Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP No.37308 of 2025
20 (O&M)
%#B
%#BCB<D %$ < 5 @ 6
+" %$ 4( (%! B#
B#<B# < A
###### "("(%!
####
#
!"
'%!- !"
# )!!7 1# (!:.+, -3%4+"
$%
% ""& ' "("(%! 5 6#
# )!*+!
&"+, --.# # #, )!
)!*+/#
# &)/&+0 1+) &(2, -3%4+"
$%
%
'%!- !" %#?#
EEEE
, # 5 +.6
& ' "("(%!
-+" - ;#< # <
%.. 4"% ,
%$ "&
/+
, /7 8+7 %$ '
5 !! F)
6 '+
%&+.
&+.( 5$% &% " G
+!-
449)( ("(%!
!" ' "("(%!,
- /7
H6,
H6 8&
4", D;? 5$%
2 9)+ &(!: %$ +! % -
'%!- !"
%#
+!-
49)( ("(%!
("(
/7 "& ( +''.(4+"(%! )!&% " G"&
4"H6 "+!-
4"(%! D
* 4" - / (!:
(
- /7 .(0("+"
"+"(%!#
= >
( $.7 "+"(!:, %0 .+!- %8! - /7 "& ' "("(%! 5 6 .+!-%8!
! 56
$% 0(!: '+ " %$$ "&
"
3 !)
"+" %$
(..+:
++9/+,
& (. +!-
4+0 "% / +49
49)( - 3(- !%"($(4+"(%! -+" - B#<A# <<
)!8
4"(%! ? @ A %$ "&
+(!
%$ "&
+ 2 " +"
MOHMED ATIK
2026.03.25 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
)..+')
+" %$
::
: ( 3 - "&
@ <#<A# << ( ) -
' 4"(3 .7 $% "& ')/.(4 ') '%
%$
""(!: )' +
+2&+, ( " (4"" )-&(+!+# ! 8+ - )!-
4" 8+ +!!%)!4 - /7 "&
- " 0(! - +"" "&
/ ! $(" #
4"
( " (4" )-&(+
(+!+,
#A .+2& '
4"(%!
4"(
%! B# # <<B +!- "& 4%0' ! +"(%!
! 8+
+44
%$, %0 %$ "& %"&
"&
/ (-
: +!" %$ %"&
.+!-%8!
' $
"+")"%
")"% 7
-
$
!4
!
CWP No.37308 of 2025
20 (O&M)
)!-
4"(%!
!
5 !! F)
D %$ "&
4", 8&(4& 4+0
6 /7 "& . + ! -
$
!4
"% /
- 4(- - %!
?# # < B
%) " 8&(. - " 0(!(!: "& 0++ 2 "
3+.) %$ "& +49)
49)( - .+!- +" "&
+" %$
# <,<<
,<<,<<<J '
+4 #
=B>
+(- +8+ -, "& ' "("(%!
' $
- +! +''.(4+"(
+"(%!
4" / $%
'%
'%!- !"
%#
%! B<#<B## <
6, 8&(4& 4+0 "% / -( 0(
- / (!: /+
+ - %! "& +$%
)!-
4"(%!
5 !! F)
D
-+" - ;#< # <
=? >
'+'
%$ "&
5 !! F)
6#
?# # < B '+
- /7 "& . + ! -
4% - &%8 "&+", /+ - %! "&
- +! +''.(4+"(%!
+''
)!-
'%!- !"
%#
$
(!:
$
:).+
:).
%) ", "& %"&
( "
'' +. $% $) "&
' F %) " (! +!8+ ( +!- %"&
.+!-%
-%8!
/ $%
$
!4
%) "#
% %3 ,
+'' %+4& - "&(
!!&+!4 0 !", +!- "&
%) " /7
+0 +
"(..
DDB< < ? "4##
"&+", (! " 0 %$ .+8 .+(- -%8! /7 "&
3 # + 7+!+
+!+ "+"
% '% +"(%! (0(" - 5
5 (3(.6 B H, "& ' "("(%!
MOHMED ATIK
2026.03.25 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
4" %! B<#<B# <
! %$ )4& +'' ++. , + '%(!" - %)" /7 "& . + ! -
"0
0+7 / !%"(4 - &
%$ "&
%%$ "&
- /7 "& . + ! -
!4
4%)! . $% ' "("(%!
"("(
5 6, (
3 .%'0 !""
%%) ", "& ' "("(%! 5 6 .+!-%8!
! 56
4% - "&+" +:: ( 3 - %$ "& - " 0(!+"(%! -+" - ?# # < B /7
' !-(!: $% +-*)
-*)-(4+"(%!#
=A >
8+ - -+" -
, 8&(4& 8+ +''+ !".7
".7 $(. - / 7%!- + ' (%- %$ "&
(" &+ +. % 4%0 %!
"& . + ! -
!4
4"(%! D
0%!"& $ %0 "& -+" %$ +8+ - '+
D
+!- :%! "& %):&
& "&
"
/%%2#
' ) +. %$ "&
' $
!" 8 (" ' "("(%!#
&
&+3
& + - . + ! - 4%)! . $%% "& '+ "(
= >
' $
!4 , "& '
- /7 .(0("+"(%! 3(- % -
.+!-%8!
%!I/
!I/.
!-) " (+. +!- !$ + " )4")
6 ++!- +!%"& I
&+3 "&
'% " - + G < 5 6
(:&" "% (!3%2
4"(%!
4"(
4" 3 ! (! ') )+!4 %$ "& $(!+.. - " 0(!+"(%! 0+- /7 "&(
%)
) " (!
CWP No.37308 of 2025
20 (O&M)
"&
' !-(!:
.+!-%8!
:).+
( "
'' +. , ' $
' "+(!(!:
"+
"% "&
+0 +49)( ("(%!##
"& +$% 0 !"(%!
(%! - *)-:0 !" +
G #
! "& '
F" +4" - &
)!!-
(! "+!4
%$ ' "("(%!
!
. 3+!" '+ +: +'& % #
@ A %$
))!-
!" 4+ , (" ( !%"" (! -( ')" "&+" "&
8++ +..%8 - /7 "&
< A 8+ (!
- +" "&
( "
(:& %) " 3((- *)-:0 !" +!- % -
' 4" %$ "& .+!- 8&(4&
(4& 8+ 4%3
'' +. 8&(4&
8&(
-+" - !--
- /7 "&
+0 !%"($(4+"(
(4+"(%!
8&(4& !%"($(4+"(%! "& +'' ..+!"
.+!" I .+!- ( +. % 4%3
-# " ( +.. % !%"
!
(!! -(
- ')" "&+" "& +0%)!" +8+ - - //7 "&
'' +. ( (! F4
%$
% "&
(:&
%) " (! "&
+(-- ( "
%$ "& +0%)!" +8+ - - /7 "&
%.. 4"% )!-
4"(%!
4"(
D;? 4" (! "& 4+
%$ "&& .+
.+!- %$ "& +'' ..+!" # " ( +. % !%" (!
-(( ')"
'
"&+" "& +'' ..+!" &+- !%"" 0
0+- +! +''.(4+"(%! "% "&
)!!-
+7
4"(%!
D %$ "&
D;?
%..
.. 4"%
4"# " ( +. % !%" (! -( ')" "&+"
+" "&
"
+''.
''.(4+"(%! 0+- /7 "& +'' ..+!" )!
)!-
4"(%! D
"&&
0%!"& $ %0 "& -+" %$ "&
"
%.. 4"% 8+ 8("&(! + ' (%- %$ "&
*)-:
)-:0 !" +!- % - %$ "&
A#
%$ "&
D;? 4" "%
(:& %)) "#
%0 "& ' ) +. %$ "& *)-:0
0 !!" %$ "&(
%) " (! "& 4+
%$
+- '
1)0
)0+ ( 5 )' +6, (" ( 4. + "&+" "& .(
.(0("+"(%! $% 0%3(!: "& +''.(4+"(
(4+"(%!
)!!-
4"(%! D
%$ "&
D;? 4" 8
8(.. / :(! "% )! %!.7 $ %0 "& -+" %$
"&& +8+ - %! "& /+ ( %$ 8&(4&
- " 0(!+"(%! %$ "& 4%0' ! +"(%!
"(%! (
%):
%):&"# & +'' ..+!" +
- " 0(!+"(%! %$ "& 4%0' ! +"(%!
(%! %!
2(!:
"&& /+
/ ( %$ "& *)-:0 !" +!- % -
%$ "&
? ; %$ < B -+" - !-
+7 < A# " ( !%" -( ')" - "&+" "& +''.(4+"(%!! %$
"&& +''
+ ..+!" )!-
4"(%! D
"&&
+7 < A#H
0%!"& $ %0 !-
%$ "&
) ""& , "& - 4( (%! 0+- (! "& 4+
&+ +. % / ! $%..%8
$%
- /7 "&
!-(+ +!- +!%"&
%"& 3 # &
"+" %$
MOHMED ATIK
2026.03.25 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
(3( (%!
4" ( 8("&(! + ' (%- %$
%$ +!8+ ( +!- %"&
!4&& %$ "&(
, < 5B6
%) " (! 4+
5 )' +6
%$ K !(%!
(%! %$
5 (3(.6 CDA#
% %3 , (! " 0 %$ &+ +" (!:
!:: J%
+&++ + &" + @
D;?
49)(
' 4(+. +!- 49
)( ("
("(%! %.. 4"% 4)0 )/ (3(( (%!+.
(%!
+!- %"&
+:( " +" , +"&+!2%"
+"&+
=C >
(:& %) " (! ( " '' +. %#
#,
).+/ (!:& +2&+- @
'% " - + G < DD5 6
; H, %!4 "&
#
:).+
:)
#
CWP No.37308 of 2025
20 (O&M)
( "
'' +.
' $
- +" "&
(! "+!4
%$ "&
- " 0(!+"(%! %$ 0+ 2 " 3+.) ' "+(!(!: "% "&
' !-(!: / $%
"&(
"
%) ", (" 8+ 0%
%"&
.+!-%8!
9)+ "&
"
+0 +49)( ("(%! ' %4 -(!: 8
+'' %'' (+
(+" $%
'%!- !"
%# "% 8+("
(" $%
"& $(!+. %)"4%0
%0 %$ )4& +'' +.
+"&
"&+!! +-*)-(4+"(!: )'%! "& +''.(4+"(
+"(%!
' $
%$
"&
4"
. 3+!" '+ +: +'&
% #
-
' "("(%!
)!-
4"(%!
J.+!-%
-%8!
#
*)-:0 !" +
F" +4" - &
G #
D
+"
"&
(! "+!4
%$
"&
"
"% C %$ "& +$% 0 !"(%!
(%! -
)!-
! "& 4+
%$ "& +'' ..+!" , 8& ! "& (
- 4(4( -, /+ - %! +8+ - (!
+8+
8+ - 8
%#
B +!-
; %$ ;DB, "& 3 7 +0
"&
(:&
' !-(!: (! +'' +. / $$%
%.. 4"% ' %4 - - "% 4%! (# <# <<<# &
+$" , $
4"(%! D +''.(4+"(%!
%! 8+
%) "#
%8 3 , "&
"
"& ( +''.(4+"(%! +!- - 4(- - "&
& +''.(4+"
(4+"(%! )!-
C#< # <<; /+ - %! "& *)-:0 !"" %$ "&
4"(%! D
+0
0 %!
8+ $(.. - %!
(:& %) " -+" - B#<B# <<;# "
8++ "&( +''.(4+"(%! "&+" 8+ & .- "% / !%" 0+(!"+(!+/. , / (!: +
4%!4%
+''.
''.(4+"(%!#
A#
&%):& "&
( !% 9)+
. 8
8("& "& ' (!4('. "&+" %!.7 + (!:.
(!:
+''.
''.(4+"(%! ( 0+(!"+(!+/. , (! "& (! "+!" 4+ , )!$% ")!+" .7, "&
%) " %0("" - "% "+2 !%" %$ "& $+4
$+4" "&+" "& +'' +. %! "&
+8+
8+ - 8
( "&
' !-(!: 8& ! "&
(!!
&
4"(%
4"(%! D +''.(4+"(%! 8+ - 4(- -## &+"
&
4"(%! D ( + / ! $(4(+. ' %3( (%!#
4"(%! D
%#
+''
'' +. "&
B +!$ %0 8
+''.(4+"(%!! -+
-+" - B # # ;; /+ - %! "& +8+
8+ ; %$ ;DBB 8
8+ - 4(- - %!
' !-(!:#
&
' (!4('.
(!4 , "&
(:& %) " ( 4%
(0')
0'):! - *)-:0 !" "&+" "&
4"(%!
4"
D
(! 3( 8 %$
0+(!
+(!"+(!+/. #
- 4(- - %!
B#<B# <<;#
;#
!
4" +!
+!- *) "($( - (! "& 3( 8 "+2 ! (! "&
"
4+!!%
+!!%" /
)44
(3 +''.(4+"(%! )!-
+- ' 1)0
)0+ ( 5 )' +6# )" "&+" ( !%" "& '%(!"
'%
+ ( (!:
( $% 4%! (- +"(%! &
C#< # <<; $%
# <# <<< 8& ! "&
"
%.. 4"% %):&" "% &+3 2 '" "&
"
+''.
''.(4+"(%! ' !-(!: "(.. "& +'' +. 8
MOHMED ATIK
2026.03.25 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
.(( - %!
' 4(+. +!- -( "(!4"(3 $+4")+.. '% ("(%! (! "& (! "+!" 4+ # " 0) " +.
+ %
/ 2 '" (! 0(!- "&+"
C#
(:&
(
#
% --%)/", "&
4%!- +''.(4+"(%! -+" -
$(F+"(%! (! .(:&"" %$ "& +'' ..+" 4%) " *)-:0 !" ( !%"
!
%8 3 , (!4 "&
%.
%.. 4"% ( +. % +" $+)." (! - 4(-(!:
!: "&
"
CWP No.37308 of 2025
20 (O&M)
+''.
''.(4+"(%! 8& ! "& 0+""
8+ ' !-(
!-(!: (! +'' +., 8 +
%$ "& 3( 8 "&+"
"&
(!! "& ' 4).(+ $+4" %$ "& (! "+!"" 4+ , "& +''.(4+"(%! -+" - B # # ;;
;
&%)
&%).- / 4%! (-
- +$
$%..%
%..%8 # &
49)( ("(%! %..
.. 44"% ( -( 4" - "% 4%! (-
+!-
&#
44%% --(!:.7, "& +'' +. ( -( '% - %$ +
4"(%!
4"
D +''.(4+"(%! -+" - B # # ;;; +!- '+ % *)-:
)-:0 !" %$ "&
C< %$
& "&
"
(! "& .(:&" %$ "&
"
(:& %) " -+" - B#<
B#<B# <<; (! ( " '' +. % # A; +!+
;;C %! "&
) ++!:+/+-# %
-+"
+" -
+$
$(.
%$ "&
!+/.(!: "&
# <# <<< (
(:&
%) " %$
%... 4"% "% '+
%-
%0/+7,
!4& +"
+ +/%3 , "& % -
" + (- # %8 3 , "& +0%)!" +. +-7 '+(- +
"% /
-).7
).7 +-*) " -#H
=D >
)4&, (! 3( 8 %$ "& +$%
F'% ("(%! %$ .+8 /7 "&
8 .. +
%!I/.
+!8+
8+ ( +!- %"&
)' 0
' !-(!: 4.+(0 9)+
9)
4"(%!
D
( "
/7
:).+
+
:).+
%$ "&
'' +. , "& (
%#
-#
- +" "& (! "+!44 %$
"(.. ' !-(!: +-*)-(4+"(
+"(%!#
( &
/7
" + (- #
'%!- !"
F+0(! "& +''
''.(4+"(%! -+" - < # # < ; ' $
2(!:
( "
4" / (!: "(0 /++
''' +. ' $
! )4& 4( 4)0 "+!4 , "& (0'):!
:! - % '%!- !""
4" %! "& /+ ( %$
- " 0(!+"(%! %$ 4%0' ! +"(%! 8+ !%" "% / - 4.(! - 8&(.
8&
) "& 0% , "& $+4" "&+" "&
=; >
%$ "&
%) " (! "& ' !!-(!:
4"(%! D
.+!-%8
%8!
%$ &+ +" (!: 5 )' +6 +
%) " (! 4+
* 4"(!: "& ( +''.(4+"(%!
+'
$(. - )!-
$ 8 %"&
+!- "&
"
5 )' +6, %!4 "& ' "("(%! 5 6 .+!-%8! 5 6 8+
!"(". - "% 0+2
+2 +''.(4+"(%! )!- " 0(!+"(%! 0+0
/7 "&(
+(- $+4" +!- 4( 4)0 "+!4
-+" - ;#< # <
%#
'++
-
( -( 4" - "%
- /7 "& ' "("(%!
.+!-%8!
8!
- " 0(!+"(%!
%$ 4%0' ! +"(%! /+ - %! "& $(!+. - " 0(!+"(%! "% /
0+- /7 "&(
%
%) " (! "& ' !-(!:
:).+
( "
'' +. + ( (!: %)" %$ "&( 3 7
+49)( ("(%! 8("&(
("&(! "8% 0%!"& $ %0 "& - 4( (%! (! +(- +'' +.5 6# " ( 0+- 4. +
"&+" "& +''.(4+"
4+"(%! -+" - B<#<B# <
' $
%$ "&
4" +"
"& (! "+!4 %$$ ' "("(%!
&+.. !%"
%" / - 4.(! - / (!: "(0 /+
-## " (
MOHMED ATIK
2026.03.25 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
.+!-%8!
- )!-
4"(%! D
CWP No.37308 of 2025
20 (O&M)
$) "&
0+- 4. + "&+" (! 4+
"&
%$ %"&
.+!-%8!
8!
-, "& ' "("(%!!
-( 0(
( "
'' +. ' $
.+!-%8!
- +" "& (! "+!4
"+!
&+.. /
!"(". - $%
"& / ! $(" %$ !
!&+!4 0 !" %! "& /+ ( %$ +8+
8+ - -+" - ?# # < B '+
- /7
7 "&
"
. +! -
+
:).+
$
!4
!
%) " +.%!:8("& +.. %"&&
' %3(- - )!-
""&
4" 8("&(! "8% 0%!"& %$ "& +-*)-(4+"(%! /7
'%!- !" %# #
= <>
<>
&(
%) " ( %$ "& $( 0 %'(!(%!! "&+" "& ' "("(%!
.+!-%8!
"&(
"+: , +
!
!"(". - $%
+4
%! '+ ("7 /+ ( , + : +!" - "% "& %"&
/ ! $(" ' %3((- - )!. +! -
$
!4
(0(.+ 4%0' ! +"(%!
(%! +" "&
"&
%) "# &
4" + '
"&
( "
+!- (!""
"+")"%
)"% 7
+8++ - -+" - ?# # < B '+
- /7
7 "&
"
"% "&
- "% "& ' "("(%!
$$ 4" "&+" (! 4+
'' +. ' !-(!: / $%
"&(
8("&
("&(!
)/* 4" "%
"& +0%)!"" +
%) ", "& 7 &+..
= >
('
'% - %$$ +44% -(!:.7#
= >#
>#
!
!-(!: +''.(4+"(%!5 6, ($ +!7 &+..
.. ++. % "+!- -( '% - %$#
+ 4& B, < A
"(2
MOHMED ATIK
2026.03.25 17:13
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
order/judgment
' +2(!:J + %! '% "+/.
, +"
+.%!:8("& %"&
+0 #
& "&
& "&
"
# <,<<,<<<J '
4 ('" %$ 4 "($
"($( - 4%'7 %$ "&( % -
$) !( &(!: (!- 0!("7
/%!- "% "&
:).+
+" %$
.+!
.+!-%8!
+(- +0%)!" / --( /)
"8% 0%!"& $ %0 "& -+" %$
-)4 - (! "&
"+")"% 7 / ! $("
J %
J %
$)!$)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review