Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 32s6 l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE
STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY
OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE C.V.
BHASKAR REDDY
Appeals fired under section 123 of M.V.Act.,
Decree dated: 30.11.2010 passed in o.p.No.
chairrnan' Motor Vehicle Accidents claims
Karimnagar at Jagtial.
aggrieved by the Award and
2gr of 2007 on the fire of the
Tribunal-cum-ll Addl. District Judge,
Between:
Boddukuri shankaraiah, s/o Laxmirajam,
aged about 51 years, occ: Business
g:._::f-ipet, at present r/o oddad'vilge: M";ip"riy Mindat of Karimnasar
...nr
...APPELLANT
rLLLrttY I I(petitioner)
AND
1. Bantu Vittar yadav, s/o Narayana, aged 4T years,
occ. Head constabre,
owner of Bajaj purser Motor
beaiing
_s_2262 H.No. 18_
Reg.t\o
Ap_11
9vd:
I -543, Chatrinaka, padical Gate,
Boiguda,-HyJJraOaO.
2' Bajaj Allianz Generat tnsurance_ company Limited, rep.
Eil:r:ffi
by its Manager, Far
ll Floor, 3€-111t1t8, street ilro.ra-uain noao,
iimayatnnasar,
...RESPONDENTS(RESPONDENTS)
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri. Syed Ghouse
counser for the Respondent No.2: sri. T.
Basha
Mahender Rao
M.A.C.M.A.NOi 2425 OF 2019
Between:
Bajaj Ailianz General insurance Co. Ltd., rep. by its Manager Far East plaza,
ll Floor, 3-6-1111118, Street No.18, Main Road, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad.
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT No.2
AND
1. Boddukuri Shankaraiah, S/o. Laxmirajam aged 50 years, Occ: Business, R/o.
Luxettipet at present R/o. Oddad (v) of Medipally Mandal, Karimnagar district.
2. Bantu Vitlal Yadav, S/o. Narayana aged 46 years Occ: Head Constable of
Chandanergar Police Station and driver cum owner of Bajaj pulser Motor
Cycle bearing no. AP 115 2262, H. No.18-7-543, Chatrinaka', padical gate,
Boiguda, 1{yderabad.
...RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT No.1
MACMAMP. NO:2251 OF 2011
Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased grant stay of
all further proceedings in pursuance of the award and the decree dated3o-11-2b10
passed in oP.Ncr 287 of 2007 on the file of the MACT cum ll Additional District
Judge Karimnaga - at Jagtial pending disposal of the above appeal.
Counsel for the lrppellant: Sri. T Mahender Rao
Counsel for the Flespondents: -The Court delivered the following: COMMON JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COURT F'OR
THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE
C.V.BHASKAR REDDY
I
N
I
DATE:26.02.2Cl26
M.A.C.M.A.No.9B L of 2Ot9
Between:
Boddukuri Shankaraiah
.....Appellant
AND
Bantu Vittal yadav and another
....Respondents
M
Between:
t3ajaj Altianz General Insurance
Company Limited,
rep. by its Manager, Far East piaza
II Floor,
Streer
No.lB
fvf.ir-,
*^ Road,
9;6-1lL/LlB,
I{imayathnagar,
Hyderabad.
i
AND
.....Appellant
I
I
i
Boddukuri shankaraiah and
another
I
I
t
I
Respondents
I
i
!
COMMON JUDGMENT
MACMA'No.2425 0f 201g
challenging the judgment and
is filed by the Insurance company
decree dated 30.11.2o10 passed
chairman' Motor vehicres
l
by the
Accidents claims Tribunar-cum-Il
I
:
i
I
I
iI
I
I
I
I
I
!
-.\-:---Ei
'.\
_- .\
r1
'2
AdditioneLl District Judge, Karimnagar at Jagtial (for short .,the
Tribunal") in o.p.No.287 of 2ooz, whereby compensation of
Rs.l,48,0ool- was awarded in favour of the claimant flor injurics
sustained in a road accident, whereas M.A.C.M.A.No.93 L of 2o19 is
filed by the claimant seeking enhancement of the compensation
awarded try the Tribunal.
2-
For the sake of convenience, the parties u,ill hereinafter be
referred to as arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that on 02.09.20o6 at about
it:3o p.m., while the claimant was crossing the road near park Flotel,
Nampally, Hyderabad, a Bajaj pulsar motorcycle bearing Registration
No.AP-rl-s;-2262 driven by respondent No.1 struck him. As a resurt
of the collir;ion, the claimant sustained multiple grievous injuries. He
was admitt,:d as an inpatient at Medwin Hospital from 03.09.2006
to
08-09.20o6 and underwent surgery on o5.09.2006. He rvas advised
prolonged Lred-rest and physiotherapy for recovery. Stating that
the
claimant rarl a kirana business in Luxettipet, earning about Rslo,ooo
per month and due to the accident, he suffered loss of earnings,
incurred substantial medical expenses, and would Eequire future
surgery to rr:move internal interlocking nails, in addition to
enduring
pain, suffering and disability, he filed the aforesaid claim petition
before the Tribunal seeking compensation of Rs.3,OO,OOO/_.
\
\
\
\
4'
Before the Tribunal, respondent No. rl, the driver-cum-owner
of
the offending motorcycre, remained ex parte. Respondent No.2lnsurance company not onty denied riability, contending
respondent No. I was not holding a valid driving licence on
that
the date of
the accident and thereby violated policy conditions, absolving the
insurer of liability. Further, respondent No.2 disputed occurrence
of
the accident and challenged the quantum of compensation claimedOn appreciation of oral and documentary evidence, the Tribunal
found
that the accident was caused by rash and negligent driving of the
motorcycle by respondent No.l and awarded compensation
of
Rs. 1,48,0OO / -
with interest @ 7 -svo per annum, jointry and severarly
against the owner and insurer. while the Insurance company
preferred MACMA.No.242s of 2oI9 challenging liability
and quantum,
the claimant llled MACMA.No.93l of 2ol9 seeking enhancement
of
compensation.
5.
considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and perused the record.
6-
So far as negrigence and liability are concerned., the Tribunal,
based on the evidence, correctly concluded that the accident
was
caused by rash and negrigent driving of respondent No.1.
The
Tribunal also correctly found that the insurance policy (Ex.B_l)
was
valid on the date of the accident. Respondent No.2-Insurance
t
t
company failed to prove that respondent No.l did not hold a valid
driving licence on the date of accident by producing independent,
reliable rlr credible documentary evidence. It is rvell settled that an
insurer c:annof avoid liability merely on the basis of an oral assertion
by its witness without credible documentary evidence. Accordingly,
the Tribrrnal was justified in fixing joint and several liability on
respondents No.l and No.2 and there is no suflicient ground to
interfiere with this finding.
7.
As regards assessment of compensation, this court, on a careflul
consideration of the evidence on record, the nature and extent of
injuries susterined by the claimant, the medicar treatment undergone,
and the period of recovery, finds that the Tribunal rightly awarded
compensation under various heads, including medical expenses, loss
o[ earnings, extra nourishment, attendant charges, future surgery and
pain and r;uffering, arriving at a total of Rs.I,4g,oo0/-. In addition to
that, this court, having regard to the grievous nature o[ injuries,
including a closed fracture o[ the tibia and fibula and fracture o[ the
neck of the humerus which necessitated surgical operation and
prolonged rehabititation, grants an amount of Rs.5o,oo0/- to,w,ards
injuries. Thus, the claimant is entitled to a total compensation of
Rs. 1,98,0OO I - (Rs. 1,48,OOO I - + I{s.5O,OOO/-).
l.
I
\
f
t
8.
Since respondent No.2-lnsurance company has
not
demonstrated any material error in law or fact warranting reduction of
liabilitl' and since the evidence supports the claimant's case that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending
vehicle and that the claimant suffered severe injuries entitling him to
enhanced compensation, the appeal filed by respondent No.2lnsurance Company deserves to be dismissed.
9.
Resultantly, MACMA No.242s of 2019 liled by the insurance
company is dismissed. MACMA No.93 L of 2019 filed by the claimant
is partty allowed by enhancing the compensation granted by the
'l'ribunal [rom Rs.l,4g,ooo/- to Rs.t,gg,ooo/- with interest
@ 7.5%
from the date of petition till reatization. There shall be no order as to
COSIS.
As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
S
//TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Chairman, Motor Vehicle Accidents
Judge, Karimnagar at Jagtial. (With Records
2. One CC to Sri. Syed Ghouse Basha, Advocateif any)
loPUCl
3. One CC to Sri. T Mahender Rao, Advocate
IoPUCI
4. Two CD Copies
PR/PSL
W
Addl. District
I
HIGH COURT
DATED i 2610212026
COMMON JUDGMENT
o
u
t
5TA
{t
unn Nn
a
.b
MACMA.NOS.93I AND
* OP5r,,n;''
2425 0F ;!019
PARTLY I\LL o WING THE
MACMA.NO.g31 0F 2019
AND DISIVXISSING THE
MACMA.NO .2425 0F 2019
tuL
..r.1fl
t. ,i
*
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
ATH
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE C.V. BHASKAR REDDY
M.A.C.M.A.NOS : 931 AND 2425 0F 2019
M.A.C.M .A.NO: 931 OF 2019
Boddukuri Shankaraiah, S/o Laxmirajam, aged about 51 years, occ: Business
r/o Luxettipet, at present r/o Oddad Villge, Medipally Mandal of Karimnagar
District.
..APPELLANT (Petitioner)
EIII.]
1. Bantu Viftal Yadav, S/o Narayana, aged 47 years, occ: Head Constable, ownerof
Bajaj Pulser Motor Cycle bearing Reg.No. AP-11-S-2262 H.No. 18-7-543,
Chatrinaka, Padical Gate, Boiguda, Hyderabad.
B,44 Allianz General lnsurance Company Limited, rep. by its Manager, Far East
Plaza ll Floor, 3-6-1 11/1/8, Street No.18 Main Road, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad.
..RESPONDENTS(RESPONDENTS)
M.A.C.M.A.NO 24250F 20'19
Bajaj Ailianz General insurance Co. Ltd., rep. by its Manager Far East Plaza,
ll Floor, 3-6-1111118, Street No.18, Main Road, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad.
AND
'1. Boddukuri Shankaraiah, S/o. Laxmirajam. aged 50 years, Occ. Business, R/o.
Luxeftipet at present R/o. Oddad (v) of Medipally Mandal, Karimnagar district.
2. Bantu Vittal Yadav, S/o. Narayana aged 46 years Occ. Head Constable of
Chandanagar Police Station and driver cum owner of Bajaj Pulser Motor
Cycle bearing no. AP 118 2262, H. No.18-7-543, Chatrinaka, Padical gate,
Boiguda, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Appeals filed under Section 173 of M.V.Act., aggrieved by the Award and
Decree dated: 30.11.2010 passed in O.P.No. 287 ol 2007 on the file of the.
Chairman, Motor Vehicle Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-ll Addl. Diskict Judge,
Karimnagar at .,agtial.
This appeerl coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal,
the Judgment and Decree of the court below and the material papers in the
MVoP and upc,n hearing the arguments of Sri. syed Ghouse Basha , counsel for
the Appellant in MACMA No. 931 ot 2019 and of sri. T Mahender Rao , Advocate
for the Respondent No.2 in MACMA No. 931 of 20'lg and Appellant in MACMA No.
2425 of 2019
This Court doth order and decree as follows:
1. That the lilotor Accident civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.931 of 20,1g be and
hereby is rJismissed;
2. That the fulotor Accident civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.2425 of 2019 be and
hereby is partly allowed by enhancing the compensation granted by the
Tribunal frr>m Rs.1,48,000/- to Rs.1,98,000/- with interest
@ 7.S% irom the
date of petition till realization;
3. That save as aforesaid the decree of the tribunal shall stands confirmed in all
other respocts;
4. That there shall be no order as to costs in this appeal.
SD/- P.PONNA KRISHNA
ASS]STANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
CTION OFFICER
To
1. The chairman, Motor Vehicle Accidents claims Tribunal-cum-ll Addl. District
Judge, Karimnagar at Jagtial.
2. Two CD Copies
PR
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2610212026
ON DECREE
c
5.931 AND
2425 0F 2019
G THE
c MA.NO.931 0F 2019
ND DISMISSING THE
MACMA.NA.2425 0F 2019
Ir
Ll,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review