Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.6
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
LPA 171/2023
CM(5407/2023)
BASHIR AHMAD RATHER AND ORS.
… APPELLANT(S)
Through:
Mr. G.A. Lone, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Mujeeb Andrabi, Advocate
V/s.
STATE OF J AND K AND ORS.
...RESPONDENT(S)
Through:
Mr. Rizwan Ul Zaman Bhat, Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE.
ORDER
11.09.2026
1.
The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has taken this
Court through the prayers made in the writ petition, which reads as
follows:
i) Writ, Order or direction in the nature of Certiorari for quashing
the impugned mutation No.327 of Village Moominhall Tehsil
& District Anantnag and also the entries made on the basis of
said mutation in the revenue record pertaining land
measuring 24 Kanals 05 Marlas comprising of survey
Nos.383/18 (7 Kanal 1- Marla), 383/25 (04 Kanal 04 Marlas),
Survey No.384/28(01 Kanal 18-Marlas), 387/41 (18 Marlas)
situate at Village Moomin Hall Tehsil & District Anantnag.
i(a) Writ, order or direction in the nature of Certiorari for quashing
the order of District Magistrate dated 14-09-2011 bearing No.
DCA/Mig/Camp/660
i(b) Writ, order or direction in the nature of Certiorari for quashing
the Supardnama dated 28-01-2012.
1 | Page
(ii) Writ, Order or direction in the nature of Certiorari for quashing
the order of District Magistrate (Deputy Commissioner)
Anantnag dated 6-12-2011 in case Gaffar & Sultan Parray &
Ors Vs. Petti Devi & Anr.
(iii) Writ, Order or direction in the nature of Mandamus
commanding the respondents to make entries of ownership in
favour of petitioners on the basis of tenancy recorded in 1971
and bring mutation No.279 of village Moominhall to its logical
conclusion by attesting mutation in favour of petitioners
under Section 8 of J&K Agrarian Reforms Act.
(iv) Writ, Order or direction in the nature of Mandamus
commanding the respondents to vest the land measuring 24
Kanals 05 Marlas comprising of survey Nos. 383/18 (7 Kanal
1- Marla), 383/25 (04 Kanal 04 Marlas), Survey No.384/28(01
Kanal 18-Marlas), 387/41 (18 Marlas) situate at Village
Moomin Hall Tehsil & District Anantnag in favour of the State
with further direction to allot the land in favour of petitioners
who were its tenants.
2.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants submits that the
land in question, measuring 48 kanals 10 marlas, is situated at village
Moomin Hall, Tehsil, Anantnag, and has remained in the tenancy of the
appellants and their predecessors-in-interest for a long time. The counsel
for the appellants, however, submits that the respondent Nos. 6 and 7
were the owners of the land, and that the land was mutated in terms of
Section 4 of the Jammu & Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act in favor of the
State, whereby the owners of the land were declared ex-owners and the
appellant/petitioners were declared as prospective owners.
3.
The counsel has drawn the attention of this Court to the fact that
Mutation No. 279 of village Moominhal was attested by the Tehsildar,
Agrarian Reforms, Tehsil Anantnag, whereafter the ex-owners filed an
application under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act for resumption
of the land.
4.
The application under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act,
after due process of law, was allowed and decided by the concerned
authority vide Mutation No. 327 dated 27.07.1985, while resuming 24
kanals and 05 marlas of the land to the ex-owners with the direction to
2 | Page
hand over the possession of the land to them. The remaining portion of
land, 24 kanals and 05 marlas, was ordered to be attested in the ownership
of the appellants under Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act.
5.
The learned Senior Counsel fairly submits that both the parties
were thus beneficiaries of the Agrarian Reforms Act, which virtually
resulted into the division of the 48 kanals and 10 marlas of land between
both the parties - one by virtue of resumption to the original owners, and
the other part being allotted to the tillers i.e., the appellants.
6.
The learned Senior Counsel submits, however, the bone of
contention today is the portion of land which was resumed in favor of the
private respondent-owners, whereas the resumption was contrary to law
inasmuch as it did not conform to the parameters laid down in the
Agrarian Reforms Act, and that the requisite process of law, including
conducting of inquiry, was not done by the concerned authorities.
Counsel further submits that appellants/petitioners were not given a
chance to produce any kind of evidence to show that the ex-owners were
not entitled to resumption and that the transfer of the land through a
decree of sale was suppressed by the ex-owners
7.
The learned Senior Counsel also tried to submit that the basic
legislative intent behind the Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 was that a person
seeking resumption was required to personally cultivate the land after the
resumption was ordered, however, in the present case, the ex-owners
never returned to the land and made no effort, even after resumption, to
cultivate the land in question, thereby debarring them from the benefit of
resumption under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act.
8.
The counsel submits that there was an intervening event, in that
the appellants were contesting the resumption in favour of the original exowners, respondent Nos. 6 and 7, in a pending appeal, they entered into a
compromise. Under the compromise, the appellants surrendered their
claim to the entire land ordered to be resumed in favour of the ex-owners,
by paying an amount of Rs. 1,30,800/-, out of which Rs. 30,800/- was paid
in cash and a cheque for Rs. 10,000/- was issued in the name of Radha
Krishna Misri (attorney holder). The remaining amount was agreed to be
3 | Page
paid by the end of the year 1997. The agreement was reduced in writing,
but the balance amount was not paid.
9.
The learned Senior Counsel has also made a submission that the
ex-owners thereafter sold the land to respondent No. 9 under an
agreement to sell, and the sale was under a fixed consideration, which has
been received, and thus, they are not entitled to the benefits of the Jammu
and Kashmir Migrant Immovable Property (Preservation, Protection and
Restraint on Distress Sales) Act, 1997.
10.
The learned Senior Counsel tried to persuade the Court that the
appellants case is twofold: first, that the resumption to the private
respondents itself was bad in law, and second, that even if the resumption
is held to be valid, the ex-owners, having further sold the land, would not
be entitled to the remedy under the Act of 1997.
11.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants further submits
that, pursuant to the compromise, the appeal against resumption to the
private respondents was not pursued and was consigned to the records.
The counsel also tried to submit that since the appeal has remained
consigned to the records since 1987, it would be in the fitness of things to
permit the appellants to revive the appeal in question. The learned Senior
Counsel submits that the appellants are in continued possession of, and
are cultivating, the land in question, and that this possession has only been
disturbed by the private respondents, who claim to be the owners
subsequent to the resumption.
12.
The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that throughout the
proceedings which were conducted either under the Agrarian Reforms
Act, 1976, or the Jammu and Kashmir Migrant Immovable Property Act,
1997, the procedure prescribed by law was not strictly followed, and that
the respondents were simply trying to take advantage of the 1997 Act and
were trying to get possession by virtue of the powers given under Section
5 of the Act of 1997, which have been exercised by them. The counsel
submits that Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act envisages certain
mandatory requirements, including cultivation and continued residence
in the village or its surrounding area, but the same have not been abided
by the respondents at any juncture throughout this time duration.
4 | Page
13.
The learned Senior Counsel submits that it would be very unfair
to deprive the appellants of their possession and ownership of the land in
question, inasmuch as neither was the resumption correct in the law, nor
is the order under Section 5 of the Act of 1997 for eviction in accordance
with law. He also submitted that even if any right survives under the
agreement entered into between the parties, the right remains with the
appellants and that the subsequent sale of the land would also render the
owners ineligible to seek eviction under the Act of 1997.
14.
The counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submits that
the resumption in favour of the private respondents cannot be challenged
in these proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution, and that any
right the appellants may have had against the resumption ought to have
been pursued in the appeal filed by them, which has remained consigned
to the records since 1987 and thus barely any right survives in their favour
to challenge the resumption at this stage.
15.
The counsel for the respondents further submits that the
agreement said to have been entered into with the appellants is denied by
the respondents, and that the respondents are, in fact, entitled to own the
property once a valid resumption order has been passed under Section 7
of the Agrarian Reforms Act, and that such an order cannot be challenged
here in the proceedings involving disputed questions of fact.
16.
The counsel for the respondents further submits that once the
land was resumed in favor of the private respondents in conformity with
Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act, all rights over the land in question
vested in them and in the given factual circumstances, it was correct for
the respondents to invoke the provisions of the Act of 1997, which entitles
them to all the rights claimed in respect of the property in question.
17.
The counsel for the respondents submits that for the order
passed under Section 5 of the Act of 1997, the remedy was in an appeal
under Section 7 of the Act of 1997.
18.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties, this Court has
perused Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act, which reads as follows:
“7.
Resumption for bona fide personal cultivation by
ex-landlord.– (1) Subject to the provisions of this
section––
5 | Page
(a) an
individual,
whose
rights
in
land
have
been
extinguished by section 4 and who was entitled to
recover rent in Kharif, 1971 directly from the tiller, may
resume land outside demarcated forests for purposes of
bona fide personal cultivation;
(b) where rights in land of one or more than one member of
a family have been extinguished by section 4 and such
member or members were entitled to recover rent in
Kharif, 1971 directly from the tiller, such member or
members may resume land for bona fide personal
cultivation;
(c) a displaced person allotted evacuees’ land or land
included in Schedule II, who is not cultivating such land
personally, may resume such land for bona fide
personal cultivation.
(2)
Resumption of land permitted by sub-section (1) shall
be subject to the following conditions, namely: ––
(a) the application for resumption shall be made in the
prescribed
manner
within
[one
year]
of
the
commencement of this Act ;
(b) the applicant for resumption, shall 2 [within six months
from the date of resumption of land] take up normal
residence for the purpose of cultivating such land
personally in the village in which the land sought to be
resumed is situated or in an adjoining village 3 [except
in the case of ––
(i) a person serving in defence force, who shall take up such
normal residence for personal cultivation within six
months of the date on which he ceases to serve in
defence force; or
(ii) a widow or a person who is physically disabled or
incapacitated by old age or infirmity] :
Provided that in the case of land situated in an
un-inhabited village on or near the border, such
residence shall be taken up within the period indicated
above in the nearest inhabited village or in the adjoining
village:
Provided further that a displaced person who has
been allotted land in more than one village, shall take
6 | Page
up such residence in any one of such villages or in the
adjoining village :
[Provided also that a person who is minor or
insane shall take up such residence within six months
of the date on which he attains the age of majority or
attains sanity.]
(c) land held by a tiller paying rent at village rates (hasabpartadeh) with or without malikana or by a tiller, who is
an occupancy tenant, shall not be resumed;
(d) no person, who or any member of whose family, if any,
is an income-tax payer, shall be eligible to resume any
land ;
(e) the person who has transferred land by sale or gift or
bequest on or after first day of September, 1971 shall
not be eligible to resume land if the land so transferred
was personally cultivated by him prior to such transfer
;
(f) the extent of land that may be resumed shall, subject to
the provisions of sub-section (3), be determined in the
following manner, namely : ––
(i) where a person was entitled, as according to records, to
rent in kind from the tiller during Kharif, 1971, the
extent of the land resumable by such person shall bear
the same proportion to the total land comprising the
tenancy as the rent in kind bears to the total produce ;
(ii) where a person was entitled, as according to records, to
rent in cash during Kharif, 1971, the extent of land
resumable by such person shall be regulated by the
extent of rent in kind to which such rent in cash can be
commuted in accordance with the provisions of
subsections (3) and (8) of section 9 ;
(iii) a person serving in defence force on or after the 1st day
of April, 1965, 1 [an ex-serviceman of the defence force]
or a widow or an orphan who is minor or a lunatic or an
imbecile, or an insane person or a person who is
crippled or incapacitated by old age or infirmity, shall be
permitted to resume land twenty per centum in excess
of the land otherwise resumable under sub-clauses (i) or
(ii).
7 | Page
2[(g) no person, who or any member of whose family holds
an orchard exceeding one hundred kanals, shall be
eligible to resume land].
(3)
The aggregate land that a person resuming land
shall hold in personal cultivation, after resumption, along
with other members of the family, if any, to which he
belongs, shall not exceed 6.50 standard acres where such
person belongs to the category of persons mentioned in
sub-clause (iii) of clause (f) of sub-section (2) and five
standard acres in other cases :
3[Provided that an ex-servicemen of the defence force
or a person serving in defence force shall be allowed to
hold one additional standard acre over and above ceiling
fixed in this sub-section :
Provided further that in the case of a person eligible
to resume land under clause (g) of sub-section (2), the
aggregate land including the orchard held by him shall
not exceed one hundred kanals].
(4)
The person resuming land under this section
shall be vested with ownership rights in such land, other
than evacuees’ land, and he shall be placed in
possession thereof, after the tiller removes the crop, if
any, standing on such land and, where no crop is
standing but the land has been prepared for sowing,
after such tiller is paid therefor in the prescribed
manner.
(5)
Where any person resuming land under this
section fails to cultivate the land personally with in one
year of entering into possession, such land shall vest in
the 1 [Union territory of Jammu and Kashmir], except
where such failure is due to circumstances beyond his
control.
(6)
The identity of the land to be resumed shall be
determined by a Revenue Officer, in the prescribed
manner, having regard to the reasonable convenience of
both the parties :
Provided that land under and appurtenant to a
dwelling house mentioned in section 6 shall not be
resumed.
8 | Page
Explanation.––For purposes of this sub-section, the land
under and appurtenant to the dwelling house shall not,
along with the land exempted by clauses (j) and (1) of
section 3 and land under and appurtenant to a building
or structure in a municipal area, town area, notified
area or village abadi, exceed four kanals for a family.
(7)
No resumption by consent shall be permissible
if, as a result of such consent, the ex-landlord is able to
resume more land than he is entitled to according to the
provisions of this section.”
The Court has also perused Section 4 of the Act, pointed out
by the counsel for the parties, which reads as follows:
“4. Vesting in the State of rights in land not held in
personal cultivation.
1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the
time being in force, but subject to the provisions of this
Chapter, all rights, title and interest in land of any
persons, not cultivating it personally in Kharif, 1971, shall
be deemed to have extinguished and vested in the 1 [Union
territory
of
Jammu
and
Kashmir],
free
from
all
encumbrances, with effect from the first day of May, 1973.
(2) Nothing in sub-section (1) shall apply to––
(a) land held by gumpa of Ladakh Districts :
Provided that the rights of tenant thereof shall be
heritable according to the law of succession applicable to
occupancy tenants and that no tenant or his successor
shall be subject to payment of rent exceeding [XXX] the
prevailing rent, [XXX] whether in cash or in kind;
3[(b) (i) unit of land
not’ exceeding 182 kanals including
residential sites Bedzars and Safedzars ; and
(ii) [Land]
held by such places of worship, waqafs or Dharmshallas,
as are recorded in the revenue records or 5 [notified by the
Government from time to time or donated for purposes of
wakaf by any person professing Islam or used as a wakaf
property] :
9 | Page
Provided that the rights of tenant thereof shall be
heritable according to the law of succession applicable to
occupancy tenants ;
6[x x x].
(c) land mentioned in Schedule II allotted to a
displaced person :
Provided that :––
(i)
such land and evacuees’ land, if any, allotted to
the same displaced person, is situated in more
than one village ; and
(ii)
(such displaced person cultivated personally the
land in at least one village in Kharif, 1971.”
The Court has further perused Rule 17 of the Agrarian Reforms
Rules, 1977, which reads as follows.
“17. Private Agreement---Before proceeding to identify
land to be resumed by the petitioner, the Revenue
Officer shall afford an opportunity to the parties to arrive
at an agreement, subject to the provisions of sub-section
(7) of Section 7.”
The provisions of the Jammu & Kashmir Migrant Immovable
Property (Preservation, Protection and Restraint On Distress Sales) Act,
1997 have also been placed before the Court. Sections 5 and 7 thereof reads
as follows.
“5. Eviction of unauthorised occupant.— If any
unauthorised occupant of any migrant property refuses
or fails on demand to surrender possession thereof to
the competent authority, such authority may use such
force as is necessary for taking possession of such
property and may for this purpose after giving
reasonable warning and facility to any women not
appearing in public to withdraw, remove or break open
any lock, bolt or any door or do any other Act, necessary
for the said purpose.”
“7. Appeal.— (1) Any person aggrieved of an order
passed under this Act, may file an appeal before the
Financial Commissioner, Revenue:
10 | P a g e
Provided that no such appeal shall be entertained
against—
(a) an interlocutory order;
(b) an order of eviction unless possession of the property
is surrendered to the competent authority;
(c) an order of payment of compensation determined
under this Act unless the amount of compensation is
deposited with the appellate authority.
(2) The period of limitation for filing of an appeal under
sub-section (1) shall be fifteen days from the date of
order appealed against.”
19.
The contours of the controversy have been accurately drawn
by the learned Single Judge and in terms of the factual matrix of the case,
this Court takes note of the fact that the dispute arose when the property
belonging to the respondents was initially taken away from them under
Section 4 of the Agrarian Reforms Act. The taking away of the property
was contested by the private respondents, and in the meanwhile, rights
accrued in favour of the appellants in respect of the property which is 24
kanals and 5 marlas out of 48 kanals and 10 marlas.
20.
While the appellants rights accrued as owners of that part of
the land, the respondents invoked Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act,
which is in tandem and in consequence of the earlier reversal of their
rights under Section 4 of the Act, and thus, the resumption was made on
27.07.1985, restoring the rights of the owners as provided in the law.
21.
The consequential mutation was challenged by the appellants
by way of an appeal, which remained pending before the appropriate
authority. It is the appellants’ own case that, in the course of these
proceedings, the original owners entered into a compromise with the
appellants, and, settled the dispute in a manner which would not amount
to a sale, but would amount to surrendering of their claim to the 24 kanals
and 5 marlas resumed in favour of the ex-owners. The learned Senior
Counsel himself pointed out that it was not actually a sale, but a right
relinquished in terms of law by the original owners, the details of which
have already been narrated in the factual matrix of this order.
11 | P a g e
22.
The fact that the appeal was given up and consigned to
records, almost in terms of law, upholds the proposition of resumption of
the land under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act in favor of the
private respondents, unless any appropriate remedy, which the appellant
may have, is invoked by them.
23.
This Court also takes note of the fact that the subsequent
agreement between the parties would not have any consequence at this
stage, because the prayers sought for were confined to the quashing of
resumption and the quashing of the order under Section 5 of the Act of
1997, whereas the correctness of the resumption itself could have been
contested in the appropriate proceedings, which were voluntarily given
up by the appellants in the circumstances narrated above.
24.
Thus, this Court does not wish to go into the details as to
whether the resumption under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act was
correct in the eyes of law or not, because that was the subject matter of
separate proceedings, which was undertaken and contested by both
parties, and laid to rest by the appeal of 1987 consigned to record.
25.
So far as Section 5 of the Act of 1997 is concerned, once the
proceedings under Section 7 of the Agrarian Reforms Act today are
sustained in the present perspective at this stage, then Section 5 is a right
which has arisen out of the Act of 1997, and thus such right exercised by
the owners cannot be said to be bad in the eyes of law. Moreover, against
the order under Section 5 of the Act of 1997, there is an appeal under
Section 7 of the Act of 1997 which was an appropriate remedy for the
appellants.
26.
This Court finds that both the parties have, at different points,
been beneficiaries of the Agrarian Reforms Act, but at the same time, due
to the long passage of time and frequent changing of the forums in which
the resumption has been challenged, and thereafter, the invocation of
Section 5 of the Act of 1997, this litigation has been put in a prolonged
process which needs to be given a quietus only to the extent of invocation
of Section 5 of the Act of 1997 and Section 7 of the Act of 1997, at this stage,
while leaving it open to the parties to seek such other remedies as may be
available to them in law.
12 | P a g e
27.
This Court is in complete agreement with the order passed by
the learned Single Judge, who has rightly noted that order under Section
5 of the Act of 1997 has a remedy under Section 7 of the Act of 1997 to the
appellants. For the aforesaid reasons, no interference in the impugned
order is called for. However, it shall be open to the appellants to seek any
of the rights which are available to them strictly in accordance with law.
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
JUDGE
(DR. PUSHPENDRA SINGH BHATI)
CHIEF JUSTICE
SRINAGAR:
11.09.2026
Junaid
13 | P a g e
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review