Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:9419
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9948 of 2025
1 - Balkrishna Tiwari S/o Late Dr. J.C. Tiwary Aged About 62 Years Reader
Grade- I, Commercial Court (District Judge Level) Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar,
District- Raipur (C.G.)
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through- Principal Secretary, Government Of
Chhattisgarh, Law And Legislative Affairs Department, Mahanadi Bhawan,
Mantralaya, Nava Raipur, Atal Nagar, Raipur (C.G.)
2 - The Registrar General Hon’ble High Court Of Chhattisgarh, Bodri Bilaspur
District Bilaspur (C.G.)
3 - The Principal District And Sessions Judge Balodabazar DistrictBalodabazar- Bhatapara (C.G.)
4 - Judge Commercial Court (District Judge Level), Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar
District Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Joint Director Treasury Accounts And Pension, City Treasury, Nagar
Ghadi Chowk, Raipur (C.G.)
BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
6 - Kailash Sahu The Then A.S.A- Accounts And Pension City Treasury,
Nagar Ghadi Chowk, Raipur, (C.G.) At Present A.S.A.- Pension Shakha,
District Treasury, Durg (C.G.)
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Pawan Kesharwani, Advocate
For Respondent-State No.1
:
Ms. Anuja Sharma, Dy.G.A.
For Respondents No.2 to 4
:
Mr. Dhiraj Kumar Wankhede, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
ORDER ON BOARD
23/02/2026
1.
Petitioner has filed this writ petition against the order of recovery dated
12.08.2025 seeking following reliefs :“10.1 May, this Hon’ble Court be pleased
to call for the records of the case
pertaining to the petitioner from the
respondents for its kind perusal.
10.2 May, the Hon’ble Court be pleased to
set-aside the impugned Notice dated
02.08.2025 and order dated 12.08.2025
(Annexure P-1) passed by respondent
No.4 directing the petitioner to deposit the
amount of Rs.2,22,603/- within 15 days.
10.3 Any other relief which this Hon’ble
Court may deem fit in the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
2.
Learned counsel for petitioner submits that petitioner was working as
Reader Grade-I under the respondent No.4 which is a Class-III post.
After attaining the age of superannuation, he retired from service on
30.09.2025.
Respondents
have
issued
an
order/notice
dated
02.08.2025 (Annexure P-1) for recovery of an amount of Rs.
2,22,603/- on the ground that excess payment is made to petitioner
due to wrong pay fixation. Excess amount is paid for the period from
02.10.2013 to 30.06.2025. It is contention of learned counsel for
petitioner that in view of decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of State of Punjab & ors vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) &
ors, reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 recovery of excess payment from
the petitioner/Class-III employee is not permissible. He also contended
that from the face of the order it is apparent that excess payment is not
made to petitioner because of his misrepresentation or any fraud
played by petitioner to the respondent-department. Recovery of
amount if paid in excess towards salary cannot be made from him.
Therefore, action on the part of respondent-department in deducting
the amount as mentioned towards excess payment is per se illegal
and arbitrary.
3.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents opposes the
submission of learned counsel for petitioner and submits that from
order Annexure P-1 it is apparent that excess payment has been made
to petitioner due to wrong fixation of pay for the period from
02.10.2013 to 30.06.2025 and petitioner has also given undertaking
for recovery of amount, if paid in excess to petitioner. He contended
that the case of respondent is covered by the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case of
Punjab and Haryana and others vs.
Jagdev Singh, reported in (2016) 14 SCC 267, Chandi Prasad
Uniyal vs. State of Uttrakhand and others reported in (2012) 8 SCC
417, Syed Abdul Qadir & Ors vs. State Of Bihar & Ors. reported in
2009 (3) SCC 475, Col. (Retd.) B.J. Akkara vs. The Govt. Of India &
Ors reported in 2006 (11) SCC 709
4.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents enclosed along with writ petition.
5.
From the arguments which is advanced by learned counsel for the
respective parties it is not in dispute that petitioner was holding the
post of Reader Grade-I, which is Class-III post, he was paid excess
payment due to wrong fixation of pay for the period from 02.10.2013 to
30.06.2025. It is not the case of respondents that excess payment is
made to petitioner due to misrepresentation or suppression of fact or
any fraud played by petitioner with respondent-department.
6.
In case of Rafiq Masih (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court considering
the issue of recovery of amount paid in excess has summarized the
situations where in certain cases, even recovery from the Class-III and
Class-IV employee by the employer would not be permissible in law. In
Para-18 it was observed thus:“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations
of hardship which would govern employees on
the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in
excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove,
we may, as a ready reference, summarise the
following few situations, wherein recoveries by
the employers would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to
Class-III and Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and
Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or
employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period in
excess of five years before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an
employee has wrongfully been required to
discharge duties of a higher post, and has been
paid accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an
inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court
arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if made
from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh
or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far
outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer's right to recover.
7.
So far submission of learned counsel for the State that petitioner has
given undertaking/ consent for refund of the excess amount paid to
him at the time of fixation of pay. Though the pleading is made by the
State that petitioner had given undertaking for return of amount if paid
in excess, however, no such document is enclosed along with reply. In
absence of any such document in this regard, pleading itself will not be
sufficient to arrive at a conclusion that petitioner had submitted any
undertaking at any point of time for return of the amount, if paid in
excess. Even if some undertaking is given then also it will not be a
ground for respondent-department to recover the amount when
Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Rafiq Masih (supra) in categorical
terms has held that recovery of excess amount from Class-III and
Class-IV employee is impermissible in law.
8.
In case of High Court of Jagdev Singh (supra), Hon’ble Supreme
Court though had considered the issue with regard to the undertaking,
however, Para-10 (i) of the decision in case of Rafiq Masih (supra)
has not been overruled or interfered. This aspect is also considered by
the Division Bench of this Court in WA No.264/2020 (State of CG vs
Labha Ram Dhruv) wherein it was observed thus:
“9. In the case at hand, the Revision of
Pay Rules, 2009 and 2017 do not make
any enabling provision reserving option for
the employer to seek refund of the amount
paid in excess, by making the employee to
furnish an undertaking. Even if we
conclude, for the sake of arguments, that
even in the absence of enabling provision
under the Rules, undertaking given by the
employee would operate, the fact remains
that against the classes of employees
against whom recovery would be
impermissible in law, as held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Rafiq Masih (Supra), recovery from the
employees belonging to Class-III and
Class-IV service (or Group 'C' and Group
'D' service) would still be impermissible in
law. Meaning thereby that even when
undertaking is submitted by the employee,
but he otherwise belongs to Class-III and
Class-IV service, and the amount has been
paid more than 5 years back, the law
declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the matter of Rafiq Masih (Supra) would
still hold the field in favour of such
employees, because the judgment in the
matter of Rafiq Masih (Supra) has not been
overruled, but only clarified, by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in its later judgment in the
matter of Jagdev Singh, Supra”
9.
From perusal of the above, it is clear that the recovery from the
employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV category (or Group 'C'
and Group 'D' service) is held to be impermissible in law. Meaning
thereby that even if undertaking is submitted by the employee, but he
otherwise belongs to Class-III or Class-IV service, recovery of excess
amount from him/her is impermissible and that too after retirement
from the service.
10.
The other decisions as relied by learned counsel for the State is prior
to the decision in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra).
11.
In the case at hand, admittedly, petitioner was holding a post of ClassIII in the Law and Legislative Affairs Department. It is also not the case
of respondents that petitioner had received excess payment by
practicing fraud or by making misrepresentation. Thus, petitioner could
not have been compelled to return the amount which has been paid by
the respondents on their own without any misrepresentation or fraud
on the part of petitioner.
12.
In light of above decisions and in the given facts and circumstances of
the case, in the considered opinion of this Court, the respondents
cannot be permitted to effect recovery from the petitioner of the
amount paid in excess and being so, recovery against petitioner is not
sustainable.
13.
Consequently, writ petition is allowed and the impugned recovery
notice dated 02.08.2025 and order of recovery dated 12.08.2025
(Annexure P-1), is hereby quashed. Respondents are directed to
return back the amount, if recovered from petitioner towards recovery
of excess payment, within a further period of 04 months from the date
of receipt of order passed by this Court, failing which the recovered
amount shall carry interest @ 8% p.a. from the date of order passed
by this Court till its realization.
Certified copy as per rules.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
JUDGE
Balram
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review