Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100171 OF 2015 (C)
BETWEEN:
BASANAGOUDA SIDDANAGOUDA PATIL,
AGE: 54 YEARS, OCC : CHC B.NO.1441,
KAKATI POLICE STATION,
NOW WORKING AT ANKALAGI POLICE STATION,
TQ : GOKAK, DIST : BELAGAVI.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. A.M.GUNDAWADE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
STATE OF KARNATAKA,
BY SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH, AT : DHARWAD
THROUGH LOKAYUKTA POLICE, BELAGAVI.
…RESPONDENT
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Date: 2026.02.02
17:04:17 +0530
(BY SRI. ANIL KALE, ADVOCATE)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED U/S 374(2) OF CR.P.C.,
SEEKING TO CALL FOR THE RECORD FROM IV ADDL. DIST. &
SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPL. JUDGE (PCA) BELAGAVI PERTAINING TO
SPL. CASE NO.17/2013 AND TO PASS A JUDGMENT OF ACQUITTAL BY
SETTING ASIDE JUDGMENT OF CONVICTION AND ORDER OF
SENTENCE PASSED AGAINST THE APPELLANT IV ADDL. DIST. &
SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPL. JUDGE (PCA) BELAGAVI, IN SPL. CASE
NO.17/2013 FOR THE ALLEGED OFFENCES U/SEC.7, 13(1)(D) R/W
13(2) OF P.C. ACT, 1988.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
Heard Sri A.M.Gundawade, learned counsel for appellant
and Sri Anil Kale, learned counsel for respondent/Lokayukta.
2.
Accused who has been convicted in Special Case
No.17/2013 for offence punishable under Section 7, 13(1)(d)
read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988 (‘P.C. Act’, for short) is the appellant. He has been
sentenced as under:
“The
accused
is
hereby
sentenced
to
undergo
simple
imprisonment for 6 months for the offence punishable under Section 7
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
The
accused
is
hereby
further
sentenced
to
undergo
simple
imprisonment for one year for the offence punishable under section
13 (1) (d) R/w Sec. 13 (2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
and he shall pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- in default, he shall undergo
simple imprisonment for two months.
Both sentences shall run concurrently.
M O No. 1 an amount of Rs. 1,000/- is ordered to be confiscated to
Government and other MOs are hereby ordered to be destroyed after
the lapse of appeal period being worthless.
A free copy of this judgment be supplied to the accused.”
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
3.
Facts of the case which are very much necessary for
disposal of the present appeal are as under:
3.1
Complainant
and
his
wife
on
suspicion
were
summoned to the Kakathi Police Station on 03.06.2011 and
06.06.2011 in regard to a complaint lodged by Raju Sulabavi at
Siddheshwar Nagar, Kakathi that somebody has stolen the gold
from his house.
3.2
therefore,
Thereafter, they were repeatedly summoned and
the
complainant
went
to
the
Office
of
the
Superintendent of Police, Belagavi on 26.08.2011 and gave an
application that they have been harassed by the Kakati Police
Station unnecessarily and they wanted a settlement in the case.
In that regard, Suresh Koli and Suresh Kumbar were sent to the
complainant to admit the guilt. Accused who was working as a
Head
Constable
with
No.1441
in
Kakathi
Police
Station
demanded sum ₹1,000/- as a legal gratification to file a
favourable report against them on the ground that the same
needs to be paid to higher authorities.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
3.3
After the complainant met the Superintendent of
Police, Circle Inspector of Kakathi Police Station was directed to
bring the complaint registered by Raju Sulebavi to logical end.
Accused demanded illegal gratification to close the complaint.
Complainant was not willing to part away the illegal gratification
demanded
by
accused
and
therefore,
he
approached
the
Lokayukta Police Station, Belagavi and informed them about the
demand made by the accused. Thereafter, the conversations
were recorded and a detailed complaint in the handwriting of the
complainant was lodged with the Lokayukta Police.
3.4
Pursuant to the complaint, head of the raid party
summoned two independent government servants to act as
panchas for the intended trap and explained to them the
contents
of
gratification
the
complaint.
comprising
of
He
secured
one
currency
intended
illegal
note
₹500/-
of
denomination and five currency notes of ₹100 denomination,
noted
the
serial
phenolphthalein
numbers
powder
on
of
the
those
same,
smeared
the
currency
notes
and
demonstrated the chemical reaction of sodium carbonate solution
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
with the phenolphthalein powder and drafted experimental
mahazar.
3.5
Instructions were given to the complainant and one
of the panch witnesses to act as shadow witness to accompany
the complainant to the accused and observe the activities that
would take place when accused demands and complainant hands
over the tainted currency.
3.6
Accordingly, complainant, shadow witness proceeded
to the Kakati Police Station, met accused. Thereafter, the
accused enquired as to who has accompanied the complainant
and complainant told that he is his relative and all the three
persons went to the tea shop, consumed tea and on returning to
the police station near an electric pole, accused demanded the
illegal gratification and complainant handed over the tainted
currency to his hands. He took it in the right hand and kept it in
his pant pocket.
3.7
Immediately complainant gave pre-designated signal
by removing his cap from his head and all the members of the
raid party who were hiding nearby came there and apprehended
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
the accused. By then, there was drizzling. Therefore, all of them
went to the police station wherein the accused was asked to
handover the tainted currency and accused took out the same
from his pant pocket and handed over to head of the raid party.
Co-pancha was directed to tally the serial number of the
currency notes with the experimental mahazar and it tallied and
therefore, the illegal gratification of ₹1,000/- was seized by the
head of the raid party.
3.8
Subsequent thereto, the explanation of the accused
was obtained and thereafter he has been arrested.
3.9
Necessary documents were seized from the Kakati
Police Station and thereafter accused was produced before the
jurisdictional Special Judge and accused was remanded to
judicial custody.
4.
Lokayukta Police completed the investigation and
filed charge sheet.
5.
After charge sheet came to be filed, learned Special
Judge took cognizance of the aforesaid offences and secured the
presence of the accused and framed the charges for the offence
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
under Section 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) P.C. Act.
Accused pleaded not guilty. Therefore, trial was held.
6.
In order to bring home the guilt of the accused, nine
witnesses were examined on behalf of the prosecution as
Exhibits P1 to P9 and as many as 24 documents were placed on
record which were exhibited and marked as Exhibits P1 to P24.
Besides marking 13 material objects as MO1 to MO13.
7.
Special
On conclusion of recording of evidence, the learned
Judge
recorded
the
accused's
statement,
wherein
accused has denied the incriminatory circumstances, but did not
choose to file any written submissions nor led any defence
evidence.
8.
Thereafter,
learned
Special
Judge
heard
the
arguments of the parties and on appreciation of the material
evidence on record, convicted the accused for the aforesaid
offences and sentenced as aforesaid supra.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
9.
Being aggrieved by the same, accused is before this
Court in this appeal on following grounds:
“That, the Appellant is an innocent person and had not
committed any offences as alleged by the Prosecution
and he is entitled to be acquitted.
That, the Accused/Appellant is an innocent person and
has not committed any of the offences as alleged and is
entitled to be acquitted from the charges leveled against
him, by setting aside judgment of conviction and order
of sentence passed against him by the trial Court.
On perusal of the contents of first information ExP4given by PW-2 Channappa discloses that, the contents
of the information are imaginary one.
On perusal of entire evidence on record it will discloses
that, there is
no
believable evidence against the
Appellant for the proof of the charges leveled against
him.
The reasoning assigned by the trial Court in concluding
that, the Prosecution has proved beyond all reasonable
grounds, that, the Accused/Appellant is committed the
offences and found guilty for the offences punishable
U/s. 7, and U/s 13(1)(d) R/w. 13(2) of Prevention of
Corruption Act 1988, are not legally acceptable one and
judgment of conviction is required to be set aside.
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
PW-2 Channappa Basavanneppa Nandihalli is the main
witness who is the informant of the case and on perusal
of his evidence on record there is no clarity in his
evidence disclosing the clear evidence of demand and
acceptance of bribe money from him by the Accused
person and the evidence given before the Court is
contrary to the contents of Ex-P4, complaint material
facts.
The evidence of PW-2 even if taken to consideration
discloses that, about the allegation of theft against him
and his wife and enquiry in that regard by the Police was
already completed, this fact discloses that, there was no
work
was
pending
with
the
Kakti
Police
and
subsequently contacting him by the Accused person and
putting a demand of bribe
unbelievable
fact and
allegation.
On perusal of evidence of PW-2 his act and conduct is
completely of suspicion in nature and allegations are
unbelievable one and he wanted to misuse his liberty by
making unbelievable allegations.
The documents produced at Ex-P18 inrespect of the
enquiry against the Complainant in respect of theft
allegations was already completed earlier to 15-06-2012
and report was submitted to the S.P.Belagavi on 15-062012 itself, Ex-P18 makes it very clear.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
Even on perusal of the contents of Ex-P18 the enquiry
report also discloses that no work was pending with the
Kakti Police inrespect of the complainant Channappa
Nandihalli, on 18-06-2012 date of filing of the complaint
with Lokayukta case and registration of the case and
trap.
The PW-2 Channappa Nandihalli was considered to be as
a hostile witness by the Prosecution and he was
subjected to cross examination by the Prosecution, this
makes it clear that, his evidence is not a substantial
evidence to believe the allegations against the Accused
person as he goes on to admit the question put to him
by the Special Public Prosecutor.
The evidence of PW-1 nowhere discloses that, the
Appellant/Accused had demanded Rs.1000/- an illegal
gratification to do an official work or showing any favour
to the informant.
The production of the alleged bribe amount at the time
of entrustment mahajar Ex-P5 by PW-2 Channappa is
unbelievable fact.
PW-6 Smt. Drakshayini who is the wife of PW-2
Channappa against whom the allegation of theft was
made and enquiry was made by the Kakti Police stated
that after enquiry Accused told and assured that the
matter was settled and took their signature, had also
not stated anything about demand of Rs.1000/- by the
Accused persons.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
On perusal of evidence of PW-2 Channappa and PW-6
Drakshayini discloses that, there was no demand of
bribe money and during the course of the trial the
Prosecution tried to put suggestions to them about the
demand,
the
same
will
not
become
a
believable
evidence and even PW-6 totally denied the suggestion of
the Prosecution.
PW-3 Kamappa who appears to be accompanied PW-2
Channappa during trap proceedings allegedly witnessed
had also not fully supported the case of the Prosecution
and he was also treated as hostile witness.
In respect of the demand of bribe money by the Accused
as stated by PW-3 Kamappa is unbelievable evidence
and the same is also not supported by the main witness
PW-2 Channappa.
On perusal of the evidence on record the alleged
recovery
of
the
bribe
money
MO.No.1
is
also
unbelievable one. Since the evidence of the witnesses is
contrary to the contents of trap mahajar.
The evidence in respect of the hand wash of the
Appellant/Accused person in Sodium Carbonate solution
is also not clearly believable one since the evidence of
PW-2, PW-4, PW-9 are contrary to each other.
Inrespect of the evidence for the proof of recovery of the
bribe amount as deposed by PW-3 Kamappa, PW-4
Mahesh,
Mahajar
witness
and
PW-9
S.G.Patil,
investigation officer and the contents of the trap
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
mahajar Ex-P6 are contrary to each other and it makes
it clear that, the allegations are unbelievable.
The evidence on record nowhere clearly discloses that,
the Appellant has demanded illegal gratification nor he
has taken or obtained money by illegal means for
himself by misusing the official powers.
On perusal of the evidence of PW-2 Channappa and PW3
Kamappa
and
PW-4
Mahesh
who
are
material
witnesses discloses that, the Appellant/Accused person
was made a scapegoat to overcome the allegations of
theft made over against the PW-2 and PW-6. Apart from
this the Appellant/Accused has no power to take any
action against PW-2, PW-6 and also has no power to
submit a report in respect of the allegation against them
and no work was pending.
The sanction order issued as per Ex-P17 is not legally
acceptable one and the same is given without properly
considering the allegations available on record including
the allegations made against the complaint and his wife.
The trial Court erred in believing the evidence of
witnesses who have not fully supported the allegations
and their evidence appears to be given in compulsion
and i.e. also in hapzed manner.
The reasoning assigned by the trial Court in coming to
the conclusion is not legally acceptable one so as to
convict the Accused person for the alleged offence.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
The evidence in respect of the voice recorded is also
unbelievable, even that evidence also nowhere discloses
the demand and acceptance of the bribe money.
The trial Court erred in believing the evidence of
Prosecution and in passing judgment of conviction and
the sentence awarded is also appears to be harsh one.
The
evidence
of
the
Prosecution
is
not
beyond
reasonable doubt so as to convict the Accused persons..
10.
Sri A.M.Gundawade, learned counsel for the appellant
reiterating the grounds urged in the appeal memorandum,
vehemently contended in the case on hand, complainant has not
supported the case of the prosecution in toto except admitting
his signature on the complaint and deposing some preliminary
facts.
11.
Therefore, demand and acceptance of the illegal
gratification is not proved which is a sine qua non for
establishing the offence under Section 7, 13(1)(d) read with
Section 13(2) of the P.C. Act and therefore, order of the
conviction is bad in law.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
12.
He would further contend that as on the date of
alleged trap, already statements had been recorded by the
accused and it has been sent to the higher authorities.
Therefore, there was no work pending of the complainant so as
to show official favour by the accused in favour of the
complainant and hence, the conviction order is bad in law.
13.
He would also contend that the social activists
namely Suresh Koli and Suresh Kumbar are not examined by the
prosecution, which would expose the hollowness of case of the
prosecution and sought for allowing the appeal.
14.
He would further contend that the prosecution has
not been able to establish with sufficient proof about the all
ingredients of the offence namely demand of illegal gratification,
acceptance of illegal gratification and work of the complainant
pending so as to show the official favour in favour of the
complainant by misusing official position and therefore, order of
conviction is bad in law.
15.
He would further contend that the averments of the
complaint is incorrect as the present appellant being the Head
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
Constable of the Kakathi Police Station did not have any role to
play in the alleged pending work of the complainant in Kakathi
Police Station and therefore there was no occasion for the
appellant to demand sum of ₹1,000/- and thus, sought for
allowing the appeal.
16.
He would invite the attention of this Court to the
explanation offered by the accused which reads as under:
“ªÀiÁ£Àå r.J¸ï.¦ ¸ÁºÉçgÀÄ
PÀ£ÁðlPÀ ¯ÉÆÃPÁAiÀÄÄPÀÛ
¨É¼ÀUÁ«gÀªÀjUɪÀiÁ£ÀågÉ,
«µÀAiÀÄ: ZÀ£ÀߥÀà £ÀA¢ºÀ½î EªÀjAzÀ ºÀt ¥ÀqÉzÀ §UÉÎ.
-*ªÉÄïÁÌt¹zÀ «µÀAiÀÄzÀ §UÉÎ §gÉzÀÄ PÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÀÄ K£ÉAzÀgÉ, £Á£ÀÄ ZÀ£ÀߥÀà
EªÀ¤UÉ zÀÄqÀÄ PÉÆqÀĪÀAvÉ MvÁÛAiÀÄ DUÀ° ¨ÉÃrPÉ DUÀ° ªÀiÁrzÀÄÝ EgÀĪÀÅ¢®è
DvÀ£É £À£Àß ºÉArAiÀÄ ªÉÄÃ¯É EgÀĪÀ C¥ÁzÀ£ÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß PÀrªÉÄ ªÀiÁrj CAvÁ
MvÁÛAiÀÄ¢AzÀ £À£ÀUÉ ¨ÉÃqÀ CAzÀgÀÆ PÀÆqÀ 1000=00 gÀÆ. PÉÆnÖgÀÄvÁÛ£É.
EAzÀ §¸ÀªÀUËqÀ ²zÀÝ£ÀUËqÀ ¥Ánî
CHC/44/ PÁPÀw ¦.J¸ï.
vÁ: 18.06.2012
PÁPÀw.¦.J¸ï.”
17.
Therefore, it is the argument of Sri A.M.Gundawade
that the appeal needs to be allowed by setting aside the order of
conviction.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
18.
Lastly, he would contend that there was no certificate
as is contemplated under Section 65(b) of the Evidence Act so as
to believe the alleged conversation between the accused and the
complainant which is part of pre-trap mahazar and therefore, the
same cannot be treated as demand and acceptance and sought
for allowing the appeal.
19.
Per contra, Sri.Anil Kale would contend that, in the
case on hand, only on the suspicious complainant and his wife
has been harassed by the Kakathi Police in respect of the
complaint lodged by Raju Sulebhavi.
20.
He would further contend that, when the harassment
was unable to be borne by the complainant he visited the office
of the Superintendent Police, Belgavi and complained about the
harassment. Pursuant thereto, instructions were issued from the
office of the Superintendent Police, Belgavi to the Circle
Inspector of Police and therefore the matter was required to be
closed.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
21.
In that regard, the complainant and his wife visited
the police station and at that juncture, it is the present appellant
who demanded a sum of ₹.1,000/- to submit a favourable report,
under the guise of paying the same to the higher authorities.
Since the complainant was not interested, he approached the
Lokayuktha Police. The complaint lodged by the complainant is in
his own handwriting, which he has admitted during the crossexamination by the Public Prosecutor.
22.
He also specifically admitted about the payment of
the bribe money near the electric pole, which has been handled
by the accused by taking the same in the right hand and keeping
it in his pant pocket, which has been established not only
through the trap mahazar, but also through the oral testimony of
the complainant as well as the shadow witness which would be
sufficient enough to establish the demand and acceptance of
illegal gratification.
23.
Therefore, all the ingredients required for the proving
of the offence under Section 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)
of the P.C.Act, have been established by the prosecution and
thus sought for dismissal of the appeal.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
24.
He would further contend that very fact that the
tainted currency has been seized from the pant pocket of the
accused, that too in the PSI chamber of Kakati Police Station and
in the absence of any proper or plausible explanation offered by
the accused, it should be presumed that the said tainted
currency was handled by the accused in respect of the illegal
gratification for which he had made a demand with the
complainant, as is found in the complaint averments and thus
sought for dismissal of the appeal.
25.
He also argued that mere non-production of the
certificate under Section 65(b) or non-seizure of the mobile
phone would not cause any dent to the case of the prosecution,
inasmuch as the conversation with regard to demand and
acceptance is incorporated in the pre-trap mahazar and no such
conversation is recorded at the time of trap. Therefore, he seeks
dismissal of the appeal.
26.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, this Court
perused the material on record meticulously.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
27.
On such perusal of the material on record, the
following points would arise for consideration:
(i)
Whether the prosecution has successfully established
the necessary ingredients to attract the offence
punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with
Section 13(2) of the P.C.Act?
(ii)
Whether the impugned judgment is suffering from
legal infirmity or perversity and thus calls for
interference?
(iii)
Whether the sentence imposed is excessive?
(iv)
What order?
Regarding Points (i) and (ii) :28.
In order to appreciate the case of the parties, it is
just and necessary to cull out the admitted facts available on
record, which reads as under:
A complaint came to be lodged by Raju Sulebhavi
alleging that there was a theft of gold in his house on
02.06.2011.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
Complainant and his wife were summoned to the Kakati
Police
Station
on
03.06.2011
on
the
ground
of
suspicion.
The complainant and his wife were again summoned on
06.06.2011.
According to the averments in the complaint, they were
harassed by repeated calls to the police station.
The complainant and his wife visited the office of
Superintendent of Police, Belgavi.
Instructions were given from office of Superintendent
of Police, Belgavi to Circle Inspector of Police.
The complainant met the accused, who was a Head
Constable having the buckle No.1441 of Kakati Police
and requested the matter to be closed.
The
accused
handled
the
tainted
currency
on
18.06.2012 at about 06.00 p.m. near the electric pole
situated between the Kakati Police station and a tea
shop.
The tainted currency was recovered from the pant
pocket of the accused in the cabin of PSI Kakathi Police
Station by head of the raid party.
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
The serial numbers of the tainted currency recovered
from the pant packet of the accused tallied with the
serial numbers recorded in the experimental mahazar
in Ex.P-5.
Hand wash of the right hand of the accused in sodium
carbonate solution turned pink and colour test stood
positive.
Likewise, the colour test for the pant packet of the
accused stood positive.
The FSL report, marked at Ex.P24, confirms that traces
of phenolphthalein powder were found in the material
objects placed on record as MOs.1,10 and 12.
29.
The following points are disputed facts, culled out
from the material on record:
(i)
The alleged demand made by the accused.
(ii)
The role of accused in the handling the complaint of
Raju Sulebhavi and in filing a favourable report.
(iii) The claim that the complainant and the shadow
witness were strangers to the accused.
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
(iv) Whether any work of the complainant was pending
with the accused?
30.
In the light of the above admitted and disputed
factual aspect, when the
material
evidence
on record is
re-appreciated, it is to be noted that PW-1 is an Engineer who
drafted the spot sketch vide Ex.P-2 and his evidence is formal in
nature.
31.
support
PW-2 is the complainant, who made a half-hearted
in
his
examination-in-chief.
Therefore,
with
the
permission of the Court, he has been treated as a hostile witness
and cross- examined by the learned Public Prosecutor.
32.
During
the
cross-examination
on
behalf
of
prosecution, the contents of the complaint and the trap mahazar
were confronted to him. The complainant not only admitted the
contents of the complaint but also admits that the entire
complaint averments are in his handwriting and admitted his
signature.
As per the settled principles of law, a complaint or
FIR can be utilized not only for the purpose of contradictions but
also to corroborate the case of prosecution.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
33.
supported
Therefore,
even
the
of
case
the
though
complainant
prosecution
in
toto
has
not
in
the
examination-in-chief, such of the answers which are elicited by
the Public Prosecutor during the course of cross-examination of
PW-1, were sought to be corroborated with the contents of the
complaint, it is crystal clear that there was a demand made by
the accused on the date of the trap for illegal gratification, that
too outside the police station, in the public place near the electric
pole which was situated between the tea shop and the police
station.
34.
Further, the accused was supposed to be inside the
Kakathi police station and if the complainant and the shadow
witness are totally strangers, as is sought to be canvassed on
behalf of the appellant, there was no necessity for the accused to
accompany the strangers to a tea shop, that too during the
working hours of the police station.
35.
known
Therefore, it is presumed that the complainant was a
person
and
of
acquaintance
to
the
accused
and
statements has been prepared by the accused which would
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
favour the complainant and his wife and later on, on the day of
trap, he had taken their signatures also on those statements.
36.
Therefore, the isolated answers elicited in the cross-
examination of the Investigation Officer, that the documents had
already been sent out from the table of the accused to his higher
authorities and therefore there was no work pending as on the
date of trap, cannot be countenanced in law.
37.
Further, if the work was already completed as is
elicited in the cross-examination of P.W.9, why the accused
contacted
the
complainant
to
his
mobile
telephone
on
16.06.2012 and made a demand is a question that remains
unanswered.
38.
Admittedly, the date of trap is 18.06.2012 and if
necessary favourable reports have been made by the accused on
15.06.2012, then was there any necessity for the accused to call
the complainant on his mobile telephone is again a question that
remains unanswered.
39.
It is to be noted that the accused has taken a
defence as referred to supra that the money was forcibly handed
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
over to him. The scene of the offence is the public road.
It is to
be noted that electric pole which was situated in between the tea
shop and the Kakti police station is the place where the
complainant actually handed over the tainted currency in the
presence of the shadow witness to the accused.
40.
It is not the case of the accused that it was forcibly
put into the pant pocket of the accused. In fact, it was handed
over by the complainant to the accused and accused took the
tainted currency in his right hand and then kept it in his pant
pocket. Immediately, pre-designated signal is given. In fact the
trap mahazar mentions all these activities as the remaining raid
party members were watching all these proceedings by parking
the jeep on the service road.
41.
In other words, since the incident has occurred in the
day light and what was transpiring in between the complainant
and the accused in the presence of the shadow witness was also
witnessed by other members of the raid party and soon after
they received the pre-designated signal, all of them arrived at
the spot and enquired the accused after showing the identity of
the head of the party and thereafter, he accepted that the
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
money has been received by him and kept in his pant pocket.
When the tainted currency was about to be seized, it started
drizzling. Therefore, the entire raid party along with the accused
and complainant, visited kakti police station and in the chambers
of Police Sub-Inspector, further proceedings took place. In the
presence of shadow witness, co-pancha, head of the raid party,
complainant and other members of the kakti police station,
tainted currency was recovered from the pant pocket of the
accused.
42.
Hand wash of both the hands have taken place in
separate Sodium Carbonate solution kept in bowls.
The bowl
which contained the Sodium Carbonate solution wherein right
hand wash took place turned into pink colour was separately
seized and sealed. M.O.9 is the right hand wash of the accused
which turned into pink colour. Unless accused had handled the
tainted currency; there could not have been colour test turned
positive.
43.
Defence as is taken by the accused that the tainted
currency has been forcefully handed over to the accused has not
been proved atleast by placing plausible evidence on record.
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
44.
Under
such
circumstances,
the
demand
and
acceptance and colour test being turned positive and tainted
currency has been accepted for furnishing the favourable report,
this Court is of the considered opinion that the prosecution is
able to establish all necessary ingredients to attract the offence.
45.
No doubt, few contradictions are elicited in the
cross-examination of prosecution witness. Much is also argued
about the non-production of Section 65(b) certificate insofar as
the proof of demand is concerned so also non-seizure of the
mobile telephone in which it has been recorded.
46.
Admittedly, those are the part of pre-trap mahazar
that was only to ensure that the contents of the complaint is true
and that did not by itself establish the demand and acceptance of
the tainted currency on the day of trap.
47.
In
other
words,
non-furnishing
of
the
65(b)
certificate, non-seizure of the mobile telephone on the day of
trap did not cause any dent muchless serious dent to the case of
the prosecution as the prosecution did not rely upon that
evidence
for
the
proof
of
demand
and
acceptance
as
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
complainant, shadow witness and recovery of the tainted
currency
have
acceptance
established
more
so
having
that
there
regard
to
was
demand
and
the
improper
and
improbable defence being taken and not establish by the
accused.
48.
Therefore,
the
prosecution
is
successful
in
establishing all ingredients which has been rightly appreciated in
the impugned judgment by the learned Trial Magistrate if not in
happy words and with logical reasons.
49.
Even after reappreciation of the material evidence on
record, this Court does not find any legal infirmity or perversity
in reaching out the conclusion that accused is guilty of the
offences punishable under Section 7 and 13(1)(d) punishable
under Section 13(2) of the P.C. Act.
50.
Accordingly, point Nos.(i) and (ii) are answered in
affirmative and negative respectively.
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
REG. POINT No.(iii):
51.
Learned
Trial
Magistrate
after
taking
into
consideration all the relevant aspects of the matter, has imposed
six months imprisonment for the offence punishable under
Section 7 of the P.C. Act and to undergo simple imprisonment of
one year for the offence under Section 13(1)(d) read with
Section 13(2) of the P.C. Act and imposed fine of Rs.5,000/- with
default sentence.
52.
This Court does not find any reasons whatsoever to
reduce the same and it is minimum sentence that has been
imposed by the learned Trial Magistrate.
53.
In view of the foregoing discussions, point No.(iii) is
answered in negative.
REG. POINT No.(iv):
54.
In view of the findings of this Court on point Nos.(i)
to (iii) as above, following:
ORDER
i.
Appeal is meritless and hereby dismissed.
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1013
CRL.A No. 100171 of 2015
HC-KAR
ii.
Appellant is directed to surrender before the
Trial Court on or before 10.02.2026 to serve
remaining part of the sentence failing which
he shall be secured through the process
known
to
law
for
serving
remaining
sentence.
iii.
Office is directed to return the Trial Court
Records with copy of this order forthwith.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
CLK,RHR,KAV
Ct-cmu
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review