Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!"
%
!
&
!
&
"
##
!
'
(
$%
&
% $
!
"
##
$%
##
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
%
%
#
%)
#!
#
##
!
(
$%
'
##
##
%$
*&
!
"
+
##
$%
##
!
"
'
%
$
##
$% *
'$(
-2-
'
%$
(
*
#!
"
##
$% *
,
#!
'
'
#
#
#
***
&
!
'
#
** &
#
!
# !
'
#
'
$
%
'
*&
!
#
- .
'
* *&(
#
#
!
#
$% *
#
"
!
##
$% *
-3-
(
!
"
##
$% *
$
!
/
# !
"
'
#
##
$% *
)
+
!
!
#
# !
" /#
'
!
*
#
$% *
!
!
/
# !
"
'
#
##
$% *
,
'
#
#!
(0
)
#
# &&(
#
#
! #
+
#
#
"
&&
"
&) *
#
2$
#
!
#
!
#
#
#
#
#
)
#
&*&
#
#
"
#
!
'
'
#
#
+
#
#
+
-4-
!
#
#
#
!
# )
$
#
#
#
#
#
)
'
!
#
#
#
#
!
'
#
#
#
#
#
#
4567 8456947 :2;9<48 =26 >?4 @4>A>A2946<
77A>A2958
2B469C49>
7B2:5>4 =26 64<@29749>
597 8456947 :2;9<48 =26 :5B45>26 64<@29749>
&
8456947
2<
2)
?A< @4>A>A29 A< =A847 <44DA9E >?4 =2882FA9E
648A4=<
!
"
(
$ #
+
#$
%
&
'
!
>2 (
*
)
!
"
#!+ !
-5-
!
%
!
"
#,+ ,
,
-
&
+
%
'
(
$ #
)
!
*
.
+
/
?4 :5<4 2= >?4 @4>A>A2946< A< >?5> 64<@29749>
2)
2:A4>G F5< 64EA<>4647 ;9746 >?4 @62BA<A29< 2= >?4
'5695>5D5
:>.
2 2@465>AB4
> ?5< 5
595EA9E
595EA9E
2:A4>G
:>
) ) =26 <?26> ->?4
2CCA>>44 2=
2CCA>>44 2= 64<@29749>
H4 4I@A647 A9 >?4 G456 &*&
&
2)
& C4CH46<
2:A4>G :5C4 >2
;6<;59> >2 F?A:? >?4
84:>A29
;>?26A>G 92>A=A47 >?4 484:>A29< >2 64<@29749>
<2:A4>G
5@@2A9>47
84:>A29
==A:46 >2 :297;:> 484:>A29<
484:>A29<
?4
==A:46 5< F488 5<
2)
4>;69A9E
9 >?4 @62:4<< 2= :297;:>A9E
>?4 B2>46< 8A<> :5C4 >2 H4 @64@5647
?4
@4>A>A2946< F464 <?2:D47 >2 <44 >?5> >?4A6 95C4< F464 92>
-6-
=2;97 A9 >?4 48AEAH84 8A<> >2 :29>4<> 597 B2>4 A9 >?4 49<;A9E
484:>A29< <:?47;847 29
%
**
&*& >2
% *& &*&
456947 :2;9<48 =26 >?4 @4>A>A2946< :29>497<
>?5> >?464 564 >2>58
2:A4>G
& :29<>A>;49:A4< 2= 64<@29749>
;> 2= F?A:?
2)
:29<>A>;49:A4< 564 :85<<A=A47 5<
H2662F463<
:29<>A>;49:G
:29<>A>;49:G
456947 :2;9<48 =26 >?4 @4>A>A2946< :29>497<
>?5> 2;> 2=
*
B2>46<
C4CH46<
*
929 H2662F463<
>?464 564 298G
48AEAH84
?4 64<@29749>< FA>?2;> =2882FA9E 7;4 @62:4<< 597
@62:47;64
=26
@64@565>A29
:29>4C@85>47 ;9746 >?4
2=
>?4
2 2@465>AB4
B2>46<3
2:A4>A4<
8A<>
5<
:> 597 >?4
;84< 597 H4?A97 >?4 H5:D 2= 588 >?4 C4CH46< F?2 564
48AEAH84 >2 :29>4<> 597 :5<> >?4A6 B2>4<
?5B4 H449
748AH465>48G C574 A948AEAH84 FA>? C585=A74 A9>49>A29< 597
;8>46A26 C2>AB4 597 ?5BA9E 92> A9:8;747 <4B4658 @4>A>A2946<
A9 >?4 B2>46<3 8A<> 597 74<:6AHA9E >?4C 5< A948AEAH84
@;H8A<?47 :5849756 2= 4B49>< 29 &) *
&*&
?4 75>4 =26
:2CC49:4C49> 2= =A8A9E 2= 92CA95>A29 F5< 29
5<> 75>4 =26 =A8A9E 2= >?4 92CA95>A29 29 *
**
*& &*&
&*&
?4
-7-
B46A=A:5>A29 =26 =A8A9E 2= >?4 92CA95>A29 @5@46< A< 29
*( *& &*&
297;:>A9E
2=
484:>A29
A<
<:?47;847
% *& &*& 597 >?4 74:8565>A29 2= 64<;8> A< 29 % *& &*&
>
A<
>?4
B4?4C49>
:2;9<48 >?5> 64<@29749>
*
C4CH46<
2)
92>A:4
A<
7A7 92> :297;:> 59G
A<<;47
>2
2=
>?4
494658
44>A9E 597 2;> 2=
*
C4CH46<
A9:8;7A9E
C4CH46< 2= >?4
:29>4<> 597 :5<> >?4A6 B2>4<
>?4
494658
C4CH46< 64<@29749>
2:A4>G @;H8A<?47 A948AEAH84 B2>46< 8A<> 2=
C5DA9E 298G
27G
> A< 58<2 :29>49747 >?5>
@4>A>A2946< ?464A9 FA>? 64E567 >2 :297;:>A9E 2= >?4
27G
8456947
2:A4>G F?A:? :29<A<>< 2=
44>A9E =26 >?4 @5<> =AB4 G456<
:29>49>A29
2)
&(& >?464HG
2:A4>G >2 H4 48AEAH84 >2
?4 @64@565>A29 2= >?4 B2>46<
8A<> F5< @;H8A<?47 >?464=264 A9 BA4F 2= 74:856A9E 298G
C4CH46< 5< 48AEAH84 597 74:856A9E
A948AEAH84
>?4 64<@29749>
@62BA<A29< 2=
2:A4>A4<
;84<
;84
# &
&(& C4CH46< >2 H4
2 ) ?5< :84568G BA285>47 >?4
2= >?4 '5695>5D5
) * =26 <?26> ->?4
;84<.
2 2@465>AB4
-8-
456947 :2;9<48 =;6>?46
:29>497< >?5> >?4
49>A64 @62:4<< 597 @62:47;64 =2882F47 A9 59 5>>4C@> >2
<5H2>5E4 >?4 484:>A29< A< 5 :8456 5H;<4 2= >?4 74C2:65>A:
@62:4<< 2= :297;:>A9E 484:>A29< 597 >?4 @;H8A:5>A29 2=
B2>46< 8A<> 2= 298G
C4CH46< 2;> 2=
*
A< 56HA>656G
A884E58 597 5@@5649>8G =5B2;6A>A<C <?2F9 >2 @56>A:;856
:597A75>4< FA>? C585 =A74 597 ;8>46A26 C2>AB4
:29>49747 >?5>
> A< =;6>?46
&(& C4CH46< F?2 564 C574 A948AEAH84 A<
56HA>656G 597 FA>?2;> =2882FA9E 7;4 @62:4<< 2= 85F 5< 92
92>A:4< 564 <46B47
> A< 58<2 :29>49747 HG 8456947 :2;9<48
>?5> >?4 298G 645<29 5<<AE947 =26 749GA9E >?4 B2>A9E 6AE?><
>2 >?4 @4>A>A2946< ?464A9 A< 29 5::2;9> 2= >?4 @4>A>A2946<
92> 5>>497A9E >F2
494658
27G
>?4 <46BA:4< 2= >?4 64<@29749>
44>A9E< 597 92> ;>A8A<A9E
2)
2:A4>G
?464=264
8456947 :2;9<48 :29>497< >?5> ;984<< >?4 C4CH46< 564
A9>AC5>47 5H2;> >?4
494658
27G
4I@4:>47 >2 5>>497 >?4 C44>A9E
44>A9E >?4G :5992> H4
< <>5>47 4568A46 A> A< >?4
E6A4B59:4 >?5> @46<2958 92>A:4< ?5B4 92> H449 A<<;47 >2
-9-
45:? 2= >?4<4 @4>A>A2946< 597 >?4G ?5B4 H449 7A<J;58A=A47
F?A:? A< 8A5H84 >2 H4 J;5<?47
(
# &
?464 A< 5 BA285>A29 2= >?4 @62BA<A29< 2=
2= >?4
;84< 597 >?464=264 >?4 49>A64 @62:4<<
=2882F47 HG 64<@29749>
597 >?4
$
;84
;84< 2= >?4
2)
2:A4>G A< :29>656G >2 >?4
2 2@465>AB4
9 >?4<4 E62;97<
:>
2:A4>G
8456947 :2;9<48 :29>497<
>?5> >?4 5:>A29 2= >?4 64<@29749>< A< 59 5H;<4 2= @62:4<<
2= 85F
:84568G C574 FA>? 59 A9>49> >2 <5H2>5E4 >?4
484:>A29< 298G >2 =5B2;6 5 =4F 2= >?4A6 2F9 F?AC< 597
=59:A4<
49:4 59G <;:? 5>>4C@> >2 92> :297;:> 484:>A29<
597 =2882FA9E ;974C2:65>A: @62:4<< :2;87 H4 A9>46=4647 HG
>?A<
2;6> ;9746
2= 97A5
6>A:84< &&
597 &&( 2= >?4
29<>A>;>A29
49:4 ?4 <44D< >2 5882F >?A< @4>A>A29 597 J;5<?
>?4 :5849756 2= 4B49>< 597 7A64:> =64<? 92>A=A:5>A29 2= >?4
:5849756 2= 4B49>< HG A<<;A9E @62@46 92>A:4 >2 >?4
@4>A>A2946< 597 2>?46<
- 10 -
)
2)
.
8456947 :2;9<48 =26 64<@29749>
2:A4>G
<;HCA><
>?5>
>?464
A<
@46B46<A>G A9 >?4 26746 @5<<47 HG >?4
A884E58A>G
2:A4>G 5< >?4
@62:4<< 597 @62:47;64 F5< =2882F47 5> >?4 >AC4 2=
A<<;59:4 2= :5849756 2= 4B49><
> A< >2>588G 749A47 HG >?4
8456947 :2;9<48 =26 64<@29749>
2)
F5< A<<;47
2:A4>G >?5> 92 92>A:4
9 =5:> ?4 :29>497< >?5> >?A< A< 5 C5>>46 2=
=5:> F?A:? ?5< >2 H4 74:A747 A9 >?4 @62@46 =26;C 597 92>
H4=264 >?A<
2;6> ;9746
6>A:84< &&
597 &&( 2= >?4
29<>A>;>A29 2= 97A5
*
4 =;6>?46 :29>497< >?5> @6AC56A8G >?A< @4>A>A29
A< 92> C5A9>5A95H84 5< @4>A>A2946< F?2 564 <44DA9E 5 648A4=
;9746 >?4 F6A> K;6A<7A:>A29 29 >?4 E62;97 >?5> 92>A:4< F464
92> <46B47 FA88 ?5B4 >2 H4 @6AC56A8G @62B47 >?5> 92 92>A:4<
F464 A<<;47 597 A> A< =26 >?4 64<@29749>< >2 @62B4 597
<?2F >?5> 92>A:4< F464 A<<;47 A9 5::26759:4 FA>? >?4
597 >?4
;84< 2= >?4
22@465>AB4
:>
2:A4>A4< 597 F?4>?46
>?464 A< 5 @56>A:A@5>A29 A9 >?4 C44>A9E 597 F?4>?46 >?4G
F464 5H<49>
88 >?4<4 5<@4:>< FA88 ?5B4 >2 H4 74:A747 A9
- 11 -
59 5@@62@6A5>4 =26;C 597 92> H4=264 >?A<
6>A:84< &&
597 &&( 2= >?4
2;6> ;9746
29<>A>;>A29 2= 97A5
456947
:2;9<48 =;6>?46 :29>497< >?5> 59G <;:? 7A<@;>4 >?5> 2::;6<
;9746 >?4
2 2@465>AB4
2:A4>A4<
:> FA>? 64E567 >2 >?4
484:>A29 @62:4<< :297;:>A9E 2= 484:>A29< 597 >?4 @62:4<<
=2882F47 A< 5C495H84 >2 5 7A<@;>4 ;9746
:>
4:>A29 (* 2= >?4
>?4 @56>A4< F2;87 ?5B4 >2 H4 6484E5>47 >2 >?4
5@@62@6A5>4 5;>?26A>G >2 57K;7A:5>4 59G <;:? J;4<>A29< 2=
=5:> F?A:? 564 5EA>5>47 HG >?4 @4>A>A2946<
9 >?4 @64<49> :5<4
A> A< :29>49747 >?5> >?4
@4>A>A2946< ?5B4 <@4:A=A:588G 5884E47 >?5> 92 92>A:4< F464
A<<;470 ?2F4B46 >?4 <5A7 5884E5>A29 A< 92> 57CA>>47 597 A<
:5>4E26A:588G 749A47 HG 64<@29749>
2)
?2;E? 8456947
:2;9<48 =26 >?4 @4>A>A2946< ?5< @85:47 648A59:4 29 >?4
26746< @5<<47 HG 5
2 267A95>4
49:? 2= >?A<
2;6>
8456947 :2;9<48 =26 >?4 64<@29749>< ?5< :29>62B46>47 >?4
<5C4 :29>497A9E >?5> A9 >?4 <5A7 26746 >?4 J;4<>A29 2=
K;6A<7A:>A29 >2 C5A9>5A9 >?4 @64<49> F6A> @4>A>A29 F5<
94A>?46 65A<47 926 :29<A74647
?464=264
A> :5992> H4
- 12 -
>645>47 5< HA97A9E @64:4749> @56>A:;8568G A9 BA4F 2= >?4
<;H<4J;49> 26746< @5<<47 HG >?A<
&
2;6> 29 >?4 A<<;4
456947 :2;9<48 =26 64<@29749>
>?4 26746< 2= >?A<
2 ) 648A4< 29
2;6> A9 >?4 :5<4 2=
!
2 &*% *)
&* $
7A<@2<47 2= 29
*
:2994:>47
./
7A<@2<47 2= 29 &% *
>?4 :5<4 2= 1
C5>>46<
&*&*0 A9 >?4 :5<4 2= " #
(*&'+,- A9 >?4 :5<4 2=
$%&%'( )
A9
2 &)* % &*&
&*&% 597 >?4 26746 2= >?A<
2;6> A9
"
$2 (%&%*( )
(++&,
5BA9E ?4567 8456947 :2;9<48 =26 >?4 @4>A>A2946<
597 8456947
77A>A2958
:2;9<48 =26 64<@29749>
:29<A7465>A29
A<
2B469C49>
2)
F?4>?46
C5A9>5A95H84 H4=264 >?A<
7B2:5>4 597 8456947
>?4 @2A9> >?5> 56A<4< =26
>?4
@64<49>
@4>A>A29
A<
2;6> A9 BA4F 2= >?4 =5:> >?5> >?4
- 13 -
@4>A>A2946<
J;4<>A29A9E
>?4
:5849756
2=
4B49><
@;6<;59> >2 A<<;59:4 29 >?4 E62;97 >?5> 92 @62@46 92>A:4
F5< A<<;47 >2 >?4 @4>A>A2946< F?2 564 C4CH46< 2=
64<@29749>
%
2)
2:A4>G
@@5649>8G >?464 A< 92 7A<@;>4 FA>? 64E567 >2
>?4 =5:> >?5> >?4 @4>A>A2946< 564 C4CH46< 2= 64<@29749>
2 )L 2:A4>G
2F4B46 >?4A6 95C4< ?5B4 H449 A9:8;747 A9
>?4 8A<> 2= A948AEAH84 B2>46< @;H8A<?47 HG 64<@29749>
@6A26 >2 >?4 A<<;59:4 2= >?4 :5849756 2= 4B49><
<5A7 8A<>
2)
< @46 >?4
&(& C4CH46< ?5B4 H449 74:85647 A948AEAH84
;> 2= 5 >2>58 C4CH46<?A@ 2=
2:A4>G 298G
*
C4CH46< A9 >?4
C4CH46< ?5B4 H449 <?2F9 5< 48AEAH84 >2
:29>4<> 597 >2 :5<> >?4A6 B2>4<
?4
2= " #
2 267A95>4
<;@65
49:? 2= >?A<
2;6> A9 >?4 :5<4
5> @565E65@? ) ?57 59 2::5<A29 >2
7458 FA>? <ACA856 A<<;4 597 648GA9E ;@29 >?4 K;7EC49> A9
>?4
:5<4
2=
)
?487 5< ;9746
!
$
('
& )$$
- 14 -
M)
@4I
2;6>
A9
>?4
:5<4
2=
B<
<;@65 64=466A9E >2 A><
B56A2;< 4568A46 /
5> @565E65@?<
& ?5< <;CC47 ;@ 5< ;9746
$
)
!
$
!
(
$
,
8#
+ 3
+
+
- 15 -
(
/
!
!
5 )
/
+
(
$
/
#
/
"
:
+
+ /
+
+
(
/
- 16 -
;
$
!
+
+
$
(
"
%
"
.
.
*& 7
+
<
+
+
+
/
)
$
/
==0
+
;
- 17 -
"""""
/
$
*
5#>
'$) *
#
+
?
@
;
!
"
#,
;
!
"
#$
;
"
@
; 6
+
/
+
$
*
5#>
'$) *
#
+
"
A
$
#
/
*
5#>
'$) *
+
- 18 -
+
?4
2 267A95>4
49:? 2= >?A<
2;6> F?A84
74:A7A9E >?4 <ACA856 C5>>46 7458> FA>? A9 74>5A8 FA>? 64E567
>2 >?4 @62:4<< 597 @62:47;64 2= :297;:>A9E 2= 484:>A29<
597 >?4 @62BA<A29< 2=
;84
# 2= >?4
;84< 5> @565E65@?
9;CH46 &* 597 & ?487 5< ;9746
A
+
%
!
/
+
1"
+
$
+
+
#
+
B
*
C
5#>
'$) *
C
C 6
+
- 19 -
!
$
+
)
@
'$) ! +
;
/
(
?4645=>46 648GA9E ;@29 >?4 26746 A9 >?4 :5<4 2=
.
A9 1
2 &)&(
&*& 5> @565E65@?
& ?487 5< ;9746
"
D
$
!
$
$
"
'
+
'
(
+
)
$ #
)
?
@ 3
! +
- 20 -
$
9 :29:8;<A29
>?4
2 267A95>4
49:? 2= >?A<
2;6> 7A<CA<<47 >?4 F6A> @4>A>A29 ?287A9E >?5> >?464 F5< 92
BA285>A29 2=
;84
#
H 2= >?4
;84<
> A< =;6>?46 <449
>?5> A9 >?4 :5<4 2=
<;@65
2 267A95>4
49:? 2= >?A<
2;6> 5E5A9 ?57 >?4 2::5<A29 29 59 4568A46 2::5<A29 7458>
FA>? >?4 J;4<>A29 2= >?4 :29<>A>;>A2958 6AE?> >2 =26C 5
<2:A4>G 597 F?4>?46 A> F2;87 H4 5 =;975C49>58 6AE?> >2
B2>4 F?A:? F5< ?487 >2 H4 =56 7A==4649> 597 ?487 >2 H4 92>
:5992> H4 :2;9>4959:47 597 >?4 :29<>A>;>A2958 B58A7A>G 2=
4:>A29 &* & 5 AB 2= >?4
:> :5C4 >2 H4 94E5>47
> 58<2
7458> FA>? >?4 58>4695>AB4 64C47G C574 5B5A85H84 ;9746
>?4 <>5>;>4 >2 H4 A9B2D47
)
/
?A<
2;6> A9 592>?46 26746 A9 >?4 :5<4 2=
.
$4 " %&%+
1" 56&5, 648A47 ;@29 >?4<4 B46G <5C4
26746< 597 :5C4 >2 >?4 :29:8;<A29 >?5> F?49 >?464 A< 59
58>4695>AB4 4==A:5:A2;< 64C47G @62BA747 ;9746 >?4 <>5>;>4
>?4 <5C4 F2;87 ?5B4 >2 H4 A9B2D47 ;984<< >?464 A<
- 21 -
4I>65267A956G :A6:;C<>59:4< F?A:? 2= :2;6<4
>?4
2;6>
FA88 ?5B4 >2 A9>46=464 A= 5 B58A7 E62;97 597 :5<4 A< C574
2;>
&*
9 >?4 @64<49> :5<4 29 ?597 >?4 4I>65267A956G
:A6:;C<>59:4< H62;E?> H4=264 >?A<
2;6> HG >?4 @4>A>A2946<
A< >?5> 2;> 2=
298G
*
C4CH46<
74:85647 >2 H4 48AEAH84 597
H4 A948AEAH84
C4CH46< 564
&(& C4CH46< 564 74:85647 >2
5G H4 >?4 B28;C4 <?2F< 856E4 9;CH46< 597
298G B46G CA926 >2 H4 48AEAH84 >2 H4 :5<>A9E B2>4 597
:29>4<>A9E H;> >?5> 58294 FA88 92> EAB4 >?4 844F5G =26 >?4
@4>A>A2946< >2 5@@625:? >?A<
K;6A<7A:>A29 ;9746
2= 97A5
> A<
6>A:84< &&
2;6> >2 A9B2D4 >?4 F6A>
597 &&( 2= >?4
29<>A>;>A29
A9 >?4 :5<4< 2= 484:>A29< 29:4 >?4
:5849756 2= 4B49>< 564 A<<;47 >?4 484:>A29 @62:4<< <?2;87
92> H4 A9>46=4647 26 A9>46K4:>47 HG >?4
2;6>< 597 A= 59G
@56>G A< 5EE6A4B47 =26 59G 645<29 F?5><24B46 ?4 ?5< 5
8AH46>G >2 :?58849E4 >?4 484:>A29< A9 5 C59946 D92F9 >2
85F
- 22 -
&
?4 26746< 64=46647 ?464A9 5H2B4 597 >?464 564
<4B4658 2>?46 K;7EC49>< 2= >?4
@4I
2;6> 597 >?A<
2;6>
F?A:? ?5B4 :29<A<>49>8G ?487 >?5> 29:4 >?4 484:>A29
92>A=A:5>A29 A< A<<;47 >?4 @62:4<< 2= 484:>A29 H4EA9< 597
2;6>< <?2;87 E4946588G 92> A9>46=464 26 A9>46K4:> 597 A9
:5<4 2= 59G <;:? A9>46K4:>A29 HG E659>A9E 59G A9>46AC 26746
A9 >?4 484:>A29 @62:4<< 597 F?A84 74:A7A9E >?4 C5A9
C5>>46
A= >?4
2;6> F464 >2 7A<CA<< >?4 @4>A>A29
>?4
484:>A29 @62:4<< <?2;87 :2CC49:4 =62C >?4 @46A27 F?49 A>
F5< A9>46K4:>47 26 A9>466;@>47 597 92> C5D4 >?4 484:>A29
@62:4<< >2 H4EA9 588 2B46 5E5A9
&&
9 >?4 @64<49> :5<4 29 ?597 >?4 :5849756 2=
4B49>< 564 586457G @;H8A<?47 F?A:? A< J;4<>A2947 5829E
FA>? >?4 8A<> 2= 48AEAH84 B2>46< 8A<> 5< B46G CA9;>4 9;CH46
2= C4CH46< 564 48AEAH84 >2 :29>4<> 597 :5<> >?4A6 B2>4<
2>?A9E @64B49>47 >?4 @4>A>A2946< =62C 65A<A9E 5 7A<@;>4
H4=264 >?4
4EA<>656 2=
4:>A29 (* 2= >?4
2 2@465>AB4
2:A4>A4< ;9746
:> 5< >?5> A< >?4 64C47G @62BA747 HG
>?4 <>5>;>4 F?A:? :2;87 ?5B4 H449 5B5A847 65>?46 >?59
- 23 -
5@@625:?A9E >?A<
7294 >?A<
2;6>
< >?4 <5C4 ?5BA9E 92> H449
2;6> A< 92> A9:8A947 >2 5::4@> >?4 B46<A29 2=
>?464 H4A9E 59 4I>65267A956G 597 4I:4@>A2958 :5<4 C574
2;> HG >?4 @4>A>A2946< >2 49>46>5A9 >?A< @4>A>A29
&
?464=264
>?A<
2;6> D44@A9E A9 CA97 >?4
7A<:A@8A94 2= K;7A:A58 @62@6A4>56G F?A:? A< C5A9>5A947 A9
<4B4658 26746< 64=46647 >2 ?464A95H2B4
5C 2= >?4 2@A9A29
>2 92> A9>46=464 A9 >?4 C5>>46 29 ?597
= :2;6<4 8AH46>G
F2;87 ?5B4 >2 H4 64<46B47 >2 @4>A>A2946< >2 5@@625:? >?4
58>4695>AB4 =26;C 5B5A85H84 =26 >?4C >2 65A<4 59G 7A<@;>4 A=
<2 57BA<47
&%
::267A9E8G
@5<< >?4 =2882FA9E
A
16A> @4>A>A29 A<
AA
AH46>G A< 64<46B47 >2 >?4 @4>A>A2946< >2
5@@625:? >?4 5@@62@6A5>4 5;>?26A>G >2 =A84
84:>A29
4>A>A29 26 65A<4 5 7A<@;>4
- 24 -
;9746
4:>A29
>?4
'5695>5D5
= 59G <;:? 7A<@;>4 A< 65A<47
>?4 <5C4
2 2@465>AB4
AAA
(*
2:A4>A4<
2=
:>
<?588 H4 :29<A74647 4I@47A>A2;<8G HG >?4
:29:46947 5;>?26A>A4<
)'
&
!
%
!
A<>
&
*
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review