )PW.3-Masipeddi
Bhaskar Rao, Dated 22.O3.2O L6; 4)PW.4 Masipe c d.i Laxmi, dated
22.03.2016; 5)PW.5 Masipeddi Padma dated 31. r.3.2016; 6)PW.6
Masipeddi Manjula, dated 31.O3.2016;7lPW.7 Boir pally Thirupathi
Rao, dated 04.O4.2016; 8)PW.8 Boinpally L r ga Rao dated
04.04.2016 and 9)PW.9 D.Kamalakar Reddy, Inr; ,ector of Police,
Intelligence, Karimnagar dated 27 .04.2016 _nd the said
documents/ depositions are essential and crucial to I rove the case.
4.
Respondent Nos.3 and 5 to t have f ed th :ir counter and
contended that the evidence of the petitioner-plain:: f is closed long
back and also failed to give cogent reasons for not filing the
documents at the time of plaintiffs evidence. The sui pertains to the
year 2OO7 and the documents are of the year 2016 therefore, they
are not relevant to the case and prayed to dismiss the application.
BRMR,J
CRP.No.laOl of 2022
5.
The leamed trial Court after going through the material on
record has dismissed I.A.No.681 of 2Ol9 vide order dated 30.1 1.2O21
which is impugned in the CRP.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
6.
leamed trial Court has failed to note that the suit is hled by the
petitioner-plaintiff for specific performance of agreement of sale and
the proposed documents which are frted along with the application
goes to show that respondent No.3-defendant No.3 has admitted the
sale transaction in favour of his purchasers and subsequent
transactions, which €rre relevant and necessar5/ for effective
adjudication of the suit. The learned trial Court ought to have
allowed the I.A. as the evidence in the case is not concluded and it is
at the stage of DW. I evidence and prayed to set aside the impugned
order.
7.
Learned counsel for respondent Nos.3 and 5 to 9 submits that
the learned trial Court has properly appreciated the facts of the case
and the depositions which are frled by the petitioner-plaintiff are no
way related to the suit for specifrc performance of contract, therefore,
no interference is called for and prayed to dismiss the application-
8.
\Heard both sides and perused the record
\
BRMR,J
CRP.No.1801 of 2022
9.
Now the point for consideration is: "Whett
plaintiff has made out arry case to interfere
--r the petitioner_
with tt : order passed by
the learned trial Court".
lO. Petitioner-plaintiff has filed suit in O.S.No.O , of
the respondents-defendants seeking relief
of spec I c performance of
agreement sale dated O4.O I .2006 against
(respondents herein) by directing them
property in his favour, if they failed
2OOZ against
def : r,lants there in
to register tLe suit scheduie
to do so, the C nrrt may register
the same in his name and in alternate prayed
f rr refund of the
amount.
11.
Respondent No.l-defendalt No.l remain
Respondent No.2-defendant
ed e:c llcrrtein the suit.
No.2 has filed \,\ r tten statement
supporting the case of the petitioner-plaintiff.
defendant No.4 has hled his written statement
Il spondent No.4_
deny ng the contents
of the plaint averments, which 1S adopted by rr
spondent No.3_
defendant No.3.
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner_plaintiff dur.i rg
arguments contended that the evidence
completed and the suit is posted for
defendant$ -.
the course of
of petiti ,ner_plaintiff is
the eviden: ) of contesting
,/
BRMR,J
CRP-No.18OI of 2022
13. The learned trial Court has observed in the order that the
petitioner-plaintiff is not sure whether I'A'No'681 of 2019 is frled
in
I.A.No.615 of 2015 in O'S.No'3 of 2OO7' The said observation
of
Iearned triat Court is incorrect in view of the fact that tl.e
petitioner-
plaintiff has filed I.A.No.681 of 2Ol9 in O'S'No'3 of 2OO7 itself' But
in the counter filed by respondent Nos'3 and 5 to 9 it is mentioned
that I.A.No.68 | of 2Ol9 is frled in I'A'No'615 of 2015 in O'S'No'3
2OO7. The learned trial Court has misread the sard
of
I'A' numbers'
14. On perusal of the affidavit frled by the petitioner in I'A'No'681
of 2Ol9 only one sentence is mentioned in the affidavit
i'e'' the said
documents are essential and crucial documents to prove the
reasons are assigned by the petitioner-plaintiff how the
case' No
depositions'
which are frled along with the application, are helpful to his
case'
15. The Ieamed trial Court has observed in para No'7 of its order
that the petitioner-plaintiff has taken the certified copies of
silent and
depositions way-back ot 27 'O4 '2OL6 and having kept
the
came up with an application on 23 'O9 '2019 that too
after a period of
three (3) years. The reasons assigned by the learned
trial Court are
proper and justihed. The petitioner-plaintiff was not diligent
prosecuting his case, moreover, no reasons are assigrred
petitioner in the affrdavit tJlat in what way the depositions
to his case.
'"'-
in
by the
are helpful
BRMR,J
CRP.No.l80l of2022
16' Powei' of the High court under Arttcre 22i :f constitution
of
India is supervisory. This power is to be sparingly
t:xercised in cases
where errors are apparent on the face of recori,
occasioning grave
injustice by the court or tribunal assuming jurisdi
tion which it does
not have or exercising its jurisdiction in a peF,r rse
K.Valarmathi and Others Vs. Kumares an _
manner (See:
2O2i SCC Online SC
e8s).
17. This Court finds no perversity in tl,re orde r ; passed by
learned trial Court. There are no merits in
Petition, the same deserves no consideration
the
flt : Civil Revision
and :l o same is liable
to be dismissed.
18. Civil Revision petition is dismissed. There sha I be no order
as
to costs.
Interim order/ s if any shall stard vacate:
Miscellaneous
petition/ s sha-ll stand closed.
Sd/. MOHD. ISMAIL
EPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Senior Civil Judge at Huzurabad.
2. One CC to Sri K Ajay Kumar, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Sri K. Venumadhav, Advocate [OPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
Kam/DL
\+
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2010112026
ORDER
CRP.No.1801 of 2022
:;'jylt't "' "
)
o
c)
t i
t
DISMISSING THE CRP
G,6"N
f-w
I B ryq
r C\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review