Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
Reserved on : 09.04.2026
Pronounced on : 08.06.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 08TH DAY OF JUNE, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
WRIT APPEAL NO. 2074 OF 2025 (BDA)
BETWEEN:
BANGALORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
BY ITS COMMISSIONER,
KUMARA PARK WEST,
T. CHOWDAIAH ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560 020.
(APPELLANT IS REPRESENTED BY SPECIAL
LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, BDA)
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. DHYAN CHINNNAPPA SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. K. KRISHNA, ADVOCATE)
REKHA R
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
SRI. CHENNAKESHAVA S.,
S/O LATE D.L. SRINIVAS,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
R/AT NO.230, MAHAVEER
CORNER APARTMENTS,
KENGERI UPANAGARA,
KENGERI,
BANGALORE - 560 060.
2.
THE TAHASHILDAR,
BANGALORE SOUTH TALUK,
BANGALORE - 560 001.
-2-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
3.
SRI. CHOODAPPA,
S/O DEVAPPA,
AGED MAJOR,
R/AT NAGEGOWDANAPALYA,
B. M. KAVAL, KENGERI HOBLI,
BANGALORE SOUTH TALUK,
BANGALORE - 560 062.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ASHOK HARANAHALLI SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. NARASIMHARAJU, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1,
SRI. ARUN G.S. AGA, FOR R2)
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE
THE ORDER OF THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE PASSED IN WP
NO.23061/2022 DATED:20.11.2025 AND DISMISS THE WRIT
PETITION.
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR JUDGMENT, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT IS DELIVERED/ PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF)
This
intra
Court
appeal
is
by
the
Bangalore
Development Authority1 calling in question the order dated
20th November
passed
by
the
Writ
Court
in
No.23061/2022.
2.
By the impugned order, the Writ Court allowed
the Writ Petition and granted prayer sought in the Writ
the BDA, for short
-3-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
Petition along with other directions to take action against
the erring officials of the BDA.
3.
The parties are referred to as per their ranking
before the Writ Court.
4.
Facts germane to filing of this appeal are as
under:
4.1
The case of the Writ Petitioner before the Writ court
was that his grandfather purchased the land in an
auction held on 04.06.1951 and the name of his
grandfather - Sri.Lakshmaiah was entered in respect
of 04 Acres of land in Sy.No.107, Block No.11 of BM
Kaval Village, Bangalore South Taluk.
4.2
A Notification came to be issued by the BDA under
Section 17(1) & (3) of the Bangalore Development
Authority Act, 19762 proposing to acquire a total of
1,532 Acres 17 Guntas of land, spread over 8
villages, including BM Kaval (194.15 Acres) for the
formation of the proposed Banashankari VI Stage
the BDA Act, 1976
-4-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
Layout and the Bangalore - Kanakapura Main Road.
The
name
of
the
petitioner's
grandfather
was
reflected in the Preliminary Notification in respect of
04 Acres of land at Sl.No.209. However, the BDA
issued Final Notification on 10.09.2003 under Section
19 of the BDA Act, 1976 in which the 04 Acres of
land
shown
against
the
name
of
petitioner's
grandfather were not included. Thereafter, the BDA
issued another Notification under Section 17(1) & (3)
of the BDA Act, 1976 dated 19.09.2003 wherein the
land
shown
against
the
name
of
petitioner's
grandfather was specifically excluded/ dropped from
acquisition and subjected to pay betterment Tax
under Section 20 of the BDA Act, 1976. This clearly
shows that the land was excluded from acquisition.
However, the authorities of the BDA saying that the
land has been acquired under the Final Notification in
the name of respondent No.3, disbursed a sum of
Rs.44,09,660/- as compensation to respondent No.3
who is not at all connected to the family, on the basis
-5-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
of a fabricated document styled as Gift Deed which
was alleged to be executed by Lakshmaiah in the
year 1981, whereas the said Lakshmaiah had expired
on 30.09.1978, which is evident from Annexure-C.
4.3
The said respondent No.3 - Choodappa got mutation
entries in his favour subsequent to the Preliminary
Notification dated 07.11.2002 i.e., on 14.11.2002
and
substituted
his
name
with
the
name
of
Lakshmaiah. The officials of the BDA though aware of
all the subsequent actions viz., under Section 19 of
the BDA Act, 1976 wherein the land shown against
the
name
of
Lakshmaiah
were
not
included,
subsequently directed to pay betterment charges
under Section 20 of the BDA Act, 1976 issuing
notification under Section 18(3) of the BDA Act, 1976.
However, disbursed the compensation amount as if
the land is acquired in favour of Choodappa, That
apart, allotted 04 sites to Choodappa as incentive
sites for the acquisition of lands. There are several
other proceedings concluded before this Court in
-6-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
W.P.No.8783/2008 and 46644/2011, so also Writ
Appeal No.444/2013. The BDA Authorities are now
coming on the petitioner for recovery of the amount,
as such the petitioner filed the present Writ Petition
seeking following reliefs:
PRAYER
WHEREFORE this Honourable court be
pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus directing
the Respondent No.1:
a.
To have 4 acres of land culled out of survey
No. 107, Block No.11 of B.M Kaval, Bangalore
South Taluk, and mark the same by metes
and bounds and release the same in favour of
the petitioner, as the sole surviving legal
representative of late Lakshmaiah and his son
Srinivas, after collecting such Betterment fee,
as may be legitimately due in respect of the
said land.
a(1)
Declaration to declare that the land bearing
Sy.No.107/P20 measuring to an extent of 4
acres of B.M Kaval Village, Kengeri Hobli,
Bangalore
South
Taluk,
excluded/
dropped
proceedings
by
Bangalore
from
virtue
the
of
stands
acquisition
the
Gazette
Notification dated 12-09-2003 bearing No.BEM
APRA:VIBHUSWA
AA:A4:PR:834:2003-04,
Bangalore
12-09-2003
dated
as
per
ANNEXURE-H & consequently restraining the
-7-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
respondents authority from interfering with
the
possession
and
enjoyment
of
the
petitioner over the aforesaid property.
a(2)
or in alternative direct the 1st respondent to
determine the compensation to the subject
property as per Right to Fair Compensation
Act, 2013 to the property of the petitioner.
b.
To
direct
the
respondent,
through
its
Commissioner, to initiate appropriate criminal
and civil investigation as to the actions of the
personnel who were involved in the acquisition
proceedings, pertaining to the subject land of
the petitioner and particularly with reference
to the release of compensation amount to the
Third respondent and also the release of the
four
incentive
house
sites
to
the
said
respondent and to submit a report, in due
course.
c.
Grant such other writ, order or direction, as
deemed appropriate in the circumstances of
the case and in the interest of justice.
4.4
Before the Writ Court, the BDA contended that
earlier
action
under
Section
18(3)
and
excluding the land and directing them
in
to pay
betterment charges was under misconception and
misdirected which has been clarified in the earlier
Writ Petition and taking note of the same, the Writ
-8-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
Court earlier directed the petitioner to approach the
appropriate Forum and sought to dismiss the Writ
Petition.
4.5
The Writ Court after considering the entire material
meticulously, especially in Paragraph Nos.19 and 22
has held that the action of the respondent Authorities
i.e., the BDA was deliberate, intentional and the
same was done without holding a proper verification
or inquiry as contemplated under the law, disbursed
the amount and allotted 04 incentive sites where the
land was never acquired and mutation was effected
only after the issuance of Preliminary Notification. As
such, the omission to conduct a minimum scrutiny,
where the proceedings having been already dropped
as per Annexure-H, renders the action of the BDA
wholly unsustainable. Further held that, despite the
proceedings having been dropped, despite the land
never having vested in the BDA, the officials of the
BDA released a sum of Rs.44,09,660/- and allotted
04 incentive sites to a person who had no semblance
-9-
WA No. 2074 of 2025
of title, action, which the BDA itself acknowledged in
Annexure-K, the objections filed in the earlier Writ
Petition, as such the action was undertaken without
statutory authority and held that the same amounts
to fraud and fraud vitiates every administrative act,
as no rights can accrue from it, and no public
authority can shelter behind it and consequently, the
BDA's entire action stands vitiated and cannot
withstand
the
contemplated
judicial
reeks
scrutiny
with
as
malafides.
the
action
Accordingly
answered the point framed by it at paragraph No.18
in favor of the petitioner and allowed the Writ
Petition. It is this order passed by the Writ Court is
called in question in this appeal by the BDA.
5.
counsel
Heard, Sri.Dhyan Chinnappa, learned Senior
assisted
by
Sri.K.Krishna,
learned
counsel
appearing for the BDA, Sri.Arun.G.S, learned AGA for
respondent No.2 and Sri.Ashok Haranahalli, learned Senior
counsel assisted by Sri.Narasimharaju, learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.1.
- 10 -
WA No. 2074 of 2025
6.
We have heard both the learned Senior counsel
for the contesting parties. After much deliberation, the
matter was listed for hearing on 12.03.2026, on the said
date
further
time
was
sought
till
01.04.2026.
On
01.04.2026, learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf of
the BDA has submitted that the petitioner way back in the
year 2020 sold the entire property and has suppressed
this important material fact before the Writ Court and
obtained an order which is unsustainable in law. As such
he has lost interest in the property and he has no locus
standi to prefer the Writ Petition seeking reliefs which are
no more amenable to him in view of the settled position of
law.
7.
Learned Senior counsel for the appellant sought
time to file an affidavit producing the copy of the Sale
Deed and sought time till 09.04.2026. On 09.04.2026,
when the matter was listed, an application was filed being
I.A.No.2/2026 seeking permission to produce Absolute
Sale Deed dated 08.02.2020 executed by the petitioner
along with his wife in favour of one Mr.Devadas Shetty and
- 11 -
WA No. 2074 of 2025
one Mr.A.Mahesh Shetty conveying the entire land in
dispute in the Writ Petition for sale consideration of
Rs.6,00,00,000/-. A copy was served well in advance on
respondent No.1, however no objections were filed.
8.
To the query of the court, learned counsel for
respondent No.1 is answerless to say anything on the
registered Sale Deed on instruction. But admitted the fact
that he has already sold the property.
9.
Further, to the query of the Court, what was
the impediment for him to not to disclose the said fact in
the Writ Petition, again counsel for contesting respondent
No.1/ petitioner is answerless to substantiate anything.
10.
Considering this aspect of the matter, since the
Sale Deed was executed in 2020, which was not within the
knowledge of the BDA and the same came to its
knowledge subsequently and since the BDA has fulfilled
the conditions as contained under Order XLI Rule 27 for
production of document, we allow the application and has
taken the document on record. After considering the said
- 12 -
WA No. 2074 of 2025
document and the conduct of the petitioner, on a short
point, this appeal is required to be disposed of on
maintainability of the Writ Petition as rightly contended by
the
Sri.Dhyan
Chinnappa,
learned
Senior
appearing for the BDA. The petitioner once
counsel
having
conveyed the entire property i.e., the property in dispute
way back in the year 2020, has lost all his right, title and
interest in the property and possess no locus and right to
stake any challenge to the actions of BDA by means of
prayer sought in the Writ Petition. In these circumstances,
the Writ Petition filed by the petitioner is required to be
dismissed as not maintainable.
11.
There are catena of Judgments by this Court as
well as the Supreme Court which held that, a person loses
right to seek challenge to acquisition proceedings once he
sells the property in dispute, as he loses his interest in the
property. In that view of the matter, without expressing
anything on the merits of the case and even on the order
passed by the Writ Court, we dispose of this appeal
- 13 -
WA No. 2074 of 2025
holding
that
the
Writ
Petition
filed
by
contesting
respondent No.1/ petitioner is not maintainable.
12.
Our
view
gain
strength
with
the
judicial
pronouncement of Coordinate bench of this Court in the
case of H.N.SHIVANNA & OTHERS VS. STATE OF
KARNATAKA AND ANOTHER3, wherein at Paragraph
No.41, the Court held as under:
"40. In view of the findings recorded earlier that
under the Act, it is permissible to issue successive
notifications under Section 28(4) of the Act the challenge
to the acquisition on that ground has to necessarily fail.
However, it was contended in view of the settled legal
position, the final notification ought to have been issued
within a reasonable time of one year and the award
ought to have been passed within a reasonable time of
two years from the date of final notification and in the
instant case, the final notification had been issued nearly
after five years from the date of preliminary notification
and the award having been passed nearly after 4 years 8
months from the date of final notification, the entire
acquisition proceedings lapses. Certainly, the said ground
would have been a valid ground for the petitioners, if
they had not sold their property immediately after the
preliminary notification. On the day they filed the writ
petitions they were not the owners of the property. The
principle underlying acquisition being vitiated on account
of delay is, once a preliminary notification is issued, the
compensation payable being the market value, the said
value is pegged to the date of preliminary notification.
Any delay in issuance of final notification and passing of
the award determining compensation would obviously
affect the interest of the land owners because they are
paid compensation on the basis of the market value
prevailing on the date of the preliminary notification. In
the instant case, the question of paying the
2013 (4) AKR 163
- 14 -
WA No. 2074 of 2025
compensation would not arise since within three months
from the date of preliminary notification, the petitioners
have sold the property. Therefore, it is clear that the
petitioners did not intend to retain the property and
hence have sold the property within three months from
the date of preliminary notification. They got the market
price and enjoyed the said value of the property. Now
they cannot be heard to say that the final notification,
which is issued 4 years 8 months after the preliminary
notification, vitiates the acquisition proceedings, on the
ground that they are deprived of the market value of the
property.”
(Emphasis supplied)
13.
We
are
alive
to
the
situation
that
any
observations or deliberations on the merits of the case,
having considered on the basis of the materials placed
before the Writ Court may prejudice either party, as per
the contention of learned Senior counsel appearing for
contesting respondent No.1/petitioner that, the same
would affect the rights of the subsequent purchaser, when
the entire action are held that the officials have acted
arbitrarily and without any authority of law in disbursing
the amount and granting 04 incentive sites to a person
who was neither in possession nor having any right, title
or interest in the property as the entire claim was based
on an unregistered document said to have been executed
by a dead person after three years of his death and only
- 15 -
WA No. 2074 of 2025
on the entry in the RTC on the basis of such document
which cannot be considered as document for the purpose
of entering acquisition rights as provided under the
provisions of Karnataka Land Revenue Act. Accordingly,
we dispose of this Writ Appeal holding that the Writ
Petition filed by the contesting respondent No.1/ petitioner
is not maintainable. However, making it clear that we have
not expressed any view of ours on the merits of the case
as considered by the Writ Court.
14.
In view of disposal of Writ Appeal, pending
interlocutory applications, if any stand disposed of.
Sd/(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/(T.M.NADAF)
JUDGE
TKN
Ct: Vn
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review