Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010261662025
2026:GAU-AS:1742DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Review.Pet./282/2025
BASIRAN NESSA
D/O LATE ZAKIR HUSSAIN @ JAGIR, W/O OSMAN GANI, R/O VILL. NIZ
NAGAJAN, P.S. KHARUPETIA, DIST. DARRANG, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA, DEPTT. OF HOME,
NEW DELHI.
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
DEPARTMENT OF HOME
DISPUR GUWAHATI-06
3:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
DARRANG
MANGALDAI. P.O
P.S AND DIST- DARRANG
ASSAM
4:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
DARRANG
MANGALDAI
PO
PS AND DIST- DARRANG
ASSAM
5:THE FOREIGNER TRIBUNAL 3RD
DARRANG
MANGALDAI
Page No.# 2/10
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. M I HUSSAIN, MS. P AHMED,R KHA,MR. N UDDIN
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., GA, ASSAM,SC, F.T
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
ORDER
Date : Date: 09.02.2026
(A.M. Kalita, J)
Heard Ms. R. Kha, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.S. Roy,
learned CGC; Mr. G. Sarma, learned Standing Counsel for the F.T. and Border matters;
Mr. M. Islam, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. A. I. Ali, learned Standing
Counsel for the ECI; and Mr. H. K. Hazarika, learned Govt. Advocate for the State
respondent.
2.
The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner, praying for review of the
order dated 21.08.2017, passed by a Division Bench of this Court in WP(C) No.
4614/2013.
3.
The case of the petitioner is that, being aggrieved with the Judgment & Order of
the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal (3rd), Darrang, Mangaldoi, dated 21.03.2013, the
petitioner approached this Court by filing WP(C) No. 4614/2013, which was dismissed,
vide order dated 21.08.2017, affirming the aforesaid Judgment & Order dated
21.03.2013, passed in F.T.(3) Case No. 191/12. Being not satisfied by the aforesaid order
dated 21.08.2017, the petitioner filed the review petition which was registered as
Review Petition No. 184/2017, praying for review of the order dated 21.08.2017. A
Division Bench of this Court, vide it’s order dated 27.11.2017, dismissed the aforesaid
review petition. Thereafter, the petitioner approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court by
Page No.# 3/10
way of filing petition being Special Leave to appeal (C) No.(s) 7350/2018, challenging
the order dated 27.11.2017, passed in the aforesaid Review Petition No. 184/2017. When
the Special Leave to Appeal came up for hearing on 17.01.2020, the learned counsel for
the petitioner made a prayer for withdrawal of the same with a liberty to file a fresh
review petition before this Court and to produce one NRC document. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court granted the prayer of the petitioner and dismissed the Special Leave
Petition as withdrawn with the liberty to file a fresh review petition, vide it’s order dated
17.01.2020. Accordingly, the instant review petition has been filed by the petitioner
before this Court for review of the order dated 21.08.2017.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner approached the
Hon’ble Supreme Court by filing the Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.(s) 7350/2018,
challenging the order dated 27.11.2017, passed in review petition No. 184/2017.
However, during the pendency of the said Special Leave to Appeal, the Final NRC in
Assam has been published, wherein the names of the mother and brother of the
petitioner were included. That being an additional document, which was neither before
the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal nor before the Gauhati High Court, the petitioner
prayed for withdrawal for the said Special Leave to Appeal and the same was allowed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, vide it’s order dated 17.01.2020 with a liberty to file a fresh
review petition before this Court. He submits that there are sufficient documents to
prove the petitioner’s Indian citizenship, which were overlooked by the learned Tribunal
as well as by this Court while rendering the respective orders. Therefore, the learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that this Court may review the Judgment & Order
dated 21.08.2017, passed in WP(C) No. 4614/2013 and also set aside the impugned
Judgment & Order dated 21.03.2023 passed in F.T. (3) Case No. 191/12, passed by the
learned Foreigners’ Tribunal (3rd), Darrang, Mangaldoi and in alternative, the case may
be remanded back to the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal for a fresh decision allowing the
petitioner to adduce further evidence in the case.
Page No.# 4/10
5.
On the other hand, Mr. G. Sarma, learned Standing Counsel, F.T. & Border
matters, submits that the instant review petition has been filed after a long delay of about
6(six) years of passing of the order by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid
Special Leave to Appeal. He submits that there is no proper and convincing explanation
of the delay has been made by the petitioner in filing the instant review petition. Though
the ground of delay has been stated to be the petitioner’s illiteracy coupled with financial
problem, she could not approach this Court immediately after passing of the order by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court. He submits that the same is totally irrelevant for such a long
delay. Therefore, the learned Standing Counsel submits that this case is hopelessly
barred by the principle of delay and laches. In this connection, the learned Standing
Counsel has referred to the case of Azmat Ali @ Amzad Ali vs. Union of India & Ors.,
reported in 2018 (4) GLT 623, wherein this Court has held as under: “15. It is more than three decades that the issue of influx of foreign nationals has
been in public domain in the state of Assam and has engaged the attention of the
people. Interest of the State is of paramount importance in that unabated influx has
the potential to affect the integrity and sovereignty of the Country. Citizenship of a
person, no doubt, is a very valuable right and should be zealously guarded. There
is no gainsaying the fact that a person who is alleged to be foreigner must given
due and reasonable opportunity to establish that he is a citizen of India. However,
if a person does not take steps for safeguarding his interest, he does so at his own
risk and peril as grant of opportunity cannot be an endless exercise. Right to a fair
hearing or principles of natural justice cannot be permitted to a farcical situation
and to be an engine to defeating the very object of identification and deportation of
foreigners.”
6.
The learned Standing Counsel submits that the NRC document which has been
annexed to the instant review petition, cannot be taken into account or considered at this
stage, as the same is not an admissible document as the Final NRC is yet to be
Page No.# 5/10
adopted/accepted by the Registrar General of Citizens Registration to be an admissible
piece of document for citizenship. In view of the aforesaid submissions, the learned
Standing Counsel submits that the instant review petition, having no merit, may be
dismissed at once.
7.
We have heard the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing for the
respective parties and also gone through the records of the learned Foreigners’ Tribunal.
8.
It is seen that the instant review petition has been filed nearly after 6 years of
passing of the order dated 17.01.2020, by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Special
Leave to Appeal, whereby liberty was granted to the petitioner to file a fresh review
petition before this Court and to produce the NRC document. However, it is seen from
the review petition that the petitioner has not explained with any convincing grounds for
the delay in filing the instant review petition after more than 6 years. We have seen that
the ground taken for the inordinate delay in filing of the instant review petition is that
she is a poor and illiterate lady and due to financial problem, she could not approach this
Court immediately after passing of the order by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the
delay occurred was not intentional. However, in our considered view, usually such a
general ground is not acceptable for condoning such a huge delay without any genuine
grounds. However, taking into account of the fact that right of citizenship of the
petitioner is involved, we have decided to examine other materials brought on record in
the review petition for ends of justice.
9.
In the instant case, it is seen that the petitioner had, on earlier occasion, filed a
review petition i.e., Review Petition No. 184/2017 against the Judgment & Order dated
21.08.2017, passed by a Division Bench in WP(C) No. 4614/2013, which was dismissed
by the aforesaid Division Bench, vide it’s order dated 27.11.2017. The said order dated
27.11.2017 was challenged by the petitioner before the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
however, the aforesaid Special Leave to Appeal was withdrawn and the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had given liberty to file a fresh review petition before this Court, vide
Page No.# 6/10
it’s order dated 17.01.2020.
10.
In the instant review petition, the petitioner has stated that while dismissing the
WP(C) No. 4614/2013, this Court has relied on the age discrepancy of one Muksed,
appearing in the 1965 voters’ list as well as in the 1989 voters’ list. It is stated that
Muksed was 21 years of age in 1965 and 29 years of age in 1989, whereas he should
have been 45 years of age in the year 1989. It is stated that it has been found that the age
of said Muksed was 49 years in 1989 voters’ list which has been given to the petitioner
by the Government Gaonburha. The petitioner applied for a certified copy of the voters’
list of 1989, as in the earlier certified copy, there was a mistake of age, i.e., 29 years in
place of 49 years. It is also stated that throughout the entire country, particularly, in the
State of Assam, some common mistakes in age are found almost everywhere due to
typographical mistakes. Therefore, such variation in the voters’ list cannot be a ground
to doubt one’s citizenship. It is also contended that the petitioner has got her voters’ list
from the respective Gaonburhas and the subsequent NRC document of her mother and
brother, to connect well with her parents, grandparents and the husband and in-laws.
Therefore, it is contended that unless these documents are properly considered, the
petitioner shall not get real justice.
11.
It is a settled principle of law that inordinate delay needs to be explained by the
petitioner while filing a petition and the same cannot be easily ignored, if there is no
genuine reason for such delay is explained by the petitioner.
12.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in catena of judgments has held that the High Court
may refuse to exercise its extra-ordinary jurisdiction if there is negligence or omission
on the part of the petitioner to assert his right.
13.
We have perused the grounds taken by the petitioner in the Review Petition No.
184/2017. It is seen that the grounds taken earlier in it’s review petition are almost the
same grounds, which have been taken by the petitioner in the instant review petition.
Page No.# 7/10
14.
As mentioned earlier, the aforesaid review petition i.e., Review Petition No.
184/2017 was dismissed by this Court, vide a detailed order dated 27.11.2017, wherein
the grounds taken were discussed and considered by the Division Bench of this Court in
it’s earlier order. The operative part of the aforesaid order dated 27.11.2017 is extracted
herein below: “Before us, it is contended that in Ext.1, age of Moksed All, elder brother of
petitioner,
was 29 years whereas it should have been 49 years. In support of his
contention, petitioner has placed reliance on an unverified/unauthenticated extract of
voters list of Kalalgaon constituency for the year 1989 (page 32 of the Review Petition)
to show age of Moksed All as 49 years. Firstly, on the basis of an
uncertified/unauthenticated document, an exhibited document cannot be discarded.
Secondly, in the review petition, petitioner is relying on such a document for reviewing
the order passed by the writ Court. As noticed by the writ Court, petitioner neither
mentioned in the written statement nor in her evidence that she had a brother by the
name of Moksed Ali.
On a query by the Court, Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel for the review petitioner,
submits that he has obtained this document from the village Gaonburah. We have
noticed that Gaonburah did not depose before the Tribunal and nobody has stated
before the Tribunal that petitioner had an elder brother by the name of Moksed Ali. That
apart, most amusing part of this document at page 32 is that Moksed All is shown as son
of Mahar Ali. On the other hand, in Ext.1, petitioner had shown that he was the son of
Mahar. Whether Mahar Ali and Mahar is one and the same person we do not know. But
certainly, this aspect cannot be gone into in review jurisdiction.
Petitioner was afforded all opportunities and after full-length hearing, writ petition was
decided. The concluded writ petition cannot be heard again on such frivolous plea taken
by the review petitioner.
There is no merit in the review petition, which is accordingly dismissed.”
Page No.# 8/10
15.
A careful perusal of the Review Petition No. 184/2017, it is seen that the
documents filed in the aforesaid review petition are identical and same with the
documents that have been filed in the instant review petition, except, one document i.e.,
NRC results for all NRC applicants as per Draft NRC & Supplementary List of
Inclusions and Exclusion (Final NRC). Therefore, since the Division Bench of this Court
has already reviewed and considered all the documents along with the contents and
grounds taken by the petitioner in her earlier review petition, i.e. Review Petition No.
184/2017, which was dismissed by the Division Bench after due consideration, vide the
order dated 27.11.2017, we do not find any reason to disagree with the aforesaid order
dated 27.11.2017, because, the petitioner has not been able to show that the order dated
21.08.2017, passed by this Court suffers from any error apparent of the face of the
record. The petitioner has not been able to establish that there was a discovery of new
and important matter of evidence, which, after the exercise of due diligence was not
within the knowledge and that the new documents are not for filing up the lacuna. There
is also no other reason which would invite a review of the said order. As far as the
document relating to Final NRC is concerned, though there is a statement at Paragraph3(xv) that Final NRC in the State of Assam has been published, wherein the names of
the mother and brother of the petitioner have been included, no other details could be
found in the review petition. Though the petitioner has referred to the NRC document, it
could not be made out as to who are persons, the petitioner has referred to as her mother
and brother respectively, as the same has not been detailed by the petitioner in her
statements made in the review petition.
16.
Be that as it may, this is an admitted position that the Final NRC, though it was
published, the same is yet to be accepted by the Registrar General of Citizens
Registration, to provide validity to the aforesaid document. Therefore, minus the
aforesaid acceptance, the document cannot be taken into consideration for deciding
someone’s citizenship, though his/her name might have appeared in the Final NRC. In
Page No.# 9/10
this connection, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Rofiqul Hoque vs. Union of
India & Ors., reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1160, held that once a Foreigners’
Tribunal holds a person as foreigner, his name could not have been included in the NRC.
Paragraph-27 of the aforesaid case being relevant is extracted herein below: “27. In view of the decision of this Court in Abdul Kuddus (supra), firstly, consequent to
the declaration by the Tribunal that appellant is a foreigner, the name of the appellant
could not have been included in the draft NRC and, secondly, even if it has been included,
it would not annul the declaration made by the Tribunal.”
17.
In another case, i.e., Md. Siraj Ali @ Chiraj Ali and 2 Ors., vs. Union of India
& Ors., dated 15.12.2024, in (Review Petition No. 184/2019), this Court has held as
follows: “9. The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has claimed that the final NRC
had been published on 31.08.2019 and in view of the observations made by the
Apex Court in Adbul Kuddus (supra), the claim of the petitioners should be reexamined as their relatives had been included in the final NRC. In this regard, it
may be seen that the publication of the supplementary list of NRC after examination
of claims and objections under paragraph No. 6 (3) of the Schedule under Rule 4A(4) of the Rules of 2003 is to be done by the local Registrar of Citizens
Registration. Thereafter, the Registrar General of Citizens Registration is required
to publish the final National Register of Indian Citizens in the State of Assam. There
are no materials placed before us to show that the Registrar General of Citizens
Registration has accepted the publication of supplementary list by the local
Registrar and published the final list. In the absence of such exercise, the final
NRC, which is relied upon by the petitioners cannot be accepted to be a ground for
reviewing the Judgment & Order dated 31.01.2018 passed by this Court. Further,
as regards the case of Abdul Kuddus (supra), relied upon by the petitioners, it may
be seen that the question of the person aggrieved having liberty to invoke writ
Page No.# 10/10
jurisdiction or even review jurisdiction of the High Court as well as the Supreme
Court would arise when there are contradictory decisions/opinions rendered by the
Foreigners Tribunal in cases of near family members. In the present case, no two
(2) contradictory decisions or opinions in respect of family members of the
petitioners have been produced before us to attract invocation of review
jurisdiction. Therefore, the case relied upon by the petitioners cannot render them
any assistance.”
18.
Coming to the present case, it is seen from what has been projected by the
petitioner, he failed to make out any case so as to persuade this Court to invoke its
review jurisdiction in terms of settled principles of law. Therefore, upon due
consideration of the projection made by the petitioner in it’s entirety, we do not find any
ground to recall the Judgment & Order dated 21.08.2017.
19.
In view of the above discussions made, we have come to the considered view that
the instant review petition does not have any merit to interfere with the Judgment &
Order dated 21.08.2017, passed in WP(C) No. 4614/2013.
20.
Accordingly, the instant review petition stands dismissed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review