Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:3713-DB
ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
Digitally signed
by ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 6899 of 2024
1 - Bashil Minj S/o Shri Daud Minj Aged About 33 Years R/o H.No. 751
Baba Lal Gali, Vrindawan Colony, Jagdalpur, District Bastar Chhattisgarh Presently Working On The Post Of Tracer (Civil) At The Office Of
Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Division No. 2, Jagdalpur,
Chhattisgarh
2 - Roshandeep Markam S/o Shri Ram Prasad Markam Aged About 35
Years R/o Infront Of Maheshwari Bhawan, Government Quarter No. 07
T.S.D. Colony, Kumharpra, Jagdalpur, District Bastar Chhattisgarh
Presently Working On The Post Of Tracer (Civil) At The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department (B And R), Division No. 1, Jagdalpur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Abhishek Vishwakarma S/o Shri S.B. Vishwakarma Aged About 30
Years R/o Kalpana Chavala Ward No. 15, Sanjaypara, Tehsil Bhairamgarh, District Bijapur Chhattisgarh, Presently Working On The Post Of
Tracer (Civil) In Public Work Department, Sub-Division No. 2, Bijapur,
District Bijapur, Chhattisgarh
4 - Vinay Kumar Jaiswal S/o Shri Pradeep Jaiswal Aged About 34 Years
R/o Village And Post Pandari, Tehsil Roghuth Nagar, District Balrampur
Chhattisgarh Presently Working On The Post Of Tracer (Civil) In Public
Work Department, Sub-Division Wadrafnafar, District Balrampur Chhattisgarh
5 - Mohnish Chandel S/o Shri Rajesh Chandel Aged About 33 Years R/o
Motitalab Para, Rawaiya Ward Pwd Quarter No. I-1, Jagdalpur, District
Bastar Chhattisgarh, Presently Working On The Post Of Assistant
Draftsmen (Civil) At The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, North Bastar, Division No. 1, Jagdalpur, Chhattisgarh
6 - Swati Singh Chandel S/o Shri Mohnish Chandel Aged About 33
Years R/o Motitalab Para, Rawaiya Ward Pwd Quarter No. I-1, Jagdalpur, District Bastar Chhattisgarh, Presently Working On The Post Of
Assistant Draftsmen (Civil) At The Office Of Chief Engineer, Public Work
Department, Bastar Zone, Jagdalpur, Chhattisgarh
7 - Ankur Vishwakarma S/o Shri Ramesh Vishwakarma Aged About 32
Years R/o Pratap Dev Ward, Near Maa Jagdamba Chowk, Jagdalpur,
District Bastar Chhattisgarh Presently Working On The Post Of Assistant Draftsmen (Civil) In Public Work Department, Sub-Division Lohandliguda, District Bastar Chahttisgarh
... Petitioners
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary General Administration
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur,
District Raipur Chhattisgarh
2 - Secretary Public Work Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan
Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
3 - Engineer-In-Chief Public Work Department, Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur,
District Raipur Chhattisgarh
4 - Chief Engineer Public Work Department, Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur,
District Raipur Chhattisgarh
5 - Satyajit Nandi Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Rastriya Rajmarga, Division Jagdalpur, District Bastar - Jagdalpur Chhattisgarh
6 - Bisoha Ram Korte Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Bijapur, Division
Bijapur, District Bijapur Chhattisgarh
7 - Sabalram Sonwani Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Ramanujganj,
Division Ramanujganj, District Ramanujganj Chhattisgarh
8 - Smt. Seema Singh Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Ramanujganj,
Division Ramanujganj, District Ramanujganj Chhattisgarh
9 - Lakhan Ram Kurre Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Mungeli, Division Mungeli, District Mungeli Chhattisgarh
10 - P.S. Chouhan Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Bemetara, Division Bemetara, District Bemetara Chhattisgarh
11 - Alok Kumar Jain Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Rastriya Rajmarga, Division Jagdalpur, District Bastar-Jagdalpur Chhattisgarh (died
and deleted)
12 - Manoj Kumar Verma Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Ramanujganj, Division Ramanujganj, District Ramanujganj Chhattisgarh
13 - Dinesh Kumar Jaiswal Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil)
In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Pathalgaon, Division Pathalgaon, District Jashpur, Chhattisgarh
14 - Ashok Kumar Tiwari Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Division
Ramanujganj, District Ramanujganj Chhattisgarh
15 - K. K. Dharai Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Rastriya Rajmarga, Division Jagdalpur, District Jagdalpur Chhattisgarh
16 - Devendra Kumar Satpathi Presently Working As Sub-Engineer
(Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department,
Setu Division Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
17 - Ramesh Kumar Pandey Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil)
In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department,
Kawardha, Division Kawardha, District Kawardha Chhattisgarh
18 - Ravindra Singh Jadon Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Setu Division Ambikapur, District Surguja Chhattisgarh
19 - Narendra Kumar Dewangan Presently Working As Sub-Engineer
(Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department,
Ramanujganj, Division Ramanujganj, District Ramanujganj Chhattisgarh
20 - Smt. Anupama Dubey Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Surajpur,
Division Surajpur, District Surajpur Chhattisgarh
21 - Mulchand Kaushik Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Kawardha,
Division Kawardha, District Kawardha Chhattisgarh
22 - Ishwari Lal Banchor Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Khairagarh,
Division Khairagarh, District Khairagarh-Chhuikhadan-Gandai Chhattisgarh
23 - Anil Kumar Soni Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Bemetara, Division Bemetara, District Bemetara Chhattisgarh
24 - Ritesh Singh Chouhan Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil)
In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Division2 Jagdalpur, District Bastar-Jagdalpur Chhattisgarh
25 - Nomesh Kumar Sahu Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Setu Division Durg, District Durg Chhattisgarh
26 - Tarun Kumar Sen Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Division-1
Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
27 - Vivek Kumar Patel Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Balodabazar, Division Balodabazar, District Balodabazar Chhattisgarh
28 - Vijay Kumar Chandrakar Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil)
In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Vidhansabha, Division Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
29 - Bhupendra Kumar Verma Presently Working As Sub-Engineer
(Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Division-2, Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
30 - Duryodhan Korram Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Division-1,
Jagdalpur, District Bastar-Jagdalpur Chhattisgarh
31 - Indra Kumar Netam Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Kanker, Division Kanker, District Kanker Chhattisgarh
32 - Ajay Kumar Bhatt Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Kondagaon, Division Kondagaon, District Kondagaon Chhattisgarh
33 - Baldhari Singh Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The
Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department, Ramanujganj,
Division Ramanujganj, District Ramanujganj Chhattisgarh
34 - Shailesh Choudhary Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In
The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Kawardha,
Division Kawardha, District Kawardha Chhattisgarh
35 - Ajay Sharma Presently Working As Sub-Engineer (Civil) In The Office Of Executive Engineer, Public Work Department Sukma, Division
Sukma, District Sukma Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioners
: Mr. Mateen Siddiqui, Advocate
For Respondent Nos.1 to 4 /State :
Mr. Shashank Thakur,
Additional Advocate General
For Respondent Nos. 5, 6, 9, 10, :
Mr. Chandresh Shrivastava,
13, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21, 22, 23,
Advocate
24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32
and 34
For Respondent Nos. 7, 8, 14,
:
Mr. Pawan Shrivastava,
20, 33 and 35
Advocate
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hon'ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Mr. Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
21.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Mateen Siddiqui, learned counsel for the petitioners.
Also heard Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional Advocate
General, appearing for the State / respondent Nos. 1 to 4,
Mr.Chandresh Shrivastava, learned counsel, appearing for
respondent Nos. 5, 6, 9, 10, 13, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21, 22, 23, 24,
25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32 and 34 and Mr. Pawan Shrivastava,
learned counsel, appearing for respondent Nos. 7, 8, 14, 20, 33
and 35.
2.
It has been pointed out by learned State counsel that during
pendency of present petition, respondent No.11, namely Alok
Kumar Jain, has died.
3.
In that view of the matter, the name of respondent No.11, namely
Alok Kumar Jain is deleted from the array of parties.
4.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioners under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, seeking following reliefs :-
“10.1 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
set-aside/quash or declare the impugned amended
notification dated 22.01.2022 (Annexure-P/1) as
being ultra-vires viz-a-viz Article 14 & 16 of the
Constitution of India;
10.2 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
quash the impugned promotion orders dated
14.07.2023 & 29.08.2023 (Annexure-P/2) issued by
the Chief Engineer, Public Work Department, Raipur.
10.3 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
direct the respondents' authorities to consider the
candidature of petitioners for promotion on the post of
Sub-Engineer (Civil) from the date of private
respondents promoted as Sub-Engineer (Civil) with
all consequential benefits.
10.4 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue any other order or orders, writ or writs, direction
or directions as this Hon'ble court may deem'fit in the
facts and circumstances of the case in favor of the
petitioners, in the interest of justice.”
5.
Facts of the case, in brief, are that the petitioners No.1 to 4 are
working on the post of Tracer (Civil) and petitioners No.5 & 7 are
working on the post of Assistant Draftsman (Civil) in the Public
Work Department of State of Chhattisgarh. The service conditions
of petitioners are governed by the rules of Chhattisgarh Public
Work Department (Non-Gazetted) Service Recruitment Rules,
2016 (for short, ‘Rules, 2016’ and the promotional post of Tracer
(Civil)/Assistant Draftsman (Civil) is Sub-Engineer (Civil).
The
Schedule-II of Rules, 2016 specified that the 95% posts of Sub
Engineer (Civil) shall be filled up by direct recruitment and rest of
5% posts be filled up through promotion.
The Schedule-III of
rules, 2016, provides that 5% post of Sub-Engineer (Civil) shall be
reserved for Tracer/Assistant Draughtman working on lower post
and prescribed educational qualification for the post of SubEngineer (Civil) is passed minimum three years diploma in Civil,
Electrical and Mechanical or equivalent Engineering from
recognized established by State Government. As per the
Schedule-IV of Rules, 2016 the Diploma holder/Degree holder
Tracer/Assistant Draftsman etc. working in lower post and having
five years of experience are eligible for promotion to the post of
Sub-Engineer (Civil).
6.
Vide impugned notification dated 22.01.2022, the respondent
authority has made amendment in column (2) of serial number 1
of Schedule-IV of Rules, 2016, after the words and symbol
"Diploma holder/Degree holder Tracer/ Assistant Draftsman etc.
working in lower post", the words and symbol "Diploma
holder/Degree
holder
Field
Assistant
of
Work
Charged
Establishment" has been added. By way of aforesaid impugned
notification dated 22.01.2022, the respondent authority made the
diploma/degree
holder
Field
Assistant
of
Work
Charged
Establishment as eligible for promotion on the post of SubEngineer (Civil). Subsequently the respondent Engineer-in-Chief,
Public Work Department, Raipur, vide orders dated 14.07.2023 &
29.08.2023, promoted the Field Assistant working under the Work
Charged Establishment (private respondents) on the post of SubEngineer (Civil).
7.
Being aggrieved by the same, the instant petition has been filed
by the petitioners challenging the legality and constitutional
validity of the impugned amended notification dated 22.01.2022,
thereby Diploma holder/Degree holder Field Assistant of Work
Charged Establishment have become eligible for promotion to the
post of Sub-Engineer (Civil). The petitioners are also challenging
promotion order dated 14.07.2023 & 29.08.2023 issued by the
Chief Engineer, Public Work Department, Raipur, whereby the
private respondents/Field Assistant working under the work
charged establishment have been promoted on the post of SubEngineer (Civil).
8.
Mr. Mateen Siddiqui, learned counsel for the petitioners
vehemently argued that work-charged / contingency paid
employees are not regular government servants and, therefore,
are not eligible for promotion under the service rules. He further
argued that Rule 2(d) of the Chhattisgarh Public Services
(Promotion) Rules, 2003 expressly excludes work-charged,
contingency paid, casual and daily wage employees from the
cadre eligible for promotion.
It is further contended that the
private respondents were never regularized or confirmed in
service and, therefore, do not fulfill the requirement of five years
of regular service, making their promotion illegal and contrary to
the Rules of 2016 and Promotion Rules, 2003. He also asserted
that work-charged employees are governed by a distinct service
regime and may claim protection under the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947, and thus cannot be equated with regular government
employees. Treating them alike amounts to equal treatment of
unequal classes, in violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
It is further submitted that the private
respondents were initially appointed as Timekeeper / Field
Assistant without following due process of selection, whereas the
petitioners were appointed through a regular recruitment process,
therefore,
granting
promotional
parity
is
arbitrary
and
unconstitutional, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Uttar
Pradesh Power Corporation Ltd. v. Ayodhya Prasad Mishra
(2008) 10 SCC 139.
9.
Mr. Siddiqui further submitted that the private respondents had
earlier sought promotion after obtaining diploma qualifications
through
distance
education,
which
was
rejected
by
the
department on 06.01.2018 on the grounds that such qualifications
were not valid and that work-charged employees were not eligible
for promotion under the Rules. He also submitted that as per the
Rules, 2016, there are 1047 sanctioned posts of Sub-Engineer
(Civil) and 5% post is reserved for promotion and 5% of 1047 post
would become around 53 posts and out of 53 posts 31 work
charged contingency paid employees have been promoted on the
post of Sub-Engineer and earlier in 2008 about 23 regular
employees were promoted and as on date 2-3 posts are lying
vacant out of 53 posts and because of impugned notification the
petitioners could not get promoted, therefore the petitioners by
way of representation requested the authority to increase the
promotion percentage, pursuant to which, the respondent Chief
Engineer, PWD Raipur sent proposal to the Additional Chief
Secretary, PWD, Raipur on 21.09.2023 for increasing the
promotion quota of Sub-Engineer (Civil) from 5% to 10% and
further proposed to divide the said 10% posts into 3.5% for
Assistant Draftsman (Civil), 1.5% for Tracer (Civil) and 05% Filed
Assistant of Work Charged Establishment. He further rely upon
similar instances in the State of Madhya Pradesh and in the
School Education Department of Chhattisgarh, where promotion
of contingency paid employees was denied or cancelled,
reinforcing the settled position that work-charged employees
cannot be promoted to regular cadre posts.
10.
On the other hand, Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional
Advocate General, appearing for the State/respondents opposed
the aforesaid submissions and submitted that the petitioners have
no locus to challenge the Rules framed under Article 309 of the
Constitution of India. The challenge is based merely on individual
hardship and reduction in chances of promotion, which is
impermissible in law. The amendment to the Rules, 2016 was
notified on 22.01.2022 and promotion orders were issued on
14.07.2023 and 29.07.2023, whereas the petition was filed on
21.10.2024. Hence, the petition is liable to be dismissed at the
threshold on the ground of delay and laches.
He further
submitted that under the Public Works Department (NonGazetted) Service Recruitment Rules, 2007, Rule 6(1)(b) and
Schedule IV provided for promotion of Diploma/Degree Holder
Tracer/Assistant Draftsman with five years’ service to the post of
Sub Engineer, including employees of work-charged and
contingency establishments. Similar provisions existed in the
Rules of 2015. However, when the Rules, 2016 were notified in
January 2017, the provision relating to work-charged and
contingency employees was omitted. Upon representations from
employees’
unions,
the
parent
department
proposed
an
amendment, pursuant to which the Rules, 2016 were amended to
substitute
the
Holder/Degree
eligibility
criteria
Holder/Field
by
Assistant
including
of
“Diploma
work-charged
establishment.”
11.
Mr. Thakur further submitted that it is the exclusive prerogative of
the State to create posts, declare cadres, or frame service rules
based on administrative necessity. The vires of rules can be
challenged only on limited grounds, namely lack of legislative
competence, excess of delegated power, conflict with the parent
Act, or violation of constitutional provisions. None of these
grounds are attracted in the present case. The State is fully
competent under Article 309 of the Constitution to frame and
amend service rules. Policy decisions cannot be invalidated
merely because they cause inconvenience or loss to a few
individuals. Judicial review of policy decisions is limited to the test
of reasonableness, and the petitioners have failed to demonstrate
any unreasonableness or arbitrariness in the Rules, 2016. It was
emphasized that there is a presumption of constitutionality in
favour of statutory rules, and the burden lies on the petitioners to
prove otherwise. Reliance was placed on G.D. Kelkar v. Chief
Controller of Imports and Exports, wherein it was held that the
onus to prove unreasonable classification lies on the person
challenging it.
12.
Mr. Thakur also submitted that the petitioners have failed to show
violation of any vested right under Articles 14 or 16 of the
Constitution. While the right to be considered for promotion is a
condition of service, mere chances of promotion are not, as held
by the Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v. Chandrakant
Anant Kulkarni, (1981) 4 SCC 130. The authority competent to
frame rules is equally competent to amend them, and mala fides
cannot be attributed to the legislature. Lastly, it was submitted that
the post of Field Assistant is a 100% direct recruitment post under
the work-charged and contingency establishment. Based on
AICTE’s clarification dated 25.11.2020 and subsequent State
Government
decision
dated
10.05.2023,
degrees/diplomas
obtained through IGNOU (2011–2012 session) were recognized,
and eligible employees were duly promoted. Therefore, the
promotions granted suffer from no illegality or infirmity.
13.
In reply to the submissions advanced by learned State counsel,
Mr. Siddiqui, learned counsel for the petitioners, submitted that
under the Chhattisgarh Public Works Department (Non-Gazetted)
Service Recruitment Rules, 2007 and the Rules of 2015, there
was no provision for promotion of work-charged contingency paid
employees to the post of Sub Engineer. Prior to the coming into
force of the Rules, 2016, not a single work-charged contingency
paid employee was ever promoted to the post of Sub Engineer.
Hence, the State’s contention that such a promotional provision
existed in earlier rules is factually incorrect and misconceived. It
was further submitted that the eligibility conditions for promotion to
the post of Sub Engineer as contained in Schedule-IV of the
Rules, 2007 and the unamended Rules, 2016 are identical.
Therefore, the State’s assertion that the promotion provision was
omitted in the Rules, 2016 and later restored by the impugned
notification is incorrect and has been made only to justify the
promotions of private respondents. The State has failed to place
on record copies of the Rules of 2007 and 2015 to substantiate its
claim, whereas the petitioners have filed the Rules of 2007 as
Annexure-P/11.
14.
Mr. Siddiqui also submitted that the State has not denied that the
services of the private respondents were never confirmed or
regularized, nor that they do not possess five years of regular
service. These facts, therefore, stand admitted. As per the
Chhattisgarh Public Services (Promotion) Rules, 2003, workcharged contingency paid employees are not eligible for
promotion. Consequently, the impugned amendment notification
dated 22.01.2022 is contrary to the Promotion Rules, 2003 and
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. He
lastly submitted that the State has also not disputed that the
private respondents, being work-charged contingency paid
employees, were governed by the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
whereas the petitioners are governed by the Rules, 2016 and
were appointed through a regular recruitment process. The
private
respondents
were
appointed
as
Timekeeper/Field
Assistant without following due process of selection. By treating
these two distinct classes as equals through the impugned
notification, the State has violated the constitutional mandate of
equality. Reliance was placed on Uttar Pradesh Power
Corporation Ltd. v. Ayodhya Prasad Mishra (2008) 10 SCC
139, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that unequals
cannot be treated equally, and such treatment offends Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution.
15.
Mr. Chandresh Shrivastava, learned counsel, appearing for
private respondents opposes the submissions advanced by
learned counsel for the petitioners and submitted that the writ
petition is not maintainable at the outset. A bare perusal of relief
clause 10.1 shows that the petitioners have not challenged the
impugned notification dated 22.01.2022 on the grounds of
legislative incompetence or lack of jurisdiction. The pleadings
disclose only a grievance against amendment in Schedule IV, yet
the entire notification has been challenged without laying any
foundational facts. On this ground alone, the petition deserves
dismissal. He further submitted that the petition also suffers from
gross delay and laches. The impugned notification came into
force on 22.01.2022, whereas the petition was filed on 21.10.2024
after more than two and a half years, without any explanation. The
combined eligibility list was published on 24.01.2023, followed by
DPC and promotion orders dated 14.07.2023 and 29.08.2023.
Despite full knowledge, the petitioners approached this Court
belatedly, and even falsely pleaded absence of delay. Such stale
claims are barred by settled principles of law. Reliance was
placed on Tridip Kumar Dingal v. State of W.B., (2009) 1 SCC
768; Karnataka Power Corporation Ltd. v. K. Thangappan ,
(2006) 4 SCC 322; and Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply v.
T.T. Murali Babu, (2014) 4 SCC 108. The belated challenge to
promotion orders is also impermissible in view of
P.S.
Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1974 SC 2271.
16.
Mr. Shrivastava further submitted that the amendment has been
made in exercise of powers under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution and carries a strong presumption of constitutionality.
The petitioners have failed to establish any of the recognized
grounds for invalidating subordinate legislation, namely lack of
competence, constitutional violation, or manifest arbitrariness.
Reliance was placed on Dental Council of India v. Biyani
Shikshan Samiti, (2022) 6 SCC 65 and Dr. Jaya Thakur v.
Union of India, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 813.
17.
On merits, it was submitted by Mr. Shrivastava that under the
PWD (Non-Gazetted) Service Recruitment Rules, 2007 and 2015,
employees of work-charged establishment recruited through
limited competitive examination formed part of the PWD (NonGazetted) Service and were promoted to the post of Sub
Engineer, as evident from promotion orders issued in 2009 and
2016. Though the Rules, 2016 omitted the method of recruitment
under Rule 6, Rule 4 clearly included persons recruited prior to
commencement of the Rules within the constitution of service.
The omission resulted in stagnation of eligible employees, which
was rectified by the impugned amendment restoring the
promotional avenue. The amendment is therefore rational,
corrective, and non-arbitrary. The reliance placed by the
petitioners on the Chhattisgarh Public Services (Promotion)
Rules, 2003 is misconceived. The said Rules apply to
“establishment”, which expressly includes work-charged and
contingency paid establishment, and are always subject to the
relevant Recruitment Rules. The private respondents fall within
the feeder category and fulfill the eligibility conditions as per the
Recruitment Rules, making them lawfully entitled to consideration
and promotion.
18.
Mr. Shrivastava also submitted that the petitioners themselves
were aware of the legality of the amendment and never
challenged it initially. Instead, they sought enhancement of
promotional quota vide representation dated 15.05.2023, which
clearly shows acquiescence and lack of bona fides in filing the
present writ petition.
Lastly, it was contended that fixation of
promotional avenues and inclusion of feeder cadres is a policy
matter within the exclusive domain of the employer. Courts do not
interfere with such policy decisions unless there is clear
constitutional violation. Reliance was placed on Dwarka Prasad
v. Union of India, (2003) 6 SCC 535 and Dilip Kumar Garg v.
State of U.P., (2009) 4 SCC 753.
19.
In reply to the submissions advanced by learned counsel
appearing for the private respondents, Mr. Siddiqui, learned
counsel for the petitioners, submitted that the private respondents
have neither denied nor disputed that their services were never
regularized and that they do not have five years of regular service.
Under the Chhattisgarh Public Service (Promotion) Rules, 2003,
work-charged and contingency-paid employees are explicitly
ineligible for promotion. The impugned notification of 22.01.2022,
which makes them eligible, is therefore arbitrary, discriminatory,
and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, as it treats
unequals permanently appointed petitioners and irregular workcharged employees as equals. The petitioners were appointed
through due process under the 2016 Recruitment Rules, whereas
the private respondents were not, further highlighting this
inequality.
20.
Mr. Siddiqui further submitted that the private respondents’ claim
of delay is misconceived. The petition challenges the vires of a
rule, which is always maintainable. Petitioners filed promptly after
receiving assurances and correspondence from the authorities,
and the period for considering representations is yet to elapse.
Additionally, the prior rules of 2007 and 2015 do not provide any
promotion channel for work-charged employees; the documents
relied on by the respondents are merely appointment orders via
departmental
examinations,
not
promotions.
Work-charged
employees are governed under separate rules of 1977 and 1979
and are materially different from regular employees, both in
service conditions and responsibilities.
21.
Mr. Siddiqui finally submitted that the 2015 and 2016 Recruitment
Rules explicitly provide that only 5% of Sub-Engineer (Civil) posts
are for promotion, and contingency-paid employees are eligible
only through direct recruitment, not promotion. The impugned
notification thus violates these rules and undermines the principle
of rewarding permanent, responsible service. In view of the
settled legal position that unequals cannot be treated as equals, it
is respectfully submitted that the notification is unconstitutional
and the petition deserves to be allowed.
22.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered
their rival submissions made hereinabove and also went through
the records with utmost circumspection.
23.
The primary issue before this Court is the constitutionality of the
amendment to the Rules, 2016, which extends eligibility for
promotion to the post of Sub-Engineer (Civil) to work-charged
employees. The petitioners argue that the inclusion of workcharged employees as eligible for promotion violates the
principles of equality under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
They contend that work-charged employees are not regular
government servants and cannot be treated as equals to
permanent employees, as they are governed by different service
rules.
24.
The respondents, however, argue that the amendment is a policy
decision made in exercise of the State's power under Article 309,
and that such decisions are generally not subject to judicial review
unless they are found to be unreasonable or arbitrary. It is wellestablished that in matters involving policy decisions, especially
related to service conditions and promotions, courts generally
refrain from interfering unless there is a clear violation of
constitutional principles or a manifest injustice.
25.
In the present case, the State has provided a rational explanation
for the amendment, stating that it was intended to rectify the
stagnation of eligible work-charged employees who had been left
out of the promotional channel. The amendment aims to include
those employees who were working in the Public Works
Department but had been excluded from promotion opportunities
due to the exclusionary language of the previous rules.
26.
The petitioners have also raised the issue that the private
respondents were not regularized in service and have not
completed five years of regular service, which is a prerequisite for
promotion to the post of Sub-Engineer (Civil) as per the Rules,
2016. The respondents counter this argument by asserting that
the private respondents, despite being work-charged employees,
were
duly
qualified
and
had
the
requisite
educational
qualifications for promotion. The private respondents further argue
that they were included in the feeder category for promotion under
the revised rules.
27.
While it is true that the work-charged employees may not have the
same status as regular employees, the State has the discretion to
amend service rules to accommodate the inclusion of workcharged employees in the promotion process. The inclusion of
work-charged employees as eligible for promotion is a corrective
measure aimed at addressing the administrative necessity of
ensuring that all qualified employees have an opportunity for
career advancement, provided they meet the eligibility criteria.
28.
The petitioners’ challenge to the promotion orders and the
amendment to the rules has been delayed by over two years. The
petitioners were aware of the amendment and the promotions
granted to the private respondents, yet they filed the petition in
October 2024, well after the amendment was made in January
2022 and the promotions were issued in mid-2023. The
respondents argue that this delay renders the petition liable to be
dismissed on the grounds of laches.
29.
The impugned amendment to the Rules, 2016 was notified on
22.01.2022. The consequential promotion orders were issued on
14.07.2023 and 29.08.2023. The present writ petition has been
filed only on 21.10.2024, i.e., after more than two and a half years
from the date of amendment and over one year after the
promotions.
30.
The petitioners were admittedly aware of the amendment and
promotions. In fact, instead of challenging the amendment at the
earliest, the petitioners chose to submit representations seeking
enhancement of promotional quota, thereby accepting the validity
of
the
amendment.
Such
conduct
clearly
amounts
to
acquiescence.
31.
The law on delay in service matters is well settled. In P.S.
Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil Nadu , AIR 1974 SC 2271, the
Supreme Court held that stale claims relating to promotion should
not be entertained. Similarly, in Karnataka Power Corporation
Ltd. v. K. Thangappan, (2006) 4 SCC 322, it was held that delay
defeats equity and courts should not unsettle settled service
positions.
32.
In Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply v. T.T. Murali Babu ,
(2014) 4 SCC 108, the Supreme Court reiterated that belated
service claims disrupt administrative certainty and deserve
outright rejection.
33.
Applying the aforesaid principles, this Court finds that the writ
petition is liable to be dismissed on the ground of delay and
laches alone.
34.
The impugned amendment has been made by the State in
exercise of its powers under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India. It is a settled principle of constitutional law
that the authority competent to frame service rules is equally
competent to amend them. Judicial review of subordinate
legislation is confined to limited grounds, namely:
(i)
lack of legislative competence,
(ii)
violation of fundamental rights,
(iii)
repugnancy to parent statute, or
(iv)
manifest arbitrariness.
[State of M.P. v. Rakesh Kohli, (2012) 6 SCC 312]
35.
The petitioners have failed to establish any of the aforesaid
grounds. No lack of competence or excess of delegation has been
demonstrated.
36.
In Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Union of India, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 813,
the Supreme Court reiterated that courts do not sit in appeal over
policy decisions reflected in statutory rules unless the policy is
manifestly arbitrary or unconstitutional.
37.
Therefore, the challenge to the amendment on the ground of
legislative incompetence is wholly misconceived.
38.
It is well settled that no government servant has a vested right to
promotion. At best, an employee has a right to be considered for
promotion in accordance with the rules prevailing on the date of
consideration.
39.
In State of Maharashtra v. Chandrakant Anant Kulkarni , (1981)
4 SCC 130, the Supreme Court categorically held:
“Mere chances of promotion are not conditions of service and can be altered by amending the rules.”
40.
Similarly, in Union of India v. Pushpa Rani, (2008) 9 SCC 242, it
was held that reduction of chances of promotion does not amount
to violation of Articles 14 or 16.
41.
The petitioners’ grievance is essentially that inclusion of another
feeder category has reduced their promotional prospects, which in
law does not confer any enforceable right.
42.
The principal contention of the petitioners is that work-charged
employees constitute a distinct class and cannot be treated at par
with regular employees. This Court finds no merit in the said
submission. The classification introduced by the impugned
amendment is educational qualification-based and experiencebased, and not solely dependent on the nature of establishment.
The Field Assistants of work-charged establishment have been
included only if they possess the same diploma/degree and
experience as prescribed under the Rules.
43.
In G.D. Kelkar v. Chief Controller of Imports & Exports , AIR
1967 SC 839, the Supreme Court held that the burden of proving
hostile discrimination lies heavily on the person alleging it.
44.
Further, in Dilip Kumar Garg v. State of U.P., (2009) 4 SCC 753,
it was held that the State has wide latitude in determining feeder
cadres and courts should not interfere unless the classification is
palpably arbitrary.
45.
The
reliance
placed
by
the
petitioners
on
U.P. Power
Corporation Ltd. v. Ayodhya Prasad Mishra , (2008) 10 SCC
139, is misplaced. The said judgment reiterates that unequals
cannot be treated equally, but it equally recognizes that
classification is permissible when founded on intelligible differentia
having nexus with the object sought to be achieved.
46.
In the present case, the object of the amendment is to remove
stagnation, provide career progression, and utilize qualified
technical manpower. The classification, therefore, satisfies the
twin test under Article 14.
47.
The petitioners’ reliance on Rule 2(d) of the Chhattisgarh Public
Services (Promotion) Rules, 2003 is also misconceived. The
Promotion Rules, 2003 are subject to the relevant Recruitment
Rules governing a particular service. Once the Recruitment Rules
themselves include a feeder category, the Promotion Rules
cannot be read in isolation to defeat the statutory scheme. This
position stands clarified in Biyani Shikshan Samiti v. Dental
Council of India, (2022) 6 SCC 65, wherein it was held that
delegated legislation must be read harmoniously with the parent
framework.
48.
In view of the foregoing discussion and findings, this Court
concludes that the writ petition suffers from gross delay; the
impugned amendment dated 22.01.2022 has been validly made in
exercise of powers under Article 309 of the Constitution; the
petitioners have no vested or accrued right to promotion, and
mere reduction of chances of promotion does not attract Articles
14 or 16; the inclusion of Field Assistants of work-charged
establishment as a feeder category is a policy decision, based on
rational classification, and does not suffer from arbitrariness or
unconstitutionality and the promotion orders dated 14.07.2023
and 29.08.2023 are legal and call for no interference and as such,
the writ petition fails both on merits and on the ground of delay.
49.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Chandra
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Head- Note
If the Government takes a step to improve the efficiency
of public service by amending the Promotion Rules in exercise
of power conferred under Article 309 of the Constitution of India,
such action cannot be held to be arbitrary or unreasonable.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review