Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/25
GAHC010058122024
2026:GAU-AS:10269
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/1678/2024
BALEN BARO
S/O- LATE BANO BARO, R/O- VILL.- KUCHIZAR, P.O. BHAWANIPUR, P.S.
AND DIST. BARPETA, ASSAM, PIN- 784352.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM, PWD (R) DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006.
2:THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL (A AND E)
ASSAM
MAIDAMGAON
BELTOLA
GUWAHATI-781036.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PWD (RR) DEPARTMENT
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI-3.
4:THE TREASURY OFFICER
BARPETA
DIST. BARPETA
ASSAM
5:EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWD (RR)
BARPETA DIVISION
DIST. BARPETA
Page No.# 2/25
ASSAM
6:ASSTT. EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWD
PATACHARKUCHI TERRITORIAL ROAD
SUB- DIVISION PATHSALA
BARPETA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR H DAS, MR. B C DEKA,D BARUAH
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, PWD ROAD, SC, FINANCE,SC, AG
Linked Case : WP(C)/6384/2025
BALEN BARO
S/O LATE BANO BARO
R/O VILLAGE- KUCHIZAR
P.O.- BHAWANIPUR
P.S.- BARPETA
DISTRICT- BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN- 784352
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
PWD (R) DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
2:THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL (A AND E) ASSAM
MAIDAMGAON
BELTOLA
GUWAHATI- 781036.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PWD (RR) DEPARTMENT
CHANDMARI
Page No.# 3/25
GUWAHATI-3.
4:THE TREASURY OFFICER
BARPETA
DISTRICT- BARPETA
ASSAM.
5:EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWRD (RR)
BARPETA DIVISION
DISTRICT- BARPETA
ASSAM
6:ASSTT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWD
PATACHARKUCHI TERRITORIAL ROAD
SUB-DIVISION PATHSALA
BARPETA.
-----------Advocate for : MR H DAS
Advocate for : SC
PWD appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 24.07.2026
Heard Mr. H. Das, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner in
the above noted 02 (two) writ petitions. Also heard Mr. P. Nayak, learned
Additional Advocate General, appearing for the State Respondents as well
as Mr. R. Boro, learned Standing Counsel, Accountant General (A&E),
Assam, appearing for the respondent no.2.
2.
The petitioner by way of instituting WP(C).No.1678/2024, has
Page No.# 4/25
assailed a communication dated 30.09.2020, by which he was directed to
appear before a Enquiry Committee, constituted for ascertaining as to
whether the petitioner had over stayed in his services. The petitioner has
further prayed for a direction for release of his current salaries w.e.f. the
month of August, 2020, and for continuance of the same till his actual
date of retirement i.e. 31.07.2026.
In WP(C).No.6384/2025, the petitioner has prayed for a direction
upon the Respondent Authorities for correction of his date of birth
recorded in his service book as “31.12.1956” to “28.07.1966”.
3.
The petitioner, herein, was initially engaged as a muster roll labour
in pursuance to the death of his father who was at that relevant point of
time engaged as muster roll worker in the establishment of the
respondent no.6. Such engagement of the petitioner as a muster roll
labour was so effected vide a communication dated 18.07.1985. The
petitioner being a pre 01.04.1993 engagee, his case was covered by a
policy decision taken by the Government of Assam, for regularization of
services of muster roll /work charged/casual employees, engaged prior to
01.04.1993.The case of the petitioner being so processed, on due
approval being granted by the Government, the services of the petitioner
came to be regularized vide order dated 07.10.2005 w.e.f. 22.07.2005. As
the petitioner was discharging his duties as a regular employee in the
Page No.# 5/25
establishment
of
the
respondent
no.6,
a
communication
dated
30.09.2020, came to be issued to him requiring him to appear before a
Enquiry Committee on 07.10.2020, for ascertaining as to whether he had
over stayed in his service.
Thereafter, the enquiry so held having been concluded, the Enquiry
Committee submitted its report in the matter. However, the salaries of the
petitioner was withheld w.e.f. August 2020. The Enquiry Committee on
appreciating the statements made by the petitioner before it as well as
from
the
statements
of
the
Departmental
Authorities
and
the
contemporaneous records, had come to a conclusion that the petitioner
was involved in the manipulation of his service records in connivance with
one Mahananda Sarma, who was the Dealing Assistant. Accordingly , the
petitioner was held to be responsible for the over stay in service
occasioning in his case, which was held to have caused huge financial loss
to the Government. The Enquiry Committee, on a consideration had found
that the date of birth in his service book was recorded as 31.12.1956,
basing on a school certificate produced by the petitioner.
Being aggrieved by the conclusions reached by the Enquiry
Committee in its report dated 20.10.2020, the petitioner had instituted
WP(C).No.1678/2024.
During the pendency of WP(C).No.1678/2024, the petitioner had
Page No.# 6/25
again instituted a writ petition being WP(C).No.6384/2025, praying for
correction of his date of birth as recorded in his service book. The date of
birth now required to be recorded in his service book is demonstrated to
be 28.07.1966.
4.
Mr. H. Das, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner, by
reiterating the facts, noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that the
petitioner had submitted a school certificate dated 27.05.2005, before the
Respondent Authorities for the purpose of determination of his date of
birth at the time when his services were being considered for
regularization. He submits that from the school certificate as produced by
him, his date of birth is found to be recorded, therein, as “28.07.1966”. He
submits that accordingly, the petitioner would retire from his services only
w.e.f., “31.07.2026”. However, the Respondent Authorities had prevented
the petitioner from continuing in his services w.e.f. August 2020 and the
salaries of the petitioner are in arrears w.e.f. August 2020.
5.
Mr. H. Das, submits that the Respondent Authorities by projecting
that the date of birth of the petitioner was “31.12.1956”, basing on a
similar certificate brought on record by some other person, had proceeded
to hold that the petitioner had over stayed in his services. He submits that
no Departmental proceedings came to be instituted against the petitioner
in this connection. However, an enquiry being directed, the petitioner had
Page No.# 7/25
appeared before the constituted Enquiry Committee. He submits that the
Enquiry Committee on a superficial examination of the records as well as
the contentions raised by the petitioner, had proceeded to hold that the
petitioner was due to retire from his services on “31.12.2016” upon
verification of the records. It was further submitted that one Mahananda
Sarma was a prima facie responsible for allowing the petitioner to
continue upto July 2020 and for the reasons of which, a loss to the tune
of Rs.12,46,113/- (Rupees Twelve Lakhs Forty Six Thousand One Hundred
Thirteen), had occasioned to the Government exchequer. Mr. Das,
highlights that the Enquiry Committee recommended institution of
appropriate Disciplinary Action against said Mahananda Sarma and the
petitioner, herein, as well as for recovery of the amount drawn as salary
by the petitioner during the period of his such over stay. He further
submits that no proceedings came to be instituted against the petitioner in
the matter.
6.
Mr. H. Das, further submits that the Respondent Authorities, not
having further proceeded in the matter by instituting a Departmental
proceeding against the petitioner, no recovery would be permissible to be
so made from the pension and pensionary benefits of the petitioner after
he had retired from his services on reaching the age of superannuation.
7.
Mr. H. Das, further submits that a penalty of censure was imposed
Page No.# 8/25
upon Mahananda Sarma for his role in allowing the petitioner to continue
in his services beyond his date of superannuation. Mr. H. Das, thereafter
by referring to the date of birth of the petitioner recorded in his Pan Card,
Aadhar Card, Voter’s List etc, has submitted that in all the said
documents, the date of birth of the petitioner was recorded as
“28.07.1966”. He submits that the same being Government documents,
the date of birth as recorded, therein, corresponding to the date of birth
recorded in the school certificate produced by the petitioner i.e.
“28.07.1966”, the same was mandated to be so considered by the
Respondent Authorities and a rectification was mandated to be carried out
with regard to the date of birth recorded in the service book of the
petitioner as “31.12.1956”. Accordingly, he prays that the impugned
Enquiry Report be set aside, with a further direction to the Respondent
Authorities to effect correction in the date of birth of the petitioner as
recorded in his service book. He also prays that the petitioner be
thereafter, permitted to continue in his services till 31.07.2026, by
reckoning his date of birth to be “28.07.1966”, with all due consequential
benefits.
8.
Per contra Mr. P. Nayak, learned Additional Advocate General,
appearing for the State Respondents, at the outset has submitted that in
the order issued towards regularization of the services of the petitioner as
well as in the proposal submitted in this connection before the
Page No.# 9/25
Government, the date of birth of the petitioner was recorded as
“31.12.1956”. The petitioner at no point of time had raised any objections
in this connection. Mr. Nayak, submits that the said date of birth recorded
against the name of the petitioner in the orders/documents relating to the
regularization of his services was so recorded basing on a school
certificate furnished by the petitioner. He submits that on the services of
the petitioner being regularized, his service book was opened and therein,
also the date of birth of the petitioner was recorded as “31.12.1956”, and
the petitioner in acceptance of the same as well as the other particulars
recorded, therein, appended his thumb impression.
9.
Mr. P. Nayak, learned Additional Advocate General, submitted that
in the GPF account opened in respect of the petitioner his date of birth
was recorded as “28.12.1956”, and the said date was reflected in all the
statements that were issued to the petitioner over period of time. Mr.
Nayak, further submits that the petitioner had never raised any objection
in this connection. Mr. Nayak, by referring to the Enquiry Report of the
Enquiry Committee, constituted to ascertain as to whether the petitioner
had over stayed in his services, has submitted that the Enquiry Committee
basing on the materials coming on record during the Enquiry had
conclusively held that such over stay in services of the petitioner is on
account of manipulations made by him in connivance with the Dealing
Assistant of the establishment, wherein, the petitioner was serving. He
Page No.# 10/25
submits that the over stay in service by the petitioner after the date of his
retirement was admittedly on account of reasons attributable to him and
accordingly, the salaries drawn by the petitioner during such period of
over stay, would mandate to be recovered.
10.
With regard to the prayer made by the petitioner for correction of
his date of birth recorded in his service book, Mr. P. Nayak, submits that
the said prayer was made only after the petitioner had retired from his
services basing on the date of birth so recorded in the service book. The
petitioner after the regularization of his services, opening of his service
book as well as his GPF account, had never approached the Respondent
Authorities, praying for rectification of his date of birth. Mr. Nayak, submits
that the petitioner in support of his said prayer had produced a School
Leaving Certificate dated 27.05.2005, with his date of birth recorded,
therein, as “28.07.1966”. He submits that the said certificate was not the
certificate produced by the petitioner while his case for regularization of
his services was being so considered and further that the said certificate
was not found available in the service records maintained in the
establishment, wherein, the petitioner was serving. Accordingly, he
submits that the said certificate cannot be given any credence.
11.
In the above premises, Mr. P. Nayak, submits that the petitioner
must be deemed to have superannuated from his services on completion
Page No.# 11/25
of 60 years of age by reckoning his date of birth as “31.12.1956” i.e. the
petitioner is to be deemed to have retired from his services w.e.f.
31.12.2016. He further submits that the salaries drawn by the petitioner
w.e.f. 01.01.2017 till 31.07.2020 would mandate to be recovered from the
petitioner. He submits that the salaries drawn in excess by the petitioner
has already been quantified at Rs,12,46,113/- (Rupees Twelve Lakhs Forty
Six Thousand One Hundred Thirteen).
12.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused
the materials available on record.
13.
The petitioner’s case for regularization of his services was
processed by reckoning his date of birth to be “31.12.1956”. The said date
of birth was recorded against the name of the petitioner in the order
issued by the Government towards approving the regularization of
services of the petitioner. Thereafter, the petitioner was regularized in his
services vide an order dated 07.10.2005 w.e.f. 22.07.2005. In pursuance
to the regularization of his services, the service book of the petitioner was
opened and therein, his date of birth was recorded as “31.12.1956”,
basing on a school leaving certificate, furnished by the petitioner. The
petitioner now being a regular employee and also entitled to pension and
pensionary benefits, a GPF account came to be opened in the name of the
petitioner. From the statements of the said GPF account, it is found that
Page No.# 12/25
the date of birth of the petitioner, therein, was also recorded as
“28.12.1956”. The petitioner during his long period of service w.e.f 2005
till 2016, had never approached the Respondent Authorities highlighting
any error existing in his recorded date of birth in his service book as well
as in his GPF account. The respondents on a scrutiny being made with
regard to the payment of salaries in the establishment, wherein, the
petitioner was serving and then it having come to the notice of the
Respondent Authorities that the petitioner was to retire from his services
on 31.12.2016, and had over stayed in his services, an Enquiry Committee
was constituted and the petitioner was directed to appear before the said
Enquiry Committee. The Enquiry Committee on a consideration of the
materials coming on record, during the Enquiry as well as appreciating the
statements made before it by the petitioner and on appreciating the
contemporaneous records, found that in the records maintained with
regard to the services of the petitioner, his date of birth was recorded as
“31.12.1956” which was based on a school leaving certificate, wherein, his
date of birth was recorded as “31.12.1956”. The other School Leaving
Certificate, relied upon by the petitioner, wherein, his date of birth as
recorded as “28.07.1966” was not to be so found available in the records.
The Enquiry Committee had then examined the role of one Mahananda
Sarma, a Dealing Assistant in the establishment, and thereafter,
proceeded to draw a conclusion that the records were manipulated by the
Page No.# 13/25
said dealing Assistant, in connivance with the petitioner which had led to
the petitioner over staying in his service. The Enquiry Committee also
concluded that the petitioner was due to retire on “31.12.2016”, as per
the contemporaneous records of his service. Mahananda Sarma, was held
to be a prima facie responsible for permitting the petitioner to continue in
his services after 31.12.2016 till July 2020. Further, the Enquiry
Committee had quantified the amount recoverable from the petitioner on
account of his over stay to be Rs.12,46,113/- (Rupees Twelve Lakhs Forty
Six Thousand One Hundred Thirteen).
14.
Having drawn the said conclusions, the Enquiry Committee, had
recommended for initiation of appropriate Disciplinary action, both against
the said Mahananda Sarma, and the petitioner, herein, for recovery of the
amount drawn as salary by the petitioner during the period of his over
stay in his services.
15.
From the materials brought on record, this Court does not find
that the said recommendation made by the Enquiry Committee was acted
upon by the Respondent Authorities in respect of the petitioner, herein.
The petitioner may have a hand in over staying in his services beyond the
date of retirement but the exact role of the petitioner in the matter was
not
determined by the
respondents by drawing an appropriate
Departmental proceedings against him. Accordingly, the allegation of
Page No.# 14/25
misrepresentation and/or manipulation committed by the petitioner in the
matter in the considered view of this Court remains in the realm of a
speculation only.
16.
The Respondents from the date of birth of the petitioner recorded
in his service book as well as in his GPF account, had the knowledge that
the petitioner was slated to superannuate from his services w.e.f.
“31.12.2016”. However, it is not found that any notice in this connection
came to be issued to the petitioner intimating him about his date of
superannuation from service. Accordingly, the Respondents also cannot be
held to be not blameworthy for the over stay in service occasioning in
respect of the petitioner, herein. This Court notices that the petitioner was
earlier a muster roll worker and thereafter, was regularized as a Grade-IV
employee and accordingly, he cannot be imputed with the knowledge of
the niceties of the Service Rules and Regulations and the date of his
superannuation was one aspect which was to be monitored by his
superiors in his Department.
17.
Accordingly, having drawn the said conclusions, with regard to the
over stay in service by the petitioner, this Court would now consider the
prayer made by the petitioner more specifically in WP(C).No.6384/2025,
for a correction of the date of birth of the petitioner recorded in his
service book. The said prayer is found to have been made by the
Page No.# 15/25
petitioner only by way of instituting the said writ petition.
18.
It is a settled position of law that, in the event, an erroneous date
of birth has been recorded in the service book of an employee, the same
is permissible to be so rectified prior to 03 (three) years from the date of
superannuation of such employee. No such application is found by this
Court to have been submitted by the petitioner in the matter in
accordance with the procedure in vogue for correction of date of birth.
The petitioner has relied upon the date of birth recorded in his Pan Card,
Aadhar Card, Voter ID Card etc, in support of his prayer for correction of
the date of birth recorded in his service book. The petitioner has now
projected that his date of birth is actually “28.07.1966” and for the
purpose has also relied upon a school Leaving Certificate dated
27.05.2005.
19.
As noticed, hereinabove, the School Leaving Certificate dated
27.05.2005, wherein, the date of birth of the petitioner has been recorded
as 28.07.1966, is not found in the service records of the petitioner. It is
also not the case projected by the petitioner that it was the said certificate
that was produced by him at the time when his case for regularization was
being so considered. In the event, it was the said School Leaving
Certificate with the date of birth of the petitioner, therein, recorded as
“28.07.1966”, which was produced before the Respondent Authorities, the
Page No.# 16/25
petitioner would have objected to the recording of his date of birth in his
service book as “31.12.1956”. The petitioner is found to have accepted the
date of birth recorded in his service book as “31.12.1956”, by
acknowledging the same to be correct by putting his thumb impression,
therein. Further, the petitioner was in receipt of the GPF account
statements from time to time and in the said statements also the date of
birth of the petitioner being recorded as “28.12.1956”, the petitioner had
not also raised any grievance in this connection.
20.
Be that as it may, the petitioner from his service book as well as
the School Leaving Certificate available in the service records and from
the statements of GPF accounts is found to have been born in “December,
1956” and not “July, 1966”. The date of birth as recorded in the Pan Card,
Aadhar Card and Voter ID Card, in the considered view of this Court being
document subsequent to the joining in service by the petitioner and such
date of birth recorded also having an element of a self declaration being
made by the petitioner, would not mandate to be reckoned for the
purpose of determining the actual date of birth of the petitioner.
Accordingly, the prayer made by the petitioner in WP(C).No.6384/2025
stands rejected.
21.
In view of the above conclusions, this Court having found that the
Departmental Authorities had also contributed towards over stayal in
Page No.# 17/25
service by the petitioner, by not acting upon the materials available on
record with regard to the date on which the petitioner was to
superannuate from his services and further, this Court not being able to
determine that the petitioner had committed a mis-representation in the
matter and/or had manipulated records, proceeds to hold that recovery
under such circumstances of the salaries drawn by him during the period
of such over stay would not mandate to be recovered.
22.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Col. B.J. Akkara
(Rtd.) Vs. Govt. of India, reported in (2006) 11 SCC 709, on
consideration of the similar issue arising in the present proceeding held as
under:
"27. The last question to be considered is whether relief should be granted
against the recovery of the excess payments made on account of the wrong
interpretation/ misunderstanding of the circular dated 7-6- 1999. This Court
has consistently granted relief against recovery of excess wrong payment of
emoluments/allowances from an employee, if the following conditions are
fulfilled (vide Sahib Ram v. State of Haryana [1995 Supp (1) SCC 18 1995 SCC
(L&S) 248), Shyam Babu Verma v. Union of India ((1994) 2 SCC 521 1994 SCC
(L&S) 683 (1994) 27 ATC 1211, Union of India v. M. Bhaskar [(1996) 4 SCC
416 1996 SCC (L&S) 967] and V. Gangaram v. Regional Jt. Director [(1997) 6
SCC 139: 1997 SCC (L&S) 1652]):
(a) The excess payment was not made on account of any
misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the employee.
(b) Such excess payment was made by the employer by applying a
wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the basis of a
particular interpretation of rule/order, which is subsequently found to
be erroneous.
28.
Such relief, restraining back recovery of excess payment, is granted by
courts not because of any right in the employees, but in equity, in exercise of
Page No.# 18/25
judicial discretion to relieve the employees from the hardship that will be
caused if recovery is implemented. A government servant, particularly one in
the lower rungs of service would spend whatever emoluments he receives for
the upkeep of his family. If he receives an excess payment for a long period, he
would spend it, genuinely believing that he is entitled to it. As any subsequent
action to recover the excess payment will cause undue hardship to him, relief
is granted in that behalf. But where the employee had knowledge that the
payment received was in excess of what was due or wrongly paid, or where
the error is detected or corrected within a short time of wrong payment, courts
will not grant relief against recovery. The matter being in the realm of judicial
discretion, courts may on the facts and circumstances of any particular case
refuse to grant such relief against recovery.
29.
On the same principle, pensioners can also seek a direction that wrong
payments
should
not
be
recovered,
as
pensioners
are
in
a
more
disadvantageous position when compared to in-service employees. Any
attempt to recover excess wrong payment would cause undue hardship to
them. The petitioners are not guilty of any misrepresentation or fraud in
regard to the excess payment. NPA was added to minimum pay, for purposes
of stepping up, due to a wrong understanding by the implementing
departments. We are therefore of the view that the respondents shall not
recover any excess payments made towards pension in pursuance of the
circular dated 7-6-1999 till the issue of the clarificatory circular dated 11-92001. Insofar as any excess payment made after the circular dated 11-9-2001,
obviously the Union of India will be entitled to recover the excess as the
validity of the said circular has been upheld and as pensioners have been put
on notice in regard to the wrong calculations earlier made."
23.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in its decision in the case of Syed
Abdul Qadir Vs. State of Bihar, reported in (2009) 3 SCC 475, on
noticing that the excess payment so made to the appellants therein, which
was sought to be recovered was so made on account of a mistake and
wrong interpretation of the rules holding the field, held that the
appellants, therein, cannot be held responsible in such a situation and the
recovery of the excess amount should not be ordered, especially, when
Page No.# 19/25
the employees had subsequently retired from their services. This Court
further observed that in general parlance, recovery is prohibited by Courts
where there exists no mis-representation or fraud played on the part of
the employee and the excess payment has been made by applying a
wrong interpretation of a rule or order. The Hon’ble Supreme Court had
held as under: "59. Undoubtedly, the excess amount that has been paid to the appellant
teachers was not because of any misrepresentation or fraud on their part
and the appellants also had no knowledge that the amount that was being
paid to them was more than what they were entitled to. It would not be
out of place to mention here that the Finance Department had, in its
counter-affidavit, admitted that it was a bonafide mistake on their part.
The excess payment made was the result of wrong interpretation of the
Rule that was applicable to them, for which the appellants cannot be held
responsible. Rather, the whole confusion was because of inaction,
negligence and carelessness of the officials concerned of the Government
of Bihar. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant teachers
submitted that majority of the beneficiaries have either retired or are on
the verge of it. Keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case at hand and to avoid any hardship to the appellant teachers, we are
of the view that no recovery of the amount that has been paid in excess to
the appellant teachers should be made.”
24.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab Vs.
Rafiq Mashih (White Washer), reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334,
examined the validity of an order passed by the State to recover the
monetary gains wrongly extended to the employees drawing in excess of
their entitlements without any fault or misrepresentation on the part of
such employees. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, upon considering the
situation of hardship caused to an employee, if recovery is directed to
Page No.# 20/25
reimburse the employee and accordingly, disallowed the same, exempting
the beneficiary employees from such recovery, it was held thus:
"8. As between two parties, if a determination is rendered in favour of the
party which is the weaker of the two, without any serious detriment to the
other (which is truly a welfare State), the issue resolved would be in
consonance with the concept of justice, which is assured to the citizens of
India, even in the Preamble of the Constitution of India. The right to recover
being pursued by the employer will have to be compared, with the effect of
the recovery on the employee concerned. If the effect of the recovery from
the employee concerned would be, more unfair, more wrongful, more
improper, and more unwarranted, than the corresponding right of the
employer to recover the amount, then it would be iniquitous and arbitrary,
to effect the recovery. In such a situation, the employee's right would
outbalance, and therefore eclipse, the right of the employer to recover.
………………………………………….
18.
It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be
that as it may, based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a
ready
reference,
summarize
the
following
few
situations,
wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be Impermissible in law:
(1) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service
(or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are due to
retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has been
made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to
discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior
post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
Page No.# 21/25
the employer's right to recover."
25.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in a recent decision in the case of
Jogeswar Sahoo & Ors. Vs. District Judge, Cuttack & Ors, reported
in (2025) SCC Online SC 724, by noticing its earlier decision on the
issue had drawn the following conclusions: “7. The issue falling for our consideration is not about the legality of the
retrospective promotion and the financial benefit granted to the appellants on
10.05.2017. The issue for consideration is whether recovery of the amount
extended to the appellants while they were in service is justified after their
retirement and that too without affording any opportunity of hearing.
8. The law in this regard has been settled by this Court in catena of judgments
rendered time and again; Sahib Ram vs. State of Haryana1, Shyam Babu
Verma vs. Union of India2, Union of India vs. M. Bhaskar3 and V. Gangaram
vs. Regional Jt. Director4 and in a recent decision in the matter of Thomas
Daniel vs. State of Kerala & Ors.5.
9. This Court has consistently taken the view that if the excess amount was
not paid on account of any misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the
employee or if such excess payment was made by the employer by applying a
wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the basis of a
particular interpretation of rule/order, which is subsequently found to be
erroneous, such excess payments of emoluments or allowances are not
recoverable. It is held that such relief against the recovery is not because of
any right of the employee but in equity, exercising judicial discretion to
provide relief to the employee from the hardship that will be caused if the
recovery is ordered.
10. In Thomas Daniel (supra), this Court has held thus in paras 10, 11, 12 and
13:
“10. In Sahib Ram v. State of Haryana1 this Court restrained recovery
of payment which was given under the upgraded pay scale on account
of wrong construction of relevant order by the authority concerned,
without any misrepresentation on part of the employees. It was held
thus:
“5. Admittedly the appellant does not possess the required educational
Page No.# 22/25
qualifications. Under the circumstances the appellant would not be
entitled to the relaxation. The Principal erred in granting him the
relaxation. Since the date of relaxation, the appellant had been paid
his salary on the revised scale. However, it is not on account of any
misrepresentation made by the appellant that the benefit of the higher
pay scale was given to him but by wrong construction made by the
Principal for which the appellant cannot be held to be at fault. Under
the circumstances the amount paid till date may not be recovered from
the appellant. The principle of equal pay for equal work would not
apply to the scales prescribed by the University Grants Commission.
The appeal is allowed partly without any order as to costs.”
11. In Col. B.J. Akkara (Retd.) v. Government of India this Court considered
an identical question as under:
“27. The last question to be considered is whether relief should be
granted against the recovery of the excess payments made on account
of the wrong interpretation/understanding of the circular dated 7-61999. This Court has consistently granted relief against recovery of
excess wrong payment of emoluments/allowances from an employee, if
the following conditions are fulfilled (vide Sahib Ram v. State of
Haryana [1995 Supp (1) SCC 18 : 1995 SCC (L&S) 248], Shyam Babu
Verma v. Union of India [(1994) 2 SCC 521 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 683 :
(1994) 27 ATC 121], Union of India v. M. Bhaskar [(1996) 4 SCC 416 :
1996 SCC (L&S) 967] and V. Gangaram v. Regional Jt. Director [(1997)
6 SCC 139 : 1997 SCC (L&S) 1652]):
(a) The excess payment was not made on account of any
misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the employee.
(b) Such excess payment was made by the employer by applying a
wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the basis of
a particular interpretation of rule/order, which is subsequently
found to be erroneous.
28.
Such relief, restraining back recovery of excess payment, is
granted by courts not because of any right in the employees, but in
equity, in exercise of judicial discretion to relieve the employees from
the hardship that will be caused if recovery is implemented. A
government servant, particularly one in the lower rungs of service
Page No.# 23/25
would spend whatever emoluments he receives for the upkeep of his
family. If he receives an excess payment for a long period, he would
spend it, genuinely believing that he is entitled to it. As any subsequent
action to recover the excess payment will cause undue hardship to him,
relief is granted in that behalf. But where the employee had knowledge
that the payment received was in excess of what was due or wrongly
paid, or where the error is detected or corrected within a short time of
wrong payment, courts will not grant relief against recovery. The
matter being in the realm of judicial discretion, courts may on the facts
and circumstances of any particular case refuse to grant such relief
against recovery.
29.
On the same principle, pensioners can also seek a direction that
wrong payments should not be recovered, as pensioners are in a more
disadvantageous position when compared to in-service employees. Any
attempt to recover excess wrong payment would cause undue hardship
to
them. The petitioners are not guilty of any misrepresentation or fraud
in regard to the excess payment. NPA was added to minimum pay, for
purposes of stepping up, due to a wrong understanding by the
implementing departments. We are therefore of the view that the
respondents shall not recover any excess payments made towards
pension in pursuance of the circular dated 7-6-1999 till the issue of the
clarificatory circular dated 11-9-2001. Insofar as any excess payment
made after the circular dated 11-9-2001, obviously the Union of India
will be entitled to recover the excess as the validity of the said circular
has been upheld and as pensioners have been put on notice in regard to
the wrong calculations earlier made.”
26.
Applying the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, noticed
above, to the facts of the present case, this Court is of the considered
view that the recovery of the amount of Rs.12,46,113/- (Rupees Twelve
Lakhs Forty Six Thousand One Hundred Thirteen), his pension and
pensionary benefits to be clearly iniquitous, harsh and arbitrary and
Page No.# 24/25
accordingly, directs that the said recovery would not be permissible to be
made.
27.
In view of the above discussion, the recovery of the salary drawn
by the petitioner during his period of over stayal, having being held by this
Court to be not permissible, the Respondent Authorities are now directed
to process the matter for preparation of a pension proposal in respect of
the petitioner for disbursement to him his pension and pensionary benefits
by reckoning that the petitioner had superannuated from his services
w.e.f. 31.12.2016. The matter be processed and a pension proposal be
finalized. The pension proposal be thereafter, forwarded to the Office of
the Accountant General (A&E), Assam, within a period of 03 (three)
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. The
Office of the Accountant General (A&E), Assam, on receipt of such
proposal for disbursement of pension and pensionary benefits to the
petitioner, herein, shall process the same and within a further period of 02
(two) months from the date of receipt of such proposal issue the requisite
Pension Payment Order (PPO)/Gratuity Payment Order (GPO), to the
petitioner. As this Court has permitted to retain the salaries drawn by him
w.e.f. 01.01.2017 till 31.07.2020, the pension of the petitioner would now
be authorized only w.e.f., 01.08.2020.
28.
This Court having now held that the petitioner stood retired from
Page No.# 25/25
his services w.e.f. 31.12.2016 and on account of the pendency of the
present proceeding, the pension and pensionary benefits of the petitioner
not having been settled, requires the Respondent Authorities to authorize
to the petitioner a provisional pension pending finalization of his pension
and pensionary benefits. The said orders authorizing to petitioner his
provisional pension as well as his provisional gratuity be issued within a
period of 01 (one) month from the date of a receipt of a certified copy of
this order.
29.
In view of the above discussion, the writ petition being
WP(C).No.1678/2024 stands disposed of. The writ petition being
WP(C).No.6384/2025, stands dismissed. However, there would be no
order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review